Might it be a good idea to find out if it is true first?
Ask Montclair.
The Amaral supporters claim to be loud and proud of their support of him.
So what is the problem by confirming it when asked by any journalist? &%+((£
Now theres a thought.
Can't see what all the fuss is about (if true). If they knocked on my door I would happily tell them of my continued support for Madeleine and her family. 8(0(*
We all would. It's them others who appear to be a bit reluctant.
We all would. It's them others who appear to be a bit reluctant.When a journalist doorsteps its deliberate confrontation without the person's permission.
When a journalist doorsteps its deliberate confrontation without the person's permission.
I think you need something a bit more solid than 'if a member's report is correct' to initiate substantive debate, or you are inviting opinions about speculation.
Do we have any sort of solid source for such doorstepping?
And please tidy up the title of the topic - thanks.
The Amaral supporters claim to be loud and proud of their support of him.
So what is the problem by confirming it when asked by any journalist? &%+((£
We all would. It's them others who appear to be a bit reluctant.
Would you agree that should be extended to the dossier compilers and donors to Madeleine's fund, and see their names and addresses on the internet ?
At the moment it is one way traffic.
I am only concerned with what I would do.
When a journalist doorsteps its deliberate confrontation without the person's permission.
Would you agree that should be extended to the dossier compilers and donors to Madeleine's fund, and see their names and addresses on the internet ?
At the moment it is one way traffic.
well we all know what happned when a certian journalist doorknocked someone relating to the mcann case they killed themselves....... and some supporters thought that person deserved what she got
I think you need something a bit more solid than 'if a member's report is correct' to initiate substantive debate, or you are inviting opinions about speculation.
Do we have any sort of solid source for such doorstepping?
And please tidy up the title of the topic - thanks.
How have the media obtained these name?
Have individuals phoned them up and volunteered their details or is this another of these 'dossiers'?
Pretty pathetic activity whatever, as the defence fund has done its job in allowing Amaral to win his appeal.
well we all know what happned when a certian journalist doorknocked someone relating to the mcann case they killed themselves....... and some supporters thought that person deserved what she got
How have the media obtained these name?
Have individuals phoned them up and volunteered their details or is this another of these 'dossiers'?
Pretty pathetic activity whatever, as the defence fund has done its job in allowing Amaral to win his appeal.
FaceBook it seems.
I have a friend who messaged me last night to say she was doorstepped yesterday.can you supply any proof
How have the media obtained these name?
Have individuals phoned them up and volunteered their details or is this another of these 'dossiers'?
Pretty pathetic activity whatever, as the defence fund has done its job in allowing Amaral to win his appeal.
It is interesting how supporters rarely use their own names. Are they afraid to stand up and be counted ?
Ah well, more fool them for having an account.
well we all know what happned when a certian journalist doorknocked someone relating to the mcann case they killed themselves....... and some supporters thought that person deserved what she got
Investigative journalism? They are conversant with social media where people tend to boast about their exploits ... I don't 'do' facebook or 'twitter' for example and am a member only of this forum because I worked out very early on that the smaller the footprint left on the internet the less chance of unwelcome intrusion there is.
No-one needs to source information directly from those who donated to the Amaral fund ... my route would be via particular facebook pages and work back from there.
The thing is carly I am sure if this journalist had known that BL was a frail person with mental illness, he wouldn't have approached her. BL though seemed a very confident strong woman going by what I read on twitter and chatted to this journalist. This journalist said he was devastated over her death. Do you not think that many many people are door stepped in this fashion? Or do you think it is just anti McCann's?
How many supporters were doorstepped over the theats to Lwanne Baulch then ? How many journalists actually looked into the claims ?
why should donors names be published on the net...what a bizarre statement...if people have used their real name that's their problem
It is interesting how supporters rarely use their own names. Are they afraid to stand up and be counted ?
I would be happy to use my real name but fear what some of the utter nutcases that are involved in this case might do
There seems to be a bit of Pot Kettle going on.
