UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: John on January 05, 2014, 10:09:02 PM

Title: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: John on January 05, 2014, 10:09:02 PM
Three members of the tapas-7 claim to have seen Robert Murat at the Ocean Club Garden a short time after Madeleine disappeared.  Mr Murat for his part claims to have been home with his mother from 8.30pm that evening.  He is adamant that he did not leave his home until breakfast time the next morning.

Let's have a look at what Russell O'Brien had to say about Mr Murat's whereabouts...

 Comments- I am troubled by MURAT’S denial of being there on the night of Madeleine’s disappearance and assisting in the translations.  This has troubled me he would have an alibi had he have been honest about being there. The statement given in Portugal are true and accurate, other people put MURAT there on the night one of those being Sylvia head of house keeping. I would like to point out that I do not wish to change the statement given to the PJ but have reservations that the time may have been inaccurate and it may have been the following morning when I saw him.

I’ve written about, erm, Robert MURAT and then there’s a whole, my whole third statement is, is solely about our meetings, erm, so there, there is a vast amount of information that, that isn’t there, but obviously in my third statement is, is a sort of testimony for that.  I think what I’ve written here really is that, erm, we gave that statement, erm, within a few days of him being made aguido, certainly before, erm, any details of, of his movements, according to his statement, had been, had been leaked or had come out into the open.  Erm, we certainly, the three, you know, the three of us, all immediately thought, when we saw him on the television, that we recognised him and that he was there on the night and the statements that were given were given relatively soon after the event and at the time I had absolutely no doubt that that was, that those were accurate.  The reason I brought this back up here is because I cannot see what he stood to gain by not, by not being, well by saying he wasn’t there on the night when there was the potential for so many people to have seen him.  Erm, and it’s been a bit difficult, kind of, erm, you know, he was trying to knock a square peg into a round hole here, because I certainly had a great deal of faith in what I said at the time, you know, there was no, I didn’t have any doubts, was it the evening, sorry, was it the night, was it the next morning, but with him denying it, with no further evidence coming out, with no questions in here whatsoever that kind of led, that would, that sort of said, you know, ‘What about Robert MURAT’, I can only speculate that there’s, that there is no further evidence, erm, that kind will push, will push the case further on him.  Erm, and then I also got the information from the likes of Charlotte PENNINGTON and, and, erm, at least earlier on, Sylvia, erm, well sort of the Housekeeper, and Press reports saying that other people also placed him there on the night, that kind of made me think, well this is, that I, you know, that I am correct”.
 

www.mccannfiles.com/id221.html
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: John on January 06, 2014, 12:40:48 AM
Russell O'Brien's Rogatory Statement contd...

 1578    “So is there anything that you would like to add to that paragraph?”
Reply    “Well only that it’s, it’s out, out of the context of what I’ve just been saying again there”.
1578    “Is there anything you would like to add to improve?”
Reply    “I think at the end ‘that he would have an alibi’, erm, ‘Although’, ‘Although convinced of the accuracy of our statements at the time of’, erm, ‘of giving’”.
1578    “Okay.  ‘Although convinced’?”
Reply    “’Convinced of the accuracy of our statements at the time of giving’”.
1578    “Yeah?”
Reply    “’And further backed up by the testimony of Fiona, Rachael’ and potentially a number of other people if you believe the Press”.
1578    “’And further backed up’?”
Reply    “’By the testimony of Rachael, Fiona and other people’.  It not going to make sense this, after this, is it, it’s one of these long O’BRIEN sentences that don’t really end, erm”.
1578    “’Backed up by the testimony of Rachael, Fiona and others’ did you say?”
Reply    “Yeah”.
1578    “Yeah?”
Reply    “’I cannot understand why Robert MURAT would deny being there and I do not wish to change my statement but have’”.
1578    “Which statement?”
Reply    “Well ‘I do not wish to change’, you know, the”.
1578    “’My original statement’?”
Reply    “’The original kind of statement’”.
1578    “Yes?”
Reply    “’But have’, you know, ‘the niggle that unintentionally we have’, ‘that we have got a time wrong and that it was in the morning’”.
1578    “’A niggle that unintentionally’?”
Reply    “You know, ‘I may’, ‘I may have the time wrong’.  Erm, let you write that”.
1578    “Yes?”
Reply    “Erm, can I just see how that.  Erm, ‘However Rachael and Fiona report they only saw him once and it was on the night’”.
1578    “Sorry, ‘However’?”
Reply    “’However Rachael and Fiona said they’, you know, ‘they firmly place him there on the night’”.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: John on January 06, 2014, 02:47:55 AM
In Russell O'Briens Portuguese statement of 16 May he is very specific about his encounter with Murat...

 When asked whether he is capable of recognising without any doubt the suspect Robert Murat, the witness replies yes.

 When questioned he says that the first time he saw Robert Murat was on the night of the events currently under investigation, in other words, the night upon which Madeleine disappeared, at about 01.00 in the early morning of 4th May.

 That he saw Murat for the first time at this moment in the Rua Silva in front of the apartment where the events occurred, near to the parking area.

 When asked whether Murat arrived before or after the police, the witness says that he does not know, given that at the time the police arrived he was not present as he was searching for Madeleine.

 When he saw him for the first time the police were on the scene.

 Robert Murat appeared in the middle of different people (friends from the group, people from the resort, tourists and locals) who were searching for Madeleine. he adds that he does not know at what time Murat appeared on the scene, nor whether he arrive alone or accompanied, in the sense that when the witness arrived at the scene, Murat was already there.

 When asked, he says that as far as he can remember, Robert was translating conversations between two officers and various people who were searching for Madeleine. As far as he could make out at that time, it seemed that Robert was trying to help, in the sense that these people were exasperated with some of the officers. He remembers that all the people were quite upset, whilst Robert was very calm. That morning was the first time the witness spoke to Murat, not remembering whether he had approached Murat or whether Robert had addressed him. They had various discussions including the fact that Robert was fluent in Portuguese as he had lived in the country for many years.

 He adds that Robert told him he had a daughter of Madeleines age in the UK and that Madeleines disappearance was a terrible thing.

 When asked what Murat was wearing that night, the witness says he is not certain but thinks he was wearing dark coloured trousers, he can't remember the colour, and a T-shirt, perhaps dark grey in colour and perhaps a jacket, the characteristics of which he cannot describe. He clearly remembers that Robert wore glasses.

 When asked he says he does not know how Robert found out about Madeleines disappearance nor how he arrived at the scene.

 When asked, he says that he had never seen Robert before.

