UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Mrs. B on June 13, 2013, 04:04:08 PM
-
Mr and Mrs McCann, both 39, said last night that they were prepared to take a lie detector test if requested by the Portuguese authorities. “Kate and Gerry are happy to do anything that will help them to clear their names,” a source close to the couple said. “They have said all along that they want to cooperate fully with the Portuguese police, but as of today they have received no such request.”
http://www.standard.co.uk/newsheadlines/mccanns-offer-to-take-lie-test-6698135.html
-
Mr and Mrs McCann, both 39, said last night that they were prepared to take a lie detector test if requested by the Portuguese authorities. “Kate and Gerry are happy to do anything that will help them to clear their names,” a source close to the couple said. “They have said all along that they want to cooperate fully with the Portuguese police, but as of today they have received no such request.”
http://www.standard.co.uk/newsheadlines/mccanns-offer-to-take-lie-test-6698135.html
Clarence Mitchell goes on to say that they are fully aware that lie-detectors are not used by the Portuguese police because the evidence is inadmissable in Portuguese courts
So the 'offer' was nothing more than empty posturing, wasn't it ?
-
Fact remains, they were telling the truth, & those who accuse them of lying about this has once again been proven to be liars themselves.
-
OK Red - knowing that Lie detectors are not 100% accurate, and some people can even beat them, - with hand on heart tell us what you would say if the McCanns took one and passed.
(I'll take a guess that you won't give a straight answer to that question.)
irrelevant to my point, no one who takes such a test has the right to impose conditions, its preposterous..but that is what clarence mitchell does for a living, be preposterous, .but like the tapas 7 trying to guarantee conditions before they hauled their backsides back to pdl to do a reconstruction, no leaving no stone unturned there as they promised were they??... to answer your point, i would, like most people, accept the results, with the small proviso that sometimes they are wrong
-
And WHY would they take a lie detector test, if they haven't been asked by authorities & knowing that the results aren't valid in court?
To placate the hounders? No, sorry, simply not worth it.
-
Kate refuses lie test, 18 November 2007
Kate refuses lie test Sunday Express (no longer online)
Camilla Tominey
Sunday November 18,2007
KATE McCann has done a U-turn over plans to take a lie detector test about daughter Madeleine's disappearance.
She and husband Gerry offered to undergo a polygraph examination in September to clear their names. They hoped it would help to clear up any doubts about their involvement.
Sources close to the couple made it known they were willing to be questioned after Kate was officially declared an "arguido" or official suspect in the case in Portugal.
But despite being approached by a leading UK polygraph expert, mother-of-three Kate, 39, turned down the chance. Don Cargill, chairman of the British And European Polygraph Association, said he was "shocked" by her decision.
Mr Cargill, official lie detector expert on TV's Trisha Goddard TV show, said: "I spoke to the McCanns' people and they came back with a list of conditions that would have been impossible to satisfy.
"They wanted me to prove the test would be 100 per cent accurate, that I was the world's best examiner and that it would be admissible in a Portuguese court – but I could not guarantee any of those things. Although polygraph testing is very accurate, it is not infallible."
Lie detectors work by measuring physiological responses such as blood pressure levels, pulse rate, breathing and sweat gland activity in the skin during questioning.
Any significant difference in these rates as the subject answers may indicate they are lying.
The process has been criticised but The American Polygraph Association says the current computerised technology is 98 per cent accurate.
Lie detector tests are not admissible in British or Portuguese courts, but a positive polygraph result from Kate would prove a useful weapon for the McCanns against smears by the Portuguese police.
Mr Cargill said: "Kate said she'd take it to prove her innocence but in reality, she wasn't willing. I was dumbfounded, to tell the truth.
"I don't think it was the McCanns' fault. I was left with the impression the whole thing was a PR exercise to get sympathy at a time when Kate was under increasing scrutiny."
Mr Cargill believes if the McCanns were to change their minds, now is the time to do it.
Tomorrow marks 200 days since Madeleine, from Rothley, Leics, vanished from the family’s holiday apartment in Praia da Luz.
He said: "In the immediate aftermath of Madeleine's disappearance, feelings would have been running too high. But now Kate is back in England and has had more time to come to terms with things, the timing would be perfect."
Clarence Mitchell, the couple's spokesman, dismissed the idea, saying: "Of course they are not going to take the test. It's inadmissible in Portugal and there are doubts about the accuracy.
"Gerry and Kate don't need to do one as they are telling the truth."
Killer Adrian Prout failed lie detector test and then admitted: "Your test is not wrong", 19 November 2011
-
Clarence Mitchell goes on to say that they are fully aware that lie-detectors are not used by the Portuguese police because the evidence is inadmissable in Portuguese courts
So the 'offer' was nothing more than empty posturing, wasn't it ?
precisely, why did they even say they would be willing to do one in the first place if a) no one asked them let alone the police b) not valid anyway and c) set conditions on such a test
Nonsense
Eta seems one of their* friends *dropped them in it here reading that article again
-
Irrelevant, as they only said they'd do a lie detector test IF asked by Portuguese authorities, nothing else.
-
Irrelevant, as they only said they'd do a lie detector test IF asked by Portuguese authorities, nothing else.
of course you have the cite for that, and yea, why WOULD the police ask for one when its non admissable, more smoke and pathetic mirrors
-
Mr and Mrs McCann, both 39, said last night that they were prepared to take a lie detector test if requested by the Portuguese authorities. “Kate and Gerry are happy to do anything that will help them to clear their names,” a source close to the couple said. “They have said all along that they want to cooperate fully with the Portuguese police, but as of today they have received no such request.”
http://www.standard.co.uk/newsheadlines/mccanns-offer-to-take-lie-test-6698135.html
And again..
-
And WHY would they take a lie detector test, if they haven't been asked by authorities & knowing that the results aren't valid in court?
To placate the hounders? No, sorry, simply not worth it.
May be they regret it now. In fact they proposed it and then escaped it, not politically correct.
-
Why would they? They said they'd take a lie detector test IF THE PORTUGUESE AUTHORITIES REQUESTED IT - nothing else. They did not refuse to take a lie detector test - this is a case of a missing child, not the Jeremy Kyle show.
-
Why would they? They said they'd take a lie detector test IF THE PORTUGUESE AUTHORITIES REQUESTED IT - nothing else. They did not refuse to take a lie detector test - this is a case of a missing child, not the Jeremy Kyle show.
Don't tell me they ignored the Portuguese authorities would never request a test they considered as not reliable.
-
There you go then, they weren't asked by police, so they never refused to do a lie detector test.
-
There you go then, they weren't asked by police, so they never refused to do a lie detector test.
Why was that article posted n th FIRST PLACE??
-
Because some editors thought it was newsworthy?
-
Because some editors thought it was newsworthy?
So the editors made it all up? You mean with mitchell breathing down their backs?getting paid 75 k a year? Pull the other one, otherwise you are very near to sayng mitchell was responsible for all the stories, wouldnt surprise me though, the media black arts are quite horrendous
-
LOL Nobody said they made it up, they reported a comment made by the McCanns - for some reason, they found it newsworthy.
-
LOL Nobody said they made it up, they reported a comment made by the McCanns - for some reason, they found it newsworthy.
What was the comment? And why did they make it?
-
For the third time...
Mr and Mrs McCann, both 39, said last night that they were prepared to take a lie detector test if requested by the Portuguese authorities. “Kate and Gerry are happy to do anything that will help them to clear their names,” a source close to the couple said. “They have said all along that they want to cooperate fully with the Portuguese police, but as of today they have received no such request.”
http://www.standard.co.uk/newsheadlines/mccanns-offer-to-take-lie-test-6698135.html
-
Maybe they're not big Jeremy Kyle fans?
-
Maybe they're not big Jeremy Kyle fans?
8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)( @)(++(* 8((()*/
-
Maybe they're not big Jeremy Kyle fans?
pathetic response, it was THEM that made it an issue and it backfired doublebarrelled
-
No, it hasn't backfired on them,they didn't lie & they didn't refuse to take a lie detector test. Apart from the Jeremy Kyle variety, which they never said they would do anyway. Please be aware that a few anonymous nutters screaming online & spreading lies aren't actually important in the real scheme of things.
-
No, it hasn't backfired on them,they didn't lie & they didn't refuse to take a lie detector test. Apart from the Jeremy Kyle variety, which they never said they would do anyway. Please be aware that a few anonymous nutters screaming online & spreading lies aren't actually important in the real scheme of things.
I don't know why the 'sceptics' even bother to bring up the subject of Polygraphs. We all know that if the McCanns took one and passed, they'd all be claiming 'it was fixed'.
-
I don't know why the 'sceptics' even bother to bring up the subject of Polygraphs. We all know that if the McCanns took one and passed, they'd all be claiming 'it was fixed'.
Of course they would & I'm actually glad that they have chosen to ignore the majority of these mindless fools who think they have a right to conduct trials by internet based on baseless speculation. Bennett of course was the exception & he got what he deserved.
-
No, it hasn't backfired on them,they didn't lie & they didn't refuse to take a lie detector test. Apart from the Jeremy Kyle variety, which they never said they would do anyway. Please be aware that a few anonymous nutters screaming online & spreading lies aren't actually important in the real scheme of things.
you do refuse to answer questions, where did the story originate if but from mccanns and or mitchell and why did it become such a pathetic piece, with the lie detedtor getting involved, simple question, really it is
-
Because some editors thought it was newsworthy?
This was counterproductive, people started to suspect them with a certain reason. They should have firmly denied they had even thought of doing such a test.
In the US parents of missing children ask to be tested to make sure the investigation will concentrate on the child.
-
Quote from: Benice on Today at 09:16:08 PM
I don't know why the 'sceptics' even bother to bring up the subject of Polygraphs. We all know that if the McCanns took one and passed, they'd all be claiming 'it was fixed'.
on. Bennett of course was the exception & he got what he deserved.
You seem to know people better than they do know themselves. Are you Madame Sosostris, famous clairvoyante ?
-
This was counterproductive, people started to suspect them with a certain reason. They should have firmly denied they had even thought of doing such a test.
In the US parents of missing children ask to be tested to make sure the investigation will concentrate on the child.
Elizabeth Smart's father did and we are told that the McCanns set great store by his advice.
-
No, it hasn't backfired on them,they didn't lie & they didn't refuse to take a lie detector test.
How do you know "they didn't lie" ? I thought Mr Mitchell had the privilege to know this and state it.
-
someone set limits on the lie detector test..... Unprecedented
@)(++(*
-
The question of the polygraph is a new thread spun off from another topic.
-
From the article that Faithlilly posted:
But despite being approached by a leading UK polygraph expert, mother-of-three Kate, 39, turned down the chance. Don Cargill, chairman of the British And European Polygraph Association, said he was "shocked" by her decision.
Mr Cargill, official lie detector expert on TV's Trisha Goddard TV show, said: "I spoke to the McCanns' people and they came back with a list of conditions that would have been impossible to satisfy.
"They wanted me to prove the test would be 100 per cent accurate, that I was the world's best examiner and that it would be admissible in a Portuguese court – but I could not guarantee any of those things. Although polygraph testing is very accurate, it is not infallible."
Lie detectors work by measuring physiological responses such as blood pressure levels, pulse rate, breathing and sweat gland activity in the skin during questioning.
Any significant difference in these rates as the subject answers may indicate they are lying.
From a different article:
The bosses of two companies that conduct lie detector tests for TV chat shows are set for a High Court battle - over which one is lying.
Bruce Burgess, who conducts polygraph tests for The Jeremy Kyle Show, is suing Don Cargill, whose company is used by rival programme The Trisha Goddard Show, for defamation.
The argument between Mr Burgess's Distress Services and Cargill's Nadac Group started last year after an episode of Trisha's show on which a woman was accused of stealing a £38,000 watch.
Dispute: A polygraph on Trisha Goddard's show was queried and retested by a Bruce Burgess, who conducts polygraphs for The Jeremy Kyle Show, and came up with a different result
Betty Hipson, 57 , appeared on the show determined to prove her innocence after her family accused her of stealing the Rolex.
Cargill's polygraph test found that she was lying but , undeterred, the Leatherhead grandmother approached Burgess's company for a second test, which found her innocent.
Mrs Hipson complained to Ofcom about the findings of the test used on the Trisha show.
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-1091578/Jeremy-Kyle-Trisha-war-lie-detector-test-Polygraph-experts-set-court-battle-decide-fibbing.html#ixzz2WS7ZkFoN
-
Lie Detectors have anaccuracy of just over 96%.
The results are not admissible in court.
The Mccanns offered to take one, then backed out, with words to the effect they are unreliable.
In the words of Gerry Mccann..........
''Ask the dogs Sandra''
-
Lie Detectors have anaccuracy of just over 96%.
The results are not admissible in court.
The Mccanns offered to take one, then backed out, with words to the effect they are unreliable.
In the words of Gerry Mccann..........
''Ask the dogs Sandra''
Well I find it odd that one company found that the woman in the case above was lying and the other found that she wasn't.
Which one was having a 4% bad-hair day?
-
Well I find it odd that one company found that the woman in the case above was lying and the other found that she wasn't.
Which one was having a 4% bad-hair day?
Not sufficient evidence to say lie detectors don't work.
1 'case' means nothing.
and if the mccanns think they have no value . rather like their opinion of the dogs,though of course the police worldwide say different, why did they back out ?
-
Not sufficient evidence to say lie detectors don't work.
1 'case' means nothing.
and if the mccanns think they have no value . rather like their opinion of the dogs,yhough of course the police worldwide say different, why did they back out ?
The police worldwide?
Europe
In most European jurisdictions, polygraphs are not considered reliable evidence and are not generally used by law enforcement. Courts themselves do not order nor facilitate polygraph testing. In most cases, polygraph tests are voluntarily taken by a defendant in order to substantiate his or her defense.
The Federal Court of Justice of Germany has ruled that polygraph evidence is inherently inconclusive and not admissible in court. Motions by prosecution or defense for polygraph tests to be exercised will be declined under any circumstance.[33]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polygraph#cite_note-33
-
The police worldwide?
Europe
In most European jurisdictions, polygraphs are not considered reliable evidence and are not generally used by law enforcement. Courts themselves do not order nor facilitate polygraph testing. In most cases, polygraph tests are voluntarily taken by a defendant in order to substantiate his or her defense.
The Federal Court of Justice of Germany has ruled that polygraph evidence is inherently inconclusive and not admissible in court. Motions by prosecution or defense for polygraph tests to be exercised will be declined under any circumstance.[33]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polygraph#cite_note-33
I know that already.
Lie detectors are reliable but not normally admissible in courts. They are in some American courts if the judge deems it of relevance.
So why are you and the Mccanns afraid of lie detectors Carana ? >@@(*&)
-
I know that already.
Lie detectors are reliable but not normally admissible in courts. They are in some American courts if the judge deems it of relevance.
So why are you and the Mccanns afraid of lie detectors Carana ? >@@(*&)
The PJ never asked them to take one.
-
The PJ never asked them to take one.
They volunteered to take one, then backed out. >@@(*&)
-
This is pathetic. The McCanns don't have to do anything they don't want to do, or answer any questions they don't want to answer. Whether or not people believe them is entirely irrelevant. They have been charged with nothing and found guilty of nothing.
Scotland Yard are now actively Investigating the disappearance of their daughter which is what they have always wanted, so they have a lot to be hopeful about.
A Lie Detector Test was always pointless because it would prove nothing.
-
This is pathetic. The McCanns don't have to do anything they don't want to do, or answer any questions they don't want to answer. Whether or not people believe them is entirely irrelevant. They have been charged with nothing and found guilty of nothing.
Scotland Yard are now actively Investigating the disappearance of their daughter which is what they have always wanted, so they have a lot to be hopeful about.
A Lie Detector Test was always pointless because it would prove nothing.
They haven't been found guilty ELEANOR, AS THEY HAVEN'T BEEN CHARGED.
The case was shelved, in case you need reminding, pending new evidence.
The Mccanns volunteered to take a lie detector test and then backed out. See Mitchell's word on that.
As to having anything to answer for, they most certainly have. Their negligence of 3 children led to the 'disappearance Madeleine.
-
There was no negligence, and it is certainly unproven that leaving the children between checks had any bearing on Madeleine's abduction.
-
They haven't been found guilty ELEANOR, AS THEY HAVEN'T BEEN CHARGED.
The case was shelved, in case you need reminding, pending new evidence.
The Mccanns volunteered to take a lie detector test and then backed out. See Mitchell's word on that.
As to having anything to answer for, they most certainly have. Their negligence of 3 children led to the 'disappearance Madeleine.
The Rule of Law doesn't appear to agree with you.
-
There was no negligence, and it is certainly unproven that leaving the children between checks had any bearing on Madeleine's abduction.
What abduction exactly ?
NO PROOF AT ALL.
-
The Rule of Law doesn't appear to agree with you.
The rule of law means, you can't be found innocent of a crime, unless you have been charged with one and found innocent.
Read up on hypothesis testing. It's quite enlightening.
-
The rule of law means, you can't be found innocent of a crime, unless you have been charged with one and found innocent.
Read up on hypothesis testing. It's quite enlightening.
The first issue is to define the nature of the crime. The investigation wasn't able to determine it. There was a fact (disappearance), but what sort of crime ?
