UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: John on August 03, 2016, 10:19:04 PM

Title: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: John on August 03, 2016, 10:19:04 PM
These facts appear to be beyond dispute.  Nine members of the Smith family encountered a man carrying a small female child on the night of 3rd May 2007 at approximately 10pm yet despite national and international appeals he has failed to come forward.

Is there anyone who still doesn't find that suspicious?


37
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 03, 2016, 10:41:21 PM
These facts appear to be beyond dispute.  Nine members of the Smith family encountered a man carrying a small female child on the night of 3rd May 2007 at approximately 10pm yet despite national and international appeals he has failed to come forward.

Is there anyone who still doesn't find that suspicious?
Yes - me.  Here's why.

No appeal on McCann FM pages.  No CirimeWatch in Portugal or Spain.  Person described exclusively here as the new suspect - suspeito.

At best he gets hauled off to Faro for a day or two next time SY swan out (at his own time, own expense, plus costs for a lawyer).  Then all he has to do is PROVE he is innocent.
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: Alfie on August 03, 2016, 10:52:34 PM
Yes - me.  Here's why.

No appeal on McCann FM pages.  No CirimeWatch in Portugal or Spain.  Person described exclusively here as the new suspect - suspeito.

At best he gets hauled off to Faro for a day or two next time SY swan out (at his own time, own expense, plus costs for a lawyer).  Then all he has to do is PROVE he is innocent.
Is that how it works in Portugal?  People have to prove their innocence?  What about the police finding evidence of guilt?  Carrying a child (presumably your own if you have one and can show that you have one fitting the bill) is not a crime, even in Portugal is it?
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 03, 2016, 11:38:37 PM
Is that how it works in Portugal?  People have to prove their innocence?  What about the police finding evidence of guilt?  Carrying a child (presumably your own if you have one and can show that you have one fitting the bill) is not a crime, even in Portugal is it?
Nope, all you have to PROVE is the child didn't belong to the McCanns.  Given that the only missing child is a McCann child, and SY made Smithman the new suspeito, all you have to explain is why Smithman, even if he recognised himself, should stick his head in a noose.  Go for it.
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: mercury on August 03, 2016, 11:49:42 PM
Is that how it works in Portugal?  People have to prove their innocence?  What about the police finding evidence of guilt?  Carrying a child (presumably your own if you have one and can show that you have one fitting the bill) is not a crime, even in Portugal is it?

No different to uk and nz it seems as some poor girls family was asked for a dna test to prove she wasnt MM, just because some people thought she looked like her
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 03, 2016, 11:55:06 PM
Nope, all you have to PROVE is the child didn't belong to the McCanns.  Given that the only missing child is a McCann child, and SY made Smithman the new suspeito, all you have to explain is why Smithman, even if he recognised himself, should stick his head in a noose.  Go for it.
That is not going to be so easy.  If Smithman is willing to lie maybe but what happens if he is fearful of lying.  (What does it say "liars will be cast into the lake of fire".)  So that prospect could be worse than living with the fear of coming forward.  One option is lying but the other is not lying.
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: Brietta on August 04, 2016, 12:56:19 AM
Nope, all you have to PROVE is the child didn't belong to the McCanns.  Given that the only missing child is a McCann child, and SY made Smithman the new suspeito, all you have to explain is why Smithman, even if he recognised himself, should stick his head in a noose.  Go for it.

I can see where you are coming from with this, Shining. But the father DCI Redwood told us about who had come forward and claimed he was carrying his daughter home from a creche ... didn't seem to have that problem with Scotland Yard.
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: mercury on August 04, 2016, 02:02:58 AM
I can see where you are coming from with this, Shining. But the father DCI Redwood told us about who had come forward and claimed he was carrying his daughter home from a creche ... didn't seem to have that problem with Scotland Yard.

he wasnt personally accused so wouldnt have
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 04, 2016, 03:19:02 AM
he wasnt personally accused so wouldnt have
But it takes a bit of courage to admit being near the scene of the crime.    So it would be interesting to know who was this person?
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: G-Unit on August 04, 2016, 10:20:11 AM
Yes - me.  Here's why.

No appeal on McCann FM pages.  No CirimeWatch in Portugal or Spain.  Person described exclusively here as the new suspect - suspeito.

