Among fair-minded people, there are either the anoraks who hang out on forums such as this, have followed events from the beginning, or shortly after the beginning, and understand what a pile of crock the manufactured, strained and contrived 'case' against the McCanns there actually is; or there are the more casual observers who understand that the McCanns are innocent, that their daughter is missing and they want her back; and who wish the McCanns well in their efforts (and the efforts of law-enforcement agencies on their behalf) to try to find her, or at least solve the crime of what happened to her.
And then there are the others - the gullible idiots who simply do not recognise a pup when they are being sold one.
Some Portuguese people don't like Amaral very much. And one TV Spoof was an absolute hoot. They know that Amaral tried to stitch up The McCanns. They've seen it all too often. This is support of The McCanns.
Some Portuguese people don't like Amaral very much. And one TV Spoof was an absolute hoot. They know that Amaral tried to stitch up The McCanns. They've seen it all too often. This is support of The McCanns.
due to censorship what we don't know is how much the mccs are un supported ....with them everything is always one sided...the mcc sided
this is why the very expensive top lawyers pr man were all put into place in the beginning
over the years ...the hundreds of conversations i have had about the mccs ....the ones in support of them is always either they know something is not right they were neglecting to leave the children ...but maddie must of been abducted because...like how can parents/doctors cover up the loss of their child [in suspicious cicumstances]...and the only info they go by is the propaganda that is fed to them...etc etc etc
the amount of support from abroad i think you will find is very little ...because they have privy of reading and seeing what is censored here
the only support here is what is filtered through the mccs censorship....anything said negative ...never sees the light of day ...
if the UK wasn't brainwashed into the abduction theory being the only one ...i think you would find the amount of support in the UK ...would be very little ..or even lost in non existence....
It would seem only fair to balance the other thread as regards the support given to Amaral. So I await a fair and reasoned response to this thread
IMO to this ...at least the support G.A. receives is 100% genuine...as at times he is the voice of the non supporters of the mccs ....and also he has no place to hide ..every skeleton is out in the domain warts and all yet he has a massive following ...this speaks for itself in volumes
I would say you have had propaganda fed to you...and you have swallowed it
The very visible propaganda has been on behalf of the mccanns, aided by certain xenophobic sections of the UK Tabloid press.
Really.
So who are these Portuguese people who think Amaral stitched up the mccanns ?
"Tried to stitch up The McCanns.'
You should read some of the comments on Portuguese Newspaper Articles. The interview with Amaral by a Lawyer.
Sorry, can't supply it because I've forgotten his name, but I expect someone will.
The ordinary people who don't support Amaral, and by inference, The McCanns, post anonymously, just like you.
and how many of these 'Portuguese' made comments ?
If you think these people represent anything but a minor section of Portuguese opinion, you are mistaken.
"Tried to stitch up The McCanns.'
You should read some of the comments on Portuguese Newspaper Articles. The interview with Amaral by a Lawyer.
Sorry, can't supply it because I've forgotten his name, but I expect someone will.
The ordinary people who don't support Amaral, and by inference, The McCanns, post anonymously, just like you.
just as the McCann critics are a tiny...tiny section of the UK population
due to censorship what we don't know is how much the mccs are un supported ....with them everything is always one sided...the mcc sided
this is why the very expensive top lawyers pr man were all put into place in the beginning
over the years ...the hundreds of conversations i have had about the mccs ....the ones in support of them is always either they know something is not right they were neglecting to leave the children ...but maddie must of been abducted because...like how can parents/doctors cover up the loss of their child [in suspicious cicumstances]...and the only info they go by is the propaganda that is fed to them...etc etc etc
the amount of support from abroad i think you will find is very little ...because they have privy of reading and seeing what is censored here
the only support here is what is filtered through the mccs censorship....anything said negative ...never sees the light of day ...
if the UK wasn't brainwashed into the abduction theory being the only one ...i think you would find the amount of support in the UK ...would be very little ..or even lost in non existence....
It would seem only fair to balance the other thread as regards the support given to Amaral. So I await a fair and reasoned response to this thread
IMO to this ...at least the support G.A. receives is 100% genuine...as at times he is the voice of the non supporters of the mccs ....and also he has no place to hide ..every skeleton is out in the domain warts and all yet he has a massive following ...this speaks for itself in volumes
I would say you have had propaganda fed to you...and you have swallowed it
Thanks, Davel.
As you all know, I support The McCanns 100%. Not particularly because I like them, or know them, but because I know that logistically it was impossible for them to have done that of which they are accused by some.
I also know that Amaral went off on a one track agenda, as has been adequately proved by later events.
Most of my neighbours go glassy eyed every time I mention the case, but with what very little information and knowledge that they have, they all agree with Innocent Until Proven Guilty. and they almost certainly didn't dun it.
And one of my neighbours is a retired Prison Officer. Never was there such a sceptic who has just about seen it all.
just as the McCann critics are a tiny...tiny section of the UK population
Logistically impossible ?
How did you arrive at that conclusion ?
It's a bit of a contradiction isn't it. An 'abductor' is said to have been able to whizz in and out of G5A in a few minutes and disappear into thin air. The parents couldn't do the same though, oh no!
Perhaps you can provide a cite for the claims above Eleanor and perhaps you can explain that with so many Portuguese people, by default, supporting the McCanns not one has deemed fit to redress the balance of dodgy translations by translating themselves ?
Logistically impossible ?
How did you arrive at that conclusion ?
You need to be able to understand Logistics, Stephen.
But this is going Off Topic. So let's get back on track.
Well if comments pages, which are edited, as on the Mail, then those who interested in the case, would reflect that an overwhelming majority either don't believe the mccanns and/or have had enough of the mccanns.
So Stephen, do you think the comments in the Daily Mail reflect the views of what one can loosely term "the general public" - i.e those who do not post on forums such as this, and some of the more virulent anti mccann forums?
Thanks, Davel.
As you all know, I support The McCanns 100%. Not particularly because I like them, or know them, but because I know that logistically it was impossible for them to have done that of which they are accused by some.
I also know that Amaral went off on a one track agenda, as has been adequately proved by later events.
Most of my neighbours go glassy eyed every time I mention the case, but with what very little information and knowledge that they have, they all agree with Innocent Until Proven Guilty. and they almost certainly didn't dun it.
