UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: stephen25000 on July 27, 2014, 06:07:59 AM

Title: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on July 27, 2014, 06:07:59 AM
On the radio. LBC.

Detective going to sue the mccanns.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: jassi on July 27, 2014, 08:35:48 AM
In which country?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Matt Erixon on July 27, 2014, 08:46:28 AM
On the radio. LBC.

Detective going to sue the mccanns.

Interesting.
Any links?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on July 27, 2014, 08:57:55 AM
Interesting.
Any links?

I heard it on LBC this morning.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Matt Erixon on July 27, 2014, 08:59:45 AM
 8((()*/
I heard it on LBC this morning.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: sadie on July 27, 2014, 09:26:03 AM
I heard it on LBC this morning.
Links please Stephen.  No mention in newsnow or in google, that I can find.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Wonderfulspam on July 27, 2014, 09:36:35 AM
Yes Stephen, you must provide a cite or else it's just hearsay.

Like when Sean heard Amarals theory on a bus.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on July 27, 2014, 09:48:45 AM
Yes Stephen, you must provide a cite or else it's just hearsay.

Like when Sean heard Amarals theory on a bus.

I know, I'm terribly naughty.

Well for the benefit of the mccann supporters, it was the Steve Allen program. 8(0(*
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on July 27, 2014, 10:00:13 AM
I know, I'm terribly naughty.

Well for the benefit of the mccann supporters, it was the Steve Allen program. 8(0(*

Amaral has no grounds to sue the mccanns and you have almost certainly misunderstood what was said . Just a repeat of what amaral said on his facebook page
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on July 27, 2014, 10:03:21 AM
Amaral has no grounds to sue the mccanns and you have almost certainly misunderstood what was said . Just a repeat of what amaral said on his facebook page

No misunderstanding.

Very clear on the radio.

Are you calling the broadcaster Steve Allen a liar perchance ?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on July 27, 2014, 10:06:49 AM
No misunderstanding.

Very clear on the radio.

Are you calling the broadcaster Steve Allen a liar perchance ?
as I haven't heard what he said...I cant

You have completely misunderstood Kates statement re the PIs in Portugal so its quite possible you have misunderstood this...when we hear the exact words used we can make a judgement...strange no one else is reporting it
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on July 27, 2014, 10:12:04 AM
as I haven't heard what he said...I cant

You have completely misunderstood Kates statement re the PIs in Portugal so its quite possible you have misunderstood this...when we hear the exact words used we can make a judgement...strange no one else is reporting it

We shall see.

If it happens, just desserts.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on July 27, 2014, 10:15:03 AM
We shall see.

If it happens, just desserts.

Looks like your are backtracking already...you said amaral is to sue the mccanns...that's quite definite

Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on July 27, 2014, 10:17:52 AM
Looks like your are backtracking already...you said amaral is to sue the mccanns...that's quite definite

Not backtracking.

Let's see what happens.

....and I can think of very few people who need a taste of their own medicine than the mccanns.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on July 27, 2014, 10:21:32 AM
Not backtracking.

Let's see what happens.

....and I can think of very few people who need a taste of their own medicine than the mccanns.

Lets see what happens....you mean you may have misheard it and nothing will happen
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on July 27, 2014, 10:24:51 AM
Lets see what happens....you mean you may have misheard it and nothing will happen

No dave.

I say the same about the trial in Portugal. 8((()*/
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on July 27, 2014, 10:30:57 AM
No dave.

I say the same about the trial in Portugal. 8((()*/

but there is a trial in Portugal....there is no trial where amaral is suing the mccanns...you have misunderstood
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on July 27, 2014, 10:35:39 AM
but there is a trial in Portugal....there is no trial where amaral is suing the mccanns...you have misunderstood

Not yet. 8((()*/
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on July 27, 2014, 10:53:00 AM
Not yet. 8((()*/

yes another tic toc...but will amaral be able to sue the mccanns before amaral is spectacularly reinstated as head of the PJ and personally arrests the mccanns...overseas their prosecution...as they are jailed in portugal
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Wonderfulspam on July 27, 2014, 02:03:00 PM
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2707366/Former-Portuguese-policeman-sued-Madeleine-McCann-s-parents-claiming-faked-abduction-planning-sue-BACK.html

Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Jean-Pierre on July 27, 2014, 02:36:02 PM
Given that is IS the Daily Mail (funny how it suddenly becomes the delphic oracle at times like this) I do wonder on what grounds Amaral is intending to sue.

And where
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: ferryman on July 27, 2014, 02:38:34 PM
At the very least he would need to await the outcome of present proceedings.

Wouldn't he?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 27, 2014, 03:01:29 PM
He  can raise an action anytime it is not based on the outcome of this session. However, he can use evidence gained from Team McC outrageous and unsubstantiated claims for damages from Amaral. It seems to have unnerved a few "internet supporters" I can't think why.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: faithlilly on July 27, 2014, 03:10:38 PM
If Amaral does sue the McCanns surely they would have to fund their own defence this time as I really can't see anyway they would be able to justify using the fund.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on July 27, 2014, 03:17:41 PM
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2707366/Former-Portuguese-policeman-sued-Madeleine-McCann-s-parents-claiming-faked-abduction-planning-sue-BACK.html

So Steve Allen wasn't making it up on LBC.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: ferryman on July 27, 2014, 03:18:23 PM
If Amaral does sue the McCanns surely they would have to fund their own defence this time as I really can't see anyway they would be able to justify using the fund.

First things first.

Having written a book dripping with provable and proven lies that denigrate the McCanns, and having been taken to court for that book, what possible basis would Amaral have for suing the McCanns?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on July 27, 2014, 03:21:59 PM
First things first.

Having written a book dripping with provable and proven lies that denigrate the McCanns, and having been taken to court for that book, what possible basis would Amaral have for suing the McCanns?

Proven lies ???


Wait for the verdict ferryman.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 27, 2014, 03:24:13 PM
First things first.

Having written a book dripping with provable and proven lies that denigrate the McCanns, and having been taken to court for that book, what possible basis would Amaral have for suing the McCanns?

Well my dear I am sure one of the self appointed legal whizz kids on here will come up with a theory of how and why or how not and why not depending on which meadow they are grazing in at the time.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: faithlilly on July 27, 2014, 03:24:58 PM
First things first.

Having written a book dripping with provable and proven lies that denigrate the McCanns, and having been taken to court for that book, what possible basis would Amaral have for suing the McCanns?

The McCann-Metodo3-Correia link would, if proven, certainly give Amaral grounds to sue.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: ferryman on July 27, 2014, 03:28:45 PM
Proven lies ???


Wait for the verdict ferryman.


I don't need to do that.

I just need to read his book and compare it with the files.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on July 27, 2014, 03:30:49 PM


I don't need to do that.

I just need to read his book and compare it with the files.

It's not up to you ferryman.

It's up to a court(s).

Don't you know that ?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Brietta on July 27, 2014, 07:04:25 PM
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2707366/Former-Portuguese-policeman-sued-Madeleine-McCann-s-parents-claiming-faked-abduction-planning-sue-BACK.html

snipped from the mail ... Writing on Facebook, Amaral, 55 ...

FB ... a bit tacky for such an important announcement I would have thought.  Wonder why he didn't use his official channel this time?

Breaking News: Gonçalo Amaral to sue the McCanns                                                                                   http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2009/05/breaking-news-goncalo-amaral-to-sue.html

Gonçalo Amaral to countersue the McCanns                                                                                                         http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2010/10/goncalo-amaral-to-countersue-mccanns.html
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: faithlilly on July 27, 2014, 07:10:18 PM
snipped from the mail ... Writing on Facebook, Amaral, 55 ...

FB ... a bit tacky for such an important announcement I would have thought.  Wonder why he didn't use his official channel this time?

Breaking News: Gonçalo Amaral to sue the McCanns                                                                                   http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2009/05/breaking-news-goncalo-amaral-to-sue.html

Gonçalo Amaral to countersue the McCanns                                                                                                         http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2010/10/goncalo-amaral-to-countersue-mccanns.html

I believe the McCanns use their Facebook page for much the same reason.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: John on July 27, 2014, 07:20:57 PM
It seems the Daily Mail has caught up on the Amaral plans to counter-sue the McCanns story.  As I predicted several months ago this was always on the cards and so inevitable.

                        _________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _________ _________

MailOnline
Sunday 27July 2014

Former Portuguese policeman being sued by Madeleine McCann's parents for claiming they faked her abduction is planning to sue them BACK


The former Portuguese police chief accused of libelling Madeleine McCann's parents is planning to sue them back, it emerged today.

Goncalo Amaral, who was axed from the investigation into the missing three-year-old, accused Kate and Gerry McCann of causing him 'enormous damage' and the effect was 'moral, professional and financial'.

Writing on Facebook, Amaral, 55, said: 'The time to judicially react to those who put my privacy, intimacy, freedom of expression and opinion and survival at stake is approaching.

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2014/07/27/1406462843649_wps_1_The_former_Portuguese_pol.jpg)
The former Portuguese police chief Goncalo Amaral  arrives at the courthouse for the trial in which he is accused
of libel by the British couple Gerry and Kate McCann. He is now believed to be suing them back.

'They have tried to assassinate me civilly. But due to the support and solidarity of all of you, they were not successful.'

Amaral has been on trial at Lisbon's Palace of Justice after claiming Kate and Gerry McCann faked their daughter's abduction.  Now he is believed to be launching a counter case against the couple claiming they breached his right to 'privacy and freedom of expression'.

Amaral made the claims in a book about their role in the disappearance of their daughter from the family's holiday apartment in Praia da Luz in the Algarve in 2007.

The book, The Truth of the Lie, was published a year later. Amaral also ridiculed the McCanns' claims of feeling socially isolated by pointing out they spoke in Parliament and were quizzed by TV's Oprah Winfrey, The Sun on Sunday reported today.

Madeleine disappeared from her family's holiday apartment in Praia da Luz in the Algarve on May 3, 2007, as her parents dined at a nearby restaurant with friends.

The McCanns are suing for libel over claims made in Mr Amaral's 2008 book, including suggestions that they hid Madeleine's body after she died in an accident and faked an abduction.

They say the allegations damaged the hunt for their daughter and exacerbated their anguish.

Mr McCann also told the court in Lisbon that one group distributed a leaflet called 60 Reasons Why Madeleine McCann Was Not Abducted to their neighbours in Leicestershire.

