UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Alfred R Jones on October 30, 2015, 06:15:34 PM

Title: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on October 30, 2015, 06:15:34 PM
...it would be the perfect opportunity for Madeleine's parents to draw a line under her disappearance, accept that she is lost forever, have her certified deceased and get on with living their lives as best as they can in the knowledge that they will never see their daughter again.

Instead the McCanns have made it known that they plan to hire more detectives and continue the search for as long as they have the resources to do so.

Sceptics, if they do continue to spend time and money on a case that the combined effort of several police forces and millions of pounds failed to solve what will that tell you about the McCanns?  Will it make any difference to your view of their involvement in their child's disappearance? If not, what possible reasons can there be in your view for them to continue with the costly search nearly 9 years after the event, when no one could blame them for losing hope and finally admitting defeat? 
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Brietta on October 30, 2015, 07:04:33 PM
It tells me that the McCanns are convinced that Madeleine is alive ... and they are not going to cease looking until they have either confirmation of that or that she is dead.
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: stephen25000 on October 30, 2015, 07:06:45 PM
It tells me that the McCanns are convinced that Madeleine is alive ... and they are not going to cease looking until they have either confirmation of that or that she is dead.

So why do they think she is alive ?

Why do they repeat the mantra, that there is no evidence that she has come to any harm ?
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: mercury on October 30, 2015, 07:23:32 PM
So why do they think she is alive ?

Why do they repeat the mantra, that there is no evidence that she has come to any harm ?

In the absence of any body found, in this case, and others, there is always room for hope, however tenuous, and despite stats, dogs, and zero confirmed sightings!

I echo what Gunit said...what do they think a couple PIs are going to achieve after 37 SY officers have spent years on on top of their previous PIs finding, well,not alot...

Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Alice Purjorick on October 30, 2015, 07:32:39 PM
>>>>> snip

"A source close to the McCanns told the newspaper that Kate and Gerry McCann will "never give up" on the search.

They have apparently ring-fenced the remaining money in the Find Madeleine Fund – around £750,000 – to pay for a team of private investigators.

The Sun says the team, believed to be former police officers, would be the fourth group of private investigators employed by the McCanns. The newspaper's source said the family had "spearheaded the hunt for Madeleine themselves before and will do so again if they have to".

The family's spokesman Clarence Mitchell confirmed: "Should the need arise for a private investigation to be resumed, they have made sure they have enough money left in Madeleine's fund."
<<<<< snip

Let's see if it happens first.
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: faithlilly on October 30, 2015, 08:39:40 PM
...it would be the perfect opportunity for Madeleine's parents to draw a line under her disappearance, accept that she is lost forever, have her certified deceased and get on with living their lives as best as they can in the knowledge that they will never see their daughter again.

Instead the McCanns have made it known that they plan to hire more detectives and continue the search for as long as they have the resources to do so.

Sceptics, if they do continue to spend time and money on a case that the combined effort of several police forces and millions of pounds failed to solve what will that tell you about the McCanns?  Will it make any difference to your view of their involvement in their child's disappearance? If not, what possible reasons can there be in your view for them to continue with the costly search nearly 9 years after the event, when no one could blame them for losing hope and finally admitting defeat?

Tell you what Alfie, after all the money in the fund is spent and they downsize to free up some money to continue their private investigation then I may just change my opinion about the McCanns.
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Alfred R Jones on October 30, 2015, 09:02:02 PM
Tell you what Alfie, after all the money in the fund is spent and they downsize to free up some money to continue their private investigation then I may just change my opinion about the McCanns.
would you like to have a go at answering my question?
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on October 30, 2015, 11:58:19 PM
...it would be the perfect opportunity for Madeleine's parents to draw a line under her disappearance, accept that she is lost forever, have her certified deceased and get on with living their lives as best as they can in the knowledge that they will never see their daughter again.

Instead the McCanns have made it known that they plan to hire more detectives and continue the search for as long as they have the resources to do so.

