UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Angelo222 on October 24, 2014, 01:04:20 AM

Title: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Angelo222 on October 24, 2014, 01:04:20 AM
This question has bothered me recently so I am opening it up for discussion. 

What is more important, finding out what happened to Maddie and possibly getting her back or managing to convict someone for involvement in her abduction?

I ask this question because of a comment made on the reward thread, is it not better to know what happened to her regardless of any conviction?  An amnesty could be offered alongside a reward in a last attempt to get resolution.

Any takers??
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Eleanor on October 24, 2014, 01:19:56 AM

Not really, No.  I think someone, or several, will be charged before there is any chance of finding out where she is.  And then I expect them to deny it.

One bloody fingerprint isn't going to prove anything.  "I was there, but I never done it."
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Angelo222 on October 24, 2014, 01:30:45 AM
Not really, No.  I think someone, or several, will be charged before there is any chance of finding out where she is.  And then I expect them to deny it.

One bloody fingerprint isn't going to prove anything.  "I was there, but I never done it."

If I was her parent i would be wanting her back safe and sound and to hell with any conviction.  Do you agree Eleanor?
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Benice on October 24, 2014, 01:37:37 AM
This question has bothered me recently so I am opening it up for discussion. 

What is more important, finding out what happened to Maddie and possibly getting her back or managing to convict someone for involvement in her abduction?

I ask this question because of a comment made on the reward thread, is it not better to know what happened to her regardless of any conviction?  An amnesty could be offered alongside a reward in a last attempt to get resolution.

Any takers??

Definitely finding her IMO.    Any prosecutions which followed would just be a bonus IMO.  The McCanns need closure - one way or another.   The same goes for Ben Needham's family.   The 'not knowing' must be pure hell.


Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Eleanor on October 24, 2014, 01:39:43 AM
If I was her parent i would be wanting her back safe and sound and to hell with any conviction.  Do you agree Eleanor?

Too much assumption for me.  And too late now.  It wouldn't be for The McCanns to choose now.

However, if someone approached them secretly, heaven alone knows what they would decide to do.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Brietta on October 24, 2014, 01:39:58 AM
If I was her parent i would be wanting her back safe and sound and to hell with any conviction.  Do you agree Eleanor?

It isn't down to them ... it is down to due process.

I don’t think anyone is going to give Madeleine up even if they could or volunteer any information at all about what happened to her or who may have been involved. 

I think her best chance is in pursuing the criminals in this case as they would in any other, and hoping they uncover evidence in the process. 

I do not think anyone who knows anything will talk, for the simple reason that neither they nor their loved ones would be likely to enjoy spending a euro of any reward.  Omertà
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: jassi on October 24, 2014, 08:38:35 AM
All in all a depressing picture - no one talking , no likely conviction, no likely closure.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: stephen25000 on October 24, 2014, 08:43:42 AM
All in all a depressing picture - no one talking , no likely conviction, no likely closure.

..and SY are investigating a murder, well at least according to BHH.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: jassi on October 24, 2014, 09:01:52 AM
..and SY are investigating a murder, well at least according to BHH.

I find their stance interesting considering that we have been told countless times that there is no evidence that Madeleine has come to any harm.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: stephen25000 on October 24, 2014, 09:07:11 AM
I find their stance interesting considering that we have been told countless times that there is no evidence that Madeleine has come to any harm.

Indeed. That cliche  has been trotted out so many times, it has become crass.

If Madeleine had come to no harm, she would not have disappeared in the first place.




Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Benice on October 24, 2014, 09:12:18 AM
I find their stance interesting considering that we have been told countless times that there is no evidence that Madeleine has come to any harm.

DCI Redwood acknowledged that Madeleine may be dead a long time ago. 
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: jassi on October 24, 2014, 09:15:39 AM
DCI Redwood acknowledged that Madeleine may be dead a long time ago.


So, either there is evidence that she is dead, or SY are basing their investigation on a hunch.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Benice on October 24, 2014, 09:20:21 AM

So, either there is evidence that she is dead, or SY are basing their investigation on a hunch.

No.  SY believe she was removed from 5A by a stranger.   For what purpose they do not know.   She could have been murdered or not been murdered.   That is what they are trying to find out.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: stephen25000 on October 24, 2014, 09:44:48 AM
No.  SY believe she was removed from 5A by a stranger.   For what purpose they do not know.   She could have been murdered or not been murdered.   That is what they are trying to find out.

