Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: pathfinder73 on June 22, 2014, 02:19:02 AM
Title: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: pathfinder73 on June 22, 2014, 02:19:02 AM
If they took a lie detector this case would be finished tomorrow instead of wasting millions.
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: VIXTE on June 22, 2014, 02:28:23 AM
If they took a lie detector this case would be finished tomorrow instead of wasting millions.
What you are talking about? The polygraphs are only around 65 or even 50% reliable, ie. not reliable. All pathological liars would pass the polygraph test, and innocent people would often fail it. http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-human-beast/201303/do-lie-detectors-work
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: pathfinder73 on June 22, 2014, 02:35:04 AM
What you are talking about? The polygraphs are only around 65 or even 50% reliable, ie. not reliable. All pathological liars would pass the polygraph test, and innocent people would often fail it. http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-human-beast/201303/do-lie-detectors-work
Well they should take it if it's so easy to pass.
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: VIXTE on June 22, 2014, 02:39:48 AM
But why? It is not accurate, not valuable. I personally would never accept taking it except for a fun.
If you're guilty you won't take one. If you're nervous about any pact of covering up timelines and checks but not knowing what really happened to Madeleine then that should also be revealed. A lie detector scares the liars and they will refuse to take it.
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Eleanor on June 22, 2014, 08:52:28 AM
If you're guilty you won't take one. If you're nervous about any pact of covering up timelines and checks but not knowing what really happened to Madeleine then that should also be revealed. A lie detector scares the liars and they will refuse to take it.
Lie Detector Tests are not admissible in Court, so what is the point.?
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: stephen25000 on June 22, 2014, 08:55:17 AM
Lie Detector Tests are not admissible in Court, so what is the point.?
So why after saying they would, did they back out ?
Could it be they would have been caught out ?
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 22, 2014, 09:02:04 AM
Lie detector tests are unreliable..thats why they are not admissible. Anyone who thinks they would be of any use here is showing how little they understand how things really work
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: stephen25000 on June 22, 2014, 09:07:22 AM
Lie detector tests are unreliable..thats why they are not admissible. Anyone who thinks they would be of any use here is showing how little they understand how things really work
Ah, yet again, so it never works when the mccanns are involved. @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Benice on June 22, 2014, 09:09:11 AM
If you're guilty you won't take one. If you're nervous about any pact of covering up timelines and checks but not knowing what really happened to Madeleine then that should also be revealed. A lie detector scares the liars and they will refuse to take it.
There would be no point in the McCanns taking a polygraph test imo.
If they failed it - their supporters would be out in force pointing out the proven unreliability of this test - and if they passed it - the sceptics would be out in force pointing out the proven unreliability of this test.
Therefore a complete waste of time.
With regard to the recon. I would still like to know how the recon as described and required by the PJ could be achieved.:-
Quote The PJ is trying to find out, with accuracy, the circumstances of the events occurred, using for that purpose the exact place of events and the same persons who took part in it. unquote
How can you demand accuracy and exactitude of times and events from a group of people who have already clearly stated that they do not know the exact times of their movements and so 'accuracy' is the very thing they cannot guarantee?
For instance:-
The PJ ask Jez to set out on his walk at the exact time he did on the 3rd May the year before. Jez says..... 'But I don't know the exact time. I can take a stab at it, but what if I'm wrong and I end up missing Gerry completely?''
Where do the PJ go from there???
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 22, 2014, 09:09:49 AM
Ah, yet again, so it never works when the mccanns are involved. @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*
You are making afool of yourself agin...something you are getting quite expert in..every intelligent person knows lie detectors are unreliable. I heard a case on the radio yesterday where a suspect passed a test and was eventually found guilty....probably be in the papers today
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 22, 2014, 09:11:26 AM
There would be no point in the McCanns taking a polygraph test imo.
If they failed it - their supporters would be out in force pointing out the proven unreliability of this test - and if they passed it - the sceptics would be out in force pointing out the proven unreliability of this test.
Therefore a complete waste of time.
With regard to the recon. I would still like to know how the recon as described and required by the PJ could be achieved.:-
Quote The PJ is trying to find out, with accuracy, the circumstances of the events occurred, using for that purpose the exact place of events and the same persons who took part in it. unquote
How can you demand accuracy and exactitude of times and events from a group of people who have already clearly stated that they do not know the exact times of their movements and so 'accuracy' is the very thing they cannot guarantee?
For instance:-
The PJ ask Jez to set out on his walk at the exact time he did on the 3rd May the year before. Jez says..... 'But I don't know the exact time. I can take a stab at it, but what if I'm wrong and I end up missing Gerry completely?''
