UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: sadie on August 07, 2014, 10:49:44 AM

Title: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: sadie on August 07, 2014, 10:49:44 AM
In previous threads we have proved that Eddie did not alert to Ccat but seemingly to a pile of (?) folders and or a sheet of paper on top of it.

Just

1)  How did that pile get there?

2)  When was it placed there ?   Was it there before Ccat was placed in the cupboard ... or after ?

4)  I seem to remember a video very pointedly showing Martin Grime placing Ccat in that cupboard.  What has happened to that video?

5)  To whom do the following belong?
(a) pile of (?)folders 
(b) the sheet of paper   


There are several versions of the videos.    Every video is different.  Bits left out and other bits added in according to the whim of the editor.  Were they produced to obfuscate ? ......... or what ?


Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: sadie on August 07, 2014, 12:52:46 PM
i was hoping that we could share all the various videos out between a group of us and each check our particular section of say 20 minutes to see

1)  If anyone can find the snip of Ccat being put into the cupboard?  I feel sure tat i have seen it somewhere.

2)  If there was sign of the folders on the counter before Cuddlecat went into the cupboard ?

3)  If there are any shots of the folders being carried ?

4)  Did the folders vanish afterwards ? or were they still there at the end?



But first, if people are willing to take on a poportion of the task, we must assemble all the videos for checking.

At one time I would have waded thru all the videos myself, but am no longer up to the task.  Would be good if we could pinpoint the origin of the (?)cadavar odour



If no-one much is interested, then i propose that we suggest the task to Myths forum.  They excel at that sort of analysis.



Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 07, 2014, 03:40:59 PM
In previous threads we have proved that Eddie did not alert to Ccat but seemingly to a pile of (?) folders and or a sheet of paper on top of it.

Just

1)  How did that pile get there?

2)  When was it placed there ?   Was it there before Ccat was placed in the cupboard ... or after ?

4)  I seem to remember a video very pointedly showing Martin Grime placing Ccat in that cupboard.  What has happened to that video?

5)  To whom do the following belong?
(a) pile of (?)folders 
(b) the sheet of paper   


There are several versions of the videos.    Every video is different.  Bits left out and other bits added in according to the whim of the editor.  Were they produced to obfuscate ? ......... or what ?

Eddie alerted immediately after jumping down from inspecting the folders on the top of the sideboard; he was then taken into a bedroom before being brought back to the sideboard.

I took some screen shots illustrating his alert ... I'll post them in sequence, I don't know how to put them all in the one post ... sorry in advance to admin for being messy.

http://wn.com/madeleine_mccann__sniffer_dogs_eddie_and_keela?orderby=rating




Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 07, 2014, 03:43:07 PM
This is Eddie jumping down ...
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 07, 2014, 03:44:39 PM
Next in series ... Eddie at 4:06
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 07, 2014, 03:46:20 PM
Eddie alerting at 4:07
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 07, 2014, 03:47:59 PM
CuddleCat in the cupboard at 5:44
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 07, 2014, 03:49:31 PM
Top of the sideboard and the pile of folders Eddie was sniffing.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: sadie on August 07, 2014, 04:28:08 PM
That is brilliant, Brietta.  Thank you so much


You know what I have just realised.  Eddie alerted to by the LH side of the pile of folders and Ccat isn't even underneath the pile.  Ccat is a good ish distance to the RH side of the pile.

So my guess is that Eddies nose was about 3 feet from Ccat ....  and yet he couldn't even scent him when CC was about a handspan away.  Neither could he scent Ccat when he picked him up at least twice before hand. 


So two negatives even before CCat was placed in the cupboard
........so why,  FGS, did they put him in the cupboard to test for him if they knew he was already "clean"?


Seems terribly stinky to me.   
Jeez I am thinking awful thoughts. 



Just whose folders and papers are they?  And when were they put there?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Carana on August 07, 2014, 04:35:30 PM
Well done, Brietta.

If ever he really did react to CC, then I suppose the heat could have lifted the air to the top of the buffet and even to the corner if there was a slight breeze coming in from somewhere. I don't think that that can be excluded.

Two thoughts, however.

Any residual scent from skin/sweat decomp could account for Eddie's reaction once it had been in a small enclosed area where the scent could become more concentrated, I would have thought.

Had there been a clean sniff of those cupboards prior to CC being placed there or not? If so, I haven't found anything to that effect.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: sadie on August 07, 2014, 04:38:31 PM
Well done, Brietta.

If ever he really did react to CC, then I suppose the heat could have lifted the air to the top of the buffet and even to the corner if there was a slight breeze coming in from somewhere. I don't think that that can be excluded.

Two thoughts, however.

Any residual scent from skin/sweat decomp could account for Eddie's reaction once it had been in a small enclosed area where the scent could become more concentrated, I would have thought.

Had there been a clean sniff of those cupboards prior to CC being placed there or not? If so, I haven't found anything to that effect.

Look carefully Carana.  He didn't even alert above the cupboard where Ccat lay.  He alerted above the cupboard, which was to the left of Ccats cupboard.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Anna on August 07, 2014, 04:50:20 PM
Nicely done Brietta  8@??)(

We know that it was the paperwork on the surface that Eddie was interested in.
I suppose everyone who was present on that filming day, had paperwork of some sort
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: slartibartfast on August 07, 2014, 05:14:19 PM
What a load of rubbish.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Carana on August 07, 2014, 05:27:49 PM
Look carefully Carana.  He didn't even alert above the cupboard where Ccat lay.  He alereed above the cupboard, which was to the left of Ccats cupboard.

Yes, Sadie, I'm aware of that, and that was my first reaction as well. However, the issue seems to be the scent cone (where odour concentrates), which may not be where the object actually is.

That said, it doesn't explain why he didn't alert to CC when he first played with it.

You are more interested in the papers on top; I'm more interested in the fact that Kate had been carrying CC around with her for months and that it would therefore have had irrelevant decomp scent in it (Kate's - and despite having been washed).

In an occupied (and, therefore aired, villa), the scent may not have presented the "bouquet" that Eddie was used to being tasked to find. However, unless it can be formally excluded, he may have been zooming in on a partial "bouquet" of nothing other than the inevitable decomp in this porous toy due to Kate carrying it around with her for months. Placing it in an enclosed area (as opposed to the aired living area), could easily have concentrated the compounds that he would have reacted to and which would have risen via the partially open cupboard doors and concentrated wherever a breeze was coming from.



Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on August 07, 2014, 05:29:10 PM
What a load of rubbish.
Yes, that's probably what Eddie alerted to.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: slartibartfast on August 07, 2014, 05:29:58 PM
This entire thread is pure fantasy.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on August 07, 2014, 05:31:26 PM
So what was Eddie alerting to in the pictures on this thread Slarti?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Carana on August 07, 2014, 05:31:37 PM
Yes, that's probably what Eddie alerted to.

Red herring comes to mind.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 07, 2014, 06:16:50 PM
This entire thread is pure fantasy.

I want to see the fantasy clip of Eddie throwing CC over his head  @)(++(* The cupboard doors were left slightly open for a reason.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on August 07, 2014, 06:31:56 PM
I want to see the fantasy clip of Eddie throwing CC over his head  @)(++(* The cupboard doors were left slightly open for a reason.
there is documented evidence in the files that Eddie did this, even if the video footage has been scrubbed - has it been fabricated?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 07, 2014, 07:18:32 PM
This entire thread is pure fantasy.

In what way is it fantasy? 

The dogs did their job but left many questions in their wake while becoming a shibboleth for many people; so a closer examination of what they actually did while in PDL seems quite in order. 

For example, we know that Keela followed Eddie in 5a where she alerted to blood behind the couch.  As far as we know she wasn’t deployed in the villa to check for the presence of blood either in the sideboard or on top where Eddie showed interest.

Why would that be?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: sadie on August 07, 2014, 07:37:29 PM
They probably noticed what i noticed way before me.

They will have  a graet deal more knowledge about cones of odour than we have and will draw their own conclusions
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 07, 2014, 08:48:55 PM
there is documented evidence in the files that Eddie did this, even if the video footage has been scrubbed - has it been fabricated?

1. Eddie grabs and throws CC on the floor

2. Drags it across the floor

There is no cut in the footage.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on August 07, 2014, 09:39:26 PM
1. Eddie grabs and throws CC on the floor

2. Drags it across the floor

There is no cut in the footage.
So the description of this event that appears in the files is a fabrication in your view?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Eleanor on August 07, 2014, 11:07:32 PM
1. Eddie grabs and throws CC on the floor

2. Drags it across the floor

There is no cut in the footage.

So what happened to the bit where Martin Grime put Cuddle Cat in the cupboard?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: sadie on August 07, 2014, 11:11:17 PM
And where is the bit that so many of us have seen, where Eddie plays with Ccat , bites it and throws it up in the air.  It goes up and down in the manner that a tennis player serving throws up the ball.

What happened to that bit? 
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on August 07, 2014, 11:14:25 PM
And where is the bit that so many of us have seen, where Eddie plays with Ccat , bites it and throws it up in the air.  It goes up and down in the manner that a tennis player serving throws up the ball.

What happened to that bit?
Yeah, that bit that is described in detail and in in the Official PJ Files.  Apparently that bit of the files is fantasy according to Pathfinder here....
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: sadie on August 07, 2014, 11:17:51 PM
Yeah, that bit that is described in detail and in in the Official PJ Files.  Apparently that bit of the files is fantasy according to Pathfinder here....
As Anna says on the other thread, they understand but they dont want to know.


Now for anyone interested in Justice, that is a strange state of affairs.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Anna on August 07, 2014, 11:23:17 PM
Yeah, that bit that is described in detail and in in the Official PJ Files.  Apparently that bit of the files is fantasy according to Pathfinder here....

From the screening of the videos, referred previously, done when the dogs were working, some doubts arise. We don’t want and we can’t take the place of the trainer, we only wish to alert, with this paragraph, to some facts, that according to us, need further clarification.

If the dog is trained to react when he detects what he is looking for, why, in most of the cases, we see the dog passing more than once by that place in an uninterested way, until he finally signals the place where he had already passed several times?

On one of the films, it’s possible to see that “Eddie” sniffs Madeleine’s cuddlecat, more than once, bites it, throws it into the air and only after the toy is hidden does he “mark” it (pag 2099). Whys didn’t he signal it when he sniffs it on the first time?

Apart from all that was said about the dogs, we must also take into attention the results of the forensic analysis that was performed by the experts on the Scientific Police Laboratory on the day immediately after the facts, and alrady mentioned where no vestige of blood was found.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post420.html#p420
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 08, 2014, 01:21:09 AM
You can see Eddie throwing the toy on the ground when he first grabs it and then he drags it across the floor. Martin Grime calls Eddie over to sit down and STAY then it cuts.

1:45 to 2:15

(http://i39.servimg.com/u/f39/18/78/37/02/cuddle10.jpg)

So he hid the toy in the cupboard but left the doors slightly open for scent.




Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on August 08, 2014, 08:22:37 AM
From the screening of the videos, referred previously, done when the dogs were working, some doubts arise. We don’t want and we can’t take the place of the trainer, we only wish to alert, with this paragraph, to some facts, that according to us, need further clarification.

If the dog is trained to react when he detects what he is looking for, why, in most of the cases, we see the dog passing more than once by that place in an uninterested way, until he finally signals the place where he had already passed several times?

On one of the films, it’s possible to see that “Eddie” sniffs Madeleine’s cuddlecat, more than once, bites it, throws it into the air and only after the toy is hidden does he “mark” it (pag 2099). Whys didn’t he signal it when he sniffs it on the first time?

Apart from all that was said about the dogs, we must also take into attention the results of the forensic analysis that was performed by the experts on the Scientific Police Laboratory on the day immediately after the facts, and alrady mentioned where no vestige of blood was found.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post420.html#p420
Thank you - but according to Pathfinder the above is pure fantasy.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: sadie on August 08, 2014, 09:07:35 AM
Thank you - but according to Pathfinder the above is pure fantasy.
Ah so many of us saw it.

I am afraid that Pathfinder is in La La Land on this one.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 08, 2014, 01:29:50 PM
Ah so many of us saw it.

I am afraid that Pathfinder is in La La Land on this one.

If you all seen it then you can provide proof. Or are you telling me that this footage also disappeared.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: sadie on August 08, 2014, 02:35:53 PM
If you all seen it then you can provide proof. Or are you telling me that this footage also disappeared.

I am no longer able to watch long videos, my eyes wqnt take it, but I have done something of a search and it appears to have been wiped.  No doubt, such as SY will have access to the full video.



Well Pathfinder, I am surprised that you cannot believe the recollections of several of us.  Off the top of my head there is
Anna,
Ferryman
Me
Not many peeps around atm, but are there any others who can come forward to assure Pfinder?



And then there is the documentary evidence, as Alfred tells us:-

there is documented evidence in the files that Eddie did this, even if the video footage has been scrubbed - has it been fabricated?


Might be best to quietly back off Pfinder; you are wrong. 


In addition to throwing Ccat across the room, Eddie did bite the toy, then throw it straight up into the air and play with it.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Eleanor on August 08, 2014, 03:30:39 PM
If you all seen it then you can provide proof. Or are you telling me that this footage also disappeared.

Pathfinder.  There certainly was footage of Eddie chucking CaddleCut around.  And as we have seen, of Martin Grime putting CuddleCat into the cupboard.  Although not on this particular footage.  So this video was edited.

But not being a conspiracy theorist, I don't have the time to wonder where it has gone, or why it is now apparently difficult to find.

And it doesn't matter anyway.

In My Opinion, both The PJ and Martin Grime were grandstanding, albeit for different reasons.  And I don't particularly blame any of them.  It was all so silly, and so easy to decimate.

The Dogs' Evidence will never be used in Court, even in an attempt to convict an Abductor of the death of Madeleine.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 08, 2014, 05:35:56 PM
Pathfinder.  There certainly was footage of Eddie chucking CaddleCut around.  And as we have seen, of Martin Grime putting CuddleCat into the cupboard.  Although not on this particular footage.  So this video was edited.

But not being a conspiracy theorist, I don't have the time to wonder where it has gone, or why it is now apparently difficult to find.

And it doesn't matter anyway.

In My Opinion, both The PJ and Martin Grime were grandstanding, albeit for different reasons.  And I don't particularly blame any of them.  It was all so silly, and so easy to decimate.

The Dogs' Evidence will never be used in Court, even in an attempt to convict an Abductor of the death of Madeleine.

Absolutely: I doubt if there is anything on them which would be admissable in a court.

Unfortunately that doesn't prevent people from continuing to use them to discredit the Drs McCann.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: slartibartfast on August 08, 2014, 05:40:33 PM
Absolutely: I doubt if there is anything on them which would be admissable in a court.

Unfortunately that doesn't prevent people from continuing to use them to discredit the Drs McCann.

IMO, it would be very interesting to see Martin Grime take the stand as an expert witness. It would clear up all the misinformation propagated by the supporters on here.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 08, 2014, 05:49:41 PM
IMO, it would be very interesting to see Martin Grime take the stand as an expert witness. It would clear up all the misinformation propagated by the supporters on here.

He wouldn't need to take the stand;  he has already explained his and the dogs' role precisely in his Rogatory statements;  I doubt he would have anything to add.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 08, 2014, 06:11:20 PM
IMO, it would be very interesting to see Martin Grime take the stand as an expert witness. It would clear up all the misinformation propagated by the supporters on here.
first as Brietta says grime already made his opinion clear...he cannot conform the alert was to cadaverine..it is only suggestive.

secondly, as someone posted recently grime's training methods are confidential...he is therefore in a very poor position to support the alerts...

my point has always been that the value of the dogs is to find evidence which can help solve the case and be used in court. no such evidence was found
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on August 08, 2014, 06:17:00 PM
IMO, it would be very interesting to see Martin Grime take the stand as an expert witness. It would clear up all the misinformation propagated by the supporters on here.
Yes it would be great to have him cross-questioned about a number of aspects of the dogs alerts - for example why in the whole of PdL it was only at the McCanns property where both dogs alerted to the presence of human blood, and nowhere else.  I wonder what his explanation would be...
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Eleanor on August 08, 2014, 06:24:17 PM
IMO, it would be very interesting to see Martin Grime take the stand as an expert witness. It would clear up all the misinformation propagated by the supporters on here.

