UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: stephen25000 on April 25, 2016, 09:43:59 PM
-
It is quite clear by now, no trace of Madeleine has been found.
The mccanns claim no harm has come to her, which beggars all belief.
At various times it has been said she was taken by a paedophile(s), or taken to be given to another family. Yet not one jot of evidence exists to show either of these two happened.
So why do some claim, she is still alive ?
Is it a genuine belief, or is it merely a way of defending the mccanns, and ignoring the most likely conclusion, that she died some time ago ?
Those that claim she is dead are often called heartless or worse.
Others look at what happened, including me , and see with the clear lack of evidence of any trail of her since May the 3 rd 2007, there is only one logical conclusion.
-
It is quite clear by now, no trace of Madeleine has been found.
The mccanns claim no harm has come to her, which beggars all belief.
At various times it has been said she was taken by a paedophile(s), or taken to be given to another family. Yet not one jot of evidence exists to show either of these two happened.
So why do some claim, she is still alive ?
Is it a genuine belief, or is it merely a way of defending the mccanns, and ignoring the most likely conclusion, that she died some time ago ?
Those that claim she is dead are often called heartless or worse.
Others look at what happened, including me , and see with the clear lack of evidence of any trail of her since May the 3 rd 2007, there is only one logical conclusion.
I don' know one poster on here who thinks Maddie is still alive
So who are you referring to
-
I don' know one poster on here who thinks Maddie is still alive
So who are you referring to
Then read around on the forum tonight.
-
I happen to think the probability that she is alive is not high, for many reasons.
But I happen to think she is alive is the most probable of the options.
It is not a case of either hope or belief in my instance. It is simply a case or working through the odds and evaluating all the scenarios. From that, the most likely one is that she is alive, IMO of course.
-
I happen to think the probability that she is alive is not high, for many reasons.
But I happen to think she is alive is the most probable of the options.
It is not a case of either hope or belief in my instance. It is simply a case or working through the odds and evaluating all the scenarios. From that, the most likely one is that she is alive, IMO of course.
Thank you. Your post exactly replicates my feelings.
-
Then read around on the forum tonight.
You are totally confused
Posters here believe she may be alive
Not that she is
-
I happen to think the probability that she is alive is not high, for many reasons.
But I happen to think she is alive is the most probable of the options.
It is not a case of either hope or belief in my instance. It is simply a case or working through the odds and evaluating all the scenarios. From that, the most likely one is that she is alive, IMO of course.
I do know something of statistics Shining.
I have also studied the data regarding finding missing children alive after such a time and the lack of evidence of any trace of her.
That shining reflects the part of stats called probability.
Quite why you made an a evaluation she is alive, does not correlate with the statistics of finding missing children alive after such a long period.
The other cases which inevitably some will try to compare with, don't compare one iota with this case.
-
Why do some people will and want Madeleine to be dead?
-
Why do some people will and want Madeleine to be dead?
Do you actually comprehend the difference between wanting someone dead, and evaluating the evidence and coming to the conclusion she is ?
-
I happen to think the probability that she is alive is not high, for many reasons.
But I happen to think she is alive is the most probable of the options.
It is not a case of either hope or belief in my instance. It is simply a case or working through the odds and evaluating all the scenarios. From that, the most likely one is that she is alive, IMO of course.
your post doesn't make any sense....if the probability she is alive is not high...then the probability she is dead must be greater ...then death must be the most probable.......
-
There is absolutely no proof that Madeleine is dead, so I fail to understand why I should think she is.
I am not interested in statistics. They don't mean anything in a situation like this.
-
Why do some people will and want Madeleine to be dead?
Do they?
The options however include but are not limited to:
Dead.
Alive being passed around from one one group of ne'er do wells to another.
Alive on her own living on the streets and on her wits.
Alive with a loving caring family.
So who believes what?
-
There is absolutely no proof that Madeleine is dead, so I fail to understand why I should think she is.
I am not interested in statistics. They don't mean anything in a situation like this.
Of course they do.
You need to do some studying rather than make blind statements.
Do you know how police normally evaluate how much time and money is spent on cases ?
It is evaluated in terms of statistics Eleanor, not just blind faith.
As to Madeleine, there is not one iota of evidence to show that she is alive.
-
Of course they do.
You need to do some studying rather than make blind statements.
Do you know how police normally evaluate how much time and money is spent on cases ?
It is evaluated in terms of statistics Eleanor, not just blind faith.
As to Madeleine, there is not one iota of evidence to show that she is alive.
There is not one iota of evidence to show that Madeleine McCann is dead.
-
Of course they do.
You need to do some studying rather than make blind statements.
Do you know how police normally evaluate how much time and money is spent on cases ?
It is evaluated in terms of statistics Eleanor, not just blind faith.
As to Madeleine, there is not one iota of evidence to show that she is alive.
I'm not talking about The Police. I'm talking about me. And I think Madeleine could well be very much alive.
-
There is not one iota of evidence to show that Madeleine McCann is dead.
I evaluate the evidence and information available. It is called logic.
There is no trace of Madeleine .
-
I'm not talking about The Police. I'm talking about me. And I think Madeleine could well be very much alive.
Really ?
There is still a flat earth society and people convinced therefore the earth is flat, regardless of the evidence to the contrary.
-
I evaluate the evidence and information available. It is called logic.
There is no trace of Madeleine .
Why is it important to you to insist that a child is dead when there is no evidence to support that supposition.
-
Why is it important to you to insist that a child is dead when there is no evidence to support that supposition.
You need to read again.
I have looked at the information and evidence available.
Why do you think she may be alive then ?
There is no evidence that she is...
-
Of course they do.
You need to do some studying rather than make blind statements.
Do you know how police normally evaluate how much time and money is spent on cases ?
It is evaluated in terms of statistics Eleanor, not just blind faith.
As to Madeleine, there is not one iota of evidence to show that she is alive.
the very fact that there is no evidence of death is evidence that Maddie MAY still be alive....fact
-
You need to read again.
I have looked at the information and evidence available.
Why do you think she may be alive then ?
There is no evidence that she is...
Because there's no evidence that she isn't.
-
You need to read again.
I have looked at the information and evidence available.
Why do you think she may be alive then ?
There is no evidence that she is...
There is no evidence Madeleine McCann is dead, who are you to decide she is?
-
You need to read again.
I have looked at the information and evidence available.
