UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: John on October 19, 2015, 05:23:34 PM

Title: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: John on October 19, 2015, 05:23:34 PM
'Madeleine McCann case' behind Jet2 decision to bar sixteen-year-old girl from flying to Portugal alone

(http://i.imgur.com/Bf313qt.jpg?1)

By Steve Robson
18 October 2015

Staff at Jet2 said Portuguese authorities now have tighter controls around "minors" as a result of the high-profile abduction case.

(http://i3.mirror.co.uk/incoming/article6654970.ece/ALTERNATES/s615b/PAY-jet2.jpg)

A sixteen-year-old girl was told she couldn’t board a flight to Portugal alone "because of the Madeleine McCann case ".

Eilidh Strathie was all set to travel to Faro from Edinburgh to stay with her grandparents on the Algarve but was stopped at the gate by ground staff from Jet2.

They said that Eilidh - who is old enough to get married, join the army and ride a motorbike - needed a letter of consent from her parents and details of who would be collecting her in Portugal.

Although the British airline "allows persons aged 14 or over to travel alone", staff said rules in Portugal have tightened up as a result of the high-profile McCann abduction case.

Eilidh's parents were unable to email their consent in time to get her on the flight, and ended up having to come and bring their disappointed daughter home from Edinburgh airport.

Eilidh said: "My mum and dad took me to the airport and waited until I was through security.

"I went to the gate when boarding was called, but when I got to the desk the woman took me out of the queue and said I could not fly as I didn't have a letter giving my parents' consent and saying who was picking me up at the other end. It was really embarrassing."

Eilidh's mum, Corinna Strathie, was shocked when she got a call just 25 minutes before Eilidh's flight was due to leave.

Corinna, 42, said: "We'd left the airport by that time to go to work, and the Jet2 staff told us Eilidh would only be allowed to board if we quickly emailed our consent and the details of who she would be staying with.

"We tried desperately to send it, but the phone reception wasn't good and the emails simply wouldn't go through. It was heartbreaking and so frustrating."

Corinna added: "The staff, who were kind and helpful, explained that the reason Portugal is so strict is that the authorities there were criticised after the Madeleine McCann case.

"But this seems like a real overreaction to that."

"It didn't even cross my mind that you wouldn't be able to fly alone at that age. You can get married and leave home, but you need a letter from your mum and dad to fly to Portugal.

"I was so angry. At no point when I was booking the flight online did it flag up that people need written consent to travel to Portugal at that age.

"I was told that the information was included in the FAQ section, but when I checked later it was not clear at all that you are considered a minor at 16."

The Foreign Office guidance on travelling to Portugal now states: "All minors entering or leaving Portugal must be in possession of a letter of parental consent if travelling with adults other than their parents or legal guardians."

A Jet2.com spokesperson said: "We're sorry Eilidh and her family had such a frustrating experience.

"Jet2.com follows the clear advice set out by the Portuguese authorities, which can also be seen on the Foreign Office travel advice website.

"We have to ask for the letter of consent and details of who is meeting someone of this age as it is possible the Portuguese passport control may deny them entry into the country without such documents. In that case the airline can also be subject to a large fine.

"However, we acknowledge our FAQs could have been clearer and will be taking steps to change them. We would also like to offer the family a refund of the cost of the flight Eilidh missed as a goodwill gesture."

A spokesman for the British Air Travel Association said: "We encourage parents of minors who will be travelling unaccompanied to check with their airline before travel.

"Travel advice is also available on the Foreign Office website."

http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/madeleine-mccann-case-behind-jet2-6654982
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: ferryman on October 19, 2015, 05:49:25 PM
So what are we supposed to be debating?
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: John on October 19, 2015, 06:05:56 PM
So what are we supposed to be debating?

Basically how the Madeleine case continues to have the strangest of repercussions for young people even today.
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: Alfred R Jones on October 19, 2015, 06:06:28 PM
Looks like the  Portuguese authorities have definitely abandoned the idea that Madeleine came a cropper at the hands of her own parents, so that's probably a good starting point for a debate - I doubt the "sceptics" will agree!
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on October 19, 2015, 07:12:04 PM
I have got to say this is weird.