And one of my neighbours is a retired Prison Officer. Never was there such a sceptic who has just about seen it all.
It's a bit of a contradiction isn't it. An 'abductor' is said to have been able to whizz in and out of G5A in a few minutes and disappear into thin air. The parents couldn't do the same though, oh no!
So Stephen, do you think the comments in the Daily Mail reflect the views of what one can loosely term "the general public" - i.e those who do not post on forums such as this, and some of the more virulent anti mccann forums?
According to SY it's possible
According to SY it's possible
(https://encrypted-tbn1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcT_krjpir0lCrEDYhUOx5r6rAyINpMSVRycodSUKGOkxKlTAMLDiQ)I hope their carol service gives some measure of comfort and publicity of it encourages someone who is missing and able to contact their family to do so.
Contrary to dire predictions and campaigns against at the time ... it seems that Dr Kate McCann is an asset to the charity Missing People as their ambassador.
Her association with the charity certainly hasn't put a block on people making contributions to it.
Last night, over £100,000 was raised by our phenomenally generous guests at our Home for Christmas Appeal Fundraising Dinner. Thanks to everyone who came and supported and especially our sponsors for the evening Outsmart.
Christmas is a time when families and friends gather together; but for families with a missing loved one it can be the bleakest time of year. The fundraising dinner and auction will help ensure that the charity can be a lifeline this Christmas and beyond.
https://www.facebook.com/missingpeople.uk/photos/ms.c.eJxl0MENwDAIA8CNqhhwgvdfrFVfrfmeHEPAAvMgmtpVVFz4SMiE9Ze9CjVkZNIzj7nUFO~;p0dzyVwoTrJRLu6TPAuQS9Obk6GnPcOzD7bJH5vhV0X5DdPj0cQ3o~;ekNzPRhzA~-~-.bps.a.10153712858374592.1073741869.8141704591/10153712860414592/?type=3&theater
Distinctly possible when you consider the market it is traditionally aimed at and allegedly its readership is split pretty well 50/50 male to female.
In that case you are hopelessly naive. Every time a hapless newspaper leaves the comments section "open" there is a flurry of activity as members of various fora scramble to get their comments "in".
Followed a couple of hours later by "have you seen the comments in Daily xxxxx, you see all these people who agree tat the McCanns are s..mbags etc"
It happens every time there is a comments box left open, and its a truly pathetic game. But it seems to convince some of the more gullible members of the community.
*&*%£ *&*%£
In that case you are hopelessly naive. Every time a hapless newspaper leaves the comments section "open" there is a flurry of activity as members of various fora scramble to get their comments "in".
Followed a couple of hours later by "have you seen the comments in Daily xxxxx, you see all these people who agree tat the McCanns are s..mbags etc"
It happens every time there is a comments box left open, and its a truly pathetic game. But it seems to convince some of the more gullible members of the community.
*&*%£ *&*%£
No, I can't.
In the topsy turvy world of McCann supporters and sceptics indubitably old stick.
Who are these gullible members of the community that folk keep banging on about? Why are they so important?
I guess "the game" is no more pathetic than racking up an inordinate number of posts on here in the naive belief something of noble purpose will be achieved by it.
Were this case to be resolved tomorrow elements of both "sides" will decamp elsewhere and form their little teams to slag each other off. Big-Endians and Little-Endians (sort of).
No Eleanor I thought not.
You and me both, along with a fair few others. But this constant demand for spurious Cites is very boring.
Thems the rules Eleanor so best you either shape up or ship out huh !
Be serious Eleanor. One sketch how many years ago ?
What difference does it make when the spoof sketch was made? It doesn't alter the contempt which was obviously felt for Amaral by some of his own countrymen, for it to be made in the first place.
So how many were the few ?
Have you seen the spoof of the mccanns on 'you tube' ?
A spoof of a stupid, incompetent and lying ex-cop is funny.
Poking fun at innocent and despairing parents, hovering between hope and grief, is despicable ...
What difference does it make when the spoof sketch was made? It doesn't alter the contempt which was obviously felt for Amaral by some of his own countrymen, for it to be made in the first place.
A spoof of a stupid, incompetent and lying ex-cop is funny.
Poking fun at innocent and despairing parents, hovering between hope and grief, is despicable ...
The urban dictionary ...
Written (in part) by some of the same cruel wretches who torment the McCanns and deny the reality of other victims' grievous losses ...
The mccanns are victims of their own behaviour.
Whatever you may type, you cannot change that implicit truth.
it isn't true...the mccanns are victims of a crime
Madeleine is the victim, never forget that.
The perpetrators remain unknown.
Madeleine is the victim, never forget that.
The perpetrators remain unknown.
Well at least you have finally admitted that. Up until now you have claimed the McCanns are the perpetrators.
Perpetrators benice ?
Perpetrators of what exactly ?
I have not said the mccanns physically harmed their children directly, have I ?
Madeleine is the victim, never forget that.
The perpetrators remain unknown.
the McCann family are all victims of a criminal act by a stranger ...according to SY
The insurance companies, however, expect you to take reasonable care of your property and belongings. Unless the police manage to get your stuff back you will have to bear the cost yourself, as your home insurance is unlikely to pay out.
If an incident is deemed to be your fault e.g. insufficient security precautions were in place at the time your claim occured, an insurer may reject your claim.
For example, you nip around to your neighbour’s house but forget to lock your front door or leave a window open and you are burgled. Some insurance policies may even refuse a claim for burglary if your alarm was not set when you retired to bed. It’s important to read through the policy wording thoroughly.
https://www.coventrybuildingsociety.co.uk/onlineservices/login/ols_login.aspx
the mcans are not talked about in our australian media anymore
Fair enough. Without explanation your posts can be written off as incontinent rants then. 8)--))
I know insurances won't pay out if you leave the door open for burglars, I was just saying that the person responsible for the possessions taken would be the thief.
Of course Madeleine wasn't a possession, but she was taken, the person responsible for that is the person who took her.
3192 posts. Impressive! 8(0(*
awww bless ...it don't take much to make you happy...sweetie
just a little tip though ...people have choices...
some choose to support the mccs ...
some choose not too
but however you dress this up ...how ever you like to think of it
it was the mccs.....who left the door wide open to opportunity ..open to the aliments..
