UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: pathfinder73 on July 19, 2014, 02:09:38 PM
-
"He found the parents to be nervous and anxious, he did not see any tears from either of them although they produced noises identical to crying." José María Batista Roque - GNR Officer
(http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/zz0505d.jpg)
THURSDAY, MAY 3: Milk and biscuits for the kids. I left them with this and books and games and went to have a quick shower/wash my hair.
"Gerry took her documents and showed them to the third person and told him that they were authentic and were certified by the police.
At this moment, the third person, who was always near to the couple and the witness, moved the couple away from her and the three of them talked in whispers for some time.
After this, and leaving the couple behind him, he approached the witness and told her that the couple did not want to speak any more with her, nor with anyone else.
As she said earlier, this third person of the group is familiar to her, and thinks that she may have come across him in the course of her work, as a suspect or witness." (YM - worked for 25 years in the area of child protection - Profession: Social Services and Child Protection)
The third man and his visit will be investigated. About time SY got their skates on. Investigation from 5:30 not 8:30.
-
"He found the parents to be nervous and anxious, he did not see any tears from either of them although they produced noises identical to crying." José María Batista Roque - GNR Officer
(http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/zz0505d.jpg)
THURSDAY, MAY 3: Milk and biscuits for the kids. I left them with this and books and games and went to have a quick shower/wash my hair.
"Gerry took her documents and showed them to the third person and told him that they were authentic and were certified by the police.
At this moment, the third person, who was always near to the couple and the witness, moved the couple away from her and the three of them talked in whispers for some time.
After this, and leaving the couple behind him, he approached the witness and told her that the couple did not want to speak any more with her, nor with anyone else.
As she said earlier, this third person of the group is familiar to her, and thinks that she may have come across him in the course of her work, as a suspect or witness." (YM - worked for 25 years in the area of child protection - Profession: Social Services and Child Protection)
The third man and his visit will be investigated. About time SY got their skates on. Investigation from 5:30 not 8:30.
Apart from being the author of an anonymous letter to the police ... what on earth did this woman think she was doing?...
- Because she found it strange that Kate told her that her daughter had been taken by a couple, she tried to separate her from the other two individuals so that she could speak to her with more privacy, suggesting to Kate that they (Y and K) should enter the apartment, Kate aggressively rejected this idea and told her that they could speak on the street. http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
HOW DARE SHE! ... she was a complete stranger and imo has proved she is exactly the type of person from whom victims of crime ought to be protected.
-
Apart from being the author of an anonymous letter to the police ... what on earth did this woman think she was doing?...
- Because she found it strange that Kate told her that her daughter had been taken by a couple, she tried to separate her from the other two individuals so that she could speak to her with more privacy, suggesting to Kate that they (Y and K) should enter the apartment, Kate aggressively rejected this idea and told her that they could speak on the street. http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
HOW DARE SHE! ... she was a complete stranger and imo has proved she is exactly the type of person from whom victims of crime ought to be protected.
I think it reasonable to infer that PJ Inspector Fereria (sp?) who interviewed her concluded much the same ...
-
Apart from being the author of an anonymous letter to the police ... what on earth did this woman think she was doing?...
- Because she found it strange that Kate told her that her daughter had been taken by a couple, she tried to separate her from the other two individuals so that she could speak to her with more privacy, suggesting to Kate that they (Y and K) should enter the apartment, Kate aggressively rejected this idea and told her that they could speak on the street. http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
HOW DARE SHE! ... she was a complete stranger and imo has proved she is exactly the type of person from whom victims of crime ought to be protected.
Maybe it was because she was a professional who happened to be on hand and was trying to help?
-
Maybe it was because she was a professional who happened to be on hand and was trying to help?
Trying to solve the crime, by all accounts ...
-
Maybe it was because she was a professional who happened to be on hand and was trying to help?
Then her behaviour was most unprofessional both in her attitude at the event and afterwards.
-
Trying to solve the crime, by all accounts ...
I was under the assumption that was the job of the PJ ... what locus did that person have in 'trying to solve the crime'?
-
I was under the assumption that was the job of the PJ ... what locus did that person have in 'trying to solve the crime'?
Me too.
No locus and no authority.
But she was quite convinced she knew who dunnit ...
The concluding remark of PJ Inspector Ferreira:
The statements given to the PJ today by Yvonne Martin provide a concrete clarification of the reasons for her suspicions, which in my opinion, do not point to any concrete element that could, in any way, make other inquiries directly related to her statements, viable.
-
Me too.
No locus and no authority.
But she was quite convinced she knew who dunnit ...
The concluding remark of PJ Inspector Ferreira:
The statements given to the PJ today by Yvonne Martin provide a concrete clarification of the reasons for her suspicions, which in my opinion, do not point to any concrete element that could, in any way, make other inquiries directly related to her statements, viable.
Another expert rubbished?
-
Another expert rubbished?
a run of the mill social worker described as an expert
-
Another expert rubbished?
More another rubbish "expert", I would say ...
-
Another expert rubbished?
As ferryman has pointed out PJ Inspector Ferreira indicated very clearly what he thought about her 'expertise'.
-
Another expert rubbished?
Who's claiming she's an expert?
-
As ferryman has pointed out PJ Inspector Ferreira indicated very clearly what he thought about her 'expertise'.
The officer said nothing about how 'expert' she was but merely that her suspicions had given them nothing concrete to work on.
-
When you're acting defensive in a situation like that it is always suspicious. Anyone who has lost a child would ask and accept anyone's help to find her. But the third man intervened. Why? These 3 have never been properly investigated - SY sort your head out! They contradict each other so much that it can't be truth. An experienced (25 years) child protection officer trying to help when the father said that a paedo gang had taken her. But they don't want her help - acting DEFENSIVE just like the dog alerts >@@(*&)
-
When you're acting defensive in a situation like that it is always suspicious. Anyone who has lost a child would ask and accept anyone's help to find her. But the third man intervened. Why? These 3 have never been properly investigated - SY sort your head out! They contradict each other so much that it can't be truth. An experienced (25 years) child protection officer trying to help when the father said that a paedo gang had taken her. But they don't want her help - acting DEFENSIVE just like the dog alerts >@@(*&)
Yes the Algarve was full of incompetents - the entire GNR, the entire PJ, all MW staff, all OC staff, and now YM, all bumbling, interfering, useless. Seems the only true experts in this whole case, whose professionalism stands out like a shaft of gold when all around is darkness, were a small group of foreign pioneering specialists in remote toddler and baby care.
-
Yes the Algarve was full of incompetents - the entire GNR, the entire PJ, all MW staff, all OC staff, and now YM, all bumbling, interfering, useless. Seems the only true experts in this whole case, whose professionalism stands out like a shaft of gold when all around is darkness, were a small group of foreign pioneering specialists in remote toddler and baby care.
The only incompetents at the present time are the detectives working on this case - looking for drivers when the prime suspect is getting away on foot with the missing child 8-)(--) They're many top detectives (yet to be seen!) so it's about time they got their fingers out and started doing real investigation work and getting to the heart of the matter instead of beating around the bush (pardon the pun!). But I have faith they're trying to be smarter than smartass 8)--))
-
The only incompetents at the present time are the detectives working on this case - looking for drivers when the prime suspect is getting away on foot with the missing child 8-)(--) They're many top detectives (yet to be seen!) so it's about time they got their fingers out and started doing real investigation work and getting to the heart of the matter instead of beating around the bush (pardon the pun!). But I have faith they're trying to be smarter than smartass 8)--))
Getting away on foot maybe but I think you have tooootally the wrong time for it and the totally wrong method too.
-
Getting away on foot maybe but I think you have tooootally the wrong time for it and the totally wrong method too.
Smithman did it 100%! Everything connects with him - why when how! Where he hid the body is the hard part but that's why the dogs are back.
-
When you're acting defensive in a situation like that it is always suspicious. Anyone who has lost a child would ask and accept anyone's help to find her. But the third man intervened. Why? These 3 have never been properly investigated - SY sort your head out! They contradict each other so much that it can't be truth. An experienced (25 years) child protection officer trying to help when the father said that a paedo gang had taken her. But they don't want her help - acting DEFENSIVE just like the dog alerts >@@(*&)
What makes you think 'these 3'' have never been properly investigated? That's a preposterous suggestion IMO.
IIRC Yvonne Martin was a stranger off the street who turned up and even though she could see how distraught Kate was - started bombarding her with intrusive questions. When she was asked to leave she strongly resisted and eventually they had to insist that she left. She then went off to Reception to ask more questions. IMO she was more of a busybody than anything else.
It seems to me her ego was dented - hence the anonymous letter re David Payne, who was the person who asked her to leave.
The only contribution she has made to the case IMO - is that she confirmed what a dreadful state Kate was in that morning (crying intensely) - even asking if a doctor had seen her - which directly contradicts the claims made by some sceptics that Kate and Gerry blythely went off for a jog along the beach that morning - as if nothing serious had happened.
What has YM contributed apart from that?? Well - she said that she thought she remembered David Payne's face from somewhere. To date she has not remembered from where. And that's it.
I've got no time for people who send anonymous letters - that's not how professonal people behave IMO.
-
What makes you think 'these 3'' have never been properly investigated? That's a preposterous suggestion IMO.
IIRC Yvonne Martin was a stranger off the street who turned up and even though she could see how distraught Kate was - started bombarding her with intrusive questions. When she was asked to leave she strongly resisted and eventually they had to insist that she left. She then went off to Reception to ask more questions. IMO she was more of a busybody than anything else.
It seems to me her ego was dented - hence the anonymous letter re David Payne, who was the person who asked her to leave.
The only contribution she has made to the case IMO - is that she confirmed what a dreadful state Kate was in that morning (crying intensely) - even asking if a doctor had seen her - which directly contradicts the claims made by some sceptics that Kate and Gerry blythely went off for a jog along the beach that morning - as if nothing serious had happened.
What has YM contributed apart from that?? Well - she said that she thought she remembered David Payne's face from somewhere. To date she has not remembered from where. And that's it.
I've got no time for people who send anonymous letters - that's not how professonal people behave IMO.
Interesting statement though. She says KM says checks every hour...missing for 13 hours at 10am.