Where do the PJ go from there???
I totally agree...this has all been discussed before but seem to have the memory of a goldfish so we end up discussing the same points over and over again...lie detectors...unreliable...fact
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: stephen25000 on June 22, 2014, 09:26:07 AM
Would you care to give the statistics on their use ?
Why would the mccanns first say they would, and then back out ?
As so called 'intelligent people' wouldn't they know that in the first place ?
Or did the media manipulator otherwise known as Clarence Mitchell make them change their mind ?
Let's face it, Mitchell got a lot of experience in the Blair era, in becoming economical with the truth. I'm sure you will agree.
From the American Pschologist Association....Polygraph testing has generated considerable scientific and public controversy. Most psychologists and other scientists agree that there is little basis for the validity of polygraph tests. Courts, including the United States Supreme Court (cf. U.S. v. Scheffer, 1998 in which Dr.'s Saxe's research on polygraph fallibility was cited), have repeatedly rejected the use of polygraph evidence because of its inherent unreliability.
Of course you can quote the Jeremy Kyle Show in your defence
@)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Eleanor on June 22, 2014, 09:30:26 AM
Who are these 'intelligent persons' who know lie detectors are unreliable ?
Ah yes, MCCANN SUPPORTERS. 8((()*/
As to making a fool of themselves dave, you continue to excel in that area.
Please carry on. 8(0(*
Lie Detector Tests are not even allowed in court in America where they seem to spend an inordinate amount of money doing them. Nor is anyone deemed guilty if they refuse. It is often used as a form of blackmail wherein distraught parents feel forced to take them under stress.
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 22, 2014, 09:30:51 AM
From the American Pschologist Association....Polygraph testing has generated considerable scientific and public controversy. Most psychologists and other scientists agree that there is little basis for the validity of polygraph tests. Courts, including the United States Supreme Court (cf. U.S. v. Scheffer, 1998 in which Dr.'s Saxe's research on polygraph fallibility was cited), have repeatedly rejected the use of polygraph evidence because of its inherent unreliability.
Of course you can quote the Jeremy Kyle Show in your defence
@)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(* @)(++(*
I wasn't going to mention Jeremy Kyle, though I understand that would be your type of viewing.
http://polygraphs.co.uk/lie-detector-testing.html
You are clearly hell bent on dismissing anything the mccanns agreed to and then backed out of.
Mmm.
Why is that ?
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 22, 2014, 09:38:42 AM
I wasn't going to mention Jeremy Kyle, though I understand that would be your type of viewing.
http://polygraphs.co.uk/lie-detector-testing.html
You are clearly hell bent on dismissing anything the mccanns agreed to and then backed out of.
Mmm.
Why is that ?
The site you have quoted is a commercial site whose business it is to conduct lie detector tests...do you see where I am going...its like the tobacco companies telling you smoking is not harmful..
Your problem and that of others on this site is that you do not understand how to assess evidence...
The ability to assess evidence...which you have just shown you do not have...is an important factor in arriving at the truth..
That's why you and others have got so much wrong... I wont be replying to your next post so don't bother
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: stephen25000 on June 22, 2014, 09:44:13 AM
The site you have quoted is a commercial site whose business it is to conduct lie detector tests...do you see where I am going...its like the tobacco companies telling you smoking is not harmful..
Your problem and that of others on this site is that you do not understand how to assess evidence...
The ability to assess evidence...which you have just shown you do not have...is an important factor in arriving at the truth..
That's why you and others have got so much wrong... I wont be replying to your next post so don't bother
Utter rubbish.
How can you compare lie detectors to tobacco firms.
If the lie detector companies did not have a system which worked, they would be out of business, and you know that.
and the reason tobacco companies still exist, as with alcohol manufacturers, is that they bring in hefty TAX REVENUES, and you know that as well.
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Eleanor on June 22, 2014, 09:52:47 AM
How can you compare lie detectors to tobacco firms.
If the lie detector companies did not have a system which worked, they would be out of business, and you know that.
and the reason tobacco companies still exist, as with alcohol manufacturers, is that they bring in hefty TAX REVENUES, and you know that as well.
Lie Detector Tests are used as a form of blackmail against distraught parents when they are suffering serious stress, and possibly guilt for some imagined failure on their part.
These companies don't do them free gratis. They make money.
It would be interesting to know how much they do charge.
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 22, 2014, 09:55:00 AM
Then gullible people such as you who believe in the mccanns.
Now that is an aporopriate analogy.
So why are lie detectors used all over thevworld if they are so unreliable ?
IMO In the same league as those PJ policemen (yes policemen!!) who actually believed that a 'dream' by a witness was a credible reason to change the whole course of a case.
