UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: pegasus on July 27, 2014, 11:57:49 PM

Title: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: pegasus on July 27, 2014, 11:57:49 PM
Press said SY were going to search the empty land west of Rua Primeiro de Maio but then it seems SY went home without doing so. The northern end of that land was at the time:
(1) The closest unused land to the apartment.
(2) Shielded from public view by high opaque fence and trees.
(3) Inaccessible to dog walkers.
(4) Accessible (by sneaking through gap under fence) to someone wishing to hide something.
For those 4 reasons it would have been sensible to search there.

(http://i.imgur.com/dGYWTDc.jpg?1)

The Ocean Club Garden complex and the McCann apartment (depicted with blue dot) from where Madeleine
 disappeared, can be seen top right.  Rua Primeiro de Maio runs down the middle of the photo. 
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: pathfinder73 on July 28, 2014, 12:03:20 AM
Press said SY were going to search the empty land west of Rua Primeiro de Maio but then it seems SY went home without doing so. The northern end of that land was at the time:
(1) The closest unused land to the apartment.
(2) Shielded from public view by high opaque fence and trees.
(3) Inaccessible to dog walkers.
For those 3 reasons it would have been sensible to search there.

I agree that they should search at the wasteland because in my theory the body was hidden and later moved from there (maybe northwest outside perimeter fence) at 10pm.
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: pegasus on July 28, 2014, 12:23:11 AM
I agree that they should search at the wasteland because in my theory the body was hidden and later moved from there (maybe northwest outside perimeter fence) at 10pm.
It does not make sense to hide something just outside that fence when as you have seen in photos some of the metal panels around the north part had a gap underneath which a person could just fit through and then be totally invisible from public view inside the panel fence - it's the only place close to the apartment offering this invisibilty to someone wishing to hide something without being observed.
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: pathfinder73 on July 28, 2014, 12:28:11 AM
It does not make sense to hide something just outside that fence when as you have seen in photos some of the metal panels around the north part had a gap underneath which a person could just fit through and then be totally invisible from public view inside the panel fence - it's the only place close to the apartment offering this invisibilty to someone wishing to hide something without being observed.

Wasteland seems safer if he knew he could get under the fence in the dark. Otherwise a bin or bushes are first thoughts.
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: sadie on July 28, 2014, 12:39:41 AM
Press said SY were going to search the empty land west of Rua 1 Maio but then it seems SY went home without doing so. The northern end of that land was at the time:
(1) The closest unused land to the apartment.
(2) Shielded from public view by high opaque fence and trees.
(3) Inaccessible to dog walkers.
(4) Accessible (by sneaking through gap under fence) to someone wishing to hide something.
For those 4 reasons it would have been sensible to search there.
When I went there I dismissed any idea of anyone carrying a little girl on to that piece of waste land.

1)  It was pretty inaccessable and in view of the main road
2)  THe eastern edge was steep and shaley... very unsafe to walk on with coke like bits.
3)  Imo, it would have been dangerous for someone on their own to scramble down there ... especially after dark
4)  Imo it would have been impossible for someone carrying a child to scramble down from the eastern edge. 

I did not look at the western edge cos that was on the wrong side, neither did I look at the northern edge.


If it was in the least accessible, I feel sure thta the searchers would have given it a good going over.  Soz, Pegasus but I think it is a non runner.  Maybe SY thought the same?
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: pegasus on July 28, 2014, 12:44:51 AM
Wasteland seems safer if he knew he could get under the fence in the dark. Otherwise a bin or bushes are first thoughts.
Wouldn't take much observation, even in dark, to see it's possible to get under.
Someone walking alongside the fence even in no-moon darkness can see the ground so can also see the gap next to the ground.
Anyway seems like a big omission that Tito and Muzzy had to go home before they got to that area, if only to rule it out.
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: pegasus on July 28, 2014, 12:50:51 AM
When I went there I dismissed any idea of anyone carrying a little girl on to that piece of waste land.

1)  It was pretty inaccessable and in view of the main road
2)  THe eastern edge was steep and shaley... very unsafe to walk on with coke like bits.
3)  Imo, it would have been dangerous for someone on their own to scramble down there ... especially after dark
4)  Imo it would have been impossible for someone carrying a child to scramble down from the eastern edge. 

I did not look at the western edge cos that was on the wrong side, neither did I look at the northern edge.
If it was in the least accessible, I feel sure thta the searchers would have given it a good going over.  Soz, Pegasus but I think it is a non runner.  Maybe SY thought the same?
What year was that?
Maybe you went there after the opaque metal panel fence which you can't see through (present in May 2007) had been replaced by the more recent metal wire  fence which you can see through?