-
What makes you think 'these 3'' have never been properly investigated? That's a preposterous suggestion IMO.
IIRC Yvonne Martin was a stranger off the street who turned up and even though she could see how distraught Kate was - started bombarding her with intrusive questions. When she was asked to leave she strongly resisted and eventually they had to insist that she left. She then went off to Reception to ask more questions. IMO she was more of a busybody than anything else.
It seems to me her ego was dented - hence the anonymous letter re David Payne, who was the person who asked her to leave.
The only contribution she has made to the case IMO - is that she confirmed what a dreadful state Kate was in that morning (crying intensely) - even asking if a doctor had seen her - which directly contradicts the claims made by some sceptics that Kate and Gerry blythely went off for a jog along the beach that morning - as if nothing serious had happened.
What has YM contributed apart from that?? Well - she said that she thought she remembered David Payne's face from somewhere. To date she has not remembered from where. And that's it.
I've got no time for people who send anonymous letters - that's not how professonal people behave IMO.
On what particular dates were they re-interviewed by SY?
-
I can't remember. But Yvonne Martin did send an anonymous letter, and admitted to having done so. Probably not one of her finer moments.
She did say that she recognised David Payne from somewhere, but has never said from where.
This was not the act of a Professional.
-
When you're acting defensive in a situation like that it is always suspicious. Anyone who has lost a child would ask and accept anyone's help to find her. But the third man intervened. Why? These 3 have never been properly investigated - SY sort your head out! They contradict each other so much that it can't be truth. An experienced (25 years) child protection officer trying to help when the father said that a paedo gang had taken her. But they don't want her help - acting DEFENSIVE just like the dog alerts >@@(*&)
When she intervened did they know she was an experienced child protection officer of 25 years standing or do you think they should have all just taken her word for it, this (to them) anonymous holiday maker?
-
When she intervened did they know she was an experienced child protection officer of 25 years standing or do you think they should have all just taken her word for it, this (to them) anonymous holiday maker?
I think Yvonne Martin did produce her "Credentials", But for heaven's sake, it was early on the morning of the 4th of May.
And I do believe, from memory, that she asked Kate if Gerry was Madeleine's father. But I need help on this one.
And believe me, Admin are not adversed to deleting my posts if my opinion offends the rules of this Forum. As indeed, they should.
-
I think Yvonne Martin did produce her "Credentials", But for heaven's sake, it was early on the morning of the 4th of May.
And I do believe, from memory, that she asked Kate if Gerry was Madeleine's father. But I need help on this one.
And believe me, Admin are not adversed to deleting my posts if my opinion offends the rules of this Forum. As indeed, they should.
Do you mean admin should delete your posts?
Or that your opinions should offend? ...
-
I think Yvonne Martin did produce her "Credentials", But for heaven's sake, it was early on the morning of the 4th of May.
And I do believe, from memory, that she asked Kate if Gerry was Madeleine's father. But I need help on this one.
And believe me, Admin are not adversed to deleting my posts if my opinion offends the rules of this Forum. As indeed, they should.
Another interesting point.
How many off-duty social workers produce their credentials?
-
Another interesting point.
How many off-duty social workers produce their credentials?
I have wondered about that myself.
It is possible that she carried some sort of professional registration documents in her wallet/handbag, rather in the way that you might carry a driving licence, or photo ID
-
Another interesting point.
How many off-duty social workers produce their credentials?
How many Off Duty, British Social Workers were Holidaying somewhere near to Praia da Luz at the time? And then hot footed to Praia da Luz by breakfast time? To poke her nose in. In My Opinion.
-
How many Off Duty, British Social Workers were Holidaying somewhere near to Praia da Luz at the time? And then hot footed to Praia da Luz by breakfast time? To poke her nose in. In My Opinion.
Or alternatively, in order to help.
The speed of it, though, suggests very rapid publication of the event for a foreign holidaymaker to hear of it so early.
-
I can't remember. But Yvonne Martin did send an anonymous letter, and admitted to having done so. Probably not one of her finer moments.
She did say that she recognised David Payne from somewhere, but has never said from where.
This was not the act of a Professional.
She [Yvonne Martin] says that about two weeks after Madeleine's disappearance, when the police made an appeal for information about a man, carrying a child, who had been seen in the Luz zone, and whose clothing was described, she wrote an anonymous letter to the British police, telling them the following: : regarding the various details she observed during her contact with the McCanns it is her opinion that they could be in some way involved in the disappearance of Madeleine.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
-
She [Yvonne Martin] says that about two weeks after Madeleine's disappearance, when the police made an appeal for information about a man, carrying a child, who had been seen in the Luz zone, and whose clothing was described, she wrote an anonymous letter to the British police, telling them the following: : regarding the various details she observed during her contact with the McCanns it is her opinion that they could be in some way involved in the disappearance of Madeleine.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
Thank you, Ferryman. That makes me feel vaguely sick. But precisely as I remember Yvonne Martin and her statements.
-
Or alternatively, in order to help.
The speed of it, though, suggests very rapid publication of the event for a foreign holidaymaker to hear of it so early.
But she wasn't just a foreign holidaymaker
Name: YVONE WARREN MARTIN
Profession: Social Services and Child Protection
The witness is accompanied by a PJ interpreter, Carlos Moura, as she does not speak Portuguese.
She says that she has lived in Portugal for seven years on a part-time basis, in other words, for some months of the year she lives in her home in Sargaçal and for the rest of the year lives in England, where she still works.
-
But she wasn't just a foreign holidaymaker
Name: YVONE WARREN MARTIN
Profession: Social Services and Child Protection
The witness is accompanied by a PJ interpreter, Carlos Moura, as she does not speak Portuguese.
She says that she has lived in Portugal for seven years on a part-time basis, in other words, for some months of the year she lives in her home in Sargaçal and for the rest of the year lives in England, where she still works.
OK. What I really meant was someone who didn't speak the language and therefore less likely to pick the news up off the TV or radio. She must have been told about it very early on.
-
She [Yvonne Martin] says that about two weeks after Madeleine's disappearance, when the police made an appeal for information about a man, carrying a child, who had been seen in the Luz zone, and whose clothing was described, she wrote an anonymous letter to the British police, telling them the following: : regarding the various details she observed during her contact with the McCanns it is her opinion that they could be in some way involved in the disappearance of Madeleine.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
And that, in a nutshell, is why her name, and professional abilities, have to be trashed.
-
OK. What I really meant was someone who didn't speak the language and therefore less likely to pick the news up off the TV or radio. She must have been told about it very early on.
By whom, do you think? And for what purpose?
-
And that, in a nutshell, is why her name, and professional abilities, have to be trashed.
Would you not think so? Anonymous letter? How utterly disgraceful.
-
Would you not think so? Anonymous letter? How utterly disgraceful.
Hardly something to get worked up over.
-
Hardly something to get worked up over.
Oh, you think that an anonymous letter from a self confessed Professional is hardly anything to get worked up about?
Nasty old women send anonymous letters because they don't want anyone to know who they are. Some bloody Professional.
Yvonne Martin damned herself when she did that.
-
Oh, you think that an anonymous letter from a self confessed Professional is hardly anything to get worked up about?
Nasty old women send anonymous letters because they don't want anyone to know who they are. Some bloody Professional.
Yvonne Martin damned herself when she did that.
You do seem to take these things to heart @)(++(*
-
You do seem to take these things to heart @)(++(*
Indeed, I do. When a self confessed Professional in the field of Child Protection start sending anonymous letters, then the whole system needs looking at. Especially when she voiced the opinion that The McCanns were likely culpable.
And if you don't see that as a problem then God help you if you ever fall under their watchful eye.
-
Indeed, I do. When a self confessed Professional in the field of Child Protection start sending anonymous letters, then the whole system needs looking at. Especially when she voiced the opinion that The McCanns were likely culpable.
And if you don't see that as a problem then God help you if you ever fall under their watchful eye.
I deal with problems as they arise and she is no problem to me. Why should she be one to you?
-
OK. What I really meant was someone who didn't speak the language and therefore less likely to pick the news up off the TV or radio. She must have been told about it very early on.
They don't just have Portuguese TV in Portugal.
During the past month of May or more precisely on the 04th of May 2007, the witness was in Portugal, enjoying holidays, when at about 07H00 she turned on the television and watched an English news channel (BBC or SKY NEWS) where she saw an appeal to British citizens on holiday in the Algarve to offer all possible support to a British couple who were on holiday in Praia da Luz and whose daughter, a child, had disappeared on May 03, 2007.
Didn't take her long to get there for 9 am. What use did she think she would be, not speaking the language.
I didn't hear them ask for an "appeal to British citizens on holiday in the Algarve to offer all possible support " that early into the abduction.
-
Yvonne Martin was and still remains a disgrace. On day one when she knew sweet feck all about anything.
I am appalled by the fact that she should so quickly have decided.
This fuelled much of what was said later.
-
Yvonne Martin was and still remains a disgrace. On day one when she knew sweet feck all about anything.
I am appalled by the fact that she should so quickly have decided.
This fuelled much of what was said later.
I thought it was all Amarals fault.
-
Yvonne Martin was and still remains a disgrace. On day one when she knew sweet feck all about anything.
I am appalled by the fact that she should so quickly have decided.
This fuelled much of what was said later.
Who the hell did she think she bloody was?
Taking advantage of the information that she had heard on the news, she began questioning the couple about how often they had checked on the children, obtaining the reply that people would go to see them every hour.
Cheeky barsteward
As is normal and routine in her service, she asked whether Gerry was the biological father of the missing child, to which he replied yes.
-
She was only trying to help.
That's why they didn't want her there.
-
As PF already pointed out.
He said something along the lines of there being Paedophile gangs in Portugal and that they had abducted Madeleine.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GRAHAM-MCKENZIE.htm
Gerry knew, apparently, that a gang of Portuguese paedophiles, no less, had abducted Madeleine.
And yet, when a woman from Child Protection turns up to help, they get rid of her.....
Absolutely nothing suspicious about that is there.
-
Yes, she was keen to help them find Madeleine, they didn't want to.
Nor did they want her asking all those pesky unhelpful & hurtful questions.