Why should they be doorstepped ?
How would you like it ?
They are scared.
Happy to pass on other people's details, never their own.
You mean like the ones who threatened the lady who organised the donations to Amaral'says legal fund ?
How many supporters were doorstepped over the theats to Lwanne Baulch then ? How many journalists actually looked into the claims ?
Name one McCann supporter who has been doorsteppedPrecisely Stephen.
you don't use your own name
Firstly I have seen no threats towards Leanne and secondly was it an article in the Daily Mail? that in my opinion is where these Journalists are getting their info, people going crazy on the comment page make interesting stories.
Name one McCann supporter who has been doorstepped
(http://i21.servimg.com/u/f21/14/71/15/18/untold10.jpg)
We never did get to see the completed video, did we?
If i have been stupid enough to reveal my real name then it's my own fault....I don't have a problem with anything i have said on here
So your are privy to what goes on in Leanne's email inbox, her DM inbox or her telephone calle are you ?
you don't use your own name
So your are privy to what goes on in Leanne's email inbox, her DM inbox or her telephone calle are you ?
Wait and see.
For me doorstepping is the lowest form of journalism. It was wrong when Brunt did it to Brenda Leyland, it was wrong when Poulton did it to Kate McCann and it is wrong now. As Pegasus says, why can't they just ring up and ask for an interview ? If I was one of the individuals being doorstepped I would be filing an allegation of harrasment not giving them a comment.
Here we have photographic evidence in a still taken from a video of a person who has taken it upon herself to doorstep the mother of a missing child.
I heard no howls of protest or outrage at that event.
I think if people wish to be considered seriously there has to be a certain consistency to their argument.
Here we have photographic evidence in a still taken from a video of a person who has taken it upon herself to doorstep the mother of a missing child.
I heard no howls of protest or outrage at that event.
I think if people wish to be considered seriously there has to be a certain consistency to their argument.
Why haven't the anti's gone mad over threats to Leanne? They usually do, yet nothing.
Plus that is not the reason Leanne give for leaving was it.
Why do you need to go mad for ?
Did you protest over what happened to Brenda Leyland ?
Maybe people is agitated cos they is afeared the Boogah Man be after them.
Why do you need to go mad for ?
Did you protest over what happened to Brenda Leyland ?
Maybe people is agitated cos they is afeared the Boogah Man be after them.
Anything like that they start calling pro McCann's everything under the sun, I'm not on twitter by the way thank god.
I was very sad about what happened to BL, but Journalists behave that way that's their job, he wasn't to know she had mental problems.
Intrinsically some mccann supporters like to expose other people , but take every measure to cover their own derrieres.
Oh please Stephen, don't pretend it's one sided. There's someone on that forum you like who loves trying to get hold of peoples identities and even boasts about it.
Name me one mccann backer labelled a troll in the press.
Second , read my other posts on this page first.
McCann Supporters aren't Trolls.
McCann Supporters aren't Trolls.Some are..not many though. Same as h a t e r s.
In other people's views Eleanor some are.
You clearly believe some of the sceptics are.
i personally think it is childish of any journo to doorknock people for having a opinion about 2 people who put themselves into the spotlight by their actions whiile on holidays
That's journalists for you they are eager to get a story and don't care how they go about it.
Intrinsically some mccann supporters like to expose other people , but take every measure to cover their own derrieres.I imagine it wouldn't be too difficult for an expert to work out who for many years has been doing the internet activity to prevent closure in this case. It's probably present in elements of their posts.
i personally think it is childish of any journo to doorknock people for having a opinion about 2 people who put themselves into the spotlight by their actions whiile on holidays
It seems some people, who used their real names on the GoFundMe page when making a donation, have been doorstepped by journalists.
The name calling goes both ways Lace.
As to Brenda Leyland , did Brunt or any of team check her background first, or did they just jump in head first for a nice little story. 8)-)))
Easy answer to that one.