A belief in not evidence, let alone proof of anything.


BHH said, in his 'slip', a murder investigation, then altered that as he realized what he let slip.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Angelo222 on October 24, 2014, 10:23:10 AM
Definitely finding her IMO.    Any prosecutions which followed would just be a bonus IMO.  The McCanns need closure - one way or another.   The same goes for Ben Needham's family.   The 'not knowing' must be pure hell.

My sentiments for sure, that is why there has to be some unique thinking in this case and to date we haven't seen any.  Assuming for a moment she was abducted then someone knows about it but they won't come forward without some incentive.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Brietta on October 24, 2014, 10:24:24 AM
A belief in not evidence, let alone proof of anything.


BHH said, in his 'slip', a murder investigation, then altered that as he realized what he let slip.

If Madeleine has been murdered ... don't you think it is a good idea NSY are trying to find out by whom?

If Madeleine has not been murdered ... don't you think it is a good idea that NSY are making the effort to find out where she is?
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Angelo222 on October 24, 2014, 10:24:58 AM
Too much assumption for me.  And too late now.  It wouldn't be for The McCanns to choose now.

However, if someone approached them secretly, heaven alone knows what they would decide to do.

By that I assume you don't trust the políce?
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on October 24, 2014, 11:58:34 AM
This question has bothered me recently so I am opening it up for discussion. 

What is more important, finding out what happened to Maddie and possibly getting her back or managing to convict someone for involvement in her abduction?

I ask this question because of a comment made on the reward thread, is it not better to know what happened to her regardless of any conviction?  An amnesty could be offered alongside a reward in a last attempt to get resolution.

Any takers??

Removing political crimes from the argument why should there be any amnesty? What makes this case so special that one would offer amnesty from prosecution to the perpetrator of kidnap or murder either of which crimes is possible in this particular instance?.
Expanding to a wider view apart from family and police who has use for that particular piece of information in cases similar this?  Doing what you suggest leaves the judiciary powerless in exchange for a piece of information that then has little value.
How far would you wish to take this as a principle? If only as far as the McCann case see my first question.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on October 24, 2014, 02:02:42 PM
Removing political crimes from the argument why should there be any amnesty? What makes this case so special that one would offer amnesty from prosecution to the perpetrator of kidnap or murder either of which crimes is possible in this particular instance?.
Expanding to a wider view apart from family and police who has use for that particular piece of information in cases similar this?  Doing what you suggest leaves the judiciary powerless in exchange for a piece of information that then has little value.
How far would you wish to take this as a principle? If only as far as the McCann case see my first question.

Strongly agree with you there Alice.  Offering amnesties in ordr to solve deliberate crimes is rather pointless. 
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Mr Gray on October 24, 2014, 07:29:13 PM
getting back on topic...I don't see a scenario where this choice would be an option...so a pointless discussion
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Carana on October 24, 2014, 08:07:42 PM
This question has bothered me recently so I am opening it up for discussion. 

What is more important, finding out what happened to Maddie and possibly getting her back or managing to convict someone for involvement in her abduction?

I ask this question because of a comment made on the reward thread, is it not better to know what happened to her regardless of any conviction?  An amnesty could be offered alongside a reward in a last attempt to get resolution.

Any takers??

I'm not sure that I understand your question (at least as a separate issue to the comments on the reward thread).
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: sadie on October 27, 2014, 11:14:28 AM


Going back to topic.

Our emotions say, the most important thing is to get Madeleine back.
Our brains tell us that he must be stopped.

And there are 7 other missing kids in PT, they must be found.



It is imperative that this man and his group are stopped.  Children are too precious to leave such predators around.  A conviction; nay several convictions are called for imo.



And a previously whiter than white group must be exposed and its illicit trading stopped.

The Phoenix unfortunately will rise again, as it has several times before.



Sorry to talk in riddles.  A few on here will know exactly what i refer to.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: slartibartfast on October 27, 2014, 12:18:49 PM


Sorry to talk in riddles.  A few on here will know exactly what i refer to.[/size]

But would anyone admit to it?
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on October 27, 2014, 12:28:35 PM
Lol Slart


SY Have not stated they are looking for an abductor. THEY are looking for Maddie in the hope of finding out what happened to her. There is a difference.