 After this morning the witness saw Murat 3 more times, once on the morning of 4th May in the same street, rua Silva at about 12.00 in the company of police officers. About two days later he saw Murat at the OC reception at about 12.00/14.00. Robert was alone and walking towards the previously mentioned road. The witness says that he (ROB) was accompanied by Rachel. The last time he saw Robert was last Sunday, near to his house at about 20.30. At that moment the witness was with Jane.

www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RUSSELL-OBRIEN.htm#p5p1320to1322




Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: John on January 06, 2014, 02:54:40 AM
In his next statement of 11 July 2007 he reaffirms...

 --- The deponent reaffirms that in truth he met Robert Murat on the night on which Madeleine
 disappeared. He saw him for the first time about 01h00 on 4 May near to the parking area in front
 of the main entrance [front door] of the apartment from which Madeleine disappeared.
 --- That in the early hours of the morning of 4 May he was speaking with Robert Murat, having
 spoken about the circumstances in which Madeleine could have disappeared. He saw him several
 times that night given that he had stayed [remained] in the area [and] having also seen him
 speaking with uniformed people.
 --- The deponent would like now to inform that at some time he was aware that Robert Murat
 assisted police officers [by] being the interpreter. Therefore, at some time, but already the following
 morning, it appeared to him, he [ROB] approached Robert Murat having asked him [RM] to give
 him [ROB] his [RM's] telephone number because he [ROB] considered that at some time he might
 need the support of that person [RM] given that he spoke Portuguese correctly. In truth Robert
 Murat furnished him with his mobile number which the deponent inserted into the calendar/address
 book of his own mobile phone. He doesn't recall exactly the time that happened but has the idea
 that it was already during the morning of 4 May [i.e. it was already daylight]. In an analysis of the
 calendar/address book of the mobile phone by PJ officers it was verified that the number of Robert
 Murat was inserted there immediately before number 914..., indicated as being of David Priest.

www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RUSSELL-OBRIEN.htm#p8p1945to1946
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: John on January 06, 2014, 03:26:33 AM
Russell O'Brien transcript of recorded interview on 10 April 2008...

 Erm, and, erm, at this point, you know, there was, erm, you know, other conversations, you know, this is where I believe I had my first meeting and conversations with, with, with Robert MURAT, he’d helped break up a little bit of a, of a fracas between a couple of guests and the, and the Police, the couple of Police who were, who were there and were standing outside the apartment or just a little bit up from it, erm, and, erm, they weren’t, they weren’t visibly doing very much and I think a couple of the, either British ex-pats who live there or tourists, one of whom, they were both in kind of their fifties, if I remember rightly, they were getting quite, quite mouthy, they were quite, they had a very clear idea of what they thought that should be done and, erm, at one point they were, they were saying this quite loudly to, to, you know, a couple of members of the GNR whose English obviously wasn’t good enough to hear a, a shouted colloquial rant in English at them, erm, and I’ve a recollection of, of, of MURAT sort of saying, you know, ‘Hang on guys they can’t understand you’, you know, being actually very helpful and that is my recollection of him on the night, that he came across as concerned, like a lot of people, you know, said ‘I’ve got a daughter the same sort of age, this is terrible, this is terrible’, helping defuse the situation with, with the, erm, with the, erm, with a couple of members of the GNR.  I had another conversation,

 

I mean, over, I’m not entirely sure what sort of timescale this is, I think my original statements said this was all around one am, but it’s all a little bit of a blur, erm, I had a few other conversations with him, erm, either round the back of the apartments, erm, I mean, he was saying that, you know, again, sort of console here, very consolatory kind of comments which were, which a lot of people were saying to anyone who they knew was part of the group, erm, and one thing he did make a mention of was, you know, it was something about Norfolk, which I believe is where he his, his, his wife and kid live and he said there was, you know, there was a case a few, a few years back, erm, of someone went missing and then they turned up, they may have turned up hundreds of miles away, but, you know, they were unharmed, they were safe.  Again, you know, the kind of thing that most people were quite happy to, happy to hear and, you know, I didn’t have any, any great sort of suspicion about him on the night, in fact, he didn’t feature in any of our statements on the first or the second attempt, erm, I know Fiona and Rachael have much more vehement views on what he was like, they found him a little, you know, different, but, from my point of view, he was, he was just helping like a number of other individuals and, erm, and being fluent in Portuguese was, was obviously a big help on such a night.  Erm, he also sort of gave the impression that he might have done some Police work before and, to be fair, I probably didn’t know at the time but now I don’t know whether he was referring to translation work that he’d done with the Portuguese Police here or whether he’d been involved in translating for, for Police in Britain, you know, in the opposite direction, but I’ve got this vague, vague now recollection of some kind of conversation on that, on that, erm, on that level.



Erm, you know, I certainly saw Robert MURAT again on the morning and that’s the occasion, erm, on which I took his, his mobile number, erm, and I thought, you know, certainly with some of the translational difficulties with, you know, with the staff, that he appeared to be a very, a very kind of useful person to sort of be able to contact should we need him, as I say, I remember taking his details just on the corner of the apartment, we were outside, not, not on the road outside five ‘A’ but just at the junction of the two roads, he was walking off and going around there and I remember kind of catching him and saying, you know, ‘What’s your name’ and just putting Robert and his number into the phone.  Erm, I think that was before I then got the number of the Anglican Priest,




www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RUSSELL-OBRIEN_ROGATORY.htm
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: John on January 06, 2014, 03:59:17 AM
Rachael Mampilly extract from statement dated 15 May 2007...



She says that the first time she saw the suspect Robert Murat was on the night of 3rd May shortly after they had discovered Madeleine was missing. She saw him for the first time at about 23h30 in the covered area between apartments 5B and D. She thought it very strange as he seemed to be there watching, trying to be the next person to talk to the couples from the group.
 
That immediately, when the police arrived, he introduced himself to elements of the group, namely Russell, accompanied by the GNR, translating all the initial contacts between the group and the police.
 
When asked, she says that she does not know whether he entered the McCanns' apartment with the police.
 
As regards the other people searching for the girl outside the apartment he tried to contact them directly, saying that he had a daughter of the same age as Madeleine, offering to translate whatever was necessary.
 
She thought this individual's behaviour was very strange, given the intensity of his presence. In addition, all the people they contacted that night belonged to the Mark Warner resort and he stayed there, in the middle of them, without anyone knowing where he had come from. Because of her profession (personnel recruitment, interviews) she thinks she knows a bit about human behaviour, thinking it rather strange that he introduced himself in such an insistent manner.
 
