UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 06:12:36 PM

Title: Was the claim that Kate screamed, "They've Taken Her" significant?
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 06:12:36 PM
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/10044350/Mark-Bridger-trial-April-Joness-mother-told-police-shes-been-taken.html

April Jones's mother told police "She's been taken" when they arrived after she reported her five-year-old daughter had vanished, a court heard.
Title: Re: Was the claim that Kate screamed, "They've Taken Her" significant?
Post by: Eleanor on May 08, 2013, 06:42:16 PM

She's been taken means that she is dead, doncha know.  The ......... did that one almost to death.
Title: Re: Was the claim that Kate screamed, "They've Taken Her" significant?
Post by: DCI on May 08, 2013, 06:51:33 PM
Charlotte was working that night.

On the 3rd of May 2007, around 22H15, the witness was working during "dinner hour", together with her colleagues Jackie and Amy, when an unknown woman came to them indicating that she was a tourist lodged at the complex and asked them if they had heard about a disappearance of a child, whose name she referred to as "Maggie" or "Maddy";

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CHARLOTTE-PENNINGTON.htm

David Payne.

I hadn't realised that she'd, you know, left the table again just busy chatting, then Kate came back just after ten o' clock, you know absolutely distraught err you know just, you know her face I'll never forget. It was a face of someone's child who had been taken and you know and very clearly said she's gone, she's you know, she's gone, you know and there was a disbelief on our face you know ah you know you must be mistaken, what, and then you know just looking at her we just all err left the table, rushed over to her and as we were walking up towards the flat she said err you know they've taken her and it was, you know, and I know there's been a controversy about what was actually said but you know that is very accurately what had been said. Like I say, as I say you know you could just never forget her face and those words, and err as we were, you know, approaching their apartment I was just saying to Kate,

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/DAVID-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
Title: Re: Was the claim that Kate screamed, "They've Taken Her" significant?
Post by: DCI on May 08, 2013, 07:28:03 PM
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-483715/Kate-McCann-DID-scream-Theyve-taken-claims-new-nanny-witness.html

This says different, though of course its a tabloid which cant be trusted, my point was the story about theyve taken her had some provenance, somewhere, and David Payne proves it was not a fabrication, though KM denies having said that

Kate said it once, to David, as they were walking to the apartment, that was after she said "she's gone" She didn't shout it from the balcony, like this elusive witness claims.
Title: Re: Was the claim that Kate screamed, "They've Taken Her" significant?
Post by: Benice on May 08, 2013, 10:42:05 PM

She's been taken means that she is dead, doncha know.  The ......... did that one almost to death.

Unless you think certain people, thanks admin,  were inferring a Mr and Mrs God as *they*

You are mistaken again. Some people thought KM saying to her mother *Madeleine's gone, she's gone Mum* could have meant she had died. The *they have taken her* was always discussed by some  in terms of who *they * were, ie in the plural and in a speculative context of KM knowning who *they* might be
Best to be accurate unless you dont really remember but say stuff anyway

I'm not quite sure what you mean Blossom, but the word 'they' is often used when the sex of a person is unknown - or when referring to someone whose name you don't know.

For example:

Girl -    ''Mum there is someone at the door who wants to speak to you.''
Mum -  ''Well whoever they are - tell them I'm too busy to speak to them at the moment.''





Title: Re: Was the claim that Kate screamed, "They've Taken Her" significant?
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 09, 2013, 02:16:24 AM

She's been taken means that she is dead, doncha know.  The ......... did that one almost to death.

Unless you think certain people, thanks admin,  were inferring a Mr and Mrs God as *they*

You are mistaken again. Some people thought KM saying to her mother *Madeleine's gone, she's gone Mum* could have meant she had died. The *they have taken her* was always discussed by some  in terms of who *they * were, ie in the plural and in a speculative context of KM knowning who *they* might be
Best to be accurate unless you dont really remember but say stuff anyway

I'm not quite sure what you mean Blossom, but the word 'they' is often used when the sex of a person is unknown - or when referring to someone whose name you don't know.

For example:

Girl -    ''Mum there is someone at the door who wants to speak to you.''
Mum -  ''Well whoever they are - tell them I'm too busy to speak to them at the moment.''
Benice is right. When you can't name the subject or when the subject is undetermined, you can use the plural of the 3rd person or the passive form. This "they" that shocked so many is perfectly normal.