At best he gets hauled off to Faro for a day or two next time SY swan out (at his own time, own expense, plus costs for a lawyer).  Then all he has to do is PROVE he is innocent.

The Metropolitan Police appeal for a man seen in Luz on 3rd May 2007 to be identified. The Crimewatch programme is shown in the UK and Ireland, followed by appeals in Holland and Germany. The majority of tourists visiting the Algarve are from those three countries, as are the majority of holiday home owners, which suggests the appeal was aimed at tourists rather than locals.

When questioned, The Met said;

there is no such show in Portugal, while the UK, Ireland, Germany and the Netherlands have regular television programmes appealing for viewers’ assistance in solving crime.

The BBC said;

 “We have provided clips of the Crimewatch programme to international broadcasters to assist them in their coverage of the appeal, and the Crimewatch film is available on the BBC Crimewatch website to international audiences. The decision on broadcasting an appeal on an equivalent programme in Portugal is a matter for the Portuguese broadcasters, Portuguese police and The Metropolitan Police”

The Portuguese police, typically, said nothing. Portuguese broadcasters said;

The Deputy Director of News at Sic Television was meanwhile reported to have exchanged e-mails with the BBC in the days running up to the Crimewatch programme in order to secure the rights to the full programme, but to no avail.
“The BBC said they are not selling the rights”, Martim Cabral told The Portugal News, “therefore we cannot show it.”
Another Portuguese news channel, TVI, told The Portugal News that it had contacted the British national broadcaster prior to the airing of the show, as it sought to “acquire the programme for Portugal, which was denied.”
http://www.theportugalnews.com/news/crimewatch-aired-in-uk-ireland-netherlands-germany-but-why-not-portugal/29659
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: John on August 04, 2016, 05:59:53 PM
Yes - me.  Here's why.

No appeal on McCann FM pages.  No CirimeWatch in Portugal or Spain.  Person described exclusively here as the new suspect - suspeito.

At best he gets hauled off to Faro for a day or two next time SY swan out (at his own time, own expense, plus costs for a lawyer).  Then all he has to do is PROVE he is innocent.

Yes, good points SiL. Has the dissemination of information been so poor on the Algarve that you think some locals are still unaware of Smithman and the need to identify him and if possible exclude him from the investigation?  If that is the case surely SY and the FM Fund money would have been better spent in a targeted campaign to find this guy?

Do you think the PJ have given up totally?
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: Alfie on August 04, 2016, 06:39:43 PM
Nope, all you have to PROVE is the child didn't belong to the McCanns.  Given that the only missing child is a McCann child, and SY made Smithman the new suspeito, all you have to explain is why Smithman, even if he recognised himself, should stick his head in a noose.  Go for it.
Well let's see...how did Crecheman manage it I wonder...? &%+((£
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: ferryman on August 04, 2016, 08:09:05 PM
These facts appear to be beyond dispute.  Nine members of the Smith family encountered a man carrying a small female child on the night of 3rd May 2007 at approximately 10pm yet despite national and international appeals he has failed to come forward.

Is there anyone who still doesn't find that suspicious?


10

If Smithman was also tractor-man (and Madeleine's abductor) Madeleine's abductor may be dead.

If that were so (I fear) that may also bode ill for Madeleine.
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: G-Unit on August 04, 2016, 08:24:52 PM
If Smithman was also tractor-man (and Madeleine's abductor) Madeleine's abductor may be dead.

If that were so (I fear) that may also bode ill for Madeleine.

Well, there's no denying the similarities [?]

(http://i.imgur.com/kZp0blv.jpg?1)
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 04, 2016, 08:31:34 PM
Yes, good points SiL. Has the dissemination of information been so poor on the Algarve that you think some locals are still unaware of Smithman and the need to identify him and if possible exclude him from the investigation?  If that is the case surely SY and the FM Fund money would have been better spent in a targeted campaign to find this guy?

Do you think the PJ have given up totally?
Quite why SY did not push to get the CrimeWatch onto Portuguese TV is a matter for conjecture.

All I can see on the Portuguese side is that this man is not referred to as someone who may be entirely innocent (as per Redwood/CrimeWatch), but became the main SUSPECT. It reminds me of the ducking stool concept.  If you drown you are innocent.  If you survive, we will burn you.

