UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: misty on April 23, 2016, 05:05:45 PM
-
It would appear a certain media outlet will be dishing some dirt in tomorrow's papers, if twiiter is anything to go by.
-
What a tease @)(++(*
Is there more?
-
What a tease @)(++(*
Is there more?
Doubtless Nigel Moore (will surface, at some point).
But otherwise, no ...
-
Have seen something elsewhere suggesting that it's the sun, but no idea of content.
-
In tomorrows Sun
-
In tomorrows Sun
oh dear
-
It would appear the Sun on Sunday are intending to do a hatchet job on Amaral tomorrow. Quick somebody give me Hacked Off's number !
-
oh dear
It's probably just a reference to his health. ?>)()<
-
It would appear the Sun on Sunday are intending to do a hatchet job on Amaral tomorrow. Quick somebody give me Hacked Off's number !
The poor, down-trodden, put-upon lamb ....
-
It would appear the Sun on Sunday are intending to do a hatchet job on Amaral tomorrow. Quick somebody give me Hacked Off's number !
I'm sure amaral will support the right of The Sun to express its opinion and its right to free speech
-
Well, I've just seen the link m as regards the Sun, and reference to a Ms. Gurney.
If true, this will guarantee Amaral's victory and leave the Sun with a libel case against them.
VERY, VERY STUPID.
-
It'll be largely irrelevant, whatever it's about. It won't have any influence on Portuguese courts and might even pique people's interest to find out more - which would be a good thing - IMO
-
Well, I've just seen the link m as regards the Sun, and reference to a Ms. Gurney.
If true, this will guarantee Amaral's victory and leave the Sun with a libel case against them.
VERY, VERY STUPID.
have you read the article then...or are you making a judgement based on no evidence
-
have you read the article then...or are you making a judgement based on no evidence
Well we know all too well the high journalistic standards of the Sun. %&5%£ %&5%£
-
Well we know all too well the high journalistic standards of the Sun. %&5%£ %&5%£
I would rather read the article first to see what it says... I think that is the most sensible approach
-
....and if it contains the expected material, what price Leveson ?
This could well turn out to be the biggest mistake yet. as the mccanns have/had a book deal and serialization rights with the 'sun'.
-
....and if it contains the expected material, what price Leveson ?
This could well turn out to be the biggest mistake yet. as the mccanns have/had a book deal and serialization rights with the 'sun'.
are you getting worried
-
are you getting worried
Not in the slightest.
It could well guarantee victory for Amaral.
Then of course the 'sun' could face a libel case as well, and I would love to see them in court. %£5&%
-
It's looking like fair game to me. If this is the right of Amaral then so shall it be for others. Silly man, he can't have it both ways.
If he can traduce others by right of Portuguese Law, then what on earth did he expect?
-
It's looking like fair game to me. If this is the right of Amaral then so shall it be for others. Silly man, he can't have it both ways.
If he can traduce others by right of Portuguese Law, then what on earth did he expect?
And neither can Gerry or Hacked Off.
-
Don't you worry dave, you can BE SURE the mccanns will get their just desserts.
Do you not realize this will be an old story dragged up by one of the mccann supporter cronies ?
whats the story about then..you dont have a clue
-
Actually, all this 'sun' article will show, is an attempt at revenge, is an admittance that the McCanns have no chance with the Supreme Court in Portugal, and they can kiss goodbye to the European Court of Human Rights as well.
So bring it on.
-
whats the story about then..you dont have a clue
We'll see at about 10 pm, when the papers come out.
The journalists at the 'sun' are not known for their brain power.
-
We'll see at about 10 pm, when the papers come out.
The journalists at the 'sun' are not known for their brain power.
But it might be worth a laugh. As if we didn't already know.
-
Acoustically, all this 'sun' article will show, is an attempt at revenge, is an admittance that the McCanns have no chance with the Supreme Court in Portugal, and they can kiss goodbye to the European Court of Human Rights as well.
So bring it on.
what do you mean by acoustically
-
But it might be worth a laugh. As if we didn't already know.
Would you like to see more salacious stories about the mccanns ?
It will happen.
You know that, don't you.
-
Would you like to see more salacious stories about the mccanns ?
It will happen.
You know that, don't you.
it won't happen ..I can guarantee that...the press will have been looking for such stories for the last 9 years and havent found any..if they had they would have published them
-
We'll see at about 10 pm, when the papers come out.
The journalists at the 'sun' are not known for their brain power.
Someone posted the sun front page with the title maddie cops sick secret or something...not sure if it was a photoshop jobbie or the real thing, cant find it now
All this angst rage and desperation about the mccanns losing, get over it, the fat lady has sung
-
Would you like to see more salacious stories about the mccanns ?
It will happen.
You know that, don't you.
No, Stephen. There are none. While Amaral was a bit of an arsehole before Madeleine was even born.
-
Someone posted the sun front page with the title maddie cops sick secret or something...not sure if it was a photoshop jobbie or the real thing, cant find it now
All this angst rage and desperation about the mccanns losing, get over it, the fat lady has sung
Perhaps the sun has had second thoughts, but I doubt it.
I wonder if cousin Clarence has had some input. &%+((£ &%+((£
-
No, Stephen. There are none. While Amaral was a bit of an arsehole before Madeleine was even born.