Why do you think she may be alive then ?
From my perspective it is not so much the thinking/hoping/wishing she were alive but just what circumstances are believed regarding her present existence; see my earlier post.
I note no one wants to come down heads or tails on that score.
-
There is no evidence Madeleine McCann is dead, who are you to decide she is?
I have given my view.
You are responding because of mantra
Now, try to respond with a logical argument.
-
I am following forum rules by not discussing on here, what I say there.
You are also breaking forum rules by doing so.
Why are you doing that ?
Is it because you have lost the argument ?
there is no argument or debate... Maddie may still be alive,,,fact
-
there is no argument or debate... Maddie may still be alive,,,fact
Where Dave ?
-
Where Dave ?
That is a silly question.
-
Where Dave ?
I have no idea...but it is a possibility...however remote ....do you disagree....if you do ...you are wrong...simple
-
That is a silly question.
No it isn't.
You claim she could well be alive, so where Eleanor ?
-
I have given my view.
You are responding because of mantra
Now, try to respond with a logical argument.
Logic dictates that as there is no evidence either way that Madeleine McCann may well be alive.
-
Logic dictates that as there is no evidence either way that Madeleine McCann may well be alive.
So where Brietta , would she be ?
-
Logic dictates that as there is no evidence either way that Madeleine McCann may well be alive.
that is simple logic which Stephen cannot seem to understand
-
Logic dictates that as there is no evidence either way that Madeleine McCann may well be alive.
You are therefore saying she can also be dead ?
Logic dictates she is either alive or dead . Not both.
-
Do you actually comprehend the difference between wanting someone dead, and evaluating the evidence and coming to the conclusion she is ?
Honest evaluation of the evidence leaves no basis that Madeleine's parents should give up on the hope that she is alive.
-
So where Brietta , would she be ?
Don't be ridiculous ... if I knew that I would not be posting it on a discussion forum.
-
that is simple logic which Stephen cannot seem to understand
So come on Dave, if alive where could she be ?
-
No it isn't.
You claim she could well be alive, so where Eleanor ?
I Don't Know, Stephen. Where do you think she is buried?
-
You are therefore saying she can also be dead ?
Logic dictates she is either alive or dead . Not both.
well done...so she is either alive or dead...not both... I cant believe you actually said that
-
Don't be ridiculous ... if I knew that I would not be posting it on a discussion forum.
It isn't ridiculous.
You postulate she could be alive.
Now give some possibility.it is to back my or view, or your view has no merit whatsoever.
-
So come on Dave, if alive where could she be ?
I've answered that question..it isn't relevant to the discussion...you are taking your own thread off topic
-
Don't be ridiculous ... if I knew that I would not be posting it on a discussion forum.
Yep. Quite right.
Anyone of honest intent who knows where Madeleine is (alive) should be talking to responsible authorities (British or Portuguese) and should it leave it to them to make the news public (their way).
If you read it first in a newspaper it's almost certainly untrue (as all such reports to date have been).
-
This is the thread I started.
It is you who is deflecting.
I did not bring other forums to this thread.
Did I ?
i personally dont think maddie is alive and imo everybody has a right to their opinion
-
I've answered that question..it isn't relevant to the discussion...you are taking your own thread off topic
Nope I haven't.
-
Yep. Quite right.
Anyone of honest intent who knows where Madeleine is (alive) should be talking to responsible authorities (British or Portuguese) and should it leave it to them to make the news public (their way).
If you read it first in a newspaper it's almost certainly untrue (as all such reports to date have been).
So ferryman, where is Madeleine ?
-
It isn't ridiculous.
You postulate she could be alive.
Now give some possibility.it is to back my or view, or your view has no merit whatsoever.
Maddie could be alive...fact..
-
i personally dont think maddie is alive and imo everybody has a right to their opinion
Precisely Carly.
That is why the mccanns have tried to silence debate on this issue as have their supporters.
It is all about the mantra.
That came unhinged LAST TUESDAY.
-
Maddie could be alive...fact..
Where ?
Cite.
-
Precisely Carly.
That is why the mccanns have tried to silence debate on this issue as have their supporters.
It is all about the mantra.
That came unhinged LAST TUESDAY.
have you read and understood carlys post
she THINKS Maddie is not alive....so she accepts she may be...and she thinks everyone is entitled to their opinion...which you are trying to silence
-
have you read and understood carlys post
she THINKS Maddie is not alive....so she accepts she may be...and she thinks everyone is entitled to their opinion...which you are trying to silence
I am asking for opinions
Believe what you wish.
I am asking the question for those that believe she is alive, where would she be ?
-
Where ?
Cite.
I think you are making yourself look a bit silly
-
I think you are making yourself look a bit silly
Just cites.
It seems some people are afraid to do that.
I shall read the responses tomorrow.
-
Where ?
Cite.
Stephen, will you please stop asking for the ridiculous.
-
i have no problem if people think maddie is alive that is their opinion that being said people who dont think maddie is alive should not be called names because of that either and imo that goes for GA etc
-
i have no problem if people think maddie is alive that is their opinion that being said people who dont think maddie is alive should not be called names because of that either
# I agree ...carly is absolutely correct...in a situation where there is no evidence either way everyones opinion is equally valid and should be respected
-
Okay, that will do with goading and ridiculous.
-
i have no problem if people think maddie is alive that is their opinion that being said people who dont think maddie is alive should not be called names because of that either and imo that goes for GA etc
8((()*/
-
Anyone care to respond to my post #11 ?
If you believe Madeleine is alive, how in your minds eye do you see her present circumstances and existence?
-
Anyone care to respond to my post #11 ?
If you believe Madeleine is alive, how in your minds eye do you see her present circumstances and existence?
as i said i dont believe she is alive and she has suffered if she is alive imo
-
Anyone care to respond to my post #11 ?
If you believe Madeleine is alive, how in your minds eye do you see her present circumstances and existence?
#no
-
I really don't understand what you are trying to say...Maddie may be alive...she may not...that is a fact and you cannot argue with a fact
No Dave.
If people believe she is alive, then should have the courage of their convictions and be able to give reasons why think that, and provide suggestions where she could be.
Otherwise, their responses are meaningless.
-
No Dave.
If people believe she is alive, then should have the courage of their convictions and be able to give reasons why think that, and provide suggestions where she could be.
Otherwise, their responses are meaningless.
agree,,,,,
-
No Dave.
