Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: faithlilly on April 24, 2016, 11:15:04 AM
Title: Litigation v The Search
Post by: faithlilly on April 24, 2016, 11:15:04 AM
While supporters seem happy that the McCanns plan to take the case against Amaral all the way to the ECHR they must know that it will be expensive to continue such litigation. My question is that if the McCanns fail in their bid to overturn the appeal court verdict and Amaral does in fact sue them will supporters be happy for the fund to be used to cover the litigation costs of the McCanns and Amaral's damages or do they feel that it is more important, if OG is wound down, that the money in the fund is kept exclusively to further the search ?
49
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Carana on April 24, 2016, 12:08:41 PM
How much would it cost to lodge an appeal, if it came to that?
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: jassi on April 24, 2016, 12:17:43 PM
If an appeal does go to the ECHR, would the Portuguese Court expect all the terms of their last judgement to be complied with irrespective of what a future judgement might be ? - i.e. all costs paid up and not held back pending a final court decision.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: faithlilly on April 24, 2016, 12:21:40 PM
While supporters seem happy that the McCanns plan to take the case against Amaral all the way to the ECHR they must know that it will be expensive to continue such litigation. My question is that if the McCanns fail in their bid to overturn the appeal court verdict and Amaral does in fact sue them will supporters be happy for the fund to be used to cover the litigation costs of the McCanns and Amaral's damages or do they feel that it is more important, if OG is wound down, that the money in the fund is kept exclusively to further the search ?
The sane sensible answer is to eat humble pie and use the money for a "real" search not gamble it whch is precisely what they would be doing and wth very bad odds and zero inches on on the road to fnd their child
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: faithlilly on April 24, 2016, 01:03:28 PM
Without relevant information I find it hard to answer your question.
Not sure what other information you need Carana. The question is straightforward. Do you believe more money should be spent on litigation or held back in case OG is disbanded ?
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Carana on April 24, 2016, 02:40:53 PM
Not sure what other information you need Carana. The question is straightforward. Do you believe more money should be spent on litigation or held back in case OG is disbanded ?
I can't answer that without more information.
If filing a suit doesn't actually cost much, then I don't see why not, if there is a reasoned case to put forward.
If simply filing a case were to amount to a substantial proportion of the funds to continue to search for Madeleine, then... no.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: faithlilly on April 24, 2016, 02:43:17 PM
Not sure what other information you need Carana. The question is straightforward. Do you believe more money should be spent on litigation or held back in case OG is disbanded ?
Mr Amaral's intention seems to be to ensure there is no money available to continue the search for Madeleine; that is if he follows through on his threat to sue the McCanns for having the audacity to sue him for libelling them.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Carana on April 24, 2016, 02:46:35 PM
Mr Amaral's intention seems to be to ensure there is no money available to continue the search for Madeleine; that is if he follows through on his threat to sue the McCanns for having the audacity to sue him for libelling them.
I think the overall intention is to make sure the McCanns don't have any money to threaten or sue anyone else. Afterall that's what they use it for.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: jassi on April 24, 2016, 02:49:12 PM
Mr Amaral's intention seems to be to ensure there is no money available to continue the search for Madeleine; that is if he follows through on his threat to sue the McCanns for having the audacity to sue him for libelling them.
He wouldn't be suing the fund, though, so that money should remain intact even if he won against the McCanns The fund is supposed to be for searching, not paying legal fees.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Carana on April 24, 2016, 02:51:17 PM
Mr Amaral's intention seems to be to ensure there is no money available to continue the search for Madeleine; that is if he follows through on his threat to sue the McCanns for having the audacity to sue him for libelling them.
I have yet to work out what exactly the basis for suing the McCanns might be... and in which jurisdiction he would intend to proceed if so.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: pathfinder73 on April 24, 2016, 02:51:54 PM
This is how the McCanns react when asked about their actual search. Clueless!
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: stephen25000 on April 24, 2016, 02:53:05 PM
Mr Amaral's intention seems to be to ensure there is no money available to continue the search for Madeleine; that is if he follows through on his threat to sue the McCanns for having the audacity to sue him for libelling them.