Quite why there would be a Portuguese restriction like this has me baffled.

Madeleine was approaching 4 and accompanied by her parents, not 16 and travelling alone.

I would have thought the airline could have handled it better, both at the time of booking and when the girl checked in, but that is another matter.  As for checking FAQ or looking at the Foreign Office website, that is pure farce.  She was travelling in Europe, not departing for Outer Mongolia (my apologies to Outer Mongolia).

I wonder how one proves that a letter of parental consent is genuine?

If this story is genuine, i.e. that Portuguese authorities imposed this requirement, it is a massive own goal.  It depicts Portugal as a dangerous country where 16 year olds are not safe, and where getting a taxi or bus from the airport is not safe.

The only bright side I can look on is the weather here is pants at the moment, although I suppose the rain is warmer than in Edinburgh.

Returning to the thread title, I have often wondered precisely what changes, if any, occurred in Portugal following Madeleine's disappearance.  One would have thought it was time to review the judicial secrecy rules in a missing child case, and to review what still seems to be a total block on police requests for help from the public, a la Crimewatch.

This travel restriction seems to be a step backward, not forward.
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: pathfinder73 on October 19, 2015, 07:25:55 PM
Woman, 29, charged with child neglect after baby "left alone" in Netherton house

15:58, 19 OCT 2015

A woman has been charged with child neglect after a baby was allegedly left alone at a house in Netherton.

Ashley Mossman, 29, of Hereford Drive, Netherton , has been released on bail to appear at Liverpool Magistrates Court on Thursday.

Neighbours yesterday described seeing police officers arriving in the street in the early hours.

Merseyside Police confirmed officers were called to reports a child had been left alone for a short period of time at an address.

The child was not injured and is now in the care of relatives. Social services have been informed.

A police spokesman said: “Merseyside Police can confirm a 29-year-old woman has been charged with child neglect following an incident in Netherton on Sunday.

“Ashley Mossman, 29, of Hereford Drive, Netherton has been released on bail to appear at Liverpool Magistrates Court on Thursday, October 22.”

http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/woman-29-charged-child-neglect-10291028
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: mercury on October 19, 2015, 07:26:50 PM
In Portugal a minor is anyone under 18 and as such travel restrictions apply.

https://www.gov.uk/foreign-travel-advice/portugal/entry-requirements

I don't believe for a second this "incident' has anything at all to do with the Madeleine case, unless anyone can prove a 16 year old could travel to Portugal alone and without consent or supervision prior to 2007



Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on October 19, 2015, 07:34:54 PM

In Portugal a minor is anyone under 18 and as such travel restrictions apply.

https://www.gov.uk/foreign-travel-advice/portugal/entry-requirements

I don't believe for a second this "incident' has anything at all to do with the Madeleine case, unless anyone can prove a 16 year old could travel to Portugal alone and without consent or supervision prior to 2007

You beat me to the punch Mercury!
Portugal is not the only place in the world to place restrictions on minors.
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: mercury on October 19, 2015, 07:51:33 PM
You beat me to the punch Mercury!
Portugal is not the only place in the world to place restrictions on minors.

No it isn't. It seems the travel agent is mostly to blame here, especially as seeing it's a country where millions travel to so shouldn't be ignorant or negligent. As for the J2 "unnamed staff" saying what they said, well, what can I say? Another stupid article.

Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: Carana on October 19, 2015, 08:13:49 PM
I have got to say this is weird.

Quite why there would be a Portuguese restriction like this has me baffled.

Madeleine was approaching 4 and accompanied by her parents, not 16 and travelling alone.

I would have thought the airline could have handled it better, both at the time of booking and when the girl checked in, but that is another matter.  As for checking FAQ or looking at the Foreign Office website, that is pure farce.  She was travelling in Europe, not departing for Outer Mongolia (my apologies to Outer Mongolia).

I wonder how one proves that a letter of parental consent is genuine?