If people believe she is alive, then should have the courage of their convictions and be able to give reasons why think that, and provide suggestions where she could be.
Otherwise, their responses are meaningless.
in your opinion...but no one cares about your opinion...or carlys....and as you don't care about my opinion...what is the point of me giving it
#
-
No Dave.
If people believe she is alive, then should have the courage of their convictions and be able to give reasons why think that, and provide suggestions where she could be.
Otherwise, their responses are meaningless.
I think this whole thread is meaningless
-
in your opinion...but no one cares about your opinion...or carlys....and as you don't care about my opinion...what is the point of me giving it
#
Then don't respond to me.
As to your views......
-
Then don't respond to me.
As to your views......
#I shall respond to whoever I like ....... and as to your views
-
I think this whole thread is meaningless
You would.
The same can be said about a parallel one.
-
Then don't respond to me.
As to your views......
then why ask me for my views
-
#I shall respoend to whoever I like ....... and as to your views
That was not original copying me.
Try to give reasons why Madeleine could be alive, and where , if she was, she could be.
-
That was not original copying me.
Try to give reasons why Madeleine could be alive, and where , if she was, she could be.
it is a stupid request..imo
-
71 posts, 22 by davel = 31% of the posts are his but he thinks the thread is pointless or words to that effect.......... &%+((£
-
It is quite clear by now, no trace of Madeleine has been found.
The mccanns claim no harm has come to her, which beggars all belief.
At various times it has been said she was taken by a paedophile(s), or taken to be given to another family. Yet not one jot of evidence exists to show either of these two happened.
So why do some claim, she is still alive ?
Is it a genuine belief, or is it merely a way of defending the mccanns, and ignoring the most likely conclusion, that she died some time ago ?
Those that claim she is dead are often called heartless or worse.
Others look at what happened, including me , and see with the clear lack of evidence of any trail of her since May the 3 rd 2007, there is only one logical conclusion.
I believe it is a hope. Any parent of a missing child will have the same hope even though in reality the chances of them being found alive are small. It is this hope which keeps parents going, the alternative is to abandon all hope and concede defeat.
-
The original question says believe. I can understand hope and possibilities but why believe?
-
The original question says believe. I can understand hope and possibilities but why believe?
stephens opening post contains,,,
So why do some claim, she is still alive ?
I haven't seen any posts saying Maddie is alive...
Posters say Maddie may be alive...Stephen is confusing the two statements......
I hope...believe... Maddie may still be alive based on the fact there is no real evidence she is dead....I also believe she is far more likely not to be alive.....
-
I believe it is a hope. Any parent of a missing child will have the same hope even though in reality the chances of them being found alive are small. It is this hope which keeps parents going, the alternative is to abandon all hope and concede defeat.
You will be more than aware of peoples thoughts onto Madeleine's fate and the associated scenarios.
Can you tell me why a fund, a clearly long term financial set up was necessary, if the mccanns believed Madeleine was still alive and findable ?
Set up mere days after her disappearance.
Can you cite any similar examples of this happening.
Likewise, a team of PR experts employed to manage their image, a lawyer who specialized in anti-extradition procedures, etc.
-
It is about about realising that as there is no real evidence either way...both are possible
-
My opinion is the same as all parents of children who are missing. Until there is evidence that they are dead - they will continue to hope that they are alive - and so shall I.
In your opinion the crime is unknown.
Therefore one of the possible crimes is abduction.
There are cases of abducted children being found alive.
Therefore it is possible that Madeleine (and Ben Needham) may still be alive.
Therefore I shall continue to hope that these children are found - or that it is discovered what happened to them so that their families can at least have closure.
I don't know where Madeleine is. I don't know where Ben Needham is - neither do their families, but that doesn't stop them living in hope that their children are still alive and can still be found. The fact that you appear to have no understanding of why parents of missing children would feel like that and refuse to give up hope - is not their problem.
-
Will the resident Punch and Judy duo please stop squabbling across the boards. TY
-
My opinion is the same as all parents of children who are missing. Until there is evidence that they are dead - they will continue to hope that they are alive - and so shall I.
In your opinion the crime is unknown.
Therefore one of the possible crimes is abduction.
There are cases of abducted children being found alive.
Therefore it is possible that Madeleine (and Ben Needham) may still be alive.
Therefore I shall continue to hope that these children are found - or that it is discovered what happened to them so that their families can at least have closure.
I don't know where Madeleine is. I don't know where Ben Needham is - neither do their families, but that doesn't stop them living in hope that their children are still alive and can still be found. The fact that you appear to have no understanding of why parents of missing children would feel like that and refuse to give up hope - is not their problem.
Likewise one of the crimes is accidental death.
Now why did you ignore that ?
Secondly and more poignantly, I don't believe there was an abduction, and you know full well if there never was one, as many other people believe as well, no matter the ensuing denials, what the consequences of that are.
-
My opinion is the same as all parents of children who are missing. Until there is evidence that they are dead - they will continue to hope that they are alive - and so shall I.
In your opinion the crime is unknown.
Therefore one of the possible crimes is abduction.
There are cases of abducted children being found alive.
Therefore it is possible that Madeleine (and Ben Needham) may still be alive.
Therefore I shall continue to hope that these children are found - or that it is discovered what happened to them so that their families can at least have closure.
I don't know where Madeleine is. I don't know where Ben Needham is - neither do their families, but that doesn't stop them living in hope that their children are still alive and can still be found. The fact that you appear to have no understanding of why parents of missing children would feel like that and refuse to give up hope - is not their problem.
I can go with that but this case does throw up enough anomalies to support several other possibilities some of which are not at all savoury.
Addressing the question raised in the OP for a moment I think some people believe Madeleine is alive simply because the alternative is too dreadful to contemplate.
-
Likewise one of the crimes is accidental death.
Now why did you ignore that ?
Secondly and more poignantly, I don't believe there was an abduction, and you know full well if there never was one, as many other people believe as well, no matter the ensuing denials, what the consequences of that are.
Why do you bother to ask for people's opinions when you have no intention of accepting any opinions that don't agree with your own?
As requested - I gave you my opinion. if you can't accept that other people do have opinions different to yours - and are fully entitled to hold those opinions - then that's not my problem.
I think you should edit your thread title, as I know of no-one who has claimed that Madeleine is still alive - as if it were an indisputable fact.