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 22, 2014, 10:21:48 AM
Then gullible people such as you who believe in the mccanns.
Now that is an aporopriate analogy.
So why are lie detectors used all over thevworld if they are so unreliable ?
so you disagree with the American Psychologist Association..you are right and they are wrong...not accepted in courts as evidence...you are right and the courts are wrong...do you realise how stupid you sound
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Eleanor on June 22, 2014, 10:24:20 AM
Then gullible people such as you who believe in the mccanns.
Now that is an aporopriate analogy.
So why are lie detectors used all over thevworld if they are so unreliable ?
They hope to trap people. They certainly don't use them to establish innocence. Waste of money, if you ask me. They can't be used in Court. Why is that I wonder?
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: jassi on June 22, 2014, 11:42:01 AM
Why should anyone dream about her at all, other than her family and their close acquaintances ?
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Alfred R Jones on June 22, 2014, 11:47:01 AM
Why should anyone dream about her at all, other than her family and their close acquaintances ?
WHo knows? Some people dream about her parents being banged up and then spend all day, every day hoping for their dreams to come true - equally bizarre in my view.
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Eleanor on June 22, 2014, 11:47:23 AM
so you disagree with the American Psychologist Association..you are right and they are wrong...not accepted in courts as evidence...you are right and the courts are wrong...do you realise how stupid you sound
It would probably better using body language. Psychologist seem a lot more in favour of that.
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: stephen25000 on June 22, 2014, 01:56:46 PM
so you disagree with the American Psychologist Association..you are right and they are wrong...not accepted in courts as evidence...you are right and the courts are wrong...do you realise how stupid you sound
'do you realise how stupid you sound'
Now what did you say when you said you weren't criticizing posters intelligence ?
Or is this yet another example of the limitations of your short term memory ?
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 22, 2014, 02:27:28 PM
[ quote removed ]
We have all told lies in our lives.....didn't go to work and have said we are unwell...but we are not all idiots
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: slartibartfast on June 23, 2014, 03:42:59 AM
Telling white lies are often for 'diplomatic' reasons or a desire not to hurt someone's feeling. Have you never done that?
Everybody has. And anyone who say they haven't is a liar. Allegedly.
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Mr Moderator on June 23, 2014, 12:41:02 PM
The polygraph is a fraud which seeks to work on the subjects insecurities. The Adrian Prout case is often mentioned as an example of how a polygraph can be successful, Prout failed the test and admitted his guilt. He could have failed the test and just as easily claimed innocence.
This forum has offered an open challenge to any polygraph operators to a test to prove their worth but none have seen fit to accept. The polygraph is itself a fraud!
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: stephen25000 on June 23, 2014, 12:52:00 PM
The polygraph is a fraud which seeks to work on the subjects insecurities. The Adrian Prout case is often mentioned as an example of how a polygraph can be successful, Prout failed the test and admitted his guilt. He could have failed the test and just as easily claimed innocence.
This forum has offered an open challenge to any polygraph operators to a test to prove their worth but none have seen fit to accept. The polygraph is itself a fraud!
What kind of test, and where would you test it?
and when was the challenge issued ?
What are the statistics exactly on the success/failure of polygraph tests ?
Also , when a subject under such a test, it will be invariably under some form of strain.
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Mr Moderator on June 23, 2014, 12:57:47 PM
What are the statistics exactly on the success/failure of polygraph tests ?
Also , when a subject under such a test, it will be invariably under some form of strain.
We promoted the challenge via our sister site on twitter some time ago but as suspected none of the UK operators felt confident enough to respond. The science behind the polygraph has not advanced sufficiently for it to be taken seriously.
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: stephen25000 on June 23, 2014, 01:10:34 PM
We promoted the challenge via our sister site on twitter some time ago but as suspected none of the UK operators felt confident enough to respond. The science behind the polygraph has not advanced sufficiently for it to be taken seriously.
No system is full-proof.
So why are they still employed worldwide if they are so unreliable ?
Have you contacted any Police Authorities, Psychologists to get another opinion ?
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Carana on June 23, 2014, 01:22:37 PM
If you're guilty you won't take one. If you're nervous about any pact of covering up timelines and checks but not knowing what really happened to Madeleine then that should also be revealed. A lie detector scares the liars and they will refuse to take it.
Did the PJ ever request them to take one?
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: slartibartfast on June 23, 2014, 01:30:23 PM
Would you care to give the statistics on their use ?
Why would the mccanns first say they would, and then back out ?
As so called 'intelligent people' wouldn't they know that in the first place ?
Or did the media manipulator otherwise known as Clarence Mitchell make them change their mind ?