Don't bet on that.
-
Perhaps the sun has had second thoughts, but I doubt it.
I wonder if cousin Clarence has had some input. &%+((£ &%+((£
It will be one or other of the motley unprofessional crew, we shall see near midnight
-
Someone posted the sun front page with the title maddie cops sick secret or something...not sure if it was a photoshop jobbie or the real thing, cant find it now
All this angst rage and desperation about the mccanns losing, get over it, the fat lady has sung
It's on page 34 of today's paper copy, Mercury.
-
Page 34 ? well buried, then.
Most readers go straight from page 3 to the sports section.
-
Page 34 ? well buried, then.
Most readers go straight from page 3 to the sports section.
I do hope that was unintentional.
-
It's on page 34 of today's paper copy, Mercury.
Oh! So it was real, dare I ask what was in it? I saw it in twitter but not the whole article
-
s..m paper.
Sick Brit trolls pay £50k to Portuguese cop who accused Maddie’s parents of lying about daughter’s abduction
A GoFundMe page was set up in April last year to help cop overturn the libel ruling.
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/7100537/Sick-Brit-trolls-pay-50k-to-cop-who-accused-Maddie-s-parents-of-lying-about-abduction.html
-
s..m paper.
Sick Brit trolls pay £50k to Portuguese cop who accused Maddie’s parents of lying about daughter’s abduction
A GoFundMe page was set up in April last year to help cop overturn the libel ruling.
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/7100537/Sick-Brit-trolls-pay-50k-to-cop-who-accused-Maddie-s-parents-of-lying-about-abduction.html
@)(++(*
thats the sun for you, sad paper, always, every day, but they are so sad they dont realise their readers do have a mind of their own.... next........or ...
&%+((£
-
@)(++(*
thats the sun for you, sad paper, always, every day, but they are so sad they dont realise their readers do have a mind of their own.... next........or ...
&%+((£
Surely that cannot be the article ?
-
s..m paper.
Sick Brit trolls pay £50k to Portuguese cop who accused Maddie’s parents of lying about daughter’s abduction
A GoFundMe page was set up in April last year to help cop overturn the libel ruling.
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/7100537/Sick-Brit-trolls-pay-50k-to-cop-who-accused-Maddie-s-parents-of-lying-about-abduction.html
@)(++(* sorry but i laughed
-
Surely that cannot be the article ?
Its old news revamped and embroidered with "sick" and "trolls"
I guess each member of the public not forgetting all of SY police that donated to amarals fund wont like it or will laugh it off for the horseshit it is
Pmsl this is sooo pathetic but thats the suns middle name
-
i posted this at 7.21 this evening....
unfortunately sun headlines have a habit of promising a lot but delivering little so we will have to wait and see..
look like Davel was right again
-
i posted this at 7.21 this evening....
unfortunately sun headlines have a habit of promising a lot but delivering little so we will have to wait and see..
look like Davel was right again
Third person again?
-
The sun article, minimalistic and written by a fiend of the McCann's. 8**8:/:
-
The sun article, minimalistic and written by a fiend of the McCann's. 8**8:/:
am i not surprised
-
am i not sirprised
Well she is a known fiend. *&*%£
-
I see they are already appropriate comments on the sun's article.
Excellent.
-
I see they are already appropriate comments on the sun's article.
Excellent.
And its nice to see mr amarals face against madeleines, puts thngs into perspective...he was working to find out what happened to her
-
The sun article, minimalistic and written by a fiend of the McCann's. 8**8:/:
So minimalistic that it omits to mention that the court decided in Mr Amarals favour.
Just a hypothesis - Is it possible that the Sun at the last minute had to pull the real article they were planning to print, and had to stick this old material in its place?
-
So minimalistic that it omits to mention that the court decided in Mr Amarals favour.
Just a hypothesis - Is it possible that the Sun at the last minute had to pull the real article they were planning to print, and had to stick this old material in its place?
PMSL!!!
-
Nul point for Lazzeri. If she is so ill-informed she should hang up her crayons. Or would that be a can of spray paint?
Amaral made a fortune from The Truth of the Lie, a 2008 book containing the claims, but his assets were frozen after his 2010 libel loss.
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/7100537/Madeleine-McCann-cop-paid-50k-by-sick-Brit-trolls-after-accusing-her-parents-of-lying-about-her-abduction.html
Utter nonsense.
-
It looks like the original article was dropped for fear of repercussions and we are left with this irrelevant piece og hogwash from Lazerri which has resulted in the inevitable comments on the readers section.
-
It looks like the original article was dropped for fear of repercussions and we are left with this irrelevant piece og hogwash from Lazerri which has resulted in the inevitable comments on the readers section.
There was a time when comments on McCann stories weren't allowed. Recently they're being allowed by almost all the newspapers. Is that so the commentators can say what the papers aren't allowed to say, I wonder?
-
There was a time when comments on McCann stories weren't allowed. Recently they're being allowed by almost all the newspapers. Is that so the commentators can say what the papers aren't allowed to say, I wonder?
I would venture to say yes.
I do get the feeling that many journalists/reporters would really like to say what they really feel about the mccanns and the abduction story, and with a significant amount of bad publicity for that lovely pair, it has given some of the papers courage enough to allow the views of the readers to be printed to some degree.