What do you think Martin Grime can say that he hasn't already said?  He thinks it might have been Cadaver Odour?  Where is "Thinks" going to get anyone?  "Thinks" doesn't work with dumb animals.

Martin Grime is not an expert on the mind of a dog.  Only on what he "Thinks" he has taught that dog to do.

Sheesh.  I have got a blind and demented Pug who thinks she knows where her food bowl is.  But I frequently have to stuff her nose in it before she finds it.
But, I'll tell you what.  She could find a cadaver if there was one.  I have no doubt about that that.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Anna on August 08, 2014, 06:29:49 PM
Yes it would be great to have him cross-questioned about a number of aspects of the dogs alerts - for example why in the whole of PdL it was only at the McCanns property where both dogs alerted to the presence of human blood, and nowhere else.  I wonder what his explanation would be...

have you watched the rather short searches of the other apartments?

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id167.html
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 08, 2014, 06:53:29 PM
have you watched the rather short searches of the other apartments?

http://www.mccannfiles.com/id167.html

The amount of time spent with Keela behind the couch before she alerted was remarkable; Eddie was showing lot more interest at the sideboard (which was pulled out for him, but not opened) than he did in Cuddle Cat's cupboard;  he was also very interested in whatever was under the bed.
I formed the impression that Martin Grime was dismissive and did not spend time with him, or was as close to him at these locations as behind the couch in 5a and in the bedroom corner.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 08, 2014, 06:58:30 PM
Yes it would be great to have him cross-questioned about a number of aspects of the dogs alerts - for example why in the whole of PdL it was only at the McCanns property where both dogs alerted to the presence of human blood, and nowhere else.  I wonder what his explanation would be...

Well my dear muse away it is doubtful he will be cross examined unless a case is heard in The UK or somewhere else where the adversarial system is used.
Are you really suggesting that the dear little doggies searched the whole of PdL?. Oh surely not sir?
May hap your vivid imagination is allowed too much rein?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Eleanor on August 08, 2014, 07:09:57 PM
Well my dear muse away it is doubtful he will be cross examined unless a case is heard in The UK or somewhere else where the adversarial system is used.
Are you really suggesting that the dear little doggies searched the whole of PdL?. Oh surely not sir?
May hap your vivid imagination is allowed too much rein?

Mayhap is one word.  Not sure about your vivid imagination.  Try learning English.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 10, 2014, 06:26:50 PM
In the video - what are pillows and pillow cases doing on the dining table?
Doesn't this indicate that items which had been washed and dried were folded in this area?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 10, 2014, 06:35:23 PM
(http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=5003.0;attach=4159;image)
What are yellow pillowcases doing on dining table?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Anna on August 10, 2014, 07:06:38 PM
(http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=5003.0;attach=4159;image)
What are yellow pillowcases doing on dining table?

Contents of table ? Mainly towels I think.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 10, 2014, 07:34:16 PM
Contents of table ? Mainly towels I think.
The items on the dining table in the villa video are the same as these items in these clothing photos
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/VOLUME%20VIIIa_Processo_2123.jpg
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/VOLUME%20VIIIa_Processo_2124.jpg
On the dining table are two yellow pillowcases (photo 23), a white pillow inner (photo 24), and another white pillow inner (photo 25).

I think that the presence of pillow inners and pillowcases on a dining table is unusual.
People do not eat pillows and pillow cases, nor do people sleep on a dining table.
Therefore just before the search team arrived, the dining table was IMO being used by the family or their relatives to fold items which had been washed and dried in the washerdrier.
I think further clothing items, neatly folded and possibly ironed, are on top of the sideboard, where Eddie indicates.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Anna on August 10, 2014, 07:46:13 PM
The items on the dining table in the villa video are the same as these items in these clothing photos
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/VOLUME%20VIIIa_Processo_2123.jpg
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/VOLUME%20VIIIa_Processo_2124.jpg
On the dining table are two yellow pillowcases (photo 23), a white pillow inner (photo 24), and another white pillow inner (photo 25).

I think that the presence of pillow inners and pillowcases on a dining table is unusual.
People do not eat pillows and pillow cases, nor do people sleep on a dining table.
Therefore just before the search team arrived, the dining table was IMO being used by the family or their relatives to fold items which had been washed and dried in the washerdrier.
I think further clothing items, neatly folded and possibly ironed, are on top of the sideboard, where Eddie indicates.

I think that may be the case or they were being boxed ready for the clothing search. I can see no clothing on the sideboard where Eddie alerted though.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 10, 2014, 08:04:06 PM
I think that may be the case or they were being boxed ready for the clothing search. I can see no clothing on the sideboard where Eddie alerted though.
In the villa video has anyone seen an iron (or ironing board)?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Anna on August 10, 2014, 09:35:35 PM
In the villa video has anyone seen an iron (or ironing board)?

Poss I/board at the back? Clothes seem strewn everywhere, so probably being boxed up for another search.
Ironing board would probably be kept in broom cupboard, but no such cupboard in the searches


Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: misty on August 10, 2014, 09:46:45 PM
Poss I/board at the back? Clothes seem strewn everywhere, so probably being boxed up for another search.
Ironing board would probably be kept in broom cupboard, but no such cupboard in the searches


I'm not sure who trained Grime, or whether he was not aware the clothes were going to be boxed up for testing, but what forensic examiner wanders round in his trainers in an area where cadaver & blood is being tested for? Eddie can clearly be seen climbing all over the bed & inside the wardrobe on top of clothing/linen of some description.
I wonder how much cadaver contamination is carried on the dogs' paws & Grime's trainers?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 10, 2014, 09:50:05 PM
I think that may be the case or they were being boxed ready for the clothing search. I can see no clothing on the sideboard where Eddie alerted though.

I agree; definitely no sign of clothes folded or otherwise on the sideboard.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: slartibartfast on August 10, 2014, 10:01:07 PM

I'm not sure who trained Grime, or whether he was not aware the clothes were going to be boxed up for testing, but what forensic examiner wanders round in his trainers in an area where cadaver & blood is being tested for? Eddie can clearly be seen climbing all over the bed & inside the wardrobe on top of clothing/linen of some description.
I wonder how much cadaver contamination is carried on the dogs' paws & Grime's trainers?

Interesting, looked up MGs statement on scent transfer and found...

Quote
Cadaver scent contamination may be transferred in
numerous scenarios. Any contact with a cadaver which is then passed to any
other material may be recognised by the dog causing a 'trigger' indication.

So from this example, does this mean the virulent spreading of cadaver scent as espoused by some on here is a misunderstanding and in reality requires a far more immediate contact?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: misty on August 10, 2014, 10:23:07 PM
Interesting, looked up MGs statement on scent transfer and found...

So from this example, does this mean the virulent spreading of cadaver scent as espoused by some on here is a misunderstanding and in reality requires a far more immediate contact?

I know we're on the wrong thread now but I would suggest that not only Grime should have protective material over his trainers but the dogs' paws should also be covered. If Eddie had been digging in an area where cadaver remains were present during the preceding days then surely his paws would be contaminated - and we have been told that cadaver scent cannot be removed by washing alone. I believe, without having first checked, that Eddie's paws came into contact with every area or item he "marked" BEFORE he barked, with the exception of the key to the Scenic (and that was proven to have Gerry's blood on it). I stand to be corrected but I think it's a point which needs looking at.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 11, 2014, 09:33:40 PM
Quote
(http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=5003.0;attach=4179;image)
I think that the pile which Eddie sniffs just before alerting contains from top to bottom, a sheet of printed white paper, then these folded clothing items:

1. One pair of woman's trousers, HOBBS, size 8, checked pattern (white and black).

2. One woman's top, white, H & M, European size 5.

3. A childrens T-Shirt, red, with aeroplane motifs, NEXT, for the age 2-3, length 98 cms.

4. Sleeveless woman's T-shirt, white NEXT, in UK size 10

5. Bath towel, Turkish cloth, white SAN PEDRO

Source: http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/VOLUME%20VIIIa_Processo_2110.jpg


Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Matt Erixon on August 11, 2014, 09:53:26 PM
This entire thread is pure fantasy.
Agree.
I wonder if those who call the dogs unreliable would fly in an airplane when a dog alerted for a bomb in a bag?
"The dogs are unreliable, get ready for take off"!!
And it should be no problem to bring drugs through customs, because the dogs are unreliable.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Eleanor on August 11, 2014, 10:02:01 PM

Drugs and Bombs can be found.  Cadaver Odour obviously can't.

If someone is stopped by a Drug Sniffer Dog and nothing is found then they won't be arrested.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 11, 2014, 10:11:18 PM
Drugs and Bombs can be found.  Cadaver Odour obviously can't.

If someone is stopped by a Drug Sniffer Dog and nothing is found then they won't be arrested.

I was.. and I wasn't arrested
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Eleanor on August 11, 2014, 10:19:08 PM

Okay, Mate.  That's you banged up.  You smell of drugs.  And while we are about it, where's the bomb?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: slartibartfast on August 11, 2014, 10:23:09 PM
Drugs and Bombs can be found.  Cadaver Odour obviously can't.

If someone is stopped by a Drug Sniffer Dog and nothing is found then they won't be arrested.

To be fair, dogs alert to drug odour, bomb odour and cadaver odour.  Whereas if a drug dog alerts and no drugs are found then the person will be let to, if a bomb dog alerts and no bomb is found the person may not be so quick to be released.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Matt Erixon on August 11, 2014, 10:25:08 PM
Drugs and Bombs can be found.  Cadaver Odour obviously can't.

If someone is stopped by a Drug Sniffer Dog and nothing is found then they won't be arrested.

Yes they can.to verify their value is largely lacking, specifically for scents associated with the early postmortem interval. The aim of our investigation was the comparative evaluation of the reliability, accuracy, and specificity of three cadaver dogs belonging to the Hamburg State Police in the detection of scents during the early postmortem interval. Carpet squares were used as an odor transporting media after they had been contaminated with the scent of two recently deceased bodies (bodies are all less than 3 hours old). The contamination occurred for 2 min as well as 10 min without any direct contact between the carpet and the corpse. Comparative searches by the dogs were performed over a time period of 65 days (10 min contamination) and 35 days (2 min contamination). The results of this study indicate that the well-trained cadaver dog is an outstanding tool for crime scene investigation displaying excellent sensitivity (75-100), specificity (91-100), and having a positive predictive value (90-100), negative predictive value (90-100) as well as accuracy (92-100). Reference: Cadaver dogs–a study on detection of contaminated carpet squares. Oesterhelweg L, Kröber S, Rottmann K, Willhöft J, Braun C, Thies N, Püschel K, Silkenath J, Gehl A. Institute of Legal Medicine, University Medical Center Hamburg, Germany.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 11, 2014, 10:31:11 PM
Yes they can.to verify their value is largely lacking, specifically for scents associated with the early postmortem interval. The aim of our investigation was the comparative evaluation of the reliability, accuracy, and specificity of three cadaver dogs belonging to the Hamburg State Police in the detection of scents during the early postmortem interval. Carpet squares were used as an odor transporting media after they had been contaminated with the scent of two recently deceased bodies (bodies are all less than 3 hours old). The contamination occurred for 2 min as well as 10 min without any direct contact between the carpet and the corpse. Comparative searches by the dogs were performed over a time period of 65 days (10 min contamination) and 35 days (2 min contamination). The results of this study indicate that the well-trained cadaver dog is an outstanding tool for crime scene investigation displaying excellent sensitivity (75-100), specificity (91-100), and having a positive predictive value (90-100), negative predictive value (90-100) as well as accuracy (92-100). Reference: Cadaver dogs–a study on detection of contaminated carpet squares. Oesterhelweg L, Kröber S, Rottmann K, Willhöft J, Braun C, Thies N, Püschel K, Silkenath J, Gehl A. Institute of Legal Medicine, University Medical Center Hamburg, Germany.

we have all seen this many times Matt
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Eleanor on August 11, 2014, 10:31:29 PM
To be fair, dogs alert to drug odour, bomb odour and cadaver odour.  Whereas if a drug dog alerts and no drugs are found then the person will be let to, if a bomb dog alerts and no bomb is found the person may not be so quick to be released.

This is true.

I wonder if they have different dogs for different explosives and different drugs.  They obviously need different dogs for different body odours.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Eleanor on August 11, 2014, 10:34:22 PM
Yes they can.to verify their value is largely lacking, specifically for scents associated with the early postmortem interval. The aim of our investigation was the comparative evaluation of the reliability, accuracy, and specificity of three cadaver dogs belonging to the Hamburg State Police in the detection of scents during the early postmortem interval. Carpet squares were used as an odor transporting media after they had been contaminated with the scent of two recently deceased bodies (bodies are all less than 3 hours old). The contamination occurred for 2 min as well as 10 min without any direct contact between the carpet and the corpse. Comparative searches by the dogs were performed over a time period of 65 days (10 min contamination) and 35 days (2 min contamination). The results of this study indicate that the well-trained cadaver dog is an outstanding tool for crime scene investigation displaying excellent sensitivity (75-100), specificity (91-100), and having a positive predictive value (90-100), negative predictive value (90-100) as well as accuracy (92-100). Reference: Cadaver dogs–a study on detection of contaminated carpet squares. Oesterhelweg L, Kröber S, Rottmann K, Willhöft J, Braun C, Thies N, Püschel K, Silkenath J, Gehl A. Institute of Legal Medicine, University Medical Center Hamburg, Germany.

Obviously an interesting test.   But they are still going to need a bit more than a dog alert to convict someone.  At least I hope so.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 11, 2014, 11:31:24 PM
Attracta Harron was murdered on 11 DEC 2003. In FEB 2004 Eddie alerted in the burnt out car so 2 months later. Eddie found her body on 5 APR 2004.

"The search of a suspect's 'totally burnt out vehicle' by forensic scientists did not reveal any evidence.
 A 'one minute' search by the EVRD identified a position in the rear passenger footwell where the dog alerted to the presence of human material.
 A sample was taken and when analysed revealed the victim's DNA.
 The enquiry then concentrated it's efforts on the suspect and the EVRD located the body of the woman in a river bank deposition site.
 Further searches identified a location where the EVRD alerted in the front bedroom of the offender's empty next door dwelling house.
 When interviewed the suspect admitted that the body had laid in the room for 1 hour prior to disposal. Forensic teams were unable to extract any forensic evidence despite being shown the exact position."

So 4 months later Eddie alerted to cadaver scent where a body had been in the bedroom for only 1 hour. Forensics found nothing.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 11, 2014, 11:50:09 PM
... Eddie alerted in the burnt out car ... the EVRD identified a position in the rear passenger footwell ...
Yes Eddie solved the case and jailed Hamilton.
But are you claiming that this brilliant dog, who can detect the scent in that burnt out Hyundai, would completely miss the scent on several items of non-burnt-out clothing in the villa living area?
It is a simple deduction, that those clothing items must be on the top of that sideboard.
Eddie is consistent.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 12, 2014, 12:01:49 AM
Yes Eddie solved the case and jailed Hamilton.
But are you claiming that this brilliant dog, who can detect cadaver scent in that burnt out Hyundai, would completely miss the scent on several items of non-burnt-out clothing in the villa living area?
It is a simple deduction, that those clothing items must be on the top of that sideboard.
Eddie is consistent.

There are no clothes on the sideboard and the alerted clothes are not seen in the villa footage.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 12, 2014, 12:10:04 AM
There are no clothes on the sideboard and the alerted clothes are not seen in the villa footage.
So do you think Eddie's nose was not good enough to find the red plane t-shirt in the villa living area?

 
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 12, 2014, 12:19:32 AM
So do you think Eddie's nose was not good enough to find the red plane t-shirt in the villa living area?

 

Show me where the red top is?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 12, 2014, 12:29:43 AM
Show me where the red top is?
Where Eddie detects it - item 3 http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=5003.msg178806#msg178806

Your theory has Eddie failing to find it in the villa. So where in the villa do you think it is? In a hermetically sealed container?