It's easy to understand why, in the US, parents of missing children ask to be tested, not to appear innocent but to allow investigation to focus on their child. Even if it's not 100% accurate, the probability is high and doubt very much reduced. The issue in the McCann case is precisely doubt. How will they get out of it ?
-
The rule of law means, you can't be found innocent of a crime, unless you have been charged with one and found innocent.
Read up on hypothesis testing. It's quite enlightening.
What has that got to do with anything? They haven't been charged or found guilty. That's it really.
-
The first issue is to define the nature of the crime. The investigation wasn't able to determine it. There was a fact (disappearance), but what sort of crime ?
It's easy to understand why, in the US, parents of missing children ask to be tested, not to appear innocent but to allow investigation to focus on their child. Even if it's not 100% accurate, the probability is high and doubt very much reduced. The issue in the McCann case is precisely doubt. How will they get out of it ?
The McCanns are no longer concerned with the doubts of a few Internet Trolls.
-
The rule of law means, you can't be found innocent of a crime, unless you have been charged with one and found innocent.
Read up on hypothesis testing. It's quite enlightening.
I'm presuming you haven't been charged with any McCann related crime and found innocent - so can we take it you should be regarded as a suspect? An injection of common sense is required here methinks.
-
I'm presuming you haven't been charged with any McCann related crime and found innocent - so can we take it you should be regarded as a suspect? An injection of common sense is required here methinks.
Trolling is a Crime, you know. Lots of evidence of that.
-
They volunteered to take one, then backed out. >@@(*&)
What exactly was the question asked and by whom, and what was the full reply ?
I suspect some selective editing. "If they were asked... " - the article doesn't state by whom. Hint: the first article says "in Portugal".
So then the service provider to Jeremy Kyle's rival show makes an approach.
The second article fails to point out the question about accuracy. Odd that.
What would it have achieved anyway?
If they had done one and it turned out that the results were in the 4% error margin (assuming this guy's machines actually have the same alleged accuracy as those used in the US, which may or may not be the case) - it would have been all over the tabloids within minutes that they were "lying".
If it had turned out that the test had concluded that they had replied truthfully, the sceptics would have been googling for 500 hours to find instances in which people had managed to cheat the machine, or myths would have flown around that a service provider for a chav TV reality show had been paid a fortune to fake the results.
Kate and Gerry McCann are prepared to take a lie detector test to clear their names.
Last updated at 10:04 21 September 2007
The couple are so confident of their own innocence that would take the polygraph test in Portugal, a source close to the couple said.
(...)
The McCanns' offer to submit to lie detector tests would only serve to help clear any public doubts about the McCanns' guilt or innocence, as polygraphs are inadmissible in Portuguese courts and are never used by Portuguese police during the course of investigations.
The source said last night: "If they were asked to take a lie detector test, of course they would agree.
"Kate and Gerry are happy to do anything that would help clear their names."
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-482811/Madeleines-parents-We-lie-detector-test-clear-names.html#ixzz2WSaSzrL3
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook
Now Kate McCann refuses to take a lie detector test to clear her name
By VANESSA ALLEN
Last updated at 16:58 19 November 2007
Kate McCann has refused to take a lie detector test about her daughter Madeleine's disappearance, it was revealed yesterday.
She and husband Gerry had offered to undergo a polygraph examination in September, after they were made official suspects in the investigation.
But it has now emerged that they have refused an expert's offer to carry it out, because the results would not be admissible as evidence to a Portuguese court.
Kate McCann: Refuses to take a lie detector test
Don Cargill, chairman of the British and European Polygraph Association, said the McCanns told him they would only take the test if it was 100 per cent accurate and admissible in a Portuguese court.
He told the Sunday Express: "Kate said she'd take it to prove her innocence but in reality, she wasn't willing.
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-494765/Now-Kate-McCann-refuses-lie-detector-test-clear-name.html#ixzz2WSbURusj
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook
-
I'm presuming you haven't been charged with any McCann related crime and found innocent - so can we take it you should be regarded as a suspect? An injection of common sense is required here methinks.
What a load of cobblers.
I have and would never let any of my children alone and unguarded in the circumstances they did.
So what exactly is your point ?
-
Don't you think this polygraph episode was a PR mistake, Carana ?
-
The McCanns are no longer concerned with the doubts of a few Internet Trolls.
What a truly pathetic reply, but entirely predictable.
Tis a shame they didn't take care of their children properly in the first place, or haven't you grasped that point yet. >@@(*&)
-
What a truly pathetic reply, but entirely predictable.
Tis a shame they didn't take care of their children properly in the first place, or haven't you grasped that point yet. >@@(*&)
I thought this Thread was about Polygraphs. There must be another Thread where you can slag them off about their parenting skills.
-
Don't you think this polygraph episode was a PR mistake, Carana ?
In what way?
Someone (press?) asked "a source" if they would be willing to take a test.
What the papers actually report of the question and answer can be subject to selective editing.
-
Kate and Gerry are happy to do anything that will help them to clear their names,” a source close to the couple said.
Which is jornalistic speak for a made up story.
Did either Mr or Mrs Mccann ever actually say anything about a polygraph?
-
Kate and Gerry are happy to do anything that will help them to clear their names,” a source close to the couple said.
Which is jornalistic speak for a made up story.
Did either Mr or Mrs Mccann ever actually say anything about a polygraph?
Since Polygraphs are not normal procedure in Britain or Portugal, then I very much doubt it.
-
Kate and Gerry are happy to do anything that will help them to clear their names,” a source close to the couple said.
Which is jornalistic speak for a made up story.
Did either Mr or Mrs Mccann ever actually say anything about a polygraph?
Good point as to who that original "source" was...
Clarence did respond at some point.
http://madeleinemythsexposed.pbworks.com/w/page/39077824/Rebuttal%20of%20%22Fact%22%v
-
In what way?
Someone (press?) asked "a source" if they would be willing to take a test.
What the papers actually report of the question and answer can be subject to selective editing.
Should I deduce from "in what way?" that you don't agree the polygraph episode was a spin doctor's mistake, but possibly a media's one or misunderstanding ?
-
Why was that article posted n th FIRST PLACE??
Which article? Posted here? Or published?
-
For reference purposes
From Sky News, hardly 'anti-mccann' 8)--)) are they ?
But spokesman Clarence Mitchell said evidence from any test would not be admissible in a Portuguese court.
"Kate and Gerry McCann have absolutely nothing to hide," Mr Mitchell said.
"If a request from the Portuguese authorities was made for them to undergo such a lie detector test, they would have no issue with it, provided the test is suitably overseen by an appropriate expert who can ensure the absolutely reliability of the equipment being used."
But he said he understood that such machines were not used in Portuguese criminal cases, nor was the information from them admissible in court.
"Therefore we think it is extremely unlikely that such a request for a test would come through," he added.
The McCanns' declaration that they would be happy to take a lie detector test is just the latest stage of a public fightback to show they had nothing to do with their daughter's disappearance.
The couple, from Rothley, Leicestershire, were declared suspects by detectives after DNA traces were found in a car hired after Madeleine's disappearance.
The couple have returned to Britain after a four-month stay in Portugal and have been told that police do not have enough evidence to justify interviewing them again.
-------------------------------------
-
For reference purposes
From Sky News, hardly 'anti-mccann' 8)--)) are they ?
But spokesman Clarence Mitchell said evidence from any test would not be admissible in a Portuguese court.
"Kate and Gerry McCann have absolutely nothing to hide," Mr Mitchell said.
"If a request from the Portuguese authorities was made for them to undergo such a lie detector test, they would have no issue with it, provided the test is suitably overseen by an appropriate expert who can ensure the absolutely reliability of the equipment being used."
But he said he understood that such machines were not used in Portuguese criminal cases, nor was the information from them admissible in court.
"Therefore we think it is extremely unlikely that such a request for a test would come through," he added.
The McCanns' declaration that they would be happy to take a lie detector test is just the latest stage of a public fightback to show they had nothing to do with their daughter's disappearance.
The couple, from Rothley, Leicestershire, were declared suspects by detectives after DNA traces were found in a car hired after Madeleine's disappearance.
The couple have returned to Britain after a four-month stay in Portugal and have been told that police do not have enough evidence to justify interviewing them again.
-------------------------------------
Thank you for finding that, Stephen.
-
They must be mad to even consider taking a polygraph because it is a false science and open to so many variables.
If Mitchell is counselling them in such a manner then they are being badly advised.
I have a feeling that statement was yet more media hype as he rightly knows that the polygraph has no place in criminal justice cases and should be maintained in the Jeremy Kyle arena of garbage TV.
-
It would appear that he wasn't.
Judging from the Sky News comment above - it would appear that he was answering a direct question from a journalist.
This particular thread appears to have arisen from an individual offering the McCanns a polygraph test, which they politely declined. As any rational human being would.
-
It would appear that he wasn't.
Judging from the Sky News comment above - it would appear that he was answering a direct question from a journalist.
This particular thread appears to have arisen from an individual offering the McCanns a polygraph test, which they politely declined. As any rational human being would.
8@??)( 8((()*/
-
Quite.
But that hasn't stopped the howls of "which innocent parents would REFUSE a lie detector test", though, has it?
ETA: it reminds me of a certain garden-dig appeal...
-
Howls being from these very same people who regularly view the Jeremy Kyle show every morning.
-
What a load of cobblers.
I have and would never let any of my children alone and unguarded in the circumstances they did.
So what exactly is your point ?
But I only have your word for that - and I don't know you from Adam. Care to take a polygraph test?
(See how ridiculous this is?)
If you have never been charged with any crime, then your status is exactly the same as the McCanns - there is no difference under the law.
-
Our sister site on twitter spent some time challenging these so-called polygraph experts but needless to say not one of them was prepared to put their neck on the line or their head in the noose. @)(++(*
-
Our sister site on twitter spent some time challenging these so-called polygraph experts but needless to say not one of them was prepared to put their neck on the line or their head in the noose. @)(++(*
Precisely! I would never consider taking such a test - I would fail from the start so I would be considered guilty even if there was no actual evidence against me. From what I have read of the procedure it does not take into account any medical problems that could influence the results. 8)><(
-
But I only have your word for that - and I don't know you from Adam. Care to take a polygraph test?
(See how ridiculous this is?)
If you have never been charged with any crime, then your status is exactly the same as the McCanns - there is no difference under the law.
Complete rubbish.
The mccanns behaviour and lack of childcare led to the disappearance of Madeleine. They were her parents and guardians.
If you have any doubt as to what that entails, read up on the NSPCC.
As to why they were never charged with neglect, I do not know.
What they failed to do and the subsequent consequences are why we are commenting here.
-
"Kate and Gerry McCann have absolutely nothing to hide," Mr Mitchell said.
I wonder how the British public reacts to that kind of statement, but I'm sure that in Cartesian France it would be found laughable if not ludicrous to use one of the favourite words of Mr Mitchell.
-
Complete rubbish.
The mccanns behaviour and lack of childcare led to the disappearance of Madeleine. They were her parents and guardians.
If you have any doubt as to what that entails, read up on the NSPCC.
As to why they were never charged with neglect, I do not know.
What they failed to do and the subsequent consequences are why we are commenting here.
Is there a connection between your comment and the discussion about polygraphs?
-
You may think so, this was not my point and I see no xenophobism in wondering how this kind of statement is received in the UK. I noted Inspector Redwood used very much the word "believe" which means conviction without rational basis.
Mr Mitchell assumes as given something which is only a matter of belief. This is a performative utterance.
Objectively, an investigation just under a year-and-a-half long unearthed nothing incriminating against any of the original 3 arguidos, strongly suggesting that none has anything to hide.
-
Objectively, an investigation just under a year-and-a-half long unearthed nothing incriminating against any of the original 3 arguidos, strongly suggesting that none has anything to hide.
Strange logic ! Nothing to hide by default !
When a person refuses to answer questions to authorities asked to resolve an issue, people will usually deduce the person has something to hide.
-
Strange logic ! Nothing to hide by default !
When a person refuses to answer questions to authorities asked to resolve an issue, people will usually deduce the person has something to hide.
Oh dear!
We aren't back to the questions Kate didn't answer again, are we?
-
Ferryman, my answer was for Carana who unfortunately questioned my answer to you !
Like dodgem.
-
Oh dear!
We aren't back to the questions Kate didn't answer again, are we?
No, it was just an example of what common sense tells.
(I know Mrs McCann had the right not to answer, did what her lawyer advised, both seeming to consider not what actually was at stake (getting a child back) but all the bullshit people would gossip about)
-
If there is little news, then perhaps the press are being discreet?
ETA: pending further information, or a public appeal...
I think the media feel something's fishy, but don't want to put on risk the little girl's life.
-
Complete rubbish.
The mccanns behaviour and lack of childcare led to the disappearance of Madeleine. They were her parents and guardians.
If you have any doubt as to what that entails, read up on the NSPCC.
As to why they were never charged with neglect, I do not know.
What they failed to do and the subsequent consequences are why we are commenting here.
It was your assertion that ''You can't be found innocent of a crime unless you have been charged with one and found innocent.'' By that logic then everyone, including yourself, who hasn't been charged with a crime against Madeleine and found innocent of one -still cannot be perceived to be innocent. It's your theory not mine. I prefer - Innocent until proved guilty - and so does the Law thank goodness, as it protects us from lynchmobs.
In reply to your reply which incidentally had nothing to do with my post - the McCanns did no different to thousands of other parents who, whilst on holiday, leave their children asleep knowing they will be regularly checked.
People who disagree with that particular baby listening arrangement are entitled to their opinion.
However the constant attempts to pretend they were the only parents on the planet ever to mirror the Baby Listening Service legally offered by tour operators etc. is completely unfair. IMO The McCanns are guilty of human error, for which they and their daughter have paid the most terrible price. The abductor is the criminal here, in case you've forgotten.
(apols to all for going off topic)
-
My guess is that the question was 'put' to Clarence Mitchell by a journo, , and, slipping into 'I speak for Kate and Gerry' mode, he made a committment on their behalf that they would never have even considered ... and I wouldn't blame them for not considering it either. They faced very serious charges potentially being brought and risking ANY chance of error in the procedure would be madness
That was just Clarence Michell at his arrogant 'we call all the shots' best ( or worst ) in my opinion
-
No, it was just an example of what common sense tells.
(I know Mrs McCann had the right not to answer, did what her lawyer advised, both seeming to consider not what actually was at stake (getting a child back) but all the bullshit people would gossip about)
Surely the whole point, though, Anne is that these questions did not contribute to getting at the material truth.
I should stress, I don't mean, by that, that the PJ as a whole were out to get the McCanns. I actually believe, quite genuinely, that the opposite is true. In particular, I am an absolute fan of the PJ inspector Dias, and I think that Inspector Carlos, after a wobbly 5 minutes, emerged with great credit, especially for his final report.
And I believe many other Portuguese officers put in a great deal of hard and excellent work.
But I believe that there is a model within Portuguese policing (borrowed, I think, from the American model) that it is acceptable practice to test a suspect by lying to them, the rationale being, simply, that if they hold firm, that helps to establish that they have nothing to hide.
The McCanns held firm and the PJ and prosecutors concluded that the McCanns had nothing to hide, and that that was reflected in the final report.
I also liked the work of PJ Inspector Ferraria (sp) who interviewed Yvonne Martin and (I believe) assessed her and the worth of her evidence exactly right.
There are many other examples of very fine work put in by PJ officers.
But the tragedy (for Madeleine especially) is that the focus on her parents allowed the true perpetrator(s) to get away, and I fear that is where it all went most badly wrong.
-
Surely the whole point, though, Anne is that these questions did not contribute to getting at the material truth.
I should stress, I don't mean, by that, that the PJ as a whole were out to get the McCanns. I actually believe, quite genuinely, that the opposite is true. In particular, I am an absolute fan of the PJ inspector Dias, and I think that Inspector Carlos, after a wobbly 5 minutes, emerged with great credit, especially for his final report.
And I believe many other Portuguese officers put in a great deal of hard and excellent work.
But I believe that there is a model within Portuguese policing (borrowed, I think, from the American model) that it is acceptable practice to test a suspect by lying to them, the rationale being, simply, that if they hold firm, that helps to establish that they have nothing to hide.
The McCanns held firm and the PJ and prosecutors concluded that the McCanns had nothing to hide, and that that was reflected in the final report.
I also liked the work of PJ Inspector Ferraria (sp) who interviewed Yvonne Martin and (I believe) assessed her and the worth of her evidence exactly right.
There are many other examples of very fine work put in by PJ officers.
But the tragedy (for Madeleine especially) is that the focus on her parents allowed the true perpetrator(s) to get away, and I fear that is where it all went most badly wrong.
Agreed. My sentiments entirely.
-
I think the media feel something's fishy, but don't want to put on risk the little girl's life.
Quite rightly so.
Have the French been insisting on a polygraph?
-
Quite rightly so.
Have the French been insisting on a polygraph?
How would Amaral fair with a polygraph test?
Would he submit to one?
-
How would Amaral fair with a polygraph test?
Would he submit to one?
Along with his wife, Sofia?.
-
Quite rightly so.
Have the French been insisting on a polygraph?