-
I would venture to say yes.
I do get the feeling that many journalists/reporters would really like to say what they really feel about the mccanns and the abduction story, and with a significant amount of bad publicity for that lovely pair, it has given some of the papers courage enough to allow the views of the readers to be printed to some degree.
we know the papers are limited to what they can print as anything in the uk has to be supported by evidence
-
What a damp squib 8(8-))
I get up, all bright-eyed and bushy-tailed, ready for exciting gossip and what do I see - a tired old story of no interest to anyone. Bah humbug.
-
What a damp squib 8(8-))
I get up, all bright-eyed and bushy-tailed, ready for exciting gossip and what do I see - a tired old story of no interest to anyone. Bah humbug.
That's Lazerri for you , a good friend of the mccanns, who writes total rollocks.
-
Having a glance through the comment section, the irony is that under a piece on trolls, some of the comments are helpfully providing a perfect illustration of why some people on the more rabid end of the "sceptic" spectrum get labelled as, erm, trolls.
-
Having a glance through the comment section, the irony is that under a piece on trolls, some of the comments are helpfully providing a perfect illustration of why some people on the more rabid end of the "sceptic" spectrum get labelled as, erm, trolls.
ironic isn't it
-
Having a glance through the comment section, the irony is that under a piece on trolls, some of the comments are helpfully providing a perfect illustration of why some people on the more rabid end of the "sceptic" spectrum get labelled as, erm, trolls.
and some are more than reasonable comments about the mccanns.
I would love to see the 'sun' publish comments from the mccann supporting trolls on twitter.
-
and some are more than reasonable comments about the mccanns.
I would love to see the 'sun' publish comments from the mccann supporting trolls on twitter.
I read some of them, dear dear, half of them had their facts wrong, it makes me wonder if they really know anything about the case.
-
I read some of them, dear dear, half of them had their facts wrong, it makes me wonder if they really know anything about the case.
You mean like the mccanns leaving their children unprotected in an empty apartment whilst they boozed and ate ?
-
You mean like the mccanns leaving their children unprotected in an empty apartment whilst they boozed and ate ?
yes..just like that....an innacurate statement....the mccanns were not boozing...you are your own worst enemy and your post is libellous
-
You mean like the mccanns leaving their children unprotected in an empty apartment whilst they boozed and ate ?
What has that got to do with the case against Amaral?
-
What has that got to do with the case against Amaral?
That is where the case started.
-
I read some of them, dear dear, half of them had their facts wrong, it makes me wonder if they really know anything about the case.
The person who wrote the article didn't get her facts right either. Facts don't seem to matter to anyone who comments on this case. They pick their 'side' and then make the facts fit their opinions.
-
The person who wrote the article didn't get her facts right either. Facts don't seem to matter to anyone who comments on this case. They pick their 'side' and then make the facts fit their opinions.
Lazerri is nothing but a mccann prawn. 8**8:/:
Oh, did I mistype again. 8)--))
-
I read some of them, dear dear, half of them had their facts wrong, it makes me wonder if they really know anything about the case.
it makes me wonder if they really know anything about the case.
well a lot of them ............... won't do will they..
that was the mccs/lawyers intention.....
surely you must know that ....the majority only know what they are told to believe ...like some on here....
if I'm called a troll .so what ....what i know is i am a truth seeker .....who has a mind of my own ...of what i know ....if that makes me a troll .so be it ....
more people now are learning ...the other side of a so called abduction .......
and the publicity for the book for Amaral .must be phenomenal .all free............
shows they are thinking now ....... what the can and can't put about G A ........
good to see maddie pic ...against him ....the one who cares what happened to her ...... 8((()*/
-
Better than the Sun expose , there might be some interesting stuff emerging from Amaral's TV spectacular last night.
Not available to view yet, but promised soon.
Youtube probably, I can't see it being on Iplayer
-
Better than the Sun expose , there might be some interesting stuff emerging from Amaral's TV spectacular last night.
Not available to view yet, but promised soon.
Youtube probably, I can't see it being on Iplayer
well this shows he is going for the English version
quote
the mccs don't own the English language ... @)(++(*
http://www.servimg.com/view/14388310/1873
-
it makes me wonder if they really know anything about the case.
well a lot of them ............... won't do will they..
that was the mccs/lawyers intention.....
surely you must know that ....the majority only know what they are told to believe ...like some on here....
if I'm called a troll .so what ....what i know is i am a truth seeker .....who has a mind of my own ...of what i know ....if that makes me a troll .so be it ....
more people now are learning ...the other side of a so called abduction .......
and the publicity for the book for Amaral .must be phenomenal .all free............
shows they are thinking now ....... what the can and can't put about G A ........
good to see maddie pic ...against him ....the one who cares what happened to her ...... 8((()*/
That's what I don't understand.
If he did actually care about what really happened to her, as opposed to soothing his wounded pride against the PJ for having got unceremoniously kicked off the case (and making a packet of money in the process), he wouldn't have been insisting that she's definitely dead and that the parents (and just about any public agency that one can think of) were involved on every media outlet that would host him for the past 8 years without any proof.
This case was about whether or not he was within his rights to express his opinion. As it stands, the legal position in PT is that he is. However, it is still only his opinion, based on a few cherry-picked "facts" and a largely garbled interpretation of them.
