UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Alfred R Jones on November 18, 2015, 06:48:18 PM

Title: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on November 18, 2015, 06:48:18 PM
Here's a question - does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?  If so, please provide the evidence. 
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: John on December 14, 2015, 02:13:32 AM
Here's a question - does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?  If so, please provide the evidence.

I have given your question its own thread Alfred. 

I could be wrong in this and stand to be corrected by our members resident in Portugal but I cannot see the Portuguese at large being in the least interested in Mr Amaral and his troubles.  The Portuguese police had quite a reputation in years gone by and most people have long memories. Interest is probably limited to the Algarve region but guaging support for Amaral in Portugal is probably an impossible task. I could be completely wrong though, please discuss.

Curiously, he certainly enjoys support in the UK but I have a feeling it is more to do with being anti McCann than support for Amaral himself.  I think if you took the McCann name out of the equation Amaral would effectively be a non entity.  I could be completely wrong though so open this up to other views.
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Benice on December 14, 2015, 09:05:13 AM
I have given your question its own thread Alfred. 

I could be wrong in this and stand to be corrected by our members resident in Portugal but I cannot see the Portuguese at large being in the least interested in Mr Amaral and his troubles.  The Portuguese police had quite a reputation in years gone by and most people have long memories. Interest is probably limited to the Algarve region but guaging support for Amaral in Portugal is probably an impossible task. I could be completely wrong though, please discuss.

Curiously, he certainly enjoys support in the UK but I have a feeling it is more to do with being anti McCann than support for Amaral himself.  I think if you took the McCann name out of the equation Amaral would effectively be a non entity.  I could be completely wrong though so open this up to other views.

I totally agree with that.
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 14, 2015, 09:17:52 AM
I totally agree with that.
Me too.
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 09:18:26 AM
The gofundme account ought to be a gauge of Amaral's support for his appeal.

But is it?
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 10:06:29 AM
The gofundme account ought to be a gauge of Amaral's support for his appeal.

But is it?

even then that would not be massive support...he enjoys some support from a small group who have believed his lies and think they understand DNA evidence...cadaver dogs....and the rest
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: stephen25000 on December 14, 2015, 10:12:47 AM
even then that would not be massive support...he enjoys some support from a small group who have believed his lies and think they understand DNA evidence...cadaver dogs....and the rest


So rather like the small clique of mccann supporters who back them then, and back abduction without a shred of evidence to back it up ?
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 14, 2015, 10:13:53 AM
Even then, in order to understand the true level of financial support, it would be necessary to see the gross receipts to the GoFundMe site and net receipts to the PJGA account.

In the interests of openness, I cannot see the problem in producing a set of accounts.   
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 10:14:34 AM

So rather like the small clique of mccann supporters who back them then, and back abduction without a shred of evidence to back it up ?

There is plenty of evidence to support abduction...I would also say far more believe in abduction than parental involvement
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: stephen25000 on December 14, 2015, 10:15:34 AM
There is plenty of evidence to support abduction...I would also say far more believe in abduction than parental involvement

No there isn't.

So prove me wrong.
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 10:19:42 AM
No there isn't.

So prove me wrong.

don't you mean prove me wrong again....can't be bothered...your opinion is of no importance
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: stephen25000 on December 14, 2015, 10:25:38 AM
don't you mean prove me wrong again....can't be bothered...your opinion is of no importance


As I said, no evidence of abduction.
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 10:27:16 AM

As I said, no evidence of abduction.

in your opinion...or is you opinion fact now
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: stephen25000 on December 14, 2015, 10:29:08 AM
in your opinion...or is you opinion fact now

I thought it was Amaral under discussion.
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 10:34:23 AM
I thought it was Amaral under discussion.

it was until YOU introduced abduction ...at 10.12
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: stephen25000 on December 14, 2015, 10:37:10 AM
it was until YOU introduced abduction ...at 10.12

Yet you introduced the dogs again.

You are trying to have your cake and eat it.
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 10:43:21 AM
Yet you introduced the dogs again.