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 12, 2014, 01:10:27 AM
Where Eddie detects it - item 3 http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=5003.msg178806#msg178806

Your theory has Eddie failing to find it in the villa. So where in the villa do you think it is? In a hermetically sealed container?



How would I know where it is. You can't find it in the footage. Clothes are separated and Eddie sniffs close to alert. See pic.

(https://imagizer.imageshack.us/v2/349x190q50/46/lar4.jpg)

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 12, 2014, 02:18:15 AM
http://youtu.be/c4NMYPsFKb8?t=10m20s
evidence box outside on balcony 10:20
evidence box in hall 10:43
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: misty on August 12, 2014, 02:39:02 AM
How would I know where it is. You can't find it in the footage. Clothes are separated and Eddie sniffs close to alert. See pic.

(https://imagizer.imageshack.us/v2/349x190q50/46/lar4.jpg)


Another example of the dog's paws all over the item before he marks it!!
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 12, 2014, 03:09:31 AM

Another example of the dog's paws all over the item before he marks it!!
But cadaver scent can be transferred from Eddie's paws onto an item ONLY if cadaver scent was earlier transferred onto Eddie's paws from another item which he trod on earlier.
So the paw transfer theory works ONLY if one starts off with an item which does have cadaver scent on.



Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 12, 2014, 03:10:17 AM
http://youtu.be/c4NMYPsFKb8?t=10m20s
evidence box outside on balcony 10:20
evidence box in hall 10:43

According to Dr Amaral’s book there were three bites at the cherry. 

One in the villa where he states “Eddie goes immediately to the lounge. He comes to a stop in front of a wicker armchair on which is lying Madeleine's small pink soft toy, which Kate was never without in the early days of the investigation. Nowadays, she wears a rosary and a green ribbon around her neck. Eddie barks to let us know that he has detected an odour: the soft toy has been in contact with a body.” Which is not exactly the sequence of events we have watched ad nauseam in the video, but there you are.

However what is certain is that Eddie did not alert to clothing in the villa.

The second bite is also mentioned in Dr Amaral’s book where he tells us that great pains were taken to decontaminate a garage for the purpose of the inspection.

However that is ineffective also, as he tells us, “The soft toy and all the clothes from the house are placed into boxes specially made to preserve evidence. These objects are then conveyed to the decontaminated premises. They are placed on the ground, a good distance apart for the dogs to examine.
At 8pm, Tavares de Almeida calls me to let me know that Mark Harrison requires another place because this one is not sufficiently clean.
How do I find a place at this kind of time?
- Sort it out!
Julio Barroso offers us the new sports hall in Lagos which, finally, meets the required standards. The objects are once again laid out on the ground and the dogs can start. Eddie alerts us to a strong cadaver odour on some of Kate's clothes, but the CSI dog doesn't detect the slightest trace of blood.”

Wow ~ wonder what a defence would have made of that little performance.

There is no doubt these items were present in the villa the VRD ignored them despite having access to them where they were laid out over chairs, beds etc; and to drawers and cupboards; they were boxed and transported to premises where they were laid out on the ground which was too contaminated to allow a VRD's nose pick up a scent IMO because there was no scent there to begin with.
They were boxed again and taken to a gymnasium where they were laid out on a floor again ... and a bemused VRD ran all over them, chucked them about a bit and barked.

http://goncaloamaraltruthofthelie.blogspot.co.uk/2009/06/chapter-16.html
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 12, 2014, 03:13:34 AM
But cadaver scent can be transferred from Eddie's paws onto an item ONLY if cadaver scent was earlier transferred onto his paws from another item which he trod on earlier.
So the paw transfer theory works ONLY if one starts off with an item which does have cadaver scent on.

Lordy pegasus ... think of all the juicy scents available in a gymnasium.

Eddie's feet were the least of it.  None of the humans present had covered their outdoor shoes.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 12, 2014, 03:17:49 AM
"...He comes to a stop in front of a wicker armchair ..."
I question the translation "wicker armchair". What are the words in the original portuguese book? Would "bentwood chair" be a better translation? If so, this may refer to the bentwood dining chair, next to which Eddie does alert (the second alert in the villa video).
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 12, 2014, 03:24:06 AM
I question the translation "wicker armchair". What are the words in the original portuguese book? Would "bentwood chair" be a better translation? If so, this may refer to the bentwood dining chair, next to which Eddie does alert (the second alert in the villa video).

Don't know about the translation but Eddie did not go immediately to the lounge. He was in the master bedroom where Martin Grime can be seen replacing a pink blanket into the cupboard before exiting and proceeding to the lounge, where Eddie hauled cuddle cat unceremoniously out of a box then studiously ignored him.
Next time we see CC he is emerging from a cupboard. No sign of him on any type of chair.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 12, 2014, 03:25:38 AM
Lordy pegasus ... think of all the juicy scents available in a gymnasium.

Eddie's feet were the least of it.  None of the humans present had covered their outdoor shoes.
If Eddie was a sweaty foot detection dog he would have alerted in all the bathrooms and bedrooms of Casa Liliana, Vista do Mar, 5A, 5B, 5D, 5H, and 4G.
He didn't. Because he is not a sweaty foot detection dog.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 12, 2014, 03:47:05 AM
If Eddie was a sweaty foot detection dog he would have alerted in all the bathrooms and bedrooms of Casa Liliana, Vista do Mar, 5A, 5B, 5D, 5H, and 4G.
He didn't. Because he is not a sweaty foot detection dog.

Quite simply, I do not believe Eddie alerted to cadaver odour on the clothes in the gymnasium.  How do you explain that he did not alert to these items in the villa.  To Dr Amaral's consternation neither did he alert to the same items in the decontaminated garage.
If he alerted to cadaver odour in the gymnasium and he had not alerted on two previous inspections it stands to reason the clothes became contaminated between their last port of call ~ the decontaminated garage ~ and their next.
The question then arises ~ how exactly did that tranference occur ~ and that might be worth pondering.

I'm off, this is a ridiculous time to be up at ... sleep tight (unless you're working a nightshift)
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 12, 2014, 03:48:44 AM
Don't know about the translation but Eddie did not go immediately to the lounge. He was in the master bedroom where Martin Grime can be seen replacing a pink blanket into the cupboard before exiting and proceeding to the lounge, where Eddie hauled cuddle cat unceremoniously out of a box then studiously ignored him.
Next time we see CC he is emerging from a cupboard. No sign of him on any type of chair.

ALERT 1 (watch from 03:52 in the video)
Eddie has a good sniff at the cupboard containing the cat and totally ignores it.
Eddie alerts (loud barking) to the second pile he sniffs on top of the sideboard.
http://youtu.be/c4NMYPsFKb8?t=3m52s

ALERT 2 (watch from 04:15 in the video)
Eddie alerts (loud barking) to something which is on the seat of the bentwood dining chair.
http://youtu.be/c4NMYPsFKb8?t=4m15s

I think that "bentwood chair" is likely to be the correct translation of Mr Amaral's original portuguese words in his book.

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 12, 2014, 09:04:54 AM
ALERT 1 (watch from 03:52 in the video)
Eddie has a good sniff at the cupboard containing the cat and totally ignores it.
Eddie alerts (loud barking) to the second pile he sniffs on top of the sideboard.
http://youtu.be/c4NMYPsFKb8?t=3m52s

ALERT 2 (watch from 04:15 in the video)
Eddie alerts (loud barking) to something which is on the seat of the bentwood dining chair.
http://youtu.be/c4NMYPsFKb8?t=4m15s

I think that "bentwood chair" is likely to be the correct translation of Mr Amaral's original portuguese words in his book.

Eddie was barking all over the place after sniffing at the pile of papers on top of the cupboard, particularly in the direction of his handler.  In the absence of a shot of the chair there will never be a definitive answer because the cupboard was not opened until after they left to have a quick sniff in the bedroom before the door was opened to reveal him sitting there; only after Eddie had been stood down was CC revealed.
Three things spring to mind; who put him in there; why was he put in there; and when was he put in there?

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: ferryman on August 12, 2014, 09:22:00 AM
Don't know about the translation but Eddie did not go immediately to the lounge. He was in the master bedroom where Martin Grime can be seen replacing a pink blanket into the cupboard before exiting and proceeding to the lounge, where Eddie hauled cuddle cat unceremoniously out of a box then studiously ignored him.
Next time we see CC he is emerging from a cupboard. No sign of him on any type of chair.

Don't forget the edited-out sequence of Eddie physically playing with the toy, biting it, tossing it in the air and so forth ...
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 12, 2014, 11:56:20 AM
Quite simply, I do not believe Eddie alerted to cadaver odour on the clothes in the gymnasium.  How do you explain that he did not alert to these items in the villa.  To Dr Amaral's consternation neither did he alert to the same items in the decontaminated garage.
If he alerted to cadaver odour in the gymnasium and he had not alerted on two previous inspections it stands to reason the clothes became contaminated between their last port of call ~ the decontaminated garage ~ and their next.
The question then arises ~ how exactly did that tranference occur ~ and that might be worth pondering.

I'm off, this is a ridiculous time to be up at ... sleep tight (unless you're working a nightshift)

Show me the alerted clothes in the villa. You are assuming without evidence. If they're in the footage then show me. It should be easy. Until that day speculate all you want because it changes nothing. Eddie alerted to death on Kate's pants and a kid's t-shirt. The last time the missing kid and Kate are alone together are from 6-7pm 3 May. 6:30 is there someone at the door?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 12, 2014, 12:05:50 PM
Show me the alerted clothes in the villa. You are assuming without evidence. If they're in the footage then show me. It should be easy. Until that day speculate all you want because it changes nothing. Eddie alerted to death on Kate's pants and a kid's t-shirt.

So the PJ carefully extracted the items of clothing which miraculously developed cadaver scent between the ‘decontaminated’ garage and the Lagos gymnasium from the clothing we saw draped over chairs and on beds in the villa and removed them before Eddie had a chance to sniff them?  Is that what you are saying?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 12, 2014, 01:04:31 PM
So the PJ carefully extracted the items of clothing which miraculously developed cadaver scent between the ‘decontaminated’ garage and the Lagos gymnasium from the clothing we saw draped over chairs and on beds in the villa and removed them before Eddie had a chance to sniff them?  Is that what you are saying?


Cadaver scent was alerted in the apartment where the child went missing and the clothes connect to that not the villa or gym months later.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 12, 2014, 02:20:37 PM
Eddie barked in 5a three months after Madeleine went missing; if Eddie had barked at the clothing in the villa it would never have been packed and removed to the garage; if Eddie had barked in the garage it would never have been packed and removed to the gymnasium where Eddie barked again.

The fact that Eddie did not alert to the clothing in either the villa or the garage imo means that there was no cadaver scent on it; if there had been Eddie's nose would have found it at that stage.

The connection is not between 5a and the gymnasium.

The connection is between the garage - where he did not alert - and the gymnasium - where he did.

Somewhere along the line the chain of evidence changed.

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 12, 2014, 02:40:14 PM
Eddie barked in 5a three months after Madeleine went missing; if Eddie had barked at the clothing in the villa it would never have been packed and removed to the garage; if Eddie had barked in the garage it would never have been packed and removed to the gymnasium where Eddie barked again.

The fact that Eddie did not alert to the clothing in either the villa or the garage imo means that there was no cadaver scent on it; if there had been Eddie's nose would have found it at that stage.

The connection is not between 5a and the gymnasium.

The connection is between the garage - where he did not alert - and the gymnasium - where he did.

Somewhere along the line the chain of evidence changed.

There was alerts inside the apartment where the child went missing and outside in the corner of the garden. On the clothes and from the car.

As Kate quoted in her book:
As a lawyer once said to me, ‘One coincidence, two coincidences – maybe they’re still coincidences. Any more than that and it stops being coincidence.’
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: DCI on August 12, 2014, 03:19:21 PM
So the PJ carefully extracted the items of clothing which miraculously developed cadaver scent between the ‘decontaminated’ garage and the Lagos gymnasium from the clothing we saw draped over chairs and on beds in the villa and removed them before Eddie had a chance to sniff them?  Is that what you are saying?

How many handled cuddle cat before it was tested? There are 3 or 4 men in that room,

1. Dog plays with it, Grime picks up cuddle cat, dog goes missing for ages

2. Grime removes cuddle cat from floor and waves it about before putting it on the dining table.

3.Someone? Puts it in the cupboard, dog ignores it.

How many more times was cuddle cat handled before testing?

God if Grime's an expert in forensics, I'm the Queen of Sheba.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: ferryman on August 12, 2014, 03:45:40 PM
Eddie barked in 5a three months after Madeleine went missing; if Eddie had barked at the clothing in the villa it would never have been packed and removed to the garage; if Eddie had barked in the garage it would never have been packed and removed to the gymnasium where Eddie barked again.

The fact that Eddie did not alert to the clothing in either the villa or the garage imo means that there was no cadaver scent on it; if there had been Eddie's nose would have found it at that stage.

The connection is not between 5a and the gymnasium.

The connection is between the garage - where he did not alert - and the gymnasium - where he did.

Somewhere along the line the chain of evidence changed.

Hang on, hang on.

Wasn't the garage the venue of the inspection of the vehicles?

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 12, 2014, 05:01:08 PM
Hang on, hang on.

Wasn't the garage the venue of the inspection of the vehicles?

According to Dr Amaral’s book the clothes were removed to a garage which had been decontaminated ‘from top to bottom’ for the purpose, prior to them being moved to the gymnasium, because it wasn't clean enough? or because Eddie didn't alert?
No video record of the event, and nothing I can see in the files about it, unlike the record of the cuddle cat tossing incident.

The vehicle search was another entity designed not to find cadaver scent on the clothes, but in the vehicle hire vehicle.  Where despite the damaging leaks to the press resulting in lurid headlines like 100% Madeleine's DNA being found; Eddie's alert was not associated with any harm coming to Madeleine.

The imperative of finding something to use against the Drs McCann emphasises that the whole case against them rested solely on achieving alerts from the dogs because they had no other evidence against them. 

“either we find evidence of their responsibility in Madeleine's disappearance, or they will definitely be cleared of all suspicion.”

Quite scary if you think about it and if you have watched the videos.
 
Following are three quotes from Dr Amaral's books to which I have referred.

To avoid contamination of evidence that will be gathered at the McCanns', Mark Harrison has insisted on the availability of decontaminated premises exclusively set aside for this purpose. Julio Barroso, mayor of Lagos, agrees to lend us the garage of a new, unoccupied building in the centre of Lagos. The place is cleaned from top to bottom. http://goncaloamaraltruthofthelie.blogspot.co.uk/2009/06/chapter-16.html

At 8pm, Tavares de Almeida calls me to let me know that Mark Harrison requires another place because this one is not sufficiently clean.
- How do I find a place at this kind of time?
- Sort it out!
Julio Barroso offers us the new sports hall in Lagos which, finally, meets the required standards. The objects are once again laid out on the ground and the dogs can start. Eddie alerts us to a strong cadaver odour on some of Kate's clothes, but the CSI dog doesn't detect the slightest trace of blood. http://goncaloamaraltruthofthelie.blogspot.co.uk/2009/06/chapter-16.html

EXAMINATION OF THE McCANNS' HOUSE.
"The moment of truth has arrived." That's what everybody is thinking when searching begins at the accommodation the family is occupying from now on: either we find evidence of their responsibility in Madeleine's disappearance, or they will definitely be cleared of all suspicion.
http://goncaloamaraltruthofthelie.blogspot.co.uk/2009/06/chapter-16.html
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 12, 2014, 05:10:10 PM
There was alerts inside the apartment where the child went missing and outside in the corner of the garden. On the clothes and from the car.

As Kate quoted in her book:
As a lawyer once said to me, ‘One coincidence, two coincidences – maybe they’re still coincidences. Any more than that and it stops being coincidence.’

None of the alerts meant a thing, despite a huge case having been built on the strength of them.

If there was no evidence to enable the Drs McCann to be charged and prosecuted neither was there evidence to allow them to be traduced so shamefully in the pages of a book.   
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: slartibartfast on August 12, 2014, 05:12:46 PM
None of the alerts meant a thing, despite a huge case having been built on the strength of them.