If successful, the family stand to gain around £1million in damages. A judgment is not expected in the trial until later this year.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2707366/Former-Portuguese-policeman-sued-Madeleine-McCann-s-parents-claiming-faked-abduction-planning-sue-BACK.html
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: sadie on July 27, 2014, 07:24:46 PM
It seems the Daily Mail has caught up on the Amaral plans to counter-sue the McCanns story.

MailOnline
Sunday 27July 2014

Former Portuguese policeman being sued by Madeleine McCann's parents for claiming they faked her abduction is planning to sue them BACK

  • Goncalo Amaral accused McCanns of causing him 'enormous damage'
  • Writing on Facebook, he said: 'They have tried to assassinate me civilly'
  • The former police chief has been on trial at Lisbon's Palace of Justice
  • He claimed Kate and Gerry McCann faked their daughter's abduction
  • They say he exacerbated their anguish after Madeleine's disappearance

The former Portuguese police chief accused of libelling Madeleine McCann's parents is planning to sue them back, it emerged today.

Goncalo Amaral, who was axed from the investigation into the missing three-year-old, accused Kate and Gerry McCann of causing him 'enormous damage' and the effect was 'moral, professional and financial'.

Writing on Facebook, Amaral, 55, said: 'The time to judicially react to those who put my privacy, intimacy, freedom of expression and opinion and survival at stake is approaching.

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2014/07/27/1406462843649_wps_1_The_former_Portuguese_pol.jpg)
The former Portuguese police chief Goncalo Amaral  arrives at the courthouse for the trial in which he is accused of libel by the British couple Gerry and Kate McCann. He is now believed to be suing them back.
Just a threat atm.  Lets wait and see if anything materialises, shall we?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: pegasus on July 28, 2014, 01:23:35 AM
Correio Da Manha will have an article about the possible lawsuit later this morning (28 July)
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Brietta on July 28, 2014, 01:50:16 AM
Correio Da Manha will have an article about the possible lawsuit later this morning (28 July)

For as long as people are content to fund him Dr Amaral can really take out as many lawsuits as he feels he needs to.  Personally I would find it interesting; although I think it is something the Drs McCann could well do without as they suffer the anguish of watching the physical search for their daughter.

However in the longer term I believe Dr Amaral will run the risk of releasing the whirlwind of closer scrutiny.  He may not wish to do that.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: pegasus on July 28, 2014, 02:48:50 AM
For as long as people are content to fund him Dr Amaral can really take out as many lawsuits as he feels he needs to.  Personally I would find it interesting; although I think it is something the Drs McCann could well do without as they suffer the anguish of watching the physical search for their daughter.

However in the longer term I believe Dr Amaral will run the risk of releasing the whirlwind of closer scrutiny.  He may not wish to do that.
I think you will find that the supporters of Mr Amaral are ordinary people.
He has never had the support of millionaires Richard Branson, Brian Kennedy, Philip Green, Steven Winyard.
No-one has ever given him use of a private jet.
The UK government never fixed it for him to see the Pope.
Obviously Mr Amaral is a poor man as far as millionaire connections go.
Fortunately he more than makes up for that by being rich in down-to-earth integrity
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: faithlilly on July 28, 2014, 05:46:28 AM
For as long as people are content to fund him Dr Amaral can really take out as many lawsuits as he feels he needs to.  Personally I would find it interesting; although I think it is something the Drs McCann could well do without as they suffer the anguish of watching the physical search for their daughter.

However in the longer term I believe Dr Amaral will run the risk of releasing the whirlwind of closer scrutiny.  He may not wish to do that.

What will be interesting is watching the McCanns fund their own defence, as Amaral has had to do, without having the fund to rely on.

What a delicious irony that the seeds of the McCanns own ruin may lie in their own inhuman campaign of vilification against Amaral.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: faithlilly on July 28, 2014, 05:47:09 AM
I think you will find that the supporters of Mr Amaral are ordinary people.
He has never had the support of millionaires Richard Branson, Brian Kennedy, Philip Green, Steven Winyard.
No-one has ever given him use of a private jet.
The UK government never fixed it for him to see the Pope.
Obviously Mr Amaral is a poor man as far as millionaire connections go.
Fortunately he more than makes up for that by being rich in down-to-earth integrity

Well said Pegasus.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Benice on July 28, 2014, 08:02:16 AM
I think you will find that the supporters of Mr Amaral are ordinary people.
He has never had the support of millionaires Richard Branson, Brian Kennedy, Philip Green, Steven Winyard.
No-one has ever given him use of a private jet.
The UK government never fixed it for him to see the Pope.
Obviously Mr Amaral is a poor man as far as millionaire connections go.
Fortunately he more than makes up for that by being rich in down-to-earth integrity


Good Grief -  IMO Amaral is the lowest of the low - i.e. a corrupt policeman with a criminal conviction to prove it.   He  has also betrayed his wife's trust - and defrauded his own brother   - And you think he has integrity?

I've heard it all now.

IMO Amaral wouldn't stand a cat in hells chance of seeing the Pope.  IIRC the Catholic church does not condone divorce or adulterers.   His  name appearing in Amnesty International under the torture section would also be a bit of an obstacle imo.

Any suggestion that there is something wrong with rich people supporting the McCanns is inexplicable to me.  What's that all about?
 
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: ferryman on July 28, 2014, 08:09:31 AM
I think you will find that the supporters of Mr Amaral are ordinary people.

Very ordinary indeed.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 28, 2014, 08:13:33 AM
Amaral's threat to sue the McCanns first surfaced in 2009, so I wouldn't get too excited just yet Ammyfans.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: ferryman on July 28, 2014, 08:21:04 AM
Amaral's threat to sue the McCanns first surfaced in 2009, so I wouldn't get too excited just yet Ammyfans.

On what grounds?

Having the temerity to tear to shreds the factual inaccuracy and explicit calumny of (in) his book ...
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Brietta on July 28, 2014, 10:11:13 AM
What will be interesting is watching the McCanns fund their own defence, as Amaral has had to do, without having the fund to rely on.

What a delicious irony that the seeds of the McCanns own ruin may lie in their own inhuman campaign of vilification against Amaral.

Actually I have been a bit amazed by the easy ride Dr Amaral has had from the British gutter press;  probably because he isn’t really all that ‘newsworthy’; for example up until last September I could not have spelt his name let alone know anything about him, probably in line with the majority of the Great British public.

That will change if he proceeds with his counter action as he has been threatening to do since 2009 and the ‘delicious irony’ will be to see what else the press have on him that we don’t yet know about.

Maybe this is his cunning plan to throw a spanner into the works of Portuguese/ Brit concord and disrupt the investigation into Madeleine’s case which has hung his investigation out to dry in the eyes of the world.

If and when the press turn their sights on him … it would be worth remembering that they will not be required to print any libels as it is mostly a matter of record. 
Should be worth a consideration particularly if there are things there he would prefer to keep out of the public domain.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: faithlilly on July 28, 2014, 11:28:12 AM
Actually I have been a bit amazed by the easy ride Dr Amaral has had from the British gutter press;  probably because he isn’t really all that ‘newsworthy’; for example up until last September I could not have spelt his name let alone know anything about him, probably in line with the majority of the Great British public.

That will change if he proceeds with his counter action as he has been threatening to do since 2009 and the ‘delicious irony’ will be to see what else the press have on him that we don’t yet know about.

Maybe this is his cunning plan to throw a spanner into the works of Portuguese/ Brit concord and disrupt the investigation into Madeleine’s case which has hung his investigation out to dry in the eyes of the world.

If and when the press turn their sights on him … it would be worth remembering that they will not be required to print any libels as it is mostly a matter of record. 
Should be worth a consideration particularly if there are things there he would prefer to keep out of the public domain.

If everything is already a matter of record, what has Amaral to fear ? And TBH why would he fear what a bunch of British Sun-readers think of him anyway ? Many thousands of the GBP has helped him fund his defence against the vexatious litigation of the McCanns and so he knows he has the support here that a few dodgy tabloid stories won't alter.

BTW why do you think Amaral suing the McCanns would have any effect on the present SY/PJ investigation ?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Brietta on July 28, 2014, 11:52:08 AM
If everything is already a matter of record, what has Amaral to fear ? And TBH why would he fear what a bunch of British Sun-readers think of him anyway ? Many thousands of the GBP has helped him fund his defence against the vexatious litigation of the McCanns and so he knows he has the support here that a few dodgy tabloid stories won't alter.

BTW why do you think Amaral suing the McCanns would have any effect on the present SY/PJ investigation ?


I imagine a large proportion of Dr Amaral's support are SUN readers; maybe the light will begin to dawn on some when they read what will be printed in its inimical journalistic style; could very well end up in there being no funds available and yet another Portuguese lawyer whistling for his remuneration.

Full of questions aren't you Faithlilly? ANSWER- I believe a xenophobic press war between organs like the Sun and Portuguese equivalents of the Sun will play directly into the hands of idiots like the poster defacers, grafitti painters and Stop the McCann Circus oddballs who seem to get a kick from supporting child abductors. That is my answer if you do not like it ... tough.


Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: faithlilly on July 28, 2014, 12:09:20 PM

I imagine a large proportion of Dr Amaral's support are SUN readers; maybe the light will begin to dawn on some when they read what will be printed in its inimical journalistic style; could very well end up in there being no funds available and yet another Portuguese lawyer whistling for his remuneration.

Full of questions aren't you Faithlilly? ANSWER- I believe a xenophobic press war between organs like the Sun and Portuguese equivalents of the Sun will play directly into the hands of idiots like the poster defacers, grafitti painters and Stop the McCann Circus oddballs who seem to get a kick from supporting child abductors. That is my answer if you do not like it ... tough.

That you imagine the Sun/NOTW ( as was ) readership are supportive of Amaral when, in reality, they have been the vehicle of choice for the McCanns when pushing their xenophobic campaign against the Portuguese people in general and Amaral in particular  is simply ridiculous.

And why you think the press, at war or otherwise, or a few malcontents will scupper the SY/PJ investigation heaven alone knows.

Still it never hurts to give the 'Amaral is hurting the search for Madeleine by his actions' lie another airing, does it ? ;0)
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Brietta on July 28, 2014, 12:18:32 PM
I was just posing the opposite to your opinion.

You seem to believe we support abductors because we don't succumb to the abduction mantra.

My personal opinion is that anyone who supports the McCanns, actively endorses the concealment of little girls dead bodies.


if you do not like it ... tough.

I do not like what you accused me of in the slightest and I take it as a personal insult.  You are so used to being offensive where the Drs McCann are concerned, you just do not know where to draw the line on common decency.