Also I think the north or northwest sides would be the more likely entry point
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: sadie on July 28, 2014, 01:14:19 AM
What year was that?
Maybe you went there after the opaque metal panel fence which you can't see through (present in May 2007) had been replaced by the more recent metal wire  fence which you can see through?

Also I think the north or northwest sides would be the more likely entry point
Pegasus I only had three nights there and I wanted to have a quick look at Figueira (Joana Cipriano) and Bensafrim [some oddities there !] so I was unable to do certain things as thoroughly as I would have liked.  I made sure of having a good look at Ocean Club eating at the outdoor Tapas restaurant and I also had a good look at the front door and realised just how dark and vulnrerable that was.  I saw a number of other things too but was unable to fit everything in.

I have a remberance, I think, of open metal work being around the waste ground.  It certainly wasn't like it is now, a building site, I think?   When I started to go down the slope, my overall impression was that it was far too dangerous, even in the daylight.  I didn't go any further and dismissed it from my thioughts as a likely place that bundleman / smith man would have gone - just too dangerous..  I looked north and I looked south and it appeared the same in both directions

 It is quite a long pierce of waste land, but if I remember correctly it was enclosed all the way around apart from this bit I scrambled thru.  This was summer 2010.  Faith might be able to help you and I feel sure Heri could if he were around.
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: pegasus on July 28, 2014, 01:53:15 AM
Thanks Sadie, that is interesting, about the slope and the shale, on the east side.
However I still think it is unwise to rule out a place so very close to the apartment, just because it was in one part difficult terrain.
The northern part of this plot, as you can see on google aerial images, in addition to being in 2007 completely shielded from view by a tall metal panel fence, has (unlike the other parts of the plot) good tree cover, and I just note that invisibility, provided by the combination of a high fence and tree cover, is something which any concealor of any type would value.
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: sadie on July 28, 2014, 08:22:18 AM
Thanks Sadie, that is interesting, about the slope and the shale, on the east side.
However I still think it is unwise to rule out a place so very close to the apartment, just because it was in one part difficult terrain.
The northern part of this plot, as you can see on google aerial images, in addition to being in 2007 completely shielded from view by a tall metal panel fence, has (unlike the other parts of the plot) good tree cover, and I just note that invisibility, provided by the combination of a high fence and tree cover, is something which any concealor of any type would value.

I originally wondered if Madeleine was carried the full length of Rua d'Escola, possibly skirting along the north-eastern edge of that waste land, just on the waste land.  I didn't have the time to walk that.   

I also wondered if she was taken around the southern edge of the waste land, but unless she was going to the Staff quarters or somewhere near, then it seemed silly to go west from near the bottom of Rua Maio, when they were almost down by the church already   That would have been a lot longer than going straight down south towards the Church or little rocky beach,

Of course we have to face facts and not have preset ideas, maybe he was taking her somewhere altogether different, but it was somewhere in that direction.
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: Brietta on August 02, 2014, 05:20:30 PM
Press said SY were going to search the empty land west of Rua Primeiro de Maio but then it seems SY went home without doing so. The northern end of that land was at the time:
(1) The closest unused land to the apartment.
(2) Shielded from public view by high opaque fence and trees.
(3) Inaccessible to dog walkers.
(4) Accessible (by sneaking through gap under fence) to someone wishing to hide something.
For those 4 reasons it would have been sensible to search there.

(http://i.imgur.com/dGYWTDc.jpg?1)

The Ocean Club Garden complex and the McCann apartment (depicted with blue dot) from where Madeleine
 disappeared, can be seen top right.  Rua Primeiro de Maio runs down the middle of the photo.


I think the devil is in the detail, pegasus, the press said it but did Scotland Yard confirm it officially?
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: pegasus on August 04, 2014, 08:05:38 PM
I think the devil is in the detail, pegasus, the press said it but did Scotland Yard confirm it officially?
Yes it's possible the press were mistaken. Maybe SY never intended to search this plot. Or maybe they wanted to but couldn't get a warrant. I don't know. Just saying it seems like a logical place to search, the northern end with trees, because it's well concealed and it's literally just over the road from block 4. I think early searches were not looking for deliberate concealment.

Two places I never heard any mention of are the lift engine rooms of block 5 and of block 4. Presumably access is by a door or hatch at the very top of each block's stairwell? 
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: sadie on August 05, 2014, 12:02:03 AM
Yes it's possible the press were mistaken. Maybe SY never intended to search this plot. Or maybe they wanted to but couldn't get a warrant. I don't know. Just saying it seems like a logical place to search, the northern end with trees, because it's well concealed and it's literally just over the road from block 4. I think early searches were not looking for deliberate concealment.