She saw that this individual was with the police in the area for some minutes before she lost sight of him. She does not know whether he managed to enter the McCann's apartment.
 
She thinks that after this night she only saw him again on Sunday, 6th May in the morning, in the Praia da Luz church during mass.
 
She saw him again on 11th May when he was translating some statements at the PJ in Portimao. She thinks he spoke again and wanted to draw close to her companions with great intensity, wanting to talk about his life, saying that he was carrying out work in a house in the UK, that he had a daughter of the same age as Madeleine, that she was phoning him a lot to ask how he was (which she thought strange given the girl's young age), always showing a familiarity that was out of the ordinary.
 
She always had the impression that this individual had strange behaviour and that he wanted to impose his presence, trying to take part in everything that was related to Madeleine's disappearance.
 
She did not see him again, except for yesterday, when he was shown on various television channels as a suspect in the abduction of Madeleine. She then felt her suspicions about this individual would be confirmed, feeling bad for not having expressed them earlier to others and to the police.
 
Reads, ratifies, signs.

www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RACHAEL-OLDFIELD-11-MAY07.htm#p5p1292
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: John on January 06, 2014, 04:12:46 AM
Fiona Payne extract from statement dated 16 May 2007...

 Questioned, states that she became aware following various news bulletins - namely on Sky News - that Robert Murat was the main suspect in the abduction of Madeleine McCann.
 
That upon seeing the individual on television, she recognised him immediately as someone from the night of the disappearance of Madeleine who had made his presence noted.
 
That she never saw this individual before, and saw him for the first time, as stated, on the night of May 3rd, around 23h30, outside, and next to the door of the McCann apartment in the company of GNR elements, who had arrived.
 
That at this point, one and a half hours had passed since Kate McCann had noted that her daughter had disappeared.
 
Questioned, states that she does not remember the characteristics (type, colour, etc) of the clothes that Robert Murat wore that night.
 
That she found the presence of this individual at the site very strange, and never got to know what his role was (contrary to other people who were there, and who belonged to the police or the resort).
 
That at a certain time, he said that he was there to help the police but his behaviour was not compatible with this role, in that he looked to be leading the process, stating that he was offering his help in all that was necessary.
 
That she found his behaviour so excessively strange that she stayed as far away from him as she could.
 
That she does not remember if he entered the McCann's apartment on this night. She does not know if he spoke to Gerry, but is certain that he did not speak to Kate, in that after the disappearance of Madeleine, the deponent stayed with [Kate] for most of the time in her [Kate's] apartment.
 
That during this night, she saw him walking to and fro, the majority of the time accompanied by the police, and always with an air of authority, offering suggestions and trying to lead the situation.
 
That she did not speak to him, and only observed his behaviour.
 
She only came across him at around 23h30, next to the McCann apartment, when he went there to offer his help in any way possible. She does not remember if anyone was with him at this time.
 
That in the following days she saw him various times with numerous reporters who were in the locale.
 
That she did not see him in any other place or situation.
 
States that since the night of the disappearance, she found his behaviour strange, as he wanted to know everything that was happening and gave the idea that he knew everything. He tried insistently to lead the process - especially the actions of the police.
 
At one point, he even seemed to try and lead the police movements with his presence and wanted to translate everything.
 
That she had never seen him before this night.
 
And nothing more was said.

www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE_16_05-07.htm
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: John on January 06, 2014, 04:23:08 AM
Record of anonymous telephone call received by the Portuguese police on 8 May 2007...

 At about 20.00 the police received a phone call from a number that could not be identified, from a person with a female voice speaking in correct Portuguese, who did not want to be identified for reasons of safety. She refers to an individual who abducted Madeleine, who knows how to keep quiet and is quite close to the police. When asked who she was referring to she said it was an individual who resides in Praia da Luz, who has an English mother, who speaks this language very well, who was near the area since the disappearance of the little girl, supposedly with the intention of helping the investigation. She said this man was called Robert and that he used to consult Internet chats of a pretty heavy sexual nature. He would also use Internet for contacts with different acquaintances he had in other countries, especially in the UK. She said most of the mails he sent were encrypted due to the monitoring of the kind of content they possessed. This is why she wanted to alert the authorities about the characteristics of this man, who, in her opinion, could have sexual motives and opportunity, knowing the area perfectly for committing or collaborating in this type of crime.

www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/ROBERT-MURAT.htm#p2p461
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: John on January 06, 2014, 05:19:55 AM
Extract from Jane Tanner interview of 8 April 2008...

 Reply    “Erm I think the only part which, I mean it’s more relevant to everybody else than to me, it’s probably some of the Robert MURAT bits, in terms of erm Rachel, Fi and Russ and into, erm it was sort of how that came about and how they came to give their statements on that, I don’t know whether it’s a good time to talk about that”?
 

4078    “Yes, yes go on”.
  Reply    “Erm well I think it’s when I’d done the, well I did the surveillance and then the next day after that, I think it came on Sky News about whether they were searching, what the MURAT’s house, so that’s Rachel sort of came running down at that point and sort of said, have you seen this blah, blah and at this point, nobody knew that I’d done the surveillance cos the Portuguese Police were very adamant that I shouldn’t tell anybody and I didn’t tell anybody for days actually, I didn’t even tell them then that it was actually, that I’d done it, I mean it was a couple of days afterwards.  So Rachel came down and sort of said, oh I saw him blah, blah, blah and then I think Russell, I can’t remember who else but then somebody else said oh they, they saw him and etc., so at that point it was, I rang Bob SMALL cos I’d got, I’d got his number from the day before for them and you know, they sort of, you know to say, oh is this, is this relevant and also I wanted to tell him that I’d seen him on the way to the doing the surveillance as well yeah just for that, so I think it’s just to make the point really that I think at that point, they didn’t know that Robert MURAT said he wasn’t there on the night”.
 

4078    “Right”.
  Reply    “You know, or said yeah, had said that he wasn’t there on the night, so you know was immediately, I think it was immediately, I’m not trying to push anything onto Robert MURAT’s door, cos as I say I don’t think it was him that I saw”.
 

4078    “No”.
  Reply    “But I just thought it was”.
 

4078    “Because there had been some dispute as to whether they’ve actually seen him when they’ve said they’ve seen him”.
  Reply    “Yeah I think, I just want to make it clear that from my own point of view, they gave that information as soon as it came onto Sky and asked and you know they were sort of like, oh let’s ring Bob SMALL to see if it’s relevant at this point and at that point, none of us knew that he wasn’t there on you know, that he didn’t say that he was there on the night and”.
 