[depending on what you believe]
in a foreign country they left there children open to the numerous dangers of what could happen ...and it did.
they are to blame for that ...
If someone steals your possessions the fault is theirs. If you make it easy for them the insurance company may punish you for your carelessness. They don't 'blame' you for the theft, but they do 'blame' you for your lack of care.
The thing is I support the McCann's in their search for Madeleine, I wouldn't have left my children alone to go out and I think the McCann's were idiotic to do so, I also know that they are devastated by the loss of their child and would do anything to get her back. As they said they wish they could put the clock back but they can't, they love and miss Madeleine and want her back.
To not support the McCann's in their search for Madeleine because they left them alone is punishing Madeleine in my eyes.
The Portuguese investigated the McCann's for leaving the children their conclusion was that there was no intent, in other words they didn't want any harm to be fall the children, they could not foresee some one coming in and taking one of their children, and so they do not put the blame on the parents.
They deliberately left their children.
Obviously they didn't want to place their children in danger, but the behaviour was repeated, and doing what they did in had been in this country, there would have been repercussions. Cases of parents leaving children, and facing charges and/or with a criminal record are in the newspapers.
like i said its down to choice ....OK
They were visited by Social Services in this country Stephen.
It certainly is and if you choose not to support the McCann's in their search for their daughter then it is up to you.
I am aware of that.
Since when social services broadcast their report.
I was referring to the police.
There is little doubt that they would have taken action if the mccanns had done what they did in the UK.
http://metro.co.uk/2007/09/09/social-services-and-police-probe-mccanns-111375/
ye it is .....do you want me to thank you for your approval as well lol
you see what you don't get though is .....IMO ...i don't believe maddie will ever be found ..[alive anyway]
i have no sympathy empathy ...or what ever you want to call it ....with the mccs whatsoever ...
whatever others think or have said ..... police statements ...etc etc
never mind if they could turn the clock back ....they should be responsible for there choice there actions
i believe the mccs are responsible ....the actions of the mccs ....are to blame for maddies fate...
What happened occurred in Portugal, therefore outside the UK police jurisdiction.
Now if they had done what they did in the UK...........
They could still have taken the twins away from them.
Why would I want you to thank me for my approval?
It is more likely Madeleine is dead, you don't need to be a rocket scientist to work that one out, but until she is found there is hope that she is still alive.
As I have said you can think what you like, but don't put people down who wish to support the McCann's in their search for Madeleine, that is also our choice.
good job I'm not a rocket scientist then
i think you will find you started this not me ......................lecturing and spouting how we should all feel sorry and support the mcss....at least you realise we have choices........the mccs had a choice
the difference is only......................i support maddie.......who had no choice......
Children are only removed from a family as a last resort by social services, and as you find in the newspapers, sometimes too late.
Though I don't apply the latter in this case.
Yes I do know that Stephen, what you said was the police should have investigated them and I give a link to show you that they did.
I am aware of that.
Since when social services broadcast their report.
I was referring to the police.
There is little doubt that they would have taken action if the mccanns had done what they did in the UK.
Where do I say you have to feel sorry and support the McCann's? I said no such thing. I said the McCann's know they left the children and for that decision they are suffering , it is the guilt of leaving Madeleine alone that they will have for life, and you repeating that they shouldn't have left the children is not going to change anything.
I don't agree that they left the children alone, yet I support the McCann's in their search for Madeleine, which will benefit Madeleine who as you have said had no choice in the matter.
The thing is I support the McCann's in their search for Madeleine, I wouldn't have left my children alone to go out and I think the McCann's were idiotic to do so, I also know that they are devastated by the loss of their child and would do anything to get her back. As they said they wish they could put the clock back but they can't, they love and miss Madeleine and want her back.
To not support the McCann's in their search for Madeleine because they left them alone is punishing Madeleine in my eyes.
Do you think that if the McCann's had said "we were idiotic to leave them", it would have reduced the criticism?I don't think if the McCanns crawled on their hands and knees in sackcloth and ashes from PdL to Rothley that it would have reduced the criticism, frankly.
Do you think that if the McCann's had said "we were idiotic to leave them", it would have reduced the criticism?
Did you actually read the final statement by the Portuguese when investigating the McCann's leaving the children alone? There was no INTENT they did not want or for see any harm coming to their children.
The person responsible is the person who took her from her bed.
If you left your door open to your house and all your possessions were taken, even though you left your door open the person responsible for the loss of your possessions is the person who took them the thief not you.
And if you drove after drinking alcohol, not thinking you were over the limit and killed someone you would still be prosecuted.
Do I have to say yet again that I did this? And with never a thought that one of my children would be abducted. I made every reasonably prevision for their safety while I was away for half an hour.
The McCanns are not alone in this, and I cannot castigate them for what I did myself.
Bully for all of you who never did this.
The McCann's didn't kill anyone. Amaral could have though drinking with his children in his car, did they investigate him?
Firstly I didn't say the McCanns killed anyone.
Secondly, as in this country, if Amaral was caught behind the wheel of a car and found to be over the legal alcohol limit then he would have been banned. It is not enough for someone to afterwards claim it happened.
The supporters club, as we have seen, will say anything to attack Amaral.
IIRC it was his own wife Sofia who 'attacked' him re drinking and driving in her letter to his boss asking for his help. Also IIRC receipt of her letter of complaint was recorded by the PJ. i.e. time and date of when she delivered it to the police station. From memory so am happy to be corrected if necessary.
The vast majority of the uninformed public in the UK, both uninformed and spoon fed by the British media, have no idea of the details of this case, so the question is rather moot ...if it had been reported for instance, that the Drs Mccann had left their children five nights in a row (a fact that Clarence Mitchell tried to hide as heard in his interview with Jon Gaunt), that they had left the back door open, or even that they on top of this, had told complete strangers (for some reason) that they did this...the view of the GBP might be, to a reasonable person, exactly the opposite! So, lets not kid ourselves.
I think the british public do understand the facts of the case but they have enough sense not to believe the lies that were told by the Portuguese press and published by the UK press...with SY on the case the papers are now being forced to report the truth
It would seem that the British public do understand that the abduction scenario does not hold water and that millions of pounds have been wasted.do you have any evidence to support this... I simply don't see it...
