UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: faithlilly on December 07, 2015, 03:49:51 PM
-
I believe the Euro Weekly News revealed the details of the Gaspar statement yet I don't remember ..... ....... or for that matter Gerry demanding a retraction. Does that mean it was true ?
[Editor comment...
Posts which breach the forum rules will be edited or removed]
171
-
I believe the Euro Weekly News revealed the details of the Gaspar statement yet I don't remember ..... ...... or for that matter Gerry demanding a retraction. Does that mean it was true ?
Link?
-
Link?
http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2010/01/euro-weekly-news-gaspars-on-david-payne.html
(http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_lWXrpwC28yU/S1hxs20tD5I/AAAAAAAAHSM/UoTHyOBrRo4/s576/euroweeklynews.png)
-
http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2010/01/euro-weekly-news-gaspars-on-david-payne.html
(http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_lWXrpwC28yU/S1hxs20tD5I/AAAAAAAAHSM/UoTHyOBrRo4/s576/euroweeklynews.png)
That article does not appear on the Euro Weekly News website. But even if it did, then what grounds would ..... .......have to demand a retraction? It is an accurate quote from a police statement, nothing he could do about it. Whereas if one of his unnamed friends had told blatant lies to a reporter who then wrote them up into a long newspaper article (as you are alleging has occurred with Mr Sousa) then that would be a different matter.
-
That article does not appear on the Euro Weekly News website. But even if it did, then what grounds would ..... ....... have to demand a retraction? It is an accurate quote from a police statement, nothing he could do about it. Whereas if one of his unnamed friends had told blatant lies to a reporter who then wrote them up into a long newspaper article (as you are alleging has occurred with Mr Sousa) then that would be a different matter.
So you believe the tabloids every time they say 'a friend of the McCanns' or 'someone close to the couple' says so and so do you ?
-
So you believe the tabloids every time they say 'a friend of the McCanns' or 'someone close to the couple' says so and so do you ?
If the story has the ring of truth to it, I'll give it the benefit of the doubt, yes. I'm not one of those conspiracy theorists who believes that every word written in the MSM is lies designed to hoodwink the sheeple.
-
If the story has the ring of truth to it, I'll give it the benefit of the doubt, yes. I'm not one of those conspiracy theorists who believes that every word written in the MSM is lies designed to hoodwink the sheeple.
So basically you think that if the 'friend's' comment fits your agenda then it's true. At least you're being honest I suppose.
-
So basically you think that if the 'friend's' comment fits your agenda then it's true. At least you're being honest I suppose.
Perhaps you could give us some examples of a "friend of the McCanns" or "someone close to the McCanns" giving a completely false story to the press?
-
That article does not appear on the Euro Weekly News website. But even if it did, then what grounds would David Payne have to demand a retraction? It is an accurate quote from a police statement, nothing he could do about it. Whereas if one of his unnamed friends had told blatant lies to a reporter who then wrote them up into a long newspaper article (as you are alleging has occurred with Mr Sousa) then that would be a different matter.
Your interpretation of the legal position is not quite right, there, Alfred. The Gaspar statements, confined to the files, are not actionable, because they form part of a police enquiry, and are therefore protected from action in libel. Exactly the same would be true in England or Portugal.
As soon as those statements (and particularly Mrs G's) stray outside the confines of the process, they become actionable.
-
Your interpretation of the legal position is not quite right, there, Alfred. The Gaspar statements, confined to the files, are not actionable, because they form part of a police enquiry, and are therefore protected from action in libel. Exactly the same would be true in England or Portugal.
As soon as those statements (and particularly Mrs G's) stray outside the confines of the process, they become actionable.
I don't see how that particular excerpt would be actionable but If that is so then maybe it explains why the article no longer appears on the Euro Weekly website (as far as I can see). Perhaps they were threatened with legal action?
-
I don't see how that particular excerpt would be actionable but If that is so then maybe it explains why the article no longer appears on the Euro Weekly website (as far as I can see). Perhaps they were threatened with legal action?
I don't know for sure, but that wouldn't surprise me in the least ...
-
I don't see how that particular excerpt would be actionable but If that is so then maybe it explains why the article no longer appears on the Euro Weekly website (as far as I can see). Perhaps they were threatened with legal action?
If the report wasn't libellous what legal action could be threatened ?
-
If the report wasn't libellous what legal action could be threatened ?
Maybe the Gaspars themselves asked for the report to be removed?
-
Maybe the Gaspars themselves asked for the report to be removed?
Why ?
-
Why ?
Data protection act? Altered from original statements? Unhappy that their confidential statements had found their way into the media?
-
Data protection act? Altered from original statements? Unhappy that their confidential statements had found their way into the media?
With the release of the files the statements were in the public domain anyway. The newspaper article was published in Spain so I very much doubt our data protection laws would cover it and the Gaspars had signed the statements as a true record of their evidence and, according to the Alfred R Jones Reactive Retraction Law 2015, if they didn't try to publicly retract their statements then they must be true.
-
With the release of the files the statements were in the public domain anyway. The newspaper article was published in Spain so I very much doubt our data protection laws would cover it and the Gaspars had signed the statements as a true record of their evidence and, according to the Alfred R Jones Reactive Retraction Law 2015, if they didn't try to publicly retract their statements then they must be true.
I have been "reliably" informed that any statements made to police in the UK, which were not at the behest of the PJ, do not form part of the PJ files made available for release (think of Balu, Sperrey, Carpenter, Tranmer, Jenson, Wilshire, etc). The files appear to show a Portuguese translation then retranslated back into English, hence no original signed copy.
Were those statements released with the original Levy DVD?
-
Photostats of Katerina Gaspar statements from the released PJ files :
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P13/13_VOLUME_XIIIa_Page_3911.jpg
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P13/13_VOLUME_XIIIa_Page_3912.jpg
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P13/13_VOLUME_XIIIa_Page_3913.jpg
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P13/13_VOLUME_XIIIa_Page_3915.jpg
-
Photostats of Katerina Gaspar statements from the released PJ files :
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P13/13_VOLUME_XIIIa_Page_3911.jpg
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P13/13_VOLUME_XIIIa_Page_3912.jpg
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P13/13_VOLUME_XIIIa_Page_3913.jpg
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P13/13_VOLUME_XIIIa_Page_3915.jpg
so no one has seen the original signed gaspar statement
-
With the release of the files the statements were in the public domain anyway. The newspaper article was published in Spain so I very much doubt our data protection laws would cover it and the Gaspars had signed the statements as a true record of their evidence and, according to the Alfred R Jones Reactive Retraction Law 2015, if they didn't try to publicly retract their statements then they must be true.
Don't be absurd. The law you refer to is entirely yours, I think you cited it only the other day in relation to Pamela Fenn. Funny how it only applies in certain circumstances and you don't like it when it's used to counter your arguments. @)(++(*
-
If I could read Dr Gaspar's original statement in english then I would comment...so do you think Gerry discussed the abuse of Maddie openly for all to hear
-
If I could read Dr Gaspar's original statement in english then I would comment...so do you think Gerry discussed the abuse of Maddie openly for all to hear
Then read her statements.
Mrs. Gasper, who had no axe to grind, observed the behaviour of the two men.
So dave, you tell me, what they were discussing.
-
Then read her statements.
Mrs. Gasper, who had no axe to grind, observed the behaviour of the two men.
So dave, you tell me, what they were discussing.
where is her original statement made in English...why has it not been made available..I'm 100% sure they were not discussing the abuse of maddie...I have asked YOU 3 times...what do you think
-
where is her original statement made in English...why has it not been made available..I'm 100% sure they were not discussing the abuse of maddie...I have asked YOU 3 times...what do you think
It has already been made available on the internet, I believe on the mccannfiles.com.
Mrs Gasper, i repeat, had no axe to grind.
She made the statement in good faith.
You brought up this matter this morning.
So what were these two men discussing ?
it seems a very sore point with you.
-
It has already been made available on the internet, I believe on the mccannfiles.com.
Mrs Gasper, i repeat, had no axe to grind.
She made the statement in good faith.
You brought up this matter this morning.
So what were these two men discussing ?
it seems a very sore point with you.
seems you cannot answer a simple question....I have never seen the original ...it is not available anywhere...stick to the truth... I didn't bring it up...faith did..stick to the facts...
I'm not in the slightest concerned about it.....
-
seems you cannot answer a simple question....I have never seen the original ...it is not available anywhere...stick to the truth... I didn't bring it up...faith did..stick to the facts...
I'm not in the slightest concerned about it.....
You are.
The statements posted on the mccannfiles.com have not been rescinded and are there for public viewing.
So why should they be doubted.
How come any statement it seems made by any party which casts doubt on them, is always questioned as to it's authenticity by the mccann supporters and the mccanns themselves.
The Gaspers appear to be honourable people, and thanks to you dave, I have re-read their statements this morning.
-
I have been "reliably" informed that any statements made to police in the UK, which were not at the behest of the PJ, do not form part of the PJ files made available for release (think of Balu, Sperrey, Carpenter, Tranmer, Jenson, Wilshire, etc). The files appear to show a Portuguese translation then retranslated back into English, hence no original signed copy.
Were those statements released with the original Levy DVD?
A whole raft of stuff released was patently at odds with the wishes of the UK wishes and procedures and protocols, generally, for releasing information about a criminal investigation into the public domain.
Read this:
ETA: second section down marked by the dark blue band.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LAWYERS_UK_POLICE.htm
Somewhere, Leicestershire police (as the lead English force in the investigation) wrote up a rota of what information should be released into the public domain and when.
That document was completely was completely ignored.
And the objection that the Portuguese police were the lead force (whilst true) doesn't wash, because the (combined) condition of English participation in the investigation was that English procedures and protocols for undertaking an investigation should be adhered to.
In the way information was released, that was just trampled over roughshod ....
-
A whole raft of stuff released was patently at odds with the wishes of the UK wishes and procedures and protocols, generally, for releasing information about a criminal investigation into the public domain.
Read this:
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LAWYERS_UK_POLICE.htm
So who reliably informed misty ? 8)-)))
-
You are.
The statements posted on the mccannfiles.com have not been rescinded and are there for public viewing.