If he sues them , which I hope he will. The money will come from them if he was successful, not the fund.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Carana on April 24, 2016, 02:54:11 PM
Mr Amaral's intention seems to be to ensure there is no money available to continue the search for Madeleine; that is if he follows through on his threat to sue the McCanns for having the audacity to sue him for libelling them.
So you are happy that if the couple appeal to the Supreme Court the fund is used to pay for that litigation and if Amaral does sue the McCanns for them to pay their lawyers with money from the fund too ? Isn't it more important to say the money to pay PIs ?
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: pathfinder73 on April 24, 2016, 02:57:45 PM
If that's the case, how is Amaral helping to find what happened to Madeleine?
One is by asking to get them back to do a reconstruction. Man that would be a great way to unlock the secrets and prove the discrepancies in their timeline.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: faithlilly on April 24, 2016, 03:01:49 PM
That would depend on the validity of the arguments in dispute, wouldn't it?
So you believe they should gamble the money in the fund, money that could pay PIs, on the very remote chance that the Supreme Court will overturn the appeal judge's decision ? what good would that do the search for Madeleine now ?
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Carana on April 24, 2016, 03:10:52 PM
So you believe they should gamble the money in the fund, money that could pay PIs, on the very remote chance that the Supreme Court will overturn the appeal judge's decision ? what good would that do the search for Madeleine now ?
How on earth can you assert that I said that, if you take into account my previous post, based on the fact that we are only allowed to quote one post on here. I didn't say that, did I?
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: jassi on April 24, 2016, 03:13:04 PM
I have yet to work out what exactly the basis for suing the McCanns might be... and in which jurisdiction he would intend to proceed if so.
I suppose that would be for Amaral & his lawyers to determine. I can't see any benefit in suing in a Portuguese court, as even if successful, the McCanns have no assets in Portugal and the verdict would have no validity in UK .
Suing in UK could be costly unless he had a rich backer willing to take the risk of losing.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Carana on April 24, 2016, 03:14:22 PM
Here we go, Faithlilly.
This is my previous reply to your question, in case you missed it.
Re: Litigation v The Search « Reply #7 on: Today at 02:40:53 PM »
Quote from: Faithlilly on Today at 01:03:28 PM
Not sure what other information you need Carana. The question is straightforward. Do you believe more money should be spent on litigation or held back in case OG is disbanded ?
[Me] I can't answer that without more information.
If filing a suit doesn't actually cost much, then I don't see why not, if there is a reasoned case to put forward.
If simply filing a case were to amount to a substantial proportion of the funds to continue to search for Madeleine, then... no.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: faithlilly on April 24, 2016, 03:14:54 PM
How on earth can you assert that I said that, if you take into account my previous post, based on the fact that we are only allowed to quote one post on here. I didn't say that, did I?
Any litigation is a gamble, no matter how strong the legal arguments.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: faithlilly on April 24, 2016, 03:16:42 PM
This is my previous reply to your question, in case you missed it.
Re: Litigation v The Search « Reply #7 on: Today at 02:40:53 PM »
Quote from: Faithlilly on Today at 01:03:28 PM
Not sure what other information you need Carana. The question is straightforward. Do you believe more money should be spent on litigation or held back in case OG is disbanded ?
[Me] I can't answer that without more information.
If filing a suit doesn't actually cost much, then I don't see why not, if there is a reasoned case to put forward.
If simply filing a case were to amount to a substantial proportion of the funds to continue to search for Madeleine, then... no.
This is what you posted Carana :
That would depend on the validity of the arguments in dispute, wouldn't it?
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: jassi on April 24, 2016, 03:17:24 PM
This is my previous reply to your question, in case you missed it.
Re: Litigation v The Search « Reply #7 on: Today at 02:40:53 PM »
Quote from: Faithlilly on Today at 01:03:28 PM
Not sure what other information you need Carana. The question is straightforward. Do you believe more money should be spent on litigation or held back in case OG is disbanded ?