People like you have done all in your power to impede and indeed stop the present investigation into what happened to Madeleine McCann.  Cui bono from that other than the perpetrators of an horrific crime?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Brietta on July 28, 2014, 12:20:59 PM
That you imagine the Sun/NOTW ( as was ) readership are supportive of Amaral when, in reality, they have been the vehicle of choice for the McCanns when pushing their xenophobic campaign against the Portuguese people in general and Amaral in particular  is simply ridiculous.

And why you think the press, at war or otherwise, or a few malcontents will scupper the SY/PJ investigation heaven alone knows.

Still it never hurts to give the 'Amaral is hurting the search for Madeleine by his actions' lie another airing, does it ? ;0)

Going to be interesting to see which one of us the judge agrees with, won't it?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Wonderfulspam on July 28, 2014, 12:26:34 PM
I do not like what you accused me of in the slightest and I take it as a personal insult.  You are so used to being offensive where the Drs McCann are concerned, you just do not know where to draw the line on common decency.

People like you have done all in your power to impede and indeed stop the present investigation into what happened to Madeleine McCann.  Cui bono from that other than the perpetrators of an horrific crime?

I apologise for having an opinion contrary to your own & expressing such.

People like you have done all in your power to impede and indeed stop the present investigation

People like me.

So, not actually me specifically then, ok.

An horrific crime is it now?

Strange, I thought she disappeared.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 28, 2014, 01:26:20 PM
It is actually true that paedophiles in the catholic church do believe children are a 'gift from God'.
The history of the Catholic church and child abuse is horrific.

Kate did mention that she was angry at God- she kind of blamed him because she specifically asked him to take care of her in prayer Tsk... is there no end to this list of people/Gods to blame. I think she should sue God-after all he made them all didn't he? How could he sit back and let this happen?


[ off topic content deleted ]
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: John on July 28, 2014, 02:34:15 PM
Gonçalo Amaral to sue the McCanns

Correio da Manhã
28 July 2014

by John C. Robinson

Former Judiciary Police coordinator revealed that the time to respond in court is approaching.

All that remains for me is to proceed with a case against the McCanns and others, in order to be compensated for the enormous damage they have caused me, at all levels: moral, professional and financially. 

The time to respond in court against all those who have questioned my privacy, privacy, freedom of expression and survival conditions is approaching.  It was in this way that Gonçalo Amaral announced in English and through Facebook, his intentions towards Kate and Gerry McCann, parents of Madeleine, the missing girl from Praia da Luz in May 2007.

Without announcing dates, the former coordinator of the Police Judicial is preparing to respond to the € 1.2 million suit that still runs in the Civil Court of Lisbon.  The British couple demand to be compensated for the damage caused by the book 'True Lies', where Amaral defends the thesis that Kate and Gerry concealed the body of Maddie or simulated an abduction.

www.translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=pt&u=http://www.cmjornal.xl.pt/detalhe/noticias/nacional/portugal/goncalo-amaral-vai-processar-casal-mccann&prev=/search%3Fq%3Dgon%25C3%25A7alo%2Bamaral%2Bvai%2Bprocessar%2Bcasal%2Bmccann%26client%3Dms-opera-mobile%26channel%3Dnew
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 28, 2014, 02:45:37 PM
According to "Faithlilly" Goncalo has been receiving financial support from "many thousands" of the Great British Public, a claim which I find highly improbable - it would be nice to see some actual evidence to support it!  But let's say it's true, then maybe that accounts for his emboldened threat to sue the McCanns - why, if he's rolling in spare cash now then why not use it to try and get his revenge?  After all he's been threatening to do so for five long years, time to put his money where his mouth is!
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: misty on July 28, 2014, 02:46:42 PM
Gonçalo Amaral to sue the McCanns

Correio da Manhã
28 July 2014

by John C. Robinson

Former Judiciary Police coordinator revealed that the time to respond in court is approaching.

All that remains for me is to proceed with a case against the McCanns and others, in order to be compensated for the enormous damage they have caused me, at all levels: moral, professional and financially. 

The time to react to trial all those who have questioned my privacy, privacy, freedom of expression and survival conditions are approaching.  It was in this way that Gonçalo Amaral announced in English and through Facebook, which will render Kate and Gerry McCann, parents of Madeleine, the missing girl from Praia da Luz in May 2007.

Excluding announce dates, the former coordinator of the Police Judicial prepares to respond well to the € 1.2 million that still runs in the Civil Court of Lisbon.  The British couple demands to be compensated for the damage caused by the book 'True Lies', where Amaral defends the thesis that Kate and Gerry concealed the body of Maddie or simulated an abduction.

www.translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=pt&u=http://www.cmjornal.xl.pt/detalhe/noticias/nacional/portugal/goncalo-amaral-vai-processar-casal-mccann&prev=/search%3Fq%3Dgon%25C3%25A7alo%2Bamaral%2Bvai%2Bprocessar%2Bcasal%2Bmccann%26client%3Dms-opera-mobile%26channel%3Dnew

It's pure & simple spite. His golden goose has all but stopped laying eggs & its feathers are now falling out.
Perish the thought the McCanns should even partly enjoy the summer holidays with the twins when he is facing humiliation & destitution after abusing his position as an officer of the law.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: John on July 28, 2014, 02:50:14 PM
I fear this can only get worse if he goes ahead with what some perceive to be a threat.  The McCanns could see their own assets frozen pending the outcome of another libel trial.  Remember, he is not threatening to sue the Fund. 
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Angelo222 on July 28, 2014, 02:58:02 PM
I fear this can only get worse if he goes ahead with what some perceive to be a threat.  The McCanns could see their own assets frozen pending the outcome of another libel trial.  Remember, he is not threatening to sue the Fund.

Did somebody mention the Ace card which is no longer up his sleeve??   @)(++(*
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: misty on July 28, 2014, 03:04:17 PM
I fear this can only get worse if he goes ahead with what some perceive to be a threat.  The McCanns could see their own assets frozen pending the outcome of another libel trial.  Remember, he is not threatening to sue the Fund.

Amaral has invaded the privacy & affected the reputation of many people involved in this case with his actions, not least the remaining Tapas members & the Murats. I can see lawyers salivating at the prospect of counter-suing, on behalf of said folk, not only Amaral but the Portuguese state, for permitting an illegal breach of judicial secrecy, should Amaral issue any proceedings.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on July 28, 2014, 03:09:41 PM
I fear this can only get worse if he goes ahead with what some perceive to be a threat.  The McCanns could see their own assets frozen pending the outcome of another libel trial.  Remember, he is not threatening to sue the Fund.

apart from the fact that this may never happen...apart from the fact he lost his libel trial against the lawyer....what power do Portuguese courts have to freeze assets in the UK...none
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: John on July 28, 2014, 03:17:09 PM
apart from the fact that this may never happen...apart from the fact he lost his libel trial against the lawyer....what power do Portuguese courts have to freeze assets in the UK...none

You are assuming of course that he would not sue them in the UK.  And the reason he lost the libel trial against Correia was because the assault on Cipriano by police was accepted by the Court as having been established.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: ferryman on July 28, 2014, 03:19:37 PM
I apologise for having an opinion contrary to your own & expressing such.

People like you have done all in your power to impede and indeed stop the present investigation

People like me.

So, not actually me specifically then, ok.

An horrific crime is it now?

Strange, I thought she disappeared.

Madeleine disappeared because Madeleine was abducted.

And abduction is an horrific crime ...
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Eleanor on July 28, 2014, 03:22:57 PM
I fear this can only get worse if he goes ahead with what some perceive to be a threat.  The McCanns could see their own assets frozen pending the outcome of another libel trial.  Remember, he is not threatening to sue the Fund.

The McCanns haven't got any assets.  And their "Mansion" is mortgaged to the hilt.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on July 28, 2014, 03:26:07 PM
You are assuming of course that he would not sue them in the UK.  And the reason he lost the libel trial against Correia was because the assault on Cipriano by police was accepted by the Court as having been established.

we all know how the law works in the uk and I cannot see any grounds to sue...can you
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: ferryman on July 28, 2014, 03:28:06 PM
I fear this can only get worse if he goes ahead with what some perceive to be a threat.  The McCanns could see their own assets frozen pending the outcome of another libel trial.  Remember, he is not threatening to sue the Fund.

What on earth are you on about?

The McCanns have taken Amaral to court for telling a pack of demonstrable lies in a best-selling book and a best-selling film, both sold for profit in countries throughout Europe.

What possible action against the McCanns could Amaral have for that?

Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: ferryman on July 28, 2014, 03:33:36 PM
'They [the McCanns] have tried to assassinate me civilly. But due to the support and solidarity of all of you, they were not successful.'

Has Amaral had a sneak preview of a judgment (so far as the rest of us are concerned) yet to be delivered in the ibel trial?

Yes, that's libel trial ... ?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Brietta on July 28, 2014, 03:36:00 PM
Did somebody mention the Ace card which is no longer up his sleeve??   @)(++(*

Do you think this threatened law suit is it?  Not the Ace of Hearts then ... more the Ace of Spades ... and the bleatings of desperation.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Eleanor on July 28, 2014, 03:40:29 PM

If Amaral wins this case, will he have to wait for all of the appeals to be sorted before he can sue The McCanns?  Although I am not sure for what.

But if he loses, who will he sue then?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Jean-Pierre on July 28, 2014, 03:58:09 PM
According to "Faithlilly" Goncalo has been receiving financial support from "many thousands" of the Great British Public, a claim which I find highly improbable - it would be nice to see some actual evidence to support it!  But let's say it's true, then maybe that accounts for his emboldened threat to sue the McCanns - why, if he's rolling in spare cash now then why not use it to try and get his revenge?  After all he's been threatening to do so for five long years, time to put his money where his mouth is!

Perhaps pay his recently ex lawer first, may be a wise move.  Not sure how many UK lawyers will be falling over themselves to take the case otherwise. 

Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: slartibartfast on July 28, 2014, 04:17:32 PM
Perhaps pay his recently ex lawer first, may be a wise move.  Not sure how many UK lawyers will be falling over themselves to take the case otherwise.

Maybe he will employ Carter Ruck.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Eleanor on July 28, 2014, 04:34:39 PM
Maybe he will employ Carter Ruck.

I don't think so.  His supporters can't afford Carter Ruck.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Jean-Pierre on July 28, 2014, 04:39:01 PM
I don't think so.  His supporters can't afford Carter Ruck.

I am pretty sure Cater Ruck would represent The Devil himself.  But may want paying upfront

Probably not a problem for Beelzebub, but more of a challenge for Amaral. 
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: ferryman on July 28, 2014, 04:45:01 PM
I am pretty sure Cater Ruck would represent The Devil himself.  But may want paying upfront

Probably not a problem for Beelzebub, but more of a challenge for Amaral.