So why should they be doubted.
How come any statement it seems made by any party which casts doubt on them, is always questioned as to it's authenticity by the mccann supporters and the mccanns themselves.
The Gaspers appear to be honourable people, and thanks to you dave, I have re-read their statements this morning.
this is how deluded you are...you have not read their statements...you have never read their statements.....
you can read the online letters as much as you like...makes no difference...their is just so much in the supposed statements that makes no sense whatsoever...that's why I question them
-
this is how deluded you are...you have not read their statements...you have never read their statements.....
you can read the online letters as much as you like...makes no difference...their is just so much in the supposed statements that makes no sense whatsoever...that's why I question them
How do you know these are not their statements ?
It is you who is clearly deluded and worried by these statements.
.....and what precisely makes no sense in those statements ?
-
How do you know these are not their statements ?
It is you who is clearly deluded and worried by these statements.
.....and what precisely makes no sense in those statements ?
Because the original statements given to the UK police would be in English...is that so hard for you to grasp...
you wouldn't understand what makes no sense ...your mind is closed
-
Then read her statements.
Mrs. Gasper, who had no axe to grind, observed the behaviour of the two men.
So dave, you tell me, what they were discussing.
I doubt very much if Gerry and ..... ..... were discussing Paedophilia with Mrs. Gaspar sat between them.
Nothing has come about from the Gaspar's statement and so I presume it had no bearing what so ever on the McCann case.
-
Because the original statements given to the UK police would be in English...is that so hard for you to grasp...
you wouldn't understand what makes no sense ...your mind is closed
My mind is not closed, unlike yours.
Are you therefore staing what is on the mccannfiles.com is faked ?
and if you are, back it ,up.
-
perhaps I am a little out of step but I have three daughters and I have never bathed any of them. the idea of a man bathing any of my daughters would seem very strange... the idea that I would allow a man I suspected of being a paedophile bathe my daughter is ridiculous but we are supposed to believe Dr Gaspar and her husband both allowed this
-
perhaps I am a little out of step but I have three daughters and I have never bathed any of them. the idea of a man bathing any of my daughters would seem very strange... the idea that I would allow a man I suspected of being a paedophile bathe my daughter is ridiculous but we are supposed to believe Dr Gaspar and her husband both allowed this
Re-read the statements.
It might help.
-
perhaps I am a little out of step but I have three daughters and I have never bathed any of them. the idea of a man bathing any of my daughters would seem very strange... the idea that I would allow a man I suspected of being a paedophile bathe my daughter is ridiculous but we are supposed to believe Dr Gaspar and her husband both allowed this
Particularly with Mrs G (apparently) harbouring the suspicions that she did ...
-
Re-read the statements.
It might help.
it seems you need to read them again...Dr Gaspar supposedly accuses Payne of being a paedophile and then allows him to bathe her daughter...You might be gullible enough to believe this but I ma not
-
it seems you need to read them again...Dr Gaspar supposedly accuses Payne of being a paedophile and then allows him to bathe her daughter...You might be gullible enough to believe this but I ma not
Do keep up.
I've read them this morning already.
I will let any readers to this forum decide what is the truth. The statements are easily accessible on-line. All they have to do is type the Gasper statements on a search engine.
The more you hark on about these statements and try to denigrate them, the more guests here will realize that they are worth reading.
-
Particularly with Mrs G (apparently) harbouring the suspicions that she did ...
What was strange to me was that she had suspicions about .... ....... but not Gerry, yet .... ....... was conversing with Gerry!! It doesn't make sense.
I don't know why the Gaspar statements are brought up, it is quite obvious they have been investigated and have been found to be of no interest to the McCann case
Indeed Andy Redwood stated 'the McCann's and friends are not suspects'
-
Do keep up.
I've read them this morning already.
I will let any readers to this forum decide what is the truth. The statements are easily accessible on-line. All they have to do is type the Gasper statements on a search engine.
The more you hark on about these statements and try to denigrate them, the more guests here will realize that they are worth reading.
Why are they worth reading Stephen, what are you suggesting?
It is obvious to me that they have been read by the people who matter e.g. the POLICE and that they have been found to be of no importance.
-
Thanks - but the copies don't address any of the issues I raised a few posts back.
You said the statements were not released with the original PJ files - they were.
You said they were a translation from English into Portuguese then back to English. Many of the statements taken in England followed the same procedure so don't really see why it's relevant.
As to coming from the original Levy DVD I don't see why that's relevant either.
-
The two Gaspar Statements do not support each other.
-
Do keep up.
I've read them this morning already.
I will let any readers to this forum decide what is the truth. The statements are easily accessible on-line. All they have to do is type the Gasper statements on a search engine.
The more you hark on about these statements and try to denigrate them, the more guests here will realize that they are worth reading.
Wonder where you read them, wouldn't be a persons post who is calling all pro McCann's nonces and belonging to a paedo ring would it by any chance? did you vote his post up, yes you did didn't you!!!
-
Don't be absurd. The law you refer to is entirely yours, I think you cited it only the other day in relation to Pamela Fenn. Funny how it only applies in certain circumstances and you don't like it when it's used to counter your arguments. @)(++(*
So as Katerina Gaspar didn't ask for a retraction, much like Sousa, can we assume her statement is true ?
-
Wonder where you read them, wouldn't be a persons post who is calling all pro McCann's nonces and belonging to a paedo ring would it by any chance? did you vote his post up, yes you did didn't you!!!
Wrong again Lace.
I read both of them on the mccannfiles.
Try paying attention, it really would help.
Also, interesting to see what a mccann supporter said on the same site last night.
Definitely a faux pas.
-
'Absolute Secrecy' is the name of the game when it comes to paedaphiles. The idea that such a person would sit chatting about it openly at the dinner table is preposterous. Especially when he had to talk across Mrs Gasper - who was sitting inbetween him and Gerry at the time and who was not even a friend of his.
It's clear that nothing was found by the authorities to substantiate what was in part the produce of Mrs Gaspars vivid imagination.
Arul Gaspar's opinion was very different to his wife's.
-
So as Katerina Gaspar didn't ask for a retraction, much like Sousa, can we assume her statement is true ?
you can assume what you like...makes no difference
-
The two Gaspar Statements do not support each other.
So if, as seems to be being claimed by supporters, Katerina's statement has been altered to say something she didn't say why not alter Arul's to agree with her and make the evidence stronger ?
-
'Absolute Secrecy' is the name of the game when it comes to paedaphiles. The idea that such a person would sit chatting about it openly at the dinner table is preposterous. Especially when he had to talk across Mrs Gasper - who was sitting inbetween him and Gerry at the time and who was not even a friend of his.
It's clear that nothing was found by the authorities to substantiate what was in part the produce of Mrs Gaspars vivid imagination.
Arul Gaspar's opinion was very different to his wife's.
Why would she lie to the police, knowing the gravity of the accusation ?
-
Why would she lie to the police, knowing the gravity of the accusation ?
Precisely Faithlilly.
Don't expect a logical reply from the faithful.
-
I doubt very much if Gerry and .... ......?. were discussing Paedophilia with Mrs. Gaspar sat between them.
Nothing has come about from the Gaspar's statement and so I presume it had no bearing what so ever on the McCann case.
The seating arrangement alone makes the whole scenario extremely improbable and in my opinion an impossibility.
Sitting in the middle of the trio it is ridiculous to suggest Dr Gaspar did not hear what was said. It would have been impossible for her not to have heard every word of the conversation unless she suffered a hearing impairment.
Similarly it would have been difficult for her to describe hand gestures without twisting around quickly to catch sight of one then immediately twisting round with dizzying speed to catch sight of the other.
It is naive to believe that as a woman who was privy to a conversation featuring paedophilia with an infant as the alleged focus ... she then allowed her daughter to be bathed by them.
Anyone who believes that for a minute is deluded.
No-one has ever seen the original unadulterated statement.
-
The seating arrangement alone makes the whole scenario extremely improbable and in my opinion an impossibility.
Sitting in the middle of the trio it is ridiculous to suggest Dr Gaspar did not hear what was said. It would have been impossible for her not to have heard every word of the conversation unless she suffered a hearing impairment.
Similarly it would have been difficult for her to describe hand gestures without twisting around quickly to catch sight of one then immediately twisting round with dizzying speed to catch sight of the other.
It is naive to believe that as a woman who was privy to a conversation featuring paedophilia with an infant as the alleged focus ... she then allowed her daughter to be bathed by them.
Anyone who believes that for a minute is deluded.
No-one has ever seen the original unadulterated statement.
I presume you can prove as you claim that her statement was 'adulterated' ?
-
I presume you can prove as you claim that her statement was 'adulterated' ?
Of course not.
-
Why would she lie to the police, knowing the gravity of the accusation ?
as we have not seen her original statement we do not know what she said to the police...she certainly would not have lied...what we do know is that the statement that she allegedly made seems contradictory.
Why would she say she thought he was the type to visit internet porn sites when she had no reason to say so...why would a police statement include this piece of speculation...it makes no sense...that is why I think all is not right with the statement
-
as we have not seen her original statement we do not know what she said to the police...she certainly would not have lied...what we do know is that the statement that she allegedly made seems contradictory.
Why would she say she thought he was the type to visit internet porn sites when she had no reason to say so...why would a police statement include this piece of speculation...it makes no sense...that is why I think all is not right with the statement
How do you know this is not her original statement ?
I expect a logical reply with a cite.
-
as we have not seen her original statement we do not know what she said to the police...she certainly would not have lied...what we do know is that the statement that she allegedly made seems contradictory.
Why would she say she thought he was the type to visit internet porn sites when she had no reason to say so...why would a police statement include this piece of speculation...it makes no sense...that is why I think all is not right with the statement
Agreed.
With the statement distinct from with the witness ...
That's what I think, too.
-
Agreed.
With the statement distinct from with the witness ...
That's what I think, too.
Well, you are not going to say anything else, are you ?
-
Mrs Gaspar saw ..... ....... make a gesture, she didn't know what the conversation was about, but she THINKS it was about Madeleine, she jumps to conclusions about ..... ..... YET she doesn't about Gerry who was the person ..... ....... was talking to. Mrs. Gaspar didn't know ..... ......, but Gerry on the other hand was a friend of her husbands.