Two places I never heard any mention of are the lift engine rooms of block 5 and of block 4. Presumably access is by a door or hatch at the very top of each block's stairwell?

Perhaps the special scanning cameras in  the helicopters showed nothing of interest ... so why waste their time digging?
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 05, 2014, 12:04:22 AM
Perhaps the special scanning cameras in  the helicopters showed nothing of interest ... so why waste their time digging?

Nobody stayed there because Smithman passed the wasteland with the child. That doesn't mean that the child wasn't hidden there prior to that sighting. Two moves in my theory. First move away from the crime scene. Second move to her destination and seen passing the Smith family. Why not one move? Time constraint to keep your alibi.
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: sadie on August 05, 2014, 12:19:16 AM
Nobody stayed there because Smithman passed the wasteland with the child. That doesn't mean that the child wasn't hidden there prior to that sighting. Two moves in my theory. First move away from the crime scene. Second move to her destination and seen passing the Smith family.
I think the same, two moves.

Move 1 to the Staff quarters and

Move 2 from there onwards to where-ever (past Aoife either south down the steps towards the sea possibly, or East towards Malinkas and the church

But it is only an educated guess.  Not fact
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: pegasus on August 05, 2014, 01:58:57 AM
Perhaps the special scanning cameras in  the helicopters showed nothing of interest ... so why waste their time digging?
By using IR photography maybe they can detect recent ground disturbances on open ground, but not under trees. 

Here is the northern end of that plot. In background is block 4.

https://maps.google.co.uk/maps?q=8600+Praia+da+Luz,+Portugal&ll=37.087993,-8.732237&spn=0.001305,0.002468&hnear=Praia+da+Luz,+Portugal&t=m&z=19&layer=c&cbll=37.087908,-8.732194&panoid=JPty9ddW2pkbbk3iyzni_Q&cbp=12,48.63,,0,-5.87
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: John on August 05, 2014, 03:00:39 AM
As Amaral found out when he attempted to bury the family pet dog that had been run over, the ground in Portugal is rock hard.  I don't see any would-be abductor going armed with a shovel.  If Madeleine was hidden anywhere t had to be in a ready made hole or a well.
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: sadie on August 05, 2014, 05:53:12 AM
As Amaral found out when he attempted to bury the family pet dog that had been run over, the ground in Portugal is rock hard.  I don't see any would-be abductor going armed with a shovel.  If Madeleine was hidden anywhere t had to be in a ready made hole or a well.

Good thinking.

That is probably why they honed in on that big hole in the hilly wasteland.    The big hole tht we saw 2 or 3 months ago to the SW of Oceann Club
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: ferryman on August 05, 2014, 06:19:11 AM
As Amaral found out when he attempted to bury the family pet dog that had been run over, the ground in Portugal is rock hard.  I don't see any would-be abductor going armed with a shovel.  If Madeleine was hidden anywhere t had to be in a ready made hole or a well.

My "sympathy" with that (non) "argument" is precisely zero!

Amaral simply plagiarised the proper detective-work of Mark Harrison in digging holes in various places in PdL and ruling out burial in coming up with a half-cocked "!thesis" of his own that Gerry hid (Amaral's operative word!) Madeleine's body on the beach.

If you read Harrison's report carefully, you'll find he noted an area of free-standing rocks where he says that it would be possible (sic) to secrete the body of a small child.

But at no point did Harrison say that anything of the kind had happened to Madeleine, done by Gerry or anyone else.

Amaral's (perfectly disgraceful) "thesis" is contained in his El Mundo interview.

When will people wake up to what a pack of outright lies and distortions Amaral has told, both in his book and in interviews? 

Sub Surface Burial on P D Luz Beach

For Body Disposal Purposes The Beach Can Be Separated And
Discussed Into 6 Areas.

Figure 2.The boulders in the rock falls are too large
to man handle. Vegetative growth suggests rock
falls have been in situ for some time. The low energy
wave action would not move any of the boulders. It
is possible a small child could be secreted amongst
the rocks in natural voids.


Figure 3.The cliff edge at the base of the beach is at
an angle that inhibits soil removal. The shale re fills
any hole dug and is unsuitable to achieve a burial.

Figure4.At the base of the cliff are wave cuts where
the bedrock has been eroded by wave action. Here
sand can be easily dug but after a few centimetres
the digger reaches the bed rock, preventing a
successful burial.

