UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: pathfinder73 on July 31, 2014, 12:29:27 PM

Title: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: pathfinder73 on July 31, 2014, 12:29:27 PM
Sky Live Transcript Libel Case..............complete

Day One full Transcript from 8.40am till 5.29pm. 12/01/2010

- clipped -

3:33 Inspector ricardo paiva, of the portuguese police, has taken the stand.

3:34 Insp paiva says he was the family liaison officer for the case but was taken off at the mcanns' request.

3:45 Paiva is asked whether he ever got the impression from the mccanns they thought maddie could be dead. He says yes.

3:47 Kate whispers something in gerry's ear and gives him a little smile. He stays looking straight in front.

3:52 Gerry has put his arm round kate as they listen to paiva's testimony

4:03 Paiva also says the mccanns were made suspects after the british sniffer dogs were brought in

4:04 Paiva: there was total collaboration between british and portuguese police on the case

4:09 Paiva: it was scotland yard who first thought it could be a murder case.

4:09 Paiva: amaral's theories are based on the facts of the investigation

4:12 Paiva: amaral's thesis has prevented other theories from being investigated.

4:13 Paiva: mccanns never pointed me towards any evidence that maddie was still alive.

4:16 Mr amaral looks like he's dozing off

4:29 Paiva: we found the 'merchandising' operation with wristbands and so on very strange

4:31 Paiva: if she was being held somewhere publicity would be more likely to hasten her death.

4:55 The mcanns' lawyer is taking an aggressive tone as she cross-examines mr paiva

5:08 Proceedings have ended for today.

Gerry's Transcript at the Press Conference outside the court. 13/01/2010

5:04 jondipaolo: He also rejected the testimony yesterday that Kate had had a dream about Madeleine lying buried somewhere, saying "that never happened"..

5:07 jondipaolo: "I hope that everyone remembers that there is a little girl missing that still has to be found," Mr McCann continued.


http://missingmadeleine.forumotion.net/t7174-sky-live-transcript-libel-casecomplete

Title: Re: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: Brietta on July 31, 2014, 12:34:21 PM
4:09 Paiva: it was scotland yard who first thought it could be a murder case.

Giving the valid advice that the parents should be the first to be investigated in any inquiry into a missing child ... I hardly think so ... particularly as the 'theory' was developed very shortly after Madeleine was taken.
Check Dr Amaral's book and subsequent numerous interviews for that.
Title: Re: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: Angelo222 on July 31, 2014, 12:37:10 PM
4:09 Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.

An extremely interesting observation.
Title: Re: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: DCI on July 31, 2014, 12:42:37 PM
I wonder who changed Paiva's mind for him about the McCann's? Or was his "friendship" with them deliberate to try and stitch them up?
He invited them for dinner and his kids played with the twins. Then all of a sudden he stabbed them in the back. Doesn't add up.

Title: Re: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 31, 2014, 03:46:14 PM

From Pathfinder:
4:09 Paiva: it was scotland yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
An extremely interesting observation.

Would some nice kind person remind us which division of NSY is investigating this case now?
Title: Re: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on August 14, 2014, 06:20:34 PM
Would some nice kind person remind us which division of NSY is investigating this case now?

Homicide and Serious Crime

The Homicide and Serious Crime Command is responsible for the investigation of homicide and other serious crimes in London.

Murder Investigation Teams investigate:
◾All murder, manslaughter and infanticide offences;
◾Deaths within the workplace or mass disaster where culpability for the loss of life is likely to be an issue in criminal court
◾Attempted murder where the evidence of intent is unambiguous or where a risk assessment identifies substantive risk to life
◾High-risk missing persons where there is a substantive reason to suspect life has been taken or is under threat
◾Linked series of two or more stranger rapes which are beyond the capability of SCD2 Sapphire Command or other 'critical incidents'

Hope this helps jog your memory.
Title: Re: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: Mr Gray on August 14, 2014, 06:58:23 PM
Of course murder was and still is a possibility...did the PJ need SY to tell them this..how inept were they
Title: Re: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: Montclair on August 14, 2014, 08:11:52 PM
I wonder who changed Paiva's mind for him about the McCann's? Or was his "friendship" with them deliberate to try and stitch them up?
He invited them for dinner and his kids played with the twins. Then all of a sudden he stabbed them in the back. Doesn't add up.

Paiva was a liaison officer and their remit is not just to be nice to these people but also to do detective work and study their psychology.
Title: Re: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: ferryman on August 14, 2014, 08:22:27 PM
An extremely interesting observation.

An outright lie.

The PJ instructed Mark Harrison to investigate that Madeleine had been murdered, long before Scotland Yard had anything to do with the investigation.

To clarify, Paivia's is the outright lie:

4:09 Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Title: Re: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: Brietta on August 14, 2014, 08:30:55 PM
Paiva was a liaison officer and their remit is not just to be nice to these people but also to do detective work and study their psychology.

The British liaison officers were all emphatic in their rogatory interviews, all answering in exactly the same way and I doubt very much if they were 'innit'  ~

 - Snipped -
According to the Letters of Request from the Portuguese police, I was asked to respond to the following question:
 
Was anything said or done by Kate or Gerry McCann in your presence or during your contacts that may have raised any suspicion that they had knowledge of what happened to Madeleine, besides the circumstances described to the Portuguese investigators?
 