Doesn't anyone else think this odd?
To me it sounds as though she didn't like ..... .....
Her husband stated he thought the gesture was not very nice but forgot about it, he didn't see ..... ....... acting abnormally around the children and found him a nice person.
-
'Absolute Secrecy' is the name of the game when it comes to paedaphiles. The idea that such a person would sit chatting about it openly at the dinner table is preposterous. Especially when he had to talk across Mrs Gasper - who was sitting inbetween him and Gerry at the time and who was not even a friend of his.
It's clear that nothing was found by the authorities to substantiate what was in part the produce of Mrs Gaspars vivid imagination.
Arul Gaspar's opinion was very different to his wife's.
Anyone who thinks paedophiles openly discuss their perversions at a dinner table is seriously deluded.
Perhaps it is worth bearing in mind the originator of the statement's delayed release has had a finger in many murky money making (how's that for alliteration) scams all profiteering from a missing child.
It is worth bearing in mind what Ms Morais has to say about him ...
Exposing a Swindler: The Truth About a Pathological Liar
There are other stories essentially similar to the above mentioned, some which I could only explain betraying the confidence deposited in me. Suffice to say that I had to erase all the knowledge gathered in the past two years through 'Duarte Levy' articles.
http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2009/06/exposing-swindler-truth-about.html
-
How do you know this is not her original statement ?
I expect a logical reply with a cite.
because its in portuguese
-
as we have not seen her original statement we do not know what she said to the police...she certainly would not have lied...what we do know is that the statement that she allegedly made seems contradictory.
Why would she say she thought he was the type to visit internet porn sites when she had no reason to say so...why would a police statement include this piece of speculation...it makes no sense...that is why I think all is not right with the statement
I find that a very peculiar thing to say, that she thought he was the type to visit internet porn sites, how the hell did she jump to that conclusion.
I'm sorry but I think this woman had it in for ..... ......
-
Anyone who thinks paedophiles openly discuss their perversions at a dinner table is seriously deluded.
Perhaps it is worth bearing in mind the originator of the statement's delayed release has had a finger in many murky money making (how's that for alliteration) scams all profiteering from a missing child.
It is worth bearing in mind what Ms Morais has to say about him ...
Exposing a Swindler: The Truth About a Pathological Liar
There are other stories essentially similar to the above mentioned, some which I could only explain betraying the confidence deposited in me. Suffice to say that I had to erase all the knowledge gathered in the past two years through 'Duarte Levy' articles.
http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2009/06/exposing-swindler-truth-about.html
Can you provide a cite to show the Gasper's statements have been adulterated ?
-
I find that a very peculiar thing to say, that she thought he was the type to visit internet porn sites, how the hell did she jump to that conclusion.
I'm sorry but I think this woman had it in for ..... ......
Why would she 'have it in for him' ?
Explain your reasoning, rather than make a wild unjustified statement yourself.
-
because its in portuguese
So you can prove that and second prove it has been changed ?
Otherwise your response is just hot air.
-
So you can prove that and second prove it has been changed ?
Otherwise your response is just hot air.
can you prove its genuine...no
-
Can you provide a cite to show the Gasper's statements have been adulterated ?
You first ... I've been waiting several days now for the cite I requested from you concerning the allegation you made about me.
-
can you prove its genuine...no
You and your fellows are saying it isn't.
It is therefore your prerogative to prove your point.
-
Why would she lie to the police, knowing the gravity of the accusation ?
I have never said she lied. She gave her own interpretation of something - and IMO it was clearly a misinterpretation - as paedophiles do not casually chat about their vile perversions at the dinner table in front of several other people. She then talked about what she 'imagined' he might do - which means nothing in evidential terms.
Fathers do get involved when it comes to bathtime nowadays. Nothing odd in that at all IMO.
IIRC DP and Arul Gaspars children were both being bathed together on holiday - with both their dads on bathtime duty at the time. Nothing strange about that either IMO. The idea that there was something suspect about DP because he bathed his own child is nonsense IMO.
For all we know Mrs Gaspar was a massive prude - and that coloured her perceptions. Who knows.
(must go out now)
-
You and your fellows are saying it isn't.
It is therefore your prerogative to prove your point.
I don't have to prove anything......it may be genuine...or it may be not...probably not as far as I'm concerned
-
Why would she 'have it in for him' ?
Explain your reasoning, rather than make a wild unjustified statement yourself.
Why leave Gerry out of her accusation? After all Gerry was conversing with ..... ....... about paedophilia according to her.
He made the same gesture again later on to Gerry yet still she doesn't include Gerry in her accusations it's all ..... ......
-
I don't have to prove anything......it may be genuine...or it may be not...probably not as far as I'm concerned
What a surprise.
-
I have never said she lied. She gave her own interpretation of something - and IMO it was clearly a misinterpretation - as paedophiles do not casually chat about their vile perversions at the dinner table in front of several other people. She then talked about what she 'imagined' he might do - which means nothing in evidential terms.
Fathers do get involved when it comes to bathtime nowadays. Nothing odd in that at all IMO.
IIRC DP and Arul Gaspars children were both being bathed together on holiday - with both their dads on bathtime duty at the time. Nothing strange about that either IMO. The idea that there was something suspect about DP because he bathed his own child is nonsense IMO.
For all we know Mrs Gaspar was a massive prude - and that coloured her perceptions. Who knows.
(must go out now)
must have been a big bath
-
I have never said she lied. She gave her own interpretation of something - and IMO it was clearly a misinterpretation - as paedophiles do not casually chat about their vile perversions at the dinner table in front of several other people. She then talked about what she 'imagined' he might do - which means nothing in evidential terms.
Fathers do get involved when it comes to bathtime nowadays. Nothing odd in that at all IMO.
IIRC DP and Arul Gaspars children were both being bathed together on holiday - with both their dads on bathtime duty at the time. Nothing strange about that either IMO. The idea that there was something suspect about DP because he bathed his own child is nonsense IMO.
For all we know Mrs Gaspar was a massive prude - and that coloured her perceptions. Who knows.
(must go out now)
I think it's really sad that people think it odd that fathers should bathe their children, we take it in turns, why shouldn't the Dad get involved. The idea that it should all be the mothers job is ridiculous.
Paedophile are sly and secretive from what I have read about them, no way would any paedophile chat openly about their favourite subject with someone they don't really know well sat between them.
-
What I find most peculiar is two highly professional people, one a doctor, one a social worker, both with child abuse experience but unknown to each other, would both single out .... ....... for accusations of a nefarious nature if there was no foundation for those accusations. Surely even the most ardent of supporters must see this as something more than just a coincidence?
-
So as Katerina Gaspar didn't ask for a retraction, much like Sousa, can we assume her statement is true ?
Why would she ask for a retraction? Yes we can assume that her statement is true, it's her interpretation of the significance of her observation that is very much open to question, even it seems by her own husband!
-
It's also interesting to note that Leicestershire police seem to have chosen to hold statements back from the PJ. The Gasper statements were seemingly only sent to the PJ because they asked for them. We don't know how they knew they existed.
-
I have never said she lied. She gave her own interpretation of something - and IMO it was clearly a misinterpretation - as paedophiles do not casually chat about their vile perversions at the dinner table in front of several other people. She then talked about what she 'imagined' he might do - which means nothing in evidential terms.
Fathers do get involved when it comes to bathtime nowadays. Nothing odd in that at all IMO.
IIRC DP and Arul Gaspars children were both being bathed together on holiday - with both their dads on bathtime duty at the time. Nothing strange about that either IMO. The idea that there was something suspect about DP because he bathed his own child is nonsense IMO.
For all we know Mrs Gaspar was a massive prude - and that coloured her perceptions. Who knows.
(must go out now)
It was not even an incident but two -- separate -- observations of an action during the course of a holiday in another country years before.
There has long been a recognised distinction in police enquiries between evidence and intelligence (with the latter being something not directly germane to a police enquiry that can, nevertheless, lead to a line of enquiry that does generate evidence).
But this "gesture" thing was not even that.
-
You have never ... on any occasion ... provided a cite when asked to. Why on earth would I expect you to provide one or do the honourable thing and apologise for being ... mistaken.
I have never ... on any occasion ... questioned any posters right to post here in any way - shape - or form. Which was your accusation ... nor have I ever posted nonsense such as your last sentence which is a riposte used frequently by you to all and sundry.
Don't make accusations you are incapable of backing up ... and do try to cut down a little on the ad hominems ... so tiresome and predictable ... also against forum etiquette and rules.
It wasn't the posters rights I was referring to.
It was the reasons for doing it. The quote i gave from one of your posts more than demonstrates that point.
As to cites, I gave them when they are available. So stop making allegations up, yet again.
I don't however, just cut and paste material i don't understand.
-
What I find most peculiar is two highly professional peope, one a doctor, one a social worker, both with child abuse experience but unknown to each other, would both single out ..... ....?? for accusations of a nefarious nature if there was no foundation for those accusations. Surely even the most ardent of supporters must see this as something more than just a coincidence?
What did the social worker accuse him of?
-
What did the social worker accuse him of?
The social worker did the PJ's job for them. (Or she tried to). Fortunately the PJ inspector who interviewed her assessed her very well and dismissed her testimony ....
-
What I find most peculiar is two highly professional peope, one a doctor, one a social worker, both with child abuse experience but unknown to each other, would both single out ..... ...... for accusations of a nefarious nature if there was no foundation for those accusations. Surely even the most ardent of supporters must see this as something more than just a coincidence?
Yvonne Martin did no such thing. She observed NO inappropriate behaviour whatsoever by DP during her uninvited visit - neither did she report any.
Her only claim was that she thought she recognised him from somewhere. It may have been through work - but even then she didn't know whether he was a goodie or a baddie. i.e. a work colleague or someone who had been investigated from in her past. I presume she mentioned the sex offenders register as a way of narrowing down the options. Nothing was found and to date she still hasn't remembered why she thinks she recognised him. On the other hand I'm pretty sure DP would be able to show that he'd never met or seen the woman before 4th May in his life.