-
Look now, I am bailing out now, because I have had far too much to say already.
The opinions are all yours.. And I don't really approve of Moderators having opinions anyway. But I just get a bit carried away sometimes.
Most of the threads have been really good this last couple of days, and I am really pleased about that.
This Forum is a good place to be. Proud of that, I am. If I have had anything to do with it.
-
Nor did they want her asking all those pesky unhelpful & hurtful questions.
It wasn't her place to ask ANY questions. Funny she told them to keep silent, innit!
Meanwhile a fourth individual came towards the group and identified himself as a journalist. The witness alerted the couple to the type of statements they should give and that it would be better for them to keep silent.
-
Nor did they want her asking all those pesky unhelpful & hurtful questions.
shouldn't she have been arrested for interfering with an official police investigation
-
It wasn't her place to ask ANY questions. Funny she told them to keep silent, innit!
Meanwhile a fourth individual came towards the group and identified himself as a journalist. The witness alerted the couple to the type of statements they should give and that it would be better for them to keep silent.
Says who?
Whether or not she would get a reply is another matter.
-
Says who?
Whether or not she would get a reply is another matter.
what could she possibly achieve by asking questions?
-
shouldn't she have been arrested for interfering with an official police investigation
Yes she should have, what she did was technically illegal after all.
-
Couple of relevant posts from other thread.
I don't think Yvonne Martin had anything to offer in the way of 'help' to the McCanns that day ... she was being an officious busy-body in my opinion
Before Social workers are allocated work assignments, case-conferences are held where all known information ( usually from multiple sources ) is reveiwed and discussed
This woman just stormed in ... with no knowledge of the family or circumstances, and, more importantly, no official or sanctioned remit
I don't blame the McCanns at all for sending her off with a flea in her ear
She was out of order to impose herself on a family in that situation, I think ( without relevant information or remit )
Social Work isn't an emergency service ... it's not like a doctor, or nurse, or fireman, stepping up to the plate in desperate circumstances
She had no business interfering
-
As PF already pointed out.
He said something along the lines of there being Paedophile gangs in Portugal and that they had abducted Madeleine.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/GRAHAM-MCKENZIE.htm
Gerry knew, apparently, that a gang of Portuguese paedophiles, no less, had abducted Madeleine.
And yet, when a woman from Child Protection turns up to help, they get rid of her.....
Absolutely nothing suspicious about that is there.
“And yet, when a woman from Child Protection turns up to help, they get rid of her.....”
Let’s look at that statement.
She … turned up … unannounced and uninvited … and immediately on arrival started asking intrusive questions of the victims while they were standing in the street. She then tried to steer the distraught mother to a place where she could interrogate her on her own.
What on earth???
A child protection worker was she?
Madeleine was missing … but the twins were not; yet no offer of help with them or even an enquiry of how they were or where they were.
She wanted a ringside seat where the action was taking place, not behind the scenes making sure that the severely traumatised friends were supported with their own children and the twins.
If the Drs McCann had been known to social services and she was their caseworker she had a locus; as neither was the case her actions in pushing herself forward were intrusive and unprofessional. She had no more right to be there than any other holidaymaker and her lack of concern for the other children in the party is indicative of that.
That she was also vindictive can be ascertained by the anonymous letter she wrote to implicate the friend who had intervened to prevent her … a total stranger … from insisting that an unwilling Dr McCann should accompany her to a private place.
Not on! … and again an illustration of the total disregard this woman had for professional practice. If she had any qualms whatsoever about anyone … there are official channels that anyone with her alleged 25years professional experience should have known about and ought to have accessed to address her so called concerns.
Writing an anonymous letter does not cut the mustard.
-
shouldn't she have been arrested for interfering with an official police investigation
As in a private investigation on PT soil? LOL
On a more serious note, I find it feasible that she probably reacted on the spur of the moment in good faith, but intervened in an insensitive way at a delicate moment. She was apparently connected to child protection work in the UK, but turned up out of the blue, was not present in any official capacity and doesn't seem to have been a trauma counsellor.
-
As in a private investigation on PT soil? LOL
On a more serious note, I find it feasible that she probably reacted on the spur of the moment in good faith, but intervened in an insensitive way at a delicate moment. She was apparently connected to child protection work in the UK, but turned up out of the blue, was not present in any official capacity and doesn't seem to have been a trauma counsellor.
And your thoughts on Kate telling her Madeleine had been abducted by a couple ?
-
And your thoughts on Kate telling her Madeleine had been abducted by a couple ?
How do we know what it is alleged Dr McCann told her?
-
How do we know what it is alleged Dr McCann told her?
It's recorded in Yvonne Martin's statement. Or is she a liar as well as unprofessional ?
'
- She identified herself and presented her credentials and immediately began talking to the mother of the missing child as she was visibly upset with the situation.
- During the conversation the mother told her that she did not understand why a couple had abducted'
-
And your thoughts on Kate telling her Madeleine had been abducted by a couple ?
By all accounts, Kate was still in a total panic and no one knew who this YM person was.
What did Kate actually say to her? Kate may have assumed that more than one person was involved for whatever reason.
-
Just a thought.
What are the chances of two witnesses who are unknown to each other, both giving statements which expressed concern over the same individual in a group of nine having inappropriate thoughts with regard to children ?
-
By all accounts, Kate was still in a total panic and no one knew who this YM person was.
What did Kate actually say to her? Kate may have assumed that more than one person was involved for whatever reason.
I can't imagine that not knowing who someone is would make you say something that had no foundation in fact.
A couple is not how you would describe two or more abductors, you would say a couple of. A couple is much more specific.
-
Just a thought.
What are the chances of two witnesses who are unknown to each other, both giving statements which expressed concern over the same individual in a group of nine having inappropriate thoughts with regard to children ?
How many people thought that they'd seen Gerry and or Kate at various locations where the PJ eventually established that they weren't?
None of these "thoughts" passed on to the police would normally have been in the public domain.
-
And your thoughts on Kate telling her Madeleine had been abducted by a couple ?
There is an interesting passage in KM's book - about a couple - who had supposedly been checked out
(Source: "Madeleine" by K Mccann, page 114)
"I remember Gerry and me exchanging quizzical looks after the FLOs tried to explain how one couple had been ruled out of the enquiry. We asked them if they were comfortable with this decision, there was an awkward pause before they replied 'No, not really'.
I wonder if that is the same couple as in the suspicion which KM told YM?
-
I can't imagine that not knowing who someone is would make you say something that had no foundation in fact.
A couple is not how you would describe two or more abductors, you would say a couple of. A couple is much more specific.
What did she actually state in English?
-
What did she actually state in English?
YM statement 12 Jun 2007
"the mother told her that she did not understand why a couple had abducted her daughter."
YM statement 13 Jun 2007
"she found it strange that Kate told her that her daughter had been taken by a couple"
YM statement 14 Nov 2007
"Kate told her that the child had been taken by a couple"
-
There is an interesting passage in KM's book - about a couple - who had supposedly been checked out
(Source: "Madeleine" by K Mccann, page 114)
"I remember Gerry and me exchanging quizzical looks after the FLOs tried to explain how one couple had been ruled out of the enquiry. We asked them if they were comfortable with this decision, there was an awkward pause before they replied 'No, not really'.
I wonder if that is the same couple as in the suspicion which KM told YM?
I can't imagine Kate would have known about any people of interest at just after 9am on the 4th of May Pegasus.
-
Just a thought.
What are the chances of two witnesses who are unknown to each other, both giving statements which expressed concern over the same individual in a group of nine having inappropriate thoughts with regard to children ?
Just another thought ... in this instance, the type of person whose self importance appears to circumvent decency by causing alarm and even more upset at a time of immeasurable distress for the parents of a missing child ...
At this moment, the witness notices that the couple began to have doubts about her capacity and she immediately showed them her official documents and credentials issued by the British government to calm them down. http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
-
YM statement 12 June 2007
"During the conversation the mother told her that she did not understand why a couple had abducted her daughter."
.
If as Carana claimed, Kate meant a couple of people rather than a couple, why would she not understand that ?
-
Just another thought ... in this instance, the type of person whose self importance appears to circumvent decency by causing alarm and even more upset at a time of immeasurable distress for the parents of a missing child ...
At this moment, the witness notices that the couple began to have doubts about her capacity and she immediately showed them her official documents and credentials issued by the British government to calm them down. http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
Not sure what point you are trying to make Brietta.
Two professionals, unknown to each other, both make similar claims about one individual and his inappropriate behaviour with regard to children. Surely that is beyond coincidence ?
-
I can't imagine Kate would have known about any people of interest at just after 9am on the 4th of May Pegasus.
I think it is possible this may be connected with a couple who (if a UK paper reported correctly) may have entered the apartment evening 2nd May in response to crying?
-
Not sure what point you are trying to make Brietta.
Two professionals, unknown to each other, both make similar claims about one individual and his inappropriate behaviour with regard to children. Surely that is beyond coincidence ?
"She adds that, after having spoken to the McCann couple, she spoke to the resort manager, and after identifying herself, asked him whether there had been a break-in in the apartment where the child was, to which he replied no but that the door was open as were the window blinds, which, according to Kate, should have been closed but were found open."
WHAT ??? >@@(*&)
-
There is an interesting passage in KM's book - about a couple - who had supposedly been checked out
(Source: "Madeleine" by K Mccann, page 114)
"I remember Gerry and me exchanging quizzical looks after the FLOs tried to explain how one couple had been ruled out of the enquiry. We asked them if they were comfortable with this decision, there was an awkward pause before they replied 'No, not really'.
I wonder if that is the same couple as in the suspicion which KM told YM?
I don't think so. Perhaps wrongly, but I'd assumed that that referred to the Polish couple.
-
I think it is possible this may be connected with a couple who (if a UK paper reported correctly) may have entered the apartment evening 2nd May in response to crying?
But how would Kate have known that so early on the morning of the 4th ?
-
"She adds that, after having spoken to the McCann couple, she spoke to the resort manager, and after identifying herself, asked him whether there had been a break-in in the apartment where the child was, to which he replied no but that the door was open as were the window blinds, which, according to Kate, should have been closed but were found open."
WHAT ??? >@@(*&)
You really don't want to answer my question, do you Brietta ?