If there was no evidence to enable the Drs McCann to be charged and prosecuted neither was there evidence to allow them to be traduced so shamefully in the pages of a book.

I'm surprised the police even bother to check when a dog alerts........
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: jassi on August 12, 2014, 05:15:01 PM
I'm surprised the police even bother to check when a dog alerts........

Quite. Beats me why the police even bother to train and deploy them.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 12, 2014, 05:31:32 PM
I'm surprised the police even bother to check when a dog alerts........

Oh dearie me ... usually when a dog alerts there is physical evidence to support what has been alerted to.  In 5a that 'evidence' may have been a blood spot behind the couch.

Cuddle cat ?? who can tell as there is no record of him being forensically inspected.

The clothes ... were they sent off for forensic examination?

The hire car ... blood on the key fob?

Desperate measures were required and the 'evidence' was aparently used to make the parents fess up; they refused to play that game; so under the circumstances when they did bother to check the results were inconclusive and I have no idea why other possible alerts were not checked.
Then again, I have no idea what those alerts signified and according to record, neither did the dog handler.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Benice on August 12, 2014, 06:15:03 PM
Quite. Beats me why the police even bother to train and deploy them.

I have no problem with the dogs - they are wonderful.    It was because of the humans involved that problems arose - particularly from those who didn't understand or who chose not to understand everything the handler tells us about their skills, but just wanted to cherry pick the skills which suited them and ignore those that didn't.   

Amaral comes firmly into this category IMO.      IIRC according to him Eddie only alerted to dead body scent and Keela only alerted to blood from dead bodies.  Wrong on both counts.   Why he didn't bother to acquaint himself with the full facts about the dogs before making accusations which could so gravely affect other people's lives is anyone's guess.   Or maybe he did know, but getting a 'result' was more important to him than getting the right result.

 
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 12, 2014, 06:24:13 PM
There was no forensic evidence found in the bedroom but Harron's body was there for an hour. Eddie was very good at his job so no forensics doesn't mean that they don't believe the dogs evidence.

"My professional opinion as regards to the EVRD's alert indications is that it is suggestive that this is 'cadaver scent' contaminant. This does not however suggest a motive or suspect as cross contamination could be as a result of a number of given scenarios and in any event no evidential or intelligence reliability can be made from these alerts unless they can be confirmed with corroborating evidence." (MG)


Heroic Puppy Saves Karina Chikitova, 3, Lost In Siberian Forest For 11 Days
http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2014/08/11/heroic-puppy-saves-karina-chikitova-lost-siberian-forest-11-days_n_5668293.html
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 12, 2014, 06:58:20 PM
There was no forensic evidence found in the bedroom but Harron's body was there for an hour. Eddie was very good at his job so no forensics doesn't mean that they don't believe the dogs evidence.

"My professional opinion as regards to the EVRD's alert indications is that it is suggestive that this is 'cadaver scent' contaminant. This does not however suggest a motive or suspect as cross contamination could be as a result of a number of given scenarios and in any event no evidential or intelligence reliability can be made from these alerts unless they can be confirmed with corroborating evidence." (MG)


Heroic Puppy Saves Karina Chikitova, 3, Lost In Siberian Forest For 11 Days
http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2014/08/11/heroic-puppy-saves-karina-chikitova-lost-siberian-forest-11-days_n_5668293.html

They continued looking until eventually they found Mrs Harron's body, that was a requirement to validate the dog's alert, without that corroboration or some other compelling evidence the alert could only have been considered an indication.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: ferryman on August 12, 2014, 07:05:11 PM
There was no forensic evidence found in the bedroom but Harron's body was there for an hour. Eddie was very good at his job so no forensics doesn't mean that they don't believe the dogs evidence.

"My professional opinion as regards to the EVRD's alert indications is that it is suggestive that this is 'cadaver scent' contaminant. This does not however suggest a motive or suspect as cross contamination could be as a result of a number of given scenarios and in any event no evidential or intelligence reliability can be made from these alerts unless they can be confirmed with corroborating evidence." (MG)


Heroic Puppy Saves Karina Chikitova, 3, Lost In Siberian Forest For 11 Days
http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2014/08/11/heroic-puppy-saves-karina-chikitova-lost-siberian-forest-11-days_n_5668293.html

... so no forensics doesn't mean that they don't believe the dogs evidence.

Dogs don't produce evidence!

They give indications.

Quite different!
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 12, 2014, 07:16:45 PM
Quite. Beats me why the police even bother to train and deploy them.

Think of the money that police forces and law enforcement agencies the world over,including the FBI, could have saved had they the perspicacity to consult with the internet jockeys on here rather than consult with a load of deadbeat so called experts in their field ? They could have put a few more button-men on the streets with all the dosh they saved. Bloody criminal waste of
money I call it and those experts on here who failed to notify the FBI & co  they were wasting their time show dereliction of their public duties. IMO.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 12, 2014, 07:50:58 PM
Think of the money that police forces and law enforcement agencies the world over,including the FBI, could have saved had they the perspicacity to consult with the internet jockeys on here rather than consult with a load of deadbeat so called experts in their field ? They could have put a few more button-men on the streets with all the dosh they saved. Bloody criminal waste of
money I call it and those experts on here who failed to notify the FBI & co  they were wasting their time show dereliction of their public duties. IMO.


You seem to be another one who does not understand the criticism of the alerts on this forum. Dog's are trained to find evidence and that's what makes them so useful. In this case no evidence was found. No one is criticising the dogs...its the belief that a wag of the tail or a bark has any real significance.

Unlike 10 kilos of heroin...a dead body....a bagful of semtex...finding these is what makes the dogs so valuable
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: slartibartfast on August 12, 2014, 09:39:26 PM
They continued looking until eventually they found Mrs Harron's body, that was a requirement to validate the dog's alert, without that corroboration or some other compelling evidence the alert could only have been considered an indication.

We agree on that, it is an indication that needs investigation.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 12, 2014, 09:59:36 PM

You seem to be another one who does not understand the criticism of the alerts on this forum. Dog's are trained to find evidence and that's what makes them so useful. In this case no evidence was found. No one is criticising the dogs...its the belief that a wag of the tail or a bark has any real significance.

Unlike 10 kilos of heroin...a dead body....a bagful of semtex...finding these is what makes the dogs so valuable

You are, sir, kicking against an open door that has no bias. I just find the antics of the "supporters" rather amusing when it comes to "The Dogs". My partner refers to my visits here as my "Bishop of Buckingham moments". I am not sure precisely what it means but nonetheless my partner chuckles when saying it so I presume it is amusing .
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 12, 2014, 10:07:42 PM
You are, sir, kicking against an open door that has no bias. I just find the antics of the "supporters" rather amusing when it comes to "The Dogs". My partner refers to my visits here as my "Bishop of Buckingham moments". I am not sure precisely what it means but nonetheless my partner chuckles when saying it so I presume it is amusing .

and you make no sense and add nothing to the debate... I am not surprised your partner laughs at you
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 13, 2014, 10:08:51 AM
and you make no sense and add nothing to the debate... I am not surprised your partner laughs at you
How unkind sir; but your idea that a dog "alerting" has no meaning or value is preposterous considering world wide experts disagree with you.
Tell me why should I believe the opinion of a faceless internet jockey, with too much time to spare, over the opinion of a real expert?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 13, 2014, 10:10:51 AM
How unkind sir; but your idea that a dog "alerting" has no meaning or value is preposterous considering world wide experts disagree with you.
Tell me why should I believe the opinion of a faceless internet jockey, with too much time to spare, over the opinion of a real expert?

It is not my opinion it's Grimes
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: slartibartfast on August 13, 2014, 12:19:43 PM
It is not my opinion it's Grimes

No it isn't.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 13, 2014, 12:39:53 PM
No it isn't.

So what value do the alerts have...what do they tell us
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 13, 2014, 02:19:39 PM
So what value do the alerts have...what do they tell us
That the dog has found a scent it has been trained to find and that operator intervention is now required to proceed further.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 13, 2014, 02:37:41 PM
That the dog has found a scent it has been trained to find and that operator intervention is now required to proceed further.

 ... that there was 'operator intervention' is incontrovertible ~ unless cuddle cat walked from the floor where Eddie threw him and hid himself in the cupboard hoping to continue the game.                 
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: ferryman on August 13, 2014, 03:29:49 PM
... that there was 'operator intervention' is incontrovertible ~ unless cuddle cat walked from the floor where Eddie threw him and hid himself in the cupboard hoping to continue the game.               

Assuming Grime directed operations, he either will have put the toy in the cupboard or directed someone else to do so.

Why?

I am inclined to think he simply didn't want a repeat of the fiasco of Eddie playing with it -- and rather made a "virtue" out of an embarrassment by holding the toy up as if some sort of trophy after Eddie had barked all around the cupboard ....
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Montclair on August 13, 2014, 04:01:48 PM
Quite simply, I do not believe Eddie alerted to cadaver odour on the clothes in the gymnasium.  How do you explain that he did not alert to these items in the villa.  To Dr Amaral's consternation neither did he alert to the same items in the decontaminated garage.
If he alerted to cadaver odour in the gymnasium and he had not alerted on two previous inspections it stands to reason the clothes became contaminated between their last port of call ~ the decontaminated garage ~ and their next.
The question then arises ~ how exactly did that tranference occur ~ and that might be worth pondering.

I'm off, this is a ridiculous time to be up at ... sleep tight (unless you're working a nightshift)

I believe that the clothes were packed and taken away before Eddie was brought in. The clothes were not laid out in the garage. The English translation which states that "the clothes were placed on the ground" is taken from an incorrect translation in the French edition of the book. In the original edition in Portuguese, it is said that the "clothes were to be placed" not "were placed".
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 13, 2014, 04:17:21 PM
That the dog has found a scent it has been trained to find and that operator intervention is now required to proceed further.

That's right...to look for evidence in the spot alerted to. No evidence found....so in this case the alert is of no use ..value...whatever
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 13, 2014, 04:47:34 PM
I believe that the clothes were packed and taken away before Eddie was brought in. The clothes were not laid out in the garage. The English translation which states that "the clothes were placed on the ground" is taken from an incorrect translation in the French edition of the book. In the original edition in Portuguese, it is said that the "clothes were to be placed" not "were placed".

In the video we saw clothes lying on beds and over chairs; we also saw boxes; later we viewed labels on the boxes stating which rooms in the villa the clothes had been taken from.  IMO the clothes were left out for the benefit of the VRD and if they had been alerted to they would have been bagged in situ.
Cadaver scent as we now know is highly transferrable and the VRD would have been able to alert to where they had been stored in the villa even if they had been moved.

You see this is all guess work re the forensically cleaned garage; there is nothing in the files about the clothes being taken to the garage that I can see and there is no way of knowing exactly what happened there because there is no video selectively edited or otherwise.

As for being ‘too dirty’ what exactly is too dirty for a cadaver dog? 

If it was necessary to have a search warrant to conduct these searches, wouldn’t it be usual to have someone from the defence team in attendance?  Just a thought.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 13, 2014, 05:14:38 PM
Assuming Grime directed operations, he either will have put the toy in the cupboard or directed someone else to do so.

Why?

I am inclined to think he simply didn't want a repeat of the fiasco of Eddie playing with it -- and rather made a "virtue" out of an embarrassment by holding the toy up as if some sort of trophy after Eddie had barked all around the cupboard ....

Perhaps he only said something like ‘put that toy out of sight’ and someone shoved it in the cupboard, so the jury is out on whether he knew it was there or not.

I think he believed the scent cone causing the alert had come from CC via the door which had been left ajar; but I think he may also  have seized on it as you say to avoid more embarrassment.

Eddie had played with CC and I have no doubt he would have been able to recognise CC’s scent; but I have no doubt either that his interest was in whatever was on top of the sideboard; could even have been blood from a paper cut, but on this occasion Keela was conspicuous by her absence, certainly in the video record.

With the door being ajar I think Eddie would have alerted at the gaps in the middle and the bottom, I don't think he would have jumped to smell the items on the top unless the scent was coming from there.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 13, 2014, 06:41:05 PM
That's right...to look for evidence in the spot alerted to. No evidence found....so in this case the alert is of no use ..value...whatever

As the dogs sense of smell is so acute it can alert to something we cannot find. That does not mean it does not exist.
To say something is worthless in this instance is rather fatuous and biased. Whilst it may not be useful in court it helps build up a picture for the investigators; note in this instance the investigation is led by an officer of the court not the bogeyman.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: colombosstogey on August 14, 2014, 04:46:42 AM
Nothing changes still on about the useless dogs lol.....this case is never going to  be solved. Life has moved on sadly.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 14, 2014, 09:06:17 AM
Nothing changes still on about the useless dogs lol.....this case is never going to  be solved. Life has moved on sadly.

I don’t think the dogs were particularly useless; I think they just could not find what was not there to be found in the first place; unfortunately a huge belief system has been built round what they singularly did not find which has persisted for nearly seven years now. 

Life has moved on for most of us and the mere fact that official resources have now been directed at investigating Madeleine’s case gives it the best chance it has ever had of being solved; the PJ stopped looking for her in the days after her disappearance because they had decided she was dead.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: ferryman on August 14, 2014, 09:54:33 AM
I don’t think the dogs were particularly useless; I think they just could not find what was not there to be found in the first place; unfortunately a huge belief system has been built round what they singularly did not find which has persisted for nearly seven years now. 

Life has moved on for most of us and the mere fact that official resources have now been directed at investigating Madeleine’s case gives it the best chance it has ever had of being solved; the PJ stopped looking for her in the days after her disappearance because they had decided she was dead.

What has long intrigued me about the searches is Mark Harrison's summary of them.

He owns UK participation in those searches he recommended; the places Madeleine either had been or conceivably might have been: the holiday apartments, areas in and around PdL and the Murats' place.

Both inspections at the villa and at the gym he summaries as PJ exercises.

And Harrison's only recommendation in respect of vehicles was all vehicles owned or driven by Murat.

In his summary, Harrison gives no clue who took part in the inspection of vehicles. 

From the files, the only explanation of the inspection at the gym is as it is about to happen: an attempt to identify clothing possibly indicated by the dogs (in the earlier inspection at the villa).

Most curious.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: sadie on August 14, 2014, 10:34:39 AM
Nothing changes still on about the useless dogs lol.....this case is never going to  be solved. Life has moved on sadly.

There was NOTHING useles about the dogs per se. 


It was Amarals non understanding of what the forensics meant that was useless.


I am being very kind to Amaral stating that it was his lack of understanding .....
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: ferryman on August 14, 2014, 11:45:54 AM
There was NOTHING useles about the dogs per se. 


It was Amarals non understanding of what the forensics meant that was useless.


I am being very kind to Amaral stating that it was his lack of understanding .....

Grime said Eddie reacted to the toy and he is (supposed to be!) the expert ...

If there was any scent coming from those papers or something associated, I guess that will for ever remain a point of speculation.

An interesting one, though ...
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 14, 2014, 12:33:40 PM
you only have to look at the rogatory questions to grime...proof that the pj did not understand the alerts
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: stephen25000 on August 14, 2014, 12:36:07 PM
you only have to look at the rogatory questions to grime...proof that the pj did not understand the alerts

They understood perfectly well what the dogs more than probably alerted to, it merely lacked the forensic corroboration.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 14, 2014, 02:05:43 PM
They understood perfectly well what the dogs more than probably alerted to, it merely lacked the forensic corroboration.

"merely ?? lacked the forensic corroboration."

You seem to believe that 'mere' evidence has no value; that is indeed a dangerous philosophy quite on a par with believing in the effectiveness of the ducking stool.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: stephen25000 on August 14, 2014, 03:52:59 PM
"merely ?? lacked the forensic corroboration."

You seem to believe that 'mere' evidence has no value; that is indeed a dangerous philosophy quite on a par with believing in the effectiveness of the ducking stool.

A completely irrelevant and childish comparison.

I have already stated innumerable times, the forensics were inconclusive.

Now if a body was found, it could well be a different matter.