 @)(++(*

On a serious note, though, wouldn't there be a conflict of interest for Carter Ruck to represent Amaral given that they have represented the McCanns (assuming, hypothetically, that money was not an obstacle)?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Eleanor on July 28, 2014, 04:48:59 PM
@)(++(*

On a serious note, though, wouldn't there be a conflict of interest for Carter Ruck to represent Amaral given that they have represented the McCanns (assuming, hypothetically, that money was not an obstacle)?

Phew.  Thank goodness for that.

Absolutely right, of course.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: DCI on July 28, 2014, 04:57:18 PM
Perhaps pay his recently ex lawer first, may be a wise move.  Not sure how many UK lawyers will be falling over themselves to take the case otherwise.

Come on JP, there's one fine, famous lawyer just waiting to represent him. Pro bono.

Just can't think of his name at the moment!  8(>((

Then there's Enid to do his accounts, no problemo.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Eleanor on July 28, 2014, 05:03:09 PM
Come on JP, there's one fine, famous lawyer just waiting to represent him. Pro bono.

Just can't think of his name at the moment!  8(>((

Then there's Enid to do his accounts, no problemo.

Ah.  Now this just might be a possibility.  It wouldn't have to be a Barrister, would it.

Can't wait.

Sorry.  Got to go and have a lie down.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 28, 2014, 05:32:00 PM
I fear this can only get worse if he goes ahead with what some perceive to be a threat.  The McCanns could see their own assets frozen pending the outcome of another libel trial.  Remember, he is not threatening to sue the Fund.
Personally I think it's more like that hell will freeze over than the McCanns assets be frozen anytime soon. 
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 28, 2014, 05:35:00 PM
Did somebody mention the Ace card which is no longer up his sleeve??   @)(++(*
Less an ace, more a last straw to be desperately grasped at I would say.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on July 28, 2014, 06:37:24 PM
the problem amaral has is his criminal conviction. He has no defence against anyone calling him  a disgraced cop.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 28, 2014, 06:43:36 PM
the problem amaral has is his criminal conviction. He has no defence against anyone calling him  a disgraced cop.
does Amaral believe in free speech or not?  It's hard to tell with this latest threat of legal action.  What exactly is his complaint?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Jean-Pierre on July 28, 2014, 06:56:35 PM
Come on JP, there's one fine, famous lawyer just waiting to represent him. Pro bono.

Just can't think of his name at the moment!  8(>((

Then there's Enid to do his accounts, no problemo.

Are we talking about the Harlow whizzkid?

Well he could apply to be readmitted as a solicitor

Amaral really needs a fine legal brain to advise him
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: DCI on July 28, 2014, 07:06:47 PM
Are we talking about the Harlow whizzkid?

Well he could apply to be readmitted as a solicitor

Amaral really needs a fine legal brain to advise him

Yes that's the one.

He doesn't need to be re admitted does he? He can do what he likes.

Would Amaral find a better legal brain, than that one? I don't think he would.


Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Montclair on July 28, 2014, 07:15:00 PM
You are assuming of course that he would not sue them in the UK.  And the reason he lost the libel trial against Correia was because the assault on Cipriano by police was accepted by the Court as having been established.

The judges at the libel trial decided in favour of Marcos Aragão Correia because they said that he had the right to believe what his client told him.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Carew on July 28, 2014, 07:35:00 PM
Come on JP, there's one fine, famous lawyer just waiting to represent him. Pro bono.

Just can't think of his name at the moment!  8(>((

Then there's Enid to do his accounts, no problemo.

Passing the popcorn around again are we whilst waving our LOL placards?

( Or is it time for that jolly emoticon in which we all smack ourselves in the head chanting "stop the insanity!")

Such jollity we bring to this place from the Lower First Form.

Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: DCI on July 28, 2014, 07:37:03 PM
The judges at the libel trial decided in favour of Marcos Aragão Correia because they said that he had the right to believe what his client told him.

The judges at the defamation trial decided in favour of Marcos Aragão Correia.

Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: ferryman on July 28, 2014, 07:41:50 PM
Passing the popcorn around again are we whilst waving our LOL placards?

( Or is it time for that jolly emoticon in which we all smack ourselves in the head chanting "stop the insanity!")

Such jollity we bring to this place from the Lower First Form.

Sometimes gallows-humour (as a prelude to confirmation of grim and unrelenting tragedy such as confirmation that Kate and Gerry McCann are victims of the worst news possible about Madeleine) has a place ...
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Montclair on July 29, 2014, 10:31:28 AM
The judges at the defamation trial decided in favour of Marcos Aragão Correia.

As I said the judge acquitted Marcos Aragão Correia because he repeated what his client, Leonor Cipriano, told him and believed her. That does not mean that what he said was true though.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: John on July 29, 2014, 02:15:20 PM
As I said the judge acquitted Marcos Aragão Correia because he repeated what his client, Leonor Cipriano, told him and believed her. That does not mean that what he said was true though.

Yes, that's correct too Montclair, I knew I had missed out something from my original post.  Marcos has got off very lightly so far but I fear he has upset some very powerful people which might come back to bite him in the ass.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Eleanor on July 29, 2014, 03:02:06 PM

There is something not quite right here.  Amaral can't sue The McCanns for suing him.  This Trial, whatever it is for, is a straightforward  win or lose situation.
The winner can't sue the loser for losing.  The Law would be utter chaos if they could.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 29, 2014, 03:06:07 PM
There is something not quite right here.  Amaral can't sue The McCanns for suing him.  This Trial, whatever it is for, is a straightforward  win or lose situation.
The winner can't sue the loser for losing.  The Law would be utter chaos if they could.
Ah, but can the loser sue the winners for winning?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Eleanor on July 29, 2014, 03:22:30 PM
Ah, but can the loser sue the winners for winning?

Erm......I don't think so.  But I suppose he could try.  But what for exactly?

Free Speech is for everybody.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: ferryman on July 29, 2014, 03:40:45 PM
Ah, but can the loser sue the winners for winning?

I'm fairly certain not.

But if so, I have just 3, probably very highly xenophobic, words:

Only in Portugal ...
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on July 29, 2014, 03:42:30 PM
just looked on the facebook page and this is the line....

Or to lead me to ponder, as I do, to file a lawsuit against the McCann couple and others...

So  he is NOT filing a lawsuit against the mccanns....he is just THINKING about it
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Jean-Pierre on July 29, 2014, 04:06:07 PM
Erm......I don't think so.  But I suppose he could try.  But what for exactly?

Free Speech is for everybody.

The answer is no.  Under all legal systems.  If the court makes judgement against you then to sue the other party on those grounds would be an "insult" to the court - although it would of course never get past first base. 

This is quite different from leave to appeal a decision, where the decision of the lower court would be reviewd by a higher court, until eventually all appeals are exhausted when the final judgement will stand.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfred R Jones on July 29, 2014, 05:35:15 PM
Erm......I don't think so.  But I suppose he could try.  But what for exactly?

Free Speach is for everybody.
For being jolly rotten sports and not allowing him to make money out of writing a book full of unfounded accusations about them I guess...
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Carana on July 29, 2014, 05:58:04 PM
The answer is no.  Under all legal systems.  If the court makes judgement against you then to sue the other party on those grounds would be an "insult" to the court - although it would of course never get past first base. 

This is quite different from leave to appeal a decision, where the decision of the lower court would be reviewd by a higher court, until eventually all appeals are exhausted when the final judgement will stand.

If he did try to sue them, the jurisdiction would be Portugal, wouldn't it?
http://ec.europa.eu/justice/civil/files/study_privacy_annexe_3_en.pdf (The section on PT starts on p. 121.)

Even in Portugal, I still don't see what grounds he would have...
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Eleanor on July 29, 2014, 06:08:46 PM

If he wins his reputation is restored.  Nothing to sue for.

If he loses his reputation is trashed.  Nothing to sue for.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on July 30, 2014, 07:42:33 AM
I await to see if he gives the mccanns what they truly deserve.

A libel trial.

I.M.O. of course. 8)-)))
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Benice on July 30, 2014, 08:23:06 AM
I await to see if he gives the mccanns what they truly deserve.

A libel trial.

I.M.O. of course. 8)-)))


Where and when  have they libelled him?    Can you give an example please.


.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on July 30, 2014, 08:36:38 AM

Where and when  have they libelled him?    Can you give an example please.


.


Why don't you read through his statements on this issue ?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on July 30, 2014, 08:45:10 AM

Why don't you read through his statements on this issue ?

amaral has already lost one libel case..is on track to lose another...very poor judgement if he starts a third
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on July 30, 2014, 08:50:22 AM
amaral has already lost one libel case..is on track to lose another...very poor judgement if he starts a third

As you know, it is very difficult to prove libel in Portugal, and proceedings will carry on for years, draining the resources of the mccanns.

I'm sure they will be happy with that.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on July 30, 2014, 08:52:36 AM
As you know, it is very difficult to prove libel in Portugal, and proceedings will carry on for years, draining the resources of the mccanns.

I'm sure they will be happy with that.

That's why I think amaral has no intention of suing the mccanns
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on July 30, 2014, 08:53:51 AM
That's why I think amaral has no intention of suing the mccanns

We shall see on that.

After all, what does he have to lose ?

Now,  time for work.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Benice on July 30, 2014, 08:54:17 AM

Why don't you read through his statements on this issue ?

I'm interested in your opinion not Amaral's,  It was your opinion that the McCanns 'truly deserve' to be sued for libel by him.
   
Where and when in your opinion have the McCanns libelled Amaral - and can you give an example please.

Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Jean-Pierre on July 30, 2014, 09:23:48 AM
No chance of a straight answer to that, Bernice.  You might get another question though.   8)--))
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: faithlilly on July 30, 2014, 10:23:04 AM
I'm interested in your opinion not Amaral's,  It was your opinion that the McCanns 'truly deserve' to be sued for libel by him.
   
Where and when in your opinion have the McCanns libelled Amaral - and can you give an example please.


Do we know , if it happens, that he will sue the McCanns for libel ?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Benice on June 02, 2016, 08:15:49 AM
I don't think there was any doubt as to the grounds on which the McCanns decided to due Amaral.  Anyone reading his book or watching his TV progs would have no difficulty in working that out imo mercury.     

On the other hand I have no idea on what grounds Amaral could sue the McCanns and their friends -  especially their friends - who weren't even made arguidos in this case.

Hence my asking  ... 'Any ideas?   

Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 08:25:55 AM
I don't think there was any doubt as to the grounds on which the McCanns decided to due Amaral.  Anyone reading his book or watching his TV progs would have no difficulty in working that out imo mercury.     

On the other hand I have no idea on what grounds Amaral could sue the McCanns and their friends -  especially their friends - who weren't even made arguidos in this case.

Hence my asking  ... 'Any ideas?

The very fact taht amaral is talking of suing the mccanns friends shows he has not thought this through properl...anyone who disagrees tell me what grounds he has.....and...the supreme court have not made their decision yet
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: G-Unit on June 02, 2016, 08:43:55 AM
I don't think there was any doubt as to the grounds on which the McCanns decided to due Amaral.  Anyone reading his book or watching his TV progs would have no difficulty in working that out imo mercury.     

On the other hand I have no idea on what grounds Amaral could sue the McCanns and their friends -  especially their friends - who weren't even made arguidos in this case.

Hence my asking  ... 'Any ideas?

I don't know about the 'friends', wasn't that said a long time ago? Recently Amaral's lawyer said;

"We will proceed with a claim for compensation against the McCann couple. These have been years of losses", said Miguel Cruz Rodrigues, the lawyer of the former inspector to Expresso. At stake are the financial damages caused by the prohibition of the sale of Gonçalo Amaral's book following the favourable court decisions for the parents of Madeleine McCann, the English girl who went missing in the Algarve on May 3, 2007.

The defence of Gonçalo Amaral argues that the former inspector feels harmed not only at a monetary level but also morally. And that his good name has been called into question in this case.
http://joana-morais.blogspot.co.uk/2016/04/portuguese-media-goncalo-amaral-to.html
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 08:46:36 AM
I don't know about the 'friends', wasn't that said a long time ago? Recently Amaral's lawyer said;

"We will proceed with a claim for compensation against the McCann couple. These have been years of losses", said Miguel Cruz Rodrigues, the lawyer of the former inspector to Expresso. At stake are the financial damages caused by the prohibition of the sale of Gonçalo Amaral's book following the favourable court decisions for the parents of Madeleine McCann, the English girl who went missing in the Algarve on May 3, 2007.

The defence of Gonçalo Amaral argues that the former inspector feels harmed not only at a monetary level but also morally. And that his good name has been called into question in this case.
http://joana-morais.blogspot.co.uk/2016/04/portuguese-media-goncalo-amaral-to.html

he feels his good name has been bought into question...isn't that a bit odd...what has happened to the freedom of speech he has talked about
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Benice on June 02, 2016, 09:21:33 AM
I don't know about the 'friends', wasn't that said a long time ago? Recently Amaral's lawyer said;

"We will proceed with a claim for compensation against the McCann couple. These have been years of losses", said Miguel Cruz Rodrigues, the lawyer of the former inspector to Expresso. At stake are the financial damages caused by the prohibition of the sale of Gonçalo Amaral's book following the favourable court decisions for the parents of Madeleine McCann, the English girl who went missing in the Algarve on May 3, 2007.

The defence of Gonçalo Amaral argues that the former inspector feels harmed not only at a monetary level but also morally. And that his good name has been called into question in this case.
http://joana-morais.blogspot.co.uk/2016/04/portuguese-media-goncalo-amaral-to.html

What  monetary losses?   And what good name?   How can a policeman who abused his position of trust to such an extent that it resulted in a criminal conviction - claim to still have a good name?     Surely that conviction alone left his 'good name' in tatters.    He's a corrupt policeman fgs.

IMO the only people he can potentially sue regarding financial losses in relation to the sale of his book are his own supporters who have distributed it for free on the internet.




Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: John on June 02, 2016, 09:57:43 AM
It really is very simple, the McCanns by their actions have crucified Gonçalo Amaral financially over the last few years.  They blocked sales of his book and dvd and sequestrated his income.  Now that the Portuguese Court of Appeal has ordained that he had the right to publish what he did he has the opportunity to seek redress for all losses incurred. This could amount to more than the original claim.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 10:07:48 AM
It really is very simple, the McCanns by their actions have crucified Gonçalo Amaral financially over the last few years.  They blocked sales of his book and dvd and sequestrated his income.  Now that the Portuguese Court of Appeal has ordained that he had the right to publish what he did he has the opportunity to seek redress for all losses incurred. This could amount to more than the original claim.

i think you are totally wrong...it is the court who banned the book. We had two years of Murats lawyer saying he was going to sue JT and nothing came of it
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: xtina on June 02, 2016, 10:28:02 AM
The very fact taht amaral is talking of suing the mccanns friends shows he has not thought this through properl...anyone who disagrees tell me what grounds he has.....and...the supreme court have not made their decision yet


i think you will find it was the mccs who never thought this through properly

but after saying that ...through there actions ..[again]

they are creating more and more people to question ...the so called abduction

why they have such a hatred for .G A ...

why they never left well alone..and just let the book die a death

there continued we want this man to suffer ...attitude....gives advertisement ..money could not buy...

maddie suffered because of there actions ...as i would say so did G A children ...and god knows how many more who has dared to voice an opinion ...

they are so hell bent ....from the beginning ....protecting themselves ....if only they had done such a good job protecting maddie ...as there so called reputation....or everyone must believe abduction
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 10:31:51 AM

i think you will find it was the mccs who never thought this through properly

but after saying that ...through there actions ..[again]

they are creating more and more people to question ...the so called abduction

why they have such a hatred for .G A ...

why they never left well alone..and just let the book die a death

there continued we want this man to suffer ...attitude....gives advertisement ..money could not buy...

maddie suffered because of there actions ...as i would say so did G A children ...and god knows how many more who has dared to voice an opinion ...

they are so hell bent ....from the beginning ....protecting themselves ....if only they had done such a good job protecting maddie ...as there so called reputation....or everyone must believe abduction

I think only a few question abduction. Many criticise them for leaving the children alone but in my experience most think she was abducted
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 10:44:05 AM
I think only a few question abduction. Many criticise them for leaving the children alone but in my experience most think she was abducted

How many were there in your sample ?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: xtina on June 02, 2016, 10:50:40 AM
I think only a few question abduction. Many criticise them for leaving the children alone but in my experience most think she was abducted

don't you think that could possibly be at the moment ....

because very few dare say any other for fear of getting sued by the mccs..
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: G-Unit on June 02, 2016, 10:53:46 AM
i think you are totally wrong...it is the court who banned the book. We had two years of Murats lawyer saying he was going to sue JT and nothing came of it

The courts acted at the McCann's request.

I didn't know that re; Murat. I wonder if they would have had a case had there been a statement in the files saying she identified him? All there is is Amaral saying she did.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: John on June 02, 2016, 11:07:12 AM
i think you are totally wrong...it is the court who banned the book. We had two years of Murats lawyer saying he was going to sue JT and nothing came of it

No it is you who are wrong, a Court is merely a mechanism, the McCanns sought to destroy Amaral but now it is them who face that same fate.

Murat could very well be biding his time, watch this space!
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: John on June 02, 2016, 11:09:46 AM
How many were there in your sample ?

If the negative comments in the pro McCann Press are anything to go by...      @)(++(*
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 11:44:27 AM
No it is you who are wrong, a Court is merely a mechanism, the McCanns sought to destroy Amaral but now it is them who face that same fate.

Murat could very well be biding his time, watch this space!


one thing is certain....it is just speculation at the moment...I don't see anyway amaral can "destroy" the mccanns...


I doubt very much the mcCanns have much in the way of assets apart from their house. All they do if they are worried is take out  a large mortgage so there is no equity in their house. if amaral was to gain a settlement ...which I don't think he will...declare themselves bankrupt and amaral gets nothing. They do not have to sell their house if there is no equity. Dischrged after 12 months...write a book and pocket a million...job done...

Its a little more complex than that but that is basically it

Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Montclair on June 02, 2016, 12:00:47 PM
In his interview on CMTV, Gonçalo Amaral stated that he was not thinking of suing the McCanns.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: jassi on June 02, 2016, 12:03:44 PM

one thing is certain....it is just speculation at the moment...I don't see anyway amaral can "destroy" the mccanns...


I doubt very much the mcCanns have much in the way of assets apart from their house. All they do if they are worried is take out  a large mortgage so there is no equity in their house. if amaral was to gain a settlement ...which I don't think he will...declare themselves bankrupt and amaral gets nothing. They do not have to sell their house if there is no equity. Dischrged after 12 months...write a book and pocket a million...job done...

Its a little more complex than that but that is basically it


Do you think he wants to ?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 12:04:42 PM

one thing is certain....it is just speculation at the moment...I don't see anyway amaral can "destroy" the mccanns...


I doubt very much the mcCanns have much in the way of assets apart from their house. All they do if they are worried is take out  a large mortgage so there is no equity in their house. if amaral was to gain a settlement ...which I don't think he will...declare themselves bankrupt and amaral gets nothing. They do not have to sell their house if there is no equity. Dischrged after 12 months...write a book and pocket a million...job done...

Its a little more complex than that but that is basically it

That scheme needs a little more work on it.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 12:09:26 PM
That scheme needs a little more work on it.

not much.....you agree its a reasonable scenario....I know several people who have done it
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 12:10:39 PM

Do you think he wants to ?

it was Johns suggestion...ask him
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 12:17:15 PM
not much.....you agree its a reasonable scenario....I know several people who have done it

1 No.
2 Of course you do.


Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 12:21:14 PM
1 No.
2 Of course you do.

then this time its you who is wrong..you obviously have little knowledge in this area.....you just need a co operative trustee in bankruptcy havig got past the official receiver.  How do you think kerry katona and others write off million pound debts to the tax man and still live  a millionaire lifestyle. it's understanding how the system works...you obvioulsy don't
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 12:33:01 PM
then this time its you who is wrong..you obviously have little knowledge in this area.....you just need a co operative trustee in bankruptcy havig got past the official receiver.  How do you think kerry katona and others write off million pound debts to the tax man and still live  a millionaire lifestyle. it's understanding how the system works...you obvioulsy don't

Yeah yeah whatever.
You seem not to be thinking this through and just trapping off about my ignorance.
Explain in detail how your proposed scheme will work. I fancy being educated by the self professed world authority on all topics.

Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: slartibartfast on June 02, 2016, 12:33:31 PM
then this time its you who is wrong..you obviously have little knowledge in this area.....you just need a co operative trustee in bankruptcy havig got past the official receiver.  How do you think kerry katona and others write off million pound debts to the tax man and still live  a millionaire lifestyle. it's understanding how the system works...you obvioulsy don't

It's morally as well as financially bankrupt.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 12:35:02 PM
It's morally as well as financially bankrupt.