4078    “Yes”.
  Reply    “And I, I mean I didn’t myself see him on the night at all but somebody did say to me, who translated for you, was it the lady or the man and it, it was the lady, I said, Sylvie and I hadn’t seen a man but again I don’t know whether that has any relevance that there was somebody else there translating, you know during the night so”.
 

4078    “Okay, that’s certainly a point worth bringing up when we interview the other people that have seen him there on the night”.
  Reply    “Yeah exactly, I’m not trying to, cos I feel you know, if he’s not involved, the poor chap’s had as much crap as us really, I feel very, you know, he’s not involved but I do think it’s important that”.
 

4078    “Get to the truth of the matter”?
  Reply    “Get to the truth of the matter and the truth is you know they, when they asked me to ring Bob SMALL to make these statements, we didn’t even know that he’d erm, hadn’t, hadn’t said he was there on the night and they didn’t know that I’d done the surveillance”.

www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JANE_TANNER_RIGATORY.htm
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: John on January 06, 2014, 05:37:42 AM
Question is...could three people be so wrong in what they saw?
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: colombosstogey on January 06, 2014, 06:08:02 AM
Question is...could three people be so wrong in what they saw?

It depends on what is at stake I suppose.

Are you doubting Murat? (The saying goes MUD STICKS).

What about DP he looks remarkably like Murat, perhaps in the distance they saw him in his searching and mistook him for Murat who knows anything is possible.....OR there is a post by VIXTE on the other thread about Murat where a journalist was mistaken for Murat.....and so it begins............

(http://i159.photobucket.com/albums/t140/MrsAristotle/payne--muratprofile_zpsffa859d5.jpg)
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Mr Gray on January 06, 2014, 07:55:01 AM
didn't murat change his alibi.....
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: stephen25000 on January 06, 2014, 09:23:04 AM
didn't murat change his alibi.....

Have the Mccanns and associates changed their accounts ?  >@@(*&)
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Luz on January 06, 2014, 09:48:35 AM
Have the Mccanns and associates changed their accounts ?  >@@(*&)

Actually Murat never changed his alibi for the night in question, neither did his mother. He claimed he stayed at home and none of the GNR that knew him, and were called to Ocean Club that night, saw him.
I tend to give more credence to the GNR than to a bunch of people that had contributed to the consumption of 14 bottles of wine+ aperitifs.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: stephen25000 on January 06, 2014, 09:59:11 AM
Actually Murat never changed his alibi for the night in question, neither did his mother. He claimed he stayed at home and none of the GNR that knew him, and were called to Ocean Club that night, saw him.
I tend to give more credence to the GNR than to a bunch of people that had contributed to the consumption of 14 bottles of wine+ aperitifs.

That Luz is precisely the point.

Though on the night of Madeleine's disappearance they had only just started on the booze.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Benice on January 06, 2014, 10:02:30 AM
Actually Murat never changed his alibi for the night in question, neither did his mother. He claimed he stayed at home and none of the GNR that knew him, and were called to Ocean Club that night, saw him.
I tend to give more credence to the GNR than to a bunch of people that had contributed to the consumption of 14 bottles of wine+ aperitifs.

14 bottles of wine in an hour?  - and whilst eating a 3 course meal at the same time? - and some people taking time out to check on the children?    I don't think so.

IIRC correctly the 14 bottles of wine was the total amount served to everyone that night  - not just the McCanns.

According to one of their waiters - he put 4 bottles of wine on the table - and no-one can say how much of that had been consumed or how much was left in glasses and bottles when the alarm was raised an hour later.   

Just another fabrication to add to the others you keep trying to introduce on here imo.

 

Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Luz on January 06, 2014, 10:04:34 AM
I don't know about that. The McCann, according to Mrs diary, had already began with Neo Zeland wine at the apartment,...as far as I know none were tested before they gave their testimonies.

Only they know what happened inside that apartment, on that night, while they had wine and prepared to go to diner with their friends.

What's clear, as far as the police investigation goes, is that Murat had not been close to OC that night
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Luz on January 06, 2014, 10:14:03 AM


First of all, woman is your mother because you probably don't deserve the title.
Second, after almost 7 years I decline to have to point the Case Files everytime, but here it goes, read http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/ (http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/)
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: sadie on January 06, 2014, 12:48:24 PM

First of all, woman is your mother because you probably don't deserve the title.
Second, after almost 7 years I decline to have to point the Case Files everytime, but here it goes, read http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/ (http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/)
Who are you abusing here, Luz?

Not Benice, are you?
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: CPN on January 06, 2014, 12:51:03 PM
Who are you abusing here, Luz?

Not Benice, are you?

Luz was responding to abuse to HER.  And no, it was not from Benice
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: ferryman on January 06, 2014, 01:26:17 PM
Here is the record of the confrontation:

Processo, Volume VIII, pages 1957 to 1958

RECORD OF CONFRONTATION

---- On 11 July, at 10:00, in the premises of the Department of Criminal Investigation of the Portimao Judicial Police, before me, Paulo Ferreira, Inspector, and Dr. Guilhermino Encarnacao, Deputy National Director of Judicial Police, appeared the defendant ROBERT JAMES QUERIOL EVELEIGH MURAT, already identified in the file, in order to proceed with his interrogation. Following on [prior] interrogatory work and contradictions having been seen between that which the defendant said and that of the witnesses, RACHEL MARIAMMA JEAN MAMPILLY, RUSSEL JAMES O'BRIEN, and FIONA ELAINE PAYNE, all also duly identified in the file, given that in the depositions of these people there exist clear contradictions with the answers of the defendant, this present work proceeded.
---- This work was conducted in the presence of the defence attorney of the defendant, Dr. Francisco Pagarete, as well as Mrs Carla E., translator and interpreter who translated all the declarations in English and vice versa, that having been started at 12:00.
---- By the first confronter, RACHEL MARIAMMA JEAN MAMPILLY it was said that she confirms her deposition recorded at pages 1212 ff. of the case file, namely that she saw the defendant present in this confrontation at about 23h30 on 03 May 2007 in the circumstances that she makes clear in the [above] document.
---- By the second confronter, RUSSEL JAMES O'BRIEN it was said that he confirms his testimony recorded in pages 1320 and 1321, specifically when it states that he saw the defendant ROBERT MURAT on the night on which occurred the events now under investigation, that is on the night on which Madeleine disappeared, about 01:00 in the early hours of 04 May last, [and] in all the rest he confirms his testimony in what it says with respect to the contact that he had with the defendant.
---- By the third confronter, FIONA ELAINE PAYNE it was said that she confirms her testimony recorded in pages 1323 and 1324, namely when it states that she saw the defendant for the first time, personally, on the night of 03 May about 23h30 outside, next to the door of the McCann apartment in the company of officers of the GNR that in the meantime had already arrived at the place. In all the rest she confirms the "circumstantionalism" [all encompassing circumstances] of the approach that she made to the defendant.
---- By the fourth confronter the accused ROBERT JAMES QUERIOL EVELEIGH MURAT it was said that it is a lie [fabrication] what the other confronters had said because on that night of the disappearance of Madeleine he was not nor had been in that place, not having on the night of 03 May 2007 even gone out of
his house.
---- Nothing else was declared by the confronters, this document having been read to them they found it conforms (with their statements made) it is going to be signed by all the participants.
[/b]

High pantomime farce.