So other than the dogs 'indications', what else has come to light in this case ?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 14, 2014, 04:50:33 PM
A completely irrelevant and childish comparison.

I have already stated innumerable times, the forensics were inconclusive.

Now if a body was found, it could well be a different matter.

So other than the dogs 'indications', what else has come to light in this case ?

 ... and what light have the dogs' indications thrown onto Madeleine's case? ... apart from very successfully deflecting attention from the perpetrator/s.

You have demonstrated one thing in your previous post ~ and that is your disregard for the probity of evidence.

In this post you have demonstrated your total hypocrisy; you continue to berate other posters and report them for 'abusive' comments at every opportunity; what is your “A completely irrelevant and childish comparison.”?

If not abusive it most certainly is derogatory.

People in glass houses and all that, but then I have noticed you tend to lose the plot in ratio to losing the argument.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: colombosstogey on August 17, 2014, 05:27:01 AM
A completely irrelevant and childish comparison.

I have already stated innumerable times, the forensics were inconclusive.

Now if a body was found, it could well be a different matter.

So other than the dogs 'indications', what else has come to light in this case ?

NOTHING, all that money SY spent, ZERO. Ground zero in fact. Until the blinkers are taken off there is no point to any of it. Every single post is just like ground hog day , round and round it goes........nothing new, nothing new, nothing new........

Lots of things have happened in the world since the child disappeared. SY waste of space IMHO. They should concentrate on their own cold cases...perhaps find Claudia Lawrence, and Suzy Lamplugh, might be a start.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 17, 2014, 07:53:21 AM
NOTHING, all that money SY spent, ZERO. Ground zero in fact. Until the blinkers are taken off there is no point to any of it. Every single post is just like ground hog dog, round and round it goes........nothing new, nothing new, nothing new........

Lots of things have happened in the world since the child disappeared. SY waste of space IMHO. They should concentrate on their own cold cases...perhaps find Claudia Lawrence, and Suzy Lamplugh, might be a start.

Glad you were able to get that off your chest.

Now ~ since you obviously have an opinion on everything under the sun ~ what is your opinion of Eddie having a good sniff at the pile of papers on top of the sideboard before starting to bark?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 17, 2014, 11:18:57 PM
Glad you were able to get that off your chest.

Now ~ since you obviously have an opinion on everything under the sun ~ what is your opinion of Eddie having a good sniff at the pile of papers on top of the sideboard before starting to bark?
An exact parallel:

1. In the apartment, Eddie sniffs the first wardrobe shelf up from the floor and then immediately alerts.
(Note that this is the shelf which, on the night, had contained a large untidy pile of clothing).

2. In the villa, Eddie sniffs a neatly folded pile of clothing (or papers as everyone else claims) and then immediately alerts.

In both alerts, last place sniffed is the place to look.
 
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 18, 2014, 03:37:05 AM
Hypothetically: If something had 3 months earlier been located temporarily on the first shelf up in wardrobe - wouldn't that explain why the exact location sniffed immediately before alerting was the first shelf up in wardrobe?



Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 18, 2014, 08:33:16 AM
Hypothetically: If something had 3 months earlier been located temporarily on the first shelf up in wardrobe - wouldn't that explain why the exact location sniffed immediately before alerting was the first shelf up in wardrobe?

Following that logic, your assertion seems to be that ‘something’ had been located on top of the sideboard.

I think that it is really way beyond the time when the fact that there was no forensic evidence found anywhere in PDL which could even hypothetically indicate the death of Madeleine McCann should be accepted.

Saying it, imagining it, ignoring the information received from the FSS does not alter that fact.

It should also be accepted that had there been the slightest evidence pointing to the guilt of Madeleine's parents in any way whatsoever, they would have been charged.


Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2014, 11:08:37 AM
Following that logic, your assertion seems to be that ‘something’ had been located on top of the sideboard.

I think that it is really way beyond the time when the fact that there was no forensic evidence found anywhere in PDL which could even hypothetically indicate the death of Madeleine McCann should be accepted.

Saying it, imagining it, ignoring the information received from the FSS does not alter that fact.

It should also be accepted that had there been the slightest evidence pointing to the guilt of Madeleine's parents in any way whatsoever, they would have been charged.

Then you seem to be at odds with SY who seem to have indications that Madeleine may indeed have perished in 5a.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Benice on August 18, 2014, 11:46:42 AM
Then you seem to be at odds with SY who seem to have indications that Madeleine may indeed have perished in 5a.

IMO no doubt emanating from information gleaned from the parents of all those UK children assaulted in their beds by the same man whilst on holiday in Portugal.    There may well be something in his MO which has caused them to believe that Madeleine may have been killed, either purposely or by accident, if he was the perpetrator.   If, for instance, he always put his hand over his victims mouths - that could result in death by suffocation.

Anyone hoping that SY's belief (that it is possible that Madeleine may have died in 5A) is connected to her parents, is deluding themselves IMO.   








Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: sadie on August 18, 2014, 11:49:44 AM
Then you seem to be at odds with SY who seem to have indications that Madeleine may indeed have perished in 5a.
No forensic evidence at all Faith. 

SY are just going thru the motions as they must do. 

Nothing to show that Madeleine died in 5A.  Nothing at all except overly suspicious minds.... or minds that have an agenda to hide the perpetrator and any others behind him.



We all know that Madeleine may have died somewhere in PdL, but there is enough evidence around that she almost certainly lived ... much I cant share.  Sorry.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on August 18, 2014, 12:06:42 PM
No forensic evidence at all Faith. 

SY are just going thru the motions as they must do. 

Nothing to show that Madeleine died in 5A.  Nothing at all except overly suspicious minds.... or minds that have an agenda to hide the perpetrator and any others behind him.



We all know that Madeleine may have died somewhere in PdL, but there is enough evidence around that she almost certainly lived ... much I cant share.  Sorry.

No, there ain't.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2014, 12:19:41 PM
No forensic evidence at all Faith. 

SY are just going thru the motions as they must do. 

Nothing to show that Madeleine died in 5A.  Nothing at all except overly suspicious minds.... or minds that have an agenda to hide the perpetrator and any others behind him.



We all know that Madeleine may have died somewhere in PdL, but there is enough evidence around that she almost certainly lived ... much I cant share.  Sorry.

You have no evidence that Madeleine is alive sadie. You have theories that you have based on cobbled together snippets of information from the internet and a large dose of wishful thinking.

Of course it is your prerogative to believe your theories carry some kind of weight but I'm afraid in the real world they don't.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2014, 12:23:04 PM
IMO no doubt emanating from information gleaned from the parents of all those UK children assaulted in their beds by the same man whilst on holiday in Portugal.    There may well be something in his MO which has caused them to believe that Madeleine may have been killed, either purposely or by accident, if he was the perpetrator.   If, for instance, he always put his hand over his victims mouths - that could result in death by suffocation.

Anyone hoping that SY's belief (that it is possible that Madeleine may have died in 5A) is connected to her parents, is deluding themselves IMO.

Benice what do you think SY are basing that belief on ?  Could it be the cadaver dog alerts perhaps ?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 18, 2014, 01:25:14 PM
Then you seem to be at odds with SY who seem to have indications that Madeleine may indeed have perished in 5a.

I have no issues nor am I at odds with the NSY investigation into what may have happened to Madeleine McCann; NSY are conducting a professional inquiry into her case I am sure they will rule nothing in nor out without corroborating evidence.

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Benice on August 18, 2014, 01:26:27 PM
Benice what do you think SY are basing that belief on ?  Could it be the cadaver dog alerts perhaps ?

As I said before - I believe they are basing it on the information from the UK parents - particularly on the MO of the person who assaulted their children.  Especially if there was a common denominator.

I don't know what SY think about the dogs alerts.     Except to say the alerts haven't prevented them from ruling out the McCanns and their friends from the enquiry.   

One can only speculate, but IMO it is likely that with there being so many different reasons why Eddie would alert - which do not involve a cadaver being in 5A - coupled with other reasons,  -   such as timelines which don't fit in with the time required for cadaver contamination to be present etc. etc.   they may have dismissed the possibility that Eddies alerts could have related to Madeleine.

IMO if Madeleine did die in 5A -  I think SY would believe she was removed very quickly - mainly to remove DNA evidence from the scene.

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2014, 02:26:25 PM
I have no issues nor am I at odds with the NSY investigation into what may have happened to Madeleine McCann; NSY are conducting a professional inquiry into her case I am sure they will rule nothing in nor out without corroborating evidence.

Of course you are at odds. You posted that there is no evidence that Madeleine is dead, SY seem to feel otherwise.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2014, 02:33:30 PM
As I said before - I believe they are basing it on the information from the UK parents - particularly on the MO of the person who assaulted their children.  Especially if there was a common denominator.

I don't know what SY think about the dogs alerts.     Except to say the alerts haven't prevented them from ruling out the McCanns and their friends from the enquiry.   

One can only speculate, but IMO it is likely that with there being so many different reasons why Eddie would alert - which do not involve a cadaver being in 5A - coupled with other reasons,  -   such as timelines which don't fit in with the time required for cadaver contamination to be present etc. etc.   they may have dismissed the possibility that Eddies alerts could have related to Madeleine.

IMO if Madeleine did die in 5A -  I think SY would believe she was removed very quickly - mainly to remove DNA evidence from the scene.

The MO of the individual who allegedly assaulted those children did not include killing and abducting their bodies. As far as I am aware every one of those victims are very much alive therefore that can't be it.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 18, 2014, 02:43:52 PM
Of course you are at odds. You posted that there is no evidence that Madeleine is dead, SY seem to feel otherwise.

Do not presume to tell me with whom I am at odds ~ I know that all too well and NSY certainly does not come into that category; and if you can show me what your evidence is that 'SY seem to feel otherwise' perhaps there can be debate rather than unsubstantiated opinion being posted which will no doubt become the fact of the matter in due time.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on August 18, 2014, 02:47:02 PM
Didn't Redwood say 18 months ago that there was no evidence that Madeleine is dead?  Whatever evidence may have come to light subsequently to make him now consider it a possibility it obviously wasn't the dog alerts as he knew about them at the time of his first statement on the matter.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: ferryman on August 18, 2014, 02:51:00 PM
I wonder how Amaral's plans to counter-sue the McCanns are shaping up?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 18, 2014, 03:00:28 PM
As I said before - I believe they are basing it on the information from the UK parents - particularly on the MO of the person who assaulted their children.  Especially if there was a common denominator.

I don't know what SY think about the dogs alerts.     Except to say the alerts haven't prevented them from ruling out the McCanns and their friends from the enquiry.   

One can only speculate, but IMO it is likely that with there being so many different reasons why Eddie would alert - which do not involve a cadaver being in 5A - coupled with other reasons,  -   such as timelines which don't fit in with the time required for cadaver contamination to be present etc. etc.   they may have dismissed the possibility that Eddies alerts could have related to Madeleine.

IMO if Madeleine did die in 5A -  I think SY would believe she was removed very quickly - mainly to remove DNA evidence from the scene.

As a result of the CW appeal they certainly have had more information from UK parents and the older victims who perhaps did not confide in anyone at the time of the offences.
I believe it is in the nature of offenders to escalate the wrongdoing the longer they are able to get away with it.
NSY will have collated and looked very closely at what was probably entirely new information.

At the time I was intigued by the DCI's statement not to assume that because something had been reported to the police to assume that Operation Grange knew about it and to phone in again.
I wonder if that could have been in relation to these assaults.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2014, 03:05:37 PM
Do not presume to tell me with whom I am at odds ~ I know that all too well and NSY certainly does not come into that category; and if you can show me what your evidence is that 'SY seem to feel otherwise' perhaps there can be debate rather than unsubstantiated opinion being posted which will no doubt become the fact of the matter in due time.

You said there was no evidence Madeleine is dead. SY say their thinking now is that Madeleine may have died in the apartment. Even you must see the disparity in those two statements.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on August 18, 2014, 03:10:57 PM
You said there was no evidence Madeleine is dead. SY say their thinking now is that Madeleine may have died in the apartment. Even you must see the disparity in those two statements.
There is no disparity.  SY acknowledge it may be a possibility, it doesn't mean they have solid evidence.  Like, for example in Yorkshire the police are certain Claudia Lawrence is dead, though they have not one shred of evidence that she is.  See how it works?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 18, 2014, 04:07:23 PM
You said there was no evidence Madeleine is dead. SY say their thinking now is that Madeleine may have died in the apartment. Even you must see the disparity in those two statements.
It would be more precise to say there is no conclusive evidence maddie is dead
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Benice on August 18, 2014, 04:17:14 PM
The MO of the individual who allegedly assaulted those children did not include killing and abducting their bodies. As far as I am aware every one of those victims are very much alive therefore that can't be it.


We don't know what the MO was - as we haven't been given details of the information which emanated from the interviews which will have taken place with the parents. 

It is not unknown for serial sex offenders to progressively get worse if they are not caught.  In fact I believe that is what usually happens.

IMO even an accidental death at the hands of the perpetrator is a very credible possibility and a very good reason to remove the body.

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2014, 05:56:29 PM

We don't know what the MO was - as we haven't been given details of the information which emanated from the interviews which will have taken place with the parents. 

It is not unknown for serial sex offenders to progressively get worse if they are not caught.  In fact I believe that is what usually happens.

IMO even an accidental death at the hands of the perpetrator is a very credible possibility and a very good reason to remove the body.

But it is almost unknown for a sexual offender to escalate his offending to murder then deescalate again to simply assaulting his victims as this offender seems to have done.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on August 18, 2014, 06:03:45 PM
But it is almost unknown for a sexual offender to escalate his offending to murder then deescalate again to simply assaulting his victims as this offender seems to have done.
Rubbish.  He may not have intended to kill Madeleine (indeed she may not even be dead).
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: faithlilly on August 18, 2014, 06:31:25 PM
Rubbish.  He may not have intended to kill Madeleine (indeed she may not even be dead).

You really don't know much about criminal psychology, do you Alfred ?

Now what part of my post was ' rubbish ' ?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: ferryman on August 18, 2014, 06:33:59 PM
The MO of the individual who allegedly assaulted those children did not include killing and abducting their bodies. As far as I am aware every one of those victims are very much alive therefore that can't be it.

Nevertheless, it is the modus operandi of the individual responsible for those attacks that prompted SY to consider that Madeleine may not have left apartment 5a alive.

Kate and Gerry McCann pose with a computer generated image of how their missing daughter Madeleine might look now, during a news conference in London May 2, 2012. REUTERS/Andrew Winning
Kate and Gerry McCann pose with a computer generated image of how their missing daughter Madeleine might look now, during a news conference in London May 2, 2012.
CREDIT: REUTERS/ANDREW WINNING
RELATED TOPICS
World »
(Reuters) - British detectives investigating the 2007 disappearance of Madeleine McCann said they were looking for a man suspected of carrying out a series of sexual assaults on young girls staying in Portuguese holiday villas between 2004 and 2010.

Madeleine McCann, then aged three, went missing from her bedroom at the Praia da Luz holiday resort in the Algarve region while her parents were dining with friends at a nearby restaurant, leading to a global search that gripped the world's media.

London police, who started a review of the case in 2011 and began their own investigation last year, said on Wednesday they were looking for more information about 12 crimes committed in Portuguese holiday resorts.

In four cases between 2004 and 2006 a man sexually assaulted five white girls, aged between 7 and 10 years, in their beds, in three different Algarve resorts, police said. Two of the 12 offences were committed in Praia da Luz.

"We need to eliminate this man from our enquiries and ascertain whether these offences are linked to Madeleine's disappearance," Andy Redwood, senior investigating officer at London's Metropolitan Police Service, told a news briefing.

The man, described as being tanned with short, dark, unkempt hair, spoke English with a foreign accent and would appear early in the morning. In some incidents, he was disturbed and left.

"This an offender who has got a very, very unhealthy interest in young, white female children who he's attacking while they're on holiday in their beds," Redwood said.

"ALL OPTIONS" OPEN

Redwood said the new appeal for information on the man who carried out the attacks was just one of the "priority lines" of inquiry currently being pursued. British police are also in contact with their counterparts in Spain, Belgium, Jersey, Switzerland, Netherlands and Germany over the case.