So another one who realises its possible
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 12:36:57 PM
Yeah yeah whatever.
You seem not to be thinking this through and just trapping off about my ignorance.
Explain in detail how your proposed scheme will work. I fancy being educated by the self professed world authority on all topics.

cars have to be on finance of course...so they don't actually own them...
which part do you deem not possible
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 12:37:12 PM
So another one who realises its possible

We are still waiting for your full explanation.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 12:39:10 PM
cars have to be on finance of course...so they don't actually own them...
which part do you deem not possible

It was your proposition sunshine so it's up to you to show how it works.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: G-Unit on June 02, 2016, 12:44:38 PM
not much.....you agree its a reasonable scenario....I know several people who have done it

You seem to know such nice people.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: slartibartfast on June 02, 2016, 12:45:06 PM
So another one who realises its possible

Of course it's possible, PR suicide though.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 12:46:17 PM
It was your proposition sunshine so it's up to you to show how it works.

you have said it isn't possible...I know it is.....I have given basic details and will not say anymore on a public forum....can you provide any contradictions to what I have already posted...you can't.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 12:47:13 PM
Of course it's possible, PR suicide though.

Thank you..it wouldn't be PR suicide if handled correctly...at least you accept its a reality
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 12:49:29 PM
Of course it's possible, PR suicide though.

so you think the headline.....FORCED INTO BANKRUPTCY BY PORTUGUESE COP.....would be bad PR
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: slartibartfast on June 02, 2016, 12:51:59 PM
Thank you..it wouldn't be PR suicide if handled correctly...at least you accept its a reality

If there is one thing that annoys the Brits, it's people who welsh on debts.

You weren't involved in their original PR were you?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 12:54:35 PM
If there is one thing that annoys the Brits, it's people who welsh on debts.

You weren't involved in their original PR were you?
you obviously have lived a very sheltered life... I will say no more
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: jassi on June 02, 2016, 12:56:34 PM
I can just see the headlines - Bankrupt professor and his family forced to live in cardboard box -  @)(++(*
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 12:57:50 PM
If there is one thing that annoys the Brits, it's people who welsh on debts.

You weren't involved in their original PR were you?

so if you think the mccanns remortgaged...put the money in the fund to help the search...then had no money to pay amaral and were forced into bankruptcy people would think them immoral...think again
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 12:58:24 PM
I can just see the headlines - Bankrupt professor and his family forced to live in cardboard box -  @)(++(*

they wouldn't lose the house
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: xtina on June 02, 2016, 01:02:57 PM

one thing is certain....it is just speculation at the moment...I don't see anyway amaral can "destroy" the mccanns...


I doubt very much the mcCanns have much in the way of assets apart from their house. All they do if they are worried is take out  a large mortgage so there is no equity in their house. if amaral was to gain a settlement ...which I don't think he will...declare themselves bankrupt and amaral gets nothing. They do not have to sell their house if there is no equity. Dischrged after 12 months...write a book and pocket a million...job done...

Its a little more complex than that but that is basically it


one thing is certain....it is just speculation at the moment...I don't see anyway amaral can "destroy" the mccanns...


no......................they will end up doing that themselves

with the obsession they have for him.......revenge is a terrible thing
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: John on June 02, 2016, 01:08:32 PM

one thing is certain....it is just speculation at the moment...I don't see anyway amaral can "destroy" the mccanns...


I doubt very much the mcCanns have much in the way of assets apart from their house. All they do if they are worried is take out  a large mortgage so there is no equity in their house. if amaral was to gain a settlement ...which I don't think he will...declare themselves bankrupt and amaral gets nothing. They do not have to sell their house if there is no equity. Dischrged after 12 months...write a book and pocket a million...job done...

Its a little more complex than that but that is basically it

With respect davel, it is them who are feeling fear at the moment.  This entire debacle hangs on the Supreme Court, Carly once remarked, don't go putting your shirt on it just now.

There are many ways to destroy a person, we have all watched as Amaral was destroyed by being crippled financially, by not knowing what the next Court decision would be.  He has also lost his wife and daughters to this fiasco.

I sometimes wonder if he was asked if he had to do it all over agan would he have asked for another deployment?

Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: John on June 02, 2016, 01:13:01 PM

one thing is certain....it is just speculation at the moment...I don't see anyway amaral can "destroy" the mccanns...


no......................they will end up doing that themselves

with the obsession they have for him.......revenge is a terrible thing

I agree xtina, after what I personally went through I swore revenge for years, now I only seek justice.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 01:37:13 PM
you have said it isn't possible...I know it is.....I have given basic details and will not say anymore on a public forum....can you provide any contradictions to what I have already posted...you can't.

1. Show me where I said that.
You haven't said anything worth a damn on the topic so give us chapter and verse on how you think it will be done and the devices which will be used.
2.  @)(++(*
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: jassi on June 02, 2016, 01:46:24 PM
they wouldn't lose the house

How could repossession be avoided?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfie on June 02, 2016, 01:53:48 PM
How could repossession be avoided?
Davel has already explained:

"All they do if they are worried is take out  a large mortgage so there is no equity in their house. if amaral was to gain a settlement ...which I don't think he will...declare themselves bankrupt and amaral gets nothing. They do not have to sell their house if there is no equity."

More info here if you need it.

http://homeguides.sfgate.com/lose-house-declare-personal-bankruptcy-7498.html
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 01:58:10 PM
How could repossession be avoided?

very...very easily
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 02:02:39 PM
Davel has already explained:

"All they do if they are worried is take out  a large mortgage so there is no equity in their house. if amaral was to gain a settlement ...which I don't think he will...declare themselves bankrupt and amaral gets nothing. They do not have to sell their house if there is no equity."

More info here if you need it.

http://homeguides.sfgate.com/lose-house-declare-personal-bankruptcy-7498.html

I wonder what SF stands for ?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: slartibartfast on June 02, 2016, 02:07:22 PM
I wonder what SF stands for ?

Seems to be San Francisco... 8(0(*
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 02:14:30 PM
Why don't you just sign over the house to your partner?

I am often asked if this is possible and the short answer is no. When someone applies for bankruptcy they have to disclose what assets they have and if they have sold anything of value within the past five years and this includes transferring the home into the Mrs's name only and it also includes cars.

If you do that and go bankrupt within the five years of the date of transfer then expect the OR to come looking and I have to agree - one should not remove assets from creditors. How would you like it if you were owed money by someone that did just that, just changed the names of the owner of the home to avoid having to pay up?

Bottom line then, those individuals thinking of going bankrupt should first take professional advice to ensure that this is the right course of action for them and if then it is deemed the only way forward, get professional advice about the situation with the home.
[/b]

researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/SN05271/SN05271.pdf
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 02:16:02 PM
Seems to be San Francisco... 8(0(*

Have the McCanns moved there then?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: John on June 02, 2016, 02:17:04 PM
Davel has already explained:

"All they do if they are worried is take out  a large mortgage so there is no equity in their house. if amaral was to gain a settlement ...which I don't think he will...declare themselves bankrupt and amaral gets nothing. They do not have to sell their house if there is no equity."

More info here if you need it.

http://homeguides.sfgate.com/lose-house-declare-personal-bankruptcy-7498.html

Some might believe that Alfred but have you ever heard of a Restraint Order?   As with what happened to him, Amaral could sue and seek that all worldwide assets be frozen. 

There is an old saying which goes something like, play with fire...expect to get burned!
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 02:28:11 PM
Some might believe that Alfred but have you ever heard of a Restraint Order?   As with what happened to him, Amaral could sue and seek that all worldwide assets be frozen. 

There is an old saying which goes something like, play with fire...expect to get burned!

depends if you have any assets......in your own name that is...there is another legal saying...you cannot get blood out of a stone
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: slartibartfast on June 02, 2016, 02:45:29 PM
depends if you have any assets......in your own name that is...there is another legal saying...you cannot get blood out of a stone

So you are suggesting that they would use illegal means to avoid any payout? Is that just if they were sued or also for the costs in the current case? You probably need to be careful of libelling them.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 02:46:39 PM
So you are suggesting that they would use illegal means to avoid any payout? Is that just if they were sued or also for the costs in the current case? You probably need to be careful of libelling them.

I haven't suggested anything illegal....it isn't necessary
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: John on June 02, 2016, 02:52:08 PM
When one thinks about it, all this from one little missing girl whom nobody is bothered to look for any more.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 02:56:57 PM
When one thinks about it, all this from one little missing girl whom nobody is bothered to look for any more.

According to amaral shes dead...perhaps thats why
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: G-Unit on June 02, 2016, 03:06:43 PM
so if you think the mccanns remortgaged...put the money in the fund to help the search...then had no money to pay amaral and were forced into bankruptcy people would think them immoral...think again

As the fund bankrolled their pursuit of Amaral through the courts it's assets might be seen as fair game in the opposite situation.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 03:11:57 PM
As the fund bankrolled their pursuit of Amaral through the courts it's assets might be seen as fair game in the opposite situation.

Might seem fair game but I don't see how they could sue the fund
If they could that would be even easier to put into liquidation
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 03:15:44 PM
The point I am making is that even if amaral could sue the McCanns they may well have little as regards assets
 pension funds are not seen as assets
If they have no assets amaral gets nothing
Kate then writes a best seller about the ordeal which would guarantee a million no doubt
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: G-Unit on June 02, 2016, 03:32:08 PM
The point I am making is that even if amaral could sue the McCanns they may well have little as regards assets
 pension funds are not seen as assets
If they have no assets amaral gets nothing
Kate then writes a best seller about the ordeal which would guarantee a million no doubt

Assuming enough mugs kind people bought it, naturally.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 03:34:37 PM
Assuming enough mugs kind people bought it, naturally.

its a matter of opinion...I would describe those who bought amarals book and those that contributed to his defense mugs...and if you had not made your comment my post would probably have been removed
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: xtina on June 02, 2016, 03:34:54 PM
81. As a consequence of the defendant Gonçalo Amaral’s statements in the book, documentary and interview to Correio da Manhã the applicants Kate McCann and Gerald McCann felt anger , despair , anguish ,worry and also insomnia as well as lack of apetite .



OMG..........can you believe this ........yet when they lost maddie......they were told to show no emotion ..........

they ate three meals a day IIRC and slept

so is G A   book...the worst thing that happened to them ........

as it seems to me they coped better with maddies so called abduction

when you read the reasons for suing G A
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: xtina on June 02, 2016, 03:41:03 PM
Assuming enough mugs kind people bought it, naturally.

its quite  @)(++(* @)(++(* really.................i mean what more could she write about .....that people don't already know ...seems the public are sick of reading about them as it is...after nine years of there whining

where as i would think ......a book by G A would be a best seller ............to read what has not been shown the last nine years
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on June 02, 2016, 03:43:07 PM
The point I am making is that even if amaral could sue the McCanns they may well have little as regards assets
 pension funds are not seen as assets
If they have no assets amaral gets nothing
Kate then writes a best seller about the ordeal which would guarantee a million no doubt

They have their house.