[Me] I can't answer that without more information.
If filing a suit doesn't actually cost much, then I don't see why not, if there is a reasoned case to put forward.
If simply filing a case were to amount to a substantial proportion of the funds to continue to search for Madeleine, then... no.
How could they even contemplate using fund money for that purpose?
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Carana on April 24, 2016, 03:19:53 PM
Again.. How much would it cost to simply file a complaint?
You haven't answered that question.
I haven't examined it, have you?
Let's take it one step at a time. Are you in agreement with the McCanns gambling more of the fund money on the chance that the Supreme Court will take a different view of the case than that of the three appeal judges ?
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Carana on April 24, 2016, 03:32:11 PM
Let's take it one step at a time. Are you in agreement with the McCanns gambling more of the fund money on the chance that the Supreme Court will take a different view of the case than that of the three appeal judges ?
Until you tell me how much it would cost to simply file a counter-appeal, and what the arguments of an appeal would be, I have no way of forming an opinion.
ETA: If Amaral is intending to have a new media blitz insisting on his largely discredited "thesis", and if whatever he or his pals say are likely to be taken as credible, yet again, then I can understand that filing an appeal may be deemed worthwhile.. or perhaps not.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: G-Unit on April 24, 2016, 03:50:05 PM
The first step is to exhaust all the appeal procedures of the country involved. Only then can someone apply to the ECHR.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: faithlilly on April 24, 2016, 03:54:53 PM
Until you tell me how much it would cost to simply file a counter-appeal, and what the arguments of an appeal would be, I have no way of forming an opinion.
ETA: If Amaral is intending to have a new media blitz insisting on his largely discredited "thesis", and if whatever he or his pals say are likely to be taken as credible, yet again, then I can understand that filing an appeal may be deemed worthwhile.. or perhaps not.
Isn't any amount from the fund too much to spend on what will more than likely be a failed endeavour ? It can make no difference to the search for Madeleine now so is it just a case of chasing the money ?
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Carana on April 24, 2016, 04:07:53 PM
Isn't any amount from the fund too much to spend on what will more than likely be a failed endeavour ? It can make no difference to the search for Madeleine now so is it just a case of chasing the money ?
What do you consider too much if you are desperately seeking help to find your child and find that some cop with a suspended sentence over his only other missing child case has a following insisting that your child is dead and that you covered it up, and that therefore she isn't worth looking for?
Luckily, two police investigations are now open, so his spoutings may not be as damaging to the search as they were before.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: jassi on April 24, 2016, 04:09:26 PM
Isn't any amount from the fund too much to spend on what will more than likely be a failed endeavour ? It can make no difference to the search for Madeleine now so is it just a case of chasing the money ?
I see their problem as being that if they do not attempt to lodge an appeal, then they are seen as having given up. Being very much an alpha male, Gerry would find this extremely difficult to do. Being defeated is bad enough for them, but no making the attempt is worse than defeat. If the appeal application is rejected, then there are a number of excuses to provide balm for bruised ego. I reckon they will attempt to lodge the appeal, irrespective of cost.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: jassi on April 24, 2016, 04:12:56 PM
What do you consider too much if you are desperately seeking help to find your child and find that some cop with a suspended sentence over his only other missing child case has a following insisting that your child is dead and that you covered it up, and that therefore she isn't worth looking for? Luckily, two police investigations are now open, so his spoutings may not be as damaging to the search as they were before.
Does that not weaken the McCann case? - the search continues irrespective of Amaral's activities.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Alice Purjorick on April 24, 2016, 04:24:36 PM
I see their problem as being that if they do not attempt to lodge an appeal, then they are seen as having given up. Being very much an alpha male, Gerry would find this extremely difficult to do. Being defeated is bad enough for them, but no making the attempt is worse than defeat. If the appeal application is rejected, then there are a number of excuses to provide balm for bruised ego. I reckon they will attempt to lodge the appeal, irrespective of cost.