Sceptics, if they do continue to spend time and money on a case that the combined effort of several police forces and millions of pounds failed to solve what will that tell you about the McCanns?  Will it make any difference to your view of their involvement in their child's disappearance? If not, what possible reasons can there be in your view for them to continue with the costly search nearly 9 years after the event, when no one could blame them for losing hope and finally admitting defeat?

In Red,

That would be illegal in Portugual.

But with millions already spend, two police forces, 3 PI companies, countless books and theories investigated by interested amatures, 11 years later.... no sign of Maddie.

Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Mr Gray on October 31, 2015, 12:11:16 AM
In Red,

That would be illegal in Portugual.

But with millions already spend, two police forces, 3 PI companies, countless books and theories investigated by interested amatures, 11 years later.... no sign of Maddie.

it wont be illegal if the case is closed
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: pegasus on October 31, 2015, 12:59:23 AM
it wont be illegal if the case is closed
So the money for that possible future search, why is it ring-fenced? What does the fence seperate it from?
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: slartibartfast on October 31, 2015, 07:08:08 AM
So the money for that possible future search, why is it ring-fenced? What does the fence seperate it from?

I suppose it stops it going to charity as per one of the original aims.
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: ShiningInLuz on October 31, 2015, 07:53:38 AM
In Red,

Instead the McCanns have made it known that they plan to hire more detectives and continue the search for as long as they have the resources to do so.

That would be illegal in Portugual.

But with millions already spend, two police forces, 3 PI companies, countless books and theories investigated by interested amatures, 11 years later.... no sign of Maddie.
NB I have altered the quote purely so that it makes sense when it stands alone.

It is illegal for a private citizen within Portugal to investigate a crime that occurred within Portugal.  If the investigators restricted themselves to investigating whilst based outside Portugal, I doubt the authorities would be willing to see if they can be prosecuted under Portuguese law.

The Dispatches documentary that took place before the PJ Files were released looked to me very much like private individuals in Portugal investigating a crime that occurred in Portugal, and no one got prosecuted for that.  And surely Crimewatch 2013 has the presenter in Luz falling into the same category, as he was facilitating an investigation into a crime?
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: faithlilly on October 31, 2015, 12:09:17 PM
So the money for that possible future search, why is it ring-fenced? What does the fence seperate it from?

That is the $64,000 question Pegasus.
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Alice Purjorick on October 31, 2015, 12:29:53 PM
That is the $64,000 question Pegasus.
Given these are the company objects for MF:LNSU Ltd:
Objects
2B. The objects of the Foundation are:
2B.1.1 To secure the safe return to her family of Madeleine McCann who was abducted in Praia da Luz, Portugal on Thursday 3rd May 2007; and
2B.1.2 To procure that Madeleine's abduction is thoroughly investigated and that her abductors, as well as those who played or play any part in assisting them, are identified and brought to Justice.
2B.2 If the above objects are fulfilled then the objects of the Foundation shall be to pursue such purposes in similar cases arising in the United Kingdom, Portugal or elsewhere.


There would be no need to ring fence funds for searching as that is the company objective.
It's just PR gobbledegook, bullshit baffles brains stuff I guess. 
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: ferryman on October 31, 2015, 12:51:41 PM
...it would be the perfect opportunity for Madeleine's parents to draw a line under her disappearance, accept that she is lost forever, have her certified deceased and get on with living their lives as best as they can in the knowledge that they will never see their daughter again.

Instead the McCanns have made it known that they plan to hire more detectives and continue the search for as long as they have the resources to do so.

Sceptics, if they do continue to spend time and money on a case that the combined effort of several police forces and millions of pounds failed to solve what will that tell you about the McCanns?  Will it make any difference to your view of their involvement in their child's disappearance? If not, what possible reasons can there be in your view for them to continue with the costly search nearly 9 years after the event, when no one could blame them for losing hope and finally admitting defeat?

Not even read the rest of the posts of this thread.