The polygraph isn't admitted as evidence in France, Carana. Family members aren't (yet) officially suspected. As I said above, in the US, polygraph is used by family members, in case of a missing child, to contribute to the investigation, not letting the police lose time on them.
-
The polygraph isn't admitted as evidence in France, Carana. Family members aren't (yet) officially suspected. As I said above, in the US, polygraph is used by family members, in case of a missing child, to contribute to the investigation, not letting the police lose time on them.
So why isn't it standard practice by police forces in Europe, whatever the alleged crime?
-
It was your assertion that ''You can't be found innocent of a crime unless you have been charged with one and found innocent.'' By that logic then everyone, including yourself, who hasn't been charged with a crime against Madeleine and found innocent of one -still cannot be perceived to be innocent. It's your theory not mine. I prefer - Innocent until proved guilty - and so does the Law thank goodness, as it protects us from lynchmobs.
In reply to your reply which incidentally had nothing to do with my post - the McCanns did no different to thousands of other parents who, whilst on holiday, leave their children asleep knowing they will be regularly checked.
People who disagree with that particular baby listening arrangement are entitled to their opinion.
However the constant attempts to pretend they were the only parents on the planet ever to mirror the Baby Listening Service legally offered by tour operators etc. is completely unfair. IMO The McCanns are guilty of human error, for which they and their daughter have paid the most terrible price. The abductor is the criminal here, in case you've forgotten.
(apols to all for going off topic)
You are making excuses,no more and no less.
The cliche, of many other people did what they did, doesn't wash,literally or metaphorically.
It wasn't an error, they did what they did for several nights in a row, leaving their children in an unlocked/locked apartment, in a country they did not know. They went out to wine and dine, and no matter what you say to divert attention, that was and is never acceptable behaviour.
They had left their children with people they did not know during the daytime, yet could not be bothered to pay for a babysitter.
As to an abductor, please provide proof, not rhetoric.
-
You are making excuses,no more and no less.
The cliche, of many other people did what they did, doesn't wash,literally or metaphorically.
It wasn't an error, they did what they did for several nights in a row, leaving their children in an unlocked/locked apartment, in a country they did not know. They went out to wine and dine, and no matter what you say to divert attention, that was and is never acceptable behaviour.
They had left their children with people they did not know during the daytime, yet could not be bothered to pay for a babysitter.
As to an abductor, please provide proof, not rhetoric.
Isn't there an existing moan thread for having dined outside of the apartment?
-
Isn't there an existing moan thread for having dined outside of the apartment?
Add the drinking to that.
-
So why isn't it standard practice by police forces in Europe, whatever the alleged crime?
Why ? I suggest you ask the Commissaire Viviane Reding (she always answers) responsible for justice issues
http://ec.europa.eu/commission_2010-2014/reding/index_fr.htm
-
Why ? I suggest you ask the Commissaire Viviane Reding (she always answers) responsible for justice issues
http://ec.europa.eu/commission_2010-2014/reding/index_fr.htm
Thanks for that, Anne. Did you already ask about this? And if so what was the reply?
-
Isn't there an existing moan thread for having dined outside of the apartment?
There is no record of anyone outside the tapas bunch leaving their babies unattended whilst they went out for the evening....common sense should have told them there was a reason there was no baby listening service in PDL, not as if thy were stupid and couldnt figure it out, quite staggering how so many people support what they did or rather excuse it,....the criticism as you well know had not been about them dining outside the apartment, but not taking their children with them as plenty of other holidaymakers managed to do, or arranging suitable childcare but taking risks, and yes, they took many risks IMO...and as for gerry mccann saying thousands of people wrote to him saying ey had done the same or would do, well, a porky IMO and you also have no idea because any other resort offered baby listening, how many parents actually did leave their babies and toddlers alone
i feel another spin off thread coming up
-
There is no record of anyone outside the tapas bunch leaving their babies unattended whilst they went out for the evening....common sense should have told them there was a reason there was no baby listening service in PDL, not as if thy were stupid and couldnt figure it out, quite staggering how so many people support what they did or rather excuse it,....the criticism as you well know had not been about them dining outside the apartment, but not taking their children with them as plenty of other holidaymakers managed to do, or arranging suitable childcare but taking risks, and yes, they took many risks IMO...and as for gerry mccann saying thousands of people wrote to him saying ey had done the same or would do, well, a porky IMO and you also have no idea because any other resort offered baby listening, how many parents actually did leave their babies and toddlers alone
i feel another spin off thread coming up
The connection to a polygraph test by a service provider to a chav TV show being?
-
The connection to a polygraph test by a service provider to a chav TV show being?
You asked a question, which was misleading in itself, i answered
-
The only use a polygraph or lie detector has is to scare suspects into making a confession as happened to Adrian Prout. In the US they use it as often as they use the coffee maker is routinely.
It has been shown on many occasions that the polygraph cannot be trusted. In fact in some places the polygraph has become known as the lie creator.
-
The only use a polygraph or lie detector has is to scare suspects into making a confession as happened to Adrian Prout. In the US they use it as often as they use the coffee maker is routinely.
It has been shown on many occasions that the polygraph cannot be trusted. In fact in some places the polygraph has become known as the lie creator.
Agreed, the polygraph in all its forms is rubbish and is only any use on "Shock-Jock TV". You get more sense out of playing with Tarot Cards. Same goes for "Truth-Drugs" and torture for that matter, (sorry enhanced interrogation techniques).
Guilty people normally use it as a way of claiming innocence but there is no legal or scientific process of using it to prove guilt or innocence.
-
Agreed, the polygraph in all its forms is rubbish and is only any use on "Shock-Jock TV". You get more sense out of playing with Tarot Cards. Same goes for "Truth-Drugs" and torture for that matter, (sorry enhanced interrogation techniques).
Guilty people normally use it as a way of claiming innocence but there is no legal or scientific process of using it to prove guilt or innocence.
Aren't they supposed to work by measuring increased heart beat in someone likely not to be telling the truth?
-
The only use a polygraph or lie detector has is to scare suspects into making a confession
Yes, but lie detectors have to be furbished like dissuasive weapons in the Cold War.
-
Agreed, the polygraph in all its forms is rubbish and is only any use on "Shock-Jock TV". You get more sense out of playing with Tarot Cards. Same goes for "Truth-Drugs" and torture for that matter, (sorry enhanced interrogation techniques).
What about the GHB (toiffies) or Fantasy, flunitrazépam (better known as Rohypnol3), Zolpidem4 and sometimes kétamine ?
-
Thanks for that, Anne. Did you already ask about this? And if so what was the reply?
I wrote to Viviane Reding many years ago, not on that topic but on a practice among teenagers that ends up with death (about 4 a month in the UK) called the fainting lark.
-
Aren't they supposed to work by measuring increased heart beat in someone likely not to be telling the truth?
Increased heart rate, blood pressure, respiration rate, pupil dilation, eye movement, skin conductivity, all sort of things. However, the results depend on the reactions to "control questions" and previous training, psychological states and conditioning and self-belief even psychopathy can confuse the results. As the test itself is an abnormal condition then the above physical changes will be elevated to start with. Self-inflicted minor pains or muscle cramping during the "control questions" reduce the difference between the "control" and "actual" questions.
So if these things are "reliable" then why are they not in public use so we can dispense with trials, juries, investigations, appeals and just go from "rounding up the usual suspects", one simple test and then straight to the death penalty? If they boast 96% accuracy then that is better than any justice system. In fact the machine could just "fry" the victim at the end of the "reliable" test.
Be popular in Texas.
-
Increased heart rate, blood pressure, respiration rate, pupil dilation, eye movement, skin conductivity, all sort of things. However, the results depend on the reactions to "control questions" and previous training, psychological states and conditioning and self-belief even psychopathy can confuse the results. As the test itself is an abnormal condition then the above physical changes will be elevated to start with. Self-inflicted minor pains or muscle cramping during the "control questions" reduce the difference between the "control" and "actual" questions.
So if these things are "reliable" then why are they not in public use so we can dispense with trials, juries, investigations, appeals and just go from "rounding up the usual suspects", one simple test and then straight to the death penalty? If they boast 96% accuracy then that is better than any justice system. In fact the machine could just "fry" the victim at the end of the "reliable" test.
Be popular in Texas.
Thank you for that.
Interesting ...
-
Thank you for that.
Interesting ...
Yes, agree. Very interesting.
-
If they boast 96% accuracy then that is better than any justice system.
But it's no justice system !
-
What has Guantanamo torture got to do with polygraph ?
in reply #100 I referred to torture being probably more reliable than the Polygraph.
Both are demonstrably flawed concepts.
-
in reply #100 I referred to torture being probably more reliable than the Polygraph.
Both are demonstrably flawed concepts.
yes they are, do truth drugs work? Or is that a myth?
-
yes they are, do truth drugs work? Or is that a myth?
As far as I know there are no such things as "Truth Drugs" but there are some drugs that have an inhibition lowering effect. However, can you ever rely on anything that changes someone's mental state?
The only "Proper Truth Drug" I know of is moderately high qualities of alcohol but the after effects can be unpleasant ranging from violent sickness and headaches to unwanted pregnancies and social diseases and worse still - unwanted marriage.
Again alcohol usually induces extreme self-delusion of physical beauty, susceptibility to verbal rubbish and a delusion of being able to sing and dance to showroom standards.
Here is the Wiki on Truth Serums. It seems some Governments have messed with various things but mostly it does not work, is largely fictional, and highly unreliable.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truth_serum
In other words it is more Hollywood bollocks.
-
As far as I know there are no such things as "Truth Drugs" but there are some drugs that have an inhibition lowering effect. However, can you ever rely on anything that changes someone's mental state?
The only "Proper Truth Drug" I know of is moderately high qualities of alcohol but the after effects can be unpleasant ranging from violent sickness and headaches to unwanted pregnancies and social diseases and worse still - unwanted marriage.
Again alcohol usually induces extreme self-delusion of physical beauty, susceptibility to verbal rubbish and a delusion of being able to sing and dance to showroom standards.
Here is the Wiki on Truth Serums. It seems some Governments have messed with various things but mostly it does not work, is largely fictional, and highly unreliable.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truth_serum
In other words it is more Hollywood bollocks.
Very interesting.
Thank you Outlook
-
Can we keep to the topic under discussion.
-
Surely if the McCanns took a polygraph and passed it would be assumed that those conducting the polygraph were "in on it"
-
Surely if the McCanns took a polygraph and passed it would be assumed that those conducting the polygraph were "in on it"
Particularly if the test was offered by someone involved in daytime TV entertainment...
-
We would certainly see all of the evidence about how unreliable Polygraphs are.
Let's face it, they are never going to believe that The McCanns are innocent because a Polygraph said so, especially since it is useless in Court.
No, they done it, alright.
-
We would certainly see all of the evidence about how unreliable Polygraphs are.
Let's face it, they are never going to believe that The McCanns are innocent because a Polygraph said so, especially since it is useless in Court.
No, they done it, alright.
......and what would those like you say, if dare I say it, it showed the Mccanns lying.
Time for a GM scratch around the ear.
-
This just underlines the futility of taking a polygraph test because in the final analysis it is a lose lose scenario. It they passed it with flying colours it would be called a fluke, lucky or they managed to fool it. If they were to fail it they would be damned and for ever doomed to being guilty.
The polygraph is very dangerous and very false.
-
This just underlines the futility of taking a polygraph test because in the final analysis it is a lose lose scenario. It they passed it with flying colours it would be called a fluke, lucky or they managed to fool it. If they were to fail it they would be damned and for ever doomed to being guilty.
The polygraph is very dangerous and very false.
8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)(
-
This just underlines the futility of taking a polygraph test because in the final analysis it is a lose lose scenario. It they passed it with flying colours it would be called a fluke, lucky or they managed to fool it. If they were to fail it they would be damned and for ever doomed to being guilty.
The polygraph is very dangerous and very false.
It might help as a general asset. Maybe.
I find it odd that in the case cited a few pages above (link below) one lie detector expert found that a person was lying and another found that the same person wasn't.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=1819.msg56505#msg56505
-
Lie detectors whether some like it or not are used and are accurate to a level of 96%.
The real reason people fear them is that if they fail, others will think they are liars.
No system is foolproof.
However, if the Mccanns have nothing to fear they could of course volunteer to take Sodium Pentathol.
-
Lie detectors whether some like it or not are used and are accurate to a level of 96%.
The real reason people fear them is that if they fail, others will think they are liars.
No system is foolproof.
However, if the Mccanns have nothing to fear they could of course volunteer to take Sodium Pentathol.
They are not accurate to anything. They are science fiction rubbish. What would drugging people achieve, again sodium pentathol is the stuff of spy stories and does not work.
-
Lie detectors whether some like it or not are used and are accurate to a level of 96%.
The real reason people fear them is that if they fail, others will think they are liars.
No system is foolproof.
However, if the Mccanns have nothing to fear they could of course volunteer to take Sodium Pentathol.
Absolute rubbish Stephen. I doubt you have been reading too many sci fi magazines.
-
Polygraphs are for chav day time telly shows (and they're probably harmful enough even there), not for regular police work.
-
They are not accurate to anything. They are science fiction rubbish. What would drugging people achieve, again sodium pentathol is the stuff of spy stories and does not work.
Some people I note, don't get sarcasm, i.e. in my reference to Sodiun Pentathol.
However, why this fear of lie detectors amongst supporters of the Mccanns ?
First they would accept them, then they wouldn't.
Now why is that ?
Also, of interest to put it mildly, is the non-verbal responses of the Mccanns in their interviews.
Cue another debate.
-
This just underlines the futility of taking a polygraph test because in the final analysis it is a lose lose scenario. It they passed it with flying colours it would be called a fluke, lucky or they managed to fool it. If they were to fail it they would be damned and for ever doomed to being guilty.
The polygraph is very dangerous and very false.
I agree, the McCanns had nothing to gain from doing any of those Jeremy Kyle style lie detector tests &, more to the point, they never said they would do that.
-
I agree, the McCanns had nothing to gain from doing any of those Jeremy Kyle style lie detector tests &, more to the point, they never said they would do that.
Complete rubbish, it's not just a Jeremy Kyle' tool for chavs.
-
Lie Detector Tests serve absolutely no purpose simply because they are not Evidence. Often taken under extreme stress, and duress, the persons taking the test are in no fit state in the first place.
It is an American trend that will likely be dropped even by America in the not so distant future. In fact, more and more people in America are now refusing to take these tests, where it is freely admitted by Law Enforcement that they prove nothing.
-
Lie Detector Tests serve absolutely no purpose simply because they are not Evidence. Often taken under extreme stress, and duress, the persons taking the test are in no fit state in the first place.
It is an American trend that will likely be dropped even by America in the not so distant future. In fact, more and more people in America are now refusing to take these tests, where it is freely admitted by Law Enforcement that they prove nothing.
Yes, as I said, only for day time telly chavs, they seem to like these little "tests" a lot though.
-
Yes, as I said, only for day time telly chavs, they seem to like these little "tests" a lot though.
Utter balderdash.
If lie detectors were completely useless, then they wouldn't be used at all.
The reaction to them on here is simply because of the Mccanns failure to take them, and the pitiful excuses offered after they initially said they would.
-
And again
Mr and Mrs McCann, both 39, said last night that they were prepared to take a lie detector test if requested by the Portuguese authorities. “Kate and Gerry are happy to do anything that will help them to clear their names,” a source close to the couple said. “They have said all along that they want to cooperate fully with the Portuguese police, but as of today they have received no such request.”
http://www.standard.co.uk/newsheadlines/mccanns-offer-to-take-lie-test-6698135.html
-
And again
Mr and Mrs McCann, both 39, said last night that they were prepared to take a lie detector test if requested by the Portuguese authorities. “Kate and Gerry are happy to do anything that will help them to clear their names,” a source close to the couple said. “They have said all along that they want to cooperate fully with the Portuguese police, but as of today they have received no such request.”
http://www.standard.co.uk/newsheadlines/mccanns-offer-to-take-lie-test-6698135.html
Why won't you quote what Mitchell said about this ?
-
The only people who want them to take a polygraph are the same people who never believe a word they say, and find fault with every single thing they do. I've never read one post (anywhere) from a Sceptic to say that they would change their mind and believe them to be innocent - if such a test was passed. So a totally pointless exercise anyway.
Just another tired old stick to beat the McCanns with. imo
-
Yes, as I said, only for day time telly chavs, they seem to like these little "tests" a lot though.
Well, they would, wouldn't they. Endless pitch forking debate. Pass or fail, it makes no difference. In fact, "Pass" is often better because then they can rabbit on interminably about Sociopaths and Psychopaths who are apparently well know for passing these tests.
-
Well, they would, wouldn't they. Endless pitch forking debate. Pass or fail, it makes no difference. In fact, "Pass" is often better because then they can rabbit on interminably about Sociopaths and Psychopaths who are apparently well know for passing these tests.
Yes, sure.
And here's what Mitchell had to say:
Clarence Mitchell, the McCanns' spokesman, said that it was "extremely unlikely" the couple would be asked to take a lie detector test by police. He said: "Kate and Gerry McCann have absolutely nothing to hide and, if a request from the Portuguese authorities was made for them to undergo such a lie detector test, they would have no issue with it, provided the test is suitably overseen by an appropriate expert who can ensure the absolutely reliability of the equipment being used.
http://www.standard.co.uk/newsheadlines/mccanns-offer-to-take-lie-test-6698135.html
-
There have been murderers who passed the test, which does make the subject somewhat suspect.