If you want the nearest equivalent, think of the pig farmer hauled in for questioning in Dec 14.  His criminal past was that the crime was committed in Luz, but otherwise has absolutely no connection to the McCann case, in time or MO.  But nonetheless he got flame roasted by the press in Portugal and the UK.

As to the PJ, judging by the James Watson/Rikki Neave news recently, I think they are quite happy to carry out actions that are requested and legal under European law.  I am not sure if that actually makes them interested though.

Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: Carana on August 04, 2016, 08:51:04 PM
Crimewatch did make clips available at the time.

The foreign online media did pick up on it. I'm trying to remember if I saw embedded clips or stills with a summary translation of the main details. I have no idea whether the clips were copied for live broadcast in PT or not.

 The Crimewatch equivalent in at least one or two countries (Germany and Holland?) did feature it.
There doesn't appear to be an equivalent of Crimewatch in PT (or at least there wasn't).

One potential issue may have been the risk of the populist TV media (TVI or CMTV if that one existed at the time) using a UK police appeal followed by a panel chat involving Amaral slamming out against the UK police and Smithman = Gerry, with fridges, bags, dogs and DNA gibberish yet again.

Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: misty on August 04, 2016, 10:57:33 PM
Quite why SY did not push to get the CrimeWatch onto Portuguese TV is a matter for conjecture.

All I can see on the Portuguese side is that this man is not referred to as someone who may be entirely innocent (as per Redwood/CrimeWatch), but became the main SUSPECT. It reminds me of the ducking stool concept.  If you drown you are innocent.  If you survive, we will burn you.

If you want the nearest equivalent, think of the pig farmer hauled in for questioning in Dec 14.  His criminal past was that the crime was committed in Luz, but otherwise has absolutely no connection to the McCann case, in time or MO.  But nonetheless he got flame roasted by the press in Portugal and the UK.

As to the PJ, judging by the James Watson/Rikki Neave news recently, I think they are quite happy to carry out actions that are requested and legal under European law.  I am not sure if that actually makes them interested though.


How heavily edited do you think a Portuguese offering would have been, bearing in mind that the investigation had not even been reopened there when Crimewatch was aired? Their judicial reluctance to release efits in criminal  investigations is well-known.

http://cmtv.sapo.pt/opiniao/detalhe/carlos-anjos-divulgacao-de-retrato-robo-e-muito-pouco-profissional.html

(see http://joana-morais.blogspot.co.uk/2013/10/carlos-anjos-release-of-e-fits-is-very.html  for full interview translation)


*snipped*

CMTV October 14th 2013

News anchor Andreia Vale [AV]: In the studio with us is Carlos Anjos, CMTV commentator. Hello Carlos, good afternoon. Thank you for being here. This e-fit of an individual, this new "breath" of the [English police] investigation, does it have any credibility in your opinion?

Carlos Anjos [CA], President of the Committee for the Protection of Crime Victims/ former president of the Criminal Investigation Officers' Union of the PJ (ASFIC/PJ) - Good afternoon. Unfortunately, no. Unfortunately, no. It seems to me, from the way that this is being carried out, from the standpoint of the criminal investigation to be very unprofessional. We do have in fact two schools of thought. We have the school of thought of criminal investigation in Continental Europe that has a particular way of working, where the media is only used to divulge any information when it reaches a dead end and is unable to go further; and the Anglo-Saxon school that uses the media in every way possible...

Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: Brietta on August 05, 2016, 12:57:33 AM

How heavily edited do you think a Portuguese offering would have been, bearing in mind that the investigation had not even been reopened there when Crimewatch was aired? Their judicial reluctance to release efits in criminal  investigations is well-known.

http://cmtv.sapo.pt/opiniao/detalhe/carlos-anjos-divulgacao-de-retrato-robo-e-muito-pouco-profissional.html

(see http://joana-morais.blogspot.co.uk/2013/10/carlos-anjos-release-of-e-fits-is-very.html  for full interview translation)


*snipped*

CMTV October 14th 2013

News anchor Andreia Vale [AV]: In the studio with us is Carlos Anjos, CMTV commentator. Hello Carlos, good afternoon. Thank you for being here. This e-fit of an individual, this new "breath" of the [English police] investigation, does it have any credibility in your opinion?

