UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: ferryman on May 09, 2013, 07:54:11 AM

Title: Dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: ferryman on May 09, 2013, 07:54:11 AM
Is it acceptable, ever, for a dog attending a crime scene to pick stuff up in its mouth?

Is it acceptable, ever, for a dog attending a crime scene to trample over stuff it is tasked to inspect?

Discuss.
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: debunker on May 09, 2013, 09:29:10 AM
Is it acceptable, ever, for a dog attending a crime scene to pick stuff up in its mouth?

Is it acceptable, ever, for a dog attending a crime scene to trample over stuff it is tasked to inspect?

Discuss.

No discussion really necessary.

I would love to see the tapes examined in a court of law!
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: Benice on May 09, 2013, 09:43:52 AM
Is it acceptable, ever, for a dog attending a crime scene to pick stuff up in its mouth?

Is it acceptable, ever, for a dog attending a crime scene to trample over stuff it is tasked to inspect?

Discuss.

Not in my book.   Such behaviour is far too 'random' to be able to come to any real meaningful conclusions.


 
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: Benice on May 09, 2013, 10:03:38 AM
If a "cadaver" dog has been chewing on a bone or sniffing out corpses with its nose, and then later picks up an object in its teeth which it had not alerted to, then returns to the object and alerts to it would it not be likely that there had been transference of the corpse scent?

According to Martin Grime transference of contamination is instant - so in theory it is possible

I do wonder why Grime considered it necessary to be dressed from head to toe in protective clothing - but not in all the searches.    I would imagine that as the handler, who regularly trained Eddie with cadaver odour  and therefore regularly came into contact with it  that  he himself was likely to be a potential source of 'innocent' contamination  and so he wore the clothing to prevent that.   And yet at times he only wore gloves.  One would think protective clothing was either essential or it wasn't?




 


Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: Eleanor on May 09, 2013, 11:50:25 AM

Eddie was a bit manic, anyone can see that.  Probably okay in a Search and Rescue situation, for which he was originally trained, but not very good in a Criminal Investigation.
I suspect that he got a bit confused sometimes because he didn't really understand what he was supposed to be doing.
Martin Grime should never have given him that extra E.  Eddie was only an Enhanced Victim Recovery Dog because Martin Grime decided he would be.  So it was always guess work.
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: icabodcrane on May 09, 2013, 01:27:05 PM

Eddie was a bit manic, anyone can see that.  Probably okay in a Search and Rescue situation, for which he was originally trained, but not very good in a Criminal Investigation.
I suspect that he got a bit confused sometimes because he didn't really understand what he was supposed to be doing.
Martin Grime should never have given him that extra E.  Eddie was only an Enhanced Victim Recovery Dog because Martin Grime decided he would be.  So it was always guess work.

He made a pretty good  'guess'  when he found black Bob's body buried in a sand dune  on that Scottish island

That's the only story I remember reading  in the paper about that particular dog,  but I'm sure he had other successes  (  who would pay £1,000 a day for his services unless his CV was pretty impressive ? )
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: Eleanor on May 09, 2013, 01:40:09 PM

Eddie was a bit manic, anyone can see that.  Probably okay in a Search and Rescue situation, for which he was originally trained, but not very good in a Criminal Investigation.
I suspect that he got a bit confused sometimes because he didn't really understand what he was supposed to be doing.
Martin Grime should never have given him that extra E.  Eddie was only an Enhanced Victim Recovery Dog because Martin Grime decided he would be.  So it was always guess work.

He made a pretty good  'guess'  when he found black Bob's body buried in a sand dune  on that Scottish island

That's the only story I remember reading  in the paper about that particular dog,  but I'm sure he had other successes  (  who would pay £1,000 a day for his services unless his CV was pretty impressive ? )

You need to read up a bit on that Case.  The perpetrator confessed, and then led the police to the approximate area.  He couldn't remember the precise location because he was drunk when he buried the body.
And then Eddie tried to dig up the body, and they had to drag him off.
But then any old dog could have done that.  Many  of them do.
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: debunker on May 09, 2013, 01:48:28 PM

Eddie was a bit manic, anyone can see that.  Probably okay in a Search and Rescue situation, for which he was originally trained, but not very good in a Criminal Investigation.
I suspect that he got a bit confused sometimes because he didn't really understand what he was supposed to be doing.
Martin Grime should never have given him that extra E.  Eddie was only an Enhanced Victim Recovery Dog because Martin Grime decided he would be.  So it was always guess work.

He made a pretty good  'guess'  when he found black Bob's body buried in a sand dune  on that Scottish island

That's the only story I remember reading  in the paper about that particular dog,  but I'm sure he had other successes  (  who would pay £1,000 a day for his services unless his CV was pretty impressive ? )

Finding a buried or exposed body was what he was originally trained for so it is not surprising he managed that. There is considerable doubt about dog efficacy in retrieval of evidence as in this case and Jersey.
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: ferryman on May 09, 2013, 02:17:20 PM
I do wonder why Grime considered it necessary to be dressed from head to toe in protective clothing - but not in all the searches.