IMO YM didn't like DP. IIRC YM was asked to leave but resisted and it was DP who eventually had to insist that she did leave. IMO she took offence at that - and after brooding about it for a few days - sent an anonymous letter about him to the PJ.
(all from memory so am happy to be corrected if necessary)
-
Yvonne Martin did no such thing. She observed NO inappropriate behaviour whatsoever by DP during her uninvited visit - neither did she report any.
Her only claim was that she thought she recognised him from somewhere. It may have been through work - but even then she didn't know whether he was a goodie or a baddie. i.e. a work colleague or someone who had been investigated from in her past. I presume she mentioned the sex offenders register as a way of narrowing down the options. Nothing was found and to date she still hasn't remembered why she thinks she recognised him. On the other hand I'm pretty sure DP would be able to show that he'd never met or seen the woman before 4th May in his life.
I agree with Lace. She didn't like DP. IIRC YM was asked to leave but resisted and it was DP who eventually had to insist that she did leave. IMO she took offence at that - and after brooding about it for a few days - sent an anonymous letter about him to the PJ.
(all from memory so am happy to be corrected if necessary)
I think that sums it up very well.
She is exactly the type of person one is advised to keep well back from a scene such as the one she inveigled herself into.
The police thought she was there in an official capacity and the victims thought she was with the police.
Inspector Paolo Ferreira didn't take long to suss her out ... "The statements given to the PJ today by Yvonne Martin provide a concrete clarification of the reasons for her suspicions, which in my opinion, do not point to any concrete element that could, in any way, make other inquiries directly related to her statements, viable."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/YVONNE-WARREN-MARTIN.htm
Absolutely incredible that at this remove there are those who hold her totally unprofessional interference up as an example of ... unprofessionalism???
What else does penning an anonymous letter about an individual indicate?
Wonder if she used green ink and upper case lettering?
-
Katerina Gaspar's statement was vague and full of personal opinion /fear/interpretation and lacking in concrete ncriminating facts...I think she put two and two together and made five personally on hearing about MMs disappearance, she exactly did the right thing though anyway and should not be criticised or lbelled as some have done ie she made it up because she didnt like DP, so cast a pedo cloud on him, thats plain stupid
-
It's also interesting to note that Leicestershire police seem to have chosen to hold statements back from the PJ. The Gasper statements were seemingly only sent to the PJ because they asked for them. We don't know how they knew they existed.
Which police force were the statements made to in the first place?
-
Which police force were the statements made to in the first place?
Leicestershire.
-
Leicestershire.
Where is that detail, please?
-
Katerina Gaspar's statement was vague and full of personal opinion /fear/interpretation and lacking in concrete ncriminating facts...I think she put two and two together and made five personally on hearing about MMs disappearance, she exactly did the right thing though anyway and should not be criticised or lbelled as some have done ie she made it up because she didnt like DP, so cast a pedo cloud on him, thats plain stupid
There's nothing vague about it.
Possibly, around the fourth or perhaps the fifth day abroad, I remember an incident that stayed recorded in my head................The first time I heard of the terrible news about Madeleine's disappearance through the radio, my thoughts went immediately to............
-
There's nothing vague about it.
Possibly, around the fourth or perhaps the fifth day abroad, I remember an incident that stayed recorded in my head................The first time I heard of the terrible news about Madeleine's disappearance through the radio, my thoughts went immediately to............
The statement we have seen on the internet show quite succinctly that neither Dr Gaspar's husband or anyone else present at the times in question seemed at all perturbed or even noticed this blatant display of sexuality.
The second occasion when this extraordinary gesturing is alleged to have been performed was in a restaurant ... correct me if I am wrong on that.
Wonder what the other diners made of it.
-
There's nothing vague about it.
Possibly, around the fourth or perhaps the fifth day abroad, I remember an incident that stayed recorded in my head................The first time I heard of the terrible news about Madeleine's disappearance through the radio, my thoughts went immediately to............
........yet it took her up to 12 days to report these thoughts to the police when her "intimate" friends' child was missing without trace.
-
Where is that detail, please?
Leicestershire Constabulary were in charge of the UK investigations.
-
Katerina Gaspar's statement was vague and full of personal opinion /fear/interpretation and lacking in concrete ncriminating facts...I think she put two and two together and made five personally on hearing about MMs disappearance, she exactly did the right thing though anyway and should not be criticised or lbelled as some have done ie she made it up because she didnt like DP, so cast a pedo cloud on him, thats plain stupid
agreed...although I have not seen anyone libel or label her...it made me think how doctors are encouraged to report the slightest suspicion of abuse which has resulted in children being unfairly removed from their homes
-
........yet it took her up to 12 days to report these thoughts to the police when her "intimate" friends' child was missing without trace.
it took 12 days for a statement to be taken. Do we know the date when she contacted the police?
-
it took 12 days for a statement to be taken. Do we know the date when she contacted the police?
We know that the supposed incident happened two years before, but was not reported at the time.
-
We know that the supposed incident happened two years before, but was not reported at the time.
There have been a lot of delayed statements, remembered details and after the event books in this case.
-
There have been a lot of delayed statements, remembered details and after the event books in this case.
What? With regard to serious suspicions of Paedophillia? It seems a very funny way for a professional woman to behave if she thinks children are at risk.
-
What? With regard to serious suspicions of Paedophillia? It seems a very funny way for a professional woman to behave if she thinks children are at risk.
Can't disagree with that however can you give me one sensible reason why she would come forward, albeit late, with this information if it wasn't true ?
-
We know that the supposed incident happened two years before, but was not reported at the time.
And she never 'reported' her concerns about Madeleine's safety to her intimate friend Kate at all. Some friend! A great shame IMO because I reckon if she had spoken to Kate about it - they would have got to the bottom of it there and then - and sorted out what IMO was a mistaken interpretation on Mrs Gaspar's part.
So much future anguish could have been avoided.
-
And she never 'reported' her concerns about Madeleine's safety to her intimate friend Kate at all. Some friend! A great shame IMO because I reckon if she had spoken to Kate about it - they would have got to the bottom of it there and then - and sorted out what IMO was a mistaken interpretation on Mrs Gaspar's part.
So much future anguish could have been avoided.
Absolutely Benice but it still doesn't explain why she made the statement in the first place, knowing the seriousness of the allegation.
-
Can't disagree with that however can you give me one sensible reason why she would come forward, albeit late, with this information if it wasn't true ?
She was basically expressing her opinion without any evidence. She was right to do so if she had genuine concerns, although in that event, two years previously would have been a better idea.
These statements should never have been released for public viewing, and I very much doubt that she or her husband thought they would.
In the event of a Trial any Barrister would have torn her to pieces, if they would even have been used.
As for translations, her statement was a rambling miss mash of personal thought and emotions that would have been very hard to correctly translate twice.
-
She was basically expressing her opinion without any evidence. She was right to do so if she had genuine concerns, although in that event, two years previously would have been a better idea.
These statements should never have been released for public viewing, and I very much doubt that she or her husband thought they would.
In the event of a Trial any Barrister would have torn her to pieces, if they would even have been used.
As for translations, her statement was a rambling miss mash of personal thought and emotions that would have been very hard to correctly translate twice.
Whether the statements should have been released or whether Mrs Gaspar knew they would be is irrelevant, unless you are suggesting she would have changed her statement if she had known. As to being hard to translate, I really can't see why it'd be harder than any other statement which would also contain personal thought as well as hard evidence.
-
Absolutely Benice but it still doesn't explain why she made the statement in the first place, knowing the seriousness of the allegation.
Only Mrs Gaspar can answer that one Faith. And as we know nothing at all about this lady - or how her mind works - it's difficult to try to work it out IMO.
-
Absolutely Benice but it still doesn't explain why she made the statement in the first place, knowing the seriousness of the allegation.
It was her husband who was Kate's friend from University, not her She saw some behaviour she wasn't sure about between a friend of the McCanns and Kate's husband. A difficult subject to raise because it involved the child's father. It also involved a serious accusation about fellow doctors. I can understand why she chose to remain silent at the time. When she saw the news she remembered and contacted the police.
-
Whether the statements should have been released or whether Mrs Gaspar knew they would be is irrelevant, unless you are suggesting she would have changed her statement if she had known. As to being hard to translate, I really can't see why it'd be harder than any other statement which would also contain personal thought as well as hard evidence.
Hindsight. Would you make a similar accusation about friends without evidence if you thought it be splattered all over The Internet for eight years?
British Law does not allow this.
No wonder The PJ have problems with people coming forward.
-
In my view she was deeply upset by Madeleine's abduction and wanted to help in any way she could, so she racked her brains to think who among the holiday group could possibly be responsible, remembered the "incident" and decided to tell it to the police in an attempt to be helpful. Of course this is simply my interpretation of the event and the reality may be quite different, like she may have simply had it in for DP, or sees "paedos" everywhere she looks.
-
Hindsight. Would you make a similar accusation about friends without evidence if you thought it be splattered all over The Internet for eight years?
British Law does not allow this.
No wonder The PJ have problems with people coming forward.
If I had concerns about the safety of a child it wouldn't cross my mind Eleanor.
As to the PJ having problems with people coming forward have we any evidence of this other than Mrs Murat and her stall ?
-
Only Mrs Gaspar can answer that one Faith. And as we know nothing at all about this lady - or how her mind works - it's difficult to try to work it out IMO.
We know nothing about how any of the witness's minds work so I'm not sure what point you're making Benice.
-
If I had concerns about the safety of a child it wouldn't cross my mind Eleanor.
As to the PJ having problems with people coming forward have we any evidence of this other than Mrs Murat and her stall ?
So you wouldn't mind people wondering why you didn't come forward initially if you were so worried about the safety of a child? I think Madeleine was two years old at the time. And you wouldn't mind people knowing that you had allowed a supposed Paedophile to bath your daughter?
Of course she didn't expect her statement to all over Social Media. It contains No Evidence or Proof.
Meanwhile, the suspected Paedophiles, Gerry and DP have absolutely no right to respond. Not that I think either of them would want to.
Actually, I feel very sorry for her. But I wouldn't invite her to my house. Her judgement is now very seriously in question, and no such suspicions by her will ever be considered again.