Carlos Anjos [CA], President of the Committee for the Protection of Crime Victims/ former president of the Criminal Investigation Officers' Union of the PJ (ASFIC/PJ) - Good afternoon. Unfortunately, no. Unfortunately, no. It seems to me, from the way that this is being carried out, from the standpoint of the criminal investigation to be very unprofessional. We do have in fact two schools of thought. We have the school of thought of criminal investigation in Continental Europe that has a particular way of working, where the media is only used to divulge any information when it reaches a dead end and is unable to go further; and the Anglo-Saxon school that uses the media in every way possible...

The Polícia Judiciária were in the process of finalising their own review of Madeleine's case which had taken a different path from that carried out by Scotland Yard.

There was great sensitivity as far as reopening Madeleine's case was concerned.  The Scotland Yard review had realised sufficient investigative leads to justify reopening the investigation into Madeleine's disappearance.  The process was not at that stage in Portugal where the decision to proceed with a new Portuguese investigation had not been ratified when the Crimewatch programme was broadcast. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-24655826

The very fine balance between Madeleine's case being reopened or not by the Portuguese might have been jeopardised by broadcasting the Crimewatch programme with content which was at variance with the evidence being followed by the PJ.
It is perfectly possible that the PJ in their independent inquiry had looked at the Smith sighting again and had their own reason for discounting it.  They had no interest in it first time round ... until Mr Smith's false memory moment in September.
 
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: John on August 05, 2016, 01:02:00 AM
Well let's see...how did Crecheman manage it I wonder...? &%+((£

Could it be that Crecheman is English while Smithman is Portuguese?
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: John on August 05, 2016, 01:03:08 AM
If Smithman was also tractor-man (and Madeleine's abductor) Madeleine's abductor may be dead.

If that were so (I fear) that may also bode ill for Madeleine.

Smithman wasn't black.
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: John on August 05, 2016, 01:09:10 AM
Finding Smithman and eliminating him is possible is crucial to this investigation.  Why have SY through the PJ not made attempts to do so, I find this extremely puzzling?
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: mercury on August 05, 2016, 02:28:46 AM
Well, there's no denying the similarities [?]

(http://i.imgur.com/kZp0blv.jpg?1)

 @)(++(*
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: Angelo222 on August 05, 2016, 12:40:04 PM
Find Smithman and at least half the mystery will be solved imo.  But it ain't gonna happen so ask yourselves WHY?
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: pegasus on August 06, 2016, 03:54:58 AM
Finding Smithman and eliminating him is possible is crucial to this investigation.  Why have SY through the PJ not made attempts to do so, I find this extremely puzzling?
Basically that Crimewatch program was completely inaccessible to the portuguese-speaking public in portugal.
Portuguese broadcasters wanted to show it but were refused permission.
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 06, 2016, 04:56:25 AM
Basically that Crimewatch program was completely inaccessible to the portuguese-speaking public in portugal.
Portuguese broadcasters wanted to show it but were refused permission.
"Portuguese broadcasters wanted to show it but were refused permission", by whom?  PJ or government interference?
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: John on August 06, 2016, 11:41:57 AM
Find Smithman and at least half the mystery will be solved imo.  But it ain't gonna happen so ask yourselves WHY?

I agree, Smithman could very well be the key to this.  A concerted effort should have been made in Luz and the surrounding area to identify this man.  Even now some nine years on identifying him would establish once and for all if this sighting at 10pm has any prominence.
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: pegasus on August 06, 2016, 03:02:15 PM
"Portuguese broadcasters wanted to show it but were refused permission", by whom?  PJ or government interference?
See http://joana-morais.blogspot.co.uk/2013/10/crimewatch-aired-in-uk-ireland.html Robbity
Quote
The Deputy Director of News at SIC Television was meanwhile reported to have exchanged e-mails with the BBC in the days running up to the Crimewatch programme in order to secure the rights to the full programme, but to no avail.

“The BBC said they are not selling the rights”, Martim Cabral told The Portugal News, “therefore we cannot show it.”