British Prime Minister David Cameron ordered a new investigation by London police after the McCanns wrote to him three years ago saying neither British nor Portuguese authorities had done enough to try to find their daughter.

Redwood said McCann might have long been dead.

"There is always the potential that she didn't leave the apartment alive. What is important for us to do is consider all the options," he said
.


Key point: consideration of this line of enquiry has nothing to do with Kate, Gerry or any of their friends.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Benice on August 18, 2014, 06:37:58 PM
But it is almost unknown for a sexual offender to escalate his offending to murder then deescalate again to simply assaulting his victims as this offender seems to have done.


The 'escalation' aspect of his offending could be her age.     And I did say an accidental death was a credible possibility.

(Must go - visitors are imminent)
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on August 18, 2014, 06:40:51 PM
You really don't know much about criminal psychology, do you Alfred ?

Now what part of my post was ' rubbish ' ?
Oh, right - so are you a criminal psychologist then?  Should I bow to your superior knowledge in these matters?

I have read enough about serial offenders to know that they do not always follow the same pattern, ie: that their behaviour only ever escalates.  Check out John Wayne Gacy's crimes for example.

Just because a certain behaviour may not be typical it does not mean it can be ruled out which is what you appear to want to do.  Also, we do not know if Madeleine's assailant has even struck again subsequently.  The sex attacks on children in the Algarve may have been carried out by more than one assailant.  We just don't know at this stage.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 18, 2014, 09:01:31 PM
Nevertheless, it is the modus operandi of the individual responsible for those attacks that prompted SY to consider that Madeleine may not have left apartment 5a alive.

Kate and Gerry McCann pose with a computer generated image of how their missing daughter Madeleine might look now, during a news conference in London May 2, 2012. REUTERS/Andrew Winning
Kate and Gerry McCann pose with a computer generated image of how their missing daughter Madeleine might look now, during a news conference in London May 2, 2012.
CREDIT: REUTERS/ANDREW WINNING
RELATED TOPICS
World »
(Reuters) - British detectives investigating the 2007 disappearance of Madeleine McCann said they were looking for a man suspected of carrying out a series of sexual assaults on young girls staying in Portuguese holiday villas between 2004 and 2010.

Madeleine McCann, then aged three, went missing from her bedroom at the Praia da Luz holiday resort in the Algarve region while her parents were dining with friends at a nearby restaurant, leading to a global search that gripped the world's media.

London police, who started a review of the case in 2011 and began their own investigation last year, said on Wednesday they were looking for more information about 12 crimes committed in Portuguese holiday resorts.

In four cases between 2004 and 2006 a man sexually assaulted five white girls, aged between 7 and 10 years, in their beds, in three different Algarve resorts, police said. Two of the 12 offences were committed in Praia da Luz.

"We need to eliminate this man from our enquiries and ascertain whether these offences are linked to Madeleine's disappearance," Andy Redwood, senior investigating officer at London's Metropolitan Police Service, told a news briefing.

The man, described as being tanned with short, dark, unkempt hair, spoke English with a foreign accent and would appear early in the morning. In some incidents, he was disturbed and left.

"This an offender who has got a very, very unhealthy interest in young, white female children who he's attacking while they're on holiday in their beds," Redwood said.

"ALL OPTIONS" OPEN

Redwood said the new appeal for information on the man who carried out the attacks was just one of the "priority lines" of inquiry currently being pursued. British police are also in contact with their counterparts in Spain, Belgium, Jersey, Switzerland, Netherlands and Germany over the case.

British Prime Minister David Cameron ordered a new investigation by London police after the McCanns wrote to him three years ago saying neither British nor Portuguese authorities had done enough to try to find their daughter.

Redwood said McCann might have long been dead.

"There is always the potential that she didn't leave the apartment alive. What is important for us to do is consider all the options," he said
.


Key point: consideration of this line of enquiry has nothing to do with Kate, Gerry or any of their friends.

ALL is the key word. All options are being considered as it should be.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 21, 2014, 11:12:11 AM
Sorry to resurrect Ccat, but trying hard to stay on topic.

Concerning the discussion taking place re: the laundry and the items alerted to in the gymnasium all coming from the same container; see - http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=4989.msg180804#msg180804 the potential for cross contamination suggested itself to me.

We have discussed and in general agreed that Eddie showed interest in the paperwork on top of the sideboard; the two yellow items which can be seen on top of the table must either be the pillowcases or towels mentioned in the list inspected in the gymnasium.

The first JPG shows Eddie alerting.

The second shows the table top with two yellow items.

The third shows the table top with the items removed.

The fourth shows yellow items being laid out on the gymnasium floor.

Therefore since all these items were transported in the same box it could be argued that whatever scent interested Eddie in the papers on top of the sideboard, had been transferred.




[attachment deleted by admin]
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: ferryman on August 21, 2014, 11:44:38 AM
ALL is the key word. All options are being considered as it should be.

Having made it plain separately that neither the McCanns nor their friends are suspects, Andy Redwood clearly saw no need  to belabour the point.

Perhaps he should have (belaboured the point!)

Either way, the fact remains the same.

Neither the McCanns nor their friends are suspects
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Matthew Wyse on August 21, 2014, 04:06:02 PM
... so no forensics doesn't mean that they don't believe the dogs evidence.

Dogs don't produce evidence!

They give indications.

Quite different!
not according to expert Martin Grime who stated that the no evidential or intelligence reliability can be made from these alerts unless they can be confirmed with corroborating evidence.  In other words had corroborating evidence been found the dog alerts would have constituted evidence.

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: ferryman on August 21, 2014, 04:08:59 PM
not according to expert Martin Grime who stated that the no evidential or intelligence reliability can be made from these alerts unless they can be confirmed with corroborating evidence.  In other words had corroborating evidence been found the dog alerts would have constituted evidence.

In other words (even Grime!) confirmed that dog alerts do not amount to evidence.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Mr Moderator on August 21, 2014, 04:31:22 PM
My own observation on the claimed alert to cuddle cat is that Eddie would have nosed into the cupboard if the soft toy was his target.  From the video it is plain to see that the dog made no attempt whatsoever to gain access to the cupboards even though the doors were left slightly ajar.  A bit of a dogs dinner I agree.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Carana on August 21, 2014, 04:47:57 PM
not according to expert Martin Grime who stated that the no evidential or intelligence reliability can be made from these alerts unless they can be confirmed with corroborating evidence.  In other words had corroborating evidence been found the dog alerts would have constituted evidence.

Well, hmm, yes, presumably. If a child's body (or other concrete evidence of her death) had been found as a result, then the dogs would have done their job.

The dogs are an asset to help forensic officers zoom in to locate potential evidence, just as a georadar scanner can be helpful. However, no evidence was found.

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Angelo222 on August 21, 2014, 04:49:59 PM
We all know that Madeleine may have died somewhere in PdL, but there is enough evidence around that she almost certainly lived ... much I cant share.  Sorry.

What nonsense Sadie. There isn't a single scrap of evidence which points to Madeleine having survived.  Why do you continue to post this dribble??
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Angelo222 on August 21, 2014, 05:14:35 PM

We don't know what the MO was - as we haven't been given details of the information which emanated from the interviews which will have taken place with the parents. 

It is not unknown for serial sex offenders to progressively get worse if they are not caught.  In fact I believe that is what usually happens.

IMO even an accidental death at the hands of the perpetrator is a very credible possibility and a very good reason to remove the body.

Speaking of the assaults that have recently been revealed, one thing comes to mind.  It has been claimed that an abductor may have been already in the apartment when GMcC did his check around 9.10pm.  Had that been the case and had it been the smelly pot-bellied bloke we so often hear about then in the confines of the apartment it was Gerry who would have smelled him and not the dogs.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Carana on August 21, 2014, 05:42:27 PM
Speaking of the assaults that have recently been revealed, one thing comes to mind.  It has been claimed that an abductor may have been already in the apartment when GMcC did his check around 9.10pm.  Had that been the case and had it been the smelly pot-bellied bloke we so often hear about then in the confines of the apartment it was Gerry who would have smelled him and not the dogs.

If he had a strong personal odour, I'd agree that Gerry would probably have noticed. However not all of the victims reported that, IIRC.

Neither the parents' bedroom, nor the kitchen were checked by the initial forensics team so it's not impossible that someone was already in there.

On the other hand, the idea that someone could have been lurking somewhere may just be thinking out loud about possibilities at the time in view of the relatively short time-frames, particularly as they were convinced that Jane's sighting was Madeleine.

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 21, 2014, 07:03:19 PM
My own observation on the claimed alert to cuddle cat is that Eddie would have nosed into the cupboard if the soft toy was his target.  From the video it is plain to see that the dog made no attempt whatsoever to gain access to the cupboards even though the doors were left slightly ajar.  A bit of a dogs dinner I agree.
Precisely. Eddie did not alert to Cuddlecat.
This is very important. The non-signalling of the cat tells me that:
1. The mother is telling the truth when she says the cat was on the bed when she entered the room.
2. The child left the cat on the bed when she got out of bed and walked into the other room.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 21, 2014, 11:26:55 PM
Precisely. Eddie did not alert to Cuddlecat.
This is very important. The non-signalling of the cat tells me that:
1. The mother is telling the truth when she says the cat was on the bed when she entered the room.
2. The child left the cat on the bed when she got out of bed and walked into the other room.


I agree that there was no alert from Eddie to Ccat and it is also my opinion that Madeleine's mother told the truth not only about finding the toy on the bed but about everything else she witnessed that night.

Dr Amaral theorised that Madeleine left bed of her own volition to walk into the other room where she met with a fatal accident which her parents and their friends proceeded to cover up.
That just did not happen and you only have to think "Why would they?" to realise that they would have had no reason to attempt to hide such a thing.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 21, 2014, 11:48:10 PM
I agree that there was no alert from Eddie to Ccat and it is also my opinion that Madeleine's mother told the truth not only about finding the toy on the bed but about everything else she witnessed that night.
I agree completely with you on that. An honest witness, and a big mistake by Mr Amaral to assume the contrary.
Dr Amaral theorised that Madeleine left bed of her own volition to walk into the other room
Well that seems like the most likely reason for a child not being in their bed doesn't it?
I think that is what happened. I do not understand why almost everyone from both sides (except Mr Amaral and me) rejects this simple and entirely possible action.
where she met with a fatal accident
Just looking at other cases it is physically not absolutely impossible.
which her parents and their friends proceeded to cover up.
That just did not happen and you only have to think "Why would they?" to realise that they would have had no reason to attempt to hide such a thing.
Here again I agree with you. Such a large quantity of people covering something like that up is absolutely unprecedented in previous cases and is impossible IMO.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 22, 2014, 12:00:36 AM
I agree completely with you on that.Well that seems like the most likely reason for a child not being in their bed doesn't it?
I think that is what happened. I do not understand why everyone from both sides (except Mr Amaral and me) rejects this simple and entirely possible action. Just looking at other cases it is physically not absolutely impossible.Here again I agree with you. Such a large quantity of people covering something like that up is absolutely unprecedented in previous cases and is impossible IMO.

Heri is of the opinion that she left her bed and went to the window and was lifted out, he demonstrates how this would be possible and how quickly it could be done in his blog.

It would have been possible for Madeleine to meet with an accident; but I discount that because I do not believe such an event would have been covered up; also I think it would not have been possible for her to either open the doors or the window and shutter to exit; I believe someone unknown removed her from the apartment.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 22, 2014, 12:32:16 AM
Heri is of the opinion that she left her bed and went to the window and was lifted out, he demonstrates how this would be possible and how quickly it could be done in his blog.

It would have been possible for Madeleine to meet with an accident; but I discount that because I do not believe such an event would have been covered up; also I think it would not have been possible for her to either open the doors or the window and shutter to exit; I believe someone unknown removed her from the apartment.
Well then you and me and Heri and Amaral have in common the small but important recognition, that it is possible the child may have got out of bed of own volition.
Surprisingly almost everyone who proposes abduction seems to think it could only have been by lifting directly from the bed. If I were proposing abduction I would think it far more likely that the child heard something and woke and walked into another room and got abducted from that other room. Do you rule that out?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 22, 2014, 01:22:29 AM
Well then you and me and Heri and Amaral have in common the small but important recognition, that it is possible the child may have got out of bed of own volition.
Surprisingly almost everyone who proposes abduction seems to think it could only have been by lifting directly from the bed. If I were proposing abduction I would think it far more likely that the child heard something and woke and walked into another room and got abducted from that other room. Do you rule that out?

No, I think it is a possibility; because we just do not know what happened so anything is possible. 

But although I think it possible and ties in with a lone abductor / burglar who was in the room when Madeleine interrupted him/her ~ it isn't what I think happened.

I also think she was alive when she left the apartment, but accept the possibility that she might have been dead.

I think Madeleine was targeted and I think a lot to do with it was the ease of access to and the vulnerability of apartment 5a; I think the absence of her parents was a ‘bonus’ but I think she would have been taken anyway during the night via the front door for which, I am sure, the perpetrator had a key.

 


Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Carana on August 22, 2014, 11:34:16 AM
Well then you and me and Heri and Amaral have in common the small but important recognition, that it is possible the child may have got out of bed of own volition.
Surprisingly almost everyone who proposes abduction seems to think it could only have been by lifting directly from the bed. If I were proposing abduction I would think it far more likely that the child heard something and woke and walked into another room and got abducted from that other room. Do you rule that out?

I wouldn't rule it out, either.

However, in that scenario, I've often wondered if she might have woken up to go to the loo and was faced with someone while up. In favour of that is the relatively neat bed and she would presumably not have taken CC with her to the loo. Against it, is that she was particularly tired and depending on the length of her natural first cycle of sleep and when she disappeared, it might not have been completed by that time.

If she had woken up due to an intruder in the bedroom... what would she have done? Immediately screamed if still very sleepy? Grabbed CC and "hidden" under the covers? Slipped out of bed silently towards and past an unknown person in the dark? The latter seems more unlikely to me.

A point that I still find important concerns the "lost" six hairs on the bed: if they had been analysed and found to belong to someone who had no reason to be there, then that might have proven to be a significant clue.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: sadie on August 22, 2014, 01:27:06 PM
Precisely. Eddie did not alert to Cuddlecat.
This is very important. The non-signalling of the cat tells me that:
1. The mother is telling the truth when she says the cat was on the bed when she entered the room.
2. The child left the cat on the bed when she got out of bed and walked into the other room.
Soz Pegasus, I dont think she walked into the other room.  I think she was almost certainly drugged, then lifted from her bed.  Children do not leave their beds as neatly as that.

We cant be sure, admittedly, that the bed was exactly like that when Madeleine went.
TBH, we are all assuming that it was and that is silly really .... cos we dont know.

My bet is that Kate opened the bed up and searched in there despite seeing no Madeleine shape there.  In panic, I probably would have done.  Also, my bet is that others might have looked into the bed to check for any clues that they might find.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Anna on August 22, 2014, 01:31:48 PM
Soz Pegasus, I dont think she walked into the other room.  I think she was almost certainly drugged, then lifted from her bed.  Children do not leave their beds as neatly as that.

We cant be sure, admittedly, that the bed was exactly like that when Madeleine went.
TBH, we are all assuming that it was and that is silly really .... cos we dont know.

My bet is that Kate opened the bed up and searched in there despite seeing no Madeleine shape there.  In panic, I probably would have done.  Also, my bet is that others might have looked into the bed to check for any clues that they might find.

I totally agree Sadie and most certainly someone would have pulled the bedcovers back to check and then replaced the covers
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on August 22, 2014, 02:24:45 PM
Soz Pegasus, I dont think she walked into the other room.  I think she was almost certainly drugged, then lifted from her bed.  Children do not leave their beds as neatly as that.

We cant be sure, admittedly, that the bed was exactly like that when Madeleine went.
TBH, we are all assuming that it was and that is silly really .... cos we dont know.

My bet is that Kate opened the bed up and searched in there despite seeing no Madeleine shape there.  In panic, I probably would have done.  Also, my bet is that others might have looked into the bed to check for any clues that they might find.

Was Maddie lying under the covers or on top of them, or were they perhaps folded down by her feet, do we know?