-
So you wouldn't mind people wondering why you didn't come forward initially if you were so worried about the safety of a child? I think Madeleine was two years old at the time. And you wouldn't mind people knowing that you had allowed a supposed Paedophile to bath your daughter?
Of course she didn't expect her statement to all over Social Media. It contains No Evidence or Proof.
Meanwhile, the suspected Paedophiles, Gerry and DP have absolutely no right to respond. Not that I think either of them would want to.
Actually, I feel very sorry for her. But I wouldn't invite her to my house. Her judgement is now very seriously in question, and no such suspicions by her will ever be considered again.
Your judgement of her is based on your prejudices in the case.
As to the actions witnessed by her, people have come to their own conclusions.,
Her and her husbands statements are extremely unlikely to be ever used, other than what is discussed on forums such as these.
So why do some people get so worked up about them ?
-
So you wouldn't mind people wondering why you didn't come forward initially if you were so worried about the safety of a child? I think Madeleine was two years old at the time. And you wouldn't mind people knowing that you had allowed a supposed Paedophile to bath your daughter?
Of course she didn't expect her statement to all over Social Media. It contains No Evidence or Proof.
Meanwhile, the suspected Paedophiles, Gerry and DP have absolutely no right to respond. Not that I think either of them would want to.
Actually, I feel very sorry for her. But I wouldn't invite her to my house. Her judgement is now very seriously in question, and no such suspicions by her will ever be considered again.
TBH Eleanor I think your and your fellow supporters attitude is perhaps why Mrs Gaspar kept her suspicions to herself for so long. Imagine having to betray a friend, with all that entails, then not being believed. Thankfully when Madeleine went missing her need to help overtook her self-interest.
-
TBH Eleanor I think your and your fellow supporters attitude is perhaps why Mrs Gaspar kept her suspicions to herself for so long. Imagine having to betray a friend, with all that entails, then not being believed. Thankfully when Madeleine went missing her need to help overtook her self-interest.
DP was not a friend though was he? Her aspersions were not cast upon Gerry.
-
DP was not a friend though was he? Her aspersions were not cast upon Gerry.
The reported conversation was between DP and GM and the inference is they may have been joking about abusing a child? It's a strange thing to say don't you think? The explanation could be this is just a snippet of conversation and likely taken completely out of context or an insider joke which caused the confusion.
-
We know nothing about how any of the witness's minds work so I'm not sure what point you're making Benice.
But in this particular context, in order to answer your question, we would need to know more about her as a person IMO Faith. That doesn't always apply with other witnesses.
Why didn't she immediately discuss the incident with her husband? Why didn't she take Kate to one side and let her know her fears? Why did she agree to go out to dinner months(?) later knowing this person who she suspected of being a paedaphile would be in the company? Why didn't she report him to the authorities at the time?
She had never met DP before that holiday - and yet on the strength of one small incident at the dinner table - in full view of everyone - she suspected this comparative stranger of being a paedaphile - to the extent that she reported him to the police 2 years later. I'm wondering why an obviously intelligent person would come to such a hasty conclusion.
This is why I say that we would need to know more about her mindset to understand. At the moment we know nothing about her except that she's a doctor married to a doctor.
-
Your judgement of her is based on your prejudices in the case.
As to the actions witnessed by her, people have come to their own conclusions.,
Her and her husbands statements are extremely unlikely to be ever used, other than what is discussed on forums such as these.
So why do some people get so worked up about them ?
I am not concerned with what she said in a statement that should never have seen the light of day. I am only concerned with what some people have made of it, a lot of which is libellous.
There is no evidence or proof in her statement. I don't have to be prejudiced to see that. Perhaps you do.
-
If I had concerns about the safety of a child it wouldn't cross my mind Eleanor.
As to the PJ having problems with people coming forward have we any evidence of this other than Mrs Murat and her stall ?
Isn't that enough? People who may have known something but decided not to risk coming forward to the PJ - are hardly going to advertise that fact are they?
-
TBH Eleanor I think your and your fellow supporters attitude is perhaps why Mrs Gaspar kept her suspicions to herself for so long. Imagine having to betray a friend, with all that entails, then not being believed. Thankfully when Madeleine went missing her need to help overtook her self-interest.
Her mistaken belief that her statement would not be released for public viewing, more like.
I don't have a problem with what she said. It is all too easy to discredit it, especially in the light of what her husband had to say. How does "Thankfully" come into this?
But you did fail to mention how you would feel if you had done the same in similar circumstances. So no surprises there.
-
The reported conversation was between DP and GM and the inference is they may have been joking about abusing a child? It's a strange thing to say don't you think? The explanation could be this is just a snippet of conversation and likely taken completely out of context or an insider joke which caused the confusion.
So you think from her statement that Gaspar believed Gerry was a paedo too? I don't.
-
DP was not a friend though was he? Her aspersions were not cast upon Gerry.
Really ? That DP felt able to talk to Gerry in such a way about his own daughter certainly casts aspersions on Gerry too.
-
Really ? That DP felt able to talk to Gerry in such a way about his own daughter certainly casts aspersions on Gerry too.
Does the fact that DP felt able to talk about Gerry's daughter "in such a way" in front of the Gaspars not cast aspersions on them also - if not, why not?
-
But in this particular context, in order to answer your question, we would need to know more about her as a person IMO Faith. That doesn't always apply with other witnesses.
Why didn't she immediately discuss the incident with her husband? Why didn't she take Kate to one side and let her know her fears? Why did she agree to go out to dinner months(?) later knowing this person who she suspected of being a paedaphile would be in the company? Why didn't she report him to the authorities at the time?
She had never met DP before that holiday - and yet on the strength of one small incident at the dinner table - in full view of everyone - she suspected this comparative stranger of being a paedaphile - to the extent that she reported him to the police 2 years later. I'm wondering why an obviously intelligent person would come to such a hasty conclusion.
This is why I say that we would need to know more about her mindset to understand. At the moment we know nothing about her except that she's a doctor married to a doctor.
She was absolutely remiss by not coming forward at the time but when it comes to accusations that may concern the abuse of a child I think those accusations should be treated at face value.
-
Mrs Gaspar's statement as exists in the public domain could certainly infer some sort of salicious goings on if interpreted in a particular way. It could also however be interpreted as high ginks by a group of friends on holiday which was how Mr Gaspar more or less represented it.
The question which interests me most however has always been why Mrs Gaspar felt her comments were important enough to give a statement recalling her observation?
-
Isn't that enough? People who may have known something but decided not to risk coming forward to the PJ - are hardly going to advertise that fact are they?
No it isn't enough. How are we even sure that that is why Mrs Murat set up her stall ?
-
Mrs. Gaspar cannot remember what the conversation was about. You would think she would remember wouldn't you, if she was so shocked it would stick in her mind. Mrs. Gaspar didn't even know if it was about Madeleine she said she 'THINKS' it was about Madeleine.
It was thoroughly investigated by the police and nothing came of it, ..... ..... is still working as a Dr. and SY have said the parents and their friends are not suspects.
-
Mrs. Gaspar cannot remember what the conversation was about. You would think she would remember wouldn't you, if she was so shocked it would stick in her mind. Mrs. Gaspar didn't even know if it was about Madeleine she said she 'THINKS' it was about Madeleine.
It was thoroughly investigated by the police and nothing came of it, ..... ..... is still working as a Dr. and SY have said the parents and their friends are not suspects.
Oh please. That's far too simplistic. How do you know the Met haven't bugged the ...... and McCann household for the last few years and are busy gathering evidence of lewd hand gestures and obscene language even as we write?! They might have you know, anything's possible in "Sceptic" Land!
-
Mrs. Gaspar cannot remember what the conversation was about. You would think she would remember wouldn't you, if she was so shocked it would stick in her mind. Mrs. Gaspar didn't even know if it was about Madeleine she said she 'THINKS' it was about Madeleine.
It was thoroughly investigated by the police and nothing came of it, ..... ...... is still working as a Dr. and SY have said the parents and their friends are not suspects.
It was Mrs Gaspar's word against ..... and Gerry, what do you think would happen ? The majority of rape accusations never see the inside of a court for much the same reason.
-
Oh please. That's far too simplistic. How do you know the Met haven't bugged the ...... and McCann household for the last few years and are busy gathering evidence of lewd hand gestures and obscene language even as we write?! They might have you know, anything's possible in "Sceptic" Land!
Dare I say, "Tick Tock?"
-
Mrs. Gaspar cannot remember what the conversation was about. You would think she would remember wouldn't you, if she was so shocked it would stick in her mind. Mrs. Gaspar didn't even know if it was about Madeleine she said she 'THINKS' it was about Madeleine.
It was thoroughly investigated by the police and nothing came of it, ..... ..... is still working as a Dr. and SY have said the parents and their friends are not suspects.
And despite world-wide publicity - in 8 years not a single person has come forward claiming to be a victim.
-
And despite world-wide publicity - in 8 years not a single person has come forward claiming to be a victim.
Many abusers never abuse outside their family.
-
Many abusers never abuse outside their family.
DP isn't a member of Madeleine's family. No allegations or suspicions were directed at Gerry.
-
The reported conversation was between DP and GM and the inference is they may have been joking about abusing a child? It's a strange thing to say don't you think? The explanation could be this is just a snippet of conversation and likely taken completely out of context or an insider joke which caused the confusion.
I found a comment on the internet which mirrored my own thought about the improbability of Dr Gaspar not hearing what was said in the conversation bearing in mind where she was seated.
It went a little further by pointing out the absolute rudeness of the pair 'talking over' her as if she weren't there.
It made me think about past conversations at dinner tables ~ some of them round as in this tale ~ in a similar situation when people on either side were in conversation.
- you lean back in your chair ... you hear every word being said ... you participate in the conversation
- f you are really not interested in either golf or football or rugby or in this case perhaps a medical anecdote, you lean forward to engage in conversation with the person opposite, leaving the two on either side of you in a conversation at your back. In which case you neither hear their conversation nor do you see their gestures
The whole setting for the scenario as related by Dr Gasper really doesn't work for me.