-
Why do you bother to ask for people's opinions when you have no intention of accepting any opinions that don't agree with your own?
As requested - I gave you my opinion. if you can't accept that other people do have opinions different to yours - and are fully entitled to hold those opinions - then that's not my problem.
I think you should edit your thread title, as I know of no-one who has claimed that Madeleine is still alive - as if it were an indisputable fact.
The problem is, as I perceive it, that mccann supporters in reality will only accept 1 scenario, i.e. that of abduction,and you expect others to swallow it.
So, for the last time, do you accept the possibility of accidental death in the apartment, or the walking out scenario ?
I await your answer.
-
The problem is, as I perceive it, that mccann supporters in reality will only accept 1 scenario, i.e. that of abduction,and you expect others to swallow it.
So, for the last time, do you accept the possibility of accidental death in the apartment, or the walking out scenario ?
I await your answer.
Not only that, but it must be abduction with a happy ending. Nothing else is acceptable.
-
I can go with that but this case does throw up enough anomalies to support several other possibilities some of which are not at all savoury.
Addressing the question raised in the OP for a moment I think some people believe Madeleine is alive simply because the alternative is too dreadful to contemplate.
no john...posters think Maddie MAY be alive because its a possibilty...remote...but a possibility
-
The problem is, as I perceive it, that mccann supporters in reality will only accept 1 scenario, i.e. that of abduction,and you expect others to swallow it.
So, for the last time, do you accept the possibility of accidental death in the apartment, or the walking out scenario ?
I await your answer.
I accept that there is a tiny, minute possibility that either of the above claims occurred. However in my opinion, after taking into consideration all of the info I know about this case - they fade into total insignificance compared to the claim that she was abducted.
Unless you can provide proof that Madeleine is dead, I will carry on holding the opinion that she was abducted and therefore will also continue to hope that she may still be alive.
Why that should be a problem to anyone is beyond my comprehension.
-
I accept that there is a tiny, minute possibility that either of the above claims occurred. However in my opinion, after taking into consideration all of the info I know about this case - they fade into total insignificance compared to the claim that she was abducted.
Unless you can provide proof that Madeleine is dead, I will carry on holding the opinion that she was abducted and therefore will also continue to hope that she may still be alive.
Why that should be a problem to anyone is beyond my comprehension.
I follow your rationale, which ought to be flawless.
but it's not beyond my comprehension.
-
I accept that there is a tiny, minute possibility that either of the above claims occurred. However in my opinion, after taking into consideration all of the info I know about this case - they fade into total insignificance compared to the claim that she was abducted.
Unless you can provide proof that Madeleine is dead, I will carry on holding the opinion that she was abducted and therefore will also continue to hope that she may still be alive.
Why that should be a problem to anyone is beyond my comprehension.
Well that was a surprise.
I have also analysed the case and looked through the files and other information, including the lack of any evidence of abduction, including forensics, and bearing in mind paedophile rings have been investigated with no vestige of evidence she was took by one, or is living with another family either.
Also note I am not a member of any group on either side of the case.
-
Well that was a surprise.
I have also analysed the case and looked through the files and other information, including the lack of any evidence of abduction, including forensics, and bearing in mind paedophile rings have been investigated with no vestige of evidence she was took by one, or is living with another family either.
Also note I am not a member of any group on either side of the case.
Information is not a lack.
Your scientific rigour has deserted you ....
-
Information is not a lack.
Your scientific rigour has deserted you ....
Information is essential ferryman.
Without it you have nothing,and that is what is comes down to for you and certain other people, with no abduction, just two directions to go.
-
I am puzzled about this thread. I think most sensible posters here accept that it is unlikely that Madeleine is still alive, but that it is possible (given that no trace of her has been found).
Statistics can be of course be useful for guidance when it comes to making decisions, but are useless in something which is binary (like pregnancy or life / death), and are not of much help in this issue.
I am not sure why some posters here seem to find it so personally offensive that others hold that the opinion that Madeleine may still be alive, somewhere. I suppose it takes all sorts.
-
Well that was a surprise.
I have also analysed the case and looked through the files and other information, including the lack of any evidence of abduction, including forensics, and bearing in mind paedophile rings have been investigated with no vestige of evidence she was took by one, or is living with another family either.
Also note I am not a member of any group on either side of the case.
I too have analysed the case and come to the conclusion...based on the evidence that abduction is by far the most probable reason for the disappearance...
You want to discount abduction because you say there is no evidence... i posted an interesting article last week showing that the evidence that parachutes prevent serious injury when jumpng out of a plane...is weak...so by your arguments you would be happy not to wear one....
-
I am puzzled about this thread. I think most sensible posters here accept that it is unlikely that Madeleine is still alive, but that it is possible (given that no trace of her has been found).
Statistics can be of course be useful for guidance when it comes to making decisions, but are useless in something which is binary (like pregnancy or life / death), and are not of much help in this issue.
I am not sure why some posters here seem to find it so personally offensive that others hold that the opinion that Madeleine may still be alive, somewhere. I suppose it takes all sorts.
I was waiting for you to chip in.
The point made earlier and on many other occasions refers to the supporter mantra of abduction, and everything else must be attacked.
Don't you agree ?
-
I too have analysed the case and come to the conclusion...based on the evidence that abduction is by far the most probable reason for the disappearance...
You want to discount abduction because you say there is no evidence... i posted an interesting article last week showing that the evidence that parachutes prevent serious injury when jumpng out of a plane...is weak...so by your arguments you would be happy not to wear one....
Have you paid attention to what John said earlier ?
-
I am puzzled about this thread. I think most sensible posters here accept that it is unlikely that Madeleine is still alive, but that it is possible (given that no trace of her has been found).
Statistics can be of course be useful for guidance when it comes to making decisions, but are useless in something which is binary (like pregnancy or life / death), and are not of much help in this issue.
I am not sure why some posters here seem to find it so personally offensive that others hold that the opinion that Madeleine may still be alive, somewhere. I suppose it takes all sorts.
Actually, that argument goes both ways. I have also seen offensive posts criticising those who believe she is dead.
-
Have you paid attention to what John said earlier ?
yes...my post is absolutely serious....it illustrates that just because you may feel the evidence is weak to support an argumant does not mean the argument isn't true...
AFAIAC the evidence strongly supports abduction
-
I was waiting for you to chip in.