I agree totally.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Carana on April 24, 2016, 04:38:52 PM
There are two investigations open NOW, but not at the time.
The case has dragged on so long that that may now be irrelevant, though it would have been if it had been completed before Operation Grange got underway.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Carana on April 24, 2016, 04:53:05 PM
The case has dragged on so long that that may now be irrelevant, though it would have been if it had been completed before Operation Grange got underway.
"Completed"??
Madeleine is still missing.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: jassi on April 24, 2016, 04:53:54 PM
I see their problem as being that if they do not attempt to lodge an appeal, then they are seen as having given up. Being very much an alpha male, Gerry would find this extremely difficult to do. Being defeated is bad enough for them, but no making the attempt is worse than defeat. If the appeal application is rejected, then there are a number of excuses to provide balm for bruised ego. I reckon they will attempt to lodge the appeal, irrespective of cost.
Unfortunately I think you're absolutely right jassi.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: stephen25000 on April 24, 2016, 05:15:02 PM
deleted.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Lace on April 24, 2016, 05:24:31 PM
And the McCann's appeal to the Supreme Court ? Is that worth the lawyer's fees when it has already been judged that the book didn't harm the search ?
It couldn't be PROVEN that his book didn't harm the search, and how could it be proven, who is to know if there were people who didn't ring with information because they believed Madeleine to be dead.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Lace on April 24, 2016, 05:28:03 PM
I see their problem as being that if they do not attempt to lodge an appeal, then they are seen as having given up. Being very much an alpha male, Gerry would find this extremely difficult to do. Being defeated is bad enough for them, but no making the attempt is worse than defeat. If the appeal application is rejected, then there are a number of excuses to provide balm for bruised ego. I reckon they will attempt to lodge the appeal, irrespective of cost.
I am more than likely to think that it would be a lawyer who suggests the next move, puts it to the McCann's then they decide whether they will or not, if the Lawyer is saying it is worth a go then I think the McCann's would go for it.
Their main concern though by what they have stated is their continual search for Madeleine and bringing her home.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: pathfinder73 on April 24, 2016, 05:34:15 PM
It couldn't be PROVEN that his book didn't harm the search, and how could it be proven, who is to know if there were people who didn't ring with information because they believed Madeleine to be dead.
Doesn't look like it.
OG looked at 8,685 potential sightings of Madeleine around the world.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: John on April 24, 2016, 05:58:43 PM
While supporters seem happy that the McCanns plan to take the case against Amaral all the way to the ECHR they must know that it will be expensive to continue such litigation. My question is that if the McCanns fail in their bid to overturn the appeal court verdict and Amaral does in fact sue them will supporters be happy for the fund to be used to cover the litigation costs of the McCanns and Amaral's damages or do they feel that it is more important, if OG is wound down, that the money in the fund is kept exclusively to further the search ?
I cannot see any further appeal getting anywhere. I think the threat of such action is merely a knee-jerk reaction to the Appeal Court's decison.
The Portuguese Supreme Court will only be interested in principal points of Law and not in the mechanics of any squabble between the McCanns and Goncalo Amaral. The Lisbon Appeal Court has done all the donkey work so I find it very unlikely that the Supreme Court will do anything other than rubber stamp that decision.
Similiarly, the ECHR is only interested in the Articles of the Human Rights Act and whether they have been compromised in any way by a State within the EU, they are not interested in law suits.
In attempting to block Amaral's book the McCann's have unintentionally given those who doubt them ammunition. Why run scared, let him publish his book and then publish their own book countering his claims. They are entitled to express their opinion in just the same way as Amaral is.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Lace on April 24, 2016, 06:02:19 PM
OG looked at 8,685 potential sightings of Madeleine around the world.
Amaral's book came out early on, who is to know that someone could have given information that they knew and was put off because it was stated Madeleine was dead? It may not have been a sighting.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: stephen25000 on April 24, 2016, 06:03:10 PM
Perhaps Duarte should get out whilst the going is good John.
She should have advised her clients of this already.
As you say , they have given a knee jerk reaction in anger.
