UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Eleanor on March 30, 2016, 12:44:41 PM

Title: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Eleanor on March 30, 2016, 12:44:41 PM

Madeleine might still vaguely remember who she was.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: John on March 30, 2016, 12:51:21 PM
Madeleine might still vaguely remember who she was.

She would probably have memories but be unable to assimilate them into anything meaningful.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Eleanor on March 30, 2016, 12:59:27 PM
She would probably have memories but be unable to assimilate them into anything meaningful.

Yet.  But as she gets older she might.  Especially if she remembers her name.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: jassi on March 30, 2016, 01:04:25 PM
I think the opposite more likely - as she gets older (if she does) then earlier memories will fade, particularly if effort is made to imprint new (false) memories.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: John on March 30, 2016, 06:25:40 PM
I think the opposite more likely - as she gets older (if she does) then earlier memories will fade, particularly if effort is made to imprint new (false) memories.

Stressful or alarming/exciting events are usually imprinted on a child's memory in the form of images.  I can recall one or two of events in my own life experience going back to when I was a mere babe.  Everyone experiences different things and no two memories are ever the same when experienced by different people.  If Madeleine is still alive she could very well remember her alarm at finding strangers looking after her.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: John on April 25, 2016, 06:14:30 PM
This is a resurrected thread.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Erngath on April 25, 2016, 06:23:26 PM
Yes, she will.
As she gets older she will try to place those early memories. She was almost four. Children begin school at four and a half years old and by then there will be details of events, family happenings that will never be erased.
Perhaps difficult for her to put into context but nevertheless they will be there.
Sad to think of. x
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: stephen25000 on April 25, 2016, 06:31:07 PM
Yes, she will.
As she gets older she will try to place those early memories. She was almost four. Children begin school at four and a half years old and by then there will be details of events, family happenings that will never be erased.
Perhaps difficult for her to put into context but nevertheless they will be there.
Sad to think of. x

What makes you think she will be found Erngath ?
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on April 25, 2016, 07:40:34 PM
I can remember things from when I was 4 or earlier.  Q1  Could I remember them when I was 13?  Q2  Could I make sense of them?

A1.  I could, but only in dreams, and there were so many dreams that had nothing to do with being 4 or younger.

A2.  These memories are very vague.  I know the language we MUST have spoken, but I do not remember speaking or being spoken to.  I remember the man was my grandfather, but I cannot remember his name or my name from the dreams.

I think for it to click, it requires that Madeleine sees a specific photo or video and thinks, hang on, that was me.  I remember that.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Erngath on April 25, 2016, 07:49:42 PM
I was four and a half years old when I began school.

I have very strong memories of that day. I have always had those memories. No parents there to remind me of what was in the classroom ( parents just dropped one off in those days ) and no photographs of the day but the memories are there.
I also remember climbing into my baby sister's pram and I was three at the time.
Madeleine will have vague memories of her early childhood.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on April 25, 2016, 08:02:48 PM
I was four and a half years old when I began school.

I have very strong memories of that day. I have always had those memories. No parents there to remind me of what was in the classroom ( parents just dropped one off in those days ) and no photographs of the day but the memories are there.
I also remember climbing into my baby sister's pram and I was three at the time.
Madeleine will have vague memories of her early childhood.
The issue is, if you had spent the next 9 years living a different life, would you have anything to identify or trace your life from that?  I assume there are no photographs of either event.  So there is nothing to match your memory against.

See John earlier.  Basically you remember, but does the memory make any difference?
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Erngath on April 25, 2016, 08:08:34 PM
The issue is, if you had spent the next 9 years living a different life, would you have anything to identify or trace your life from that?  I assume there are no photographs of either event.  So there is nothing to match your memory against.

See John earlier.  Basically you remember, but does the memory make any difference?

No there are no photographs of either event.
Why would I forget the many features of that first classroom I was ever in?
My younger sister fell and was quite badly injured. I was about four when this happened. Would I not wonder where that younger sibling had gone?
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: stephen25000 on April 25, 2016, 08:32:48 PM
Your post is certainly off topic because the question on the thread certainly implies that Madeleine could be alive and could she have memories from her earlier childhood.