The ‘Angel of Death’, Charles Cullen, working as a nurse, murdered as many as 40 people over a ten year period by giving them lethal injections. After his first victim died, he was considered a suspect and asked to take a polygraph test. He passed the polygraph test and went on to kill at least another 39 people. The failure of the polygraph cost 39 people their lives.
The Green River Killer, Gary Leon Ridgeway, pled guilty to murdering 48 women in the Seattle area over a twenty-year period. Ridgeway was given a polygraph following the murder of his fourth victim and passed the polygraph exam. He was then dropped as a suspect and went on to kill another 44 women. He is listed as the most prolific killer in U.S. history. If the polygraph had been accurate, his reign of terror would have ended after his fourth victim. The failure of the polygraph to detect Ridgeway cost 44 women their lives.
-
There have been murderers who passed the test, which does make the subject somewhat suspect.
Scary, that alone should be enough to outlaw the practice.
-
Scary, that alone should be enough to outlaw the practice.
There is also the case of the traitor Adrich Ames who, in 1986 and 1991, passed two polygraph tests while spying for the Soviet Union and Russia, respectively. Ames was initially "terrified" at the prospect of taking the test, but he was advised by the KGB "to just relax." Ames's test demonstrated deceptive answers to some questions but the examiners passed him, perhaps in the later opinion of the CIA because the examiners were "overly friendly" and therefore did not induce the proper physiological response. He was responsible for the death of at least 10 US agents.
-
Well, they would, wouldn't they. Endless pitch forking debate. Pass or fail, it makes no difference. In fact, "Pass" is often better because then they can rabbit on interminably about Sociopaths and Psychopaths who are apparently well know for passing these tests.
Well you really like that phrase don't you, 'pitch-forking'.
Now that really sums up the obsessive mccannites.
-
There is also the case of the traitor Adrich Ames who, in 1986 and 1991, passed two polygraph tests while spying for the Soviet Union and Russia, respectively. Ames was initially "terrified" at the prospect of taking the test, but he was advised by the KGB "to just relax." Ames's test demonstrated deceptive answers to some questions but the examiners passed him, perhaps in the later opinion of the CIA because the examiners were "overly friendly" and therefore did not induce the proper physiological response. He was responsible for the death of at least 10 US agents.
Equally scary.
-
I can understand very well that parents of a missing child, in order to have the police concentrating on the child and not on vain suspicions on them, deliberately ask to be lie detected.
It has anyhow only a presumption value in the US. Though cold criminals manage unsurprisingly to pass the test, there's no story of an innocent being condemned because, as he/she was a particular emotional person, he/she didn't pass the test.
-
The Truth About Lie Detectors, Says David Lykken, Is That They Can't Detect a Lie
http://www.people.com/people/archive/article/0,,20079233,00.html
The innocent will fail them 50 percent of the time. Thousands of people, he says, are being refused employment, fired from their jobs and, in some cases, sent to prison—without having committed any crime. A psychiatry and psychology professor at the University of Minnesota who has studied lie detectors for over two decades, Lykken talked with PEOPLE's Linda Witt in his Minneapolis office about the evils of the polygraph.
-
The Truth About Lie Detectors, Says David Lykken, Is That They Can't Detect a Lie
http://www.people.com/people/archive/article/0,,20079233,00.html
This was more than 30 years ago, the situation has changed and measuring possibly improved. It has no proof value in the US, it's just a presumption, so nobody can be charged because of a polygraph result.
I still understand that the US parents of a missing child desperately propose to do it. Moreover if you think of stats concerning the perpetrators.
In the McCann case, the suggestion and later rejection was a communication mistake, imo, nothing more.
-
The only communication mistake was by those who failed to understand what the McCanns actually said, it was clear enough to the rest of us.
-
Find a Lawyer with LegalMatch Find the Right Lawyer Now
Legal Topics > Criminal Law and Police > General Criminal Law > Criminal Procedure
Admissability of Polygraph Tests in Court
Authored by Ken LaMance, LegalMatch Law Library Managing Editor and Attorney at Law
inShare
What Exactly is a Polygraph Test?
A polygraph, or "lie-detector," is a machine that measures various physical attributes (blood pressure, perspiration, heart rate, etc...) and attempts to correlate them with telling lies. In past times they were often used by police and government agents to interrogate suspected criminals, but as they have been proven to be extremely unreliable indicators of lying, their use has lessened in recent years (usually because of court rules prohibiting their use).
If I am Arrested For a Crime, Can I be Forced to Take a Polygraph?
No! In no state can anyone be forced by the police or anyone else to take a polygraph examination. However, many people are not aware of this, and police can often apply plenty of psychological pressure on a suspect to the effect that not taking the test is an automatic admission of guilt. Moreover, refusing to take a test may often convince police that you are guilty, at which point you may be harassed and searched until some kind of evidence is found. But even if one agrees to take a polygraph test and passes it, if the police consider you a suspect, they may believe you "beat the test" rather than told the truth, making it somewhat of a lose-lose situation.
What are the State Laws Concerning Polygraph Admissibility?
Almost every state fits into one of two categories; those that find them completely inadmissible and those that allow their admission with "the stipulations of both parties" (meaning both you and the prosecutor agree to admit the test results as evidence).
States like California, Arizona, Nevada, Georgia, and Florida allow the tests if everyone agrees to them, but may put different emphasis on the test's accuracy.
California, for instance, presents the results to the jury, and allows them to draw whatever inferences from it they wish.
Georgia, on the other hand, allows defendants who suffer damage because of a false result on a polygraph test (which are somewhat frequent) to sue the polygraph operator for damages and attorneys fees.
Florida is the one state that does require some people to submit to polygraph tests (previously convicted sex offenders), but even then those test results cannot be used against them in court, and are for use only within the course of their therapy.
The states in which polygraphs are inadmissible include New York, Texas, Illinois, Pennsylvania, and the District of Columbia. In these states, even if both parties wish to enter polygraph test results into evidence, it is forbidden (except in very rare scenarios).
Some states, like New York and Texas, forbid their use completely in all employment and law enforcement contexts.
Other states, like Massachusetts, do not allow them to be entered as evidence, but CAN use them as supporting probable cause (to obtain search warrants).
Federal courts have their own rules on when to allow the admission of polygraph evidence (it is usually at the judge's discretion). For a complete list of the state and federal rules regarding polygraphs, you can check here for your state.
Do I Need an Attorney?
If you are suspected of a crime, or have already been arrested, and the police are trying to make you take a polygraph examination, you should speak to a lawyer immediately. The police will try to make it seem like refusing the test (or even asking for an attorney!) will lead to your arrest or prove your guilt, but this is absolutely not the case, so it is essential that you have a lawyer present to defend your rights. No one can ever be forced to take this very unreliable test, and you should speak to an experienced criminal lawyer as soon as you can about whether you should agree to one and what would be in your best interest.
Consult a Lawyer - Present Your Case Now!
Last Modified: 05-06-2013 09:59 AM PDT
http://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/admissability-of-polygraph-tests-in-court.html
-
Why would anyone want to faff around with 'lie detector' tests?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-EyT-7Zi5HM
-
If so, people who actually know how to read body language declared the McCanns are innocent.
Why would anyone want to faff around with 'lie detector' tests?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-EyT-7Zi5HM
Who is she? Anyone interesting? Or relevant? Has body language reading qualification above other body language commentators?
As for lie detector tests, if they weren't an issue in any way why did anyone bring the subject up?
PS, it's OK, I found some info...it was him that "dun it"
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id393.html
-
indubitably, the failure to do the lie detector tests as promised.
I haven't found anything to indicate that lie detector tests are accepted as evidence in Portugal.
Who invited them to take such tests? What credentials does whoever it was have? And what purpose would it have served beyond a Jeremy Kyle pantomime show?
-
I haven't found anything to indicate that lie detector tests are accepted as evidence in Portugal.
Who invited them to take such tests? What credentials does whoever it was have? And what purpose would it have served beyond a Jeremy Kyle pantomime show?
You've only got one thing wrong there Carana ... not Jeremy Kyle ... maybe Trisha Goddard??
Summary of Verifiable Facts
- The McCanns' spokesman, Clarence Mitchell is quoted as saying that the McCanns would take a lie detector (polygraph) test if the Portuguese Police asked them to - NOT one sponsored for the media and administered by a polygrapher who works in the entertainment industry.
- The Portuguese Police did not ask the McCanns to take a lie detector test.
- Lie detector tests are not admissible in Portuguese courts, nor in British courts.
- The McCanns declined a lie detector test administered by Don Cargill who is a polygrapher on daytime entertainment programme "Trisha".
http://madeleinemythsexposed.pbworks.com/w/page/39077824/Rebuttal%20of%20%22Fact%22%2022
-
Any evidence the PJ asked for a lie detector test?
Who else apart from Mitchell the Jeremy Kyle n this saga would bring this up?
-
I haven't found anything to indicate that lie detector tests are accepted as evidence in Portugal.
Who invited them to take such tests? What credentials does whoever it was have? And what purpose would it have served beyond a Jeremy Kyle pantomime show?
They volunteered to do so.
Then they changed their minds.
-
They volunteered to do so.
Then they changed their minds.
Is there any point in posting information complete with link which is then just ignored? I have given a link showing that the Drs McCann never volunteered to take a lie detector test.
Neither the Portuguese police or Leicestershire police asked the Drs McCann to take a lie detector test ... and why would they??? They are not admissible in the courts of either jurisdiction.
I have shown you mine ... now let's see yours ... should be easy enough for you to produce a cite to substantiate your assertion.
-
Is there any point in posting information complete with link which is then just ignored? I have given a link showing that the Drs McCann never volunteered to take a lie detector test.
Neither the Portuguese police or Leicestershire police asked the Drs McCann to take a lie detector test ... and why would they??? They are not admissible in the courts of either jurisdiction.
I have shown you mine ... now let's see yours ... should be easy enough for you to produce a cite to substantiate your assertion.
There are many links.
On tablet right now, but if you can be bothered to to type in on google 'the mccanns volunteered to do a lie detector test' you will find plenty, including the mail, and 'a source close to the couple'..
and can you supply a signed statement from the mccanns to that effect ?
The link you gave after all is a somewhat biased sITE and hardly likely to say anything against the mccanns.
P.S. Have the mccanns sued the mail for lying ?
-
Mr and Mrs McCann, both 39, said last night that they were prepared to take a lie detector test if requested by the Portuguese authorities. “Kate and Gerry are happy to do anything that will help them to clear their names,” a source close to the couple said. “They have said all along that they want to cooperate fully with the Portuguese police, but as of today they have received no such request.”
http://www.standard.co.uk/newsheadlines/mccanns-offer-to-take-lie-test-6698135.html
Does this help?
-
There are many links.
On tablet right now, but if you can be bothered to to type in on google 'the mccanns volunteered to do a lie detector test' you will find plenty, including the mail, and 'a source close to the couple'..
and can you supply a signed statement from the mccanns to that effect ?
The link you gave after all is a somewhat biased sITE and hardly likely to say anything against the mccanns.
P.S. Have the mccanns sued the mail for lying ?
thanks for proving the point Stephen...from the mail article...
The source said last night: "If they
were asked to take a lie detector test,
of course they would agree.
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-482811/Madeleines-parents-We-lie-detector-test-clear-names.html#ixzz3gej3M4om
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook
Could you now provide a cite from someone asking the mccanns to take the test...that does not include a drunk down the pub...has anyone in authority asked them to take the test...
[ moderated ]
-
Does this help?
thank you John...so were the mccanns asked to take the test...did they refuse
-
how rude Davel just read up for yourself!!
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id393.html
-
Read the thread which deals with this on the forum.
' the question of the polygraph'.
The mccanns had nothing to lose by taking one, after all it could not be used in court, but their willingness to do one would show they had nothing to fear.
Likewise the mccanns had no need to fear a reconstruction either and fully cooperate with the investigation.
-
how rude Davel just read up for yourself!!
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id393.html
They have said all along that they want to co-operate fully with the Portuguese police," the anonymous 'friend' stated, adding that they had "received no such request from the Portuguese authorities".
from your link..perhaps you should read up yourself
-
thank you John...so were the mccanns asked to take the test...did they refuse
why dont you know?
%56& @)(++(*
-
Read the thread which deals with this on the forum.
' the question of the polygraph'.
The mccanns had nothing to lose by taking one, after all it could not be used in court, but their willingness to do one would show they had nothing to fear.
Likewise the mccanns had no need to fear a reconstruction either and fully cooperate with the investigation.
another lie about the mccanns exposed
-
why dont you know?
%56& @)(++(*
I know...but you seem not to
-
how rude Davel just read up for yourself!!
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id393.html
Thanks for that Mercury.
Quite illuminating.
-
They have said all along that they want to co-operate fully with the Portuguese police," the anonymous 'friend' stated, adding that they had "received no such request from the Portuguese authorities".
from your link..perhaps you should read up yourself
What did the mccanns have to fear by doing one ?
-
Thanks for that Mercury.
Quite illuminating.
it is illuminating but it seems you and mercury are still in the dark
-
What did the mccanns have to fear by doing one ?
so you accept they did not refuse
-
so you accept they did not refuse
They didn't do one.
End of story.
-
The only thng being exposed here is your childishness and utter stupidity, it's very embarrassing too, makes me squirm tbh
once again having lost the argument you resort to an ad hominem attack... 8(>((
-
it is illuminating but it seems you and mercury are still in the dark
No dave.
-
They didn't do one.
End of story.
it is the end of the story..it's all over
-
Thanks for that Mercury.
Quite illuminating.
yes it is, some times the Mccanns and their media men forget what they've said, sad really when they also spend a million quid for them, frightening really
-
once again having lost the argument you resort to an ad hominem attack... 8(>((
stating facts is never an ad hom
-
it is the end of the story..it's all over
Be precise dave.
The mccanns wanted to impose conditions on a lie detector test.
Why on earth should they be allowed to ?
After all, they had nothing to fear.
-
stating facts is never an ad hom
so this is what you think is stating facts...
The only thng being exposed here is your childishness and utter stupidity, it's very embarrassing too, makes me squirm tbh
any intelligent person would describe that s an ad hominem attack
-
Be precise dave.
The mccanns wanted to impose conditions on a lie detector test.
Why on earth should they be allowed to ?
After all, they had nothing to fear.
Bit like the t7 imposing conditions on a reconstruction thick as thieves...
-
Be precise dave.
The mccanns wanted to impose conditions on a lie detector test.
Why on earth should they be allowed to ?
After all, they had nothing to fear.
you have lost your argument by a mile
-
so this is what you think is stating facts...
The only thng being exposed here is your childishness and utter stupidity, it's very embarrassing too, makes me squirm tbh
any intelligent person would describe that s an ad hominem attack
cherry picking out of any argument never works dear
-
it is the end of the story..it's all over
what story and what is over.
@)(++(*
-
cherry picking out of any argument never works dear
stating the truth does
-
stating the truth does
No one has a problem with that
but you seem to be up in arms about...well, not sure exactly
-
I can only find one direct quote about this, from November 2007. Don Cargill gave a lie detector test to Adrian Prout in prison. It was arranged by his fiancee in an effort to prove his innocence. He failed it.
She and husband Gerry offered to undergo a polygraph examination in September to clear their names. They hoped it would help to clear up any doubts about their involvement.
Sources close to the couple made it known they were willing to be questioned after Kate was officially declared an "arguido" or official suspect in the case in Portugal.
But despite being approached by a leading UK polygraph expert, mother-of-three Kate, 39, turned down the chance. Don Cargill, chairman of the British And European Polygraph Association, said he was "shocked" by her decision.
Mr Cargill, official lie detector expert on TV's Trisha Goddard TV show, said: "I spoke to the McCanns' people and they came back with a list of conditions that would have been impossible to satisfy.
"They wanted me to prove the test would be 100 per cent accurate, that I was the world's best examiner and that it would be admissible in a Portuguese court – but I could not guarantee any of those things. Although polygraph testing is very accurate, it is not infallible."
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id393.html
-
I can only find one direct quote about this, from November 2007. Don Cargill gave a lie detector test to Adrian Prout in prison. It was arranged by his fiancee in an effort to prove his innocence. He failed it.
She and husband Gerry offered to undergo a polygraph examination in September to clear their names. They hoped it would help to clear up any doubts about their involvement.
Sources close to the couple made it known they were willing to be questioned after Kate was officially declared an "arguido" or official suspect in the case in Portugal.
But despite being approached by a leading UK polygraph expert, mother-of-three Kate, 39, turned down the chance. Don Cargill, chairman of the British And European Polygraph Association, said he was "shocked" by her decision.
Mr Cargill, official lie detector expert on TV's Trisha Goddard TV show, said: "I spoke to the McCanns' people and they came back with a list of conditions that would have been impossible to satisfy.
"They wanted me to prove the test would be 100 per cent accurate, that I was the world's best examiner and that it would be admissible in a Portuguese court – but I could not guarantee any of those things. Although polygraph testing is very accurate, it is not infallible."