My response to the above question is: No.

 
Title: Re: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: Mr Gray on August 14, 2014, 09:05:00 PM
Paiva was a liaison officer and their remit is not just to be nice to these people but also to do detective work and study their psychology.

he wasn't very good at it was he?
Title: Re: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 15, 2014, 12:48:10 AM
An outright lie.

The PJ instructed Mark Harrison to investigate that Madeleine had been murdered, long before Scotland Yard had anything to do with the investigation.

To clarify, Paivia's is the outright lie:

4:09 Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.

On June 14th, the parents are contacted by a stranger who states that he is in possession of information about Madeleine’s whereabouts.

One day, we were all together at the PJ in Portimão – inspectors and negotiators, members of Scotland Yard and the Leicestershire police – waiting for a contact to define the place and the conditions for the handing over of the money in Holland; when the tension was at its height and we were all holding our breath, Gerald McCann displayed a nonchalance that surprised all of the police officers present, including the English. The atmosphere got heavier as the waiting drew out, but McCann, relaxed, was reading trivia on the internet and discussing rugby and football with the English police, while licking a lollipop. On the telephone, he laughed with friends who called him. Perhaps this was nervousness; sometimes it’s totally displaced, given what is at stake at the time. His attitude shocked. (TOTL)
Title: Re: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: ferryman on August 15, 2014, 08:06:00 AM
On June 14th, the parents are contacted by a stranger who states that he is in possession of information about Madeleine’s whereabouts.

One day, we were all together at the PJ in Portimão – inspectors and negotiators, members of Scotland Yard and the Leicestershire police – waiting for a contact to define the place and the conditions for the handing over of the money in Holland; when the tension was at its height and we were all holding our breath, Gerald McCann displayed a nonchalance that surprised all of the police officers present, including the English. The atmosphere got heavier as the waiting drew out, but McCann, relaxed, was reading trivia on the internet and discussing rugby and football with the English police, while licking a lollipop. On the telephone, he laughed with friends who called him. Perhaps this was nervousness; sometimes it’s totally displaced, given what is at stake at the time. His attitude shocked. (TOTL)

Chapter 5 of Amaral's book, the same book, the same chapter (I think) where he says he puts English police under secret surveillance.

Do you believe everything you read in Amaral's book?
Title: Re: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: Brietta on August 15, 2014, 08:49:30 AM
Chapter 5 of Amaral's book, the same book, the same chapter (I think) where he says he puts English police under secret surveillance.

Do you believe everything you read in Amaral's book?

Dr Amaral’s book is the only source I can find for this statement which became another internet myth disseminated by the usual suspects.
Nowhere is there a mention of it in any independent source.

I think it is illustrates perfectly that Dr Amaral used his book

(a) to make money from the botched police case of a missing child 

(b) to attack and destroy the reputation of the parents of that child because their persistence in searching for their missing child highlighted the incompetence of the initial investigation

This has all the hallmarks of a lie propagated for revenge by an embittered man and exhibits the weakness of the flawed materials used in the systematic character assassination Madeleine's parents.
Title: Re: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: Jean-Pierre on August 15, 2014, 08:56:00 AM
Dr Amaral’s book is the only source I can find for this statement which became another internet myth disseminated by the usual suspects.
Nowhere is there a mention of it in any independent source.

I think it is illustrates perfectly that Dr Amaral used his book

(a) to make money from the botched police case of a missing child 

(b) to attack and destroy the reputation of the parents of that child because their persistence in searching for their missing child highlighted the incompetence of the initial investigation

This has all the hallmarks of a lie propagated for revenge by an embittered man and exhibits the weakness of the flawed materials used in the systematic character assassination Madeleine's parents.

Spot on Brietta.   It has certainly convinced a few of the more credulous members of society. 
Title: Re: Paiva: it was Scotland Yard who first thought it could be a murder case.
Post by: Benice on August 15, 2014, 09:45:37 AM
Dr Amaral’s book is the only source I can find for this statement which became another internet myth disseminated by the usual suspects.
Nowhere is there a mention of it in any independent source.

I think it is illustrates perfectly that Dr Amaral used his book

(a) to make money from the botched police case of a missing child 

(b) to attack and destroy the reputation of the parents of that child because their persistence in searching for their missing child highlighted the incompetence of the initial investigation

This has all the hallmarks of a lie propagated for revenge by an embittered man and exhibits the weakness of the flawed materials used in the systematic character assassination Madeleine's parents.

Totally agree Brietta.     He does a similar 'job' on Kate with his description of her when they were called back to the police station on 4th May.     He describes her as 'annoyed' when actually she was devastated because they thought they were being called back because Madeleine may have been found - only to be shown a picture of a little girl.      IMO even the driver thought something major had happened which is why he drove them back to the Police station at such a break-neck speed.

The fact that Amaral wasn't even there himself - and had never met Kate didn't stop him.    He uses the word 'We' to get round that little problem.      I notice he does the same in his spiteful description of Gerry.