Why would one need to believe Madeleine is alive to "defend" the McCanns ??

This is the whole point Erngath.

Why do some believe she is alive, with the total absence of evidence to show she is ?

As to defending the mccanns, every which way they can, you merely have to observe certain posters on this forum.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: jassi on April 25, 2016, 08:37:01 PM
What Stephen said was - "What makes you think she will be found Erngath ? "

That question still remains even if she is alive.  She may still never be found.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: stephen25000 on April 25, 2016, 08:38:09 PM
What Stephen said was - "What makes you think she will be found Erngath ? "

That question still remains even if she is alive.  She may still never be found.

Thank you Jassi.

THere is an avoidance of answering that question.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Erngath on April 25, 2016, 08:42:51 PM
This is the whole point Erngath.

Why do some believe she is alive, with the total absence of evidence to show she is ?

As to defending the mccanns, every which way they can, you merely have to observe certain posters on this forum.

We are going round in circles and all totally off topic.
You have not answered my question as to why I, as a "supporter" of the McCanns  must believe she is alive?
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: stephen25000 on April 25, 2016, 08:44:08 PM
We are going round in circles and all totally off topic.
You have not answered my question as to why I, as a "supporter" of the McCanns  must believe she is alive?

I suggest you actually re-read what I said.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Erngath on April 25, 2016, 08:45:59 PM
What Stephen said was - "What makes you think she will be found Erngath ? "

That question still remains even if she is alive.  She may still never be found.

there is no doubt that she may never be found...............still off topic.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: jassi on April 25, 2016, 08:47:30 PM
there is no doubt that she may never be found...............still off topic.

Its not unlnown for topics to drift   ?{)(**
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: stephen25000 on April 25, 2016, 08:50:37 PM
there is no doubt that she may never be found...............still off topic.

Perhaps you should look at the thread title.

The presumption is there.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Erngath on April 25, 2016, 08:53:57 PM
Its not unlnown for topics to drift   ?{)(**

That is true but the heading of this thread did spark an interest for me but I have no interest in where this thread is "drifting"
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: jassi on April 25, 2016, 09:00:34 PM
That is true but the heading of this thread did spark an interest for me but I have no interest in where this thread is "drifting"


Shame, but to return to your narrow line of thought - any memories that Madeleine might have can easily be explained away by her loving 'parents', as they will have spent years implanting false memories.

This all assumes that she is living some happy existence with not a care in the world.

If she is dead, then she has no memories.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Eleanor on April 25, 2016, 09:21:18 PM

If Madeleine ever does see something to trigger her memory, and there's enough stuff out there to help, then she could well find herself.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on April 25, 2016, 09:32:49 PM
No there are no photographs of either event.
Why would I forget the many features of that first classroom I was ever in?
My younger sister fell and was quite badly injured. I was about four when this happened. Would I not wonder where that younger sibling had gone?
I can remember features of my pre-school and my first classroom.  That is because I lived in the same place with the same parents until I left for university.  Years of reinforcing the memories.

I know that my first school got flattened years ago, to be replaced by light industrial units.

I suspect my pre-school also got flattened years ago, due to its age.

Would Madeleine wonder where the twins had gone?  Quite possibly on occasion.  Then she would move on swiftly to playing or talking to her new friends.

Unless she has a memory that links her clearly to the incident, then she does not have memories that anchor her to being Madeleine.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Erngath on April 25, 2016, 09:49:50 PM

Shame, but to return to your narrow line of thought - any memories that Madeleine might have can easily be explained away by her loving 'parents', as they will have spent years implanting false memories.

This all assumes that she is living some happy existence with not a care in the world.

If she is dead, then she has no memories.

It's not my "narrow line of thought " but rather the topic of the thread.
Your last point is rather self evident.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Erngath on April 25, 2016, 09:51:27 PM
If Madeleine ever does see something to trigger her memory, and there's enough stuff out there to help, then she could well find herself.