Let's face it, Mitchell got a lot of experience in the Blair era, in becoming economical with the truth. I'm sure you will agree.
No one can agree on how effective lie detectors are (and they don't actually detect lies, just changes in heart-rate and other body functions) - most non-biased sources put their accuracy at less than 65%.http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-human-beast/201303/do-lie-detectors-work
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Brietta on June 23, 2014, 07:18:34 PM
It seems the Madeleine McCann case is seen as a day time television entertainment by some.
Portuguese courts do not recognise polygraph ‘evidence’.
Courts in the United Kingdom do not recognise polygraph ‘evidence’. So just a total irrelevance.
I believe shows such as Jeremy Kyle's set great store by them.
Join ITV's Jeremy Kyle for the latest family feuds, confrontations and reconciliations. Plus lie detector tests, DNA results and more from behind the scenes www.itv.com/jeremykyle
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: stephen25000 on June 23, 2014, 07:37:10 PM
Read through the other links and all the other companies using them.
Try getting this.
Lie detectors are used all over the world.
8(0(*
and everyone in the world..including the links you have provided understand they are not reliable...apart from you of cousrse
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: John on June 24, 2014, 10:25:03 AM
The Truth About The Lie Detector
Lie detector tests have become a popular cultural icon - from crime dramas to comedies to advertisements - the picture of a polygraph pen wildly gyrating on a moving chart is readily recognized symbol. But, as psychologist Leonard Saxe, PhD, (1991) has argued, the idea that we can detect a person's veracity by monitoring psychophysiological changes is more myth than reality. Even the term "lie detector," used to refer to polygraph testing, is a misnomer. So-called "lie detection" involves inferring deception through analysis of physiological responses to a structured, but unstandardized, series of questions.
Lie detector tests have become a popular cultural icon - from crime dramas to comedies to advertisements - the picture of a polygraph pen wildly gyrating on a moving chart is readily recognized symbol. But, as psychologist Leonard Saxe, PhD, (1991) has argued, the idea that we can detect a person's veracity by monitoring psychophysiological changes is more myth than reality. Even the term "lie detector," used to refer to polygraph testing, is a misnomer. So-called "lie detection" involves inferring deception through analysis of physiological responses to a structured, but unstandardized, series of questions.
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Lace on June 24, 2014, 11:07:36 AM
I watched a 'Real Crime' programme the other night and the mother in the case of her missing child took the test and failed. Yet it had nothing at all to do with her, it just sent the investigation off the rails.
The thing is this Lie Detector test or what ever they call it, tests on the bodies reaction to stress or nervousness.
They say they ask questions such as 'what is your name' to see the reaction on the screen so that they can compare the reaction to the other questions. This simple question' What is your name' shouldn't make the person anxious or nervous in any way as it is a straight forward question with no baring on what the person is being accused of, so they can judge how nervous this person is to start with.
So when the question 'did you kill your daughter' comes up, if the person is guilty, the needle should shoot up.
Well, I'm sorry, even if I had nothing to do with the death of my child, the question ' did you kill your daughter' would still make me stressed, even the thought that my daughter could have been killed would be enough.
So I really do not see how this test can be 100% accurate, as the results of that Crime story I watched showed.
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: stephen25000 on June 24, 2014, 11:11:36 AM
I watched a 'Real Crime' programme the other night and the mother in the case of her missing child took the test and failed. Yet it had nothing at all to do with her, it just sent the investigation off the rails.
The thing is this Lie Detector test or what ever they call it, tests on the bodies reaction to stress or nervousness.
They say they ask questions such as 'what is your name' to see the reaction on the screen so that they can compare the reaction to the other questions. This simple question' What is your name' shouldn't make the person anxious or nervous in any way as it is a straight forward question with no baring on what the person is being accused of, so they can judge how nervous this person is to start with.
So when the question 'did you kill your daughter' comes up, if the person is guilty, the needle should shoot up.
Well, I'm sorry, even if I had nothing to do with the death of my child, the question ' did you kill your daughter' would still make me stressed, even the thought that my daughter could have been killed would be enough.
So I really do not see how this test can be 100% accurate, as the results of that Crime story I watched showed.
So why did the mccanns say they would take one, before they withdrew ?
Is it rather like what gerry mccann said, when he stated 'dogs are unreliable' in his interview with Sandra ?
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: Lace on June 24, 2014, 11:29:27 AM
According to Gerry they didn't have one in Portugal.
So did they really say they would take one?
Title: Re: The Polygraph or Lie Detector is a FRAUD!
Post by: pathfinder73 on June 24, 2014, 12:17:20 PM