If this story is genuine, i.e. that Portuguese authorities imposed this requirement, it is a massive own goal.  It depicts Portugal as a dangerous country where 16 year olds are not safe, and where getting a taxi or bus from the airport is not safe.

The only bright side I can look on is the weather here is pants at the moment, although I suppose the rain is warmer than in Edinburgh.

Returning to the thread title, I have often wondered precisely what changes, if any, occurred in Portugal following Madeleine's disappearance.  One would have thought it was time to review the judicial secrecy rules in a missing child case, and to review what still seems to be a total block on police requests for help from the public, a la Crimewatch.

This travel restriction seems to be a step backward, not forward.

The age 18 rule does appear to be correct. However, I don't see the connection with the Madeleine case.


(...)

Travelling with children

A minor under the age of 18 travelling to Portugal must either:

    be accompanied by a parent or guardian, or

    be met at the airport or point of entry by a parent or guardian, or

    if not accompanied by parent or guardian, carry a letter of authorisation to travel from that parent or guardian. The letter should name the adult in Portugal who will be responsible for the minor during their stay.

Resident minors leaving Portugal

A minor who is living in Portugal may be prevented from leaving the country if he/she is travelling unaccompanied and is not carrying a notarised letter of authority from a parent or guardian. The letter of authority can be issued by:

i)   one of the minor’s parents (if the parents are married)
ii)  the parent the minor lives with (if the parents are separated or divorced)
iii) one of the adoptive parents (if the child is adopted) or
iv) the minor’s legal guardian.

A standard form of words (in Portuguese) for minors exiting the country may be downloaded from the Portuguese immigration service website. There are two options under “Saída de Menores de Território Nacional”. The first one is for use by Portuguese nationals; the second is for foreign nationals.
UK Emergency Travel Documents

UK ETDs are accepted for entry, airside transit and exit from Portugal.
https://www.gov.uk/foreign-travel-advice/portugal/entry-requirements
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: ferryman on October 19, 2015, 08:22:09 PM
Easyjet's rules are clear, and by them, there is no bar on this young woman travelling to Portugal alone ...
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: jassi on October 19, 2015, 08:27:36 PM
The problems is not traveling to Portugal but being refused entry when she got there.
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: mercury on October 19, 2015, 08:27:53 PM
Easyjet's rules are clear, and by them, there is no bar on this young woman travelling to Portugal alone ...

The point is not travelling alone, and has nothing at all to do wth what airline is used, it's to do with Portuguese law / authorisation to travel to the country / being collected by a parent/legal guardian /responsible adult

Oh, it's in the daily mail as well-the Madeleine connection is bogus-these rules have been n place years before 2007 as a half decent Google search will reveal

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3277804/Teenager-16-travelling-Portugal-stopped-boarding-Jet2-flight-Madeleine-McCann-case.html
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: Carana on October 19, 2015, 08:38:45 PM
In Portugal a minor is anyone under 18 and as such travel restrictions apply.

https://www.gov.uk/foreign-travel-advice/portugal/entry-requirements

I don't believe for a second this "incident' has anything at all to do with the Madeleine case, unless anyone can prove a 16 year old could travel to Portugal alone and without consent or supervision prior to 2007

It may be an offshoot of this re unaccompanied minor asylum seekers.

Reception, Return and
Integration of
Unaccompanied Minors
in Portugal
European Migration Network
2008
http://www.sef.pt/documentos/56/UMS%20Portugal%20EN%200.91.pdf
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: mercury on October 19, 2015, 08:45:00 PM
It may be an offshoot of this re unaccompanied minor asylum seekers.

Reception, Return and
Integration of
Unaccompanied Minors
in Portugal
European Migration Network
2008
http://www.sef.pt/documentos/56/UMS%20Portugal%20EN%200.91.pdf

What might be an offshoot?
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: Carana on October 19, 2015, 09:02:32 PM
What might be an offshoot?

That PT decided to up the age to 18 in light of asylum seekers -  but what seems odd is applying it to EU nationals.