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id393.html
the mccanns offered to take a test if requested by the portuguese police...not one organised by trisha ..please stick to the facts
-
the mccanns offered to take a test if requested by the portuguese police...not one organised by trisha ..please stick to the facts
why did they say anythng at all?
what was cargil on about then?
-
In the Kate Prout murder case, the failure of Mr Prout to pass a Polygraph test led ultimately to his confession to the murder of his wife.
Back in September 2007 the McCanns, as part of their PR 'fight back' against the action of the Portuguese police in making them arguidos, made it known - albeit through the inevitable use of a proxy 'friend of the family'/'source' - that they would be willing to take a lie detector test to clear their names.
"They have said all along that they want to co-operate fully with the Portuguese police," the anonymous 'friend' stated, adding that they had "received no such request from the Portuguese authorities".
Once the frantic headlines, such as 'McCANNS: WE'LL TAKE LIE TEST', had been successfully embedded into the nation's newsstands, Clarence Mitchell, the McCanns spokesperson, stepped forward to pour cold water on the idea. Principally on the grounds that such evidence was not admissible in a Portuguese court.
And there the matter lay...
Until November, of the same year, when a "shocked" Don Cargill, chairman of the British And European Polygraph Association, spoke to the Sunday Express. He revealed that he had spoken to "the McCanns' people", with regard to taking a lie detector test, and they had come back "with a list of conditions that would have been impossible to satisfy".
Mr Cargill said: "Kate said she'd take it to prove her innocence but in reality, she wasn't willing. I was dumbfounded, to tell the truth."
The accompanying headlines, such as 'KATE REFUSES LIE TEST', were clearly unhelpful and so, as usual, Clarence Mitchell was afforded the final word on the subject:
"Gerry and Kate don't need to do one as they are telling the truth."
http://www.mccannfiles.com/id393.html
So a lot of hearsay there from "The anonymous friend" then
ETA link
-
It was history repeating itself. They promised transparency, we got fluff. They promised to take part in a reconstition, it never happened. The polygraph was yet more of the same old excuses.
-
the mccanns offered to take a test if requested by the portuguese police...not one organised by trisha ..please stick to the facts
trisha wasn't involved so pls stick to the facts
-
It was history repeating itself. They promised transparency, we got fluff. They promised to take part in a reconstition, it never happened. The polygraph was yet more of the same old excuses.
Spot on as usual
-
the mccanns offered to take a test if requested by the portuguese police...not one organised by trisha ..please stick to the facts
Lie detector test results are not admissible in the courts of Portugal or the UK. Consequently the likelihood of the Portuguese police of asking the McCanns to take a lie detector test was....nil. Therefore there was no point in making the offer you refer to, as it was never going to happen.
Then the Chairman of the British And European Polygraph Association (who also worked for the TV programme 'Tricia') offered to carry one out. In the McCann's place I would have taken it because it would obviously have been favourable because they are innocent, aren't they? The publicity generated by a successful lie detector test would have been so useful for them.
-
So ... we are agreed then.
Polygraphs are inadmissible in Portuguese courts, thus the Drs McCann were never asked by the PJ to take one and there is no record of either of the Drs volunteering to take one for the simple reason ... they did not.
-
So ... we are agreed then.
Polygraphs are inadmissible in Portuguese courts, thus the Drs McCann were never asked by the PJ to take one and there is no record of either of the Drs volunteering to take one for the simple reason ... they did not.
MSM making stories up again I suppose.
-
So ... we are agreed then.
Polygraphs are inadmissible in Portuguese courts, thus the Drs McCann were never asked by the PJ to take one and there is no record of either of the Drs volunteering to take one for the simple reason ... they did not.
Agreed on what?
I think I would have been inclined to be somewhat more circumspect in my choice of words just in case it jumped up and bit me in the ass a bit later on 8)--))
It makes one wonder why Clarence had to trap off about it doesn't it?. What purpose did that serve then ?
-
Agreed on what?
I think I would have been inclined to be somewhat more circumspect in my choice of words just in case it jumped up and bit me in the ass a bit later on 8)--))
It makes one wonder why Clarence had to trap off about it doesn't it?. What purpose did that serve then ?
He spoke up after Don Cargill reported that the McCanns refused his offer to do a test. He didn't deny that they refused Cargill's offer, he simply said they didn't need to take the test because they were innocent.
-
He spoke up after Don Cargill reported that the McCanns refused his offer to do a test. He didn't deny that they refused Cargill's offer, he simply said they didn't need to take the test because they were innocent.
Oh! So the whole schmear was just smoke and mirrors and window dressing then?
-
oh dear
@)(++(*
-
The man who 'does' the polygraph tests for a daytime television show "Trisha" offers the Drs McCann a polygraph test?? and there are those who think that is OK.
Oh well it takes all kinds I suppose.
-
Are his tests all wrong then?
Or do you have some antipathy to DOCTORS being lie detected
Lets face it Brietta docs commit as many crimes as anyone else
-
The man who 'does' the polygraph tests for a daytime television show "Trisha" offers the Drs McCann a polygraph test?? and there are those who think that is OK.
Oh well it takes all kinds I suppose.
He also did the test on Adrian Prout, which led to a confession. Not bad going. What's wrong with Trisha anyway, she's just the Oprah of the UK, isn't she?
-
He also did the test on Adrian Prout, which led to a confession. Not bad going. What's wrong with Trisha anyway, she's just the Oprah of the UK, isn't she?
OMG did he?
But obviously he is not good enough for the mccanns
LOL good one
-
OMG did he?
But obviously he is not good enough for the mccanns
LOL good one
Prout's girlfriend arranged it in a bid to prove his innocence (she believed in him). It had the opposite result however. Prout then confessed and Eddie was proved correct.
The McCanns lost two chances to 'demonstrate their innocence' then. The reconstruction and the lie detector test.
-
Prout's girlfriend arranged it in a bid to prove his innocence (she believed in him). It had the opposite result however. Prout then confessed and Eddie was proved correct.
The McCanns lost two chances to 'demonstrate their innocence' then. The reconstruction and the lie detector test.
OMG never knew all that! Thanks!
-
The man who 'does' the polygraph tests for a daytime television show "Trisha" offers the Drs McCann a polygraph test?? and there are those who think that is OK.
Oh well it takes all kinds I suppose.
I can just imagine the response from some sceptics if the McCanns failed a lie detector test. Lie detectors would be hailed as the best invention since 'the wheel', and the result would be claimed as 100% proof of their guilt - and that lie detectors are infallible.
On the other hand :
If they passed the test sceptics would claim it proved zilch - as it is a well known fact that lie detectors are not infallible and that some people can 'cheat' it. And of course there would be those who would immediately claim it was a fix.
AIMHO.
-
I can just imagine the response from some sceptics if the McCanns failed a lie detector test. Lie detectors would be hailed as the best invention since 'the wheel', and the result would be claimed as 100% proof of their guilt - and that lie detectors are infallible.
On the other hand :
If they passed the test sceptics would claim it proved zilch - as it is a well known fact that lie detectors are not infallible and that some people can 'cheat' it. And of course there would be those who would immediately claim it was a fix.
AIMHO.
Bang on the nail.
-
I can just imagine the response from some sceptics if the McCanns failed a lie detector test. Lie detectors would be hailed as the best invention since 'the wheel', and the result would be claimed as 100% proof of their guilt - and that lie detectors are infallible.
On the other hand :
If they passed the test sceptics would claim it proved zilch - as it is a well known fact that lie detectors are not infallible and that some people can 'cheat' it. And of course there would be those who would immediately claim it was a fix.
AIMHO.
If you don't answer police questions there's no way you would do a lie detector. If SY came back to them and said one suspect refused to answer questions about your missing daughter I wonder what Kate's response would be 8(0(*
-
Anyone here who says that, in identical circumstances to the McCanns, they would have answered those questions is lying, pure and simple.
-
If you don't answer police questions there's no way you would do a lie detector. If SY came back to them and said one suspect refused to answer questions about your missing daughter I wonder what Kate's response would be 8(0(*
There is no connection between the two IMO.
Kate did not refuse to answer questions because she didn't know the answers - she followed the advice of her lawyer. Not much point in having a lawyer in a foreign country where you don't understand the law and he does - and then ignoring his advice. Especially when you both know the Policemen questioning you are attempting to pin a crime on you that you didn't commit.
What is so difficult to understand about that?
-
Lie detector tests are used in court in the US. They are used for confirmation when investigators suspect someone of lying. Anyone with enough life experience can spot a liar, the difficulty lies in proving it. Pointers exist; shifting in your seat, changing the subject when asked a question, touching your head, not using eye contact, changing tenses when answering questions, using unnecessary words for emphasis and 'distancing' from the subject (saying 'you' instead of 'I', for example).
-
There is no connection between the two IMO.
Kate did not refuse to answer questions because she didn't know the answers - she followed the advice of her lawyer. Not much point in having a lawyer in a foreign country where you don't understand the law and he does - and then ignoring his advice. Especially when you both know the Policemen questioning you are attempting to pin a crime on you that you didn't commit.
What is so difficult to understand about that?
Robert Murat refused his lawyer's advice and answered all questions. He was cleared.
-
Lie detector tests are used in court in the US. They are used for confirmation when investigators suspect someone of lying. Anyone with enough life experience can spot a liar, the difficulty lies in proving it. Pointers exist; shifting in your seat, changing the subject when asked a question, touching your head, not using eye contact, changing tenses when answering questions, using unnecessary words for emphasis and 'distancing' from the subject (saying 'you' instead of 'I', for example).
lie detectors confirm nothing....the McCanns do not have to demonstrate their innocence....they have not been arrested or charged...SY consider them not suspects....because there is no evidence to charge them you are trying to build acase based on innuendo and junk science,,,signs of desperation
-
you have lost your argument by a mile
Oh dear.
@)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*
P.S. You do realize by know it was nothing to do with Trisha ?
Mccann backers like you can argue all they like, but the fundamental truth remains, they could have done a lie detector and they didn't.
Just like the reconstruction.
-
Robert Murat refused his lawyer's advice and answered all questions. He was cleared.
So did Gerry McCann.
He was cleared.
Kate didn't.
And was cleared.
-
Bang on the nail.
and of course, if the mccanns had both done the test and failed, guess what, it could show they had been lying.
8)-)))
-
Oh dear.
@)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*
P.S. You do realize by know it was nothing to do with Trisha ?
Mccann backers like you can argue all they like, but the fundamental truth remains, they could have done a lie detector and they didn't.
Just like the reconstruction.
This was your post...
They volunteered to do so.
Then they changed their minds.
It is untrue...another lie told about the mccanns
-
Lie detector tests are used in court in the US. They are used for confirmation when investigators suspect someone of lying. Anyone with enough life experience can spot a liar, the difficulty lies in proving it. Pointers exist; shifting in your seat, changing the subject when asked a question, touching your head, not using eye contact, changing tenses when answering questions, using unnecessary words for emphasis and 'distancing' from the subject (saying 'you' instead of 'I', for example).
And gulping. Look for it.
The liar has difficulty swallowing. You can hear it in his speech, or see it on his throat.
He is displaying a forced smile pasted on his face.
He is touching different parts of his face (nose, mouth, eyes, ears)
The liar answers a question by depersonalizing it. If you ask: “Did you cheat on this test?” she might answer: “No, I think cheating is the worst thing you can do.”
-
lie detectors confirm nothing....the McCanns do not have to demonstrate their innocence....they have not been arrested or charged...SY consider them not suspects....because there is no evidence to charge them you are trying to build acase based on innuendo and junk science,,,signs of desperation
Polygraphs, like dog alerts, are just another tool. In the Prout case failing the test led to his confession and the confirmation of Eddie's alert. Great result for his wife's relatives who were able to get closure.
-
And gulping. Look for it.
The liar has difficulty swallowing. You can hear it in his speech, or see it on his throat.
He is displaying a forced smile pasted on his face.
He is touching different parts of his face (nose, mouth, eyes, ears)
The liar answers a question by depersonalizing it. If you ask: “Did you cheat on this test?” she might answer: “No, I think cheating is the worst thing you can do.”
Liars spout guff on internet message-boards.
-
This was your post...
They volunteered to do so.
Then they changed their minds.
It is untrue...another lie told about the mccanns
Have you read through the posts and in connection with the discussions that took place with the lie detector practitioner
-
Lie detector tests are used in court in the US. They are used for confirmation when investigators suspect someone of lying. Anyone with enough life experience can spot a liar, the difficulty lies in proving it. Pointers exist; shifting in your seat, changing the subject when asked a question, touching your head, not using eye contact, changing tenses when answering questions, using unnecessary words for emphasis and 'distancing' from the subject (saying 'you' instead of 'I', for example).
If it was so easy to spot a liar - there would be no such thing as a '[moderated].'
-
Lie detector tests are used in court in the US. They are used for confirmation when investigators suspect someone of lying. Anyone with enough life experience can spot a liar, the difficulty lies in proving it. Pointers exist; shifting in your seat, changing the subject when asked a question, touching your head, not using eye contact, changing tenses when answering questions, using unnecessary words for emphasis and 'distancing' from the subject (saying 'you' instead of 'I', for example).
the use of lie detectors in US courts is severely limited
-
Liars spout guff on internet message-boards.
And you want to read how they train scent dogs as puppies. They put the scent on their toys! A scent dog is looking for his toy not a body. CC is a toy so a second test was performed and the TOY was hidden.
-
Why are posters only interested in lie detectors re the McCann case....there are thousands of crimes every day in the UK...why are they not used...because they are unreliable
-
Why are posters only interested in lie detectors re the McCann case....there are thousands of crimes every day in the UK...why are they not used...because they are unreliable
Unreliable ???
i.e. Only because it could have exposed the mccanns for what they are. 8**8:/:
-
Unreliable ???
i.e. Only because it could have exposed the mccanns for what they are. 8**8:/:
unreliable ..yes
-
unreliable ..yes
and as you are fond of reminding people, how valuable is your opinion ?
-
it isn't my opinion..it's a scientific fact
-
it isn't my opinion..it's a scientific fact
Cite.
Now if lie detector tests are unreliable, why are they used around the world ?
Echoes of the use of dogs here. 8)--))
-
Cite.
Now if lie detector tests are unreliable, why are they used around the world ?
Echoes of the use of dogs here. 8)--))
if you think lie detectors are reliable you are seriously deluded..
-
Cite.
Now if lie detector tests are unreliable, why are they used around the world ?
Echoes of the use of dogs here. 8)--))
Please provide the scientific proof that polygraph tests are 100% accurate.
-
The county prosecutors offered Buzz a deal: they would drop all charges if he agreed to take a polygraph – a lie detector test – to prove his innocence. Convinced the whole episode was one big mistake, Buzz readily agreed. He took two tests but both suggested he was lying about his innocence. This, along with circumstantial evidence, sealed his 1979 conviction and he spent two-and-a-half years in prison for a murder he didn't commit.
During his time in prison, Buzz studied the polygraph. He sent his results to a number of experts but received wildly different interpretations. Determined to show the test was fallible, he developed a training exercise to help people fool the lie detector and after just 15 minutes of instruction, 23 out of 27 inmates beat the polygraph. Buzz was eventually exonerated, helped by the testimony of the real killer's mother, and his case has become one of the most notorious episodes in the history of the technology.
-
if you think lie detectors are reliable you are seriously deluded..
I asked you for a cite. 8((()*/
-
Please provide the scientific proof that polygraph tests are 100% accurate.
Who said they were. ?{)(**
-
I asked you for a cite. 8((()*/
it's like asking me for a cite that father Christmas isn't real.......
-
it's like asking me for a cite that father Christmas isn't real.......
Dear oh dear.
So why are they used around the world?
-
Who said they were. ?{)(**
You said this:
''Now if lie detector tests are unreliable, why are they used around the world ?''
In view of your reply I take it you have no scientific evidence to prove that polygraph tests are not unreliable.
However, that's not surprising - as there isn't any.
-
You said this:
''Now if lie detector tests are unreliable, why are they used around the world ?''
In view of your reply I take it you have no scientific evidence to prove that polygraph tests are not unreliable.
However, that's not surprising - as there isn't any.
You really must try and comprehend.
I have never said they were 100%
Why do you fear them so much, in connection with the mccanns ?
Now that is a very pertienent question.
-
and of course, if the mccanns had both done the test and failed, guess what, it could show they had been lying.
8)-)))
Stephen have you ever watched any 'True Crime' programmes which reveal true crimes committed in America and how they go about catching the people responsible?
If you do, you would know that many times a person they have as a suspect has failed the test, yet have been proven to be innocent.
One man in particular was smiling when asked if he had killed someone [they thought, this guy is the one] turned out he failed the test, they thought they had their man, but he wasn't he was innocent.
-
If it was so easy to spot a liar - there would be no such thing as a '[moderated].'
Some people believe everything they're told and can't spot liars. Others can. [moderated]s pick their victims for a reason. I watched a programme where several silly older women were complaining because they'd been tricked out of money by young foreign men. They had convinced themselves that a young attractive man had fallen in love with them. People who get tricked usually have a weakness such as loneliness or greed. Con men home in on these weaknesses.
-
I've found nothing which states categorically that polygraph tests are infallible and in my opinion the demand for the Drs McCann to take one is merely another entertainment exercise for those with little else in their lives, to damn them if they do and to damn them if they don't.