They also question why other missing children receive very little attention.
It would seem that the British public do understand that the abduction scenario does not hold water and that millions of pounds have been wasted.
They also question why other missing children receive very little attention.
Which other missing children, specifically - stranger abduction, parental abduction or runaways?
Irrelevant.
A missing child is a missing child.
A child can be missing from a home for many reasons. In the case of parental abduction, the child may be abroad & untraceable, or not legally extradited from their new abode.
What do you think the police should be doing, at extra cost, to find more missing children? Do you believe more families should petition the police/Government for the same level of support as the McCanns?
Irrelevant.
A missing child is a missing child.
Why do you apparently believe Madeleine McCann is more important than any other missing child.
It is already very apparent that the current investigation into her disappearance has reached a dead end.
if you don't understand why 11 miil has been spent on maddie......then it really isn't worth trying to explain
Nothing has been achieved.
I would disagree and further say we do not know what progress been made
Madeleine hasn't been found, or the reason for her disappearance.
FACT.
The vast majority of the uninformed public in the UK, both uninformed and spoon fed by the British media, have no idea of the details of this case, so the question is rather moot ...if it had been reported for instance, that the Drs Mccann had left their children five nights in a row (a fact that Clarence Mitchell tried to hide as heard in his interview with Jon Gaunt), that they had left the back door open, or even that they on top of this, had told complete strangers (for some reason) that they did this...the view of the GBP might be, to a reasonable person, exactly the opposite! So, lets not kid ourselves.
Maybe one of the Drs Mccann apologisers on here can post the totally innocent explanation for them telling strangers they left their kids alone.....!
I predict a deathly silence here excepting the usual barps and burls that dont answer the question
No takers, what a surprise.....i really want to hear the mitchellesque excuse for this behaviour..surely there just be at least one mccann supporter that can come up with one? Brietta? Benice? One who always has an answer for everything? Maybe even Ferryman.....
No takers, what a surprise.....i really want to hear the mitchellesque excuse for this behaviour..surely there just be at least one mccann supporter that can come up with one? Brietta? Benice? One who always has an answer for everything? Maybe even Ferryman.....
I don't see the point as all this has been discussed a trillion times before. Some people are horrified at what the McCanns did and totally blame them for what happened to Madeleine, and some people - like me - can understand how they were lulled into a false of security which resulted in their making a massive error of judgement. It's obvious after 8 years that these differing opinions are not going to change.
Even if I thought the McCanns were totally responsible for their daughter's disappearance by leaving her - I wouldn't be objecting to the police trying to find out what happened to her - as IMO that would be punishing the child for the parents actions. However - I do get the impression that those people who do hold the parents 100% responsible- resent anything and everything that is being done by the police to find her - simply because they blame the parents. I don't understand that mindset.
There is little doubt in my mind that Madeleine McCann is collateral damage in the vicious campaign waged against her parents. It is an attitude I do not understand and deplore.
The controversy is mainly confined to this very small corner of the internet where some have developed an overblown sense of self importance. On the odd occasion when it does spill over into MSM normal people are appalled and horrified at the shenanigans for a short period ... before returning to their everyday lives.
I think there are very few in the real world who would give a moment of their time to denigrate the parents of a missing child or to actively pursue activities designed to question and ultimately curtail the police investigation into her disappearance.
There is little doubt in my mind that Madeleine McCann is collateral damage in the vicious campaign waged against her parents. It is an attitude I do not understand and deplore.
The controversy is mainly confined to this very small corner of the internet where some have developed an overblown sense of self importance. On the odd occasion when it does spill over into MSM normal people are appalled and horrified at the shenanigans for a short period ... before returning to their everyday lives.
I think there are very few in the real world who would give a moment of their time to denigrate the parents of a missing child or to actively pursue activities designed to question and ultimately curtail the police investigation into her disappearance.
I don't see the point as all this has been discussed a trillion times before. Some people are horrified at what the McCanns did and totally blame them for what happened to Madeleine, and some people - like me - can understand how they were lulled into a false of security which resulted in their making a massive error of judgement. It's obvious after 8 years that these differing opinions are not going to change.
Even if I thought the McCanns were totally responsible for their daughter's disappearance by leaving her - I wouldn't be objecting to the police trying to find out what happened to her - as IMO that would be punishing the child for the parents actions. However - I do get the impression that those people who do hold the parents 100% responsible- resent anything and everything that is being done by the police to find her - simply because they blame the parents. I don't understand that mindset.
I don't see resentment I see frustration. Some think the police are looking in the wrong direction.
you are assuming SY have not already looked at the McCanns
I'm not assuming anything, are you?
Well they failed dismally at that so why worry.
Why worry indeed. Although I think there may well be cause for those directing spite at the campaign on behalf of a missing child to examine their consciences.
Here we go again.
Propaganda mccann supporter style, by the book.
There is no campaign against Madeleine.
You have to accept, though i doubt you will, that many people can clearly see that Madeleine will not be found alive.
It's not being nasty, it's being in the real world.
8 and a half years, and not one sign of her, or the fate that befell her.
There is no accusation of a campaign against Maddie
Read the post again
I don't see resentment I see frustration. Some think the police are looking in the wrong direction.
I don't see resentment I see frustration. Some think the police are looking in the wrong direction.Why do these frustrated people believe that they know better than the police who have all the information at their disposal, unlike the frustrated ones who only have parts of the jigsaw?
Why do these frustrated people believe that they know better than the police who have all the information at their disposal, unlike the frustrated ones who only have parts of the jigsaw?Just so I know, do you approve of OG spending whatever, to dig up a central location in Luz?
Just so I know, do you approve of OG spending whatever, to dig up a central location in Luz?
I don't see the point as all this has been discussed a trillion times before. Some people are horrified at what the McCanns did and totally blame them for what happened to Madeleine, and some people - like me - can understand how they were lulled into a false of security which resulted in their making a massive error of judgement. It's obvious after 8 years that these differing opinions are not going to change.
Even if I thought the McCanns were totally responsible for their daughter's disappearance by leaving her - I wouldn't be objecting to the police trying to find out what happened to her - as IMO that would be punishing the child for the parents actions. However - I do get the impression that those people who do hold the parents 100% responsible- resent anything and everything that is being done by the police to find her - simply because they blame the parents. I don't understand that mindset.