You were out and about on the night

Oh no I wasn't

Oh yes you were

Oh no I wasn't

Oh yes ... (etc)

What was any of that supposed to prove?
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: John on January 06, 2014, 02:31:38 PM
didn't murat change his alibi.....

No, he has always maintained that he and his mother were home alone after 8.30pm on the evening that Madeleine disappeared.  Apparently he made two tel calls that night but doesn't remember doing so and had failed to report doing so in his first statement.  Memory loss appears to be a significant feature of that evening.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: John on January 06, 2014, 03:09:07 PM
Here is the record of the confrontation:

Processo, Volume VIII, pages 1957 to 1958

RECORD OF CONFRONTATION

---- On 11 July, at 10:00, in the premises of the Department of Criminal Investigation of the Portimao Judicial Police, before me, Paulo Ferreira, Inspector, and Dr. Guilhermino Encarnacao, Deputy National Director of Judicial Police, appeared the defendant ROBERT JAMES QUERIOL EVELEIGH MURAT, already identified in the file, in order to proceed with his interrogation. Following on [prior] interrogatory work and contradictions having been seen between that which the defendant said and that of the witnesses, RACHEL MARIAMMA JEAN MAMPILLY, RUSSEL JAMES O'BRIEN, and FIONA ELAINE PAYNE, all also duly identified in the file, given that in the depositions of these people there exist clear contradictions with the answers of the defendant, this present work proceeded.
---- This work was conducted in the presence of the defence attorney of the defendant, Dr. Francisco Pagarete, as well as Mrs Carla E., translator and interpreter who translated all the declarations in English and vice versa, that having been started at 12:00.
---- By the first confronter, RACHEL MARIAMMA JEAN MAMPILLY it was said that she confirms her deposition recorded at pages 1212 ff. of the case file, namely that she saw the defendant present in this confrontation at about 23h30 on 03 May 2007 in the circumstances that she makes clear in the [above] document.
---- By the second confronter, RUSSEL JAMES O'BRIEN it was said that he confirms his testimony recorded in pages 1320 and 1321, specifically when it states that he saw the defendant ROBERT MURAT on the night on which occurred the events now under investigation, that is on the night on which Madeleine disappeared, about 01:00 in the early hours of 04 May last, [and] in all the rest he confirms his testimony in what it says with respect to the contact that he had with the defendant.
---- By the third confronter, FIONA ELAINE PAYNE it was said that she confirms her testimony recorded in pages 1323 and 1324, namely when it states that she saw the defendant for the first time, personally, on the night of 03 May about 23h30 outside, next to the door of the McCann apartment in the company of officers of the GNR that in the meantime had already arrived at the place. In all the rest she confirms the "circumstantionalism" [all encompassing circumstances] of the approach that she made to the defendant.
---- By the fourth confronter the accused ROBERT JAMES QUERIOL EVELEIGH MURAT it was said that it is a lie [fabrication] what the other confronters had said because on that night of the disappearance of Madeleine he was not nor had been in that place, not having on the night of 03 May 2007 even gone out of
his house.
---- Nothing else was declared by the confronters, this document having been read to them they found it conforms (with their statements made) it is going to be signed by all the participants.
[/b]

High pantomime farce.

You were out and about on the night

Oh no I wasn't

Oh yes you were

Oh no I wasn't

Oh yes ... (etc)

What was any of that supposed to prove?
The thing I find extremely strange about all this is that Russell actually spoke to the man he identfied as RM and a few hours later even got his telephone number from him.  Very odd?
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: ferryman on January 06, 2014, 03:46:37 PM
The thing I find extremely strange about all this is that Russell actually spoke to the man he identfied as RM and a few hours later even got his telephone number from him.  Very odd?

He [Russell O'Brien] never noticed anything suspicious about Murat except for the last time he saw him when Robert was being transported in a vehicle, a green van with four windows, he does not remember the make, model or number plate and that he stopped, got out of the van, opened the back and showed photos of Madeleine and that he showed himself to be a very important person in the investigation, saying that he was providing immense help to the police in discovering the truth.

hmmmmmmmmmmmmm!
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: jassi on January 06, 2014, 03:49:32 PM
He [Russell O'Brien] never noticed anything suspicious about Murat except for the last time he saw him when Robert was being transported in a vehicle, a green van with four windows, he does not remember the make, model or number plate and that he stopped, got out of the van, opened the back and showed photos of Madeleine and that he showed himself to be a very important person in the investigation, saying that he was providing immense help to the police in discovering the truth.

hmmmmmmmmmmmmm!

Someone wanting his 15 minutes of fame ? - got rather more than he bargained for.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Benice on January 06, 2014, 05:33:36 PM
Someone wanting his 15 minutes of fame ? - got rather more than he bargained for.

I tend to agree with that Jassi.  From what we have heard he involved himself extensively from the start  - i.e. with newspaper reporters, the GNR, interpreting etc etc.    Some people thought he was part of the PJ.    I do not believe he had anything to do with Madeleine's disappearance, but even if he was just an over enthusiastic 'do-gooder' it certainly backfired on him.    I got the impression he enjoyed being at the centre of things.



 

Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: slartibartfast on January 06, 2014, 05:38:24 PM
I tend to agree with that Jassi.  From what we have heard he involved himself extensively from the start  - i.e. with newspaper reporters, the GNR, interpreting etc etc.    Some people thought he was part of the PJ.    I do not believe he had anything to do with Madeleine's disappearance, but even if he was just an over enthusiastic 'do-gooder' it certainly backfired on him.    I got the impression he enjoyed being at the centre of things.