And thanks to her parents there will be many triggers which may help her to find herself.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Eleanor on April 25, 2016, 09:53:24 PM
And thanks to her parents there will be many triggers which may help her to find herself.

All part of what The McCanns have been doing for the last nine years.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Erngath on April 25, 2016, 09:55:56 PM
I can remember features of my pre-school and my first classroom.  That is because I lived in the same place with the same parents until I left for university.  Years of reinforcing the memories.

I know that my first school got flattened years ago, to be replaced by light industrial units.

I suspect my pre-school also got flattened years ago, due to its age.

Would Madeleine wonder where the twins had gone?  Quite possibly on occasion.  Then she would move on swiftly to playing or talking to her new friends.

Unless she has a memory that links her clearly to the incident, then she does not have memories that anchor her to being Madeleine.

She was almost four. Children of that age would remember being told they have a new name, or being told they have new parents. Having taught children of four and a half/ five years old I think we can under estimate the impact of their very formative first years and the memories they may hold.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Erngath on April 25, 2016, 10:15:25 PM
All part of what The McCanns have been doing for the last nine years.

Indeed.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Brietta on April 25, 2016, 10:22:57 PM
She was almost four. Children of that age would remember being told they have a new name, or being told they have new parents. Having taught children of four and a half/ five years old I think we can under estimate the impact of their very formative first years and the memories they may hold.

I don't know how much difference a year makes but Lou Gang, who must have been a remarkable child ensured he could remember as much as he possibly could about who he was after his kidnap.

There is nothing to say that depending on the child and circumstances a similar feat of memory could not be achieved by an intelligent four year old however much it might puzzle and perplex.

I do not think that Madeleine would forget her brother and sister who she adored ... and that might be a trigger.


**snip

In 1990, at the age of five, Luo Gang was kidnapped and sold to a family in another part of China. Unable to remember his parents' names or the village they lived in, he stood little chance of ever going home. But 23 years later he did.

***   ***   ***

But when he realised there would be no reunion with his parents, Luo made the decision to start rehearsing his fading memories, determined that one day he would use them to find his way home.

So each night as he lay in bed, Luo repeated what he could remember of his life before.

How he and his brother used to play on an old stone bridge opposite their little house with a tiled roof. How he had once fallen off the bridge and hurt his back. That there were two streams outside and how they used to cross rice fields to get to school.

"I was like a computer," Luo says. "I tried to keep my memories of family and the geographical surroundings - I didn't even really know my own name."

Luo's new parents never explained why he had been taken before they died two years after his arrival. Nor did the "grandparents" who raised him after that.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-24526210
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Erngath on April 25, 2016, 10:41:25 PM
I don't know how much difference a year makes but Lou Gang, who must have been a remarkable child ensured he could remember as much as he possibly could about who he was after his kidnap.

There is nothing to say that depending on the child and circumstances a similar feat of memory could not be achieved by an intelligent four year old however much it might puzzle and perplex.

I do not think that Madeleine would forget her brother and sister who she adored ... and that might be a trigger.


**snip

In 1990, at the age of five, Luo Gang was kidnapped and sold to a family in another part of China. Unable to remember his parents' names or the village they lived in, he stood little chance of ever going home. But 23 years later he did.

***   ***   ***

But when he realised there would be no reunion with his parents, Luo made the decision to start rehearsing his fading memories, determined that one day he would use them to find his way home.

So each night as he lay in bed, Luo repeated what he could remember of his life before.

How he and his brother used to play on an old stone bridge opposite their little house with a tiled roof. How he had once fallen off the bridge and hurt his back. That there were two streams outside and how they used to cross rice fields to get to school.

"I was like a computer," Luo says. "I tried to keep my memories of family and the geographical surroundings - I didn't even really know my own name."