Benice, sometimes you talk alot and dont say too much, ie dont answer the point in question, which WAS, why would you leave your kids alone (mistake 1) , and in an insecure apartment (mistake 2) AND tell STRANGERS you were doing so.....? (Mistake 3) when we are told by GM that KM was "overprotective", cant you see the insane dichotomy? Or does it make perfect SENSE to you?
My other point was that IF the GBP knew all these details (which they do not) they might not be as supportive
Just so I know, do you approve of OG spending whatever, to dig up a central location in Luz?
Benice, sometimes you talk alot and dont say too much, ie dont answer the point in question, which WAS, why would you leave your kids alone (mistake 1) , and in an insecure apartment (mistake 2) AND tell STRANGERS you were doing so.....? (Mistake 3) when we are told by GM that KM was "overprotective", cant you see the insane dichotomy? Or does it make perfect SENSE to you?
My other point was that IF the GBP knew all these details (which they do not) they might not be as supportive
I answered your post mercury. IMO the McCanns were lulled into a false of security - and that influenced the decisions they made regarding childcare. Full stop. What is the point of dissecting it and of going over and over it - year in year out - what are you hoping to prove? They did what they did - and bitterly regret it and will carry the guilt for what they did for the rest of their lives. What more is there to say?
The only other comments I would make re your post are that' hindsight is a wonderful thing' and 'it's easy to be wise after the event'. I think those 'sayings apply in this case. Obviously you don't so we shall have to agree to disagree.
IMO the majority of the GBP believe that Madeleine was abducted - even those who completely disagree with their childcare arrangements.
IMO the no. of people who donated to Amaral's fund is a good pointer to how many people are against the McCanns. IIRC that's around 2000. Even if you treble that number - it's still a tiny proportion of the general public.
'lulled into a false sense of security' ?
What piffle.
The 'majority of the GBP believe that Madeleine was abducted'
Two classic myths for a Sunday morning.
Priceless. %£5&% %£5&%
P.S. You will find a lot of the GBP are fed up with this case in the headlines.
Unless you can prove that I am posting myths - I suggest you remove that abusive comment.
It is up to you to prove your statements.
So let's have some factual cites from you to back up your case.
...and I was not being abusive.
I merely gave my opinion of your post, as you do mine.
'lulled into a false sense of security' ?
What piffle.
The 'majority of the GBP believe that Madeleine was abducted'
Two classic myths for a Sunday morning.
Priceless. %£5&% %£5&%
P.S. You will find a lot of the GBP are fed up with this case in the headlines.
do you have a cite for this
So from now on...everything has to be backed up by cites...fine by me
It is up to you to prove your statements.
So let's have some factual cites from you to back up your case.
...and I was not being abusive.
I merely gave my opinion of your post, as you do mine.
Easy.
Daily Mail comments pages.
My opinions are clearly stated as my opinions. You are claiming that I have posted myths as if it was a proven fact. So either produce the evidence for that 'fact' or kindly remove your offensive comment.
My opinions are clearly stated as my opinions. You are claiming that I have posted myths as if it was a proven fact. So either produce the evidence for that 'fact' or kindly remove your offensive comment.
there may be comments on the case from a tiny...tiny part of the GBP...how many of these are saying they are fed up with this case being in the headlines...that was your claim...do you have a cite
Easy.
Daily Mail comments pages.
a cite needs to be a link or statement that supports your claim.....do you have one showing the GBP think as you have claimed...it seem you do not
They represent a sufficient sample size.
More than sufficient.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3293516/Police-hunt-Madeleine-McCann-scaled-investigating-60-suspects-nearly-9-000-sightings-missing-girl.html
Now have a read.
and don't bother saying it is skeptics spamming the Mail. That won't wash, as the comments have to be accepted first.
That is an article and comments discussing the police expenditure...nothing about being fed up with the McCanns being in the headlines...
You have criticised Benice...but cannot provide a cite yourself
Not a chance.
Your singular aim is to try to imply the mccanns hold no responsibility for what happened, AND THEY DO.
and if you wish to report me to the Mods, do so.
I will then treat any of your posts to me, to see if they can be viewed as personal attacks.
I would rather avoid playing these childish games Benice, and I hope you will too.
Now read the pages dave.
e.g. ' Philip1826, Doncaster, United Kingdom, 1 month ago
My god, I'm sick of these people. Enough is enough and reduce the police to ZERO '
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3293516/Police-hunt-Madeleine-McCann-scaled-investigating-60-suspects-nearly-9-000-sightings-missing-girl.html#ixzz3ur9sfplY
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook
I don't play childish games, but I do object to being accused of posting myths when no evidence whatsoever to support that allegation is provided.
You accusation that my ' singular aim is to imply that the McCanns hold no responsibility for what happened' - posted by you as a fact and not as an opinion - is also completely untrue.
Read again.
There are a plethora of articles and comments relating to peoples opinions on the mccanns , as you well know.
Well try to explain to me why most of the GBP would believe Madeleine was abducted.
yes plenty of commnets re the mccanns...but not one re headlines...
you have failed to provide a cite
Any headline mentioning the McCanns results in sales of newspapers...the editors are not stupid....doesnt that prove the GBP want to read about the mccanns....making stephens statement...which he cannot provide a cite for...false
'lulled into a false sense of security' ?
What piffle.
The 'majority of the GBP believe that Madeleine was abducted'
Two classic myths for a Sunday morning.
Priceless. %£5&% %£5&%
P.S. You will find a lot of the GBP are fed up with this case in the headlines.
You mean in the Tabloids alongside a whole list of z-list 'celebrities' ?
Well try to explain to me why most of the GBP would believe Madeleine was abducted.
Now read the pages dave.
e.g. ' Philip1826, Doncaster, United Kingdom, 1 month ago
My god, I'm sick of these people. Enough is enough and reduce the police to ZERO '
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3293516/Police-hunt-Madeleine-McCann-scaled-investigating-60-suspects-nearly-9-000-sightings-missing-girl.html#ixzz3ur9sfplY
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook
My statement was my opinion based on my own experience and was not claimed to be a fact. Your accusation that I had posted myths i.e. lies - was posted by you as a fact - and therefore you do need to provide evidence of that. So where is it?