I would tend to agree.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Innominate on May 10, 2017, 02:32:30 PM
Quote
No, he has always maintained that he and his mother were home alone after 8.30pm on the evening that Madeleine disappeared.  Apparently he made two tel calls that night but doesn't remember doing so and had failed to report doing so in his first statement.  Memory loss appears to be a significant feature of that evening.

Old thread, but it seemed the best place to post.

I'm confused by the alibi issue and would just like to check this point out; this is just a clarification of facts and nothing more.

The statement of Robert Murat  14/7/2007

Contrary to what he said originally, he was not with MICHAELA when she went to a Jehovah witnesses' meeting between 20:00 and 22:00, which is why he didn't phone her, because she turns her phone off. He does not know if he called her after 22:00, but accepts that possibility. He does not remember having used the computer. He was home with his mother, when at 22:30 or a little later, he heard a siren of an ambulance or police. He commented on that with his mother, however, did not leave the house to investigate. He did not leave again until the morning, having gone to bed around midnight.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/ROBERT-MURAT.htm

Google translate uses the word initially instead of originally.

I'm not sure what earlier statement they are referring to, if any. It looks like a change with respect to where he was that evening, but I'm not sure statement or comment he is correcting (unless I'm misunderstanding the translation or context).

Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Brietta on May 10, 2017, 03:44:04 PM
Actually Murat never changed his alibi for the night in question, neither did his mother. He claimed he stayed at home and none of the GNR that knew him, and were called to Ocean Club that night, saw him.
I tend to give more credence to the GNR than to a bunch of people that had contributed to the consumption of 14 bottles of wine+ aperitifs.

Which of the attending GNR knew Robert Murat?
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: The Singularity on May 10, 2017, 04:26:39 PM
Question is...could three people be so wrong in what they saw?

I have to admit I had no idea about the anonymous call that was saying Mr Murat frequented certain chat rooms, this seems to be information that could only be provided by someone who knew Mr Murat very well or someone close to him asking someone else to make the call. If anything I find this incredible. So much so that I begin to become very suspicious of the caller and their intentions. Especially with hindsight that most, if not all these lurid allegations were thrown out.

To directly answer your question John, it is possible but is it likely? Given any other situation I would say it is highly unlikely for any three people to misidentify someone and it is highly probable that who saw was the person identified.

My problem here is, how much of this was actually first hand witnessing? For example, did just one of them see Mr Murat and then have a conversation with the others and then they believed it was Mr Murat but weren't entirely sure.

I am very cautious about all the initial statements made because it was a highly charged evening, extremely stressful for all those concerned and it is possible that mistakes, unintentional mistakes were made.

Do I think Mr Murat had any involvement with any aspect of Madeleine's case? I don't because apart from a very odd interview he gave post libel proceedings, there is nothing to eve hint he had any hand in things.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: misty on May 10, 2017, 06:12:58 PM
I have to admit I had no idea about the anonymous call that was saying Mr Murat frequented certain chat rooms, this seems to be information that could only be provided by someone who knew Mr Murat very well or someone close to him asking someone else to make the call. If anything I find this incredible. So much so that I begin to become very suspicious of the caller and their intentions. Especially with hindsight that most, if not all these lurid allegations were thrown out.

To directly answer your question John, it is possible but is it likely? Given any other situation I would say it is highly unlikely for any three people to misidentify someone and it is highly probable that who saw was the person identified.

My problem here is, how much of this was actually first hand witnessing? For example, did just one of them see Mr Murat and then have a conversation with the others and then they believed it was Mr Murat but weren't entirely sure.

I am very cautious about all the initial statements made because it was a highly charged evening, extremely stressful for all those concerned and it is possible that mistakes, unintentional mistakes were made.

Do I think Mr Murat had any involvement with any aspect of Madeleine's case? I don't because apart from a very odd interview he gave post libel proceedings, there is nothing to eve hint he had any hand in things.
It is a fact that the 3 Tapas diners were not the only people who recalled seeing RM that evening. Silvia Batista, Charlotte Pennington, Jayne Jenson & an unnamed barrister also reported seeing him in the vicinity of 5a during the immediate aftermath yet we are expected to believe all of these witnesses were mistaken.
The lurid allegations may well have been thrown out but the files show that at least some of them were true. It is a fact that a significant amount of pornographic material  was found on one of his computers, something the mother of his young step-daughter should have been very uncomfortable with (although clearly not, as she later married him).
It is also a fact that child pornography, albeit in cartoon format, was also found on his computer.
It is also a fact that he logged onto a pornographic site at 0034hrs on 4/5/07 http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/oa/OA6_1/o_apenso_1_Vol_6_p1166.jpg
It is also a fact that there were 2 phone activities recorded on a mobile registered to him at 0335 & 0337hrs on 4/5/07.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P4/04_VOLUME_IVa_Page_1052.jpg

It is a fact that his only alibi is his mother - the same lady who has thrown us the story of the woman in the purple top & the speeding car.

And then there is this witness statement
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARIA_PIRES.htm

A journalist who arrived in Luz at around 9.30am on 4/5/07 & joined the searches, bumping into JM who was already aware at that early stage her son was helping police with translating.




 
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: G-Unit on May 10, 2017, 06:42:10 PM
That Luz is precisely the point.

Though on the night of Madeleine's disappearance they had only just started on the booze.

We don't know what they drank, really. Jane said she usually had a drink quite early, but she didn't at the Paraiso on the Thursday;

Erm, I had an orange juice, I didn’t even have a beer, I remember that, because I thought ‘Oh shall I have a beer’ and I thought ‘Oh no, I’ll have an orange juice’.....I think normally I probably would have at that time of day
thought ‘It’s time for a beer’.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JANE_TANNER_RIGATORY.htm

The McCanns drank wine before they went out.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Alfie on May 10, 2017, 06:56:51 PM
We don't know what they drank, really. Jane said she usually had a drink quite early, but she didn't at the Paraiso on the Thursday;

Erm, I had an orange juice, I didn’t even have a beer, I remember that, because I thought ‘Oh shall I have a beer’ and I thought ‘Oh no, I’ll have an orange juice’.....I think normally I probably would have at that time of day
thought ‘It’s time for a beer’.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JANE_TANNER_RIGATORY.htm

The McCanns drank wine before they went out.
What has this got to do with Robert Murat and challenges to his alibi?
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Innominate on May 11, 2017, 12:13:57 PM
Quote
And then there is this witness statement
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARIA_PIRES.htm

A journalist who arrived in Luz at around 9.30am on 4/5/07 & joined the searches, bumping into JM who was already aware at that early stage her son was helping police with translating.