The point made earlier and on many other occasions refers to the supporter mantra of abduction, and everything else must be attacked.
Don't you agree ?
there is no mantra...no group...no organised attack...just posters with a diferrent opinion to you
-
there is no mantra...no group...no organised attack...just posters with a diferrent opinion to you
Kate Mccann at Leveson.
8)-)))
-
there is no mantra...no group...no organised attack...just posters with a diferrent opinion to you
There could be a group, that they didn't tell you about as they didn't want to to join 8(0(*
-
I was waiting for you to chip in.
The point made earlier and on many other occasions refers to the supporter mantra of abduction, and everything else must be attacked.
Don't you agree ?
No attack - simply expressing my view that there is a slim chance that Madeleine may still be alive (as has happened in a few other cases). I accept that others, including yourself, may have a different view.
-
Kate Mccann at Leveson.
8)-)))
kate never mentioned posters...you are mistaken
-
No attack - simply expressing my view that there is a slim chance that Madeleine may still be alive (as has happened in a few other cases). I accept that others, including yourself, may have a different view.
it seems from the opening post it is those who believe Maddie MAY still be alive who are being attacked
-
No attack - simply expressing my view that there is a slim chance that Madeleine may still be alive (as has happened in a few other cases). I accept that others, including yourself, may have a different view.
Fair enough.
I notice JP that as far as I can see you have not commented on last weeks judgement. What is your opinion of it, and I am not being sarcastic.
-
Fair enough.
I notice JP that as far as I can see you have not commented on last weeks judgement. What is your opinion of it, and I am not being sarcastic.
I think most things have already been said - not sure I can contribute anything new.
I have been round the block enough times that nothing in law surprises me - courts and judges are predictably unpredictable.
So as things stand its 1 all. I would now expect it to proceed to appeal at the supreme court - see what happens there.
-
I think most things have already been said - not sure I can contribute anything new.
I have been round the block enough times that nothing in law surprises me - courts and judges are predictably unpredictable.
So as things stand its 1 all. I would now expect it to proceed to appeal at the supreme court - see what happens there.
Will Amaral's assets be unfrozen?
-
Logically they ought to be, as he has won his appeal. However they may remain frozen until the outcome of an appeal to the Supreme Court is no longer in doubt
-
Logically they ought to be, as he has won his appeal. However they may remain frozen until the outcome of an appeal to the Supreme Court is no longer in doubt
If that is allowed to happen.
-
Logically they ought to be, as he has won his appeal. However they may remain frozen until the outcome of an appeal to the Supreme Court is no longer in doubt
I would say the most logical position ought to that they remain frozen until there is ultimate resolution of the dispute (with no more avenues of appeal)
-
There are a few reasons why some people want to believe Madeleine is still alive.
I want her to be found alive, living with a great family where she has been loved, cherished and well looked after, I believe the chances of that are very ,very slim. I am just a bystander and love children and hate child abuse in any form. However, I do suspect she did come to harm and is no longer alive.
The parents will want to believe she is alive for their own personal reasons.
The other reason people are being told she may still be alive is to keep the circus going! And the clean cut image of the parents to be protected at all costs. The public are being convinced she may still be alive so keep looing for her ( look where exactly and she has aged) because if a dead Madeleine turns up then the parents will be vilified and held to account in some way for leaving her open to whatever harm she came to.
-
I would say the most logical position ought to that they remain frozen until there is ultimate resolution of the dispute (with no more avenues of appeal)
Once the PT Justice system is exhausted GA's assets will be unfrozen. There is no legal reason they wouldn't be.
-
You are totally confused
Posters here believe she may be alive
Not that she is
I believe that she is alive.
And I have reasons. Images that I have seen from about 4 years ago, which believe were Madeleine . I looked in a specific place determined by my investigations and found her there.
If the perps kept Madeleine alive until then, they were hardly likely to have killed her since.
I believe Madeleine is alive.
-
I believe that she is alive.
And I have reasons. Images that I have seen from about 4 years ago, which believe were Madeleine . I looked in a specific place determined by my investigations and found her there.
If the perps kept Madeleine alive until then, they were hardly likely to have killed her since.
I believe Madeleine is alive.
its all in your imagination.
-
its all in your imagination.
Well SY were interested. Maybe they have lively "imagination" too ? Or just maybe they were prepared to step outside the conventional, hackneyed methods of investigation and open their minds to new alternative research.
May i suggest that you open your mind, Matthew ?
-
Well SY were interested. Maybe they have lively "imagination" too ? Or just maybe they were prepared to step outside the conventional, hackneyed methods of investigation and open their minds to new alternative research.
May i suggest that you open your mind, Matthew ?
there are no images of madeleine and there never were. she was never seen again after 3 may 2007.
-
there are no images of madeleine and there never were. she was never seen again after 3 may 2007.
how can you say that when you haven't seen the images?
You cant know about what you haven't seen.
-
how can you say that when you haven't seen the images?
You cant know about what you haven't seen.
i know your track record for mistaken sightings. seen any photos of lord lucan recently?
-
http://www.aww.com.au/latest-news/news-stories/madeleine-mccann-search-to-officially-end-in-months-26780?adbsc=social_20160426_60972846&adbid=10153757172248621&adbpl=fb&adbpr=349591763620
-
Of course they do.
You need to do some studying rather than make blind statements.
Do you know how police normally evaluate how much time and money is spent on cases ?
It is evaluated in terms of statistics Eleanor, not just blind faith.
As to Madeleine, there is not one iota of evidence to show that she is alive.
On the news last night Scotland Yard have only got one line of enquiry left to check, and so far they have found NOTHING, they admit that themselves and this extra money they have been given was to follow this one line up and complete thier investigation. Then it is going to be shelved in a few months if this line comes to another dead end.
Of course police evaulate they have too.
The portugese police did that many years ago, thats why the closed the case. They were more looking for a body then a living breathing child.
I dont think she is alive never have, i thiink she died on the night she was taken. Its easier to hide a dead body then keep a live child secret. The child became way to hot to handle sadly. Sometimes i do sit and think i wish for a miracle and she would turn up like Ben Needham but sadly reality sets in. I dont think we will ever find her body to be honest. Such a tragic case, well any child going missing is a tragedy and sadly there are thousands of them all over the world. 8(8-))
-
I don't BELEIVE that Madeleine is alive I HOPE she is but no one knows for sure what has happened to Madeleine.