A significant number of unaccompanied minors arrive in the European Union (EU) each year. The term “unaccompanied minors” refers to non-EU country nationals or stateless persons who are below the age of eighteen and who arrive in an EU country unaccompanied by a responsible adult or who are left unaccompanied after having entered an EU country....

http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=URISERV:jl0037
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: mercury on October 19, 2015, 09:09:07 PM
That PT decided to up the age to 18 in light of asylum seekers -  but what seems odd is applying it to EU nationals.




A significant number of unaccompanied minors arrive in the European Union (EU) each year. The term “unaccompanied minors” refers to non-EU country nationals or stateless persons who are below the age of eighteen and who arrive in an EU country unaccompanied by a responsible adult or who are left unaccompanied after having entered an EU country....

Up it when? I've already posted its been 18 for years before the Madeleine case and years before your 2008 link...someone has to prove what the Mirror is stating vis a vis J2 staff saying Portuguese officials told them they made restrictions because of the Madeleine case...sounds pretty ludicrous to me...comparing chalk and cheese is not nearly a good way to describe this
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: mercury on October 19, 2015, 09:21:04 PM
Woman, 29, charged with child neglect after baby "left alone" in Netherton house

15:58, 19 OCT 2015

A woman has been charged with child neglect after a baby was allegedly left alone at a house in Netherton.

Ashley Mossman, 29, of Hereford Drive, Netherton , has been released on bail to appear at Liverpool Magistrates Court on Thursday.

Neighbours yesterday described seeing police officers arriving in the street in the early hours.

Merseyside Police confirmed officers were called to reports a child had been left alone for a short period of time at an address.

The child was not injured and is now in the care of relatives. Social services have been informed.

A police spokesman said: “Merseyside Police can confirm a 29-year-old woman has been charged with child neglect following an incident in Netherton on Sunday.

“Ashley Mossman, 29, of Hereford Drive, Netherton has been released on bail to appear at Liverpool Magistrates Court on Thursday, October 22.”

http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/woman-29-charged-child-neglect-10291028

I don't know how many parents were charged with neglect for leaving their babies alone for "a short time" before as compared to "after" the case....I have seen a few more stories in the last few years than normal, but mostly for leaving chldren alone for prolonged periods,  but I don't see how / why the UK LE's actions would have changed "because" of the Madeleine case...do countries change their procedures according to what's happened in other countries? Too much credence has been put on the the "Madeleine effect " IMO

Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: Carana on October 19, 2015, 09:22:07 PM
Up it when? I've already posted its been 18 for years before the Madeleine case and years before your 2008 link...someone has to prove what the Mirror is stating vis a vis J2 staff saying Portuguese officials told them they made restrictions because of the Madeleine case...sounds pretty ludicrous to me...comparing chalk and cheese is not nearly a good way to describe this

I suspect that "unnamed staff" made it up.

Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: mercury on October 19, 2015, 09:24:22 PM
I suspect that "unnamed staff" made it up.

Which begs the question why, as they were not the ones responsible

Scrap that as I thought I read somewhere there was a travel agent involved
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: Carana on October 19, 2015, 09:44:29 PM
The exit of Portuguese minors, as well and the entry and exit of foreign minors who are legal residents in this country is ruled by Decree-Law 138/2006, of 26 July (Article 23º) and by Act 23/2007, of 4th July (Article 31º), with the amendments of Act 29/2012 of August 9.

http://www.sef.pt/portal/V10/EN/aspx/acessibilidade/apoioCliente/detalheApoio.aspx?fromIndex=0&id_Linha=4350


Decree-Law 138/2006:
Artigo 23.º

[...]

    Os menores, quando não forem acompanhados por quem exerça o poder paternal, só podem sair do território nacional exibindo autorização para o efeito.
    A autorização a que se refere o número anterior deve constar de documento escrito, datado e com a assinatura de quem exerce o poder paternal legalmente certificada, conferindo ainda poderes de acompanhamento por parte de terceiros, devidamente identificados.
    ...
    ...