If he had been on a soapbox in the PT equivalent of Speakers' Corner in Hyde Park, his influence on public opinion would have been minimal. This is not the case: he's a former PJ coordinator who was initially in charge of the case (for a few months), and that position leads people to assume that his opinion is an expert analysis of what really happened and therefore has more sway over public opinion.
Those who believe him to be an expert are more likely to assume that his "professional" opinion is correct... and that therefore there is no point in being vigilant as to any potential sign of her, nor of any potential perp acting suspiciously at the time.
How does that help Madeleine?
-
That's what I don't understand.
If he did actually care about what really happened to her, as opposed to soothing his wounded pride against the PJ for having got unceremoniously kicked off the case (and making a packet of money in the process), he wouldn't have been insisting that she's definitely dead and that the parents (and just about any public agency that one can think of) were involved on every media outlet that would host him for the past 8 years without any proof.
This case was about whether or not he was within his rights to express his opinion. As it stands, the legal position in PT is that he is. However, it is still only his opinion, based on a few cherry-picked "facts" and a largely garbled interpretation of them.
If he had been on a soapbox in the PT equivalent of Speakers' Corner in Hyde Park, his influence on public opinion would have been minimal. This is not the case: he's a former PJ coordinator who was initially in charge of the case (for a few months), and that position leads people to assume that his opinion is an expert analysis of what really happened and therefore has more sway over public opinion.
Those who believe him to be an expert are more likely to assume that his "professional" opinion is correct... and that therefore there is no point in being vigilant as to any potential sign of her, nor of any potential perp acting suspiciously at the time.
How does that help Madeleine?
What, in your opinion, is going to help Madeleine ?
-
What, in your opinion, is going to help Madeleine ?
Finding her (hopefully alive or perhaps, sadly, not) and bringing whoever is responsible to justice.
-
Finding her (hopefully alive or perhaps, sadly, not) and bringing whoever is responsible to justice.
Yes, which is what SY are currently being paid to do.
-
Yes, which is what SY are currently being paid to do.
Indeed, as are the current PJ officers.
-
That's what I don't understand.
If he did actually care about what really happened to her, as opposed to soothing his wounded pride against the PJ for having got unceremoniously kicked off the case (and making a packet of money in the process), he wouldn't have been insisting that she's definitely dead and that the parents (and just about any public agency that one can think of) were involved on every media outlet that would host him for the past 8 years without any proof.
This case was about whether or not he was within his rights to express his opinion. As it stands, the legal position in PT is that he is. However, it is still only his opinion, based on a few cherry-picked "facts" and a largely garbled interpretation of them.
If he had been on a soapbox in the PT equivalent of Speakers' Corner in Hyde Park, his influence on public opinion would have been minimal. This is not the case: he's a former PJ coordinator who was initially in charge of the case (for a few months), and that position leads people to assume that his opinion is an expert analysis of what really happened and therefore has more sway over public opinion.
Those who believe him to be an expert are more likely to assume that his "professional" opinion is correct... and that therefore there is no point in being vigilant as to any potential sign of her, nor of any potential perp acting suspiciously at the time.
How does that help Madeleine?
How did it help Madeleine when the McCanns publicised their opinion world-wide? They shouted 'abduction' immediately with no evidence to support their opinion at all. The Portuguese police logically spent a week searching nearby, which the McCanns didn't do and didn't want the police to do. The PJ were distracted from their investigation by the massive media uproar and the largely spurious sightings which resulted from the Team McCann campaign.
Believing the McCann's version of events doesn't make it true. If it isn't, their campaign did not help Madeleine.
-
Indeed, as are the current PJ officers.
Have they found her ?
-
They won't find her sitting in warm offices, sifting through papers
-
They won't find her sitting in warm offices, sifting through papers
That is what they are doing though.
Nice easy job reading files and going nowhere.
-
They won't find her sitting in warm offices, sifting through papers
So how will they find her then? Tearing around different countries knocking on doors? hiding in gardens spying on people?
-
They won't find her - IMO
-
How did it help Madeleine when the McCanns publicised their opinion world-wide? They shouted 'abduction' immediately with no evidence to support their opinion at all. The Portuguese police logically spent a week searching nearby, which the McCanns didn't do and didn't want the police to do. The PJ were distracted from their investigation by the massive media uproar and the largely spurious sightings which resulted from the Team McCann campaign.
Believing the McCann's version of events doesn't make it true. If it isn't, their campaign did not help Madeleine.
How has Amaral's campaign helped?
What Amaral is deemed to have got right is still one of the shortest threads on this entire forum...
I started it as a genuine attempt to give him credit where it was due. I found that quickly organising the dissemination of her photo and description to the media was to his credit.
One or two other people entered into the spirit of the exercise and also chipped in. That's about it.
If Amaral's theory had stood up to scrutiny, there would have been no need for the plethora of absurd conspiracy theories that abound. Nor his own, for that matter.
-
They won't find her - IMO
Who is "they"?
-
The police officers, both UK and Portuguese.
-
Why is the sun journo in Portugal?
-
How has Amaral's campaign helped?
What Amaral is deemed to have got right is still one of the shortest threads on this entire forum...
I started it as a genuine attempt to give him credit where it was due. I found that quickly organising the dissemination of her photo and description to the media was to his credit.