-
I don't BELEIVE that Madeleine is alive I HOPE she is but no one knows for sure what has happened to Madeleine.
Of course someone knows what happened to her.
Those who removed from the apartment, unless of course she walked out herself and disappeared.
-
Of course someone knows what happened to her.
Those who removed from the apartment, unless of course she walked out herself and disappeared.
Sorry, I should have said the general public don't know what happened to her, that ok?
-
Sorry, I should have said the general public don't know what happened to her, that ok?
Yep.
-
In the great and glorious 'sun'.
It readily demonstrates that the mccanns are trying to perpetuate the story that Madeleine will be found alive and they seem totally oblivious to last weeks judgement.
'Maddie McCann's parents want a new impression of their missing daughter as no one would recognise her now'
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/7111973/Madeline-McCanns-parents-want-a-new-impression-of-their-missing-daughter-as-no-one-would-recognise-her.html
Yet look at the official facebook page and what do you see....
-
In the great and glorious 'sun'.
It readily demonstrates that the mccanns are trying to perpetuate the story that Madeleine will be found alive and they seem totally oblivious to last weeks judgement.
'Maddie McCann's parents want a new impression of their missing daughter as no one would recognise her now'
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/7111973/Madeline-McCanns-parents-want-a-new-impression-of-their-missing-daughter-as-no-one-would-recognise-her.html
Yet look at the official facebook page and what do you see....
Last week's judgement doesn't mean that it's a fact that she's dead. It's just the former coordinator (for 5 months) "we experts" apparently has the right to insist that she is, that the mccannswhatdunnit, and every public agency you can think of is involved in covering up the "truth".
-
In the great and glorious 'sun'.
It readily demonstrates that the mccanns are trying to perpetuate the story that Madeleine will be found alive and they seem totally oblivious to last weeks judgement.
'Maddie McCann's parents want a new impression of their missing daughter as no one would recognise her now'
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/7111973/Madeline-McCanns-parents-want-a-new-impression-of-their-missing-daughter-as-no-one-would-recognise-her.html
Yet look at the official facebook page and what do you see....
last weeks judgemnet has no relevance to maddie's fate...you don't seem to understand that
-
last weeks judgemnet has no relevance to maddie's fate...you don't seem to understand that
Of course it is.
It is a reaction to it.
I see the comments already reflect the image of the mccanns with the general public.
-
Of course it is.
It is a reaction to it.
I see the comments already reflect the image of the mccanns with the general public.
You are happy that a book saying that Madeleine is dead and the parents covered it up are you? Libellous in this country I may add.
-
You are happy that a book saying that Madeleine is dead and the parents covered it up are you? Libellous in this country I may add.
It was and remains a thesis.
Do you know what that means ?
-
It was and remains a thesis.
Do you know what that means ?
He gets it wrong in his book, he points to the DNA being 4 short of 100%, then argues about what the forensic scientist says, so that it seems as if the DNA was false. That isn't from the files at all.
-
You are happy that a book saying that Madeleine is dead and the parents covered it up are you? Libellous in this country I may add.
Certainly doesn't cause me to lose any sleep.
-
Certainly doesn't cause me to lose any sleep.
Yes, well you probably believe it all.
-
Certainly doesn't cause me to lose any sleep.
It might if you were desperately trying to find your missing child...
-
It might if you were desperately trying to find your missing child...
I have never believed the mccanns have.
Not from very nearly the start of this case.
-
Yes, well you probably believe it all.
Not particularly - just that I'm not so wound up by this case to worry about who said what, where and when.
Amaral is free to publish his book - learn to live with it.
-
I have never believed the mccanns have.
Not from very nearly the start of this case.
There you are then, you believe all that Amaral tells you in his 'thesis'.
-
It might if you were desperately trying to find your missing child...
I'm not, so it doesn't apply. Why are yo apparently so concerned -
-
There you are then, you believe all that Amaral tells you in his 'thesis'.
I thought you would say that.
...and if again you had taken in my previous posts, you would realize that your previous comment was flawed.
-
I thought you would say that.
...and if again you had taken in my previous posts, you would realize that your previous comment was flawed.
You believe everything that is told to you without reading through all the police files, all the statements, you just blindly carry on.
-
You believe everything that is told to you without reading through all the police files, all the statements, you just blindly carry on.
As far as many are concerned, the 'blind' are those following the mccanns, or supporting them for other reasons.
Do you remember what Mitchell said in his interview in Australia on that ?
-
As far as many are concerned, the 'blind' are those following the mccanns, or supporting them for other reasons.
Do you remember what Mitchell said in his interview in Australia on that ?
You obviously haven't read the Police files or you wouldn't keep repeating 'they didn't search' mantra.
-
You obviously haven't read the Police files or you wouldn't keep repeating 'they didn't search' mantra.
They last searched on the morning of the 4 th May 2007.
After that they were busy doing other things.
The fund, foreign visits, jogging, photo opportunities walking around PDL with cuddle cat, etc.
-
They last searched on the morning of the 4 th May 2007.
After that they were busy doing other things.
The fund, foreign visits, jogging, photo opportunities walking around PDL with cuddle cat, etc.
You missed out giving statements to the Police Stephen.
-
There is a very small chance she is still alive. Some people cling to that, I believe it is called hope. And its not a bad thing.
-
There is a very small chance she is still alive. Some people cling to that, I believe it is called hope. And its not a bad thing.
That's about it, ChloeR. Although I would give Madeleine a bit more than a small chance.
-
You missed out giving statements to the Police Stephen.
and how many did they make in their time there ?
-
There is a very small chance she is still alive. Some people cling to that, I believe it is called hope. And its not a bad thing.
Some kids (or even missing adults) have eventually been found alive, others have sadly been found dead, and yet other families are still in limbo.
Dutroux could have carried on with his evil practices for ages, but two young girls were eventually found still alive. Two sadly died even though the police had visited but tragically assumed that their cries for help were kids playing outside. Two other victims were much older.
There's simply no way of knowing what happened in this case.
Why would anyone insist that she is definitely dead in the absence of proof?
-
Some kids (or even missing adults) have eventually been found alive, others have sadly been found dead, and yet other families are still in limbo.
Dutroux could have carried on with his evil practices for ages, but two young girls were eventually found still alive. Two sadly died even though the police had visited but tragically assumed that their cries for help were kids playing outside. Two other victims were much older.