I don't know why people who say they are sick of the McCann's bother to read any article about them or make a comment. Quite bizarre unless of course it is someone who is anti McCann and just wants to make out the population is sick of hearing about the McCann's which is rubbish as the sales of newspapers rocket when there is a story about them, why do you think the papers print stories about the the McCann's Stephen?
Your indignant reply is noted.
Try reading my replies to dave, as regards that.
The Mail comments column, as it is selective and not over run by sceptics, represents a fair sample, as regards the opinions of the public.
I am quite happy for the guests who read this forum to judge for themselves what is true or false, and of course read from the official files.
I don't know why people who say they are sick of the McCann's bother to read any article about them or make a comment. Quite bizarre unless of course it is someone who is anti McCann and just wants to make out the population is sick of hearing about the McCann's which is rubbish as the sales of newspapers rocket when there is a story about them, why do you think the papers print stories about the the McCann's Stephen?
The tabloids will print any old rubbish if they think it will sell papers.
My irritation levels rise when its the same old stuff regurgitated time and time again as if its new.
your cite did not support your claim....it looks more like the GBP like to read and comment on articles re the McCANNS...IMO
So what percentage of the comments support the mccanns on the link I gave earlier ?
Why do they prints stories about other people in the public eye ?
Merely Because these stories are printed does mean the people in the articles are popular.
The tabloids will print any old rubbish if they think it will sell papers.
My irritation levels rise when its the same old stuff regurgitated time and time again as if its new.
I wouldn't bother to read anything about someone I wasn't interested in would you?
Your indignant reply is noted.
Try reading my replies to dave, as regards that.
The Mail comments column, as it is selective and not over run by sceptics, represents a fair sample, as regards the opinions of the public.
I am quite happy for the guests who read this forum to judge for themselves what is true or false, and of course read from the official files.
As you are well aware Lace, I am talking about what support there is for the mccanns.........
I wouldn't bother to read anything about someone I wasn't interested in would you?
Sorry Stephen but I really don't regard the Mail as a fair example at all. I have seen the shouts of 'the Mail is allowing comments' on the anti forums and they all rush to comment and come back laughing about what they wrote. Some saying 'don't know if they'll publish mine' as if that is something to be proud of.
I have never commented on the The Mail and never will.
All it proves IMO is that the same people are repeatedly posting the same comments. That's not a true representation of the GPB but is more a representation of how fanatical a small group of people are IMO.
There's a difference between interest in a person and liking them. I think people are still interested in Madeleine's story however I don't think the McCanns are well liked as individuals if newspaper comments and social media are any kind of yardstick.
I have come to judge the comments in the newspapers I can tell if they are the extreme anti McCann supporters by what they say. The general public usually say something such as 'I wouldn't have left my children alone, but I hope Madeleine will be found safe'.
You only go by the comments the anti McCann's make, the same ones who bombarded the Summers and Swan book reviews.
Why is it so important for the supporters that the McCanns are liked by the GBP ?
fanatics being the right word
I have come to judge the comments in the newspapers I can tell if they are the extreme anti McCann supporters by what they say. The general public usually say something such as 'I wouldn't have left my children alone, but I hope Madeleine will be found safe'.
You only go by the comments the anti McCann's make, the same ones who bombarded the Summers and Swan book reviews.
Maybe you should read the comments on the Official Find Madeleine Facebook page, which have thousands of likes.
There's a difference between interest in a person and liking them. I think people are still interested in Madeleine's story however I don't think the McCanns are well liked as individuals if newspaper comments and social media are any kind of yardstick.There are a lot of people on social media and celeb goss websites who love to hate. They enjoy reading about celebs and people in the news that annoy them and that they actively dislike and the internet provides them with the perfect opportunity to vent their spleen in the most vitriolic way possible, an opportunity that they rarely get in real life. When Jade Goody was dying she was the subject of the most appalling comments on news websites and social media, just reading them would lead you to believe she was the most reviled woman in Britain at the time of her death, but I think these comments tell us more about the writers than the object of their hatred. I was not an admirer of the woman but it would never enter my head to criticise her and bitch about her whilst she lay on her death bed but many many ordinary people did just that.
What are people who doubt the McCanns if not the general public ?
There are a lot of people on social media and celeb goss websites who love to hate. They enjoy reading about celebs and people in the news that annoy them and that they actively dislike and the internet provides them with the perfect opportunity to vent their spleen in the most vitriolic way possible, an opportunity that they rarely get in real life. When Jade Goody was dying she was the subject of the most appalling comments on news websites and social media, just reading them would lead you to believe she was the most reviled woman in Britain at the time of her death, but I think these comments tell us more about the writers than the object of their hatred. I was not an admirer of the woman but it would never enter my head to criticise her and bitch about her whilst she lay on her death bed but many many ordinary people did just that.
I obviously don't read the same websites as you Alfie as I saw nothing but praise for Jade Goody's bravery during her final month even though she'd had a less than harmonious relationship with both the press and the general public in the past.I found this link in a few seconds of googling to illustrate what I'm talking about - this is but the tip of the iceberg
Fascinating. And this relates to the topic under discussion in what way?
Fascinating. And this relates to the topic under discussion in what way?That comments left on the internet on the subject of well-known individuals and their misfortunes or successes do not necessarily represent the majority held view.
As per usual, the mccann supporters try to drag in other people to aid their cause.Why did so many people appear to hate her so much then?
The mccanns problems were self inflicted. Jade Goody's weren't, and she helped a lot of women become more aware of the threat of cancer before she died.
That comments left on the internet on the subject of well-known individuals and their misfortunes or successes do not necessarily represent the majority held view.
That comments left on the internet on the subject of well-known individuals and their misfortunes or successes do not necessarily represent the majority held view.
She was well known?
I had to Google just to find out who she was - a nonentity
No, she wasn't. More shame on you.
Yes she was well-known enough to have been front page tabloid fodder for years, a bit like the McCanns in that respect.
She was well known?
I had to Google just to find out who she was - a nonentity
Of course she was. She had absolutely no impact on the lives of countless millions, possibly billions of peopleSo the McCanns are not well known then, nor (for example) is Kate Middleton.