You are trying to have your cake and eat it.

amaral promoted false claims for the dogs ...gullible people believed him... that's where his support comes from
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: stephen25000 on December 14, 2015, 10:45:30 AM
amaral promoted false claims for the dogs ...gullible people believed him... that's where his support comes from

The claims as regards the dogs have not been proved or disproved by forensic results.#


You seem to omit as usual, people can make up their own minds as regards the case, without referral to Amaral.
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 10:59:16 AM
The claims as regards the dogs have not been proved or disproved by forensic results.#


You seem to omit as usual, people can make up their own minds as regards the case, without referral to Amaral.

amaral claimed the dogs proved Maddie died in the apartment...he was lying
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 11:08:41 AM
amaral claimed the dogs proved Maddie died in the apartment...he was lying

Or (at most charitable) incompetent.

But his appeal (verb, not adjective!) I now understand is against the notion that he breached his duties of confidentiality to keep his mouth shut about an investigation he coordinated.

When the evidence that he did (breach his duties of confidentiality) is overwhelming (it is!) what could be the basis of support for an appeal against an irrefutable case?
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: faithlilly on December 14, 2015, 11:10:31 AM
I have given your question its own thread Alfred. 

I could be wrong in this and stand to be corrected by our members resident in Portugal but I cannot see the Portuguese at large being in the least interested in Mr Amaral and his troubles.  The Portuguese police had quite a reputation in years gone by and most people have long memories. Interest is probably limited to the Algarve region but guaging support for Amaral in Portugal is probably an impossible task. I could be completely wrong though, please discuss.

Curiously, he certainly enjoys support in the UK but I have a feeling it is more to do with being anti McCann than support for Amaral himself.  I think if you took the McCann name out of the equation Amaral would effectively be a non entity.  I could be completely wrong though so open this up to other views.

I think at this point we should differentiate between supporting Amaral per se and simply believing his constant smearing both in the UK press and on supporter forums is unfair and unwarranted.

I, like John, believe that most Portuguese people neither think nor care about Amaral and his troubles ( would we be up in arms if a member of SY was facing what Amaral has, probably not ). I think, on the whole the police are seen as a necessary evil in what ever country we look at and Portugal, I suspect, is no different.
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: stephen25000 on December 14, 2015, 11:10:56 AM
amaral claimed the dogs proved Maddie died in the apartment...he was lying

What was the court judgement as to whether Amaral lied or not ?
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 11:11:15 AM
Or (at most charitable) incompetent.

But his appeal (verb, not adjective!) I now understand is against the notion that he breached his duties of confidentiality to keep his mouth shut about an investigation he coordinated.

When the evidence that he did (breach his duties of confidentiality) is overwhelming (it is!) what could be the basis of support for an appeal against an irrefutable case?

where did you get this information re the appeal
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 11:12:03 AM
What was the court judgement as to whether Amaral lied or not ?

what are you talking about...the court made no judgement re lying
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: xtina on December 14, 2015, 11:28:25 AM
well considering every thing is known about G.A. ....i think you will find he has a lot more support than the mccs here ....[below from the other thread]

IMO to this ...at least the support G.A. receives is 100% genuine...as at times he is the voice of the non supporters of the mccs ....and also he has no place to hide ..every skeleton is out in the domain warts and all yet he has a massive following ...this speaks for itself in volumes


the mccs have it all there own way ...just one of the examples

mccs its called..... inconsistencies .....Goncalo its called .....lies

means the same thing thought at the end of the day
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Admin on December 14, 2015, 12:27:17 PM
Please keep comments in context.

Admin
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on December 14, 2015, 01:41:29 PM
Here's a question - does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?  If so, please provide the evidence.
Given by "massive support" you mean an exceptionally large supporter base, I doubt he has that level of support.
Outside a few thousand anoraks who study the case, who knows of him to the point they have a continuing interest? Then how many of the general public really care when a cop finds himself in hot water?
For example how many of the offences in the link below were you aware of and post about on that tinternet every day ?

https://www.ipcc.gov.uk/sites/default/files/Documents/FOI/standards_quality/Jan_22_police_sex_offences.pdf

It's the McCann name and it's ability to create divisiveness wot does it.
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 14, 2015, 02:18:05 PM
What was the court judgement as to whether Amaral lied or not ?