Predictable and tiresome
AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION
The Truth About Lie Detectors (aka Polygraph Tests)
Most psychologists agree that there is little evidence that polygraph tests can accurately detect lies.
**snip
The accuracy (i.e., validity) of polygraph testing has long been controversial.
An underlying problem is theoretical: There is no evidence that any pattern of physiological reactions is unique to deception.
An honest person may be nervous when answering truthfully and a dishonest person may be non-anxious.
Also, there are few good studies that validate the ability of polygraph procedures to detect deception.
As Dr. Saxe and Israeli psychologist Gershon Ben-Shahar (1999) note, "it may, in fact, be impossible to conduct a proper validity study." In real-world situations, it's very difficult to know what the truth is.
A particular problem is that polygraph research has not separated placebo-like effects (the subject's belief in the efficacy of the procedure) from the actual relationship between deception and their physiological responses.
One reason that polygraph tests may appear to be accurate is that subjects who believe that the test works and that they can be detected may confess or will be very anxious when questioned.
If this view is correct, the lie detector might be better called a fear detector.
Some confusion about polygraph test accuracy arises because they are used for different purposes, and for each context somewhat different theory and research is applicable.
Thus, for example, virtually no research assesses the type of test and procedure used to screen individuals for jobs and security clearances.
Most research has focused on specific incident testing. The cumulative research evidence suggests that CQTs detect deception better than chance, but with significant error rates, both of misclassifying innocent subjects (false positives) and failing to detect guilty individuals (false negatives).
http://www.apa.org/research/action/polygraph.aspx
-
You really must try and comprehend.
I have never said they were 100%
Why do you fear them so much, in connection with the mccanns ?
Now that is a very pertienent question.
So do you agree that if they are not 100% reliable then it can never be claimed that 100% of the test results are accurate? In that case how could a test have ''exposed the McCanns for what they are'' - which is what you also claim? You can't have it both ways.
-
Stephen have you ever watched any 'True Crime' programmes which reveal true crimes committed in America and how they go about catching the people responsible?
If you do, you would know that many times a person they have as a suspect has failed the test, yet have been proven to be innocent.
One man in particular was smiling when asked if he had killed someone [they thought, this guy is the one] turned out he failed the test, they thought they had their man, but he wasn't he was innocent.
No system is perfect.
How about giving examples of cases where it has proved more than useful.
-
I've found nothing which states categorically that polygraph tests are infallible and in my opinion the demand for the Drs McCann to take one is merely another entertainment exercise for those with little else in their lives, to damn them if they do and to damn them if they don't.
Predictable and tiresome
AMERICAN PSYCHOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION
The Truth About Lie Detectors (aka Polygraph Tests)
Most psychologists agree that there is little evidence that polygraph tests can accurately detect lies.
**snip
The accuracy (i.e., validity) of polygraph testing has long been controversial.
An underlying problem is theoretical: There is no evidence that any pattern of physiological reactions is unique to deception.
An honest person may be nervous when answering truthfully and a dishonest person may be non-anxious.
Also, there are few good studies that validate the ability of polygraph procedures to detect deception.
As Dr. Saxe and Israeli psychologist Gershon Ben-Shahar (1999) note, "it may, in fact, be impossible to conduct a proper validity study." In real-world situations, it's very difficult to know what the truth is.
A particular problem is that polygraph research has not separated placebo-like effects (the subject's belief in the efficacy of the procedure) from the actual relationship between deception and their physiological responses.
One reason that polygraph tests may appear to be accurate is that subjects who believe that the test works and that they can be detected may confess or will be very anxious when questioned.
If this view is correct, the lie detector might be better called a fear detector.
Some confusion about polygraph test accuracy arises because they are used for different purposes, and for each context somewhat different theory and research is applicable.
Thus, for example, virtually no research assesses the type of test and procedure used to screen individuals for jobs and security clearances.
Most research has focused on specific incident testing. The cumulative research evidence suggests that CQTs detect deception better than chance, but with significant error rates, both of misclassifying innocent subjects (false positives) and failing to detect guilty individuals (false negatives).
http://www.apa.org/research/action/polygraph.aspx
If the system is no good, then why are polygraphs used around the world ?
-
No system is perfect.
How about giving examples of cases where it has proved more than useful.
Dear me - I'm not sure the innocent person who failed the test would have been too thrilled if that was the explanation given to him.
''Oops sorry we thought you were a murderer - but no system is perfect - OK?''
-
No system is perfect.
How about giving examples of cases where it has proved more than useful.
that is called anectdotal evidence and has no value
-
Polygraphs are like so many other things in life, including dogs.
Some folk swear by 'em others swear at 'em depending upon the point one is attempting to make.
Are the arguments on either side scientific or pseudo-scientific?
Tune in next week.
-
Dear me - I'm not sure the innocent person who failed the test would have been too thrilled if that was the explanation given to him.
''Oops sorry we thought you were a murderer - but no system is perfect - OK?''
You do realize of course that will be used normally as part of an investigation, and not the only singular element of one ?
-
If the system is no good, then why are polygraphs used around the world ?
spiritualist mediums are used all round the world.....
again...if you think polygraphs are reliable it is a good indication of your poor understanding of what is...and is not ....proper evidence. So in both the UK and Portugal Kate's testimony would be accepted in court as evidence...a polygraph would not...does that tell you anything
-
that is called anectdotal evidence and has no value
Read my previous answer.
-
spiritualist mediums are used all round the world.....
again...if you think polygraphs are reliable it is a good indication of your poor understanding of what is...and is not ....proper evidence. So in both the UK and Portugal Kate's testimony would be accepted in court as evidence...a polygraph would not...does that tell you anything
What scientific basis do spiritualists have ?
With the polygraph, there is a difference.
-
Polygraphs are like so many other things in life, including dogs.
Some folk swear by 'em others swear at 'em depending upon the point one is attempting to make.
Are the arguments on either side scientific or pseudo-scientific?
Tune in next week.
but it's not our opinions that count..it's the court's.....which accept neither...that is a fact...which 100% supports my argument
-
What scientific basis do spiritualists have ?
With the polygraph, there is a difference.
polygraphs claim scientific basis...they are still unreliable
-
What scientific basis do spiritualists have ?
With the polygraph, there is a difference.
I'm sure you will find cases ..around the world....of police forces using psychics
-
but it's not our opinions that count..it's the court's.....which accept neither...that is a fact...which 100% supports my argument
Some states in America do accept their use dave, as long as both sides agree to their ususer ?
and are subject to the discretion of thge trial judge in the Federal Court.
-
I'm sure you will find cases ..around the world....of police forces using psychics
I am already aware of that.
Have you asked SY if they are ?
-
Some states in America do accept their use dave, as long as both sides agree to their ususer ?
and are subject to the discretion of thge trial judge in the Federal Court.
so now it's some states...not all..at the discretion of the judge and if both sides agree...because they are unreliable
-
so now it's some states...not all..at the discretion of the judge and if both sides agree...because they are unreliable
So why do some use them ?
I never said everyone, I.e. court or police investigation used them.
I said they are used around the world.
and that is true.
-
Common sense and seeing the bigger picture take flight if there is the slightest chance of being able to excoriate Madeleine McCann's parents.
Why is no-one getting agitated that people who have been designated arguidos (remembering that the change in Portuguese law demands there must be evidence to allow this) have not been given the 'opportunity' to take a polygraph test.
Just another example of futile McCann bashing and the fact it keeps on being resurrected on fora is a measure of the desperation that a misguided eight year vilification campaign has been stripped bare and is being shown in its true light.
-
So why do some use them ?
I never said everyone, I.e. court or police investigation used them.
I said they are used around the world.
and that is true.
They are used around the world..as are psychics...those using them understand their limitations...you don't seem to
-
Common sense and seeing the bigger picture take flight if there is the slightest chance of being able to excoriate Madeleine McCann's parents.
Why is no-one getting agitated that people who have been designated arguidos (remembering that the change in Portuguese law demands there must be evidence to allow this) have not been given the 'opportunity' to take a polygraph test.
Just another example of futile McCann bashing and the fact it keeps on being resurrected on fora is a measure of the desperation that a misguided eight year vilification campaign has been stripped bare and is being shown in its true light.
and that post is the standard riposte of the dedicated mccann supporter.
That is the essential truth behind your posting.
The viability to accept that what has happened is solely the fault of the mccanns, unless proven otherwise.
'misguided' ?
By whose margins.
Yours ?
-
They are used around the world..as are psychics...those using them understand their limitations...you don't seem to
Wow, that's amazing.
P.S. I do.
-
and that post is the standard riposte of the dedicated mccann supporter.
That is the essential truth behind your posting.
The viability to accept that what has happened is solely the fault of the mccanns, unless proven otherwise.
'misguided' ?
By whose margins.
Yours ?
Polygraphs are inaccurate ... they are not admissible in either Portuguese or British courts ... therefore reference to their use as far as these jurisdictions are concerned is nothing more than diversion for the great unwashed when boredom with their other fantasies kicks in.
-
Polygraphs are inaccurate ... they are not admissible in either Portuguese or British courts ... therefore reference to their use as far as these jurisdictions are concerned is nothing more than diversion for the great unwashed when boredom with their other fantasies kicks in.
So you are saying polygraphs never work.
Yes or No ?
-
So you are saying polygraphs never work.
Yes or No ?
I can change traffic light from red to green...purely with the power of my mind...it works every time...though sometimes it takes longer than others
-
So you are saying polygraphs never work.
Yes or No ?
Sometimes they work, sometimes they don't.
So useful as entertainment and as a device for crime writers. But f**k all use as an investigative tool.
It is not without reason that they are not admissible in European courts, and only admissible in some states in the US with the agreement of ALL parties.
The McCanns appear to have offered to take a test if requested by the Portuguese authorities.
-
Sometimes they work, sometimes they don't.
So useful as entertainment and as a device for crime writers. But f**k all use as an investigative tool.
It is not without reason that they are not admissible in European courts, and only admissible in some states in the US with the agreement of ALL parties.
The McCanns appear to have offered to take a test if requested by the Portuguese authorities.
They have to be used JP in conjunction with the investigative procedure.
Not in isolationm.
-
I can change traffic light from red to green...purely with the power of my mind...it works every time...though sometimes it takes longer than others
There is no end to your talents.. ?>)()<
-
What Stephen has proved ..beyond all doubt ..is how much he understands what is...and isn't...reliable evidence
-
What Stephen has proved ..beyond all doubt ..is how much he understands what is...and isn't...reliable evidence
Hardly old fruit.
You merely demonstrate by that comment you back the mccanns to the exclusion of all logic.
-
They have to be used JP in conjunction with the investigative procedure.
Not in isolationm.
Where did I suggest use in isolation? The fact remains that there is no objective proof of effectiveness, and they remain inadmissible in European courts.
What the McCanns spokesman said was not unreasonable -that they would be prepared to take a polygraph test if it was requested by the Portuguese authorities. No such request has been made. End of story.
This thread seems to be more about Tricias polygraph man throwing a hissy fit that the McCanns would not accede to his demands.
-
They're admissible as court evidence in the US though? Courts in the US seem to have a far more brutal deliverance of justice imo! Far more lengthy prison sentences, 3 hits and you are out, death penalty etc...
I don't blame the McCann's in this instance. Their spokesman clearly says a polygraph asked for by the PJ. This guy administers polygraphs on Trisha(maybe he's good, but maybe he's another opportunist who crawled out the woodwork) and anyone would want to be reassured as to their reliability. Whole topic looks like a press created drama imo.
-
They're admissible as court evidence in the US though? Courts in the US seem to have a far more brutal deliverance of justice imo! Far more lengthy prison sentences, 3 hits and you are out, death penalty etc...
I don't blame the McCann's in this instance. Their spokesman clearly says a polygraph asked for by the PJ. This guy administers polygraphs on Trisha(maybe he's good, but maybe he's another opportunist who crawled out the woodwork) and anyone would want to be reassured as to their reliability. Whole topic looks like a press created drama imo.
In those states where they are admissible, it is only with the agreement of all parties that the results may be used in court.
-
Common sense and seeing the bigger picture take flight if there is the slightest chance of being able to excoriate Madeleine McCann's parents.
Why is no-one getting agitated that people who have been designated arguidos (remembering that the change in Portuguese law demands there must be evidence to allow this) have not been given the 'opportunity' to take a polygraph test.
Just another example of futile McCann bashing and the fact it keeps on being resurrected on fora is a measure of the desperation that a misguided eight year vilification campaign has been stripped bare and is being shown in its true light.
There is no common sense in this case. It started with an unlocked apartment, the twins not waking up, a neat and tidy bed and tampering with the crime scene before the police arrived. Then the next day the police couldn't find phone call history on their mobiles.
-
Where did I suggest use in isolation? The fact remains that there is no objective proof of effectiveness, and they remain inadmissible in European courts.
What the McCanns spokesman said was not unreasonable -that they would be prepared to take a polygraph test if it was requested by the Portuguese authorities. No such request has been made. End of story.
This thread seems to be more about Tricias polygraph man throwing a hissy fit that the McCanns would not accede to his demands.
It seems more the other way around. With the mccanns well known arrogance in trying to stipulate the parameters of any testing procedure.
-
They're admissible as court evidence in the US though? Courts in the US seem to have a far more brutal deliverance of justice imo! Far more lengthy prison sentences, 3 hits and you are out, death penalty etc...
I don't blame the McCann's in this instance. Their spokesman clearly says a polygraph asked for by the PJ. This guy administers polygraphs on Trisha(maybe he's good, but maybe he's another opportunist who crawled out the woodwork) and anyone would want to be reassured as to their reliability. Whole topic looks like a press created drama imo.
That's my impression as well. If it had been simply a gesture of assistance, it could have been done quietly.
-
It seems more the other way around. With the mccanns well known arrogance in trying to stipulate the parameters of any testing procedure.
That the test be requested by the Portuguese authorities? Sounds pretty reasonable to me.
You seem to be very easily seduced by Don Cargill talking up his own book.
-
It seems to me this story hit the papers because a) the McCanns authorised someone to tell the papers they would take a polygraph if the PJ wanted them to do it. b) The newspaper made the 'source' quote up to sell newspapers. Both are possible in my opinion.
Either way, the result was that someone offered to do a test, which the McCanns refused. I don't blame them for refusing whether they have anything to hide or not because the test isn't conclusive by any means.
The result was that regardless of how the story began, it ended by doing them harm. If they started the story it backfired. If they didn't they should have challenged the newspaper as to the source of the story and shown that it never originated with them.
-
That the test be requested by the Portuguese authorities? Sounds pretty reasonable to me.
You seem to be very easily seduced by Don Cargill talking up his own book.
You mean just like the mccanns did with their book, and the serialization in the sun, with the delightful accompanying headlines ?
-
Lie detector tests are not reliable. They can seem so after the fact, if the results match other evidence/confessions but not of themselves.
Many a criminal has passed with flyng colours, likewise, many innocent people have failed them or were found to be inconclusive. TBH I'm not sure why they are used at all, given that.
-
It seems to me this story hit the papers because a) the McCanns authorised someone to tell the papers they would take a polygraph if the PJ wanted them to do it. b) The newspaper made the 'source' quote up to sell newspapers. Both are possible in my opinion.
Either way, the result was that someone offered to do a test, which the McCanns refused. I don't blame them for refusing whether they have anything to hide or not because the test isn't conclusive by any means.
The result was that regardless of how the story began, it ended by doing them harm. If they started the story it backfired. If they didn't they should have challenged the newspaper as to the source of the story and shown that it never originated with them.
I very much doubt that's the way it happened
-
I very much doubt that's the way it happened
either 'the source' quoted was real or it wasn't, unless you have an alternative suggestion?
-
either 'the source' quoted was real or it wasn't, unless you have an alternative suggestion?
Depends on the context
-
Lie detector tests are not reliable. They can seem so after the fact, if the results match other evidence/confessions but not of themselves.
Many a criminal has passed with flyng colours, likewise, many innocent people have failed them or were found to be inconclusive. TBH I'm not sure why they are used at all, given that.
They are used because the majority of liars are scared of them and will fail.
-
but it's not our opinions that count..it's the court's.....which accept neither...that is a fact...which 100% supports my argument
I was merely passing comment.
I don't recall making any comment about polygraphs being acceptable in court so what was the point of your post?
I would be surprised indeed if any argument you put forward was not 100% supported by something or other.
-
I was merely passing comment.
I don't recall making any comment about polygraphs being acceptable in court so what was the point of your post?
I would be surprised indeed if any argument you put forward was not 100% supported by something or other.
The only accurate part of your post is" I don't recall"
-
Polygraphs are not acceptable in European Courts, so absolutely no point in doing them.
Do one, don't do one. All sensationalism. Fail it and you're screwed. Pass it and you are good liar. And these things should never be done under stress or duress, simply to please the masses.
-
Polygraphs are not acceptable in European Courts, so absolutely no point in doing them.
Do one, don't do one. All sensationalism. Fail it and you're screwed. Pass it and you are good liar. And these things should never be done under stress or duress, simply to please the masses.
At least Adrian Prout didn't take your advice or they wouldn't have found Kate's body. He would still be lying saying he's innocent.
-
They are used because the majority of liars are scared of them and will fail.
fair enough PF, as a polce tool I guess they can be useful
-
Polygraphs are not acceptable in European Courts, so absolutely no point in doing them.