But surely the most contemptible thing any parents can do is give up on their child?
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: pathfinder73 on October 31, 2015, 02:18:37 PM
it wont be illegal if the case is closed

This case will never be closed being one of national interest.
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: jassi on October 31, 2015, 02:38:46 PM
Are unsolved cases ever actually closed in UK, or merely shelved ?
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Mr Gray on October 31, 2015, 02:42:19 PM
If the PIs hired by the mccanns broke Portuguese law...and SY have used their information ....that makes SY complicit in a criminal act....looks like the PIs did not break any laws
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Alice Purjorick on October 31, 2015, 04:16:26 PM
Are unsolved cases ever actually closed in UK, or merely shelved ?

They are reviewed on a regular basis I think.

http://www.suffolk.police.uk/newsandevents/unsolvedcases/unsolvedcasefiles/dianejones.aspx
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on November 01, 2015, 10:56:40 AM
Are unsolved cases ever actually closed in UK, or merely shelved ?

No. Never closed. Just shelved, and in some instances new evidence  (DNA) crops up and can lead to a conviction or if dead, the identification of the criminal. Also found, those convicted of crimes released and declared innocent after a long time.
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Alice Purjorick on November 01, 2015, 02:09:54 PM
I suppose it stops it going to charity as per one of the original aims.

It would only ever have gone to a charity if the company were wound up. At least that's what the Articles of Association say. As they are the guvnor document I believe it.
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: pathfinder73 on November 01, 2015, 02:15:05 PM
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: jassi on November 01, 2015, 02:20:49 PM


  @)(++(*  @)(++(*

That film clip is just SO adaptable.
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Eleanor on November 01, 2015, 04:36:41 PM

Well, that was funny.
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Brietta on November 01, 2015, 07:35:55 PM

Godwin's Law has always constrained me from making that particular comparison for Mr Amaral.

Well done you ... absolutely purrfect.
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Benice on November 01, 2015, 07:44:40 PM
Well, that was funny.

The original is hilarious.  Perhaps Pathfinder will post that one.

(I won't hold my breath though)

Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: G-Unit on November 01, 2015, 07:45:23 PM
Godwin's Law has always constrained me from making that particular comparison for Mr Amaral.

Well done you ... absolutely purrfect.

Operation Grange reports it's findings........................to Amaral????   &%+((£
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: mercury on November 01, 2015, 10:38:23 PM

LOL!!!

what could anyone expect with all the utterly pathetic shenanigans in this case...sometimes satire is exactly right!!

Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: faithlilly on December 19, 2015, 10:00:34 PM
It would seem the McCanns don't share their supporters's belief that SY are now following some positive leads.

Madeleine McCann's parents to launch new private search with appeal fund's remaining £750k
19:06, 19 DEC 2015 UPDATED 19:11, 19 DEC 2015
BY MATTHEW DRAKE
Kate and Gerry McCann have set the money aside for another private search for their daughter with the £12million Scotland Yard operation set to wind down

   
SHARES
  Subscribe
GettyKate and Gerry McCannStill searching: Kate and Gerry McCann with an image of how Maddy might look now

Madeleine McCann’s parents are poised to launch a new ­private search for their daughter with the remaining £750,000 in their appeal fund.

Kate and Gerry, both 47, aim to begin a fresh initiative to solve the nine-year-old mystery as the £12million Scotland Yard investigation winds down.

Plans are under way to use what is left of the No Stone Unturned fund, boosted by sales of Kate’s book Madeleine, to hire private detectives to probe several unanswered questions.

A source told the Sunday People : “There is £750,000 in the account. That money has been ­preserved because Kate and Gerry knew they may want to reopen an ­investigation at some point.

“They have always said they’ll do ­anything they can to keep going. That ­commitment remains.”

PAMadeleine McCannMissing: Madeleine McCann vanished from the family holiday apartment in Portugal in 2007
The number of British officers working on the ­investigation , named Operation Grange, has been ­reduced from 29 to four.