That is an asset.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 03:45:27 PM
They have their house.

That is an asset.

I've dealt with that one..whats their mortgage and whats the value of the house
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on June 02, 2016, 03:54:17 PM
Unless they are in arrears, it will have increased in value over 10 years.

Or are you saying they are in negative equity ?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 03:59:10 PM
Unless they are in arrears, it will have increased in value over 10 years.

Or are you saying they are in negative equity ?

have they remortgaged recently....do they have any penalty clauses for early repayment...all these things and more are important...if there is little or no equity in the house they would not have to sell it....the valuation used would be that of needing an immediate sale and would be less than its true market value
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: jassi on June 02, 2016, 03:59:39 PM
All this is just a wind up about something that is not likely to happen.
Amarel would need to sue in a UK court to achieve anything, so very likely not to happen.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 04:05:32 PM
Might seem fair game but I don't see how they could sue the fund
If they could that would be even easier to put into liquidation

A members voluntary liquidation would probably be the only course open to the directors.
That would be interesting bearing in mind Clause 2F of the Articles of Association.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 04:14:57 PM
All this is just a wind up about something that is not likely to happen.
Amarel would need to sue in a UK court to achieve anything, so very likely not to happen.

I agree but it has been suggested here the mccanns could be ruined
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfie on June 02, 2016, 04:15:35 PM
I wonder what SF stands for ?
I've an idea but I'd probably get a warning if I wrote it down.  The Sleaford Mods do a song with a similar title though...
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfie on June 02, 2016, 04:19:40 PM
its quite  @)(++(* @)(++(* really.................i mean what more could she write about .....that people don't already know ...seems the public are sick of reading about them as it is...after nine years of there whining

where as i would think ......a book by G A would be a best seller ............to read what has not been shown the last nine years
It's kind of ironic that you say people are sick of reading about them, if that was the case then a)why do the media still insist on putting stories about them on their front pages and b) why are there so many people still so obsessed about the case nine years down the line?  I have absolutely no doubt that if Kate wrote another book its every word would be pored over and held up for inspection and comment not by the McCann supporters but by their dedicated detractors.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 04:23:05 PM
A members voluntary liquidation would probably be the only course open to the directors.
That would be interesting bearing in mind Clause 2F of the Articles of Association.

if the fund was sued...and it had no money....its liabilities would outway its assets...wonder what the articles say about those restricted funds
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: jassi on June 02, 2016, 04:29:21 PM
I agree but it has been suggested here the mccanns could be ruined

No doubt they won't be looking too clever if they have to pay all those legal costs after the Supreme Court decision.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 04:31:56 PM
Unless they are in arrears, it will have increased in value over 10 years.

Or are you saying they are in negative equity ?

Briefly, the Official Receiver (OR) or the appointed Trustee has three years from the date of the bankruptcy order to deal with any property owned by the bankrupt. If nothing is done within this time then any interest in the property/ies, reverts back to the bankrupt: i.e. it is no longer part of the bankrupt's estate unless the trustee;

    applies for an order of sale or possession
    applies for a charging order on the property to cover the value of the interest.
    realises the interest or reaches an amicable agreement with the bankrupt regarding the interest.

Official Receivers don't look to turf individuals and their families out of their homes: it's not cost effective as the state generally has to pick up the tab to re-house. Most bankrupts have very little equity, (the difference between the mortgage outstanding and the current value of the home) and if they did have a reasonable equity then they would either remortgage or sell the home and not go bankrupt!
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 04:38:22 PM
Briefly, the Official Receiver (OR) or the appointed Trustee has three years from the date of the bankruptcy order to deal with any property owned by the bankrupt. If nothing is done within this time then any interest in the property/ies, reverts back to the bankrupt: i.e. it is no longer part of the bankrupt's estate unless the trustee;

    applies for an order of sale or possession
    applies for a charging order on the property to cover the value of the interest.
    realises the interest or reaches an amicable agreement with the bankrupt regarding the interest.

Official Receivers don't look to turf individuals and their families out of their homes: it's not cost effective as the state generally has to pick up the tab to re-house. Most bankrupts have very little equity, (the difference between the mortgage outstanding and the current value of the home) and if they did have a reasonable equity then they would either remortgage or sell the home and not go bankrupt!


so taking into account the part in red...what do you think happens if there is little or no equity...taking into account early repayment penalties and forced sale value

its usually the part in blue
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 04:40:10 PM
if the fund was sued...and it had no money....its liabilities would outway its assets...wonder what the articles say about those restricted funds
There is no contractual relationship between The Fund and Sr Amaral so the first bit is irrelevant.
The Articles of Association say nothing about the restricted funds, why would they?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 04:45:59 PM
so taking into account the part in red...what do you think happens if there is little or no equity...taking into account early repayment penalties and forced sale value

Who knows.
I was merely demonstrating that the OR has three years to sort out property not immediately as you implied in your post to Stephen.

First you need to understand the function of the receiver.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 04:55:25 PM
Who knows.
I was merely demonstrating that the OR has three years to sort out property not immediately as you implied in your post to Stephen.

First you need to understand the function of the receiver.

the receiver will usually pass the case to a trustee...which is a specialist firm of accountants to handle the case. All they care about is that they get their fee and they will normally sort out the house asap...usually another family member buys out the small euity and the house is released from the estate
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 05:05:26 PM
Who knows.
I was merely demonstrating that the OR has three years to sort out property not immediately as you implied in your post to Stephen.

First you need to understand the function of the receiver.

the OR ...like any other civil servant wants things off his desk asap...that is the reality of the OR
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 05:17:10 PM
the OR ...like any other civil servant wants things off his desk asap...that is the reality of the OR
You don't think his being an officer of the court is relevant then ?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 05:18:24 PM
You don't think his being an officer of the court is relevant then ?

Relevant to what
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 05:19:21 PM
the receiver will usually pass the case to a trustee...which is a specialist firm of accountants to handle the case. All they care about is that they get their fee and they will normally sort out the house asap...usually another family member buys out the small euity and the house is released from the estate

And in the events where the receiver does not pass it to an IP ?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 02, 2016, 05:21:46 PM
And in the events where the receiver does not pass it to an IP ?

he will
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: xtina on June 02, 2016, 06:54:30 PM
It's kind of ironic that you say people are sick of reading about them, if that was the case then a)why do the media still insist on putting stories about them on their front pages and b) why are there so many people still so obsessed about the case nine years down the line?  I have absolutely no doubt that if Kate wrote another book its every word would be pored over and held up for inspection and comment not by the McCann supporters but by their dedicated detractors.


what ever would it be about..............G A .....and what he has put them through...

and how she wants him to suffer and feel fear

how rich would that be....when because of there actions

what have they put maddie through...how has she suffered...and felt fear.....

the obsession you talk about....by the looks of polls .comments........etc etc .....the majority are not on the mccs side..........

they don't always get the front page either...and i think of late ...you can read between the lines what is going on there ....judging by the comments they now allow
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on June 02, 2016, 07:32:54 PM

what ever would it be about..............G A .....and what he has put them through...

and how she wants him to suffer and feel fear

how rich would that be....when because of there actions

what have they put maddie through...how has she suffered...and felt fear.....

the obsession you talk about....by the looks of polls .comments........etc etc .....the majority are not on the mccs side..........

they don't always get the front page either...and i think of late ...you can read between the lines what is going on there ....judging by the comments they now allow


Indeed! and it is worth mentioning they never talk about what could have happened to their daughter apart from she was abducted. Most people think about what kind of things may have /still is, happening  to her, and all her parents can think of is ruining Amaral.  They forgave the 'abductor' way back in  the day, they forgave themselves and sought  'absolution' from the pope,got an expensive PR machine in motion for the nation to forgive them  but the parents and fanatical supporters still spew hatred toward Amaral, sounds sbout right eh?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: stephen25000 on June 02, 2016, 07:36:40 PM

Indeed! and it is worth mentioning they never talk about what could have happened to their daughter apart from she was abducted. Most people think about what kind of things may have /still is, happening  to her, and all her parents can think of is ruining Amaral.  They forgave the 'abductor' way back in  the day, they forgave themselves and sought  'absolution' from the pope,got an expensive PR machine in motion for the nation to forgive them  but the parents and fanatical supporters still spew hatred toward Amaral, sounds sbout right eh?


That sums up the situation quite accurately.  8((()*/
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 07:42:36 PM

Indeed! and it is worth mentioning they never talk about what could have happened to their daughter apart from she was abducted. Most people think about what kind of things may have /still is, happening  to her, and all her parents can think of is ruining Amaral.  They forgave the 'abductor' way back in  the day, they forgave themselves and sought  'absolution' from the pope,got an expensive PR machine in motion for the nation to forgive them  but the parents and fanatical supporters still spew hatred toward Amaral, sounds sbout right eh?

Like so many gargoyles spewing run off from a Cathedral roof ?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on June 02, 2016, 07:53:46 PM
Like so many gargoyles spewing run off from a Cathedral roof ?

Yes!


Projectile vomiting would be another euphemism!
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfie on June 02, 2016, 07:59:54 PM
Like so many gargoyles spewing run off from a Cathedral roof ?
that sounds pretty hateful too.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfie on June 02, 2016, 08:00:30 PM
Yes!


Projectile vomiting would be another euphemism!
as does that.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: jassi on June 02, 2016, 08:01:16 PM
that sounds pretty hateful too.