There's simply no way of knowing what happened in this case.
Why would anyone insist that she is definitely dead in the absence of proof?
I don't understand this either. And I am trying desperately hard to understand why some people are so insistent that Madeleine is dead.
I really don't want to believe that these people want it to be so.
And please don't quote Logic at me. Asking me to believe that The McCanns could have done that which they have been accused of is just not logical.
-
I don't understand this either. And I am trying desperately hard to understand why some people are so insistent that Madeleine is dead.
I really don't want to believe that these people want it to be so.
And please don't quote Logic at me. Asking me to believe that The McCanns could have done that which they have been accused of is just not logical.
Can you name anyone on here who has said that they want her to be dead?
-
Can you name anyone on here who has said that they want her to be dead?
I sincerely hope no one on this Forum ever has.
-
Can I take that as a 'no' then and that the people you are referring to reside elsewhere?
-
Can I take that as a 'no' then and that the people you are referring to reside elsewhere?
Obviously.
However, some members here do seem to think that Madeleine is dead, without a scrap of evidence or proof. This is what I don't understand.
-
Obviously.
However, some members here do seem to think that Madeleine is dead, without a scrap of evidence or proof. This is what I don't understand.
Nothing wrong with that. It is an either/or situation with no evidence to support either viewpoint.
-
and how many did they make in their time there ?
Well didn't it take all day? The police had taken over the search, where would the McCann's have searched? They searched everywhere that they had been on their holiday. Apart from that the Police don't really want the parents involved in the search.
-
Well didn't it take all day? The police had taken over the search, where would the McCann's have searched? They searched everywhere that they had been on their holiday. Apart from that the Police don't really want the parents involved in the search.
They did seem reluctant to search for an abductor carrying a child( who would still be in and around the apartment 30 miutes after the 'abduction')?, where would they start looking, only they knew the correct timeline, and the real window of opportunity,they also knew that no one jemmied a window and stole Maddie and hung around to be found by the family searching . Now come on be reasonable here people. Kate knew right away, RIGHT AWAY Maddie was abducted why not phone the police RIGHT AWAY and tell them she was abducted. Seems strange Kate ( knowing right away Maddie was abducted) had a wee look around to check if she wasn't in her parents room,bed... Then a search around the immediate area where it was expected the abductor hung around waiting to be found.
Ofcourse, some of us suspect that Kate never knew any such thing as an abductor jemmied the shutters and abducted her daughter,because she ,like everyone else said, there was a 'missing'child,people including the Tapas friends were looking for a missing child who may have wandered out of an unlocked apartment,why else stay close to the apartment giving almost an hour get away for an 'abductor'.
This was not meant to be investigated properly, these little loose ends and strange behaviours drew in the curious people who to this day continue to ask those pesky questions.
-
Well didn't it take all day? The police had taken over the search, where would the McCann's have searched? They searched everywhere that they had been on their holiday. Apart from that the Police don't really want the parents involved in the search.
How long did their solitary search last for ?
-
Can you name anyone on here who has said that they want her to be dead?
I am not giving names but several people on here keep almost insisting that Madeleine is dead. To keep saying that, implies that they want no more searches cos she is dead. It almost seems like a drive, propaganda put out, to push people to believe that there is no use in looking for her.
I find that sinister. The only people that I can think of that would want Madeleine NOT TO BE SEARCHED FOR are people who want to be free of watchful eyes looking for her. In other words, the perp. or people associated with the perp.
-
I am not giving names but several people on here keep almost insisting that Madeleine is dead. To keep saying that, implies that they want no more searches cos she is dead. It almost seems like a drive, propaganda put out, to push people to believe that there is no use in looking for her.
I find that sinister. The only people that I can think of that would want Madeleine NOT TO BE SEARCHED FOR are people who want to be free of watchful eyes looking for her. In other words, the perp. or people associated with the perp.
She has been searched for extensively Sadie.
People believe she is dead, because they have looked at what evidence is available, and the high probability that she won't be found alive since there has been no trace of her.
There is no conspiracy Sadie.
-
She has been searched for extensively Sadie.
People believe she is dead, because they have looked at what evidence is available, and the high probability that she won't be found alive since there has been no trace of her.
There is no conspiracy Sadie.
It's the fact that there has been no trace of Madeleine that makes it possible for her to still be alive.
-
It's the fact that there has been no trace of Madeleine that makes it possible for her to still be alive.
I don't believe in pipe dreams.
9 years bar a few days and not a trace.
-
I don't believe in pipe dreams.
9 years bar a few days and not a trace.
Exactly. Where is the body?
-
Exactly. Where is the body?
Somewhere on the third planet orbiting Sol I would presume.
If she is alive, where is she ?
-
Somewhere on the third planet orbiting Sol I would presume.
If she is alive, where is she ?
Madeleine could be anywhere in The World. The people who have her won't be advertising that fact.
-
Madeleine could be anywhere in The World. The people who have her won't be advertising that fact.
Why do you think people have her Eleanor ?
Is that because it supports your belief in abduction ?
-
Why do you think people have her Eleanor ?
Is that because it supports your belief in abduction ?
Probably just Hope, Stephen. I am not prepared to write off Madeleine at the moment.
-
Probably just Hope, Stephen. I am not prepared to write off Madeleine at the moment.
As am I Eleanor.
There is no proof that Madeleine is no more.
-
As am I Eleanor.
There is no proof that Madeleine is no more.
So where could she possibly be ?
With a paedophile or a family ?
-
So where could she possibly be ?
With a paedophile or a family ?
I would hope in some hinterland with a backward family rather than the other scenarios...some of which are just to awful to go to.
-
I would hope in some hinterland with a backward family rather than the other scenarios...some of which are just to awful to go to.
You believe what you wish.
-
So where could she possibly be ?
With a paedophile or a family ?
You can leave out any discussion on Paedophiles because I am not having it.
-
Less of the mod bashing please guys. Try to keep on topic.
-
So, dave, here we are, with the thread I started.
No sign of Madeleine.
Not one trace of her.
Not since the night she 'disappeared', and the last two known people to see her alive, were the mccanns.
ALL FACTS.
-
So, dave, here we are, with the thread I started.
No sign of Madeleine.
Not one trace of her.
Not since the night she 'disappeared', and the last two known people to see her alive, were the mccanns.