Read more: Gerry and Kate McCann reveal the reasons why they miss Maddie

The operation has cost £10million since it was launched four years ago following intervention from the Prime Minister.

A further £2million has been ­guaranteed by the Home Office until April.

PAGerry and Kate McCannNot giving up: Gerry and Kate McCann
The source added: “We don’t know exactly when Operation Grange will end but while it continues it has the finest technology and analysts.

“Private investigations are expensive and do not have anything like the range and capabilities available to the Yard.

“The McCanns still feel there are a lot of questions that remain unanswered but they still have full confidence in the Metropolitan Police .”

Madeleine disappeared from their ­ holiday apartment in the Portuguese resort of Praia da Luz in May 2007, shortly before her fourth ­birthday. Since then her parents have campaigned tirelessly.
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Benice on December 19, 2015, 10:09:25 PM
It would seem the McCanns don't share their supporters's belief that SY are now following some positive leads.

Madeleine McCann's parents to launch new private search with appeal fund's remaining £750k
19:06, 19 DEC 2015 UPDATED 19:11, 19 DEC 2015
BY MATTHEW DRAKE
Kate and Gerry McCann have set the money aside for another private search for their daughter with the £12million Scotland Yard operation set to wind down

   
SHARES
  Subscribe
GettyKate and Gerry McCannStill searching: Kate and Gerry McCann with an image of how Maddy might look now

Madeleine McCann’s parents are poised to launch a new ­private search for their daughter with the remaining £750,000 in their appeal fund.

Kate and Gerry, both 47, aim to begin a fresh initiative to solve the nine-year-old mystery as the £12million Scotland Yard investigation winds down.

Plans are under way to use what is left of the No Stone Unturned fund, boosted by sales of Kate’s book Madeleine, to hire private detectives to probe several unanswered questions.

A source told the Sunday People : “There is £750,000 in the account. That money has been ­preserved because Kate and Gerry knew they may want to reopen an ­investigation at some point.

“They have always said they’ll do ­anything they can to keep going. That ­commitment remains.”

PAMadeleine McCannMissing: Madeleine McCann vanished from the family holiday apartment in Portugal in 2007
The number of British officers working on the ­investigation , named Operation Grange, has been ­reduced from 29 to four.

Read more: Gerry and Kate McCann reveal the reasons why they miss Maddie

The operation has cost £10million since it was launched four years ago following intervention from the Prime Minister.

A further £2million has been ­guaranteed by the Home Office until April.

PAGerry and Kate McCannNot giving up: Gerry and Kate McCann
The source added: “We don’t know exactly when Operation Grange will end but while it continues it has the finest technology and analysts.

“Private investigations are expensive and do not have anything like the range and capabilities available to the Yard.

“The McCanns still feel there are a lot of questions that remain unanswered but they still have full confidence in the Metropolitan Police .”

Madeleine disappeared from their ­ holiday apartment in the Portuguese resort of Praia da Luz in May 2007, shortly before her fourth ­birthday. Since then her parents have campaigned tirelessly.

So what's new?  Just rehashed old news IMO - using every reporter's best  (invisible)  friend - ''a source''.


Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 10:14:14 PM
It would seem the McCanns don't share their supporters's belief that SY are now following some positive leads.

Madeleine McCann's parents to launch new private search with appeal fund's remaining £750k
19:06, 19 DEC 2015 UPDATED 19:11, 19 DEC 2015
BY MATTHEW DRAKE
Kate and Gerry McCann have set the money aside for another private search for their daughter with the £12million Scotland Yard operation set to wind down

   
SHARES
  Subscribe
GettyKate and Gerry McCannStill searching: Kate and Gerry McCann with an image of how Maddy might look now

Madeleine McCann’s parents are poised to launch a new ­private search for their daughter with the remaining £750,000 in their appeal fund.

Kate and Gerry, both 47, aim to begin a fresh initiative to solve the nine-year-old mystery as the £12million Scotland Yard investigation winds down.