Stephen - [ moderated ] the court actually made no judgement.

I draw your attention in particular to paragraph three as follows:

3. The complainant said that it was inaccurate to report that Mr Amaral had “lied”, as the court had not made any judgment on the truth of the detective's claims, and had merely focused on whether or not the detective's right to freedom of expression outweighed the McCanns’ right to reputation.

and here is the cite. 

https://www.ipso.co.uk/IPSO/rulings/resolution-statements/detail.html?id=57

Perhaps an apology to davel? 
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 02:40:46 PM
where did you get this information re the appeal

Fair question.

I assume the information we have been given that he has been given leave to appeal, and is being considered, is accurate.

No more than an assumption ...
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Alfred R Jones on December 14, 2015, 02:52:39 PM
I think at this point we should differentiate between supporting Amaral per se and simply believing his constant smearing both in the UK press and on supporter forums is unfair and unwarranted.

I, like John, believe that most Portuguese people neither think nor care about Amaral and his troubles ( would we be up in arms if a member of SY was facing what Amaral has, probably not ). I think, on the whole the police are seen as a necessary evil in what ever country we look at and Portugal, I suspect, is no different.
You think the police are evil now?!  So that's doctors, police, anyone else we can add to your list of dodgy professions?  Estate agents?  teachers?  Bin men?
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 02:56:54 PM
You think the police are evil now?!  So that's doctors, police, anyone else we can add to your list of dodgy professions?  Estate agents?  teachers?  Bin men?

Good distinction, Alfred.

There are rotten apples in every profession.

Doesn't make the profession as a whole rotten.
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: xtina on December 14, 2015, 03:28:06 PM

Stephen  [ moderated ] the court actually made no judgement.

I draw your attention in particular to paragraph three as follows:

3. The complainant said that it was inaccurate to report that Mr Amaral had “lied”, as the court had not made any judgment on the truth of the detective's claims, and had merely focused on whether or not the detective's right to freedom of expression outweighed the McCanns’ right to reputation.

and here is the cite. 

https://www.ipso.co.uk/IPSO/rulings/resolution-statements/detail.html?id=57

Perhaps an apology to davel?


the McCanns’ right to reputation.


mmm and lets face it ....reputation etc etc .....IMO.is all they care about

as for support......i have never seen a poll ....that hasn't gone against the mccs
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 03:36:09 PM

the McCanns’ right to reputation.


mmm and lets face it ....reputation etc etc .....IMO.is all they care about

as for support......i have never seen a poll ....that hasn't gone against the mccs

If (God forbid!) someone were ever to falsely accuse you of doing something nefarious to your daughter, then hiding the fact of her death, concealing her body, fabricating an abduction and sustaining a fraudulent fund in your (dead) daughter's name, wouldn't you care (amongst other things) about your reputation?
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 14, 2015, 03:37:55 PM
Stephen, with regard to your second paragraph, what other posters here do is not relevant.  For my part, I am perfectly capable of fighting my own battles.

But you have, as usual, successfully deflected the thread away from your comment about

"What was the court judgement as to whether Amaral lied or not "

Are you still suggesting that the court / IPSO ruled that Amaral did not lie?



Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: stephen25000 on December 14, 2015, 03:58:52 PM
i think often ....their best form of defence is attack..stephen

but on a lighter note ...i think the....apology to davel was worse  @)(++(*

It is indeed Xtina.


In more than one regard. 8((()*/
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: xtina on December 14, 2015, 04:02:38 PM
If (God forbid!) someone were ever to falsely accuse you of doing something nefarious to your daughter, then hiding the fact of her death, concealing her body, fabricating an abduction and sustaining a fraudulent fund in your (dead) daughter's name, wouldn't you care (amongst other things) about your reputation?