They mccanns have nowhere to go.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: jassi on April 24, 2016, 06:05:12 PM
Amaral's book came out early on, who is to know that someone could have given information that they knew and was put off because it was stated Madeleine was dead? It may not have been a sighting.
Maybe that hypothetical, unknown person didn't read his book anyway, so wasn't swayed by his views.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: John on April 24, 2016, 06:07:49 PM
Further litigation will be extremely costly both in financial terms and also in terms of the litigants well being with the possibility that the loser or losers could end up bankrupt. Regardless however, Amaral is signalling his intention to sue for damages which will be very costly for the McCanns both financially and in the credibiity stakes. The sensible thing for them will be to take stock and consider their options very very carefully.
If Amaral sues, the consequences for any further search could be dire.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: jassi on April 24, 2016, 06:15:28 PM
Further litigation will be extremely costly both in financial terms and also in terms of the litigants well being with the possibility that the loser or losers could end up bankrupt. Regardless however, Amaral is signalling his intention to sue for damages which will be very costly for the McCanns both financially and in the credibiity stakes. The sensible thing for them will be to take stock and consider their options very very carefully.
If Amaral sues, the consequences for any further search could be dire.
Can't see how that can be as he would not be suing the fund, which remain untouched. It would be the McCanns who would be out of pocket if he won.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: stephen25000 on April 24, 2016, 06:21:36 PM
I cannot see any further appeal getting anywhere. I think the threat of such action is merely a knee-jerk reaction to the Appeal Court's decison.
The Portuguese Supreme Court will only be interested in principal points of Law and not in the mechanics of any squabble between the McCanns and Goncalo Amaral. The Lisbon Appeal Court has done all the donkey work so I find it very unlikely that the Supreme Court will do anything other than rubber stamp that decision.
Similiarly, the ECHR is only interested in the Articles of the Human Rights Act and whether they have been compromised in any way by a State within the EU, they are not interested in law suits.
In attempting to block Amaral's book the McCann's have unintentionally given those who doubt them ammunition. Why run scared, let him publish his book and then publish their own book countering his claims. They are entitled to express their opinion in just the same way as Amaral is.
I disagree John on the basis that the ECHR is also concerned with the right to good name. If the portugues court allow amaral to defame the McCanns ..as he has done,,,then this is in the scope of the court. The Supreme court have the opportunity to put things right and Duarte has let them know that if they don't then the McCanns are prepared to go to Europe
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: stephen25000 on April 24, 2016, 06:32:10 PM
I disagree John on the basis that the ECHR is also concerned with the right to good name. If the portugues court allow amaral to defame the McCanns ..as he has done,,,then this is in the scope of the court. The Supreme court have the opportunity to put things right and Duarte has let them know that if they don't then the McCanns are prepared to go to Europe
You do realize that effectively the mccanns would have to take the Portuguese State to the ECHR ?
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Brietta on April 24, 2016, 06:33:34 PM
Further litigation will be extremely costly both in financial terms and also in terms of the litigants well being with the possibility that the loser or losers could end up bankrupt. Regardless however, Amaral is signalling his intention to sue for damages which will be very costly for the McCanns both financially and in the credibiity stakes. The sensible thing for them will be to take stock and consider their options very very carefully.
If Amaral sues, the consequences for any further search could be dire.
I don't see any way amaral can sue...the mcCanns case was legitimate ...proven by the fact that a judge has awarded them damages. Everything at the moment is speculation
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: jassi on April 24, 2016, 06:36:07 PM
I disagree John on the basis that the ECHR is also concerned with the right to good name. If the portugues court allow amaral to defame the McCanns ..as he has done,,,then this is in the scope of the court. The Supreme court have the opportunity to put things right and Duarte has let them know that if they don't then the McCanns are prepared to go to Europe
Do you think they will pay much attention to threats from a two-bit lawyer?