What are the chances of two witnesses who are unknown to each other, both giving statements which expressed concern over the same individual in a group of nine having inappropriate thoughts with regard to children ?
-
.
If as Carana claimed, Kate meant a couple of people rather than a couple, why would she not understand that ?
I haven't claimed anything.
Where is the verbatim record in English of this? If there isn't one, then there is no way of knowing whether what Kate actually said, what YM understood, what the interpreter understood and how any of that was actually recorded.
I find it quite feasible that Kate or whoever else may have spoken to YM to have said "they" at some point meaning unknown entities without any conscious reason as to why there may have been one person or more.
-
Seems this inspector didn't think much of her statements!
Processos Vol XIII Page 3421
Date : 2007-11-14
To: The Coordinator of the Criminal Investigation Paolo Rebelo
From: Paolo Ferreira, Inspector
Service Information
Subject: Expedient related to Yvonne Warren Martin
In the sequence of the contents of the service information in annex, which was prepared by Inspector José Monteira on 12-06-2007, the questioning of Yvonne Warren Martin was twice begun, according to the files that are also joined to this.
The statement relates in detail her intervention with the McCann couple after having heard about Madeleine's disappearance.
She adds that on one occasion, because it had occurred to her that the parents and the friends could eventually be involved in the child's disappearance, she wrote an anonymous letter to the British police.
The statements given to the PJ today by Yvonne Martin provide a concrete clarification of the reasons for her suspicions, which in my opinion, do not point to any concrete element that could, in any way, make other inquiries directly related to her statements, viable.
With nothing further to add.
Signed
Inspector Ferreira
-
You really don't want to answer my question, do you Brietta ?
What are the chances of two witnesses who are unknown to each other, both giving statements which expressed concern over the same individual in a group of nine having inappropriate thoughts with regard to children ?
If you wish to discuss Dr Gaspar's statement ... go ahead ... but this thread is 'dedicated' to the rather extraordinary ... originally anonymous ... statements made by Yvonne Warren Martin which consist of supposition and inuendo ... but absolutely no factual information.
So Dr Payne ruffled the feathers of a pompous ... imo ... individual who takes revenge by penning an anonymous letter designed to ruin his reputation. She did not intend her name to be appended to the letter she wrote but her intent was clear with regard to his.
- SNIP -With regards to the individual who was close to Madeleine's parents when she met them, and who was later identified as David Payne, she reaffirms that the same individual seems familiar, possibly as this same individual intervened in a situation related to a professional activity of the witness. She clarifies that neither on that occasion, nor now that time has passed, can she remember concretely the place or the situation in which she may have come to know David Payne, but that she continues to think that the same individual is familiar to her but cannot state the particular situation.http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
-
YM statement 12 Jun 2007
"the mother told her that she did not understand why a couple had abducted her daughter."
YM statement 13 Jun 2007
"she found it strange that Kate told her that her daughter had been taken by a couple"
YM statement 14 Nov 2007
"Kate told her that the child had been taken by a couple"
Unusually for you Pegasus, you are not thinking very deeply.
The Mccanns were terrified that a paedophile man had taken Madeleine.
Their friends would want to ease the pain. My bet is that most of them would be saying to Kate and Gerry a tale something like this
" Some childless couple wanted a pretty little blonde girl and chose Madeleine. They will cherish and look after her well until she is found and returned."
Kate would cling to that hope, despite niggling doubts.
-
I haven't claimed anything.
Where is the verbatim record in English of this? If there isn't one, then there is no way of knowing whether what Kate actually said, what YM understood, what the interpreter understood and how any of that was actually recorded.
I find it quite feasible that Kate or whoever else may have spoken to YM to have said "they" at some point meaning unknown entities without any conscious reason as to why there may have been one person or more.
So in two separate statements YM, at least three times, said Kate had said a couple took her daughter and you think it was a misunderstanding or a translation error ? Really ?
-
If you wish to discuss Dr Gaspar's statement ... go ahead ... but this thread is 'dedicated' to the rather extraordinary ... originally anonymous ... statements made by Yvonne Warren Martin which consist of supposition and inuendo ... but absolutely no factual information.
So Dr Payne ruffled the feathers of a pompous ... imo ... individual who takes revenge by penning an anonymous letter designed to ruin his reputation. She did not intend her name to be appended to the letter she wrote but her intent was clear with regard to his.
- SNIP -With regards to the individual who was close to Madeleine's parents when she met them, and who was later identified as David Payne, she reaffirms that the same individual seems familiar, possibly as this same individual intervened in a situation related to a professional activity of the witness. She clarifies that neither on that occasion, nor now that time has passed, can she remember concretely the place or the situation in which she may have come to know David Payne, but that she continues to think that the same individual is familiar to her but cannot state the particular situation.http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
I don't want to discuss the Gaspar statement Brietta but I would be obliged if you would answer my question.
Just a thought.
What are the chances of two witnesses who are unknown to each other, both giving statements which expressed concern over the same individual in a group of nine having inappropriate thoughts with regard to children ?
-
I don't want to discuss the Gaspar statement Brietta but I would be obliged if you would answer my question.
Just a thought.
What are the chances of two witnesses who are unknown to each other, both giving statements which expressed concern over the same individual in a group of nine having inappropriate thoughts with regard to children ?
You pretend to misunderstand what I am saying about Yvonne Martin's statement: let me put it this way I am as underwhelmed by what she had to say as was Inspector Ferreira.
If it amuses you to keep repeating yourself ... that's fine ... but it doesn't add to Martin's statement's 'viability' ... and it does nowt for your credibility.
You are not even attempting to defend the woman's suppositions which are the indefensible.
Repition seems to be your fall back position when you are incapable of debate; you never fail.
-
You pretend to misunderstand what I am saying about Yvonne Martin's statement: let me put it this way I am as underwhelmed by what she had to say as was Inspector Ferreira.
If it amuses you to keep repeating yourself ... that's fine ... but it doesn't add to Martin's statement's 'viability' ... and it does nowt for your credibility.
You are not even attempting to defend the woman's suppositions which are the indefensible.
Repition seems to be your fall back position when you are incapable of debate; you never fail.
And trying to steer the debate in a direction that makes you feel more comfortable seems to be yours.
Yvonne Martin is a Child Protection professional with twenty five years experience in her field and hard as you and your fellow supporters may try to undermine her evidence, as an individual with such longstanding experience her statement must be handled with the weight it deserves.
So two individuals , one a Child Protection professional of 25 years standing and the other a medically trained doctor express doubts about one of the McCanns friend's behaviour towards children and you don't feel that is worthy of discussion or indeed a coincidence too far ?
-
And trying to steer the debate in a direction that makes you feel more comfortable seems to be yours.
Yvonne Martin is a Child Protection professional with twenty five years experience in her field and hard as you and your fellow supporters may try to undermine her evidence, as an individual with such longstanding experience her statement must be handled with the weight it deserves.
So two individuals , one a Child Protection professional of 25 years standing and the other a medically trained doctor express doubts about one of the McCanns friend's behaviour towards children and you don't feel that is worthy of discussion or indeed a coincidence too far ?
Yvonne Martin's statement appears to have been 'handled with the weight it deserves' in equal measure by Inspector Ferreira and the British cops to whom her unfounded anonymously imparted rumours were addressed.
No-one could make a better job of 'undermining' her 'evidence' than she has herself ... and that you rely on someone who writes anonymous letters making unfounded accusations to bolster your case, does not surprise me in the slightest.
A statement consisting of such certainties as, in her words ... coincidences; could possibly; thinks; may have; seems familiar; can’t remember concretely; cannot be certain; potentially.
Wow ... how definitive is that!! when making an accusation.
- CLIP - She adds that her hypothesis is that she may have come to know him professionally through work, potentially having been colleagues at work or have worked at the same place but she cannot be certain where she met him as she does not remember.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
-
Yvonne Martin got the cold shoulder treatment for sure even though her intentions were honourable. It is this arrogant sanctimonious perception of the McCanns which has engendered so much loathing.
-
And trying to steer the debate in a direction that makes you feel more comfortable seems to be yours.
Yvonne Martin is a Child Protection professional with twenty five years experience in her field and hard as you and your fellow supporters may try to undermine her evidence, as an individual with such longstanding experience her statement must be handled with the weight it deserves.
So two individuals , one a Child Protection professional of 25 years standing and the other a medically trained doctor express doubts about one of the McCanns friend's behaviour towards children and you don't feel that is worthy of discussion or indeed a coincidence too far ?
Where have you got that a Child Protection Officer expressed doubts about one of the Mccanns friends from? Have you made it up ... or have you a cite ?
-
Yvonne Martin got the cold shoulder treatment for sure even though her intentions were honourable. It is this arrogant sanctimonious perception of the McCanns which has engendered so much loathing.
I think she was peeved at DP's dismissal of her and was hitting back at him. The fact that she didn't actually make a firm accusation but used innuendo leads me to suspect that her intentions were less than honourable.
Whereas I am of the opinion that Dr Gasper's concerns were made with the best of intentions; my criticism of her would be that she was duty bound to voice any concerns to the GMC when she returned from holiday and let them sort it out.
I don't see how you can claim that at that point the Drs McCann could be perceived as arrogant and sanctimonious ... they were in bits and the last thing they needed was some self appointed busybody asking them intrusive questions which only the police should have been doing.
-
And trying to steer the debate in a direction that makes you feel more comfortable seems to be yours.
Yvonne Martin is a Child Protection professional with twenty five years experience in her field and hard as you and your fellow supporters may try to undermine her evidence, as an individual with such longstanding experience her statement must be handled with the weight it deserves.
So two individuals , one a Child Protection professional of 25 years standing and the other a medically trained doctor express doubts about one of the McCanns friend's behaviour towards children and you don't feel that is worthy of discussion or indeed a coincidence too far ?
I met someone recently on another forum, nothing to do with Maddy by the way chicken related.
We have been chatting and it turns out that she is retired Child protection agent for a county.
I asked her off forum about the McCann case and if she had been in PDL at the time and knew they were English etc would she have approached them.
She said yes she probably would have to help them, as they are trained to assist in these cases.
So its not really odd for this Yvonne to do that.