ALL FACTS.
yes all facts...same for Ben Needham basically...both very sad cases and you have to feel for the families
-
yes all facts...same for Ben Needham basically...both very sad cases and you have to feel for the families
I am not discussing the Needham case.
You are off topic.
-
I am not discussing the Needham case.
You are off topic.
no....I claim that the conditions you think point to some sort of guilt are quite normal and quote the needham case to support my argument
-
no....I claim that the conditions you think point to some sort of guilt are quite normal and quote the needham case to support my argument
The cases do not compare on a variety of levels.
-
The cases do not compare on a variety of levels.
are you not off topic now
-
are you not off topic now
The Needham case is irrelevant to this topic and has separate threads.
-
There is absolutely no proof that Madeleine is dead, so I fail to understand why I should think she is.
I am not interested in statistics. They don't mean anything in a situation like this.
Where is the proof she is alive? So then is it a matter of statistics and a matter what is the most probable.
-
There is not one iota of evidence to show that Madeleine McCann is dead.
But wouldn't that be the case for most people who are missing. There is no evidence they are dead till they are found dead.
-
I'm not talking about The Police. I'm talking about me. And I think Madeleine could well be very much alive.
I'm like you, I believe she is alive. I had a dream where she boarded a plane and returned voluntarily to Portugal. So if I am to think that was a premonitory dream, I think she is alive but is based on faith only.
What do you base your feelings on Eleanor?
-
I believe that she is alive.
And I have reasons. Images that I have seen from about 4 years ago, which believe were Madeleine . I looked in a specific place determined by my investigations and found her there.
If the perps kept Madeleine alive until then, they were hardly likely to have killed her since.
I believe Madeleine is alive.
How could you be sure it was her?
-
As far as many are concerned, the 'blind' are those following the mccanns, or supporting them for other reasons.
Do you remember what Mitchell said in his interview in Australia on that ?
What did he say?
-
Madeleine could be anywhere in The World. The people who have her won't be advertising that fact.
It would be impossible for her to be in Great Britain would it not?
-
It would be impossible for her to be in Great Britain would it not?
It would be unlikely but not impossible.
-
It would be unlikely but not impossible.
So what would that entail how would you get in and how would they live to keep themselves from being seen?
-
So what would that entail how would you get in and how would they live to keep themselves from being seen?
That might entail them doing exactly what they are and have been doing to keep themselves from being seen wherever in the world they may be secreted ... seems to have worked for them so far.
The police haven't worked through all the cold case evidence and leads arising from that for a spokesperson to suggest that more money might be asked for to pursue active investigation into the disappearance of a child who may very well still be alive without there being some substance to that supposition.
-
....
The police haven't worked through all the cold case evidence and leads arising from that for a spokesperson to suggest that more money might be asked for to pursue active investigation into the disappearance of a child who may very well still be alive without there being some substance to that supposition.
Is this the current situation?
-
Is this the current situation?
Judging by what Operation Grange have actually said on the record they were looking for Smithman in 2013. That is possibly the one remaining lead imo.
-
Judging by what Operation Grange have actually said on the record they were looking for Smithman in 2013. That is possibly the one remaining lead imo.
Well in one of many emails to SY I suggested with evidence who Smithman was. So they shouldn't have too much trouble tracking him down.
-
Sadly, I think it is more likely that Madeleine is dead, BUT no body has ever been found, so therefore there is a possibility that she is still alive.
There is even the possibility that she is being brought up in a happy family somewhere.
However, if this were to be the case, and she IS alive, I very much doubt whether she would remember her parents and siblings, or her life before 3rd May 2007. Were she to be found, and returned to her family, all concerned would probably have a very difficult time ahead.
-
Sadly, I think it is more likely that Madeleine is dead, BUT no body has ever been found, so therefore there is a possibility that she is still alive.
There is even the possibility that she is being brought up in a happy family somewhere.
However, if this were to be the case, and she IS alive, I very much doubt whether she would remember her parents and siblings, or her life before 3rd May 2007. Were she to be found, and returned to her family, all concerned would probably have a very difficult time ahead.
I agree with what you say. Though there is no guarantee that Madeleine will have forgotten her parents, something so traumatic as being abducted I am sure would be there somewhere in her subconscious and would only need to be gently prised out.
I agree that Madeleine should be returned to her family, but I doubt if this would happen straight away.
-
Sadly, I think it is more likely that Madeleine is dead, BUT no body has ever been found, so therefore there is a possibility that she is still alive.
There is even the possibility that she is being brought up in a happy family somewhere.
However, if this were to be the case, and she IS alive, I very much doubt whether she would remember her parents and siblings, or her life before 3rd May 2007. Were she to be found, and returned to her family, all concerned would probably have a very difficult time ahead.
If Madeleine is still alive ... and if she is found and recovered ... I don't think the transition will be an easy one for anyone involved.
The recent case in South Africa is a perfect illustration of exactly that ~
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3741163/Woman-kidnapped-newborn-baby-known-South-Africa-s-Madeleine-McCann-raised-18-jailed-ten-years.html
The only positive outcome here is that the kidnap victim's family now know what happened to her and that she was loved an well cared for in her time away from them.
What the eventual effects of the initial crime will have on the young woman are yet to happen; but it cannot be denied that the actions of one individual have been truly devastating for all concerned.
-
Sadly, I think it is more likely that Madeleine is dead, BUT no body has ever been found, so therefore there is a possibility that she is still alive.
There is even the possibility that she is being brought up in a happy family somewhere.
However, if this were to be the case, and she IS alive, I very much doubt whether she would remember her parents and siblings, or her life before 3rd May 2007. Were she to be found, and returned to her family, all concerned would probably have a very difficult time ahead.
Sorry mrswah.
I should have started by welcoming you to the forum.
I hope you will enjoy posting here ... so (&£# and welcome to the fray.
-
Sadly, I think it is more likely that Madeleine is dead, BUT no body has ever been found, so therefore there is a possibility that she is still alive.
There is even the possibility that she is being brought up in a happy family somewhere.
However, if this were to be the case, and she IS alive, I very much doubt whether she would remember her parents and siblings, or her life before 3rd May 2007. Were she to be found, and returned to her family, all concerned would probably have a very difficult time ahead.
What happens sometimes if there has suffered a medical emergency and the person recovers they may have a period of amnesia. So it is possible after the 3rd MM had no recollection of who she was previously.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-traumatic_amnesia