That's a very interesting point, and I think an article in The Mail supplies the answer. 

While secrecy was still on the case at PdL, Grime used the video of Eddie alerting to the Renault to sell himself in Jersey.

I will see if I can pull out the cite.

As the emails to Coupland demonstrate, at first Harper displayed a healthy scepticism. So what made him change his mind? According to a senior detective who worked on Harper's team, one factor was sniffer dog Eddie's handler, Martin Grime.
'Grime made a presentation, showing him [Harper] a video of the dog finding the "scent of death" in Kate and Gerry McCann's car,' the detective said.

'They were still formal suspects and the case had got worldwide publicity. It seemed to get Lenny very excited. I think Grime kind of bewitched him.'


Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1217863/Bungled-Jersey-child-abuse-probe-branded-20million-shambles.html#ixzz2SnkIC2dD
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook

The job of any team attending a crime scene (including dogs!) is to find items of potential forensic interest and pass them on to a competent laboratory in a state as close to that they were in when found as possible.

That does not include direct contact of said items of interest with dogs ...
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 09, 2013, 07:34:04 PM
refer to Grime's comments on the STU machine and contamination - particularly in confined spaces and the example he gives is a vehicle.

also refer to his statement about how Keela alerts with a "point" - why did Keela lick in the car?
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: ferryman on May 09, 2013, 07:49:38 PM
Is it acceptable, ever, for a dog attending a crime scene to pick stuff up in its mouth?

Is it acceptable, ever, for a dog attending a crime scene to trample over stuff it is tasked to inspect?

Discuss.

Why not? Does a dogs paws on something mean human blood cant be smelt by Keela? or that the dogs dna would be confused with human dna? If there was a problem would Mr Grime allow this kind of search of clothes?

Use of the ST 100 is recommended when subject vehicles, property, clothing, premises

are to be forensically protected from contamination by the dog, and for covert

deployment.


Martin Grime

Never mind that the STU 100 is used to store scents of living people ...
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 09, 2013, 07:53:50 PM
refer to Grime's comments on the STU machine and contamination - particularly in confined spaces and the example he gives is a vehicle.

also refer to his statement about how Keela alerts with a "point" - why did Keela lick in the car?

You will have to ask him then, I am just offering a laymans opinion to questions asked

I don't have to ask him - he said it all in his various statements.
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 09, 2013, 08:07:26 PM
the case isn't closed because there is still a missing child.
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: registrar on May 09, 2013, 08:11:07 PM
refer to Grime's comments on the STU machine and contamination - particularly in confined spaces and the example he gives is a vehicle.

also refer to his statement about how Keela alerts with a "point" - why did Keela lick in the car?

You will have to ask him then, I am just offering a laymans opinion to questions asked

So you are layperson when on shaky ground

and a world expert when you have a little knowledge?

Pathetic
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: registrar on May 09, 2013, 08:14:44 PM
refer to Grime's comments on the STU machine and contamination - particularly in confined spaces and the example he gives is a vehicle.

also refer to his statement about how Keela alerts with a "point" - why did Keela lick in the car?

You will have to ask him then, I am just offering a laymans opinion to questions asked

So you are layperson when on shaky ground

and a world expert when you have a little knowledge?

Pathetic
8-)(--)


As are you always

I love you too
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 09, 2013, 08:15:15 PM
the case isn't closed because there is still a missing child.

Case closed vis a vis dogs meaning ANYTHING to YOU and others, how you can dismiss them so much is worrying and shameful and scary

did you know keela doesn't always alert?
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 09, 2013, 08:18:03 PM
the case isn't closed because there is still a missing child.

Case closed vis a vis dogs meaning ANYTHING to YOU and others, how you can dismiss them so much is worrying and shameful and scary

did you know keela doesn't always alert?

you might say that, and i woukd ask you for proof, tomorrows dear as the rottweilers have descended

keela missed the curtains the first time round - didn't you know that?
Title: Re: dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: debunker on May 09, 2013, 09:35:30 PM
Is it acceptable, ever, for a dog attending a crime scene to pick stuff up in its mouth?

Is it acceptable, ever, for a dog attending a crime scene to trample over stuff it is tasked to inspect?

Discuss.

Why not? Does a dogs paws on something mean human blood cant be smelt by Keela? or that the dogs dna would be confused with human dna? If there was a problem would Mr Grime allow this kind of search of clothes?

Use of the ST 100 is recommended when subject vehicles, property, clothing, premises

are to be forensically protected from contamination by the dog, and for covert

deployment.


Martin Grime

Never mind that the STU 100 is used to store scents of living people ...


Maybe it would be appropriate for Mr Grime's next machine to be called the shut up 1000.
Title: Re: Dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 09, 2013, 09:37:48 PM
dogs go through customs and immigration. Machine didn't
Title: Re: Dog discipline at a crime scene ...
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 10, 2013, 03:43:12 PM
debunker said: Maybe it would be appropriate for Mr Grime's next machine to be called the shut up 1000.

LOL! Yes, I think that would be rather appropriate!  8((()*/