They have people of interest- who they may want to ask: where they were, who they saw on that night.

The 'burglars' be have been witnesses to Maddies disappearance.

SY have not delclared the McCANNS to be 'innocent' at all.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: sadie on October 27, 2014, 06:41:59 PM
But would anyone admit to it?
I doubt it, cos it means that they know what has been going on in this dreadful affair and what goes on with the group behind the perp.

Now they aint going to admit that , are they?

Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: stephen25000 on October 27, 2014, 06:57:06 PM
I doubt it, cos it means that they know what has been going on in this dreadful affair and what goes on with the group behind the perp.

Now they aint going to admit that , are they?

Who isn't going to admit it ?



Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Brietta on October 27, 2014, 07:36:18 PM


Why don’t we just hope that the Met and the PJ manage to pull off the best of both worlds?

(a)   Finding Madeleine alive and well
(b)   Finding out all who were behind her disappearance and having enough evidence to go for a conviction

If no-one gives it a try, it sure won’t happen … but I think there is real commitment behind the present investigation … so there is every chance of progress and success.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Eleanor on October 27, 2014, 07:40:10 PM

Jolly well said, Brietta.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: jassi on October 27, 2014, 07:41:02 PM
Ain't going to happen, though
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Eleanor on October 27, 2014, 07:43:33 PM
Ain't going to happen, though

In Your Opinion.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: jassi on October 27, 2014, 07:46:55 PM
Definitely my opinion.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: John on November 05, 2014, 02:13:57 AM
This question has bothered me recently so I am opening it up for discussion. 

What is more important, finding out what happened to Maddie and possibly getting her back or managing to convict someone for involvement in her abduction?

I ask this question because of a comment made on the reward thread, is it not better to know what happened to her regardless of any conviction?  An amnesty could be offered alongside a reward in a last attempt to get resolution.

Any takers??

Too much water has flowed under the bridge for anyone to speak out now imo but that said, the priority should be to find Madeleine.  However, from what I have seen and heard coming out of Portugal recently this does not appear to be the case.  It would seem that a collar is more important to SY.  They weren't searching for an abductor, they were searching for a child who had wandered off.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: colombosstogey on November 05, 2014, 01:01:14 PM
Indeed. That cliche  has been trotted out so many times, it has become crass.

If Madeleine had come to no harm, she would not have disappeared in the first place.


Exactly Stephen. She did come to harm serious harm, just being taken away from her parents and siblings even if it was by a loving couple would have harmed her.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: colombosstogey on November 05, 2014, 01:18:49 PM
Too much water has flowed under the bridge for anyone to speak out now imo but that said, the priority should be to find Madeleine.  However, from what I have seen and heard coming out of Portugal recently this does not appear to be the case.  It would seem that a collar is more important to SY.  They weren't searching for an abductor, they were searching for a child who had wandered off.

I agree. To be honest was there anyone around who could have said anything really?  The child disappeared without a trace.

Perhaps there is no one out there who actually does no anything....

All seems odd to me. The reward was massive i really thought it would have broken someones silence but nothing.

Its like the child never existed in the first place and was all smoke and mirrors.

I think if she was to be found she would have been by now. IMHO. Thats why in my head and my heart i cant shake off the fact no one else was involved in her disappearance.

Not even her family.

I just keep having it in my head she did walk out and tragically and bizarrely she has been lost forever by a freak accident.

This can happen, children have been found dead in fridges, even killed by hiding behind cars, and fallen down holes, and wells and drain storms, and open drains horrible, and wondered off into the sea been taken by currents, drown in swimming pools, the list is endless. Yes one expect to find a body but every child is ever found again sadly.

I just wonder it would make sense to no one knowing anything, and no DNA being found etc.

Its either that or one very clever person has got away with the perfect crime.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: sadie on November 05, 2014, 07:29:34 PM
Too much water has flowed under the bridge for anyone to speak out now imo but that said, the priority should be to find Madeleine.  However, from what I have seen and heard coming out of Portugal recently this does not appear to be the case.  It would seem that a collar is more important to SY.  They weren't searching for an abductor, they were searching for a child who had wandered off.

On what grounds do you say that John?