Who is/are these journalists? Can we have their names if they really do exist so we can do the exposing??
Surely it can't be that hard?
There are dropping of names on twitter by some who have been door stepped and very proud of it too, they have given their stories and can't wait for them to be in the paper.
I have no idea, wouldn't he have had to look at her medical records?
The thing is Stephen, Brenda give as good as she got, she hounded a young girl off twitter, calling her a prostitute and other things which I won't repeat, they posted her address and hoped that she was scared and they were laughing about it. Who is to say this young girl wasn't as fragile as Brenda? Brenda chatted to the journalist as well by the way.
The way people are using BL to win arguments is quite sickening if I may say so. She thought she had found a group of friends in which to share her thoughts about the McCann's, they deserted her as soon as she was door stepped, wondering if she was a pro, had she arranged to meet the journalist, she may well have who knows.
Can someone answer the question as to why Amaral supporters have been labelled trolls by certain British newspapers?
Name me one mccann backer labelled a troll in the press.
Second , read my other posts on this page first.
They are called trolls as they are backing a Police Officer who accused the McCann's of hiding their child's body, and accusing the McCann's on their forums, facebook and twitter. They have no evidence the McCann's are guilty and they have no right to shout that the McCann's are guilty. The British Police and the Portuguese Police are trying to find Madeleine, yet this has no bearing on what they do.
Debating what you think happened to Madeleine and accusing the McCann's of having done something are two different things.
Good luck to whoever they target this time. Every word spoken will be twisted no doubt and the donators made out to be evil. But meh..kinda makes me wish I had donated to it, if only to see how the press twists things in action, as obviously I would know what I had said to them so I would know which parts had been edited out and such
I'm not sure which audience the Mail is trying to target this piece at. From the comments sections of every article featuring the McCanns it is obvious the public no longer have any great love for the couple and are really rather tired of their need for publicity and constant whinging. To print an article now which attempts to vilify ordinary individuals who have done nothing whatsoever wrong, especially after Brenda Leyland, will I'm sure, garner no sympathy for the McCanns but rather focus the readers wrath, again, on the two individuals who are actually the cause of this nastiness.
Don"'t forget the trolls on the bother side.
Just saw one on twitter ironically enough, gloating about the people being doorstepped.
'Irisheyes' for reference purposes.
DO NOT PRETEND IT IS A 1 WAY STREET as regards abuse.
As to who is the guilty party in this case, that is undetermined.
Don"'t forget the trolls on the bother side.
Just saw one on twitter ironically enough, gloating about the people being doorstepped.
'Irisheyes' for reference purposes.
DO NOT PRETEND IT IS A 1 WAY STREET as regards abuse.
As to who is the guilty party in this case, that is undetermined.
I'm not sure which audience the Mail is trying to target this piece at. From the comments sections of every article featuring the McCanns it is obvious the public no longer have any great love for the couple and are really rather tired of their need for publicity and constant whinging. To print an article now which attempts to vilify ordinary individuals who have done nothing whatsoever wrong, especially after Brenda Leyland, will I'm sure, garner no sympathy for the McCanns but rather focus the readers wrath, again, on the two individuals who are actually the cause of this nastiness.
You missed my point though Stephen, they are not interested the feud between anti and pro McCann, they are called trolls because they throw abuse at the McCann family and accuse of hiding their daughters body, and that they are sly and conniving and living off the fund, there is NO evidence for this.
A troll is someone who posts purely to get a reaction.