Do one, don't do one. All sensationalism. Fail it and you're screwed. Pass it and you are good liar. And these things should never be done under stress or duress, simply to please the masses.
Its the police that use them, for their own reasons, not the "masses" so take it up with them
-
Its the police that use them, for their own reasons, not the "masses" so take it up with them
No one is forced to take a Polygraph. And I very much doubt that The Police ask suspects to do this.
-
No one is forced to take a Polygraph. And I very much doubt that The Police ask suspects to do this.
well, leaving aside your questionable comment that you doubt police ask suspects to take a polygraph, what is all the fuss about and who started it?
-
well, leaving aside your questionable comment that you doubt police ask suspects to take a polygraph, what is all the fuss about and who started it?
I have no idea. Perhaps you can help.
-
I have no idea. Perhaps you can help.
No, sorry, nowt to do with me.
-
well, leaving aside your questionable comment that you doubt police ask suspects to take a polygraph, what is all the fuss about and who started it?
The police may, on occasion, ask a suspect to take a test. But cannot force anyone to do so.
Refusal to take such a test cannot be produced in court by the prosecution, for obvious reasons.
-
The police may, on occasion, ask a suspect to take a test. But cannot force anyone to do so.
Refusal to take such a test cannot be produced in court by the prosecution, for obvious reasons.
I was responding to Elanors comment that she doubts the police ask people to undergo polygraph testing, which begs the question, if they dont, who does ? and why would they be performed by police at all in that case.....yes, we know that all circumstances around such tests are not court permissible as "evidence"....still, they and their "use" can be helpful to police outwith their usage and results iyswim
-
That's my impression as well. If it had been simply a gesture of assistance, it could have been done quietly.
Perhaps it was and the guy only went public when the McCann's gave him their impossible 'conditions'.
-
Thing is, even if all their "conditions" were met,never in a million years would I believe they would take such a test, when they couldn't even answer straight questions with straight answers in "friendly tv interviews"
-
In fact it is possible to test the efficacy of polygraphs, but the trouble is such experiments are rare – at least according to Richard Wiseman, professor of the public understanding of psychology at the University of Hertfordshire. Because you can’t simply ask a criminal whether he was lying or not, the only method would be to use polygraphs in cases where the true answer had already been established using other evidence. Then it would be possible to check the polygraph’s responses against reality in a high-stakes situation. “If the examiner was unaware of the true answers, then that would be a proper double-blind scientific study. But there have been very few trials like that,” says Prof Wiseman.
From what evidence there is, he adds that “the polygraph seems to be very good at catching liars. But it seems very likely to give false positives as well, to 'catch’ people who are telling the truth”.
Horder agrees, pointing to research which found that polygraphs were “70-97 per cent accurate for people who turned out to be guilty, but between 12-94 per cent accurate for people who turned out to be innocent
so between 12 and 94 % accurate when the suspect is innocent
-
The only accurate part of your post is" I don't recall"
If you say so 8(0(*
-
to all those who say the McCanns should have taken the lie detector....
if they had and were judged to be telling the truth ....would you then disregard the dogs, the jemmied shutters....the discrepancies in the statements...the smith sighting...
would you then regard them as innocent...honest answers please
-
At least Adrian Prout didn't take your advice or they wouldn't have found Kate's body. He would still be lying saying he's innocent.
Wasn't he already in prison when he offered to do a test?
-
Who would have decided on the questions to ask?
-
I just checked the date on that Evening Standard article
McCanns offer to take lie test
Published: 21 January 2007
http://www.standard.co.uk/newsheadlines/mccanns-offer-to-take-lie-test-6698135.html
Maybe we should have a 100-page thread about it...
-
I just checked the date on that Evening Standard article
McCanns offer to take lie test
Published: 21 January 2007
http://www.standard.co.uk/newsheadlines/mccanns-offer-to-take-lie-test-6698135.html
Maybe we should have a 100-page thread about it...
Don't anyone mention the word "Glitch."
-
to all those who say the McCanns should have taken the lie detector....
if they had and were judged to be telling the truth ....would you then disregard the dogs, the jemmied shutters....the discrepancies in the statements...the smith sighting...
would you then regard them as innocent...honest answers please
what a silly question lol
The premise is wrong so the rest is wrong by default, try again
-
what a silly question lol
The premise is wrong so the rest is wrong by default, try again
it is a question that the McCann critics will answer....if the test found the mccanns to be telling the truth...would they accept it ...the answer is obviously no...those who have called for the test would not accept the result if it exonerated the mccanns....so tell me...
why is the premise wrong...I know you will not have an answer
-
it is a question that the McCann critics will answer....if the test found the mccanns to be telling the truth...would they accept it ...the answer is obviously no...those who have called for the test would not accept the result if it exonerated the mccanns....so tell me...
why is the premise wrong...I know you will not have an answer
The only people I can find who raised the question of the McCann's taking a polygraph were a newspaper and an unnamed 'source'. Another interesting question is would the supporters have accepted the result if the McCann's had taken the test and failed it?
-
I just checked the date on that Evening Standard article
McCanns offer to take lie test
Published: 21 January 2007
http://www.standard.co.uk/newsheadlines/mccanns-offer-to-take-lie-test-6698135.html
Maybe we should have a 100-page thread about it...
Surely this proves the "abduction" was planned months in advance, yah?
-
it is a question that the McCann critics will answer....if the test found the mccanns to be telling the truth...would they accept it ...the answer is obviously no...those who have called for the test would not accept the result if it exonerated the mccanns....so tell me...
why is the premise wrong...I know you will not have an answer
You know I will not have an answer? Are you psychic?
Well Im answering you therefore you are wrong
Your wrong premise was "all those who demanded a lie detector test, no one did, it seems the story grew wngs by itself ie whch means from Mitchell
-
The only people I can find who raised the question of the McCann's taking a polygraph were a newspaper and an unnamed 'source'. Another interesting question is would the supporters have accepted the result if the McCann's had taken the test and failed it?
The error rate for false positives against an innocent person is quite high.....for that reason I would say the test would have proved nothing
-
it is a question that the McCann critics will answer....if the test found the mccanns to be telling the truth...would they accept it ...the answer is obviously no...those who have called for the test would not accept the result if it exonerated the mccanns....so tell me...
why is the premise wrong...I know you will not have an answer
Correct, none of those who champion the lie-detector would accept the results if a test if it told them something contrary to their own entrenched views.
-
The only people I can find who raised the question of the McCann's taking a polygraph were a newspaper and an unnamed 'source'. Another interesting question is would the supporters have accepted the result if the McCann's had taken the test and failed it?
No, because polygraph tests are not reliable and are biased against the innocent.
-
You know I will not have an answer? Are you psychic?
Well Im answering you therefore you are wrong
Your wrong premise was "all those who demanded a lie detector test, no one did, it seems the story grew wngs by itself ie whch means from Mitchell
If you are going to quote using quotation marks then you need to use the words actually posted
-
I was trying to find when this issue arose. The Evening Standard date wasn't particularly helpful, but this one may be more accurate:
Kate refuses lie test Sunday Express (no longer online)
Camilla Tominey
Sunday November 18,2007
They were therefore still arguidos, but they obviously wanted to fight back against all the tabloid media smears. However, in those circumstances, I'd find it highly unlikely that they'd have spontaneously offered to do a polygraph test.
What seems more likely to me is that a newspaper asked them if they'd be willing to do one, and found this chap to do it.
It was never going to be more than more sensationalist tabloid fodder that could have been twisted whatever the results.
It might appear to be a natural reaction for the innocent to want to declare that they'd be willing to do one to clear their names, but not when you've been hounded for months on end, with everyone twisting anything you do say, with no guarantees about reliability, nor even the questions that they would be allowed to answer...
And I think that they were right to be wary - the story was no longer that they had passed or failed the test, but that they refused to take one. The tabloids got their story anyway.
-
No, because polygraph tests are not reliable and are biased against the innocent.
Absolutely, the polygraph should be confined to TV shows, it has no place within the justice system and is certainly not the device it is claimed to be. I challenge any polygraph operator to prove otherwise.
Back in 2007 I don't think the McCanns quite realised the can of worms they could be opening by agreeing to such a test.
-
Absolutely, the polygraph should be confined to TV shows, it has no place within the justice system and is certainly not the device it is claimed to be. I challenge any polygraph operator to prove otherwise.
Back in 2007 I don't think the McCanns quite realised the can of worms they could be opening by agreeing to such a test.
did they agree? and who asked them go do one???
-
did they agree? and who asked them go do one???
Several press organisations reported them as agreeing to do so should the PJ request it.
-
Several press organisations reported them as agreeing to do so should the PJ request it.
But theres no evidence a) they were asked or ever would have been or b) accepted so yes,..,press organisations John
-
If the McCanns had taken a polygraph test and it showed they were not lying would .......................?
They didn't take one so all else is speculative opinion, perm any one from about a dozen *&*%£
-
If the McCanns had taken a polygraph test and it showed they were not lying would .......................?
They didn't take one so all else is speculative opinion, perm any one from about a dozen *&*%£
Rubbish. It is a fact that had the McCanns taken and passed a polygraph test, those who are convinced they hid their child's body would remain convinced that they were right. No one is honest enough to admit it however.
-
Rubbish. It is a fact that had the McCanns taken and passed a polygraph test, those who are convinced they hid their child's body would remain convinced that they were right. No one is honest enough to admit it however.
Precisely, had the mccanns taken the test and been exonerate all those championing the test here would then be telling us how unreliable they are...
-
In fact it is possible to test the efficacy of polygraphs, but the trouble is such experiments are rare – at least according to Richard Wiseman, professor of the public understanding of psychology at the University of Hertfordshire. Because you can’t simply ask a criminal whether he was lying or not, the only method would be to use polygraphs in cases where the true answer had already been established using other evidence. Then it would be possible to check the polygraph’s responses against reality in a high-stakes situation. “If the examiner was unaware of the true answers, then that would be a proper double-blind scientific study. But there have been very few trials like that,” says Prof Wiseman.
From what evidence there is, he adds that “the polygraph seems to be very good at catching liars. But it seems very likely to give false positives as well, to 'catch’ people who are telling the truth”.
Horder agrees, pointing to research which found that polygraphs were “70-97 per cent accurate for people who turned out to be guilty, but between 12-94 per cent accurate for people who turned out to be innocent
so between 12 and 94 % accurate when the suspect is innocent
Interesting, thanks.
I can see a use by police as intelligence, but not as evidence. A bit like dogs barking.
-
The error rate for false positives against an innocent person is quite high.....for that reason I would say the test would have proved nothing
Me too lol.
-
Me too lol.
We actually agree on something... That's quite interesting
-
Interesting, thanks.
I can see a use by police as intelligence, but not as evidence. A bit like dogs barking.
not quite the same there carana, as dogs are more reliable than polygraphs and proven to be so and not by "chance"
-
The only reason the US authorities use the polygraph is to scare suspects into admitting things they might not otherwise do.
-
The only reason the US authorities use the polygraph is to scare suspects into admitting things they might not otherwise do.
And in some cases, they've announced to the media that they'd failed, haven't they?
-
not quite the same there carana, as dogs are more reliable than polygraphs and proven to be so and not by "chance"
Not necessarily, IMO. Both could be used as bluff to get someone to confess.
In either situation, there could be innocent reasons for reactions. The point, I would have thought, would be to probe further and find actual evidence.
-
Not necessarily, IMO. Both could be used as bluff to get someone to confess.
In either situation, there could be innocent reasons for reactions. The point, I would have thought, would be to probe further and find actual evidence.
Oh purleease, you think police use dog alerts as bluffs? That is just not possible unless police dont believe the dog alerts mean anything
And well yes, probe further is the key isnt it ie which means both tests and dogs mean something, no?
-
Wasn't he already in prison when he offered to do a test?
Yes and he was still claiming his innocence (everyone in the village loved Adrian!) and wanted to do the test to prove it but he failed. That lie detector found Kate's body.
-
Yes and he was still claiming his innocence (everyone in the village loved Adrian!) and wanted to do the test to prove it but he failed. That lie detector found Kate's body.
So he didn't have as much to lose as someone who has not been charged with any crime, in fact he had an opportunity of using the test to convince people of his "innocence" - anything's worth a try I suppose.
-
So he didn't have as much to lose as someone who has not been charged with any crime, in fact he had an opportunity of using the test to convince people of his "innocence" - anything's worth a try I suppose.
No he was convicted and jailed for life without the body. He was still claiming he was innocent in jail and after he failed the lie detector he confessed and showed where he had hidden the body.
Debbie Garlick who began dating Prout a year after he murdered Kate had launched a campaign to win his freedom.
-
Rubbish. It is a fact that had the McCanns taken and passed a polygraph test, those who are convinced they hid their child's body would remain convinced that they were right. No one is honest enough to admit it however.
If the McCanns had taken a polygraph no matter what the outcome it would certainly have made me reconsider if the played a part in Madeleine's disappearance.
Luke Mitchell took a polygraph to prove he played no part in his girlfriend Jodie Jones's murder. Several of Elizabeth Smart's male relatives did too. They knew the pitfalls of taking the test but did it anyway because it was the only way of moving their cases forward.
-
No he was convicted and jailed for life without the body. He was still claiming he was innocent in jail and after he failed the lie detector he confessed and showed where he had hidden the body.
Debbie Garlick who began dating Prout a year after he murdered Kate had launched a campaign to win his freedom.
You don't seem to have understood what I wrote. Never mind, I'm sure others do.
-
If the McCanns had taken a polygraph no matter what the outcome it would certainly have made me reconsider if the played a part in Madeleine's disappearance.
Luke Mitchell took a polygraph to prove he played no part in his girlfriend Jodie Jones's murder. Several of Elizabeth Smart's male relatives did too. They knew the pitfalls of taking the test but did it anyway because it was the only way of moving their cases forward.
@)(++(* So, if they'd failed the tests it would have made you reconsider their part in Madeleine's disappearance? Yeah right. And if they'd passed it you'd be assured that they were wholly innocent would you?
-
@)(++(* So, if they'd failed the tests it would have made you reconsider their part in Madeleine's disappearance? Yeah right. And if they'd passed it you'd be assured that they were wholly innocent would you?
That they'd agreed to take the test at all would have given me pause for thought yes.
-
That they'd agreed to take the test at all would have given me pause for thought yes.
Yes, you'd have paused for thought, and then carried on regardless.
-
Rubbish. It is a fact that had the McCanns taken and passed a polygraph test, those who are convinced they hid their child's body would remain convinced that they were right. No one is honest enough to admit it however.
I take it you are having a laugh? or have taken leave of your senses?
It gets better and better.
-
Yes, you'd have paused for thought, and then carried on regardless.
Who knows Alfie because they lacked the courage to do it.
-
You don't seem to have understood what I wrote. Never mind, I'm sure others do.
Sorry I was doing some work at the time. You're correct that he had nothing to lose but he was still lying. I think a lie detector can be a great tool if used in the right way but you can't get a conviction from it.
-
Sorry I was doing some work at the time. You're correct that he had nothing to lose but he was still lying. I think a lie detector can be a great tool if used in the right way but you can't get a conviction from it.
You can however refocus an investigation that you know is going in the wrong direction. A priority, you would think, if you believed your abducted daughter could still be found alive.
-
Considering that polygraph tests are inconclusive they would be nothing more nor less than a distraction from the police business of getting on with the job of finding evidence.
If they have investigated people and found no evidence worth pursuing it is puerile to suggest the result of a polygraph test will somehow spur them on to do what any professional should do ... and that is to keep looking for and investigating other avenues of investigation which may or may not provide evidence.
When one door closes another one opens.
The failure to find out what may have happened to Madeleine McCann can perhaps be put down to undue concentration on one theory which the final report prior to archiving her case blew out of the water.
It is amazing there are still people with all their eggs still in that particular basket.
I think the following answer to a forum question explains succinctly why it is inadvisable to submit to a polygraph test proving that the Drs McCann were perfectly correct not to do so.
M.S., Member, Connecticut Bar / FreeAdvice Contributing Attorney
Answered 6 years ago|
Contributor
You should not take a lie detector test, especially without an attorney present.
It works like this: The police need probable cause to arrest you for any crime.
Moreover, polygraph tests are not conclusive.
Therefore, if the police already have probable cause to arrest you prior to taking the polygraph test, they will do so regardless of your success or failure with respect to the test.
Thus, if the police have probable cause to arrest you and you pass the test, that will not negate probable cause -- the police may just interpret it as a false negative.
However, if the police do not have probable cause to arrest you but then you fail the test, the failed test result MAY give the police probable cause to arrest you.
What this means, in practical terms, is that taking a polygraph test will do very little to exonerate you, but can potentially be used to incriminate you, even with a false positive.
However, since these are serious accusations I suggest that you consult with and/or retain a skilled criminal defense attorney prior to making any further decisions (or having any more conversations with the police) with respect to this matter.
After discussing the specific facts of this matter with a criminal defense attorney, he or she will be able to more specifically advise you with respect to the best course of action in this particular instance.
Thus, in some limited situations a criminal defense attorney may, in fact suggest taking a polygraph test under certain circumstances.