Of course she was. She had absolutely no impact on the lives of countless millions, possibly billions of people
Few can probably claim to know them.Totally irrelevant. They are all "well known", even if you've never heard of them! Jade Goody was (for example) the most mourned celebrity in Britain in 2009, receiving more tributes and condolences than Michael Jackson who died in the same year, according to the Independent newspaper. The point is, Incan reproduce here hundreds of hateful comments about her and her death which would leave you with the certain impression that she was universally hated. It's no different to online comments about the McCanns - what goes on on the net does not necessarily represent the majority view.
Totally irrelevant. They are all "well known", even if you've never heard of them! Jade Goody was (for example) the most mourned celebrity in Britain in 2009, receiving more tributes and condolences than Michael Jackson who died in the same year, according to the Independent newspaper. The point is, Incan reproduce here hundreds of hateful comments about her and her death which would leave you with the certain impression that she was universally hated. It's no different to online comments about the McCanns - what goes on on the net does not necessarily represent the majority view.
And I am now feeling gutted for you.
Hmmm, I don't think Jade Goodie is an ideal example of celebrity.
i thought you didn't like speaking ill of the dead
Hmmm, I don't think Jade Goodie is an ideal example of celebrity.Why not? She was a celebrity, and the most mourned one of 2009. What is not ideal about her?
Of course she was. She had absolutely no impact on the lives of countless millions, possibly billions of people
Unlike the McCanns whose irresponsibility has cost the taxpayers millions.Their irresponsibility or their criminal doctor activities? Make up your mind dear lady!
Their irresponsibility or their criminal doctor activities? Make up your mind dear lady!
Madeleine met her end because her parents weren't there to make sure she was safe. They were irresponsible. Everything else stems from that.It's one thing to be irresponsible, and quite another to be irresponsible and then commit a criminal act to cover your tracks. According to you this is what the McCanns have done and hence it is not irresponsibility that has cost the tax payers millions but a cover up and a conspiracy, according to you.
It's one thing to be irresponsible, and quite another to be irresponsible and then commit a criminal act to cover your tracks. According to you this is what the McCanns have done and hence it is not irresponsibility that has cost the tax payers millions but a cover up and a conspiracy, according to you.
But it all stems from the McCann's irresponsibility. I think we both agree on that at least.
What about all the fat people who smoke and drink...they are irresponsible and costing us a fortune
The taxes on tobacco and alcohol help fund the N.H.S.
what about the fat ones...no tax on food...they've all got type 2 diabetes
Clearing up the vandalism caused by irresponsible graffiti 'artists' costs the tax payer £1 billion per year.
Is that a £1 billion in the UK ?
and how can that be stopped ?
However, keeping your children safe and locking the doors at the same time. doesn't cost much, does it ?
Click here: Graffiti | Graffiti | Southwark Council
What is graffiti and why is it a problem?
'Graffiti' refers to any drawings, scribbles, messages or 'tags' that are painted, written or carved on walls and other surfaces.
Graffiti is vandalism and it's become a really expensive problem. Removing graffiti costs the UK over £1 billion a year. We and other agencies have to remove graffiti from walls, street furniture, telephone boxes, bus shelters, monuments and even gravestones.
Graffiti is:
Illegal - and clearing it up costs tax payer's money
Unsightly - graffiti is a sign of a neglected neighbourhood and is associated with increased levels of crime and the fear of crime. It also discourages investment and new businesses from moving into the area.
END QUOTE
So what is the cure ?
Since graffiti has been present all the way through human history.
I think if there were less poor people there would be less graffiti as its their children who cause it...
Another mistake.
Graffiti is produced from all sections of society.
who do you blame for the graffiti in PDL....the graffiti-ist...the mccanns or the abductor
I wasn't talking about PDL.
Quite frankly, if the Portuguese have had it up to here with the mccanns, one can hardly blame them'
The mccanns and no one else are responsible for not looking after their children.
As to the abductor, would you care to cite evidence that one ever existed ?
Madeleine met her end because her parents weren't there to make sure she was safe. They were irresponsible. Everything else stems from that.
I wasn't talking about PDL.
Quite frankly, if the Portuguese have had it up to here with the mccanns, one can hardly blame them'
The mccanns and no one else are responsible for not looking after their children.
As to the abductor, would you care to cite evidence that one ever existed ?
I think if there were less poor people there would be less graffiti as its their children who cause it...
You don't believe in abduction I do the person who took her is responsible for Madeleine's disappearance.
Thank god the police don't have your attitude, the child who was abducted from her bath whilst her parent left her to go to another room wouldn't be searched for, the child left out to play at night, the child left in a tent all wouldn't be searched for would they?
You should really amend that statement.
YOU do not know an abduction took place, it is merely your belief.
The original police found nothing to show abduction, and the current investigation has not gone any further either.
Also, the investigation should have examined all possibilities, NOT ONE.
You don't believe in abduction I do the person who took her is responsible for Madeleine's disappearance.
Thank god the police don't have your attitude, the child who was abducted from her bath whilst her parent left her to go to another room wouldn't be searched for, the child left out to play at night, the child left in a tent all wouldn't be searched for would they?
Unlike the McCanns whose irresponsibility has cost the taxpayers millions.
I'm a tax payer and so is my husband, we don't begrudge one penny of what has been spent on the search for Madeleine, as unlike you, we believe a child should be searched for, whether it costs millions or not. Even if they don't find her at least the McCann's know that the police did everything they could and good for them.Makes you wonder what PIs can do?
By the way, in my opinion the person who took her is to blame not the McCann's, it comes to something when you can't leave your child asleep in bed without some slime ball coming in and taking her.
Before you say 'but they left them alone' the children who were abused in their beds had their parents sleeping in the next room, he could have taken one of them. In my opinion an abductor could have taken Madeleine when the McCann's were there asleep, he could have come in through the front door and taken her.
I
Think of the money that could be saved if we reconstructed the criminal justice system to take account of the perceived culpability of the victim and didn't even give a passing thought to the perpetrator.
I thought gone were the days when a rape victims underwear could be produced in court to excuse the rapist who must have had x-ray vision to see it through the rest of her clothing ... http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-129105/Rape-girl-driven-suicide-ordeal-court.html ...