Luo's new parents never explained why he had been taken before they died two years after his arrival. Nor did the "grandparents" who raised him after that.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-24526210

There would be so many early memories that will stay with her and she seemed a very bright articulate little girl.
The little songs she sang, the memories of her siblings, her grand parents, little trips out, the nursery she attended etc.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on April 26, 2016, 08:55:45 PM
If Maddie is still alive and living with another family- I believe she will remember who she really is. She comes across on videos as being a lively vibrant, intelligent, confident, little girl her mum claims whoever took Maddie she would give them her tuppence worth. She was smart enough to challenger her parents for leaving them alone.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: jassi on April 26, 2016, 08:56:57 PM
If Maddie is still alive and living with another family- I believe she will remember who she really is. She comes across on videos as being a lively vibrant, intelligent, confident, little girl her mum claims whoever took Maddie she would give them her tuppence worth. She was smart enough to challenger her parents for leaving them alone.

Allegedly
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on April 26, 2016, 09:19:40 PM
Allegedly

...according to her mother. Maddie- "where were you..."
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: jassi on April 26, 2016, 09:20:46 PM
...according to her mother. Maddie- "where were you..."

Exactly - an uncorroborated story that may or may not be true.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on April 26, 2016, 09:44:55 PM
Exactly - an uncorroborated story that may or may not be true.

hmmmm Yes, but I actually believe that conversation did take place, but some of it missing for some reason. Kate did confide this to another parent so she was concerned about something. There is something Kate is not telling IMO.
A child would be smart enough to almost scold her parents for not being there, but we don't hear what the parents replied to the child to comfort her, reassure her (why is that)- we are told she said what she said and then  walked away and thought nothing more of it...hmmm No, I can't buy that. A child wakes up with her sibling crying, she goes to get her parents- they are not in the apartment and  what? she goes back to bed and falls asleep?
 What did happened that night!!!?
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: sadie on April 27, 2016, 01:06:04 AM
If Madeleine ever does see something to trigger her memory, and there's enough stuff out there to help, then she could well find herself.

IMO, she would only have to hear her dad (or her mum) say 'Madeleine' in their own chacteristic way and it would likely trigger some memories.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: stephen25000 on April 27, 2016, 08:07:27 AM
IMO, she would only have to hear her dad (or her mum) say 'Madeleine' in their own chacteristic way and it would likely trigger some memories.

So come on Sadie, let us all into the big secret, where do you think she is.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: slartibartfast on April 27, 2016, 01:09:14 PM
So come on Sadie, let us all into the big secret, where do you think she is.

We know that 2 of Sadie's sightings have already been totally discounted.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: stephen25000 on April 27, 2016, 01:11:22 PM
We know that 2 of Sadie's sightings have already been totally discounted.

Exactly Slarti.

So why does she persist in citing the same ones again and again ?
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Lace on April 27, 2016, 07:45:30 PM
It is very possible that Madeleine will have memories of her life with the McCann's,  read this story about this little boy who got lost at the age of five  -


http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-17693816
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: stephen25000 on April 27, 2016, 07:52:58 PM
It is very possible that Madeleine will have memories of her life with the McCann's,  read this story about this little boy who got lost at the age of five  -


http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-17693816

That is only applicable if she was alive.

There is no evidence to support she is.

Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Lace on April 28, 2016, 09:13:55 AM
That is only applicable if she was alive.

There is no evidence to support she is.

Stephen,  what is the title of this thread?     I was posting with regards to what this thread is about.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: stephen25000 on April 28, 2016, 09:18:23 AM
Stephen,  what is the title of this thread?     I was posting with regards to what this thread is about.

I am well aware of the title of this thread and it's intent.

Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Lace on April 28, 2016, 09:19:31 AM
I am well aware of the title of this thread and it's intent.

So why the negative reply to my post about the little boy who remembered his childhood?
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Carana on April 28, 2016, 10:50:32 AM
IMO, she would only have to hear her dad (or her mum) say 'Madeleine' in their own chacteristic way and it would likely trigger some memories.

It could be more primary memories, Sadie.