The thing that is odd to me is the way the McCanns REJECTED her help. I would have grabbed hold of her and begged her for help. PERSONALLY.
-
I met someone recently on another forum, nothing to do with Maddy by the way chicken related.
We have been chatting and it turns out that she is retired Child protection agent for a county.
I asked her off forum about the McCann case and if she had been in PDL at the time and knew they were English etc would she have approached them.
She said yes she probably would have to help them, as they are trained to assist in these cases.
So its not really odd for this Yvonne to do that.
The thing that is odd to me is the way the McCanns REJECTED her help. I would have grabbed hold of her and begged her for help. PERSONALLY.
Can anyone tell me in what way a social worker could be of any help in this situation....no help whatsoever..or is this just another stick with which to beat the mccanns...of course it is
-
Can anyone tell me in what way a social worker could be of any help in this situation....no help whatsoever..or is this just another stick with which to beat the mccanns...of course it is
Agreed.
IMO The main reason some sceptics like to refer to YM is because they seem to think it is 'proof' of some kind that ...... ......... is a paedophile - which some of them are desperately keen to be true. Very disturbing IMO. The fact that she also thought he could have been a bona fide work colleague from her past - is totally ignored by those same people.
I would assume that she checked her work records at some time - and found nothing at all to link her with him.
People who write anonymous letters - especially ones which smack of 'poison pen letters' have no credibility whatsoever as reliable witnesses IMO - as their motives are usually based on 'revenge' or 'envy' etc. etc.
IMO YM was extremely 'put out' at being 'removed' by David Payne - and after simmering for a while - she wrote her anonymous letter.
Not professional - and definitely not nice IMO.
-
Can anyone tell me in what way a social worker could be of any help in this situation....no help whatsoever..or is this just another stick with which to beat the mccanns...of course it is
In the generic a social worker might have been very supportive and helpful.
In the particular, Yvonne Martin wasn't!
-
In the generic a social worker might have been very supportive and helpful.
In the particular, Yvonne Martin wasn't!
Indeed. I'm struggling to understand how 'interrogating' Kate like a policeman, even though she could see what a terribly distressed state Kate was in - was in any way 'helpful'.
I do think that as she arrived following a police car - the McCanns may have originally thought she was connected 'officially' in some way to the case - but then eventually realised she was no more than a stranger off the street who had taken it upon herself to insert herself into the proceedings - and so asked her to leave. But that's just speculation on my part - and could be completely wrong.
I truly have no idea what Y. Martin's intentions were that morning - or what she hoped to achieve.
-
Can anyone tell me in what way a social worker could be of any help in this situation....no help whatsoever..or is this just another stick with which to beat the mccanns...of course it is
Indeed sir you appear to be asking a question and answering it your good self. That truly is unwonted.
-
Indeed. I'm struggling to understand how 'interrogating' Kate like a policeman, even though she could see what a terribly distressed state Kate was in - was in any way 'helpful'.
I do think that as she arrived following a police car - the McCanns may have originally thought she was connected 'officially' in some way to the case - but then eventually realised she was no more than a stranger off the street who had taken it upon herself to insert herself into the proceedings - and so asked her to leave. But that's just speculation on my part - and could be completely wrong.
I truly have no idea what Y. Martin's intentions were that morning - or what she hoped to achieve.
' 'interrogating' Kate like a policeman '
What a load of old rubbish.
-
Indeed. I'm struggling to understand how 'interrogating' Kate like a policeman, even though she could see what a terribly distressed state Kate was in - was in any way 'helpful'.
I do think that as she arrived following a police car - the McCanns may have originally thought she was connected 'officially' in some way to the case - but then eventually realised she was no more than a stranger off the street who had taken it upon herself to insert herself into the proceedings - and so asked her to leave. But that's just speculation on my part - and could be completely wrong.
I truly have no idea what Y. Martin's intentions were that morning - or what she hoped to achieve.
I agree with that absolutely.
They would be outside taking keen note of every approaching official vehicle in case it was bringing news of Madeleine; they would have seen her arrival and discussion with the police on the ground and would naturally have made the assumption she was there in an official capacity.
These people are professionals who know how other professionals should behave ... imo they sussed out something about her with which they were extremely unhappy which is why they asked to see her credentials.
-
' These people are professionals who know how other professionals should behave '
Professionals ?
-
Where have you got that a Child Protection Officer expressed doubts about one of the Mccanns friends from? Have you made it up ... or have you a cite ?
From Yvonne Martin's statement :
'The witness was also shown attached page showing the places of work where she carried out her professional activities as Social Services Manager for Child Protection,'
'She declares that one of her main aims when she wrote the anonymous letter was for the British police to check the paedophile or child abusers registers and whether ..... ....... was on that list. '
-
Agreed.
IMO The main reason some sceptics like to refer to YM is because they seem to think it is 'proof' of some kind that ...... ......... is a paedophile - which some of them are desperately keen to be true. Very disturbing IMO. The fact that she also thought he could have been a bona fide work colleague from her past - is totally ignored by those same people.
I would assume that she checked her work records at some time - and found nothing at all to link her with him.
People who write anonymous letters - especially ones which smack of 'poison pen letters' have no credibility whatsoever as reliable witnesses IMO - as their motives are usually based on 'revenge' or 'envy' etc. etc.
IMO YM was extremely 'put out' at being 'removed' by David Payne - and after simmering for a while - she wrote her anonymous letter.
Not professional - and definitely not nice IMO.
And don't you think it's odd Benice that out of the four adult males in McCann party two professionals who where unknown to each other both suspected the same individual of inappropriate behaviour towards children ?
-
From Yvonne Martin's statement :
'The witness was also shown attached page showing the places of work where she carried out her professional activities as Social Services Manager for Child Protection,'
'She declares that one of her main aims when she wrote the anonymous letter was for the British police to check the paedophile or child abusers registers and whether ..... ......... was on that list. '
... and why on earth would they do that?
Unless you can quote a direct statement from her in which she categorically accuses him of such other than ... her main aim ...
If the woman had proof of such ... she would have produced it. It would not have been necessary to pen an anonymous letter in an attempt to destroy his reputation.
-
... and why on earth would they do that?
Unless you can quote a direct statement from her in which she categorically accuses him of such other than ... her main aim ...
If the woman had proof of such ... she would have produced it. It would not have been necessary to pen an anonymous letter in an attempt to destroy his reputation.
Stop being silly Brietta.
She suspects the individual of inappropriate behaviour towards children, she does not categorically accuse him of such. Although put her doubts together with the statement of KG and it certainly raises some questions about the individual.
-
... and why on earth would they do that?
Unless you can quote a direct statement from her in which she categorically accuses him of such other than ... her main aim ...
If the woman had proof of such ... she would have produced it. It would not have been necessary to pen an anonymous letter in an attempt to destroy his reputation.
Apparently in some people's minds - the fact that if anyone is checked out against a child abuse register in the first place - then that is 'proof' that the person is a paedaphile or should be strongly suspected of being one - even if absolutely nothing is found. Very disturbing 'lynchmob' mentality IMO.
-
Apparently in some people's minds - the fact that if anyone is checked out against a child abuse register in the first place - then that is 'proof' that the person is a paedaphile or should be strongly suspected of being one - even if absolutely nothing is found. Very disturbing 'lynchmob' mentality IMO.
No one said it was proof but the fact that two professionals suspected the same individual of certain behaviours is certainly cause for discussion.
Imagine two professionals had suspected one of the Portuguese individuals recently questioned of inappropriate behaviour towards children ? I'm sure we would be discussing that to the nth degree, and rightly so.
-
Stop being silly Brietta.
She suspects the individual of inappropriate behaviour towards children, she does not categorically accuse him of such. Although put her doubts together with the statement of KG and it certainly raises some questions about the individual.
And she was so sure of her accusations / implications that she didn't even put her name to the letter?
IMO, She should be kicked off her professional body for doing something like that .... writing effectively poison pen letters .... no proof .... and anonymous fgs. And on such a mighty topic.
She could have ruined him. She has affected his whole life anyway, it will always hang over him
Exactly Benice. Lynchmob mentality.
Is she really a professional ? ..... or one of these people who like to think they are? Anyone know ?
-
In the generic a social worker might have been very supportive and helpful.
In the particular, Yvonne Martin wasn't!
Yup, she didn't really fit in with the type of help they wished for.
-
No one said it was proof but the fact that two professionals suspected the same individual of certain behaviours is certainly cause for discussion.
Imagine two professionals had suspected one of the Portuguese individuals recently questioned of inappropriate behaviour towards children ? I'm sure we would be discussing that to the nth degree, and rightly so.
Faith
Can you show where she has said she suspects him of anything? All she said was that she thought that she had come across him before. Later she realised that it was because she had worked alongside him somewhere IIRC
[I am remembering a post somewhere on this thread. Please correct me if I am remembering incorrectly]
You MUST be SURE of facts before throwing out accusations as you have.
-
Social workers are naturally suspicious of the people they come into contact with on a professional basis,it's part and parcel of the work they do. Families are very good at hiding domestic abuses so being inquisitive is part of their basic training.
-
Social workers are naturally suspicious of the people they come into contact with on a professional basis,it's part and parcel of the work they do. Families are very good at hiding domestic abuses so being inquisitive is part of their basic training.
So making one suspicious isn't good.
-
And she was so sure of her accusations / implications that she didn't even put her name to the letter?
IMO, She should be kicked off her professional body for doing something like that .... writing effectively poison pen letters .... no proof .... and anonymous fgs. And on such a mighty topic.
She could have ruined him. She has affected his whole life anyway, it will always hang over him
Exactly Benice. Lynchmob mentality.
Is she really a professional ? ..... or one of these people who like to think they are? Anyone know ?
Many, many individuals contacted the police anonymously after Madeleine's disappearance. Does that make the information they imparted any more or less relevant. Besides the only reason we know YM wrote an anonymous letter is because she told us so.
There is nothing in the files that points to either KG or YM's statements being followed up. It would be reassuring to know SY have looked at the allegations in depth even if just to clear the individual of any suspicion.
-
I guess I'm in the middle on this.