Who put her to bed, was it Kate, Gerry or both of them?

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 22, 2014, 02:41:31 PM
Was Maddie lying under the covers or on top of them, or were they perhaps folded down by her feet, do we know?

Who put her to bed, was it Kate, Gerry or both of them?



They don't know. Kate couldn't remember and Gerry was admiring how beautiful she was. Gerry said she was on top of the covers because it was very hot.

Kate: She was under the covers, she thinks, because it was a bit cold

Gerry: Madeleine was lying down on her left side, completely uncovered, i.e. lying on top of the covers, with the soft toy and blanket, both pink, next to her head.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Carana on August 22, 2014, 02:43:54 PM
I totally agree Sadie and most certainly someone would have pulled the bedcovers back to check and then replaced the covers

Possibly, or the reaction may have initially been to peer at the bed and give a gentle prod on the area where she should have been (so as not to wake her up, if simply asleep and not visible in the dark).
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Anna on August 22, 2014, 02:49:52 PM
Possibly, or the reaction may have initially been to peer at the bed and give a gentle prod on the area where she should have been (so as not to wake her up, if simply asleep and not visible in the dark).

If there was no bump, as you would expect to find, if someone was in the bed........................What would you do next?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on August 22, 2014, 02:50:52 PM
They don't know. Kate couldn't remember and Gerry was admiring how beautiful she was. Gerry said she was on top of the covers because it was very hot.

Kate: She was under the covers, she thinks, because it was a bit cold

Gerry: Madeleine was lying down on her left side, completely uncovered, i.e. lying on top of the covers, with the soft toy and blanket, both pink, next to her head.

GM.  'I'd just like to reiterate that this isn't a four-year-old girl, errm... walking off somewhere during the day or in the evening, you know, she was tucked up in bed, errm... and there's no way she... she could have got out on her own.'
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Rw4S5o2KPY&feature=player_embedded#t=144
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on August 22, 2014, 02:55:54 PM
If there was no bump, as you would expect to find, if someone was in the bed........................What would you do next?

Strange how Kate doesn't mention searching the bed during their reconstruction then.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lhACS6ck-Dw&feature=player_detailpage#t=54

 

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on August 22, 2014, 03:05:34 PM

She never mentions it on Crimewatch either.

She she was looking at Madeleines bed & couldn't quite make her out & then realised actually she's not in her bed.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=OZ8jmdWlB8Y#t=896

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 22, 2014, 03:06:35 PM
Strange how Kate doesn't mention searching the bed during their reconstruction then.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lhACS6ck-Dw&feature=player_detailpage#t=54

If there was no bump, as you would expect to find, if someone was in the bed........................What would you do next?

The PJ asked her why she was sat on it? Sitting on the bed would leave a bump.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Carana on August 22, 2014, 03:08:58 PM
If there was no bump, as you would expect to find, if someone was in the bed........................What would you do next?

Check elsewhere. In the initial seconds, it wasn't a panic situation.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Carana on August 22, 2014, 03:11:00 PM
The PJ asked her why she was sat on it? Sitting on the bed would leave a bump.

In which statement is it mentioned that Kate sat on Madeleine's bed? And if she had, how would that leave a bump?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Anna on August 22, 2014, 03:11:28 PM
Strange how Kate doesn't mention searching the bed during their reconstruction then.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lhACS6ck-Dw&feature=player_detailpage#t=54

You are right, She did not mention pulling the covers back to check, but its something that most mums would do!
   Did she get everything perfect and remember everything in the programme?
 Was the crime scene not a mess, where a lot of people had been searching ?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on August 22, 2014, 03:19:47 PM
You are right, She did not mention pulling the covers back to check, but its something that most mums would do!
   Did she get everything perfect and remember everything in the programme?
 Was the crime scene not a mess, where a lot of people had been searching ?

So why didn't she mention it in either reconstruction?

Or ever for that matter?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Anna on August 22, 2014, 03:23:36 PM
So why didn't she mention it in either reconstruction?

Or ever for that matter?

I have no idea.
 Did anyone mention looking under the bed or would these searches have been included in searched everywhere?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on August 22, 2014, 03:29:34 PM
I have no idea.
 Did anyone mention looking under the bed or would these searches have been included in searched everywhere?

How about in her account of the truth, does she mention searching the bed & moving the bed covers in there?

Why look under the bed when she knew she'd been taken?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=WLvnfcl-Zkg#t=1372
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Carana on August 22, 2014, 03:32:00 PM
I have no idea.
 Did anyone mention looking under the bed or would these searches have been included in searched everywhere?

Several people mentioned having looked in various places, including Fiona. Whether they remember where they actually looked, or just gave examples, may be a different matter. What was important at the time is that they'd looked and she wasn't anywhere.

There was no reason for the PJ officer to note with precision every place that they had checked - he just needed to be satisfied that people had checked in plausible places and that the child was indeed missing in order to file his report.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Carana on August 22, 2014, 03:39:40 PM
How about in her account of the truth, does she mention searching the bed & moving the bed covers in there?

Why look under the bed when she knew she'd been taken?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=WLvnfcl-Zkg#t=1372

Have you ever been in a similar situation? I really have no problem with the concept of sensing something instinctively and checking remote possibiities, just in case.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on August 22, 2014, 03:42:46 PM
Have you ever been in a similar situation? I really have no problem with the concept of sensing something instinctively and checking remote possibiities, just in case.

She hasn't once mentioned (in her book, 2 reconstructions, numerous interviews) checking either under the bed or moving the bed clothes, as far as I know.

Please do correct me if I'm wrong.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Anna on August 22, 2014, 04:22:44 PM
Her bed was found neat, as it was in CSI photos and there Is no way of knowing whether or not, they had been disturbed and reset, so just a possibility .
 Kate searched the whole apartment......Covers everything, so no need for her to itemise. just for our benefit surely!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Faced with this altered situation, she verified that the twins were in their beds, unlike Madeleine, who had disappeared. The cover was neatly pulled back and the toys were on the pillow as usual. After searching the whole apartment thoroughly, and already quite scared and unnerved, she returned to the restaurant, and alerted her husband and the rest of the group to the disappearance. The group immediately headed to the club, and set about searching in all the buildings, swimming pool, tennis courts etc... as well as in the apartment with the help of employees. At the same time, they contacted the authorities, which would later arrive.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post411.html#p411
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on August 22, 2014, 04:39:00 PM
Her bed was found neat, as it was in CSI photos and there Is no way of knowing whether or not, they had been disturbed and reset, so just a possibility .
 Kate searched the whole apartment......Covers everything, so no need for her to itemise. just for our benefit surely!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Faced with this altered situation, she verified that the twins were in their beds, unlike Madeleine, who had disappeared. The cover was neatly pulled back and the toys were on the pillow as usual. After searching the whole apartment thoroughly, and already quite scared and unnerved, she returned to the restaurant, and alerted her husband and the rest of the group to the disappearance. The group immediately headed to the club, and set about searching in all the buildings, swimming pool, tennis courts etc... as well as in the apartment with the help of employees. At the same time, they contacted the authorities, which would later arrive.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post411.html#p411

So, she didn't move the cover then.

She could see that the cover was neatly pulled back.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: sadie on August 22, 2014, 04:58:42 PM
So, she didn't move the cover then.

She could see that the cover was neatly pulled back.

I agree with Anna.  Even if the bedclothes were pulled back as per the photos we see, I would have still pullee them further back and really checked,   Silly tho it might seem.  After all they weren't pulled back properly.


And my bet is that others would have folded the bed back looking for clues as it dawned that Madeleine hadn't walked off and wandered.


I think too much emphasis is being put on a situation that we really do NOT KNOW exactly. 


Was the bed left exactly like we see it ?  By Madeleine?  Or even by an abductor?   Or had someone tidied it up out of neatness ?


Tbh, it doesn't look like anyone has just got out of that bed.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on August 22, 2014, 05:09:58 PM
I agree with Anna. Even if the bedclothes were pulled back as per the photos we see, I would have still pullee them further back and really checked,   Silly tho it might seem.  After all they weren't pulled back properly.


And my bet is that others would have folded the bed back looking for clues as it dawned that Madeleine hadn't walked off and wandered.


I think too much emphasis is being put on a situation that we really do NOT KNOW exactly. 


Was the bed left exactly like we see it ?  By Madeleine?  Or even by an abductor?   Or had someone tidied it up out of neatness ?


Tbh, it doesn't look like anyone has just got out of that bed.

Was Madeleine likely to have been as flat as a pancake then?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Carana on August 22, 2014, 07:52:50 PM
Was Madeleine likely to have been as flat as a pancake then?

I was thinking along the same lines. If it was clear that the bed was flat and that she wasn't in it, then flinging back the bedclothes might be an irrational panic reflex action that many people may do, but not necessarily.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 22, 2014, 08:30:44 PM
In which statement is it mentioned that Kate sat on Madeleine's bed? And if she had, how would that leave a bump?

The lady who seems to have an opinion on everything that went on from Robert Murat to ‘praying Arabs’ and equating a request for a priest with death; but who was very reticent about her actual area of responsibility which was staffing confirms that Dr McCann sat on her own bed – not Madeleine’s.

Snipped from one of her statements - 

She opened the wardrobes of that room in order to confirm that Madeleine wasn't eventually hiding there.

Then everyone left the room and someone shut the door. She remained for some time in the living room, near the GNR elements, Gerry and other elements of the group who got in and out and spoke on their cellular phones.

She observed that none of the elements of the group including the father and mother of the child was concerned with looking for her.

The mother was sitting on the bed of her room, the father was with her (the witness) and the elements of the GNR, and other elements of the group got in and out and spoke on the phone, anxious, in her opinion, to tell the press what happened.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/SILVIA_BATISTA.htm
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Anna on August 22, 2014, 08:50:54 PM
I was thinking along the same lines. If it was clear that the bed was flat and that she wasn't in it, then flinging back the bedclothes might be an irrational panic reflex action that many people may do, but not necessarily.

It seems that she often slept on top of the covers, covered with her pink blanket.
 Covered, but on top of the bed, so the bed would be flat and if this was the case, there would be no need to check under the covers for any evidence of why she had left her bed, but I would have done, so an irrational mum I must be!

Excerpt:-
When questioned, she said that during these holidays Madeleine usually slept clutching a soft toy, a pink cat, and sometimes also wrapped in a pink blanket. Sometimes she slept on top of the bedcover and at other times she was covered with it. When shown a photo of Madeleine’s bedroom and bed, she recognizes the soft toy and the blanket of the same colour.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post507.html#p507
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Anna on August 22, 2014, 09:18:28 PM
Sorry to resurrect Ccat, but trying hard to stay on topic.

Concerning the discussion taking place re: the laundry and the items alerted to in the gymnasium all coming from the same container; see - http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=4989.msg180804#msg180804 the potential for cross contamination suggested itself to me.

We have discussed and in general agreed that Eddie showed interest in the paperwork on top of the sideboard; the two yellow items which can be seen on top of the table must either be the pillowcases or towels mentioned in the list inspected in the gymnasium.

The first JPG shows Eddie alerting.

The second shows the table top with two yellow items.

The third shows the table top with the items removed.

The fourth shows yellow items being laid out on the gymnasium floor.

Therefore since all these items were transported in the same box it could be argued that whatever scent interested Eddie in the papers on top of the sideboard, had been transferred.

and CC is on 3.

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: valeria on August 22, 2014, 09:43:17 PM
I  don't think kate sat on madeleine's bed

Witness Statement

Jose Maria Batista Roque

G.N.R. Military Personnel

During the search he did not find anything strange apart from the bedclothes on Madeleine's bed, which were too tidy, it appeared that she had been picked up from or had left the bed with great care. There was a mark on the sheet that appeared to be made by a child's body.


Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: sadie on August 22, 2014, 09:48:47 PM
It seems that she often slept on top of the covers, covered with her pink blanket.
 Covered, but on top of the bed, so the bed would be flat and if this was the case, there would be no need to check under the covers for any evidence of why she had left her bed, but I would have done, so an irrational mum I must be!

Excerpt:-
When questioned, she said that during these holidays Madeleine usually slept clutching a soft toy, a pink cat, and sometimes also wrapped in a pink blanket. Sometimes she slept on top of the bedcover and at other times she was covered with it. When shown a photo of Madeleine’s bedroom and bed, she recognizes the soft toy and the blanket of the same colour.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post507.html#p507

It was quite cool that night.  Would she have slept on top of the bed on such a night?

And if she was left on top, how come the covers are turned neatly back ... and no rumples or hollows?


I really think we are in Cloud cookoo land if we take that photo of the bed as sacresanct.  Not only the family and friends had been looking but also the GNR.  I wonder how much looking the PJ had done before the photos were taken?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Anna on August 22, 2014, 10:21:16 PM
It was quite cool that night.  Would she have slept on top of the bed on such a night?

And if she was left on top, how come the covers are turned neatly back ... and no rumples or hollows?


I really think we are in Cloud cookoo land if we take that photo of the bed as sacresanct.  Not only the family and friends had been looking but also the GNR.  I wonder how much looking the PJ had done before the photos were taken?

I think They arrived before the forensic team and did a search which discovered the sheet that Valerie posted about.  So they had to disturb the bed, to check under the covers. They arrived at reception around 11pm, but I do not know what time they arrived at the apartment for sure.


Processos
Volume II
Pages 417 to 419


Nelson Filipe Pacheco da Costa

Date/Time: 2007/05/07 18H45
G.N.R. Military Personnel

Concerning the issue of the process said;
. In the sequence of facts, he was with the patrol of the GNR that went to the Ocean Club Gardens establishment (situated in Para da Luz) on night of May 03, 2007, with the goal of investigating the circumstances that surrounded the disappearance of a minor, of British nationality, that was installed there temporarily, together with the rest of her more direct family – knowing these to be, the respective parents, and two siblings, twins, minors, whose name do not need to be clarified;
. Clarifies that the occurrence in question was transmitted to the above referenced patrol via radio, at time when they were located in Odiaxere;
. The patrol of which he took part, and now as a witness, went immediately to the principal reception of the aforementioned establishment, where there was encountered the father of the missing child;
. Following, this patrol went to the residence where the family of said minor was staying in the ‘Ocean Garden’ together with the father;
. At reaching the location, the two elements that made up the patrol , the current witness and his colleague, Jose Roque, proceeded into the interior of the apartment, with the goal of investigating the contours which eventually surrounded the disappearance of that minor;
. In this sentiment, the deponent states that they searched al the dependencies of the residence and all the pieces of furniture, in order to confirm the disappearance -- effectively confirming that that she was not in the interior;
. The question made, the deponent states that the access to interior of the residence was accessed through a principal door- that is, a wood door which is placed facing north;
. Inside, the deponent encountered the mother and two siblings of the missing minor;
. The deponent stats that he is unable to specify if that entrance door was found open or closed when he reached the apartment during which he was taking in the facts with the witness is now clarifying;
. In the sequence of confirming the facts of the effective disappearance of that minor, he states that this has been communicated prior, for the reason of helping the Policia Judiciara;
. States that other details that may be relevant to the investigation concerns that they were directed to a citizen, of British nationality, who made up the group of tourists together with the family, name of Jane Tanner, and who detected the presence of a suspicious movement of an individual in the immediate area above identified, in the discourse of which was seen transporting a child of an early age;
. And nothing more said, having read the statement, finds it in conformity and signs it;
. The document is duly signed by me …

Pedro Varanda, an Inspector with this Polícia Judiciária.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic18.html
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Anna on August 22, 2014, 11:02:48 PM
Scenes of crime officers didn't arrive until 12.50 am and the first GNR on the scene, were already there
             So it looks like it was not all friends and family who disturbed the scene



Image

Translation: Ines.

Processos Vol 15

Pages 3856-3858

Witness Statement

Date: 2007/11/20 Time: 14H00 DIC Portimão

João Franciso Páscoa Luis Trigo Barreiras

Occupation: PJ Deputy Specialist

Place of work: Criminal Investigation Department Portimão

He is a specialist in the area of Criminology for the PJ and works in the Criminal Investigation department in Portimão.