Another Portuguese news channel, TVI, told The Portugal News that it had contacted the British national broadcaster prior to the airing of the show, as it sought to “acquire the programme for Portugal, which was denied.”

Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 07, 2016, 05:07:17 AM
See http://joana-morais.blogspot.co.uk/2013/10/crimewatch-aired-in-uk-ireland.html Robbity
Seems like a lot of lame excuses to me.
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: pegasus on August 11, 2016, 01:41:28 AM
@Shining would you agree that people from other parts of Portugal sometimes holiday in the Algarve?
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 11, 2016, 02:04:39 AM
@Shining would you agree that people from other parts of Portugal sometimes holiday in the Algarve?
According to the folks here, August is the month they hate.

The folks from Lisbon swarm over the Algarve.  Rightly or wrongly, they are seen as stressed out and aggressive.  (Note - this view is from a local.)

The locals, if they can, head somewhere else for August.
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: pegasus on August 11, 2016, 02:46:36 AM
According to the folks here, August is the month they hate.

The folks from Lisbon swarm over the Algarve.  Rightly or wrongly, they are seen as stressed out and aggressive.  (Note - this view is from a local.)

The locals, if they can, head somewhere else for August.
Thanks Shining. Just looking at the possibility the man and child seen by Smith group, could be a portuguese tourist father and daughter who live in another part of Portugal and were in Luz for a week's holiday.
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 11, 2016, 03:59:45 AM
Thanks Shining. Just looking at the possibility the man and child seen by Smith group, could be a portuguese tourist father and daughter who live in another part of Portugal and were in Luz for a week's holiday.
Rather specific.  It could have been just for that day too.
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 11, 2016, 07:44:43 AM
"Her skin was very white, typical of a Brit."

"He was somewhat tanned as a result of sun exposure."

Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: pegasus on August 12, 2016, 09:36:05 PM
"Her skin was very white, typical of a Brit."

"He was somewhat tanned as a result of sun exposure."
Skin colour of mainland portuguese people varies from light pink to intermediate white and tanned.
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: misty on August 12, 2016, 10:52:31 PM
"Her skin was very white, typical of a Brit."

"He was somewhat tanned as a result of sun exposure."

Or Russian.....Dutch.....German........Scandinavian........
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: pegasus on August 12, 2016, 11:30:14 PM
Or Russian.....Dutch.....German........Scandinavian........
Precisely Misty.
There is an instructive example in another incident where 2 english witnesses tried to converse in the foreign language English with a distraught woman in the road, but without success.

The reason is the obvious one straight out of "Occam For Beginners - The Simplified Version" ...

The woman did not understand English.


 
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 28, 2016, 07:58:34 AM
I can see where you are coming from with this, Shining. But the father DCI Redwood told us about who had come forward and claimed he was carrying his daughter home from a creche ... didn't seem to have that problem with Scotland Yard.
It might be harder if this same person has to admit to being Smithman too!
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: John on August 28, 2016, 12:54:12 PM
"Portuguese broadcasters wanted to show it but were refused permission", by whom?  PJ or government interference?

See http://joana-morais.blogspot.co.uk/2013/10/crimewatch-aired-in-uk-ireland.html Robbity
Quote
The Deputy Director of News at SIC Television was meanwhile reported to have exchanged e-mails with the BBC in the days running up to the Crimewatch programme in order to secure the rights to the full programme, but to no avail.

“The BBC said they are not selling the rights”, Martim Cabral told The Portugal News, “therefore we cannot show it.”

Another Portuguese news channel, TVI, told The Portugal News that it had contacted the British national broadcaster prior to the airing of the show, as it sought to “acquire the programme for Portugal, which was denied.”


This is very bad Press for both Crimewatch and the BBC and should be pursued with them both.

A little girl has disappeared, thought to have been abducted, and the BBC is playing bloody games?
Title: Re: Surely if Smithman was innocent he would have come forward by now?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 28, 2016, 01:29:56 PM


This is very bad Press for both Crimewatch and the BBC and should be pursued with them both.

A little girl has disappeared, thought to have been abducted, and the BBC is playing bloody games?

Sub titled "she disappeared in Portugal but we will not let it be aired there where it will do more good,potentially, than being aired in UK".