 I see no evidence to point to the fact that they think she wandered off.

Can you explain please.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Carana on November 05, 2014, 07:41:10 PM
I agree. To be honest was there anyone around who could have said anything really?  The child disappeared without a trace.

Perhaps there is no one out there who actually does no anything....

All seems odd to me. The reward was massive i really thought it would have broken someones silence but nothing.

Its like the child never existed in the first place and was all smoke and mirrors.

I think if she was to be found she would have been by now. IMHO. Thats why in my head and my heart i cant shake off the fact no one else was involved in her disappearance.

Not even her family.

I just keep having it in my head she did walk out and tragically and bizarrely she has been lost forever by a freak accident.

This can happen, children have been found dead in fridges, even killed by hiding behind cars, and fallen down holes, and wells and drain storms, and open drains horrible, and wondered off into the sea been taken by currents, drown in swimming pools, the list is endless. Yes one expect to find a body but every child is ever found again sadly.

I just wonder it would make sense to no one knowing anything, and no DNA being found etc.

Its either that or one very clever person has got away with the perfect crime.

I wondered about the walked and wandered idea for quite a while. One point that seems to be against that is that not just the parents, but the police and OC staff don't think she could have opened the shutters by herself. The other is I have trouble imagining a child of that age wandering off without Cuddle Cat.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: ferryman on November 05, 2014, 07:47:15 PM
I wondered about the walked and wandered idea for quite a while. One point that seems to be against that is that not just the parents, but the police and OC staff don't think she could have opened the shutters by herself. The other is I have trouble imagining a child of that age wandering off without Cuddle Cat.

Or without shoes.

Madeleine's only pair of outdoor shoes on that holiday were found in the apartment ...
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: slartibartfast on November 05, 2014, 10:45:12 PM
Unless you can prove there was no abductor don't state as fact maddie was not abducted

He didn't.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: colombosstogey on November 06, 2014, 06:17:29 AM
I wondered about the walked and wandered idea for quite a while. One point that seems to be against that is that not just the parents, but the police and OC staff don't think she could have opened the shutters by herself. The other is I have trouble imagining a child of that age wandering off without Cuddle Cat.

What shutters? The patio door was unlocked, and I expect perhaps so was the front door....ah but was cuddle cat hers in the first place not convinced to be honest. In the pumpkin picture which is supposed to have been taken in end of October not long before her disappearance she is holding a dolly not her precious CC. In a photo she is playing on her dad geeup horsey and she is clutching a brown teddy bear....and looks about 3ish....i think she is with a friend.

Besides which kids do these things if they are ANGRY enough, they storm out and scream and shout and if they cant get their way say things like they HATE YOU, etc.....my grandson was her age at the time she went missing, and he was terrible at times and twice run off out the house causing his mother grief, because he was upset by his older brother.

4 year olds can do these things. My mum has a back patio door the same and my grandson can easily push it to the side enough to get through.

No i think she could if she set her mind to it and if she was angry enough perhaps, it could have happened. No one knows do they...

Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: colombosstogey on November 06, 2014, 06:24:13 AM
Who saw him then NO ONE?

We all know that Jane Tanners sighting was bogus, it was a creche dad going the other way.

So the SNATCH OF THE CENTURY was planned so well down to the finest detail that it went wrong because the most important part of the plan never happened. The get away driver fell asleep or broke down....

All sounds a bit far fetched to me.

All the person had to do was pick up the child from the bed say they were from mum and dad and were taking her for a treat but shhhhhh dont wake up the twins as this is special just for you.

Take the child out the front door quietly and negotiate the car park keeping in the shadows and go LEFT out towards the old road, and a car parked there. Why would anyone risk taking the child through lit streets with people walking about? Makes no sense to me.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Wonderfulspam on November 06, 2014, 07:59:24 AM
What shutters? The patio door was unlocked, and I expect perhaps so was the front door....ah but was cuddle cat hers in the first place not convinced to be honest. In the pumpkin picture which is supposed to have been taken in end of October not long before her disappearance she is holding a dolly not her precious CC. In a photo she is playing on her dad geeup horsey and she is clutching a brown teddy bear....and looks about 3ish....i think she is with a friend.

