UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: pegasus on April 24, 2016, 01:57:59 PM

Title: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 24, 2016, 01:57:59 PM
In the C4 film is the "secret cardinal" really someone the private investigators are watching?
Or is he, too, a private investigator?
And what is that staff for actually?

18
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 25, 2016, 12:52:37 AM
Here are 3 accounts of people dressed as priests. One of them is fiction, the other two are true and relate to this case.

1. "(they) stood on a carpet of rose petals as the minister read vows from a leather-bound notebook and pronounced them husband and wife. What the guests didn’t know was that the minister was ... a professional actor"

2. "One day Z, in what I can only assume was a moment of weakness, let the self-appointed ‘Lord’s Helper’ into the house. He was a tall, elderly gentleman sporting a wooden crucifix"

3. "I spent a few minutes in assisting a venerable Italian priest, who was endeavoring to make a porter understand, in his broken English, that his luggage was to be booked through to Paris"

Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: misty on April 25, 2016, 01:13:57 AM
Here are 3 accounts of people dressed as priests. One of them is fiction, the other two are true and relate to this case.

1. "(they) stood on a carpet of rose petals as the minister read vows from a leather-bound notebook and pronounced them husband and wife. What the guests didn’t know was that the minister was ... a professional actor"

2. "One day Z, in what I can only assume was a moment of weakness, let the self-appointed ‘Lord’s Helper’ into the house. He was a tall, elderly gentleman sporting a wooden crucifix"

3. "I spent a few minutes in assisting a venerable Italian priest, who was endeavoring to make a porter understand, in his broken English, that his luggage was to be booked through to Paris"

You & your riddles!
1 = Halligan's fake wedding
2. From Kate's book page 309 re Gerry letting someone into the house
3. From Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes

so 3 is the fiction.

Is the  "real" Secret Cardinal still in Luz?
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 25, 2016, 01:44:23 AM
You & your riddles!
1 = Halligan's fake wedding
2. From Kate's book page 309 re Gerry letting someone into the house
3. From Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes

so 3 is the fiction.

Is the  "real" Secret Cardinal still in Luz?
3 out of 3.
In that documentary remember that all the info about the 5-person undercover PI activity in PDL came from one of the PIs. Do you really imagine that info contains no obfuscation? Really? IMO the "secret cardinal" was possibly one of the PIs Misty.



Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: misty on April 25, 2016, 02:14:31 AM
3 out of 3.
In that documentary remember that all the info about the 5-person undercover PI activity in PDL came from one of the PIs. Do you really imagine that info contains no obfuscation? Really? IMO the "secret cardinal" was possibly one of the PIs Misty.

You may well be right. I've just looked at the footage again (8m48 onward) & the 1st cardinal's staff is just a long pole. Looking at the Wiki page for crosiers, each faith seems to have a different shaped top so either the secret cardinal is a loony with a light sabre or a poorly-disguised "plant as you suggest. No suggestion he's Metado 3, I guess?
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 25, 2016, 02:22:05 AM
You may well be right. I've just looked at the footage again (8m48 onward) & the 1st cardinal's staff is just a long pole. Looking at the Wiki page for crosiers, each faith seems to have a different shaped top so either the secret cardinal is a loony with a light sabre or a poorly-disguised "plant as you suggest. No suggestion he's Metado 3, I guess?
If two PI firms were running separate undercover ops in PDL unbeknownest to each other, and the drunken priest of one PI firm and the secret cardinal of the other firm were both following and covertly filming each other, that really would be PLF/LFP wouldn't it?
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: misty on April 25, 2016, 02:56:53 AM
If two PI firms were running separate undercover ops in PDL unbeknownest to each other, and the drunken priest of one PI firm and the secret cardinal of the other firm were both following and covertly filming each other, that really would be PLF/LFP wouldn't it?


You've lost me now. What is PLF/LFP, please?
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 25, 2016, 03:17:38 AM
You've lost me now. What is PLF/LFP, please?
It's a reference to several firms operating in the same town in Life of Brian Misty.
But seriously, although M3's contract was still running, this undercover op in PDL was entirely the UK/US outfit IMO.
1. The priest with the bible they admit is a PI. In one scene he knocks on a door and does a great big sign of the cross. In another scene he engages customers in a cafe in Luztur building in a rather animated conversation.
2. "Andy" is obviously very real, no way is he a PI.
3. The "secret cardinal" with a staff is presented in the film as a suspect the PIs are watching, however IMO he is one of the same team of PIs. BTW did you see him in the sea at night?
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: misty on April 25, 2016, 03:32:36 AM
It's a reference to several firms operating in the same town in Life of Brian Misty.
But seriously, although M3's contract was still running, this undercover op in PDL was entirely the UK/US outfit IMO.
1. The priest with the bible they admit is a PI. In one scene he knocks on a door and does a great big sign of the cross. In another scene he engages customers in a cafe in Luztur building in a rather animated conversation.
2. "Andy" is obviously very real, no way is he a PI.
3. The "secret cardinal" with a staff is presented in the film as a suspect the PIs are watching, however IMO he is one of the same team of PIs. BTW did you see him in the sea at night?