The majority of reasonably minded people tend to sympathise with the victim of a crime and are probably quite perplexed that there exists a hard core of denial of a perpetrator who entered the McCann apartment.
Many of whom were/are in denial of documented burglaries.
Many of whom were/are in denial of sexual assaults on British children while their parents were present in the properties.
Many of whom were/are in denial of many independent witness statements documenting activities by persons never traced.
I think it is time it was realised what a small rump is represented by those upholding those prejudices while the bigger picture is seen by people supporting Madeleine's family and who would be overjoyed if they achieve their aim of finding what happened to her ... particularly if she is recovered alive.
I'm a tax payer and so is my husband, we don't begrudge one penny of what has been spent on the search for Madeleine, as unlike you, we believe a child should be searched for, whether it costs millions or not. Even if they don't find her at least the McCann's know that the police did everything they could and good for them.
By the way, the person who took her is to blame not the McCann's, it comes to something when you can't leave your child asleep in bed without some slime ball coming in and taking her.
Before you say 'but they left them alone' the children who were abused in their beds had their parents sleeping in the next room, he could have taken one of them. An abductor could have taken Madeleine when the McCann's were there asleep, he could have come in through the front door and taken her.
I
There again;
And far from being a radical tearaway from an inner-city council estate, the man we have identified as Banksy is, perhaps all too predictably, a former public schoolboy brought up in middle-class suburbia.
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-1034538/Graffiti-artist-Banksy-unmasked---public-schoolboy-middle-class-suburbia.html#ixzz3uxLzUifX
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook
Who's banksy
Couldn't be any good as I've never heard of him
He is well known.
He is worth millions from his work.
Did he put a cow in a fish tank
Is that the one
Did he put a cow in a fish tank
Is that the one
Did he put a cow in a fish tank
Is that the one
Rightly, we don't know a great deal about these assaults on children by an intruder. Except that they covered a period before 2007 and a period afterwards. Random attacks of this nature are very difficult to solve ... for example Delroy Grant who targeted elderly women.
One wonders how much of an effort was made to see if there were any obvious links suggesting a single serial perp who targeted children prior to the Scotland Yard investigation looking at it ... if only British children were the victims that would be a rather obvious starting point.
I repeat, would posters please add the prefix "in my opinion" when asserting opinions on the investigation which remain unverified and uncorroborated. This is accepted convention and should be followed.
I also strongly suggest previous posts are edited accordingly otherwise they run the risk of deletion in the next edit sweep.
...all my posts are my opinion is in my avatar ...i don't know how it ended up there it should have been at the bottom of all my post
Sorted.
Makes you wonder what PIs can do?
Maybe they are hoping the next new lot, (unless they reemploy some of the ones they have already used because they will be au fait with the case details) will get some lucky fluke break? One that several agencies before, three police forces, one of them being said to be the finest in the world, and an odd assortment of various other individuals, all amounting to several millions in money and several years in work,not to mention an unprecedented and sustained worldwide media blast, havent managed to do yet? Maybe before they rush in to appoint the next "crack team" they should do a review of the reviews and investigations to date, because "part of 750k" is not going to go very far if history is anything to go by.....
I'm wondering 'if there are still unanswered questions' aren't SY being remiss by not looking into those questions ? Are the McCanns really so arrogant that they think they know better than seasoned professionals how to conduct an investigation ?
I'm wondering 'if there are still unanswered questions' aren't SY being remiss by not looking into those questions ? Are the McCanns really so arrogant that they think they know better than seasoned professionals how to conduct an investigation ?
No, they know how to employ others. If there are unanswered questions they'd better let OG know pdq so they can look at them before they give up.
I'm wondering 'if there are still unanswered questions' aren't SY being remiss by not looking into those questions ? Are the McCanns really so arrogant that they think they know better than seasoned professionals how to conduct an investigation ?
How are the McCann's being arrogant for wanting to continue the search for their child? Many parents have continued way after an investigation has ended. Who are we to say they shouldn't carry on? They don't want to give up on their daughter, it's understandable.
They are not saying they can do better, by the sound of it they are very grateful for what SY have done, stop trying to show them up as parents who are arrogant and think they know better, when all they are are parents of a missing child who want her back.
Arrogant, yes.
One only has to recall gerry mccanns infamous smirk when commenting on the dogs to Sandra Felgeiras.
He was being sarcastic. That's not being arrogant.
It was extremely arrogant, but par for the course with gerry mccann.
IMO of course.
He also said dogs are unreliable.
Perhaps he should then explain why police forces, customs officers, et al, use them around the world.
ABDUCTED
Her badly-decomposed body was later found buried in a makeshift riverbank grave less than 50 yards from Hamilton's home. [Note: Attracta Harron's body was found by Eddie].
Mrs Harron's clothes, bank documents and prayer book were burnt on a bonfire at his house as part of his attempted cover-up. [Note: Eddie found traces of Attracta in Hamilton's burned out car, DNA tests confirmed identity.]
http://eddieandkeela.blogspot.co.uk/2011/12/warder-offends-attracta-killer.html
It was extremely arrogant, but par for the course with gerry mccann.
IMO of course.
He also said dogs are unreliable.
Perhaps he should then explain why police forces, customs officers, et al, use them around the world.
They are unreliable, they have been proved to give false alerts, that is why Grime covered himself by saying forensic evidence needed to back up the alerts, they didn't.
That is not a logical answer.
Dogs are extremely reliable in a variety of fields.
I believe he said 'they are incredibly unreliable'.
By the way, I just replayed the interview where he said that.
The forensics were inconclusive.
Please stick to the facts.
forensics inconclusive...therefore the alerts inconclusive...so useless ..those are the facts...lets stick to them
forensics inconclusive...therefore the alerts inconclusive...so useless ..those are the facts...lets stick to them
By what device or mechanism were materials, sent for forensic analysis located ?
totally meaningless
That is a rather silly response to a perfectly straightforward question.it does not matter how they were located...if the alerts are not confirmed they are meaningless...far from a silly answer...more a silly question...a question you already have your own answer to so why ask me
I conclude from your response you are either incapable of answering or choose not to.
By what device or mechanism were materials, sent for forensic analysis located ?