Besides which kids do these things if they are ANGRY enough, they storm out and scream and shout and if they cant get their way say things like they HATE YOU, etc.....my grandson was her age at the time she went missing, and he was terrible at times and twice run off out the house causing his mother grief, because he was upset by his older brother.

4 year olds can do these things. My mum has a back patio door the same and my grandson can easily push it to the side enough to get through.

No i think she could if she set her mind to it and if she was angry enough perhaps, it could have happened. No one knows do they...

Childgate with childlock at the top of the stairs.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: John on November 08, 2014, 03:07:10 PM
On what grounds do you say that John?

 I see no evidence to point to the fact that they think she wandered off.

Can you explain please.

Without going off topic too much, my response would be that several well known investigators have made the same suggestion.  There was nothing to stop Madeleine opening the front door and walking out, after all, this was how she departed for kids club every morning.  This is also why the first searchers went to the kids clubs, just in case she was following routine.

As regards the op, my own position has always been find Madeleine and to hell with the perps.  Getting Madeleine back must be the main priority but from what I have seen recently this is not happening.  I have always said that a reward must be offered for her return without any strings attached.  Her parents need to know what happened to her, they need closure.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Brietta on November 08, 2014, 03:24:35 PM
Without going off topic too much, my response would be that several well known investigators have made the same suggestion.  There was nothing to stop Madeleine opening the front door and walking out, after all, this was how she departed for kids club every morning.  This is also why the first searchers went to the kids clubs, just in case she was following routine.

As regards the op, my own position has always been find Madeleine and to hell with the perps.  Getting Madeleine back must be the main priority but from what I have seen recently this is not happening.  I have always said that a reward must be offered for her return without any strings attached.  Her parents need to know what happened to her, they need closure.

I’m not following this argument, John.
I think one premise follows hot on the heels of the other.  Find one and you find the other. 

I think the best chance that Madeleine has of being found is to locate the people who had, or knew someone who had responsibility for Madeleine’s disappearance. 
If someone had been going to give information for a reward, I think that would have been in the early days when huge newspaper rewards were on offer.

Now, I think her best chance is the police investigation and what arises from that. 
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Eleanor on November 08, 2014, 03:29:43 PM
I’m not following this argument, John.
I think one premise follows hot on the heels of the other.  Find one and you find the other. 

I think the best chance that Madeleine has of being found is to locate the people who had, or knew someone who had responsibility for Madeleine’s disappearance. 
If someone had been going to give information for a reward, I think that would have been in the early days when huge newspaper rewards were on offer.

Now, I think her best chance is the police investigation and what arises from that.

Exactly.  Find the perpetrator who will know what happened to Madeleine.  She could be anywhere in the world.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: jassi on November 08, 2014, 03:30:30 PM
I would have thought that without Madeleine, or her body, or a confession, it would be extremely difficult to pin anything on anybody.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: John on November 08, 2014, 03:44:02 PM
By going after the perpetrator you endanger a live captive.  If we were sure she was dead it wouldn't matter but we don't know.  If I were her parents I would be wanting to encourage someone to speak out without fear of the consequences.

Getting Madeleine back should be the priority and not a collar.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: jassi on November 08, 2014, 03:52:10 PM
By going after the perpetrator you endanger a live captive.  If we were sure she was dead it wouldn't matter but we don't know.  If I were her parents I would be wanting to encourage someone to speak out without fear of the consequences.

Getting Madeleine back should be the priority and not a collar.


Given that there has been no sign of her since she disappeared, just where would you start?
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: John on November 08, 2014, 04:09:42 PM

Given that there has been no sign of her since she disappeared, just where would you start?

A massive publicity campaign involving a big reward for information plus a guarantee of anonymity and a further undertaking that anyone providing information which leads to Madeleine being recovered would not be prosecuted.  My fear however is that they have left it much too late.

Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Carana on November 08, 2014, 04:21:55 PM
A massive publicity campaign involving a big reward for information plus a guarantee of anonymity and a further undertaking that anyone providing information which leads to Madeleine being recovered would not be prosecuted.  My fear however is that they have left it much too late.

Does the concept of amnesty exist in PT law?
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: John on November 08, 2014, 04:24:21 PM
Does the concept of amnesty exist in PT law?