One or two other people entered into the spirit of the exercise and also chipped in. That's about it.
If Amaral's theory had stood up to scrutiny, there would have been no need for the plethora of absurd conspiracy theories that abound. Nor his own, for that matter.
The best time to find out what happened is right at the beginning of an investigation in my opinion. The McCann campaign swung into action immediately and continued relentlessly from then on. Amaral said nothing until over a year after the disappearance. A year of being criticised and libeled by the UK media.
This all reminds me of the tortoise and the hare. The McCanns were out of the starting blocks and streaking away before the PJ even began to investigate. (Well, they do like running)
Amaral has plodded (plod ha ha) along at a much slower pace but he could well be catching up now, judging by the comments sections of the UK media. It will be interesting to see if any of them will take the plunge and write a factual assessment of the case without all the sychophancy for a change.
-
The best time to find out what happened is right at the beginning of an investigation in my opinion. The McCann campaign swung into action immediately and continued relentlessly from then on. Amaral said nothing until over a year after the disappearance. A year of being criticised and libeled by the UK media.
This all reminds me of the tortoise and the hare. The McCanns were out of the starting blocks and streaking away before the PJ even began to investigate. (Well, they do like running)
Amaral has plodded (plod ha ha) along at a much slower pace but he could well be catching up now, judging by the comments sections of the UK media. It will be interesting to see if any of them will take the plunge and write a factual assessment of the case without all the sychophancy for a change.
the facts are that the mccanns are not suspects
-
the facts are that the mccanns are not suspects
Who are the suspects?
Kate Prout murder case - husband not suspect
The husband of missing Kate Prout who was arrested on suspicion of her murder is no longer a formal suspect.
Adrian Prout had been on police bail while investigations into the disappearance of his wife Kate continued.
Gloucestershire police confirmed Mr Prout’s bail had been cancelled but said they were still hopeful of solving her disappearance.
Acting Detective Superintendent Neil Kelly, the senior investigating officer in the case, said: “The investigation into Mrs Prout’s disappearance and suspected death remains active and is continuing, and will do so for the foreseeable future.”
He said a small team of officers were continuing to work on the case.
http://www.gloucestercitizen.co.uk/Kate-murder-case-husband-suspect/story-11858977-detail/story.html
-
the facts are that the mccanns are not suspects
The fact is that DCI Redwood made that statement three and a half years ago. Can it still be relied upon? Well, the police have been known to change direction during investigations. They have also been known to make such statements when the person(s) named are actually suspected and the police don't want them to know. Sometimes the police have actually been wrong too; Barry George for example.
-
How has Amaral's campaign helped?
What Amaral is deemed to have got right is still one of the shortest threads on this entire forum...
I started it as a genuine attempt to give him credit where it was due. I found that quickly organising the dissemination of her photo and description to the media was to his credit.
One or two other people entered into the spirit of the exercise and also chipped in. That's about it.
If Amaral's theory had stood up to scrutiny, there would have been no need for the plethora of absurd conspiracy theories that abound. Nor his own, for that matter.
Amaral has no duty towards Madeleine. That ended when he was taken off of the case.
-
Aww. I was expecting some nice juicy exclusive. Instead we have the same regurgitated tripe that we always get :(
-
Aww. I was expecting some nice juicy exclusive. Instead we have the same regurgitated tripe that we always get :(
awww with the mcanns spin never expect anything less 8)-))) most of us have been on forums talking about this for 9 years the mcanns have never changed and wont either will the uk media our australian media is no better
-
Amaral has no duty towards Madeleine. That ended when he was taken off of the case.
No duty in a professional sense, I agree. He was attempting to make a fortune out of his memoirs of this - as yet unresolved - case.
On the other hand, if he truly cared about Madeleine, why on earth didn't he defend his honour in a different way?
He could have written a book that would have been just as lucrative about how he had been supposedly let down by his own authorities, without insisting that Madeleine is dead and that parents (and numerous other people) were involved.
Why didn't he do that? It would still have been a best-seller. If someone advised him to take the route that he did, perhaps that advice was misguided.
-
No duty in a professional sense, I agree. He was attempting to make a fortune out of his memoirs of this - as yet unresolved - case.
On the other hand, if he truly cared about Madeleine, why on earth didn't he defend his honour in a different way?
He could have written a book that would have been just as lucrative about how he had been supposedly let down by his own authorities, without insisting that Madeleine is dead and that parents (and numerous other people) were involved.
Why didn't he do that? It would still have been a best-seller. If someone advised him to take the route that he did, perhaps that advice was misguided.
And Kate could have furthered the search for her daughter in a book that didn't include details of her sex life. I'm sure it would still have been a best seller. I suppose they both made their choices.
-
No duty in a professional sense, I agree. He was attempting to make a fortune out of his memoirs of this - as yet unresolved - case.
On the other hand, if he truly cared about Madeleine, why on earth didn't he defend his honour in a different way?
He could have written a book that would have been just as lucrative about how he had been supposedly let down by his own authorities, without insisting that Madeleine is dead and that parents (and numerous other people) were involved.
Why didn't he do that? It would still have been a best-seller. If someone advised him to take the route that he did, perhaps that advice was misguided.