I think the British press are out of order referring to everyone who supports Amaral as a troll. They do like their little labels though. Anything to sell their rubbish papers I suppose? &%+((£
This doorstepping is obviously instigated by McCanns supporters because they are angry that Gonçalo Amaral, as well as Guerra & Paz and Valentim Carvalho, won their appeal. It was only because people got together and donated money, that GA was able to benefit from the basic right to defend himself, as any citizen should be able to do. This is what angers the parents and their close supporters and family so much. They had hoped that after having Gonçalo Amaral's funds frozen, he would not be able to stand up to them. But he did and he won and they can't understand that. So they are striking out in all directions, with hate and rage. The donators gave GA the possibility to appeal, but the judges were the ones who made the decision. Since they can't go after the judges, they are going after the donators.Great post Montclair. And don't forget the extreme frustration that must have been felt by the anti-Amaral internet operatiion, because in order to make an anti-Amaral post on the GFM PJGA page, they would not only have to donate £5 to Mr Amaral's defence fund, but would also have to make themselves traceable (they would have to use debit or credit card to make that £5 donation). A effective multi-sock attack would have required at least a thousand posts and would have involved them contributing at least £5000 to Mr Amaral's defence fund.
Great post Montclair. And don't forget the extreme frustration that must have been felt by the anti-Amaral internet operatives, because in order to make an anti-Amaral post on the GFM PJGA page, they would not only have to donate £5 to Mr Amaral's defence fund, but would also have to make themselves traceable (they would have to use debit or credit card to make that £5 donation). A multi-sock attack would have required at least a thousand posts and would have involved them contributing at least £5000 to Mr Amaral's defence fund.
This doorstepping is obviously instigated by McCanns supporters because they are angry that Gonçalo Amaral, as well as Guerra & Paz and Valentim Carvalho, won their appeal. It was only because people got together and donated money, that GA was able to benefit from the basic right to defend himself, as any citizen should be able to do. This is what angers the parents and their close supporters and family so much. They had hoped that after having Gonçalo Amaral's funds frozen, he would not be able to stand up to them. But he did and he won and they can't understand that. So they are striking out in all directions, with hate and rage. The donators gave GA the possibility to appeal, but the judges were the ones who made the decision. Since they can't go after the judges, they are going after the donators.
This doorstepping is obviously instigated by McCanns supporters because they are angry that Gonçalo Amaral, as well as Guerra & Paz and Valentim Carvalho, won their appeal. It was only because people got together and donated money, that GA was able to benefit from the basic right to defend himself, as any citizen should be able to do. This is what angers the parents and their close supporters and family so much. They had hoped that after having Gonçalo Amaral's funds frozen, he would not be able to stand up to them. But he did and he won and they can't understand that. So they are striking out in all directions, with hate and rage. The donators gave GA the possibility to appeal, but the judges were the ones who made the decision. Since they can't go after the judges, they are going after the donators.
There is a certain justice in providing those who have, for best part of 9 years, demanded a global platform upon which to express their opinion about the McCanns & OG, then not actually liking the opportunity they have been presented with. The invasion of their private space is exactly what they fought so hard for GA to be allowed to do to the McCanns in publishing his book.
There is a certain justice in providing those who have, for best part of 9 years, demanded a global platform upon which to express their opinion about the McCanns & OG, then not actually liking the opportunity they have been presented with. The invasion of their private space is exactly what they fought so hard for GA to be allowed to do to the McCanns in publishing his book.
Mr Amaral in all probability enjoys a far greater income than many of those making donations to his fund ... he was refused the Portuguese equivalent of Legal Aid when it was taken into account.
I have a nasty suspicion that this didn't occur to them at the time.Those who wanted to attack the GFM appeal were mainly restricted to doing so on twitter and forums.
and the McCann's have invaded the media for the last nine years with their bleating.
Look where it's got them.
and the McCann's have invaded the media for the last nine years with their bleating.
Look where it's got them.
Mr Amaral in all probability enjoys a far greater income than many of those making donations to his fund ... he was refused the Portuguese equivalent of Legal Aid when it was taken into account.
and the McCann's have invaded the media for the last nine years with their bleating.
Look where it's got them.
Great post Montclair. And don't forget the extreme frustration that must have been felt by the anti-Amaral internet operatiion, because in order to make an anti-Amaral post on the GFM PJGA page, they would not only have to donate £5 to Mr Amaral's defence fund, but would also have to make themselves traceable (they would have to use debit or credit card to make that £5 donation). A effective multi-sock attack would have required at least a thousand posts and would have involved them contributing at least £5000 to Mr Amaral's defence fund.