Which bit in particular?  Gargoyle, spewing,  or cathedral ?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfie on June 02, 2016, 08:03:35 PM
Which bit in particular?
Well let's see... if I described McCann sceptics as gargoyles spewing run-off from the cathedral roof would that sound reasonable or hateful to you?  Don't tell me - you have no opinion on the matter. @)(++(*
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: jassi on June 02, 2016, 08:05:54 PM
Well let's see... if I described McCann sceptics as gargoyles spewing run-off from the cathedral roof would that sound reasonable or hateful to you?  Don't tell me - you have no opinion on the matter. @)(++(*

I would think that someone had been attending writing classes.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfie on June 02, 2016, 08:07:30 PM

what ever would it be about..............G A .....and what he has put them through...

and how she wants him to suffer and feel fear

how rich would that be....when because of there actions

what have they put maddie through...how has she suffered...and felt fear.....

the obsession you talk about....by the looks of polls .comments........etc etc .....the majority are not on the mccs side..........

they don't always get the front page either...and i think of late ...you can read between the lines what is going on there ....judging by the comments they now allow
you've missed the point.  I didn't say that the many people obsessed with the case were all McCann supporters, quitr the reverse in fact.  Of course these people would be extraordinarily interested in Kate's book, it would fuel the obsession and give renewed fodder for picking over and reviling.  Get it now?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfie on June 02, 2016, 08:09:53 PM
I would think that someone had been attending writing classes.
Oh look, you avoided giving a straight answer.  Do you think Alice attends writing classes then?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: ferryman on June 02, 2016, 08:10:40 PM
Well let's see... if I described McCann sceptics as gargoyles spewing run-off from the cathedral roof would that sound reasonable or hateful to you?  Don't tell me - you have no opinion on the matter. @)(++(*

I suspect you would (once again) disappear from our midsts, Alfie ....
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: jassi on June 02, 2016, 08:11:49 PM
Oh look, you avoided giving a straight answer.  Do you think Alice attends writing classes then?


Possibly, she certainly has a nice turn of phrase.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on June 02, 2016, 08:12:53 PM
I would think that someone had been attending writing classes.

Are you offended on behalf of McCann fanatics Alfie? Amaral was a police co ordinator in a case where parents left their children alone, one went missing-could have been raped /tortured/ murdered or all three over a long or short period of time, yet here you are bemoaning about hateful words to describe verbal diatribe from people who had nothing to do with this case, but join in the McCANNS hatred of a man who did a terrible thing( wrote a book)  which caused more pain that their daughters disappearance could.
Seriously?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: ferryman on June 02, 2016, 08:17:21 PM
Are you offended on behalf of McCann fanatics Alfie? Amaral was a police co ordinator in a case where parents left their children alone, one went missing-could have been raped /tortured/ murdered or all three over a long or short period of time, yet here you are bemoaning about hateful words to describe verbal diatribe from people who had nothing to do with this case, but join in the McCANNS hatred of a man who did a terrible thing( wrote a book)  which caused more pain that their daughters disappearance could.
Seriously?

It requires a modicum of intelligence to understand the true perspective, that Amaral's book added to the pain of the McCanns and to that of Madeleine's (extended) family.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfie on June 02, 2016, 08:25:47 PM

Possibly, she certainly has a nice turn of phrase.
Yes, I was particularly impressed by "jerk-off poster" the nice turn of phrase he used to describe me...of course respect for right conduct is felt by everbody blah blah blah....
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on June 02, 2016, 08:26:20 PM
It requires a modicum of intelligence to understand the true perspective, that Amaral's book added to the pain of the McCanns and to that of Madeleine's (extended) family.

There you go nothing to do with Liable, just about pain and suffering.added to the pain? could anything really be worse than your daughter abducted? BTW the judge did ask that!
 did they move those goal posts?  it was about protecting their reputation regarding Amarals claims of accidental death, then about pain and suffering for and on behalf of children who were too Young to read the book, and to be fair Maddie really would have had more on her mind if she was/is alive to be bothered by words in a book. and what good would financial gain be for her do you think, how much would you put on that?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: jassi on June 02, 2016, 08:27:41 PM
Yes, I was particularly impressed by "jerk-off poster" the nice turn of phrase he used to describe me...of course respect for right conduct is felt by everbody blah blah blah....

I missed that, but I could believe you might be a bit of a w........
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfie on June 02, 2016, 08:28:37 PM
Are you offended on behalf of McCann fanatics Alfie? Amaral was a police co ordinator in a case where parents left their children alone, one went missing-could have been raped /tortured/ murdered or all three over a long or short period of time, yet here you are bemoaning about hateful words to describe verbal diatribe from people who had nothing to do with this case, but join in the McCANNS hatred of a man who did a terrible thing( wrote a book)  which caused more pain that their daughters disappearance could.
Seriously?
Fanatics, gargoyles, projectile vomiting, verbal diatribe, spewing, w....... - anymore colourful terms you want to fling in my direction this evening people?
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfie on June 02, 2016, 08:32:39 PM
I missed that, but I could believe you might be a bit of a w........
You are of course free to call me a w....... secure in the knowledge you won't receive a warning for it, I on the otherhand, if I were to call you a bitch I would certainly get a warning, but that's life I guess, not much I can do about it....
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on June 02, 2016, 08:35:10 PM
Fanatics, gargoyles, projectile vomiting, verbal diatribe, spewing, w....... - anymore colourful terms you want to fling in my direction this evening people?

My posts are not directed at you ALFIE... unless you consider yourself to be a fanatic of the McCanns?
If so I do apologise... to the fanatics  they can go..... themselves along with Bennet and crew- who also spew hatred.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: ferryman on June 02, 2016, 08:38:11 PM
There you go nothing to do with Libel, just about pain and suffering.added to the pain? could anything really be worse than your daughter abducted? BTW the judge did ask that!
 did they move those goal posts?  it was about protecting their reputation regarding Amarals claims of accidental death, then about pain and suffering for and on behalf of children who were too Young to read the book, and to be fair Maddie really would have had more on her mind if she was/is alive to be bothered by words in a book. and what good would financial gain be for her do you think, how much would you put on that?

Amaral wrote a book, believed by (probably) hundreds of thousands of people across Europe that declared Madeleine dead  [moderated]

The shelved enquiry (in its sum and entirety, not cherry-picked) said something completely different.

That both libelled the McCanns and harmed the search for Madeleine, the first-instance judge never said different.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: jassi on June 02, 2016, 08:40:10 PM
Amaral wrote a book, believed by (probably) hundreds of thousands of people across Europe that declared Madeleine dead  [moderated]

The shelved enquiry (in its sum and entirety, not cherry-picked) said something completely different.

That both libelled the McCanns and harmed the search for Madeleine, the first-instance judge never said different.

The next three did, so it's all down the the final play-off.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on June 02, 2016, 08:45:48 PM
Amaral wrote a book, believed by (probably) hundreds of thousands of people across Europe that declared Madeleine dead  [moderated]

The shelved enquiry (in its sum and entirety, not cherry-picked) said something completely different.

That both libelled the McCanns and harmed the search for Madeleine, the first-instance judge never said different.

Ferryman it doesn't matter how many times you type that it doesn't make it true. He based his THEORY on information he had access to. He never cliamed the parents killed their daughter. People who read the book have different reasons for reading it, it doesn't matter what people's opinions are of the parents they probably had formed an opinion long before the book . some accepting the abduction and some not. I hear a great many different theories , some  quite plausable to the absolute crazy. I don't claim to support one or another. But I do listen,read about them.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfie on June 02, 2016, 08:55:07 PM
My posts are not directed at you ALFIE... unless you consider yourself to be a fanatic of the McCanns?
If so I do apologise... to the fanatics  they can go..... themselves along with Bennet and crew- who also spew hatred.
I don't believe there is such a thing as a McCann fanatic, I certainly don't consider myself one, but if such people exist then the language used here this evening to describe them has been IMO hateful, ironic as it was their supposed hatefulness that was being condemned!
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: ferryman on June 02, 2016, 08:56:28 PM
Ferryman it doesn't matter how many times you type that it doesn't make it true. He based his THEORY on information he had access to. Partially true.  He based his book (largely) on Almeida's report.  But Almeida's report was superseded by the final PJ report; even more so by the archiving dispatch.  And much Amaral says is simply not in the files.He (Amaral) never cliamed the parents killed their daughter.Yes he did (with an overdose of calpol, fell of a sofa is just window-dressing) People who read the book have different reasons for reading it, it doesn't matter what people's opinions are of the parents they probably had formed an opinion long before the book. It is naive to suppose that far too high a proportion of people who read the book decided other than that Madeleine died at the McCanns' hands, and the McCanns covered it up and fabricated 'abduction' some accepting the abduction and some not. I hear a great many different theories , some  quite plausable to the absolute crazy. I don't claim to support one or another. But I do listen,read about them.  That's all good.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on June 02, 2016, 09:01:18 PM
that sounds pretty hateful too.

I thought it was rather descriptive with no hatred whatever.


Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on June 02, 2016, 09:22:07 PM
I don't believe there is such a thing as a McCann fanatic, I certainly don't consider myself one, but if such people exist then the language used here this evening to describe them has been IMO hateful, ironic as it was their supposed hatefulness that was being condemned!


Well, so happens I do believe they are fanatical in some sections of the McCann camp. So based on that belief, I can say what I want about them -expressing ones opinion and all that- no need for you to take offence of people whom you do not believe exist... &%+((£

Yeah keep reading that bit... bring tears to a glass eye< oops no offence to glass eyes people.

So let's summarise: it is wrong to describe people who do not exist as spewing hatred.... err  hmm um... Ok
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfie on June 02, 2016, 10:42:44 PM

Well, so happens I do believe they are fanatical in some sections of the McCann camp. So based on that belief, I can say what I want about them -expressing ones opinion and all that- no need for you to take offence of people whom you do not believe exist... &%+((£

Yeah keep reading that bit... bring tears to a glass eye< oops no offence to glass eyes people.

So let's summarise: it is wrong to describe people who do not exist as spewing hatred.... err  hmm um... Ok
I believe you are arguing semantics.  I see supporters, you see fanatics.  If you believe there are two distinct camps perhaps you could explain how you diffentiate between the two sets.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on June 02, 2016, 10:50:33 PM
I believe you are arguing semantics.  I see supporters, you see fanatics.  If you believe there are two distinct camps perhaps you could explain how you diffentiate between the two sets.

Stop goading and pulling the thread your way. I will not be explaining anything to you. Read and weep if needs be, OR ignore me.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Alfie on June 02, 2016, 11:55:08 PM
Stop goading and pulling the thread your way. I will not be explaining anything to you. Read and weep if needs be, OR ignore me.
OK.
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: mercury on June 03, 2016, 02:29:43 AM
that sounds pretty hateful too.
Bits of stone carved for culture and history cant be hateful chin up though
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: Mr Gray on June 03, 2016, 08:14:08 AM
To recapitulate
If amaral was to sue the mccanns I doubt very much they have anything in the way of assets and he would get sweet FA
Title: Re: Gonçalo Amaral threatens to sue the McCanns and others!
Post by: G-Unit on June 03, 2016, 01:41:44 PM
To recapitulate
If amaral was to sue the mccanns I doubt very much they have anything in the way of assets and he would get sweet FA

Except, of course, a moral victory. Money may make the world go round but for some it's not the most important thing in that world.