She may have been trying to help in her own way, but the way in which she went about it seems insensitive. I don't have a problem with the questions she asked as if Gerry hadn't been the father and if they hadn't been checking regularly, then it might have pointed to a parental abduction.
......... name may have rung a faint bell as there were indeed several paedos of that name, but none of them were the ...... ........ in question.
It just sounds like one of the thousands of communications that police forces would get in any investigation. Some may be genuine spur-of-the-moment doubts, others may be malicious and yet others may be truly relevant. It's then up to the police to sort out the wheat from the chaff.
In this case, statements or other communications ended up on the Internet for everyone to pore over. If people had known from the outset that their communications to the police would be plastered all over the web, some might have slept on it and double-checked their facts first.
-
Many, many individuals contacted the police anonymously after Madeleine's disappearance. Does that make the information they imparted any more or less relevant. Besides the only reason we know YM wrote an anonymous letter is because she told us so.
There is nothing in the files that points to either KG or YM's statements being followed up. It would be reassuring to know SY have looked at the allegations in depth even if just to clear the individual of any suspicion.
That doesn't excuse YM. If she is a professional, she should have put her name to it.
I hope and expect SY will have looked at it in depth. I feel so sorry for the guy. What an accusation to have following you around in life ....paedophile ....Jeez !
I have told you before that I believe I know who is behind these abductions, the man who commissioned Madeleines abduction. Despite a multitude of pointers, I have never publicly pointed th finger at him because I know, if I am wrong, just what it would do to him.
-
Apparently in some people's minds - the fact that if anyone is checked out against a child abuse register in the first place - then that is 'proof' that the person is a paedophile or should be strongly suspected of being one - even if absolutely nothing is found. Very disturbing 'lynchmob' mentality IMO.
I would be absolutely amazed if the police had not checked the register specifically for the names of the party; imo it would have been negligent for them not to have done so.
I do not have a cite ... but it has been reported that the Brits passed on details of known ex pat offenders to their Portuguese colleagues ... so the suggestion they were not on the ball with this avenue of investigation is ludicrous.
-
Social workers are naturally suspicious of the people they come into contact with on a professional basis,it's part and parcel of the work they do. Families are very good at hiding domestic abuses so being inquisitive is part of their basic training.
She was not in attendance under an order; nor was she an assigned case worker.
Protocol dictates that when she was asked to leave ... that is exactly what she should have done ...
We should never have heard of YM nor would we but for her anonymous letter.
If that is an example the calibre of social care workers in GB it is little wonder there are so many associated scandals.
-
Stop being silly Brietta.
She suspects the individual of inappropriate behaviour towards children, she does not categorically accuse him of such. Although put her doubts together with the statement of KG and it certainly raises some questions about the individual.
It certainly does raise questions about the individual ... not the one you imply; but very much the one whose actions you are unable to defend because they are indefensible.
-
Er Hello,
Profession: Social Services and Child Protection
Yvonne Martin is a Child Protection professional with twenty five years experience. Then why the need to send an anonymous email to the police.
She could have found out about this through her own work. She would have had a line manager, or gone to the top brass, if she didn't have access to the information herself. Or Even gone to the Devon Police.
-
Health professionals are not supposed to use these confidential data bases for their own purposes.
-
No one said it was proof but the fact that two professionals suspected the same individual of certain behaviours is certainly cause for discussion.
Imagine two professionals had suspected one of the Portuguese individuals recently questioned of inappropriate behaviour towards children ? I'm sure we would be discussing that to the nth degree, and rightly so.
If they were questioned as witnesses the situation does not arise; that they were questioned as arguidos in an active case suggests that the professionals of the PJ and the Met think there is cause to do so.
That we do not have witness statements or know anything much about these men has rather stultified any debate at all let alone to the nth degree.
-
Er Hello,
Profession: Social Services and Child Protection
Yvonne Martin is a Child Protection professional with twenty five years experience. Then why the need to send an anonymous email to the police.
She could have found out about this through her own work. She would have had a line manager, or gone to the top brass, if she didn't have access to the information herself. Or Even gone to the Devon Police.
Precisely.
If she thought she had encountered him in a work situation it could have been easily checked with reference to her diary ... she must have kept a diary of meetings; trainings; case conferences; contacts etc.
It is mandatory for her to do so.
If she had any suspicions at all an official report from such an important idividual would have carried more weight than an anoymous letter. IMO it shows exactly what her priority was.
-
Health professionals are not supposed to use these confidential data bases for their own purposes.
WHAT!
How would it be for her own purposes? She is the one accusing.
She didn't need to access it herself, but report it to her line manager, who could have.
-
And don't you think it's odd Benice that out of the four adult males in McCann party two professionals who where unknown to each other both suspected the same individual of inappropriate behaviour towards children ?
Did you read on the news the other day the police have broken another bit pedophile ring and saved lots of kids and the main perbs where DOCTORS, lawyers, policemen lol...jeez makes you think doesnt it, who is safe nowadays really.
So the Gaspars statement for me is probably spot on the money.
-
Did you read on the news the other day the police have broken another bit pedophile ring and saved lots of kids and the main perbs where DOCTORS, lawyers, policemen lol...jeez makes you think doesnt it, who is safe nowadays really.
So the Gaspars statement for me is probably spot on the money.
A giant stride from that announcement to more or less condemning a man, dontcha think, colo ?
-
WHAT!
How would it be for her own purposes? She is the one accusing.
She didn't need to access it herself, but report it to her line manager, who could have.
Simple. She would not be using it in pursuit of her official work.
I agree she could have pushed the matter up to her manager, but the same would apply.
As I recall, I was told on here only the other day, possibly by you, that she was not a mere holidaymaker, but lived ni Portugal for several months each year. She may not have had immediate access either to the data base or to her line manager until she returned to the UK.
-
Simple. She would not be using it in pursuit of her official work.
I agree she could have pushed the matter up to her manager, but the same would apply.
As I recall, I was told on here only the other day, possibly by you, that she was not a mere holidaymaker, but lived ni Portugal for several months each year. She may not have had immediate access either to the data base or to her line manager until she returned to the UK.
To me, it is the anonymous thing that is so so wrong.
Seems that after she had thought it thru, she didn't anyhow have any qualms about the man in question. She realsed that the reason she had him on her mind was not cos he was a client, or had done anything wrong, but becos she had worked with him sometime
-
A giant stride from that announcement to more or less condemning a man, dontcha think, colo ?
Simple. She would not be using it in pursuit of her official work.
I agree she could have pushed the matter up to her manager, but the same would apply.
As I recall, I was told on here only the other day, possibly by you, that she was not a mere holidaymaker, but lived ni Portugal for several months each year. She may not have had immediate access either to the data base or to her line manager until she returned to the UK.
You can't move the goal posts now lol.
Don't you read before you post?
Was she in the Uk when she sent the anonymous letter?
She declares that one of her main aims when she wrote the anonymous letter was for the British police to check the paedophile or child abusers registers and whether ...... ....... was on that list.
See she knew how it works! I would have thought this would have been a priority, why wait 2 weeks?
She could have phoned her line manager or even the police, even if she was in Portugal.
Why didn't she tell the PJ? After all her target was still in Luz!
-
I guess I'm in the middle on this.
She may have been trying to help in her own way, but the way in which she went about it seems insensitive. I don't have a problem with the questions she asked as if Gerry hadn't been the father and if they hadn't been checking regularly, then it might have pointed to a parental abduction.
......... name may have rung a faint bell as there were indeed several paedos of that name, but none of them were the ...... ........ in question.
It just sounds like one of the thousands of communications that police forces would get in any investigation. Some may be genuine spur-of-the-moment doubts, others may be malicious and yet others may be truly relevant. It's then up to the police to sort out the wheat from the chaff.
In this case, statements or other communications ended up on the Internet for everyone to pore over. If people had known from the outset that their communications to the police would be plastered all over the web, some might have slept on it and double-checked their facts first.
I agree Carana YM statement would be like any other except for the fact that she saw the McCanns first hand shortly after Madeleine's disappearance, she is a child protection professional and her concerns are mirrored by another, also a professional's, statement.
-
Er Hello,
Profession: Social Services and Child Protection
Yvonne Martin is a Child Protection professional with twenty five years experience. Then why the need to send an anonymous email to the police.
She could have found out about this through her own work. She would have had a line manager, or gone to the top brass, if she didn't have access to the information herself. Or Even gone to the Devon Police.
And perhaps she didn't want to be at the end of exactly the trashing of her good name that we are seeing on this board.
-
You can't move the goal posts now lol.
Don't you read before you post?
Was she in the Uk when she sent the anonymous letter?
She declares that one of her main aims when she wrote the anonymous letter was for the British police to check the paedophile or child abusers registers and whether ...... ....... was on that list.
See she knew how it works! I would have thought this would have been a priority, why wait 2 weeks?
She could have phoned her line manager or even the police, even if she was in Portugal.
Why didn't she tell the PJ? After all her target was still in Luz!
So she didn't check the register herself, as indeed she should not have done.
As for the rest, I have no idea when she returned to UK or when she wrote the letter. Do you ?
-
If they were questioned as witnesses the situation does not arise; that they were questioned as arguidos in an active case suggests that the professionals of the PJ and the Met think there is cause to do so.
That we do not have witness statements or know anything much about these men has rather stultified any debate at all let alone to the nth degree.
We are informed that one of the arguidos was a thief and look at the speculation that has fuelled. Imagine if he had been accused of having an interest in children.
-
Precisely.
If she thought she had encountered him in a work situation it could have been easily checked with reference to her diary ... she must have kept a diary of meetings; trainings; case conferences; contacts etc.
It is mandatory for her to do so.
If she had any suspicions at all an official report from such an important idividual would have carried more weight than an anoymous letter. IMO it shows exactly what her priority was.
No it doesn't. So what do you think her priority was then Brietta ?
-
I agree Carana YM statement would be like any other except for the fact that she saw the McCanns first hand shortly after Madeleine's disappearance, she is a child protection professional and her concerns are mirrored by another, also a professional's, statement.
I'd agree, except that the other professional's statement (who doesn't seem to have had a professional role in the issue in question) has been wildy exaggerated.
I doubt that either would have appreciated knowing that their confidential doubts at some moment in time were plastered all over the Internet.