His professional responsibilities are to carry out examinations at crime scenes, such as detecting finger prints, biological examinations as well as the identification, signalling and collection of other traces. He is also responsible for making photographic reports and sketches. On the date of the events – 3rd May 2007 he was on duty at the Portimão DIC.

At about 00.10 on the morning of the 4th, he had just finished filing a report about a fire, when he was informed that a child had disappeared in Praia da Luz.

He was brought into service together with an Inspector from the station. It was the inspector’s duty to take notes of the services as well as all the information relating to them. The inspector who accompanied him on that date, Vitor Martins, informed him that the case in question was that of the disappearance of a small girl, of British nationality, who was staying at the OC with her parents.

The immediately left for the scene and arrived about 30 – 40 minutes later, at about 00.40/00.50.

When they arrived at the scene, which they immediately identified due to the presence of GNR officers, as well as quite a lot of people who were walking around the street searching for the child, they immediately went to the apartment in question, where they found several people, including some GNR officers, as well as the head of the Lagos GNR station.

He states that the people inside the apartment and close to it, entered and left the building and circulated in the whole apartment, completely freely, in other words, without there being any restriction or care in preserving the scene. .

He said that these people were the friends of the parents of the missing girl and a lady responsible for the resort called Silvia.

He was shown the room the child had disappeared from, having noticed that people also entered and left that room without any care in the sense of preserving traces. Inside this room there were two children, babies, sleeping in two cots placed in the middle of the room.

It was requested that the babies were moved, which was done accordingly, the witness having subsequently put his gloves on to begin the on-site inspection.

At that moment one of the GNR officers told the witness that they had already searched for the girl in the wardrobes and other places in the apartment without having taken any care as to leaving their own traces or for destroying or adulterating any traces that might be of interest to the investigation.

After the arrival of the witness and his colleague Vitor Martins the scene was isolated and the inspection began, namely the collection of statements and inspection of the scene, the respective reports that were subsequently attached to the process documents.

The witness carried out finger print testing on the inside of the bedroom window, where the girl had been sleeping, leaving other examinations for the following day given that on that occasion these tests could not be carried out in the best technical conditions. For this reason, the apartments and the surrounding area were sealed off, watched over by the GNR officers who remained on site.

As far as he knows, after the first examination, other members from the finger print detection service and also officers from the LPC Crime Scene arrived at the scene.

The witness states that, at a given moment, the father of the missing girl led him to understand that he had already contacted the Sky News TV station and informed them of the situation.

As much the father as the girl’s mother looked quite worried with the situation and he can even confirm that the mother was very agitated and out of control, crying a lot and shouting in an uncontrolled manner, saying in English “They have taken her”.

He remembers that he remained on the scene until about 04.00. There were many people in the street. He does not remember having seen Robert Murat there on that occasion.

When questioned, he says that it was a fresh night with some breeze. It was not a clear night, nor was it very dark. Referring to the light conditions around the apartment, he says they were very dark, and thinks that even on a bright night there would always be little light around the apartment because of the trees and lack of street lights.

Reads, ratifies and signs.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post112.html#p112
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 23, 2014, 03:24:05 PM
and CC is on 3.

(http://i58.tinypic.com/140lwg6.jpg)

Great find. That would explain why Eddie was interested in the table not because of pillow cases or anything else.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 23, 2014, 04:39:44 PM
Amongst the items on the villa dining table are two white pillows
These clearly correspond to the white pillows in forensic clothing photos 24 and 25.

Also on the dining table are two yellow pillowcases (not striped)
These clearly correspond to the yellow pillowcases in forensic clothing photo23.

It is easy to prove that these pillows and pillowcases were provided as part of the villa rental deal, and had therefore never been in apartment 5A.
One of the pillows is marked "Visto do Mar" (the name of the villa).

So the cardboard box we are interested in includes amongst its contents:
Four items (photos 23 24 25) which have never been in the 5A, and are not signalled
Three items (photos 1 and 3, and one of either 2 or 4) which have been in 5A, and which are signalled.



Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 23, 2014, 05:51:38 PM
(http://i58.tinypic.com/140lwg6.jpg)

Great find. That would explain why Eddie was interested in the table not because of pillow cases or anything else.

Sorry PF that is not the case.
When Eddie was showing a bit of interest in the table, cuddle cat was still hiding in the cupboard; if you check the video you will see the pillows and the pillowcases are on the table top when he was barking; that still frame is after those items had been removed to be packed.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 23, 2014, 05:58:14 PM
Sorry PF that is not the case.
When Eddie was showing a bit of interest in the table, cuddle cat was still hiding in the cupboard; if you check the video you will see the pillows and the pillowcases are on the table top when he was barking; that still frame is after those items had been removed to be packed.

What are you on about? CC scent was ON the table in the footage. Eddie can detect scent away from the source.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 23, 2014, 06:06:31 PM
What are you on about? CC scent was above/on the table in that pic. Eddie can detect scent away from the source.

Cuddle cat was in the cupboard when Eddie alerted to the papers on top; Eddie just was not interested in CC; please check the video again and you will see that still showing CCbeing packed away is taken from footage which is at a remove from the time Eddie alerted.
Eddie did not bark in the direction of the chair and the table because CC was there; when Eddie barked CC was in the cupboard.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 23, 2014, 06:07:15 PM
CC placed on the table. Watch the footage at 10:35

(http://i61.tinypic.com/dcfps9.jpg)
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 23, 2014, 06:10:57 PM
Cuddle cat was in the cupboard when Eddie alerted to the papers on top; Eddie just was not interested in CC; please check the video again and you will see that still showing CCbeing packed away is taken from footage which is at a remove from the time Eddie alerted.
Eddie did not bark in the direction of the chair and the table because CC was there; when Eddie barked CC was in the cupboard.

On the cupboard. The cupboard door was open. I repeat Eddie can detect scent away from the source.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 23, 2014, 06:53:19 PM
On the cupboard. The cupboard door was open. I repeat Eddie can detect scent away from the source.

Martin Grime has stated that the alerts are suggestive...and therefore do not confirm the presence of a cadaver in 5a
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: John on August 23, 2014, 07:21:20 PM
But consider where Cuddle Cat was when the investigation team first arrived at the villa.  Was CC found on the table to which Martin Grime returned him?

(http://i61.tinypic.com/dcfps9.jpg)
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Eleanor on August 23, 2014, 08:17:40 PM
But consider where Cuddle Cat was when the investigation team first arrived at the villa.  Was CC found on the table to which Martin Grime returned him?

(http://i61.tinypic.com/dcfps9.jpg)

Oh, that looks like Martin Grime's hand.  Was that just before he stuffed CudleCat in the cupboard?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 23, 2014, 10:41:51 PM
The two white pillows, and the two non-striped yellow pillowcases.
Why are they on a dining table?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 23, 2014, 11:18:30 PM
The yellow pillowcases are non-striped.
I described them that way to distinguish them from the other item (a yellow/white striped towel).
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Eleanor on August 24, 2014, 12:43:17 AM
The yellow pillowcases are non-striped.
I described them that way to distinguish them from the other item (a yellow/white striped towel).

Sorry, Pegasus.  Real life sometimes encroaches.  Your research is  often quite awesome.  And you don't have any bias when detailing the facts that you find.  This is really good.  And thank you for that.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: misty on August 24, 2014, 12:46:57 AM
The yellow pillowcases are non-striped.
I described them that way to distinguish them from the other item (a yellow/white striped towel).

The yellow pillowcases were on the table before CC was placed there.
Out of all those items on the table, on top of the sideboard and  in the sideboard, why did Grime decide that Eddie had marked CC- the same CC not marked when it was in the bin & in the middle of the floor? Why didn't he open the other sideboard door, right beside where Eddie was standing, barking?
The same can be said of the key to the Renault Scenic - how did Grime know it was the key & not the car upholstery the dog was indicating?
It's all a farce, and I don't know why we bother to dissect every minute detail - right down to the person who touches Sean's red t-shirt seconds before Eddie marks it.
Splish splash splosh.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: John on August 24, 2014, 03:41:23 AM
Good points Misty and there might be some news on the dogs front in the very near future according to the latest information I have been given.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 24, 2014, 07:49:51 AM
Good points Misty and there might be some news on the dogs front in the very near future according to the latest information I have been given.

Was this from the person who told you Martin Grime would answer questions from posters on this forum......doesn't sound very convincing to me but I would be happy to receive any REAL news...does this mean SY are making progress
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: John on August 24, 2014, 01:46:30 PM
Was this from the person who told you Martin Grime would answer questions from posters on this forum......doesn't sound very convincing to me but I would be happy to receive any REAL news...does this mean SY are making progress

No, from the man himself.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 26, 2014, 03:11:27 AM
The yellow pillowcases were on the table before CC was placed there.
Out of all those items on the table, on top of the sideboard and  in the sideboard, why did Grime decide that Eddie had marked CC- the same CC not marked when it was in the bin & in the middle of the floor? Why didn't he open the other sideboard door, right beside where Eddie was standing, barking?
The same can be said of the key to the Renault Scenic - how did Grime know it was the key & not the car upholstery the dog was indicating?
It's all a farce, and I don't know why we bother to dissect every minute detail - right down to the person who touches Sean's red t-shirt seconds before Eddie marks it.
Splish splash splosh.
IMO he did not know whether it was the keycard, or something else, and that's why he decided to sandbox-test the keycard, to find out whether that was the source or not..
A sensible test to do, as the keycard was in the driver door pocket just above the driver door seal where Eddie sniffed when he alerted.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 26, 2014, 08:37:06 AM
IMO he did not know whether it was the keycard, or something else, and that's why he decided to sandbox-test the keycard, to find out whether that was the source or not..
A sensible test to do, as the keycard was in the driver door pocket just above the driver door seal where Eddie sniffed when he alerted.

Was Eddie taken back to the vehicle after the removal of the card and no alert given?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: ferryman on August 26, 2014, 08:45:20 AM
That Mark Harrison didn't even acknowledge who took part in the inspection of the vehicles tells you all you need to know about that particular part of the farce.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 27, 2014, 01:29:30 AM
Was Eddie taken back to the vehicle after the removal of the card and no alert given?
I see your point.
BTW has anyone considered that at the villa the keycard may have been on the sideboard / dining table / bentwood dining chair ?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: misty on August 27, 2014, 01:44:14 AM
I see your point.
BTW has anyone considered that at the villa the keycard may have been on the sideboard / dining table / bentwood dining chair ?

Why would the keycard have been there? The McCanns were kicked out of the villa at short notice at around 6pm when the PJ came to "film". How do you suppose they left and went elsewhere other than in the Scenic?
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 27, 2014, 01:47:23 AM
I see your point.
BTW has anyone considered that at the villa the keycard may have been on the sideboard / dining table / bentwood dining chair ?

Possible, who drove the vehicle to the garage?  If it was the PJ the key card might have been in the villa, possibly in the folder. 

I considered that someone could have recieved a paper cut and deposited a drop of blood amongst the paperwork on the sideboard top, sometimes they do bleed slightly and that is all the dogs need.
When I think about it - I didn't see Keela working at the villa.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 27, 2014, 01:58:10 AM
Possible, who drove the vehicle to the garage?  If it was the PJ the key card might have been in the villa, possibly in the folder. 

I considered that someone could have recieved a paper cut and deposited a drop of blood amongst the paperwork on the sideboard top, sometimes they do bleed slightly and that is all the dogs need.
When I think about it - I didn't see Keela working at the villa.
Villa search was Aug 2nd.
Vehicle search was Aug 6th (GM drove it to a cafe in Portimao, PJ presumably drove it from cafe to garage).
.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 27, 2014, 02:39:04 AM
Villa search was Aug 2nd.
Vehicle search was Aug 6th (GM drove it to a cafe in Portimao, PJ presumably drove it from cafe to garage).
.

Just watched the Panorama Nov 19th 2007 programme after reading Misty's post, where John Corner (appx 27:37) describes the PJ asking everyone to leave the villa.  The vehicle being used to exit appeared to be the Renault hire car.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zqoj-pfBUnY

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: misty on August 27, 2014, 03:13:15 AM
Just watched the Panorama Nov 19th 2007 programme after reading Misty's post, where John Corner (appx 27:37) describes the PJ asking everyone to leave the villa.  The vehicle being used to exit appeared to be the Renault hire car.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zqoj-pfBUnY



Thanks, Brietta :)
I had only sourced Kate's book &, of course, so many don't believe the contents of the book.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: ferryman on August 27, 2014, 08:59:53 AM
Thanks, Brietta :)
I had only sourced Kate's book &, of course, so many don't believe the contents of the book.

Still more astonishing is that the self-same people who don't believe the content of Kate's book regard Amaral's book, almost, as some kind of infallible guide ...

There's just no accounting for some folk.

Or is there? ...

Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 27, 2014, 10:55:04 AM
Still more astonishing is that the self-same people who don't believe the content of Kate's book regard Amaral's book, almost, as some kind of infallible guide ...

There's just no accounting for some folk.

Or is there? ...

I have not sat down and read the internet translations of Dr Amaral’s book from start to finish but of the excerpts I have read some were just plain wrong even at time of writing and others were incredibly naïve to have been penned by a detective with his years of experience. 

I am convinced that this book was written first for the money and second as a means of revenge on Madeleine’s parents.  I believe it demonstrations the nature of the man and for me that is not an edifying experience.

As time and events have progressed the major flaws both in the investigation and the conclusions and beliefs of the investigators become even more heartbreakingly apparent ... and yes, I believe there is accounting for some folk most of whom I would probably cross the road to avoid if I saw them coming.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 27, 2014, 02:05:10 PM
Just watched the Panorama Nov 19th 2007 programme after reading Misty's post, where John Corner (appx 27:37) describes the PJ asking everyone to leave the villa.  The vehicle being used to exit appeared to be the Renault hire car.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zqoj-pfBUnY
In same film see also footage of dining table and dining chair, probably on Aug 2nd before PJ/NPIA teatime arrival, but unfortunately not of sideboard
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: Brietta on August 27, 2014, 03:56:05 PM
In same film see also footage of dining table and dining chair, probably on Aug 2nd before PJ/NPIA teatime arrival, but unfortunately not of sideboard

I just scrolled through it because I remembered J.Corner commenting.  I am going to watch it again because it will be interesting to see how things were reported in 2007 and compare it with recent developments.
I don't remember anything at all about the interior shots of the villa, so I will look out for that.

I think it is highly likely that the papers on the sideboard were put there by the PJ and are connected to the removal of items from the villa.
It was the logical place to stand as can be seen from the dog video where an officer is packing CCat and the pillow cases have already been removed from the table top.  If memory serves me well there is a brief glimpse of the standing officer and one who is seated.

If the papers had been anything at all to do with the McCann family I believe they would have been given the same close camera scrutiny as were the contents of the drawer, the bedside reading materials, the labels on prescription medicines etc;
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on August 27, 2014, 04:02:45 PM
In panorama video, the dining table has same table cloth, but instead of the pillows, has breakfast cereals and laptop, this is probably morning 2nd.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: John on September 04, 2014, 10:32:31 PM
I just scrolled through it because I remembered J.Corner commenting.  I am going to watch it again because it will be interesting to see how things were reported in 2007 and compare it with recent developments.
I don't remember anything at all about the interior shots of the villa, so I will look out for that.

I think it is highly likely that the papers on the sideboard were put there by the PJ and are connected to the removal of items from the villa.
It was the logical place to stand as can be seen from the dog video where an officer is packing CCat and the pillow cases have already been removed from the table top.  If memory serves me well there is a brief glimpse of the standing officer and one who is seated.

If the papers had been anything at all to do with the McCann family I believe they would have been given the same close camera scrutiny as were the contents of the drawer, the bedside reading materials, the labels on prescription medicines etc;

A good observation Brietta, I tend to agree.
Title: Re: Ccat: Who does that pile of folders/ papers belong to?
Post by: pegasus on September 12, 2014, 04:55:49 PM
In the Panorama footage of loading car "they haven't come yet" is said on phone.
Which indicates the car loading footage was shot on morning of 2nd?
Also note soon after, audio possibly "lock the house"?