-
I found a comment on the internet which mirrored my own thought about the improbability of Dr Gaspar not hearing what was said in the conversation bearing in mind where she was seated.
It went a little further by pointing out the absolute rudeness of the pair 'talking over' her as if she weren't there.
It made me think about past conversations at dinner tables ~ some of them round as in this tale ~ in a similar situation when people on either side were in conversation.
- you lean back in your chair ... you hear every word being said ... you participate in the conversation
- f you are really not interested in either golf or football or rugby or in this case perhaps a medical anecdote, you lean forward to engage in conversation with the person opposite, leaving the two on either side of you in a conversation at your back. In which case you neither hear their conversation nor do you see their gestures
The whole setting for the scenario as related by Dr Gasper really doesn't work for me.
Now there's a surprise.
Can you tell me that the behaviour witnessed by Mrs. Gaspar is normal male behaviour ?
-
Many abusers never abuse outside their family.
It has been suggested that that is precisely what went on here though, isn't it?
-
It was Mrs Gaspar's word against ..... and Gerry, what do you think would happen ? The majority of rape accusations never see the inside of a court for much the same reason.
If the police took Gaspar's claims seriously I would think that social services would take his kids into care, at least to give them physical and mental appraisal, and furthermore impound his home and work computers to see if there was any evidence to back up the claims, wouldn't you? Now tell me perhaps they did!
-
DP isn't a member of Madeleine's family. No allegations or suspicions were directed at Gerry.
Of course they were. The fact that Gerry seemed to listen to what ...... was suggesting without doing him physical would suggest a joint understanding.
-
It has been suggested that that is precisely what went on here though, isn't it?
Is it ? No one is suggesting ....... abused Madeleine.
-
If the police took Gaspar's claims seriously I would think that social services would take his kids into care, at least to give them physical and mental appraisal, and furthermore impound his home and work computers to see if there was any evidence to back up the claims, wouldn't you? Now tell me perhaps they did!
If the police did not take Mrs Gaspar's statement seriously then they failed in their duty of care towards both the ...... and McCann children.
-
Now there's a surprise.
Can you tell me that the behaviour witnessed by Mrs. Gaspar is normal male behaviour ?
You have failed to grasp the point I am making.
Seated where Dr Gaspar said ... it would not have been possible for her not to have been privy to the conversation between the two men. If any paedophile reference concerning the two year old daughter of one had been made ... why would she have continued to sit there in tolerance and mute acquiescence?
Why would she allow anyone to have access to her daughter by allowing him to bathe her given harbouring such suspicion?
Bearing in mind there were children in attendance neither Dr Arul Gaspar or anyone else took the slightest bit of notice of what she alleges were inappropriate gestures.
If the Policia Judicairia gave any credence to the alleged incident ... why wasn't it a question included in the rogatory interviews?
-
You have failed to grasp the point I am making.
Seated where Dr Gaspar said ... it would not have been possible for her not to have been privy to the conversation between the two men. If any paedophile reference concerning the two year old daughter of one had been made ... why would she have continued to sit there in tolerance and mute acquiescence?
Why would she allow anyone to have access to her daughter by allowing him to bathe her given harbouring such suspicion?
Bearing in mind there were children in attendance neither Dr Arul Gaspar or anyone else took the slightest bit of notice of what she alleges were inappropriate gestures.
If the Policia Judicairia gave any credence to the alleged incident ... why wasn't it a question included in the rogatory interviews?
The police certainly should have investigated.
NOW TELL ME, DID SHE OBSERVE NORMAL MALE BEHAVIOUR ?
-
Of course they were. The fact that Gerry seemed to listen to what ..... was suggesting without doing him physical would suggest a joint understanding.
We have no idea whether .... ...... was making any suggestions. Mrs Gaspar does not remember the convo.
IMO common sense alone dictates that if ..... ..... had made a paedaphilic remark about Madeleine to her own father then Gerry would have decked him on the spot and that would have been the end of that friendship.
Ask any father.
-
This is getting dangerously close to Libel. Have a care of what you say. I will be deleting any posts suggesting Libel against either Gerry McCann or DP.
-
So you think from her statement that Gaspar believed Gerry was a paedo too? I don't.
At work so can't read the statements again right now but considering the 2 in question were according to Mrs Gaspar possibly having a joke about some sort of sexual abuse then of course Mrs Gaspar would think Gerry was involved too. Don't u think? And if not, why not? It's a weird conversation imo but in the circumstances Mrs Gaspar could easily be confused and it sounds like she is very uncertain from my recollection of the statement. Hence, the confusion.
-
I found a comment on the internet which mirrored my own thought about the improbability of Dr Gaspar not hearing what was said in the conversation bearing in mind where she was seated.
It went a little further by pointing out the absolute rudeness of the pair 'talking over' her as if she weren't there.
It made me think about past conversations at dinner tables ~ some of them round as in this tale ~ in a similar situation when people on either side were in conversation.
- you lean back in your chair ... you hear every word being said ... you participate in the conversation
- f you are really not interested in either golf or football or rugby or in this case perhaps a medical anecdote, you lean forward to engage in conversation with the person opposite, leaving the two on either side of you in a conversation at your back. In which case you neither hear their conversation nor do you see their gestures
The whole setting for the scenario as related by Dr Gasper really doesn't work for me.
Yep possibly, but imo I don't think she is lying rather or making stuff up. She has heard a snippet of conversation and it's been taken out of context leading to the wrong conclusions fueled by all the talk at the time in the media it has given her a few sleepless nights and gone to the police I suppose - mere speculation I know.
-
This is getting dangerously close to Libel. Have a care of what you say. I will be deleting any posts suggesting Libel against either Gerry McCann or DP.
This thread has been edited to remove inappropriate references. Names of third parties should not be included in posts.
-
The police certainly should have investigated.
NOW TELL ME, DID SHE OBSERVE NORMAL MALE BEHAVIOUR ?
Males get up to all sorts of frivolity when out together and more so when the beverages are flowing. You could infer Mrs Gaspar was uncomfortable in their company or a bit of a prude or a party pooper.
prude (http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prude)
-
Mrs Gasper could have made a mistake. She admits she wasn't sure what was going on. When Madeleine went missing she came forward just in case it helped the investigation. She fulfilled her duty as she saw it by bringing her concerns to the people best qualified to investigate them. Given her obvious unease I think she did the right thing.
-
The police certainly should have investigated.
NOW TELL ME, DID SHE OBSERVE NORMAL MALE BEHAVIOUR ?
No-one knows what Dr Gaspar saw or why she interpreted it as she did. A situation which has given internet abuse junkies free reign to traduce and malign in the most horrible manner a person against whom there is not now nor ever has been a shred of suspicion.
Quite obviously you are incapable of addressing the substance of my posts on this matter ... which seems to make what I have posted irrefutable.
Good ... I think it is too ... so glad you agree.
-
At work so can't read the statements again right now but considering the 2 in question were according to Mrs Gaspar possibly having a joke about some sort of sexual abuse then of course Mrs Gaspar would think Gerry was involved too. Don't u think? And if not, why not? It's a weird conversation imo but in the circumstances Mrs Gaspar could easily be confused and it sounds like she is very uncertain from my recollection of the statement. Hence, the confusion.
No I don't think, because she did not report on anything that Gerry said or did that struck her as odd, plus just being on the receiving end of or in the same room as questionable comments does not infer guilt on the other party, because if it did then the Gaspars would also be in the same boat as Gerry wouldn't they?
-
Mrs Gasper could have made a mistake. She admits she wasn't sure what was going on. When Madeleine went missing she came forward just in case it helped the investigation. She fulfilled her duty as she saw it by bringing her concerns to the people best qualified to investigate them. Given her obvious unease I think she did the right thing.
I agree she was obligated to report her observations given the circumstances as were Leicestershire Police to pass it on immediately to the PJ. The latter summarily failed!
-
Yep possibly, but imo I don't think she is lying rather or making stuff up. She has heard a snippet of conversation and it's been taken out of context leading to the wrong conclusions fueled by all the talk at the time in the media it has given her a few sleepless nights and gone to the police I suppose - mere speculation I know.
Everything to do with her statement is "mere speculation" all of it internet led. The people who really matter ... that is the investigative authorities ... filed it with no further action.
She was right to take her intel to the police ... they were right to look into it (if they did) ... what was very, very wrong ~ from every point of view ~ was for its publication on the internet.
-
No-one knows what Dr Gaspar saw or why she interpreted it as she did. A situation which has given internet abuse junkies free reign to traduce and malign in the most horrible manner a person against whom there is not now nor ever has been a shred of suspicion.
Quite obviously you are incapable of addressing the substance of my posts on this matter ... which seems to make what I have posted irrefutable.
Good ... I think it is too ... so glad you agree.
Nothing irrefutable at all.
As to agreeing with your post, not a chance.
-
No I don't think, because she did not report on anything that Gerry said or did that struck her as odd, plus just being on the receiving end of or in the same room as questionable comments does not infer guilt on the other party, because if it did then the Gaspars would also be in the same boat as Gerry wouldn't they?
Not really imo, because she wasn't involved in the conversation as far as I'm aware and it reads like they were having some kind of private in joke. Mrs Gaspar imo interpreted the conversation incorrectly. Seems a logical step to me to assume that if they were having a private joke about something awful then the other party by extension is complicit. Funny old world - off topic but my personal suspicions are the dog alerts may have been planted by certain members of the PJ 2 months after that night. Hence the mass confusion around this case and add in the logistics that night and campaigning for nearly a decade decade since by the parents and plus the charges certain members of the PJ have been convicted of since it becomes more and more probable imo. It's a very confusing case all round...
-
I agree she was obligated to report her observations given the circumstances as were Leicestershire Police to pass it on immediately to the PJ. The latter summarily failed!
We don't know that Leicester Police didn't pass it on. The PJ knew about these statements when they asked for copies. How did they know? And what happened to the original statements made in English?
However, Leicester Police were primarily obligated to investigate these suspicions, especially as the incident was not directly related to the holiday in Portugal.
-
I agree she was obligated to report her observations given the circumstances as were Leicestershire Police to pass it on immediately to the PJ. The latter summarily failed!