Good question, I would think it does in some form or other.  In fact Article 127/128 of the /Portuguese Penal Code give effect to amnesty within the criminal procedure.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: jassi on November 08, 2014, 05:25:03 PM
A massive publicity campaign involving a big reward for information plus a guarantee of anonymity and a further undertaking that anyone providing information which leads to Madeleine being recovered would not be prosecuted.  My fear however is that they have left it much too late.


The McCanns undertook a massive publicity campaign - result zilch - no genuine sightings, no informers, no nothing.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Carana on November 08, 2014, 05:44:50 PM
Good question, I would think it does in some form or other.  In fact Article 127/128 of the /Portuguese Penal Code give effect to amnesty within the criminal procedure.

Well done for finding that.

The massive publicity campaign has taken place, a large reward was offered in the past (whether that was a good idea or not). Amnesty for information might be a step, but I would have thought that it would depend on the circumstances of the individual. There might be a difference between someone not coming forward due to working without a valid work permit and someone wanted for rape or violent burglaries, for example.

An interesting article on cold cases says that people coming forward with new information is more successful in solving them than DNA is. I don't know how whether that is always true or whether it simply was in the context of the scope of that particular study.
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2014/03/140306-cold-cases-murder-csi-forensic-science/

Jim Gamble said a long time ago that people do change allegiances over time, which makes sense. A family member dies, a couple splits up, a former partner in crime or violent spouse is safely in jail...

On the other hand, omertà might be strong in small communities.

DNA might also provide a breakthrough, e.g., if some of these hairs lead to a suspect, that might also help take things forward.

Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: sadie on November 08, 2014, 07:26:58 PM
A massive publicity campaign involving a big reward for information plus a guarantee of anonymity and a further undertaking that anyone providing information which leads to Madeleine being recovered would not be prosecuted.  My fear however is that they have left it much too late.
Do that, John, and any perp could take a child, subject the child to all sorts of abuse for their own satisfaction for years  .... then get off scot free.

Ready to do it all over again with another child.


Much as we all want Madeleine back, I dont think that is the right answer.  This man has to be arrested and go thru due process.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Mr Gray on November 08, 2014, 07:30:23 PM
A massive publicity campaign involving a big reward for information plus a guarantee of anonymity and a further undertaking that anyone providing information which leads to Madeleine being recovered would not be prosecuted.  My fear however is that they have left it much too late.

The McCanns cannot offer this...only the Portuguese judicial system could...would they agree?
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Carana on November 08, 2014, 07:37:56 PM
Do that, John, and any perp could take a child, subject the child to all sorts of abuse for their own satisfaction for years  .... then get off scot free.

Ready to do it all over again with another child.


Much as we all want Madeleine back, I dont think that is the right answer.  This man has to be arrested and go thru due process.

I don't think anyone is saying that the perp should get off scott-free, are they? I understood the question to be how to encourage someone who may have information to come forward.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: sadie on November 08, 2014, 07:43:55 PM
A massive publicity campaign involving a big reward for information plus a guarantee of anonymity and a further undertaking that anyone providing information which leads to Madeleine being recovered would not be prosecuted.   My fear however is that they have left it much too late.
Well I took it that John meant that.  His post doesn't exclude the perp.  Maybe he meant it to.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Carana on November 08, 2014, 08:31:04 PM
Well I took it that John meant that.  His post doesn't exclude the perp.  Maybe he meant it to.

Ah. OK. I didn't understand it that way. Perhaps John will clarify.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: misty on November 08, 2014, 08:35:36 PM
It may well be that somebody has already provided the new investigation with information which could lead to a solution of this case. However, the testimony of one individual would hardly be enough to result in a conviction, especially in Portugal, and would need to be backed up by cast-iron evidence.
Sadly, I feel the apparent lack of urgency on the part of both police forces means that finding a living Madeleine is no longer a priority.
Title: Re: What's more important? Finding Maddie or a conviction?
Post by: Carana on November 08, 2014, 08:43:35 PM
It may well be that somebody has already provided the new investigation with information which could lead to a solution of this case. However, the testimony of one individual would hardly be enough to result in a conviction, especially in Portugal, and would need to be backed up by cast-iron evidence.
Sadly, I feel the apparent lack of urgency on the part of both police forces means that finding a living Madeleine is no longer a priority.

True, but don't forget that two of the little Dutroux girls were eventually found alive. If the initial investigation had been more efficient, the first two might have been as well, poor little mites.