It doesn't stipulate the age though.

But the age of majority is 18 (unless "emancipated" by marriage).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Age_of_majority#Age_18


So... this parental authorization business for under-18s existed before 2007.

Next...
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: mercury on October 19, 2015, 09:49:37 PM
You don't need to labour anything much carana, and that  relates to Portuguese residents only and that is irrelevant in this case even it actually does mean anything which it probably doesn't
But you're right the age of 18 and restrictions has been in place for donkeys years so NOT to do with MM, so story is baloney 100 per cent, and I fail to see its purpose
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: Carana on October 19, 2015, 10:00:30 PM
You don't need to labour anything much carana, and that  relates to Portuguese residents only and that is irrelevant in this case even it actually does mean anything which it probably doesn't
But you're right the age of 18 and restrictions has been in place for donkeys years so NOT to do with MM, so story is baloney 100 per cent, and I fail to see its purpose

Actually, the one for foreign children dates back to July 07. But I still doubt it had anything to do with the McCanns.

Entrada e saída de menores
Artigo 31.
o
Entrada e saída de menores
1 — Sem prejuízo de formas de turismo ou intercâm-
bio  juvenil,  a  autoridade  competente  deve  recusar  a
entrada  no  País  aos  cidadãos  estrangeiros  menores  de
18  anos  quando  desacompanhados  de  quem  exerce  o
poder paternal ou quando em território português não
exista quem, devidamente autorizado pelo representante
legal, se responsabilize pela sua estada
http://www.sef.pt/documentos/56/NOVA%20LEI%20ESTRANGEIROS.pdf
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: mercury on October 19, 2015, 10:10:45 PM
Actually, the one for foreign children dates back to July 07. But I still doubt it had anything to do with the McCanns.

Entrada e saída de menores
Artigo 31.
o
Entrada e saída de menores
1 — Sem prejuízo de formas de turismo ou intercâm-
bio  juvenil,  a  autoridade  competente  deve  recusar  a
entrada  no  País  aos  cidadãos  estrangeiros  menores  de
18  anos  quando  desacompanhados  de  quem  exerce  o
poder paternal ou quando em território português não
exista quem, devidamente autorizado pelo representante
legal, se responsabilize pela sua estada
http://www.sef.pt/documentos/56/NOVA%20LEI%20ESTRANGEIROS.pdf

As I said don't labour it and typing a load of Portuguese ??boring
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: Alice Purjorick on October 19, 2015, 10:46:28 PM
You don't need to labour anything much carana, and that  relates to Portuguese residents only and that is irrelevant in this case even it actually does mean anything which it probably doesn't
But you're right the age of 18 and restrictions has been in place for donkeys years so NOT to do with MM, so story is baloney 100 per cent, and I fail to see its purpose

These "funnies" have a habit of popping up when something else is about to happen.
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: John on October 19, 2015, 10:47:06 PM
This hysteria followed the removal of other blonde children from Roma families in Greece and Ireland after it was thought there was a connection with the McCann case.

October 2013

Police find blonde-haired, blue eyed girl living among Roma gipsies in Ireland.

(http://i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/02709/missing-maria_2709811b.jpg)

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/ireland/10396633/Police-find-blonde-haired-blue-eyed-girl-living-among-Roma-gipsies-in-Ireland.html


Roma boy's family awarded 60,000 euros after suing Irish state over removal

19 October 2015

The family of a blond Roma boy, who was removed from his Irish home over unfounded fears he was not their son, has won 60,000 euros (£44,000) damages.

(http://www.irishtimes.com/polopoly_fs/1.1571657.1382596203!/image/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/box_620_330/image.jpg)

Dublin High Court heard the boy was one of two Roma children taken out of their homes by Irish police (Gardaí) during a "brief hysteria" across Europe in 2013.

It was sparked when DNA tests on a blonde girl in Greece did not match the DNA of the Roma family she lived with.

In both Irish cases, the children were returned to their parents within days.
'Emotional harm'

The boy was two years old when police took him out of his home in Athlone, County Westmeath, in October 2013.