Thanks for that. I must be one of the few people who hasn't seen LOB - not a Python fan at all.

I didn't spot the cardinal n the sea, I will look again tomorrow. I had to watch a shortened YouTube version tonight as I can't remember my C5 log-in details.
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 25, 2016, 03:44:59 AM
http://youtu.be/vphKz-Xjbn0?t=9m44s Misty, wading in the sea with a pole
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: slartibartfast on April 25, 2016, 07:28:25 AM
It's a reference to several firms operating in the same town in Life of Brian Misty.
But seriously, although M3's contract was still running, this undercover op in PDL was entirely the UK/US outfit IMO.
1. The priest with the bible they admit is a PI. In one scene he knocks on a door and does a great big sign of the cross. In another scene he engages customers in a cafe in Luztur building in a rather animated conversation.
2. "Andy" is obviously very real, no way is he a PI.
3. The "secret cardinal" with a staff is presented in the film as a suspect the PIs are watching, however IMO he is one of the same team of PIs. BTW did you see him in the sea at night?

3 what was he flashing?
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on April 25, 2016, 10:49:34 AM
Thanks for that. I must be one of the few people who hasn't seen LOB - not a Python fan at all.

I didn't spot the cardinal n the sea, I will look again tomorrow. I had to watch a shortened YouTube version tonight as I can't remember my C5 log-in details.

That's one thing we have in common ......  now there's a thing ?{)(**
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: misty on April 25, 2016, 11:39:07 AM
http://youtu.be/vphKz-Xjbn0?t=9m44s Misty, wading in the sea with a pole


Thanks, Pegasus. I do remember seeing that scene now, it just didn't really register at the time. Playing to the camera, was he?

BTW Did a monkey really escape from the Enigma garden?
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: misty on April 25, 2016, 11:41:02 AM
That's one thing we have in common ......  now there's a thing ?{)(**

I'm not sure if that's good or bad, Alice. 8**8:/:
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 25, 2016, 12:57:38 PM
3 what was he flashing?
He was not flashing anything Slarti
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 25, 2016, 01:14:55 PM
Thanks, Pegasus. I do remember seeing that scene now, it just didn't really register at the time. Playing to the camera, was he? (snip)
If you do a frame by frame examination you will see exactly why he is wading in the sea at night with a long pole Misty.
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: misty on April 25, 2016, 03:55:20 PM
If you do a frame by frame examination you will see exactly why he is wading in the sea at night with a long pole Misty.

I can see he removes something from his pocket. Is he killing fish, or what? Is that him picking up something at the tideline in an earlier shot?
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 25, 2016, 04:26:48 PM
I can see he removes something from his pocket. Is he killing fish, or what? Is that him picking up something at the tideline in an earlier shot?
The reason for wading out into the sea with a pole is elementary Misty, it is to probe down beneath the surface of the submerged sand with the pole. You can see him do it if you advance one frame at a time.
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: slartibartfast on April 25, 2016, 05:10:37 PM
He was not flashing anything Slarti

Cardinals in the sea at night usually do.
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: Brietta on April 25, 2016, 06:16:18 PM
The reason for wading out into the sea with a pole is elementary Misty, it is to probe down beneath the surface of the submerged sand with the pole. You can see him do it if you advance one frame at a time.

No-one in Luz noticed a Cardinal probing the sand in the dark?  It would have been the talk of the wash house had it happened where I live.

I don't really see the point.  Firstly because burying anything in the sand doesn't guarantee that the next storm won't uncover it ... looking for something buried while the tide is in ... absolutely pointless.

People dig on beaches at quiet times around dusk and sunrise depending on the tide looking for bait.  If searching surreptitiously for a buried object that would be how and when to go about it without attracting comment ... as long as you swapped the Cardinal hat for something more appropriate.
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 25, 2016, 07:45:33 PM
No-one in Luz noticed a Cardinal probing the sand in the dark?  It would have been the talk of the wash house had it happened where I live. (snip)
Remember we have no posters on this forum who lived in Luz during this 6 week 5 person covert op paid for by the MF.
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on April 25, 2016, 07:56:58 PM
Remember we have no posters on this forum who lived in Luz during this 6 week 5 person covert op paid for by the MF.
Then would you kindly educate me as to the why, when, who etc. of this mission and I will put my listening ears on.

To date, in 4+ years I have not seen a single priest on the streets of Luz, let alone a cardinal.  Such 'disguises' would attract a lot of attention.  And I've never heard of involvement by a dodgy priest, a dodgy cardinal or a team of 5 PIs on a 6 week tour of Luz.

So if you like to feed me the basics, I will be happy to drop it into conversation with the locals to see what trawls up.
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 25, 2016, 08:13:45 PM
Then would you kindly educate me as to the why, when, who etc. of this mission and I will put my listening ears on.

To date, in 4+ years I have not seen a single priest on the streets of Luz, let alone a cardinal.  Such 'disguises' would attract a lot of attention.  And I've never heard of involvement by a dodgy priest, a dodgy cardinal or a team of 5 PIs on a 6 week tour of Luz.