The relevant section is, presumably:

--- The conversation with both the above people was all in English, the old lady having said that she lived about 100 metres from the resort and that the previous night she heard the Police arrive, due to the sirens, according to her at 22h00.
 --- The old lady said she had been eating dinner with her son when she heard the sirens, that is the Police, it being that it was at that time that she became aware of the disappearance of a girl from the "Ocean Club".

===

If this statement is a strictly correct recollection of the conversation, then it would be more interesting if RM was not at the OC after Madeleine was found to be missing, i.e the witnesses that saw him there were mistaken.

I do not believe JM or RM would have been aware of the statement made by Maria Pires.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Brietta on May 11, 2017, 12:24:35 PM
The relevant section is, presumably:

--- The conversation with both the above people was all in English, the old lady having said that she lived about 100 metres from the resort and that the previous night she heard the Police arrive, due to the sirens, according to her at 22h00.
 --- The old lady said she had been eating dinner with her son when she heard the sirens, that is the Police, it being that it was at that time that she became aware of the disappearance of a girl from the "Ocean Club".

===

If this statement is a strictly correct recollection of the conversation, then it would be more interesting if RM was not at the OC after Madeleine was found to be missing, i.e the witnesses that saw him there were mistaken.

I do not believe JM or RM would have been aware of the statement made by Maria Pires.

I've never understood why Robert Murat was so adamant he was not on the streets at the time several witnesses said he was unless he really wasn't there.

What would have been incriminating about it if he had been?  I can't think of a single reason.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: misty on May 11, 2017, 12:38:24 PM
The relevant section is, presumably:

--- The conversation with both the above people was all in English, the old lady having said that she lived about 100 metres from the resort and that the previous night she heard the Police arrive, due to the sirens, according to her at 22h00.
 --- The old lady said she had been eating dinner with her son when she heard the sirens, that is the Police, it being that it was at that time that she became aware of the disappearance of a girl from the "Ocean Club".

===

If this statement is a strictly correct recollection of the conversation, then it would be more interesting if RM was not at the OC after Madeleine was found to be missing, i.e the witnesses that saw him there were mistaken.

I do not believe JM or RM would have been aware of the statement made by Maria Pires.

The part you have quoted is incriminating, yes. I was more drawn to the excerpt "-- The above lady also said that her son was working [collaborating] with the police in the attempt to find the child."
.Most people would have said that were helping with the searches, not that the were collaborating with the police. If RM had only joined the searches that morning, at what stage did he convey to his mother that he was already working for the police? There is no record of a phone call by RM to JM that morning so unless he went back home (to change his shirt?) I'm not sure how JM could have known.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Mr Gray on May 11, 2017, 12:49:14 PM
The relevant section is, presumably:

--- The conversation with both the above people was all in English, the old lady having said that she lived about 100 metres from the resort and that the previous night she heard the Police arrive, due to the sirens, according to her at 22h00.
 --- The old lady said she had been eating dinner with her son when she heard the sirens, that is the Police, it being that it was at that time that she became aware of the disappearance of a girl from the "Ocean Club".

===

If this statement is a strictly correct recollection of the conversation, then it would be more interesting if RM was not at the OC after Madeleine was found to be missing, i.e the witnesses that saw him there were mistaken.

I do not believe JM or RM would have been aware of the statement made by Maria Pires.

So you heAr police sirens in your road
A sleepy quiet road
And you don't go out and ask what is going on
Of course you do
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Innominate on May 11, 2017, 01:23:34 PM
Quote
So you heAr police sirens in your road
A sleepy quiet road
And you don't go out and ask what is going on
Of course you do

Precisely, which is why, in my opinion, it would be far more interesting if RM did not go out to see what is going on.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: misty on May 11, 2017, 01:47:56 PM
Would it be common-place for the GNR to use the siren at 2300hrs when the roads were quiet - surely warning lights would have been sufficient?
I also cannot recall any other witnesses referring to the sound of sirens nearby, prompting them to look out or venture onto the streets.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Innominate on May 11, 2017, 02:00:36 PM
Quote
Would it be common-place for the GNR to use the siren at 2300hrs when the roads were quiet - surely warning lights would have been sufficient?
I also cannot recall any other witnesses referring to the sound of sirens nearby, prompting them to look out or venture onto the streets.

Again this is an interesting question. I seem to remember some questions being asked in the interviews about whether the tone of the siren was continuous or intermittent.

Personally, I would have liked the investigators to have produced a summary list of all the emergency service call outs to that area from 9pm to 12pm.

How can it be guaranteed that the siren referred to by JM is not another emergency vehicle responding to a different event? That may explain the time discrepancy.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: misty on May 11, 2017, 02:21:26 PM
Again this is an interesting question. I seem to remember some questions being asked in the interviews about whether the tone of the siren was continuous or intermittent.

Personally, I would have liked the investigators to have produced a summary list of all the emergency service call outs to that area from 9pm to 12pm.

How can it be guaranteed that the siren referred to by JM is not another emergency vehicle responding to a different event? That may explain the time discrepancy.

Do you have links to any questions about the tone frequency of the sirens, please?
What evidence is there that any Portuguese emergency vehicles use their sirens late at night in quiet residential areas?
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Innominate on May 11, 2017, 03:09:28 PM
Quote
Do you have links to any questions about the tone frequency of the sirens, please?

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/ROBERT-MURAT.htm

He was home with his mother, when at 22:30 or a little later, he heard a siren of an ambulance or police. He commented on that with his mother, however, did not leave the house to investigate. He did not leave again until the morning, having gone to bed around midnight.

---- Questioned he says that when he heard the sound of a siren he was with his mother in the kitchen, still talking, it would be about 22:00/22:30, the time he estimates taking into account that they had the television on. Questioned he said not to recall if the sound was continuous or discontinuous. He remembers only that at that time there was the sound of voices from both their talk and the sound of television, not recalling other sounds in the background. He remembers well having heard that sound given that after it he commented to his mother that it seemed that he was in her house in England given that there he assiduously heard the sound of sirens. He was not aware of other noises namely raised voices or the dogs barking outside the property.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JENNIFER-MURAT.htm

--- Asked, she explains that while they were talking in the kitchen, she is not able to say when, she recalls having heard a siren ringing at least once. Although not usual, she also did not "connect" because it could possibly have been an ambulance.(She recalls that sometimes, when the wind blows in a certain direction, it is possible to hear in the house sirens of police cars or ambulances that pass on the EN125).

Quote
What evidence is there that any Portuguese emergency vehicles use their sirens late at night in quiet residential areas?