In case it escaped your attention Madeleine McCann has been missing for the last nine years ... now people who have been anxious to express their opinions about her parents have apparently been given the opportunity to do just that.
Why should they be 'bleating' about that?
A case perhaps of bfeing careful what you wish for in case you get it.
I suggest that you read the decision by the appeals court, where the judges state that the McCanns gave up their private space when they exposed their own private lives. Remember the headline "I couldn't make love to Gerry"?
Yes. Madeleine almost permanently in The News.
What did that disclosure have to do with the disappearance of Madeleine & the accusations made by Amaral in his book?
It had to do with courting publicity- nothing to do with searching for their daughter at all, and sex sells everything so a great marketing ploy!
It had absolutely nothing to do with making information about the case available in the public domain. Had it been Tony & Cherie Blair in the McCanns position, would all stories in the press about them have been used to support the Appeal Court's version of courting the press?
I think of donators have posted comments on the GFM website then they have put themselves in the public eye and deserve all that comes their way.
Do we assume that that argument applies to everything?Everything in what way
Everything in what way
People who put themselves in the public eye deserve all that comes their way?
I recall that JP donated to Amaral's fund.
I wonder if JP has been doorstepped.
I see in the comments section of today's stories in the papers, both the Mccanns and SY, in the form of Operation Grange, are getting caned.
Yes the professionals are out in force
It seems some have given up their jobs in order to post full time
I recall that JP donated to Amaral's fund.
I wonder if JP has been doorstepped.
JP won't have made any nasty remarks. And wouldn't, no matter what side he was on.
Not yet
Not yet
I don't consider the McCanns put themselves in the public eye
They were forced there by by the abductor ..imo
Oh by the way dave, who do you think is paying these 'professionals' to comments on the mccanns ?
*&*%£ 8)--))
Is it on that agenda we hear about?
Oh by the way dave, who do you think is paying these 'professionals' to comments on the mccanns ?
*&*%£ 8)--))
I don't consider the McCanns put themselves in the public eyeYes Davel GM was physically bundled by the abductor onto a multimillion pound private jet and tortured until he reluctantly agreed to be photographed kissing the pope's hand, and then the abductor forced Mitchell to distribute the photos worldwide.
They were forced there by by the abductor ..imo
People who put themselves in the public eye deserve all that comes their way?
Do you think that people searching for their missing child are in the same category as z-celebs who sell whatever salacious story they can think of in the hope of a walk-in role on an obscure TV sitcom?
No! but they certainly succumbed to z list celebs selling sex story as headline in a sex sells everything trash mag, and 'appearing' on the Oprah show and many ,many other 'shows' and fronting 'good causes', um yeah actually!
I imagine from the standard of their comments most are on benefits
.....and I hope it doesn't happen to you or anyone else.
Well in the unlikely event that I do get 'doorstepped' then so be it. I would do my best to
Overcome the shame of being quoted in the daily wail and explain exactly why I contributed to the fund.
But I also make it a rule never to say anything that I would not happily say face to face.
Well in the unlikely event that I do get 'doorstepped' then so be it. I would do my best to
Overcome the shame of being quoted in the daily wail and explain exactly why I contributed to the fund.
But I also make it a rule never to say anything that I would not happily say face to face.
I imagine from the standard of their comments most are on benefits
oops Hi JP... 8()-000(
Are we moving wands here? do we magic the parents 'sex sells everything' headlines out of this equasion? they allegedly put the proceeds from this sex story head line (ew, cringing), to search for their daughter BUT as we all know this money was used /will be used to pay for legal fees. No one door stepped people who donated to that fund to ask why they donated, and better still are they happy with how the money has been spent!