So if you like to feed me the basics, I will be happy to drop it into conversation with the locals to see what trawls up.
The covert op certainly happened Shining, I don't know the exact dates yet but maybe mid 2008??? Certainly some people in Luz will have seen the odd priest with the book (definitely a PI).
Just one example, if the cafe PDD in Luztur still has the same owner they would certainly remember him going in there IMO. Also any staff at the church now who were also staff in 2008 would probably remember both characters.
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 25, 2016, 08:42:19 PM
A strange question, did Sherlock Holmes ever visit a client's residence in disguise?
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on April 25, 2016, 09:17:51 PM
The covert op certainly happened Shining, I don't know the exact dates yet but maybe mid 2008??? Certainly some people in Luz will have seen the odd priest with the book (definitely a PI).
Just one example, if the cafe PDD in Luztur still has the same owner they would certainly remember him going in there IMO. Also any staff at the church now who were also staff in 2008 would probably remember both characters.
Is PDD Polly's? Just asking, cos I'm much more likely to drop into Polly's for a coffee and mention visiting priests than I am to try my luck with it in the church.

With a bit of luck, I've got another visitor to Luz arriving in the next week or so, hence the more gunpowder the better.
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 25, 2016, 10:39:56 PM
Is PDD Polly's? Just asking, cos I'm much more likely to drop into Polly's for a coffee and mention visiting priests than I am to try my luck with it in the church.

With a bit of luck, I've got another visitor to Luz arriving in the next week or so, hence the more gunpowder the better.
No I mean this one Shining. Silhouetted figure inside on left is an MF undercover priest.
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on April 26, 2016, 12:33:37 AM
No I mean this one Shining. Silhouetted figure inside on left is an MF undercover priest.
Looks like that one may be on the coffee shop round next time I'm in town, as long as there is no hint of disguising as a priest.  I'm not up for that.
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: misty on April 26, 2016, 01:53:25 AM
The reason for wading out into the sea with a pole is elementary Misty, it is to probe down beneath the surface of the submerged sand with the pole. You can see him do it if you advance one frame at a time.

Unless he's prodding to release submerged marine life, or trying to part the waters, I've no idea, Pegasus.
I understand that beach fishing is illegal without a licence & during the high season.
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: misty on April 26, 2016, 02:37:23 AM
A strange question, did Sherlock Holmes ever visit a client's residence in disguise?

Are you likening Andy the homeless ex-pat to Holmes in A Scandal in Bohemia?

ETA Are you thinking that the whole Halligen investigation film footage was based on the use of actors, right down to the  questioning of JT? One massive con?
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 26, 2016, 12:11:27 PM
Are you likening Andy the homeless ex-pat to Holmes in A Scandal in Bohemia?

ETA Are you thinking that the whole Halligen investigation film footage was based on the use of actors, right down to the  questioning of JT? One massive con?
No I am referring to another incident. Imagine you answer your doorbell and on your doorstep is some kind of religious eccentric with a cross the size of Luton hanging round his neck. What is the one thing you would not do next Misty?
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: Carana on April 26, 2016, 12:25:43 PM
Looks like that one may be on the coffee shop round next time I'm in town, as long as there is no hint of disguising as a priest.  I'm not up for that.

I expect we could fit you up as a nun. Would that do? ;)
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: misty on April 26, 2016, 02:59:33 PM
No I am referring to another incident. Imagine you answer your doorbell and on your doorstep is some kind of religious eccentric with a cross the size of Luton hanging round his neck. What is the one thing you would not do next Misty?

I certainly wouldn't allow him across the threshold unless my daughter's head was spinning through 360° & she emitting green vomit.
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 26, 2016, 03:25:57 PM
I certainly wouldn't allow him across the threshold unless my daughter's head was spinning through 360° & she emitting green vomit.
Thanks Misty, a wonderfully colourful description, but can you imagine any real reason you might invite him in?
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: misty on April 26, 2016, 03:35:32 PM
Thanks Misty, a wonderfully colourful description, but can you imagine any real reason you might invite him in?

In Gerry's shoes - only if he was clutching a photograph of Madeleine with a stranger or there was already a police presence in the house. What is your opinion?
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: pegasus on April 26, 2016, 04:05:32 PM
In Gerry's shoes - only if he was clutching a photograph of Madeleine with a stranger or there was already a police presence in the house. What is your opinion?
The only way I would invite in an apparantly disturbed person wearing a state-sized crucifix would be if I knew them Misty.
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on April 26, 2016, 04:12:52 PM
The only way I would invite in an apparantly disturbed person wearing a state-sized crucifix would be if I knew them Misty.
Is all this the Portuguese/Spanish version of the Welsh joke that ends "Oh boyo you will be wanting Jones the Spy".
Title: Re: Was the Secret Cardinal really an undercover detective?
Post by: misty on April 26, 2016, 04:23:09 PM
The only way I would invite in an apparantly disturbed person wearing a state-sized crucifix would be if I knew them Misty.

You are too trusting, Pegasus.
Why did the documentary keep showing the Secret Cardinal's face next to what was clearly an efit of MAG?