Nooooooooooo.......god forbid fgs...that is the last thing i would care about

but the mccs do .....get it
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Mr Gray on December 14, 2015, 04:04:24 PM

Nooooooooooo.......god forbid fgs...that is the last thing i would care about

but the mccs do .....get it

I suppose some do not have a reputation to worry about
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 04:07:27 PM

Nooooooooooo.......god forbid fgs...that is the last thing i would care about

but the mccs do .....get it

You would be sufficiently thick-skinned just to shrug off the barbs and taunts?

Interesting ....
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: xtina on December 14, 2015, 04:15:04 PM
You would be sufficiently thick-skinned just to shrug off the barbs and taunts?

Interesting ....


not at all.............if i had lost my daughter that way....nothing would ever bother me again...apart from getting her back..[ barbs & taunts would b the least of my heartbreak devastation]...not interesting .....just simple really
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 14, 2015, 04:21:49 PM

Nooooooooooo.......god forbid fgs...that is the last thing i would care about

but the mccs do .....get it

How relaxed would you be about someone writing a book accusing you of being involved and making a packet from the book sales?

Completely unconcerned? 
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: jassi on December 14, 2015, 04:24:33 PM
How relaxed would you be about someone writing a book accusing you of being involved and making a packet from the book sales?

Completely unconcerned?

Why are people so obsessed with money?
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 14, 2015, 04:28:10 PM
Why are people so obsessed with money?

People like Amaral, you mean?  No idea. 
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: ferryman on December 14, 2015, 04:29:22 PM

not at all.............if i had lost my daughter that way....nothing would ever bother me again...apart from getting her back..[ barbs & taunts would b the least of my heartbreak devastation]...not interesting .....just simple really

I tend to the view that to be able to empathise (that is. to put yourself in the shoes of someone going through trial and tribulation, and to know how they would think, feel and respond), you've actually got have been there yourself.

The McCanns can compartmentalise. can deal separately with striking back against the falsehoods and calumnies reigned down upon them as well as dealing with the business of attempting to find their daughter, and assisting efforts to do so.
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: xtina on December 14, 2015, 04:35:20 PM
How relaxed would you be about someone writing a book accusing you of being involved and making a packet from the book sales?

Completely unconcerned?




now come on....not only off topic...but being silly sa well.............your asking the wrong one here......i didnt neglect my children...........i didnt ask for all i get ...by doing so..like the mccs do...i dont believe in the abduction..[you did ask]

on topic though ...........that is why my 100% suport is behind ameral  8((()*/
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: faithlilly on December 14, 2015, 04:38:37 PM
I tend to the view that to be able to empathise (that is. to put yourself in the shoes of someone going through trial and tribulation, and to know how they would think, feel and respond), you've actually got have been there yourself.

The McCanns can compartmentalise. can deal separately with striking back against the falsehoods and calumnies reigned down upon them as well as dealing with the business of attempting to find their daughter, and assisting efforts to do so.
p

And how is that 'attempting to find their daughter' going FM ? Because as far as I can see the only 'attempting' being done is a few pictures of Madeleine on their OFM Facebook page which has it seems in recent times simply become an offshoot of the MP charity, that's of course when they aren't giving some poor father who couldn't stand to be parted from his children a good verbal kicking.
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: jassi on December 14, 2015, 04:39:55 PM
People like Amaral, you mean?  No idea.

From the wording of your post - 'making a packet', I thought perhaps you had problems with that.
Title: Re: Does Amaral enjoy massive support for his appeal both here and in his own country?
Post by: Jean-Pierre on December 14, 2015, 04:42:53 PM
From the wording of your post - 'making a packet', I thought perhaps you had problems with that.

Not at all.  Nothing wrong with making money honestly. 

But if you are an ex policeman and write a book accusing someone of being a criminal, then you run the risk of being taken to court.  As Amaral has found, and has been whining about it ever since.