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: stephen25000 on April 24, 2016, 06:37:28 PM
I don't see any way amaral can sue...the mcCanns case was legitimate ...proven by the fact that a judge has awarded them damages. Everything at the moment is speculation
The Court of Appeal saying the McCanns claim was unfounded isn't speculation. It's written in the judgement.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: stephen25000 on April 24, 2016, 06:41:06 PM
The Court of Appeal saying the McCanns claim was unfounded isn't speculation. It's written in the judgement.
Are you just trying to be awkward,,,shall I correct my statement to say what happens from now is speculation...it is pretty obvious that which has already happened is not speculation
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Alice Purjorick on April 24, 2016, 06:49:11 PM
Are you just trying to be awkward,,,shall I correct my statement to say what happens from now is speculation...it is pretty obvious that which has already happened is not speculation
Don't bother. But just to remind you: you said the McCanns case was legitimate. The court of appeal did not agree.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Mr Gray on April 24, 2016, 06:58:07 PM
Don't bother. But just to remind you: you said the McCanns case was legitimate. The court of appeal did not agree.
where in the judgement does it say the McCann case was not legitimate. The point I am making is that the case was not vexatious and must have had some legitimacy for the mccanns to have been awarded compensation in the first instance. As regards speculation...we do not know yet whether an appeal will be heard or whether an appeal to the supreme court will be successful...thus everything going forward is speculation..
Will the mccanns lose and appeal to the ECHR...will they be successful...more speculation
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: stephen25000 on April 24, 2016, 07:07:38 PM
where in the judgement does it say the McCann case was not legitimate. The point I am making is that the case was not vexatious and must have had some legitimacy for the mccanns to have been awarded compensation in the first instance. As regards speculation...we do not know yet whether an appeal will be heard or whether an appeal to the supreme court will be successful...thus everything going forward is speculation..
Will the mccanns lose and appeal to the ECHR...will they be successful...more speculation
Do some research before you make more brash comments.
It is becoming abundantly clear, the mccanns have reached the end of the road.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: jassi on April 24, 2016, 07:15:34 PM
If they lose at the Supreme court, that decision will stand, irrespective anything at the ECHR.
Any application to the ECHR is not an appeal, but a fresh case, based on a different argument
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Alice Purjorick on April 24, 2016, 07:17:48 PM
where in the judgement does it say the McCann case was not legitimate. The point I am making is that the case was not vexatious and must have had some legitimacy for the mccanns to have been awarded compensation in the first instance. As regards speculation...we do not know yet whether an appeal will be heard or whether an appeal to the supreme court will be successful...thus everything going forward is speculation..
Will the mccanns lose and appeal to the ECHR...will they be successful...more speculation
They will have to take the state of Portugal to the ECHR. On what basis do you think they will do that?
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: mercury on April 24, 2016, 11:45:03 PM
Mr Amaral's intention seems to be to ensure there is no money available to continue the search for Madeleine; that is if he follows through on his threat to sue the McCanns for having the audacity to sue him for libelling them.
well, its the mccanns that are spending their fund money, not him...hmmmm
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: John on April 25, 2016, 10:07:52 AM
To all members.
It is noticeable that the equilibrium of the forum has been somewhat disturbed since the McCann v Amaral appeal decision from Lisbon was announced. This is to be expected and has left moderators with a substantial amount of work to do cleaning up the threads. This will now STOP!
I am putting everyone on notice from this point on that continued disruption, goading, abuse or any conduct contrary to the forum rules will now be met with sanctions including temporary bans. Please take heed of this warning.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: faithlilly on April 25, 2016, 11:45:40 AM
Further litigation will be extremely costly both in financial terms and also in terms of the litigants well being with the possibility that the loser or losers could end up bankrupt. Regardless however, Amaral is signalling his intention to sue for damages which will be very costly for the McCanns both financially and in the credibiity stakes. The sensible thing for them will be to take stock and consider their options very very carefully.
If Amaral sues, the consequences for any further search could be dire.
Not if he sues them personally.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Carana on April 25, 2016, 03:17:12 PM
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: ChloeR on April 25, 2016, 03:36:06 PM
IMO the fund money should be solely used on searching for Madeleine.