Regardless, you should consult with and/or retain a criminal defense attorney at your earliest convenience.
Read more: http://ask-a-lawyer.freeadvice.com/law-questions/can-i-refuse-a-lie-detect-5285.htm#ixzz3gl41eAS2
-
Precisely, had the mccanns taken the test and been exonerate all those championing the test here would then be telling us how unreliable they are...
Bit like the dogs really....
-
Bit like the dogs really....
exactly like the dogs...neither admissable
-
I take it you are having a laugh? or have taken leave of your senses?
It gets better and better.
What precisely is your problem with what I have written?
-
Who knows Alfie because they lacked the courage to do it.
they had the intelligence not to do it...unlike those on the Jeremy Kyle show...which is where Lie Detectors belong
-
If the McCanns had taken a polygraph no matter what the outcome it would certainly have made me reconsider if the played a part in Madeleine's disappearance.
Luke Mitchell took a polygraph to prove he played no part in his girlfriend Jodie Jones's murder. Several of Elizabeth Smart's male relatives did too. They knew the pitfalls of taking the test but did it anyway because it was the only way of moving their cases forward.
Why only reconsider...so it would not convince you by your own admission and that's why the test would have been a waste of time
-
they had the intelligence not to do it...unlike those on the Jeremy Kyle show...which is where Lie Detectors belong
No dave, they feared it.
-
If taking a Polygraph is the only way of moving a case forward then I despair.
-
No dave, they feared it.
stating opinion as fact as usual....if you did any research you would find that lie detectors can be very inaccurate in giving false positives for innocent people....only an absolute idiot would have taken the unreliable...unproven test
-
No he was convicted and jailed for life without the body. He was still claiming he was innocent in jail and after he failed the lie detector he confessed and showed where he had hidden the body.
Debbie Garlick who began dating Prout a year after he murdered Kate had launched a campaign to win his freedom.
Prout had nothing to lose and everything to gain...he probably felt he could beat the test...it isn't difficult evidently
-
stating opinion as fact as usual....if you did any research you would find that lie detectors can be very inaccurate in giving false positives for innocent people....only an absolute idiot would have taken the unreliable...unproven test
Again, you don't read, as per usual.
They are used as part of an investigation, not the be all and end all.
Polygraphs can also reveal liars.
It is not a one way street.
-
Prout had nothing to lose and everything to gain...he probably felt he could beat the test...it isn't difficult evidently
He didn't manage it though, did he?
-
He didn't manage it though, did he?
no he didn't but it is evidently not difficult with the right training. That's why the result of a test would not prove anything ...It certainly would provide no evidence of the McCanns innocence
-
If taking a Polygraph is the only way of moving a case forward then I despair.
If you are getting nowhere with certain suspects because they refuse to answer questions then I believe a lie detector should be used in those circumstances. You have to be in control not them. They don't answer questions because they are scared. Now here's a lie detector test for you for being uncooperative %£&)**#
-
no he didn't but it is evidently not difficult with the right training. That's why the result of a test would not prove anything ...It certainly would provide no evidence of the McCanns innocence
I know nothing about polygraphs but I do know that lying is a complex matter. As I said on another thread, [moderated]s pick their victims with care and they target those who want to believe. Similarly the wife who wants to believe her husband is faithful will ignore evidence to the contrary until it becomes too much. Lying to large groups such as TV audiences is more difficult because the audience is unknown. Politicians are often trained to avoid direct lying for that reason. They learn how to give ambiguous answers and how to answer the question they want to answer rather than the one asked. A polygraph operator would ask direct questions and wouldn't accept diversion, so much more difficult to deal with imo. Innocent or guilty it's too much of a risk.
-
If you are getting nowhere with certain suspects because they refuse to answer questions then I believe a lie detector should be used in those circumstances. You have to be in control not them. They don't answer questions because they are scared. Now here's a lie detector test for you for being uncooperative %£&)**#
How do you force them to take it?
-
How do you force them to take it?
You cannot be forced to take a polygraph test. For obvious reasons.
-
What precisely is your problem with what I have written?
I have no "problem" with what you have written at all.
I find it funny in both senses of the word and cannot take it seriously.
-
You cannot be forced to take a polygraph test. For obvious reasons.
Thought not.
Thank you, Jean Pierre.
-
Thought not.
Thank you, Jean Pierre.
I'm surprised you had to have that verified Eleanor.
In this instance we are not talking about forcing the McCanns to take a polygraph but them willingly taking one in order to refocus the investigation.
-
I'm surprised you had to have that verified Eleanor.
In this instance we are not talking about forcing the McCanns to take a polygraph but them willingly taking one in order to refocus the investigation.
It wouldn't refocus the investigation. The McCanns are innocent and Scotland Yard knows this.
-
It wouldn't refocus the investigation. The McCanns are innocent and Scotland Yard knows this.
I have seen no statement by Scotland Yard saying that the McCanns are innocent?
-
I have seen no statement by Scotland Yard saying that the McCanns are innocent?
we have seen a statement saying they are not suspects
-
I know nothing about polygraphs but I do know that lying is a complex matter. As I said on another thread, [moderated]s pick their victims with care and they target those who want to believe. Similarly the wife who wants to believe her husband is faithful will ignore evidence to the contrary until it becomes too much. Lying to large groups such as TV audiences is more difficult because the audience is unknown. Politicians are often trained to avoid direct lying for that reason. They learn how to give ambiguous answers and how to answer the question they want to answer rather than the one asked. A polygraph operator would ask direct questions and wouldn't accept diversion, so much more difficult to deal with imo. Innocent or guilty it's too much of a risk.
I've done some research...there isn't a lot to know about polygraphs...this article is interesting....
The county prosecutors offered Buzz a deal: they would drop all charges if he agreed to take a polygraph – a lie detector test – to prove his innocence. Convinced the whole episode was one big mistake, Buzz readily agreed. He took two tests but both suggested he was lying about his innocence. This, along with circumstantial evidence, sealed his 1979 conviction and he spent two-and-a-half years in prison for a murder he didn't commit.
During his time in prison, Buzz studied the polygraph. He sent his results to a number of experts but received wildly different interpretations. Determined to show the test was fallible, he developed a training exercise to help people fool the lie detector and after just 15 minutes of instruction, 23 out of 27 inmates beat the polygraph. Buzz was eventually exonerated, helped by the testimony of the real killer's mother, and his case has become one of the most notorious episodes in the history of the technology.
so 23 out of 27 beat the polygraph...that's unreliable in anyone's book
-
It wouldn't refocus the investigation. The McCanns are innocent and Scotland Yard knows this.
We are not talking about now Eleanor but then when the McCanns were firmly in the spotlight and there was rather more chance of their daughter being alive.
-
We are not talking about now Eleanor but then when the McCanns were firmly in the spotlight.
Fair enough Faith.
But to my mind there are no circumstances where taking a polygraph could help. The police are perfectly aware of the shortcomings of the technique, and it is only ever used as a device to put pressure on uninformed suspects.
-
We are not talking about now Eleanor but then when the McCanns were firmly in the spotlight and there was rather more chance of their daughter being alive.
There is no logic to this. If The McCanns were responsible for the disappearance of Madeleine then they would probably have failed the test. In which case how would it have helped them?
Or are you saying that The McCanns were obligated to prove their innocence by taking a test that is less than reliable?
-
Fair enough Faith.
But to my mind there are no circumstances where taking a polygraph could help. The police are perfectly aware of the shortcomings of the technique, and it is only ever used as a device to put pressure on uninformed suspects.
That's right Jean-Pierre, and that is what happened in Adrian Prouts case. The only reason Adrian admitted to the murder of his wife and thereafter led police to where he buried her was because he failed the polygraph. He could have just as easily passed the polygraph had he not been so nervous on the day.
-
There is no logic to this. If The McCanns were responsible for the disappearance of Madeleine then they would probably have failed the test. In which case how would it have helped them?
Or are you saying that The McCanns were obligated to prove their innocence by taking a test that is less than reliable?
I'm not saying the McCanns were obligated to do anything . What I am saying is that if the McCanns were truly innocent taking a polygraph may have helped to rule them out of any part in Madeleine's disappearance and refocus the investigation on the real protagonists. At the very least it may have solidied their innocence in the public's mind and neutralised the damage to the search they claim was caused by Amaral's book.
Of course there was a slight risk that the polygraph would be wrong but if I was the parent of a missing child and I knew she may be out there somewhere waiting to be found it's certainly a chance I'd be willing to take.
-
I'm not saying the McCanns were obligated to do anything . What I am saying is that if the McCanns were truly innocent taking a polygraph may have helped to rule them out of any part in Madeleine's disappearance and refocus the investigation on the real protagonists. At the very least it may have solidied their innocence in the public's mind and neutralised the damage to the search they claim was caused by Amaral's book.
Of course there was a slight risk that the polygraph was wrong but if I was the parent of a missing child and I knew she may be out there somewhere waiting to be found it's certainly a chance I'd e willing to take.
Sorry, I can't go along with the need to take a polygraph before The Police do their job properly, or to stop a bunch of s..m bags on The Internet telling outrageous lies.
And it would likely have been another chapter in Amaral's Book. "How to Beat a Polygraph." He is bound to know how that can be done.
-
That's right Jean-Pierre, and that is what happened in Adrian Prouts case. The only reason Adrian admitted to the murder of his wife and thereafter led police to where he buried her was because he failed the polygraph. He could have just as easily passed the polygraph had he not been so nervous on the day.
That's the chance you take if you can get somebody to confess. It's a tactic as suspects reveal more on a lie detector than a normal interview.
Police trial lie detector tests on suspected sex offenders
Hertfordshire force hails success of polygraphs in assessing risk to children of 25 'low-level' sexual offenders
Suspected sex offenders have been targeted with lie detector tests in a police trial to gauge the risk they pose to the public.
Hertfordshire police has been using polygraphs, which monitor heart rate, brain activity, sweating and blood pressure, during questioning to help decide whether to charge suspects.
The force confirmed it had completed a successful pilot scheme in November in which 25 "low level" sex offenders were tested. Many were found to pose a higher risk to children than previously estimated. A further 12-month trial is expected to start in April.
Of the 10 offenders tested in April, six revealed more serious offending. Testing ended so further inquiries could take place, according to the Times. Of the other four, two revealed offences, thus passing the test, and received cautions and attended a sexual offender treatment programme.
The last two made disclosures and passed the test but refused to admit the offences when interviewed later. Their cases went to court. All four were placed on the sex offenders register.
Of the 15 offenders tested in November, eight failed while six passed. One was caught trying to beat the polygraph, breathing erratically and talking slowly.
Detective Chief Inspector Glen Channer, head of Hertfordshire's child protection unit, said the polygraph was an "added weapon in our armoury of investigative techniques". He said the tests were carried out by accredited practitioners in a scientific environment and were not relied upon on their own.
Hertfordshire police said : "The testing is undertaken ahead of any charges being brought and involves specialist officers from the constabulary's paedophile unit working with an expert who conducts the test on first-time offenders who have volunteered to co-operate with police. Evidence elicited during the examinations is not admissible at court."
The Association of Chief Police Officers (Acpo) cautioned that the tests were at a very early stage. A spokesman said: "Polygraph techniques are complex and are by no means a single solution to solving crimes, potentially offering in certain circumstances an additional tool to structured interrogation.
"These initial trials are in their very early stages and we will follow their progress, working with chief officers across the country to provide further guidance if necessary.
"Whether these techniques are adopted elsewhere in the country is a matter for individual chief constables."
http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2011/dec/31/police-trial-lie-detector-tests
-
I'm not saying the McCanns were obligated to do anything . What I am saying is that if the McCanns were truly innocent taking a polygraph may have helped to rule them out of any part in Madeleine's disappearance and refocus the investigation on the real protagonists. At the very least it may have solidified their innocence in the public's mind and neutralised the damage to the search they claim was caused by Amaral's book.
Of course there was a slight risk that the polygraph would be wrong but if I was the parent of a missing child and I knew she may be out there somewhere waiting to be found it's certainly a chance I'd be willing to take.
I don't agree Faith, a failure by one or both of them could just as easily made things so much worse for them. Polygraphs are only fit for entertainment purposes, they have no place within a justice system.
In relation to the sex offenders trial as posted by Pathfinder above, the only reason they are getting results is because subjects ARE AFRAID TO LIE. Most are not aware that the polygraph is basically just a TOY. It is indeed a weapon in the same way as putting a loaded gun to ones head is.
-
I don't agree Faith, a failure by one or both of them could just as easily made things so much worse for them. Polygraphs are only fit for entertainment purposes, they have no place within a justice system.
In relation to the sex offenders trial, the only reason they are getting results is because subjects ARE AFRAID TO LIE. Most are not aware that the polygraph is basically just a TOY.
Good heavens John - we agree about something. ?{)(**
-
Good heavens John - we agree about something. ?{)(**
If the same person were tested say six times over a six month period, I guarantee there will be both fails and passes. As far as polygraph results are concerned, they are more dangerous than helpful.
-
I have no "problem" with what you have written at all.
I find it funny in both senses of the word and cannot take it seriously.
Great, then perhaps you can tell me what it is you find so funny (in both sense of the word) about it.
-
I wonder if anyone on here would like to admit to having taken a polygraph ?
-
Great, then perhaps you can tell me what it is you find so funny (in both sense of the word) about it.
Why?
You asked I answered; subject closed really.
I am sure however if you analyse what you have written and examine the implications you will understand my mirth.
-
I wonder if anyone on here would like to admit to having taken a polygraph ?
I will take a polygraph to determine if I have previously taken one.
-
I wonder if anyone on here would like to admit to having taken a polygraph ?
Nah. They are probably all in prison for crimes they didn't commit.
-
I will take a polygraph to determine if I have previously taken one.
and there would be a 50% chance of it being right.
-
and there would be a 50% chance of it being right.
Is there not an undecided element? That would be a 33.333333..% chance surely?
-
Nah. They are probably all in prison for crimes they didn't commit.
You already know Eleanor, most courts don't use them as direct evidence.
-
and there would be a 50% chance of it being right.
Is that based on a statistical model JP ?
-
You already know Eleanor, most courts don't use them as direct evidence.
You mean The Police don't take them seriously?
-
You mean The Police don't take them seriously?
Ask John. ?{)(**
-
Why?
You asked I answered; subject closed really.
I am sure however if you analyse what you have written and examine the implications you will understand my mirth.
Probably you're hysterical with mirth that I described a hypothetical situation as a fact. Only a pedant however would dispute the verisimilitude of what I wrote which is that if the McCanns passed a polygraph test, the majority of seasoned "sceptics" would still be convinced they dunnit.
-
I will take a polygraph to determine if I have previously taken one.
And whether you were actually on a road which caught you out with a speeding ticket that you didn't yet know about, or your precise alibi when a nearby bank had been burgled?
Innocent or guilty or sort of half and half ... still cold sweat-time, perhaps?
-
Probably you're hysterical with mirth that I described a hypothetical situation as a fact. Only a pedant however would dispute the verisimilitude of what I wrote which is that if the McCanns passed a polygraph test, the majority of seasoned "sceptics" would still be convinced they dunnit.
Stop making assumptions and passing them on as true facts then....Alice is the least pedantic in here, I think you probably hold the medal and are projecting, as the know it all psychologists say, hmmm? versimillitudish enough now?
@)(++(*
-
we have seen a statement saying they are not suspects
Which doesn't mean 'innocent'. The Portuguese authorities said they weren't suspects, and they didn't think they were innocent at the time.
-
the mccanns are not suspects was said in context not written in stone for evermore
-
If the polygraph isn't 100% reliable, what 's the point? Just imagine if the polygraph found you innocent and you were in fact well and truly guilty.
-
And whether you were actually on a road which caught you out with a speeding ticket that you didn't yet know about, or your precise alibi when a nearby bank had been burgled?
Innocent or guilty or sort of half and half ... still cold sweat-time, perhaps?
Nah! being serious about it the cold sweat moment was receiving the letter from the cops in another county asking where I was at a particular time, with proof of course, as a car fitting the description of mine with a 2/3 match on the registration plate was seen at xxxxxx doing something dodgy...... oooer, mum help!
And another one; "there was accident on M? we know your car was in the vicinity (cameras) at the approximate time. If you were the driver did you see anything and will you please ask your passenger if he saw anything"?
Cold shivers down the spine when one realises just how much of trail one leaves behind going about ones legitimate business and how much one is being watched.
-
If the polygraph isn't 100% reliable, what 's the point? Just imagine if the polygraph found you innocent and you were in fact well and truly guilty.
Or guilty when you were in fact well and truly innocent. I wouldn't take one if my liberty or my public image depended on it, despite the fact that I'm as innocent as the day is long... 8**8:/:
-
I wouldn't take a polygraph if I were innocent!!. Don't blame McCANNS for refusing. but then why say they will then don't? they do it with everything to do with this case. That is why some folks suspect them if having an 'agenda'
-
I wouldn't take a polygraph if I were innocent!!. Don't blame McCANNS for refusing. but then why say they will then don't? they do it with everything to do with this case. That is why some folks suspect them if having an 'agenda'
they never said they would...they said they would if requested to by the Portuguese police......
-
they never said they would...they said they would if requested to by the Portuguese police......
They probably have enough savvey to ignore it. The polygraph has no place in any justice system.