Accusing Amaral of attempting to make a fortune out of his memoirs is just your opinion of his motivation. His book could have sunk without a trace, like the S & S one. Publishing, like litigation, is always a gamble. Like the Appeal Judges I can see no reason why Amaral should have refrained from publicising his thesis. He had as much right to do that as the McCanns had to publicise theirs.
-
Accusing Amaral of attempting to make a fortune out of his memoirs is just your opinion of his motivation. His book could have sunk without a trace, like the S & S one. Publishing, like litigation, is always a gamble. Like the Appeal Judges I can see no reason why Amaral should have refrained from publicising his thesis. He had as much right to do that as the McCanns had to publicise theirs.
He could have written a book in a different way. He chose not to.
-
No duty in a professional sense, I agree. He was attempting to make a fortune out of his memoirs of this - as yet unresolved - case.
On the other hand, if he truly cared about Madeleine, why on earth didn't he defend his honour in a different way?
He could have written a book that would have been just as lucrative about how he had been supposedly let down by his own authorities, without insisting that Madeleine is dead and that parents (and numerous other people) were involved.
Why didn't he do that? It would still have been a best-seller. If someone advised him to take the route that he did, perhaps that advice was misguided.
Portugal has libel laws that are very different to the UK.
For example, in the UK dead people are open to attack either when they die, or shortly thereafter. In Portugal, there is a right to a good name that extends to 50 years after death.
And bodies that are considered pillars of the state get special protection, including the police. You'ld have a tough time writing a bestseller about mistreatment by the police.
-
Portugal has libel laws that are very different to the UK.
For example, in the UK dead people are open to attack either when they die, or shortly thereafter. In Portugal, there is a right to a good name that extends to 50 years after death.
And bodies that are considered pillars of the state get special protection, including the police. You'ld have a tough time writing a bestseller about mistreatment by the police.
So what has happened to the McCanns right to a good name
-
Accusing Amaral of attempting to make a fortune out of his memoirs is just your opinion of his motivation. His book could have sunk without a trace, like the S & S one. Publishing, like litigation, is always a gamble. Like the Appeal Judges I can see no reason why Amaral should have refrained from publicising his thesis. He had as much right to do that as the McCanns had to publicise theirs.
If he didn't want to earn an income from his book, documentary and innumerable interviews, he could have given all the proceeds to any charity of his choice at the time and not have gained a euro from it.
Unless I've misunderstood, he is claiming his right to his earnings as a result... and is even threatening to sue for financial loss while this case has been ongoing.
-
If he didn't want to earn an income from his book, documentary and innumerable interviews, he could have given all the proceeds to any charity of his choice at the time and not have gained a euro from it.
Unless I've misunderstood, he is claiming his right to his earnings as a result... and is even threatening to sue for financial loss while this case has been ongoing.
That may be more to do with the freezing of his assets in general, rather than just earnings from any book.
-
Portugal has libel laws that are very different to the UK.
For example, in the UK dead people are open to attack either when they die, or shortly thereafter. In Portugal, there is a right to a good name that extends to 50 years after death.
And bodies that are considered pillars of the state get special protection, including the police. You'ld have a tough time writing a bestseller about mistreatment by the police.
That is an interesting thought.
From what I have learned of Portugal, it might prove to be very difficult for Leonor Cipriano to write a book about her experiences ... what price freedom of expression for Joe public?
There used to be a quaint tradition over here of not speaking ill of the dead, probably more disregarded than implemented.
However it worries me more than a little ~ with reference to your last sentence ~ that not all seem to be equal under the law in Portugal. I think it possible that we have just witnessed the McCanns falling foul of that.
-
So what has happened to the McCanns right to a good name
Good question Davel.
-
Perhaps the 'right to good name' only applies to residents of Portugal, rather than any Tom, Dick, or Harry elsewhere.
-
Perhaps the 'right to good name' only applies to residents of Portugal, rather than any Tom, Dick, or Harry elsewhere.
The Portuguese Constitution allows "any Tom, Dick or Harry elsewhere" exactly that right. I posted the article yesterday, you will find it if you Google 'Portuguese Constitution'.
-
So what has happened to the McCanns right to a good name
Good question. As I explained earlier, I expected the first judgement to be upheld but with the amount reduced.
Then comes the issue of how does one write a bestseller, and survive the legal eagles. The McCanns happen to be softer targets than many elements of Portuguese society.
It's called Portugal cos it has a Portuguese constitution, Portuguese laws, Portuguese people, and a bunch of foreigners, most whom struggle with Portuguese.
Mind you, there were bucketloads of 'obrigados' from yesterday's Luz triathletes.
-
That is an interesting thought.
From what I have learned of Portugal, it might prove to be very difficult for Leonor Cipriano to write a book about her experiences ... what price freedom of expression for Joe public?
There used to be a quaint tradition over here of not speaking ill of the dead, probably more disregarded than implemented.
However it worries me more than a little ~ with reference to your last sentence ~ that not all seem to be equal under the law in Portugal. I think it possible that we have just witnessed the McCanns falling foul of that.
Like we are over here you mean ?
Think about Chris Huhne's sentence.
As for the McCanns falling foul of Portuguese law; they had best Portuguese Lawyer money could buy we were told on here. Maybe she[the solicitrix] should have apprised the McCanns of the risks they faced.