I have no evidence on that question. It is my opinion that a list of which emergency vehicles were despatched in the area (or passing EN125) between 9pm and 12pm, and whether they were sounding sirens would have been helpful.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: jassi on May 11, 2017, 03:13:20 PM
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/ROBERT-MURAT.htm

He was home with his mother, when at 22:30 or a little later, he heard a siren of an ambulance or police. He commented on that with his mother, however, did not leave the house to investigate. He did not leave again until the morning, having gone to bed around midnight.

---- Questioned he says that when he heard the sound of a siren he was with his mother in the kitchen, still talking, it would be about 22:00/22:30, the time he estimates taking into account that they had the television on. Questioned he said not to recall if the sound was continuous or discontinuous. He remembers only that at that time there was the sound of voices from both their talk and the sound of television, not recalling other sounds in the background. He remembers well having heard that sound given that after it he commented to his mother that it seemed that he was in her house in England given that there he assiduously heard the sound of sirens. He was not aware of other noises namely raised voices or the dogs barking outside the property.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JENNIFER-MURAT.htm

--- Asked, she explains that while they were talking in the kitchen, she is not able to say when, she recalls having heard a siren ringing at least once. Although not usual, she also did not "connect" because it could possibly have been an ambulance.(She recalls that sometimes, when the wind blows in a certain direction, it is possible to hear in the house sirens of police cars or ambulances that pass on the EN125).

I have no evidence on that question. It is my opinion that a list of which emergency vehicles were despatched in the area (or passing EN125) between 9pm and 12pm, and whether they were sounding sirens would have been helpful.

Helpful to whom?
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on May 11, 2017, 03:49:01 PM
Again this is an interesting question. I seem to remember some questions being asked in the interviews about whether the tone of the siren was continuous or intermittent.

Personally, I would have liked the investigators to have produced a summary list of all the emergency service call outs to that area from 9pm to 12pm.

How can it be guaranteed that the siren referred to by JM is not another emergency vehicle responding to a different event? That may explain the time discrepancy.
Depending on the wind, one can hear sirens on the N125.  The junctions had traffic lights in 2007, and it was standard practice then to switch on sirens to enable emergency vehicles to run the lights.

Ambulances within Luz normally use sirens, presumably to allow them to speed.

Unless a police siren was very close to Casa Liliana, there is no reason to believe anyone would go out to gawp.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: misty on May 11, 2017, 03:53:44 PM
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/ROBERT-MURAT.htm

He was home with his mother, when at 22:30 or a little later, he heard a siren of an ambulance or police. He commented on that with his mother, however, did not leave the house to investigate. He did not leave again until the morning, having gone to bed around midnight.

---- Questioned he says that when he heard the sound of a siren he was with his mother in the kitchen, still talking, it would be about 22:00/22:30, the time he estimates taking into account that they had the television on. Questioned he said not to recall if the sound was continuous or discontinuous. He remembers only that at that time there was the sound of voices from both their talk and the sound of television, not recalling other sounds in the background. He remembers well having heard that sound given that after it he commented to his mother that it seemed that he was in her house in England given that there he assiduously heard the sound of sirens. He was not aware of other noises namely raised voices or the dogs barking outside the property.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JENNIFER-MURAT.htm

--- Asked, she explains that while they were talking in the kitchen, she is not able to say when, she recalls having heard a siren ringing at least once. Although not usual, she also did not "connect" because it could possibly have been an ambulance.(She recalls that sometimes, when the wind blows in a certain direction, it is possible to hear in the house sirens of police cars or ambulances that pass on the EN125).

I have no evidence on that question. It is my opinion that a list of which emergency vehicles were despatched in the area (or passing EN125) between 9pm and 12pm, and whether they were sounding sirens would have been helpful.

Ah, I was hoping for questions to folk other than the Murats. Given the proximity of the EN125 to their residence it is probable the sound of sirens on that road would have been audible in the home - but questionable if windows were closed, TV was on & people were talking.
Does the list of 112 calls in the files not cover all the emergencies that night?
For my part, I wouldn't call into question too much why RM didn't venture outside if sirens were heard passing nearby. Neither of the Murats could look out through a window to see what may have been going on, due to the thick foliage & high gates on their boundary. I am just surprised their dogs didn't make any noise, given all the unusual activity outside. 
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on May 11, 2017, 04:00:53 PM
Do you have links to any questions about the tone frequency of the sirens, please?
What evidence is there that any Portuguese emergency vehicles use their sirens late at night in quiet residential areas?
We have had a single instance, when an emergency call was required to get an ambulance to our villa well after dark.

Something the size of the Starship Enterprise turned up, sirens blaring and a very impressive array of flashing lights.  It repeated this process when it sped off towards Portimão hospital.

None of our neighbours checked what was going on.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Innominate on May 11, 2017, 04:27:08 PM
Quote
Ah, I was hoping for questions to folk other than the Murats. Given the proximity of the EN125 to their residence it is probable the sound of sirens on that road would have been audible in the home - but questionable if windows were closed, TV was on & people were talking.
Does the list of 112 calls in the files not cover all the emergencies that night?
For my part, I wouldn't call into question too much why RM didn't venture outside if sirens were heard passing nearby. Neither of the Murats could look out through a window to see what may have been going on, due to the thick foliage & high gates on their boundary. I am just surprised their dogs didn't make any noise, given all the unusual activity outside. 

As it happens I actually believe that RM was at home after the sirens were heard and, therefore, he was being truthful when he states he was not at the OC that night. There are statements from people who knew him who said they did not see him there.

The journalist statement is a contradiction, but it is not clear that much weight can be placed on it.

My overall impression is that there is not much evidence in the PJ files against anyone, although some of the alibis could be stronger.

It will be interesting to see whether Operation Grange produces a firm result.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: jassi on May 11, 2017, 04:34:07 PM
A weak alibi is not  an indication of guilt
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: Innominate on May 11, 2017, 05:13:35 PM
Quote
A weak alibi is not  an indication of guilt

I don't think I ever said it was.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: ferryman on May 11, 2017, 05:19:58 PM
One key point, of course, is that -- whether out or in -- Robert Murat was, lawfully and legally, entitled to be out.
Title: Re: Robert Murat and the challenges to his alibi.
Post by: misty on August 24, 2017, 01:40:05 PM
Is that a bell the journalist appears to be ringing at the gate of Casa Liliana which prompted Jenny to open the gate? If so, why had no-one from the search teams called at the Murats to search their grounds either overnight or prior to RM arriving on the scene to offer his services?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=igAhToRRRfE