I think it possible it was passed on timeously and subsequently misplaced ... how else would Ricardo Paiva been able to ask for it naming Dr Gaspar? he couldn't ask for something he didn't know existed.
-
If the police did not take Mrs Gaspar's statement seriously then they failed in their duty of care towards both the ...... and McCann children.
Perhaps it is incumbent on you or one of your fellow justice seekers and child abuse campaigners to find out if the police have fully investigated the suspected paedo and ensure his children are not at risk? A sort of side project for you, you could call it.
-
I think it possible it was passed on timeously and subsequently misplaced ... how else would Ricardo Paiva been able to ask for it naming Dr Gaspar? he couldn't ask for something he didn't know existed.
To some extent I agree but Paiva could have heard about them by anyone within LC before putting it into writing.
-
Perhaps it is incumbent on you or one of your fellow justice seekers and child abuse campaigners to find out if the police have fully investigated the suspected paedo and ensure his children are not at risk? A sort of side project for you, you could call it.
Not sure if Faith is quite up to the sort of thing.
I'm happy to help, though. Unfortunately, I can't copy and paste the screenshot from this (highly pertinent to the discussion) link from another board, so I'm sure the admin will forgive (in this instance) a link from another board that seems to pretty much confirm that Mrs Gaspar's statement (as we read it on line) is not a true reflection of what she actually said ....
http://www.stopthemyths.info/viewtopic.php?
In particular, the wording: Matters identified attributed to Mrs Gaspar
suggests that what we read on-line is not an accurate rending of what Mrs Gaspar said, tending to make all further discussion on the matter moot.
We have no base-line to pursue further discussion on ...
-
it must be fairly obvious to even the densest on here that if you are discussing the sexual abuse of your a daughter with another man you don't do it when someone is sitting between you. The whole idea is stupid and I am not surprised that there is some doubt about how accurate this statement is.....
is there really anyone on here who thinks it possible that Gerry was discussing sexual abuse knowing that Dr Gaspar would hear every word
-
Thursday 3 May at tennis.
"Gerry said, were just absolutely knackered and Kate was getting them bathed and ready for bed."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
I had the tendency to walk close to the bathroom.................
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATERINA-PAYNE-INCIDENT.htm
-
Thursday 3 May at tennis.
"Gerry said, were just absolutely knackered and Kate was getting them bathed and ready for bed."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
I had the tendency to walk close to the bathroom.................
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATERINA-PAYNE-INCIDENT.htm
The statements were originally taken by Leicestershire Police then translated
into Portuguese so what's the difficulty exactly? &%+((£
-
If Gerry said that to Fiona at tennis then everyone can see what is being covered up and it connects to KG statement.
-
The statements were originally taken by Leicestershire Police then translated
into Portuguese so what's the difficulty exactly? &%+((£
If you do not realise then there is no point in explaining
-
Fourth thread down in the noname forum:
http://www.stopthemyths.info/index.php
-
it must be fairly obvious to even the densest on here that if you are discussing the sexual abuse of your a daughter with another man you don't do it when someone is sitting between you. The whole idea is stupid and I am not surprised that there is some doubt about how accurate this statement is.....
is there really anyone on here who thinks it possible that Gerry was discussing sexual abuse knowing that Dr Gaspar would hear every word
Unfortunately there are. I've asked an admin at STM to resurrect the thread from the archive.
Watch this space ....
-
If you do not realise then there is no point in explaining
Are you suggesting Leicestershire Police construed their comments Dave?
-
Are you suggesting Leicestershire Police construed their comments Dave?
Leicestershire police didn't do the translating. I would want to see the original of such a controversial document as the accusations in it are ridiculous
-
Leicestershire police didn't do the translating. I would want to see the original of such a controversial document as the accusations in it are ridiculous
Are you calling the Gaspar's liars then ?
-
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/Gaspar.htm
3911 to 3915 Witness statement of Katherina Zacharias Gaspar 2007.05.16
TRANSLATIONS BY INES
13 Processos Vol XIII Pages 3911 to 3915
Final revised translation
........................................................
Translation [PJ] done by C.R.F.E.
Note: Retroversion from the Portuguese translation
___________________________________________________________________________________________
What is a "final revised translation" as done by Ines?
-
If you do not realise then there is no point in explaining
They are.
Sorry, quoted the wrong post. I had intended quoting this, from Davel:
Leicestershire police didn't do the translating. I would want to see the original of such a controversial document as the accusations in it are ridiculous
Dr David Payne has been traduced, beyond question
But arising from the "Gaspar incident", I'm unsure he's the only (doctor) to be so.
Who seriously believes that anyone (and particularly a doctor) harbouring the suspicions Mrs G is purported to have harboured would allow the man who is the subject of her suspicions to bath her daughter?
Anyone?
-
We all think doctors are proactive, but I still puzzle over Kate McCann and Fiona Payne doing nothing about those comatose twins.
-
We all think doctors are proactive, but I still puzzle over Kate McCann and Fiona Payne doing nothing about those comatose twins.
I don't
-
This Thread is a spin off about The Gaspar Statements.. Have the courtesy to stick to the topic, please.
-
They are.
Sorry, quoted the wrong post. I had intended quoting this, from Davel:
Dr David Payne has been traduced, beyond question
But arising from the "Gaspar incident", I'm unsure he's the only (doctor) to be so.
Who seriously believes that anyone (and particularly a doctor) harbouring the suspicions Mrs G is purported to have harboured would allow the man who is the subject of her suspicions to bath her daughter?
Anyone?
There is a witness who overheard Gerry blaming paedos for taking her only an hour or so after the alarm.
-
Fourth thread down in the noname forum:
http://www.stopthemyths.info/index.php
Thank you for the link ferryman. Part of the response from LP appears to be as shown below but I fail to see how any of this undermines the validity of the statements?
It is interesting that LP deemed certain matters to be of sufficient relevance that they were passed to the MPS.
(http://s16.postimg.org/bn1psggk5/gsstate_2.jpg)
http://www.stopthemyths.info/viewtopic.php?f=177&t=5639
-
UK police chief hits back at Portuguese detective’s claims
8 November 2009 | Posted by astro
The head of Leicestershire Police has rejected claims from a former Portuguese detective that his officers withheld a witness statement from the Madeleine McCann inquiry.
Chris Eyre, the Temporary Chief Constable, said “I can assure you that at no time were statements withheld and not passed on.”
Goncalo Amaral, the Algarve detective who was removed the inquiry early on, made his claim in a book, which is now banned.
Mr Eyre responded after Freedom of Information requests were submitted by the Sunday Express.
A team of Leicestershire family officers went to Portugal on 5 May 2007 to support the McCanns.
It has also emerged that the Foreign Office has withheld details about the investigation so as not to damage relations between Britain and Portugal.
An individual submitted Freedom of Information requests to get details of negotiations by John Buck, Britain’s former ambassador to Portugal.
The then Information Commissioner Richard Thomas refused in case it caused Portugal to lose trust in Britain’s discretion.
in: Sunday Express, 08.11.2009, paper edition only
http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2009/ ... guese.html
-
Thank you for the link ferryman. Part of the response from LP appears to be as shown below but I fail to see how any of this undermines the validity of the statements?
It is interesting that LP deemed certain matters to be of sufficient relevance that they were passed to the MPS.
(http://s16.postimg.org/bn1psggk5/gsstate_2.jpg)
http://www.stopthemyths.info/viewtopic.php?f=177&t=5639
"The statements on the internet attributed to Dr Gaspar" ... interesting choice of wording.
-
Now the question is, what did SY do with the statements........................... &%+((£
-
Now the question is, what did SY do with the statements........................... &%+((£
It is likely that we shall never know.
-
Copies were sent to The PJ who translated them into Portuguese. The UK Police will still have the originals, in English.
-
I dont believe DP and GM were holding a conversation about Madeleine in a sexual context...Madeleine was TWO at the time and even she were older it still does not gel and is qute sick
I think KG had a creepy feeling about DP for whatever reason and it went out of hand after that
-
I believe the Euro Weekly News revealed the details of the Gaspar statement yet I don't remember ..... ....... or for that matter Gerry demanding a retraction. Does that mean it was true ?
[Editor comment...
Posts which breach the forum rules will be edited or removed]
171
The Gaspar statements were far worse than that.
They were a travesty of justice that impugned two doctors: Doctor David Payne and Dr Katrina Gaspar.
But not a third, Katrina Gaspar's husband (whose first name eludes me).
-
We all think doctors are proactive, but I still puzzle over Kate McCann and Fiona Payne doing nothing about those comatose twins.
It's not true that she did nothing.
She monitored them regularly, and (distressed and worried as she was about Madeleine) made (I'm sure) a sound clinical judgement that the twins were not in danger.
The proof of the pudding is that the twins, today, are fine.
-
It's not true that she did nothing.
She monitored them regularly, and (distressed and worried as she was about Madeleine) made (I'm sure) a sound clinical judgement that the twins were not in danger.
The proof of the pudding is that the twins, today, are fine.
Clinical judgement when she was in a state of panic ?
That is illogical.
As to how the twins are now, how on earth would you know ?
-
Clinical judgement when she was in a state of panic ?
That is illogical.
As to how the twins are now, how on earth would you know ?
No it's not. The McCanns raised anxieties about possible sedation of the twins within days (or even hours) of Madeleine's abduction.
There is a clear distinction between a medical concern (for the twin's welfare) and a criminal concern (about the abductor's modus operandi),
-
No it's not. The McCanns raised anxieties about possible sedation of the twins within days (or even hours) of Madeleine's abduction.
There is a clear distinction between a medical concern (for the twin's welfare) and a criminal concern (about the abductor's modus operandi),
Rubbish.
If they thought the other two children had been drugged, the presence of any drugs, including anesthetics could have been identified, unless of course, they had something to hide themselves.
-
Rubbish.
If they thought the other two children had been drugged, the presence of any drugs, including anesthetics could have been identified, unless of course, they had something to hide themselves.
If they had anything to hide themselves, they would not have raised the issue of possible drug-use in the abduction as soon as they did.