The smell of a perfume or a song, for example, or a flash mental image of something that could at least trigger some sort of questioning process.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: LagosBen on April 28, 2016, 11:58:46 AM
It could be more primary memories, Sadie.

The smell of a perfume or a song, for example, or a flash mental image of something that could at least trigger some sort of questioning process.

I agree with you.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: sadie on April 28, 2016, 01:18:46 PM
So come on Sadie, let us all into the big secret, where do you think she is.
I am pretty sure that i know where she was about four years ago,  and I am convinced that Madeleine is still alive and being looked after.

I have plenty of ideas where she is now, but I aint sharing them with you.  Soz Stephen.  None of them are likely to be places that any one on here has thought of cos they haven't done my in-depth and unusual research.  Some have done admirable and equally in-depth research, but not in the same direction and therefore will not have discovered what I have (I believe).
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: stephen25000 on April 28, 2016, 02:33:56 PM
I am pretty sure that i know where she was about four years ago,  and I am convinced that Madeleine is still alive and being looked after.

I have plenty of ideas where she is now, but I aint sharing them with you.  Soz Stephen.  None of them are likely to be places that any one on here has thought of cos they haven't done my in-depth and unusual research.  Some have done admirable and equally in-depth research, but not in the same direction and therefore will not have discovered what I have (I believe).

So we have to take your word for it.

Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Eleanor on April 28, 2016, 02:37:01 PM
So we have to take your word for it.

Sadie has opinions and ideas, Stephen, to which she is entitled.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: ChloeR on April 28, 2016, 03:47:52 PM
I really really doubt it. If there was any traumatic event or something while she was still very young she may remember that...but normal memories..unlikely. Just how the mind works
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: stephen25000 on April 28, 2016, 04:29:44 PM
Sadie has opinions and ideas, Stephen, to which she is entitled.

Yet no cites.

I thought on here we are supposed to do that when possible.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Eleanor on April 28, 2016, 04:32:25 PM
Yet no cites.

I thought on here we are supposed to do that when possible.

You can't give a Cite to an opinion or an idea.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Eleanor on April 28, 2016, 04:34:56 PM
I really really doubt it. If there was any traumatic event or something while she was still very young she may remember that...but normal memories..unlikely. Just how the mind works

She will have woken up one morning in a totally different place.  And the holiday itself may trigger a memory.  Aeroplanes and a foreign country.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Lace on April 28, 2016, 04:47:29 PM
I really really doubt it. If there was any traumatic event or something while she was still very young she may remember that...but normal memories..unlikely. Just how the mind works

Yet that little Indian boy remembered normal memories and he was five,  only a year older than Madeleine.   He remembered where he used to play.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Eleanor on April 28, 2016, 04:50:11 PM
Yet that little Indian boy remembered normal memories and he was five,  only a year older than Madeleine.   He remembered where he used to play.

The Pony Rides.  The trip to Ireland.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: jassi on April 28, 2016, 04:52:15 PM
She could be so traumatised that she remembers nothing.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: G-Unit on April 28, 2016, 06:08:31 PM
She could be so traumatised that she remembers nothing.

Or just genetically disposed to forgetting like her parents. (Which door did Gerry use, were curtains closed or open Kate?)
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on April 28, 2016, 06:23:25 PM
Or, she could be reading about what her parents did to her, and their behaviour since her disappearance. If she is alive she will recall if she ran out of the house to get her mum or dad on finding that AGAIN She and the twin babies were left alone...She was picked up by: a) a kindly person who has been looking after her OR b) a not so kind person -who enjoys telling her, her parents left her to be 'found' because they didn't like her, a sort of mental torture thing.
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: sadie on April 28, 2016, 11:27:31 PM
Yet no cites.

I thought on here we are supposed to do that when possible.
I am not able to give you those because they might endanger Madeleine. 

You have to believe me, or not.

That is your prerogative
Title: Re: Would Madeleine still have memories of her former life after 9 years?
Post by: Admin on April 28, 2016, 11:36:41 PM
Posters are reminded to keep to the topic under discussion.

Admin