I do not think money from the book, suing people and stuff should have gone into the fund unless it was earmarked only for finding the child, but if not added to the fund surelythey could have been used for the search without actually going into the fund anyway...
If that makes sense.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Brietta on April 25, 2016, 03:57:05 PM
IMO the fund money should be solely used on searching for Madeleine.
I do not think money from the book, suing people and stuff should have gone into the fund unless it was earmarked only for finding the child, but if not added to the fund surelythey could have been used for the search without actually going into the fund anyway...
If that makes sense.
At the moment the fund money is an irrelevance as far as the search for Madeleine is concerned.
The British Government have spent a much complained about sum on the search, and now that the bulk of the work has been done have been granted a reduced sum to carry on the active investigation.
Similarly the Portuguese have committed resources both in money and personnel to their continued search for Madeleine.
These two investigations are the best chance that Madeleine McCann has of either being found or finding out what happened to her. What is left in the fund or what could be raised in the future could never approach the two ongoing official searches for her.
The fund which was instrumental in alone keeping Madeleine's case relevant to the general public and most important of all as a thorn in the side of government eventually forcing them to take action to instruct a review of Madeleine's case which led to it being reopened ... has, in effect served its purpose.
There has never been the slightest evidence that it is "fraudulent" ... I find the derogatory attention it receives nothing short of extraordinary given the success it has had. I am also thankful that I never had to contemplate using such a vehicle to assist me to search for my daughter and would never denigrate those who have successfully done so.
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: xtina on April 25, 2016, 04:01:08 PM
totally agree...he has been threatening to sue for years...it would be interesting to know the basis of his appeal...if indeed there are any
if the mccs hadn't wanted money made from profit of the book and to vindictivly make Amaral penniless...this would have all gone away years ago ...
the book would have probably been history now ....instead of it being brought up constantly ...for even those who knew nothing of it.....now want to read it ....
they are the ones who keep raking it up ..[not that I'M bothered like ]
they should have probably gone for just having it banned .end of book ......but no not that pair ....it has to be maximum dollars ..like everything they do
they are responsible for starting it ...........and were they are today....still promoting the book
its about time they started to pay for there own legal fees ....same as everyone else has to .instead of expecting ...hand outs ...or other people to pay for what .they did.
all about them....maddie is getting left .further and further behind...the one who suffered most ....because of them
Title: Re: Litigation v The Search
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on April 26, 2016, 09:30:29 PM
At the moment the fund money is an irrelevance as far as the search for Madeleine is concerned.
The British Government have spent a much complained about sum on the search, and now that the bulk of the work has been done have been granted a reduced sum to carry on the active investigation.
Similarly the Portuguese have committed resources both in money and personnel to their continued search for Madeleine.
These two investigations are the best chance that Madeleine McCann has of either being found or finding out what happened to her. What is left in the fund or what could be raised in the future could never approach the two ongoing official searches for her.
The fund which was instrumental in alone keeping Madeleine's case relevant to the general public and most important of all as a thorn in the side of government eventually forcing them to take action to instruct a review of Madeleine's case which led to it being reopened ... has, in effect served its purpose.
There has never been the slightest evidence that it is "fraudulent" ... I find the derogatory attention it receives nothing short of extraordinary given the success it has had. I am also thankful that I never had to contemplate using such a vehicle to assist me to search for my daughter and would never denigrate those who have successfully done so.
I would disagree about it being irrelevant, it is very relevant. Supporters have at every corner decried the fact that Amaral was out to make money from Maddie, without cross referencing the parents, who also made money and did not spend it wisely. Some People who gave to the fund feel they were helping to 'find Maddie' not to Fund Gerry!To help seek an abductor not seek legal reps and PR to protect the parents reputation, yes people do feel the fund is a fraud, and the money being misused.
Very relevant why do they need to spend millions on their 'image' and reputation? you lose it you lose it no point crying over spilled milk. They were nobodies and now they are just nobodies with a healthier bank account since their daughters disappearance..