-
The Portuguese Constitution allows "any Tom, Dick or Harry elsewhere" exactly that right. I posted the article yesterday, you will find it if you Google 'Portuguese Constitution'.
Where would you find that, because Article 26, which covers 'good name' talks about citizens and doesn't mention foreigners ?
-
Where would you find that, because Article 26, which covers 'good name' talks about citizens and doesn't mention foreigners ?
Article 15
(Foreigners, stateless persons, European citizens)
-
Article 15
(Foreigners, stateless persons, European citizens)
That seems to be talking about foreigners resident in Portugal
"Foreigners and stateless persons who fund themselves or who reside in Portugal shall enjoy the same rights and be subject to the same duties as Portuguese citizens."
However, it's no big deal, I merely thought it a possible explanation
-
The Portuguese Constitution allows "any Tom, Dick or Harry elsewhere" exactly that right. I posted the article yesterday, you will find it if you Google 'Portuguese Constitution'.
It appears to have something to do with the McCann's courting publicity.
-
Portugal has libel laws that are very different to the UK.
For example, in the UK dead people are open to attack either when they die, or shortly thereafter. In Portugal, there is a right to a good name that extends to 50 years after death.
And bodies that are considered pillars of the state get special protection, including the police. You'ld have a tough time writing a bestseller about mistreatment by the police.
Yes, I'm aware of that, but he could still have written a book that would have got sympathy without insisting on his assertions against the fate of a particular 3-year-old child.
If he hadn't accused anyone in particular in his hierarchy in Portugal, who would have sued him ?
-
It appears to have something to do with the McCann's courting publicity.
The only time the McCann's courted publicity as you put it was when they wanted to get the word out about Madeleine.
-
The only time the McCann's courted publicity as you put it was when they wanted to get the word out about Madeleine.
That is a matter of opinion.
-
It appears to have something to do with the McCann's courting publicity.
Oh that was them sitting in front of the television cameras last night courting publicity??
For Madeleine’s sake...
THE trolls funding a shamed cop’s right to lie about Kate and Gerry McCann are a new level of weirdo.
They gave £52,000 to a man whose blind prejudice may have wrecked any initial chance of finding Madeleine.
Now, after his libel appeal win, they may have destroyed all hope for good.
Talking up conspiracy theories is one thing.
Wrecking the search for an abducted child is another.
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/sun_says/6500866/Sun-Says.html
Nope ... I think it may have been the guy mentioned above doing exactly what he does best as alleged by the Sun ... and that is "talking up conspiracy theories".
-
Just goes to show what rubbish newspapers can print.
-
Oh that was them sitting in front of the television cameras last night courting publicity??
For Madeleine’s sake...
THE trolls funding a shamed cop’s right to lie about Kate and Gerry McCann are a new level of weirdo.
They gave £52,000 to a man whose blind prejudice may have wrecked any initial chance of finding Madeleine.
Now, after his libel appeal win, they may have destroyed all hope for good.
Talking up conspiracy theories is one thing.
Wrecking the search for an abducted child is another.
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/sun_says/6500866/Sun-Says.html
Nope ... I think it may have been the guy mentioned above doing exactly what he does best as alleged by the Sun ... and that is "talking up conspiracy theories".
I've read that comment in the Sun.
How has this judgement interfered in the 'search' ?
Well, that was just rubbish.
-
Oh that was them sitting in front of the television cameras last night courting publicity??
For Madeleine’s sake...
THE trolls funding a shamed cop’s right to lie about Kate and Gerry McCann are a new level of weirdo.
They gave £52,000 to a man whose blind prejudice may have wrecked any initial chance of finding Madeleine.
Now, after his libel appeal win, they may have destroyed all hope for good.
Talking up conspiracy theories is one thing.
Wrecking the search for an abducted child is another.
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/sun_says/6500866/Sun-Says.html
Nope ... I think it may have been the guy mentioned above doing exactly what he does best as alleged by the Sun ... and that is "talking up conspiracy theories".
The lesson for this week, is "when you are in a hole, stop digging."
-
The lesson for this week, is "when you are in a hole, stop digging."
It has the benefit of being an On Topic spade ... an implement for digging holes ~ useful for filling them in also.
-
It has the benefit of being an On Topic spade ... an implement for digging holes ~ useful for filling them in also.
So Brietta, how does the judgement impede the 'search' exactly ?
-
The lesson for this week, is "when you are in a hole, stop digging."
Let's hope that the Portuguese judiciary learns that lesson and reverses this ridiculous decision.
-
So Brietta, how does the judgement impede the 'search' exactly ?
I note you have bracketed the word search, Stephen.
Think about exactly why you did that and you may have answered your own question.
-
I note you have bracketed the word search, Stephen.
Think about exactly why you did that and you may have answered your own question.
Hardly.
I never have believed the mccanns really searched for Madeleine.
Meanwhile,. as you would put it, SY and the Portuguese are conducting separate investigations into her fate.
-
Let's hope that the Portuguese judiciary learns that lesson and reverses this ridiculous decision.
Which lesson is that?
Do you really think that the Supreme Court is going to do anything other than apply the law as it sees it?
-
If he didn't want to earn an income from his book, documentary and innumerable interviews, he could have given all the proceeds to any charity of his choice at the time and not have gained a euro from it.