Nor would the Irish family.
-
So she didn't check the register herself, as indeed she should not have done.
As for the rest, I have no idea when she returned to UK or when she wrote the letter. Do you ?
No but she could have got it checked.
Well she had been back to the UK before she made her 12/06/2007 statement. She had already sent that letter.
Yes she wrote the letter 2 weeks after Madeleine's disappearance
-
Why did Yvonne Martin think DP looked like the man Jane Tanner described?
Does anyone know?
-
I'd agree, except that the other professional's statement (who doesn't seem to have had a professional role in the issue in question) has been wildy exaggerated.
I doubt that either would have appreciated knowing that their confidential doubts at some moment in time were plastered all over the Internet.
Nor would the Irish family.
I'm sure you're right Carana but that doesn't alter the fact that they are.
BTW can you please point me to where I have exaggerated what YM said ?
-
Why did Yvonne Martin think DP looked like the man Jane Tanner described?
Does anyone know?
Because
She describes him as tall man, height about 1,80 m, about 35 years old, of normal physical complexion, with short, dark hair, with a round face and with a scar on the left side of his face running from the eyebrow to the cheek. He uses graduated glasses of small dimension with rectangular lenses. He spoke with a southern English accent and was wearing cream coloured trousers and a dark polo shirt
-
No but she could have got it checked.
Well she had been back to the UK before she made her 12/06/2007 statement. She had already sent that letter.
Yes she wrote the letter 2 weeks after Madeleine's disappearance
Why should she want to make an unauthorised search of the confidential data base?
She clearly wanted the police to do the check, which sounds perfectly reasonable to me.
-
Why should she want to make an unauthorised search of the data base?
She clearly wanted the police to do the check, which sounds perfectly reasonable to me.
I said she could have got it done, not her do it.
Reasonable yes I agree, but not by anonymous letters. She was in the UK so why not go to Devon Police then and explain.
Seems as though they probably traced her anyway, through that letter.
-
Who did she actually sent the letter to - which Force?
-
Yvonne Martin said that she sent the letter anonymously because she didn't want to be involved with The Media.
What can have given her the idea at that time that The Media would be involved?
-
Because
She describes him as tall man, height about 1,80 m, about 35 years old, of normal physical complexion, with short, dark hair, with a round face and with a scar on the left side of his face running from the eyebrow to the check. He uses graduated glasses of small dimension with rectangular lenses. He spoke with a southern English accent and was wearing cream coloured trousers and a dark polo shirt
I'm talking about Jane Tanner's description:
( * ) Dark skinned individual, male sex, aged between 35-40, slim physical appearance, about 1.70m tall. Very dark, thick hair, longer at the back (she could only see him from behind). He was wearing linen type cloth trousers, beige to golden in colour, a "duffy" sic type jacket (but not that thick). His shoes were dark in colour, classic type. He had a hurried walk. He was carrying a child, who was lying on both his arms, in front of his chest. By the way he was dressed, he gave her the impression that he was not a tourist, because he was very "warmly dressed".
Why did Yvonne Martin think Dr Payne looked like that?
-
The Media were involved from day one
-
The Media were involved from day one
But not The Statements of potential witnesses.
-
I said she could have got it done, not her do it.
Reasonable yes I agree, but not by anonymous letters. She was in the UK so why not go to Devon Police then and explain.
Seems as though they probably traced her anyway, through that letter.
How do we know she was in the UK ? She was in Portugal when she gave the statement to the PJ. She could have been there all the time and sent the letter to UK police from Portugal.
-
But not The Statements of potential witnesses.
Perhaps she had seen the Media in action when she was there on the Friday and decided she didn't want anything to do with them.
-
Perhaps she had seen the Media in action when she was there on the Friday and decided she didn't want anything to do with them.
Now I can understand that, but not an anonymous letter.
Thatb is the pits
-
How do we know she was in the UK ? She was in Portugal when she gave the statement to the PJ. She could have been there all the time and sent the letter to UK police from Portugal.
Jeez, why don't you read her statements?
She had been back home. Was this when she sent the letter?
- When she was back home, following the case on English television, she saw the same individual and this time, her initial doubt faded and she concluded that she had seen the face in the course of her professional activity in child protection, not being able to discern if he was a suspect/arguido or witness
Oh look, she could have had access to the database
She clarifies that she is capable of making a photographic identification of the individual, and emphasises that with the identified photo it is possible to access the database of the British Police and ascertain whether the individual is related to any crimes involving children
-
I'm talking about Jane Tanner's description:
( * ) Dark skinned individual, male sex, aged between 35-40, slim physical appearance, about 1.70m tall. Very dark, thick hair, longer at the back (she could only see him from behind). He was wearing linen type cloth trousers, beige to golden in colour, a "duffy" sic type jacket (but not that thick). His shoes were dark in colour, classic type. He had a hurried walk. He was carrying a child, who was lying on both his arms, in front of his chest. By the way he was dressed, he gave her the impression that he was not a tourist, because he was very "warmly dressed".
Why did Yvonne Martin think Dr Payne looked like that?
She says that about two weeks after Madeleine's disappearance, when the police made an appeal for information about a man, carrying a child, who had been seen in the Luz zone, and whose clothing was described, she wrote an anonymous letter to the British police, telling them the following: : regarding the various details she observed during her contact with the McCanns it is her opinion that they could be in some way involved in the disappearance of Madeleine.
-
Jeez, why don't you read her statements?
She had been back home. Was this when she sent the letter?
- When she was back home, following the case on English television, she saw the same individual and this time, her initial doubt faded and she concluded that she had seen the face in the course of her professional activity in child protection, not being able to discern if he was a suspect/arguido or witness
Oh look, she could have had access to the database
She clarifies that she is capable of making a photographic identification of the individual, and emphasises that with the identified photo it is possible to access the database of the British Police and ascertain whether the individual is related to any crimes involving children
I have read her statement and I cannot see where she says that she was in the UK
from her statement - http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
"She says that about two weeks after Madeleine's disappearance, when the police made an appeal for information about a man, carrying a child, who had been seen in the Luz zone, and whose clothing was described, she wrote an anonymous letter to the British police, telling them the following: : regarding the various details she observed during her contact with the McCanns it is her opinion that they could be in some way involved in the disappearance of Madeleine. "
-
I have read her statement and I cannot see where she says that she was in the UK
from her statement - http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
"She says that about two weeks after Madeleine's disappearance, when the police made an appeal for information about a man, carrying a child, who had been seen in the Luz zone, and whose clothing was described, she wrote an anonymous letter to the British police, telling them the following: : regarding the various details she observed during her contact with the McCanns it is her opinion that they could be in some way involved in the disappearance of Madeleine. "
She says that she has lived in Portugal for seven years on a part-time basis, in other words, for some months of the year she lives in her home in Sargaçal and for the rest of the year lives in England, where she still works.
- When she was back home, following the case on English television, she saw the same individual and this time, her initial doubt faded and she concluded that she had seen the face in the course of her professional activity in child protection, not being able to discern if he was a suspect/arguido or witness.
-
She says that she has lived in Portugal for seven years on a part-time basis, in other words, for some months of the year she lives in her home in Sargaçal and for the rest of the year lives in England, where she still works.
- When she was back home, following the case on English television, she saw the same individual and this time, her initial doubt faded and she concluded that she had seen the face in the course of her professional activity in child protection, not being able to discern if he was a suspect/arguido or witness.
Where does it say that ? what is your source?
-
Where does it say that ? what is your source?
I thought you had read her statements.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
-
I thought you had read her statements.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
Ok, found it now in a different section to where she talks about the anonymous letter, so no indication when it was sent, or who it was sent to ( other than UK police).
-
She says that about two weeks after Madeleine's disappearance, when the police made an appeal for information about a man, carrying a child, who had been seen in the Luz zone, and whose clothing was described, she wrote an anonymous letter to the British police, telling them the following: : regarding the various details she observed during her contact with the McCanns it is her opinion that they could be in some way involved in the disappearance of Madeleine.
Here is what I am referring to:
She says that about two weeks after Madeleine's disappearance, when the police made an appeal for information about a man, carrying a child, who had been seen in the Luz zone, and whose clothing was described, she wrote an anonymous letter to the British police, telling them the following: : regarding the various details she observed during her contact with the McCanns it is her opinion that they could be in some way involved in the disappearance of Madeleine.
She first found them aggressive and their reaction after she showed Madeleine's parents her credentials, also seemed strange to her. Afterwards she was informed that there were no signs of a break-in in the apartment. Knowing that they are doctors she found it absolutely abnormal that they left their children alone at home. Associating all of this with her professional experience, which tells her that in 99.99 % of missing children cases, the parents or other family members are involved, she felt it was her duty to inform the police of this.
She did this anonymously because she did not want to be bothered by the media. But she also states that according to what she remembers, when she met with Madeleine's parents, David Payne, who was with them, was wearing a dark polo shirt, blue or black coloured, cream coloured long trousers, of linen or cotton, and dark shoes (sandal/slipper type without a back buckle/catch). In her opinion, this clothing matches perfectly with the clothing the Police described the man (carrying the child) to be wearing at the time. All these coincidences made the witness think that the parents and their friends could possibly be involved in the disappearance of the child.
Certainly DP's hair is nothing like that described by Jane Tanner.
And JT say anything about a polo shirt?
I don't think so ...
-
Here is what I am referring to:
She says that about two weeks after Madeleine's disappearance, when the police made an appeal for information about a man, carrying a child, who had been seen in the Luz zone, and whose clothing was described, she wrote an anonymous letter to the British police, telling them the following: : regarding the various details she observed during her contact with the McCanns it is her opinion that they could be in some way involved in the disappearance of Madeleine.
She first found them aggressive and their reaction after she showed Madeleine's parents her credentials, also seemed strange to her. Afterwards she was informed that there were no signs of a break-in in the apartment. Knowing that they are doctors she found it absolutely abnormal that they left their children alone at home. Associating all of this with her professional experience, which tells her that in 99.99 % of missing children cases, the parents or other family members are involved, she felt it was her duty to inform the police of this.