-
If they had anything to hide themselves, they would not have raised the issue of possible drug-use in the abduction as soon as they did.
Then why didn't they pursue the tests ?
Your argument doesn't hold water, and if drugs were used, how would the mccanns know what they were ?
-
Then why didn't they pursue the tests ?
Your argument doesn't hold water, and if drugs were used, how would the mccanns know what they were ?
There were no clinical concerns.
There was a criminal concern
Simple as that.
-
No it's not. The McCanns raised anxieties about possible sedation of the twins within days (or even hours) of Madeleine's abduction.
There is a clear distinction between a medical concern (for the twin's welfare) and a criminal concern (about the abductor's modus operandi),
The McCanns didn't mention the twins when they raised their concerns with the British FLOs some days later. What the McCanns asked was if there was any evidence of sedation being used to abduct Madeleine. Very slippery of you to suggest otherwise FM.
-
If they had anything to hide themselves, they would not have raised the issue of possible drug-use in the abduction as soon as they did.
Of course they would. It was a fishing trip. Any sedation found could be blamed on the abductor.
-
There were no clinical concerns.
There was a criminal concern
Simple as that.
How do you know there were no clinical concerns ?
-
The McCanns didn't mention the twins when they raised their concerns with the British FLOs some days later. What the McCanns asked was if there was any evidence of sedation being used to abduct Madeleine. Very slippery of you to suggest otherwise FM.
Aside from in the hours after Madeleine's abduction there were no clinical concerns about the twins.
It was only after the palpably ridiculous notion that the McCanns might have drugged the twins (via a comment of Kate's father, either incompetently or fraudulently misinterpreted) that the McCanns became exercised about establishing that they hadn't drugs with the children.
-
Aside from in the hours after Madeleine's abduction there were no clinical concerns about the twins.
It was only after the palpably ridiculous notion that the McCanns might have drugged the twins (via a comment of Kate's father, either incompetently or fraudulently misinterpreted) that the McCanns became exercised about establishing that they hadn't drugs with the children.
How do you know there were no clinical concerns ?
You are not a doctor ?
and they had no way of knowing if drugs had been administrated, DID THEY ?
-
Aside from in the hours after Madeleine's abduction there were no clinical concerns about the twins.
It was only after the palpably ridiculous notion that the McCanns might have drugged the twins (via a comment of Kate's father, either incompetently or fraudulently misinterpreted) that the McCanns became exercised about establishing that they hadn't drugs with the children.
Stop changing the goalposts FM. Now you said they McCanns expressed concerns to the FLO about the twins being drugged. I proved that this was not the case. Now are you going to concede the point ?
-
Any more insults and the entire post will be removed.
-
How do you know there were no clinical concerns ?
You are not a doctor ?
and they had no way of knowing if drugs had been administrated, DID THEY ?
Curiously enough, the McCanns are doctors and Kate describes that she monitored the twins.
Panicked as she was (about Madeleine) she checked the twin's clinical readings and saw nothing to her undue concern (about them).
Then (much later) they (the McCanns) were accused, via a misconstrued comment of the twin's granndfather, of drugging the twins and all 3 of the children and (naturally) wanted to set the record straight.
-
Curiously enough, the McCanns are doctors and Kate describes that she monitored the twins.
Panicked as she was (about Madeleine) she checked the twin's clinical readings and saw nothing to her undue concern (about them).
Then (much later) they (the McCanns) were accused, via a misconstrued comment of the twin's granndfather, of drugging the twins and all 3 of the children and (naturally) wanted to set the record straight.
What is 'clinical' about putting your hand on a child to see if it's still breathing?
No, and that was the other thing, she kept going into the twins, she kept putting her hands on the twins to check they were breathing, she was very much concerned in checking that they were okay. But they were okay, I mean, they were fine, they didn't, they were asleep, but at the time it did seem weird, I remember thinking, you know, when the Police came they turned the lights on, there was loads of noise, obviously from the moment Kate discovered that Madeleine was gone, the screaming and the shouting and there was a lot of noise and they, they didn't, you know, so much as blink'.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FIONA-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
-
What ever happened to THE TOPIC. You all wanted to talk about The Gaspar Statements, so please do that.
-
What ever happened to THE TOPIC. You all wanted to talk about The Gaspar Statements, so please do that.
Apologies.
The Gaspar statements.
They are not a true reflection of what (certainly Mrs) Gaspar said.
So we can't infer anything from them.
-
Remarkable that statements from Mrs Fenn and the Drs Gaspar contradictory statements have successfully been used to deflect attention from the reality of Madeleine McCann's case ... sometimes one wonders exactly who is pulling the strings ...
-
Remarkable that statements from Mrs Fenn and the Drs Gaspar contradictory statements have successfully been used to deflect attention from the reality of Madeleine McCann's case ... sometimes one wonders exactly who is pulling the strings ...
A) when you post at least try not to mislead...MR Gaspars statement was NOT contradictory to his wifes.....it was slightly different....in ony one sense in that he did not hear any conversation so could not make any comment, a rather important difference but none the less not the ONLY difference
B) the puppetmaster......and you and no one else knows who that is or should pretend to know or present as fact
-
A) when you post at least try not to mislead...MR Gaspars statement was NOT contradictory to his wifes.....it was slightly different....in ony one sense in that he did not hear any conversation so could not make any comment, a rather important difference but none the less not the ONLY difference
B) the puppetmaster......and you and no one else knows who that is or should pretend to know or present as fact
I can describe Dave as a Caucasian male 1.78 m tall, and of a medium complexion. He had brown hair and used glasses/contact lenses depending on the circumstances.
I can say that Dave was a pleasant person. I do not remember him having any unusual characteristics.
During the holidays Dave never behaved in an inappropriate manner with Madeleine or with any of the other children. Dave was popular with the children and I took this to be because he was a close friend to the family.
I never distrusted Dave. After the holidays there was one occasion when we were with Kate and Gerry and Fiona and Dave were also present.
That was in a restaurant in Leicester in 2005. I do not remember the name of the restaurant.
We had a pleasant evening, just the three couples without the children.
I do not remember Dave having behaved inappropriately on this occasion. We have not spoken to Dave or Fiona since December 2005, only due to their being friends of Kate and Gerry, not for any other reason.
-
I only remember that Katherina saw the gesture at the time, I had forgotten the episode, it was never the subject of conversation.
At the time I did not feel the gesture was referring to Madeleine.
-
I only remember that Katherina saw the gesture at the time, I had forgotten the episode, it was never the subject of conversation.
At the time I did not feel the gesture was referring to Madeleine.
Sums up everything there is to say about both Gaspar statements.
-
Sums up everything there is to say about both Gaspar statements.
Hardly.
If McCann supporters were not worried about these statements , you and your fellows would not need to comment on them.
-
Dear Alfred, its not hard to precis, these are the facts
BOTH the Gaspars saw a lewd act and said it was such
ONE of them thought it might mean something to do with children
THAT was the only difference, ergo my original point was correct, Mr Gaspar did not contradict his wife
, their two experiences of the situation were different so ghere is no comparison to make really
-
Dear Alfred, its not hard to precis, these are the facts
BOTH the Gaspars saw a lewd act and said it was such
ONE of them thought it might mean something to do with children
THAT was the only difference, ergo my original point was correct, Mr Gaspar did not contradict his wife
, their two experiences of the situation were different so ghere is no comparison to make really
No they didn't
-
No they didn't
Your post doesnt make sense...what does "no they dont" mean?
-
Your post doesnt make sense...what does "no they dont" mean?
ITs no they didn't
A translation error from English to English
-
ITs no they didn't
A translation error from English to English
You best reread back and explain otherwise you will prove have no command of the english language at all
But once you get your calm sensible head on if it it exists perhaps you might like to explain to thr forum what you mean, remember it is a forum, not your personal punch bag lol
-
You best reread back and explain otherwise you will prove have no command of the english language at all
But once you get your calm sensible head on if it it exists perhaps you might like to explain go ghe forum what you mean, remember it is a forum, not your personal punch bag lol
The statements you refer to describe an act which they took to be lewd.....just their opinion
-
Dear Alfred, its not hard to precis, these are the facts
BOTH the Gaspars saw a lewd act and said it was such
ONE of them thought it might mean something to do with children
THAT was the only difference, ergo my original point was correct, Mr Gaspar did not contradict his wife
, their two experiences of the situation were different so ghere is no comparison to make really
Their experiences were different and their interpretation of the event was at variance as were their statements ... at least those we have seen on the internet ... therefore their statements are contradictory.
-
They could just have easily been talked ng about how Maddie breast fed.... That's makes far more sense
-
Their experiences were different and their interpretation of the event was at variance as were their statements ... at least those we have seen on the internet ... therefore their statements are contradictory.
Nope
Look up contradictory
different statements but not contradictory
I personally do not believe K Gaspars fears and imaginings....that would mean either DP or GM were sexually abusing a two year old....but she did the right thing nevertheless.....if it could ever be true it might be on her conscience
-
Nope
Look up contradictory
different statements but not contradictory
I personally do not believe K Gaspars fears and imaginings....that would mean either .... ...... or GM were sexually abusing a two year old....but she did the right thing nevertheless.....if it could ever be true it might be on her conscience
Unfortunately doctors do raise concerns that turn out to be false and result in children being removed from families
-
They could just have easily been talked ng about how Maddie breast fed.... That's makes far more sense
yes thats often a subject of mens convo lol when theyre getting pissed
Their babies breastfeeding habits rofl
More often their own "habits"
-
yes thats often a subject of mens convo lol when theyre getting pissed
Their babies breastfeeding habits rofl
More often their own "habits"
You would agree far more likely than sexually abusing a child
-
You would agree far more likely than sexually abusing a child
Your laziness and short term memory let you down dear
-
Unfortunately doctors do raise concerns that turn out to be false and result in children being removed from families
it very very rarely happens if at all...a bit like stranger abduction from holiday
I will leave you to your hijacking for now and let someone else have a word..this is NOT The davel forum you know...pathetic
-
it very very rarely happens if at all...a bit like stranger abduction from holiday
I will leave you to your hijacking for now and let someone else have a word..this is NOT The davel forum you know...pathetic
It does happen