Plans are under way to use what is left of the No Stone Unturned fund, boosted by sales of Kate’s book Madeleine, to hire private detectives to probe several unanswered questions.

A source told the Sunday People : “There is £750,000 in the account. That money has been ­preserved because Kate and Gerry knew they may want to reopen an ­investigation at some point.

“They have always said they’ll do ­anything they can to keep going. That ­commitment remains.”

PAMadeleine McCannMissing: Madeleine McCann vanished from the family holiday apartment in Portugal in 2007
The number of British officers working on the ­investigation , named Operation Grange, has been ­reduced from 29 to four.

Read more: Gerry and Kate McCann reveal the reasons why they miss Maddie

The operation has cost £10million since it was launched four years ago following intervention from the Prime Minister.

A further £2million has been ­guaranteed by the Home Office until April.

PAGerry and Kate McCannNot giving up: Gerry and Kate McCann
The source added: “We don’t know exactly when Operation Grange will end but while it continues it has the finest technology and analysts.

“Private investigations are expensive and do not have anything like the range and capabilities available to the Yard.

“The McCanns still feel there are a lot of questions that remain unanswered but they still have full confidence in the Metropolitan Police .”

Madeleine disappeared from their ­ holiday apartment in the Portuguese resort of Praia da Luz in May 2007, shortly before her fourth ­birthday. Since then her parents have campaigned tirelessly.

Grange is not being wound down...for those who understand....
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: stephen25000 on December 19, 2015, 10:27:45 PM
Grange is not being wound down...for those who understand....

Of course it is.
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 10:30:43 PM
Of course it is.

no...it has just been given more money and no decision take as to when it will end
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Brietta on December 19, 2015, 10:33:25 PM
no...it has just been given more money and no decision take as to when it will end

Which, in my opinion, will not be until they run out of evidence to follow.
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 10:34:38 PM
Which, in my opinion, will not be until they run out of evidence to follow.

much to the displeasure of some on here
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 19, 2015, 10:41:01 PM
no...it has just been given more money and no decision take as to when it will end

How do you know that other than by speculation?
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: G-Unit on December 19, 2015, 10:49:42 PM
Given these are the company objects for MF:LNSU Ltd:
Objects
2B. The objects of the Foundation are:
2B.1.1 To secure the safe return to her family of Madeleine McCann who was abducted in Praia da Luz, Portugal on Thursday 3rd May 2007; and
2B.1.2 To procure that Madeleine's abduction is thoroughly investigated and that her abductors, as well as those who played or play any part in assisting them, are identified and brought to Justice.
2B.2 If the above objects are fulfilled then the objects of the Foundation shall be to pursue such purposes in similar cases arising in the United Kingdom, Portugal or elsewhere.


There would be no need to ring fence funds for searching as that is the company objective.
It's just PR gobbledegook, bullshit baffles brains stuff I guess.

Looking at the 2013-2014 accounts the campaign costs are taken from the ring-fenced funds. Legal costs are taken from the non ring-fenced funds. That suggests that the ring-fencing is to separate the two. That could be at the suggestion of the parents with the rest of the directors agreeing or vice versa. Perhaps a limit has been placed on the funds available for legal expenditure from the fund? After all, the fund is not involved in any legal actions, the McCanns are.
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Mr Gray on December 19, 2015, 10:52:33 PM
How do you know that other than by speculation?

there was a statement in the press at the time saying a decision for further funds would be made at a later date
Title: Re: If and when the Investigation is shelved again...
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 19, 2015, 10:54:53 PM
Looking at the 2013-2014 accounts the campaign costs are taken from the ring-fenced funds. Legal costs are taken from the non ring-fenced funds. That suggests that the ring-fencing is to separate the two. That could be at the suggestion of the parents with the rest of the directors agreeing or vice versa. Perhaps a limit has been placed on the funds available for legal expenditure from the fund? After all, the fund is not involved in any legal actions, the McCanns are.

It is probably just my nasty suspicious mind but the "restricted funds" approximate to the value of book royalties that have been bandied around.