Figure 5.The beach cusps or berms are mounds of
sand made by wind action. These cusps form at the
limit of the tides reach and would only be recovered
in storm conditions. Digging on the cusps is easy but to achieve as
more than a few centimetres depth is very difficult to
the fine sand granules refill the hole


Figure 6.The dark sand in this image shows the
intertidal area. Here digging and burial could
possibly be achieved although it would be through a
mixture of grave1 and water. However any burial
would be quickly exposed by wave action and
ultimately taken into the sea.


At one point, Harrison makes reference to occultation of a body, giving rise to fevered speculation in certain quarters that Madeleine's disappearance had something to do with the 'occult'.

Of course occultation simply means hiding ...
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: bros on August 05, 2014, 09:10:55 AM
My five cents here.


I believe SJ and JP were not exclusively looking for "remains" while doing ground " swipe" this is just my opinion going into 2 nd month of reading available materials  and every lead I can find on internet.
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: ferryman on August 05, 2014, 09:14:25 AM
My five cents here.


I believe SJ and JP were not exclusively looking for "remains" while doing ground " swipe" this is just my opinion going into 2 nd month of reading available materials  and every lead I can find on internet.

Do you mean SY (Scotland Yard), Bros?
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: bros on August 05, 2014, 01:01:45 PM
Correct. Scotland Yard. My mistake,txns.
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: Wonderfulspam on August 05, 2014, 01:15:12 PM
My five cents here.


I believe SJ and JP were not exclusively looking for "remains" while doing ground " swipe" this is just my opinion going into 2 nd month of reading available materials  and every lead I can find on internet.

They were looking for that secret underground bunker she's being held captive in, IMO.
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: Eleanor on August 05, 2014, 03:21:18 PM
They were looking for that secret underground bunker she's being held captive in, IMO.

You could be right.  They might be surreptitiously flying over other places on their way to what might not be their objective.
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: pegasus on August 18, 2014, 01:20:46 AM
http://www.justpamalam.co.uk/hg/PA310172_550.jpg
A good photo of inside the tree-covered northeast end of this plot.
Photo is I believe taken from just over the road from block 4, with camera pointing southwest.
Note the excellent concealment from view by trees.
Back in 2007 this area was further concealed by a panel fence.
Photo is by Heri.
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: sadie on August 18, 2014, 10:49:16 AM
http://www.justpamalam.co.uk/hg/PA310172_550.jpg
A good photo of inside the tree-covered northeast end of this plot.
Photo is I believe taken from just over the road from block 4, with camera pointing southwest.
Note the excellent concealment from view by trees.
Back in 2007 this area was further concealed by a panel fence.
Photo is by Heri.

I think you are right, Pegasus. 
To the rear left appears to be the Luztor building, where one of the arguidos was on the balcony IIRC.
To the rear right appears to be the staff quarters building

It appears, this photo covers the whole length of the waste land, from North to south, a distance of some 200+ yards or 190 metres.   As can be seen the view is very much foreshortened.   The wooded area was almost exclusively at this northern end, but I understand it is being developed now, so the whole area might have changed.

By shortest walking route, this closest area of the waste land is just about 140 metres from 5A
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 18, 2014, 12:49:28 PM
It would only take a few minutes to walk to the wasteland and back. Anyone could manage that on a check and keep their alibi. But when is the best time to do it without the missing child being seen? 1. when everyone is present at the table. 2. in the dark - less people/witnesses about and harder to positively identify. 3. child concealed in wardrobe bag?
Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: sadie on August 18, 2014, 12:56:37 PM
It would only take a few minutes to walk to the wasteland and back. Anyone could manage that on a check and keep their alibi. But when is the best time to do it without the missing child being seen? 1. when everyone is present at the table. 2. in the dark - less people/witnesses about and harder to positively identify. 3. child concealed in wardrobe bag?
What an imagination you have, PFinder !

But you are correct.  It wouldn't take long !

Title: Re: The search area west of Rua Primeiro de Maio.
Post by: pegasus on August 18, 2014, 10:13:20 PM
I think you are right, Pegasus. 
To the rear left appears to be the Luztor building, where one of the arguidos was on the balcony IIRC.
To the rear right appears to be the staff quarters building

It appears, this photo covers the whole length of the waste land, from North to south, a distance of some 200+ yards or 190 metres.   As can be seen the view is very much foreshortened.   The wooded area was almost exclusively at this northern end, but I understand it is being developed now, so the whole area might have changed.

By shortest walking route, this closest area of the waste land is just about 140 metres from 5A
Yes the tree cover is at north (near in photo) end.
A small part of Luztur is barely visible on the left.
Buildings in centre are on south side of Rua Joaquim Teixeira.
And Edificio Pedras Brancas, or Staff Quarters as you call it, white and blue (as in an employee statement) on the right.