Unless I've misunderstood, he is claiming his right to his earnings as a result... and is even threatening to sue for financial loss while this case has been ongoing.
Why not? He published, his book sold, he made money. I can see no reason why he should give it away. I can also see no reason why he shouldn't sue the McCanns if he wants to. It's all geese and ganders. At least he'd be spending money he made, not other people's donations.
-
Why not? He published, his book sold, he made money. I can see no reason why he should give it away. I can also see no reason why he shouldn't sue the McCanns if he wants to. It's all geese and ganders. At least he'd be spending money he made, not other people's donations.
How was it he financed his legal teams if not from other people's donations?
-
Hardly.
I never have believed the mccanns really searched for Madeleine.
Meanwhile,. as you would put it, SY and the Portuguese are conducting separate investigations into her fate.
Do you think there is likely to be any degree of congruity between the two investigations ?
-
How was it he financed his legal teams if not from other people's donations?
He's not likely to be using that if he sues the McCanns as all his assets will be have been freed up.
-
He's not likely to be using that if he sues the McCanns as all his assets will be have been freed up.
I understand that it is a sort of pay as you go arrangement, Mr Amaral has had many lawyers over the years ... which rather cuts his options for litigation for his legal expenses since he didn't have to put his hand into his own pocket.
There may even be other creditors from the past who may be delighted that his assets may be unfrozen, who knows?
Maybe the Sun will run with something along those lines since they've got the bit between their teeth.
-
I understand that it is a sort of pay as you go arrangement, Mr Amaral has had many lawyers over the years ... which rather cuts his options for litigation for his legal expenses since he didn't have to put his hand into his own pocket.
There may even be other creditors from the past who may be delighted that his assets may be unfrozen, who knows?
Maybe the Sun will run with something along those lines since they've got the bit between their teeth.
Something between their teeth...
-
The judges don't agree with you and I rather think that they have a better understanding of Portuguese law than you do.
It matters not what you say, it will have absolutely no effect on what happens next.
Strange, I was replying to a Ferryman post and it has disappeared
It has now appeared below this one - somebody is playing games
-
How was it he financed his legal teams if not from other people's donations?
That would be because his assets had been frozen by his opponents. (not that the case was about money, of course).
-
Portugal will be a laughing-stock in the eyes of the world if it doesn't reverse this decision.
-
Portugal will be a laughing-stock in the eyes of the world if it doesn't reverse this decision.
The world won't even notice, or if it does, it will be for 5 minutes
-
The world won't even notice, or if it does, it will be for 5 minutes
I think the Government & Justice system of Portugal will very much notice being dragged into the ECHR over its interpretation of free speech.
-
Portugal will be a laughing-stock in the eyes of the world if it doesn't reverse this decision.
The court abided by the Portuguese Law.
It is the mccanns behaviour which has increasingly being called into question .
-
I think the Government & Justice system of Portugal will very much notice being dragged into the ECHR over its interpretation of free speech.
This is a a civil matter, not one of human rights.
The 3 judges abided by their law,
-
I have my doubts. Why should anyone outside Europe have any interest for a start?
Most countries have their own problems.
Because you are closely involved in this case, you think it is of mega importance, but it simply isn't.
Even in this country most people really don't care what the outcome is.
-
I have my doubts. Why should anyone outside Europe have any interest for a start?
Most countries have their own problems.
Because you are closely involved in this case, you think it is of mega importance, but it simply isn't.
Even in this country most people really don't care what the outcome is.
Indira Ghandi very much cared when Salman Rushdie libelled her in Midnight's children.
Will there be a rush of authors to publishing houses in Portugal if they wish to print libellous works?
-
Portugal will be a laughing-stock in the eyes of the world if it doesn't reverse this decision.
I think the opposite applies, if they were to reverse it now they certainly would be a laughing stock.
-
Indira Ghandi very much cared when Salman Rushdie libelled her in Midnight's children.
Will there be a rush of authors to publishing houses in Portugal if they wish to print libellous works?
I'm sure she did, but did the rest of the world care?
It has been established in the Portuguese court that the book is not libelous in Portugal.
-
I'm sure she did, but did the rest of the world care?
It has been established in the Portuguese court that the book is not libelous in Portugal.
Not in Portugal, maybe, but most definitely elsewhere.
Do you think Portugal wants to risk opening the floodgates by allowing this to get to the ECHR?
-
You really are trying to blow this out of all proportion.
Do you think the Portuguese government fear they are going to be ostracised by the rest of Europe just because their Supreme Court finds against a couple of nobodies whop brought a damages claim against another nobody?
-
This is a a civil matter, not one of human rights.
The 3 judges abided by their law,
Don't assume Duarte doesn't know what she is talking about
-
Don't assume Duarte doesn't know what she is talking about
Really.
-
Well, that would be a very interesting case if the McCanns took this to the EU courts.
Good ole Ger fighting for his rights to.... what would he be fighting ? anyway fighting some freedom thingy, and back home, getting 'hacked off' about some freedom thingy. Cake and eating it comes to mind.
Has anyone started a go fund me page for that little trial? OR will the McCanns use fund money again?
It is good to see Duante is doing this for free....oh she is also making money from this whoo hhoo EU here she comes with her fund trolly full of lolly.
...and in the meantime people are told to keep searching for little Maddie, the parents would but well they are very, very busy you know.