She did this anonymously because she did not want to be bothered by the media. But she also states that according to what she remembers, when she met with Madeleine's parents, David Payne, who was with them, was wearing a dark polo shirt, blue or black coloured, cream coloured long trousers, of linen or cotton, and dark shoes (sandal/slipper type without a back buckle/catch). In her opinion, this clothing matches perfectly with the clothing the Police described the man (carrying the child) to be wearing at the time. All these coincidences made the witness think that the parents and their friends could possibly be involved in the disappearance of the child.
Certainly DP's hair is nothing like that described by Jane Tanner.
And JT say anything about a polo shirt?
I don't think so ...
JT never mentioned a polo shirt, neither did Martin Smith, I don't think!
I think she needs a visit to specsavers.
She must have spent an age eyeing up David Payne, can you see a scar he is supposed to have on the left of his face. I can't.
-
Here is what I am referring to:
She says that about two weeks after Madeleine's disappearance, when the police made an appeal for information about a man, carrying a child, who had been seen in the Luz zone, and whose clothing was described, she wrote an anonymous letter to the British police, telling them the following: : regarding the various details she observed during her contact with the McCanns it is her opinion that they could be in some way involved in the disappearance of Madeleine.
She first found them aggressive and their reaction after she showed Madeleine's parents her credentials, also seemed strange to her. Afterwards she was informed that there were no signs of a break-in in the apartment. Knowing that they are doctors she found it absolutely abnormal that they left their children alone at home. Associating all of this with her professional experience, which tells her that in 99.99 % of missing children cases, the parents or other family members are involved, she felt it was her duty to inform the police of this.
She did this anonymously because she did not want to be bothered by the media. But she also states that according to what she remembers, when she met with Madeleine's parents, David Payne, who was with them, was wearing a dark polo shirt, blue or black coloured, cream coloured long trousers, of linen or cotton, and dark shoes (sandal/slipper type without a back buckle/catch). In her opinion, this clothing matches perfectly with the clothing the Police described the man (carrying the child) to be wearing at the time. All these coincidences made the witness think that the parents and their friends could possibly be involved in the disappearance of the child.
Certainly DP's hair is nothing like that described by Jane Tanner.
And JT say anything about a polo shirt?
I don't think so ...
Remember her statements were before the release of the files when there was all sorts of descriptions of Tanner's sighting doing the rounds ( remember the blanket the child was supposed to be wrapped in ).
-
Remember her statements were before the release of the files when there was all sorts of descriptions of Tanner's sighting doing the rounds ( remember the blanket the child was supposed to be wrapped in ).
So JT's description doesn't remotely match DP.
I'm glad we agree.
-
So JT's description doesn't remotely match DP.
I'm glad we agree.
We do indeed.
YM unfortunately did not have access to the statements as we do.
-
Was Smithman's description in the public domain at that time or was that much later ?
What was the appeal that police put out two weeks afterwards about a man carrying a child ?
-
We do indeed.
YM unfortunately did not have access to the statements as we do.
So we've slain the canard that JT identified David Payne.
And we've simultaneously exposed the inaccuracy of YM's bogus claim that the man JT saw matches the description of DP ...
Two-out-of-two is (almost!) 100%
-
I'm sure you're right Carana but that doesn't alter the fact that they are.
BTW can you please point me to where I have exaggerated what YM said ?
I didn't say you had and I wasn't referring to YM.
-
I have my own personal view on the case that lead me to think there is more to this than abduction.
That being said, if an abduction were true, the McCanns did right turning a stranger away, credentials or not. This woman was not brought in by police. She asserted herself into a situation and asked invasive personal questions. Their child was taken by a stranger and now another stranger is entering their apartment and poking around asking about the child? My guard with be way up around any strangers. How would they know who to trust? I would not speak with her either. I am thinking they only answered her initially thinking it was required. DP was right to warn McCanns.
If this woman wanted to help she could have either offered her services to the police...or merely left a business card with the McCanns saying "call me if you need someone." The way she walked in an flashed credentials I feel was to lend credibility that she was somehow connected to case and police sent her. She did not begin introduction with "I was not asked to be here, just offering to help." She just barged in and IMO let it be assumed she was part of investigation.
-
I have my own personal view on the case that lead me to think there is more to this than abduction.
That being said, if an abduction were true, the McCanns did right turning a stranger away, credentials or not. This woman was not brought in by police. She asserted herself into a situation and asked invasive personal questions. Their child was taken by a stranger and now another stranger is entering their apartment and poking around asking about the child? My guard with be way up around any strangers. How would they know who to trust? I would not speak with her either. I am thinking they only answered her initially thinking it was required. DP was right to warn McCanns.
If this woman wanted to help she could have either offered her services to the police...or merely left a business card with the McCanns saying "call me if you need someone." The way she walked in an flashed credentials I feel was to lend credibility that she was somehow connected to case and police sent her. She did not begin introduction with "I was not asked to be here, just offering to help." She just barged in and IMO let it be assumed she was part of investigation.
Good to see another viewpoint. Welcome Kittkat
-
Good to see another viewpoint. Welcome Kittkat
I cannot come to terms with the actions of this individual who comes over to me as some sort of 'disaster tourist'.
She seems to have been determined to insert herself into the proceedings in any way she possibly could ... that we hear no more of her seems to show her assistance was not required however much she pushed herself forward.
-SNIP - - Meanwhile, she heard comments next to the complex reception that the British Consul was coming to the site and she decided to wait for this person in order to offer her help.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
-
Some people simply do the wrong thing for the right reasons. But I have to say that I wasn't wild about the anonymous letter. That could have been the right thing for the wrong reasons.
-
Some people simply do the wrong thing for the right reasons. But I have to say that I wasn't wild about the anonymous letter. That could have been the right thing for the wrong reasons.
I have no particular opinion. She may just have reacted on reflex and somehow thought that she could be of use. Her prior experience may have led her to assume that the family/friends may have been involved and wanted to share that with the police. I doubt that any modern police force would not have thought of that possibility without her intervention, but anyway.
Someone by the name of Yvonne Martin did sign the McCanns' petition with the following remark:
Name: Yvonne Martin on Nov 2, 2010
Comments: Madeleine has my full support.
-
Dunno, to be honest. I can see both sides.
On the one hand, she comes across as a noseyparker who intervened at an insensitive time.
On the other hand, any off-duty person (firefighter, medic, whoever) may have rushed to the scene of a crime / disaster out of a reflex reaction to try to help.
Whatever the motivation, her observations were taken into account and were discarded (except by Amaral & co.) End of story.
-
Many thanks for the welcome. That was very kind.
I have opinions like everyone else but I keep an open mind to everything. Until the day someone speaks or Madeline is found, no one knows for sure what really happened. I like studying cases but I can't presume to know anything except my own thoughts/feeling on the subject. I hope that works for this place :)
I agree that people do the right thing for the wrong reason but something about this woman's approach rubbed me wrong. See seemed to want "in." How could the McCanns trust she wasn't sent by abductor to get close to investigation? She could not fathom that? Of course she would be shooed away.
Quizzing grieving people even if she had "suspicions" was not her place any more than it was to march to front desk trying to get info from reception using same approach "flashing credentials." It was deceit by omission.
-
Many thanks for the welcome. That was very kind.
I have opinions like everyone else but I keep an open mind to everything. Until the day someone speaks or Madeline is found, no one knows for sure what really happened. I like studying cases but I can't presume to know anything except my own thoughts/feeling on the subject. I hope that works for this place :)
I agree that people do the right thing for the wrong reason but something about this woman's approach rubbed me wrong. See seemed to want "in." How could the McCanns trust she wasn't sent by abductor to get close to investigation? She could not fathom that? Of course she would be shooed away.
Quizzing grieving people even if she had "suspicions" was not her place any more than it was to march to front desk trying to get info from reception using same approach "flashing credentials." It was deceit by omission.
Welcome Kittcatt.
That morning, the family and close friends had had little sleep and had no idea why she was there asking what were felt to be insensitive questions at a time of total distress.
It could simply be one of those lost in communication issues.
-
I was afraid to answer for fear of being off topic but it would be rude not to reply.
As much as I hate to say it, it is obvious is parents are not being honest about what happened that night.
The inconsistancies are glaring. The behavior is so beyond "normal" to me. I don't know how to think abductor from that. I feel they tried to point things to a certain scenerio which to me says staging.
IMO, the inconsistancies cannot be merely from alcohol to confusion. Sadly, that points me to think they know far more than they are telling. If your child is missing every details can mean something. Honesty, not defensiveness, should be above all most important if you want your child found. No, it is not ok to hide details to save own skin. If they are not not being 100 percent forthcoming, they are not doing everything to find their child. I will let that comment stand to interpretation to what that means to me.
I do not buy they "didn't know the area well enough to pull this off" nor do I buy "there wasn't time." I will go into my reasons in other threads I imagine.
-
I was afraid to answer for fear of being off topic but it would be rude not to reply.
As much as I hate to say it, it is obvious is parents are not being honest about what happened that night.
The inconsistancies are glaring. The behavior is so beyond "normal" to me. I don't know how to think abductor from that. I feel they tried to point things to a certain scenerio which to me says staging.
IMO, the inconsistancies cannot be merely from alcohol to confusion. Sadly, that points me to think they know far more than they are telling. If your child is missing every details can mean something. Honesty, not defensiveness, should be above all most important if you want your child found. No, it is not ok to hide details to save own skin. If they are not not being 100 percent forthcoming, they are not doing everything to find their child. I will let that comment stand to interpretation to what that means to me.
I do not buy they "didn't know the area well enough to pull this off" nor do I buy "there wasn't time." I will go into my reasons in other threads I imagine.
Why do you hate to say it ?
-
I don't want to be sued lol.
Seriously, I hate the fact they led to me to feel by their own words and actions that they were involved.
I want to be able to give benefit of doubt. I want to believe them. I just can't see how this abductor theory is supposed to work. I suppose it makes me sad to think about parental involvement but I would be a fool not to consider the statistics on that.
-
'They are parents whose daughter is lost.'
Not 'abducted' then.
Thought so.
Erm, I dont see anything about that in davels post. You haven't invented it, have you?
-
Erm, I dont see anything about that in davels post. You haven't invented it, have you?
The clip.