Re Phoney Tony and his wife human rights expert!!! and friend of Kate's? are not well liked by many people inside and outsie his wee group- In my opinion he is a disgrace to this country.
This doorstepping is obviously instigated by McCanns supporters because they are angry that Gonçalo Amaral, as well as Guerra & Paz and Valentim Carvalho, won their appeal. It was only because people got together and donated money, that GA was able to benefit from the basic right to defend himself, as any citizen should be able to do. This is what angers the parents and their close supporters and family so much. They had hoped that after having Gonçalo Amaral's funds frozen, he would not be able to stand up to them. But he did and he won and they can't understand that. So they are striking out in all directions, with hate and rage. The donators gave GA the possibility to appeal, but the judges were the ones who made the decision. Since they can't go after the judges, they are going after the donators.
You credit McCann supporters with way too much power 8**8:/:
I thought that I had read somewhere that Amaral had already launched his Appeal just before the GFM got into gear.
How much does it cost to launch and Appeal on a Case already running?
And why the reluctance to be transparent about it's use?
Don't know why you make such a big deal about what Kate wrote in her book, it was the newspaper who decided on the headline not the McCann's.
I am not making any deal, I am just commenting on what Kate said. Perhaps the next time I meet my friends whos sons funeral I attended last year, I will indeed ask the parents how their sex life has been affected, because apparently this is deemed as appropriate in your estimation? in anyones estimation? and perhaps you would advise on appropriate timeing of such a conversation 6 weeks? 6 months?
The book was written to make money, sex sells - live with that.
Has your friend written a book then?
Kate McCann by the looks of it left nothing out of her book, she tells about the Psychological impact having a missing child has on your relationship, how the thought that Madeleine could be with Paedophiles, revolted her and the thought of sex was sickening to her.
Not that you would understand anything that parents of a missing child go through, living in your little bubble.
Has your friend written a book then?
Kate McCann by the looks of it left nothing out of her book, she tells about the Psychological impact having a missing child has on your relationship, how the thought that Madeleine could be with Paedophiles, revolted her and the thought of sex was sickening to her.
Not that you would understand anything that parents of a missing child go through, living in your little bubble.
She should have thought of that before leaving her beloved children by themselves.
MANTRA
It's all a bit 'Katie Price' for me.
I feel sorry for you if you think that way, that sex spoken about in the way Kate McCann did to portray the way having a child disappear and the scenarios conjured up with thoughts of what your child could be going through, can have a Psychological affect on you. You just think is smut, it just shows how narrow your mind is.
She put it in the book and serialized in the 'sun' to get sympathy.
Another of the mistakes they made.
It was the Sun who put that heading in it's paper it was The Sun who were thinking on the lines of 'sex sells' though people reading it in its context would understand why Kate McCann wrote it in her book, unless they don't understand the Psychological side of it, then of course they will have childish comments to make.
What a pathetic excuse.
No one forced her to include it in the book.
She did it for sympathy.
As a reminder...
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/3571775/Kate-McCann-I-couldnt-make-love-to-Gerry.html
Don't be ridiculous, she thought it was important to point out how things affect you, many couples have split when their child has been abducted or gone missing.
To gain sympathy, why would you come to that conclusion, many parents have spoken about these things in their book.
Don't be ridiculous, she thought it was important to point out how things affect you, many couples have split when their child has been abducted or gone missing.
To gain sympathy, why would you come to that conclusion, many parents have spoken about these things in their book.
I feel sorry for you if you think that way, that sex spoken about in the way Kate McCann did to portray the way having a child disappear and the scenarios conjured up with thoughts of what your child could be going through, can have a Psychological affect on you. You just think is smut, it just shows how narrow your mind is.
i have read many books by the parents of missing children, from Lesley Ann Downey's mum to Holly Weel's father.. Most had list view their children to paedophiles. Not one saw the need to tell the world and his wife about the effect of losing their child on their sex lives. Then again none of the parents had agreed to be paid by the Sun for the serialisation rights.