The officers took the action under the Child Care Act 1991, after members of the public reported concerns that the boy might not be the biological son of the couple who were raising him.

DNA tests proved the boy was the son of the Roma couple and he was returned to his family home the following day.

The boy's parents later took legal action against the Irish state, the minister for justice and the head of the police force (Garda Commissioner) on grounds including alleged negligence, false imprisonment and infliction of emotional harm.

Dublin High Court heard that in her 2014 report into the case, the then Children's Ombudsman Emily Logan said the removal of boy from his home amounted to "ethnic profiling", as defined by the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance.
'Trauma'

A barrister acting for the boy's family told the judge that the ombudsman's report had concluded there was no well-founded suspicion or immediate emergency justifying the actions of the police.

The government had apologised over the matter, the court heard.

The judge noted, notwithstanding the undoubted trauma for the child, a medical report suggested he had not suffered personal injuries as a result of his brief removal from his home.

He approved the state's 60,000 euros offer to settle the case, plus High Court costs.

The boy, who is now four, attended the court case with his parents.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-34575545
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: mercury on October 20, 2015, 01:59:26 AM
That so many kids night be Madeleine even if they dont look like her in the slightest is a total joke

That so many kids are associated with Madeleine when there is no association is a disgrace and a disrespect to those kids, the Mccanns should be thoroughly ashamed of that

Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: Lace on October 20, 2015, 09:41:55 AM
That so many kids night be Madeleine even if they dont look like her in the slightest is a total joke

That so many kids are associated with Madeleine when there is no association is a disgrace and a disrespect to those kids, the Mccanns should be thoroughly ashamed of that

Why should the McCann's be thoroughly  ashamed?

Can you tell me why the McCann's can be blamed for a child discovered in a gypsy camp?    Are you trying to tell me that it is the McCann's who tipped off the police about this child?     Are you saying that all children associated with Madeleine have been discovered because the McCann's have found them all?
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: mercury on October 20, 2015, 07:56:14 PM
These "funnies" have a habit of popping up when something else is about to happen.

I know, I wonder who is in charge of mitigation or other tactics....

LoL at funnies! Thats exactly what they are, at best
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: Mr Gray on October 20, 2015, 07:59:05 PM
I know, I wonder who is in charge of mitigation or other tactics....

LoL at funnies! Thats exactly what they are, at best

perhaps Clarence has dressed up as an air hostess and given this story to the press to divert attention from the arrest of the mccanns by SY yesterday...it seems to have worked
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: mercury on October 20, 2015, 08:00:26 PM
Why should the McCann's be thoroughly  ashamed?

Can you tell me why the McCann's can be blamed for a child discovered in a gypsy camp?   I didn't say that.  Are you trying to tell me that it is the McCann's who tipped off the police about this child?   No Are you saying that all children associated with Madeleine have been discovered because the McCann's have found them all? No

answers in green.....but there is a lnk between connections (almost always extremely spurious) to Madeleine, their press spokesman and them...try and join the dots
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: Mr Gray on October 20, 2015, 08:03:02 PM
answers in green.....but there is a lnk between connections (almost always extremely spurious) to Madeleine, their press spokesman and them...try and join the dots

we can only accept your first answer
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: Carana on October 20, 2015, 08:40:08 PM
So far I fail to see any connection between the examples given and any so-called "Madeleine phenomenon".
Title: Re: Events shaped by the Madeleine McCann phenomenon.
Post by: mercury on October 20, 2015, 09:04:42 PM
So far I fail to see any connection between the examples given and any so-called "Madeleine phenomenon".
It is a fact that Madeleines name has been connected to the most spurious of events unconnected with her though surely you will have noticed that by now, the British media have been indeed been milking all connections (even and mainly most probably impossible ones)..it even extends to her parents, when a vigil for Claudia Lawrence featured Kate McCann and not her parents.......I find that awful for wont of a better word
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1361173/Parents-Madeleine-McCann-Claudia-Lawrence-meet-York-vigil.html