UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Angelo222 on August 18, 2016, 02:09:14 PM

Title: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Angelo222 on August 18, 2016, 02:09:14 PM
The safety of the balconies at Ocean Club seems to have attracted some discussion among tourists with young children and especially those who were accommodated on the upper floors.  I must say looking at the design of the balcony with a railing atop a low wall, it certainly doesn't engenger much confidence.  My 2½-year-old grandson can climb out of his cot so a balcony wall like that would be no obstacle to him.

(http://mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/mail260314i.jpg)

247
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 18, 2016, 08:04:32 PM
At what stage did OC put up those stickers?  Were they displayed prior to 3 May 2007?

Is this an actual quote from Goncalo Amaral? "They are being left to sleep alone, while the parents get drunk at social gatherings, falling from windows and balconies like ripe fruit, or drying inside vehicles without the according penal sanction occurring"  Is he listing things that have happened previously? http://gerrymccan-abuseofpower-humanrights.blogspot.co.nz/2010/07/jez-wilkins-and-bridget-odonnell-hoax.html
[That anonymous letter at the bottom of that article is mighty odd, and it even has the word "cover up" in it.]

This is taken from an article written by one of the OC guests and she doesn't mention these stickers.
Quote
Excitedly, we were shown to our apartments. Ours was on the fourth floor, overlooking a family and toddler pool, opposite a restaurant and bar called the Tapas. I worried about the height of the balcony. Should we ask for one on the ground floor? Was I a paranoid parent? Should I make a fuss, or just enjoy the view?
https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2007/dec/14/ukcrime.madeleinemccann

It seems to suggest the balcony was relatively low when the words: "I worried about the height of the balcony", are used.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 18, 2016, 08:55:44 PM
Am I in a minority when I say that I've never needed warning to lock my holiday accommodation any more than I have ever needed warning to lock my home?

None of that addresses the point about mobile children being left with access to a dangerous balcony anyway. I think there was a warning sticker on the patio doors about that also.
Where did the impetus for this comment come from in the first place G-unit?  "None of that addresses the point about mobile children being left with access to a dangerous balcony anyway."  Who made the point "about mobile children being left with access to a dangerous balcony" in the first place?
Do you know more than you are allowed to divulge about this case?  For that comment has the indications of quite serious behind the scenes discussion.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 18, 2016, 09:20:09 PM
Where did the impetus for this comment come from in the first place G-unit?  "None of that addresses the point about mobile children being left with access to a dangerous balcony anyway."  Who made the point "about mobile children being left with access to a dangerous balcony" in the first place?
Do you know more than you are allowed to divulge about this case?  For that comment has the indications of quite serious behind the scenes discussion.

A few points raised!

1. I think it was pegasus who posted a pic showing the patio door sticker. With or without it the balcony wasn't safe for small children on their own. I think David Payne commented on this too.

2. It is purely my own sense that tells me not to leave mobile children in an unlocked apartment with easy access to a dangerous balcony. The height is immaterial because there was patio furniture to climb up on anyway.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2016, 12:04:49 AM
The safety warning sticker.  What date was this first installed at the apartments?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2016, 12:17:49 AM
Health and safety rules would have insisted on adequate warnings being displayed.  There seems to be a "Missing Child Procedure" so they might have also had a "Health and Safety Procedure" and we should see if the version used in 2007 is still available.  We should write to Mark Warner asking for a copy.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: misty on August 19, 2016, 12:22:06 AM
That photo is not even from Block 5 IMO.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 19, 2016, 12:22:48 AM
Health and safety rules would have insisted on adequate warnings being displayed.  There seems to be a "Missing Child Procedure" so they might have also had a "Health and Safety Procedure" and we should see if the version used in 2007 is still available.  We should write to Mark Warner asking for a copy.
Parental instinct and responsibility for safety of their kids should not be the responsibility of the health and safety bodies, are you having a larf? Unless all their holidaymakers are imbeciles, as I said, but yes, write to them, let us know what reply you get
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2016, 12:23:42 AM
The safety warning sticker.  What date was this first installed at the apartments?
It seems to be the most unlikely thing one would bother to photograph whilst on holiday.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 19, 2016, 05:48:18 AM
I repeat. No parent with an ounce of sense would let small children onto those balconies alone. Neither would they leave unsupervised children with access to those balconies. No warning stickers needed.

we would keep an eye and you know explain to them that they shouldn't be out on the balcony you know without an adult present. Err but obviously we tried to keep the err door shut when no-one was out on the balcony and err open if there's someone sat out there keeping an eye on them.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/DAVID-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2016, 06:12:19 AM
I repeat. No parent with an ounce of sense would let small children onto those balconies alone. Neither would they leave unsupervised children with access to those balconies. No warning stickers needed.

we would keep an eye and you know explain to them that they shouldn't be out on the balcony you know without an adult present. Err but obviously we tried to keep the err door shut when no-one was out on the balcony and err open if there's someone sat out there keeping an eye on them.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/DAVID-PAYNE-ROGATORY.htm
If you were on the 5th floor would the parents always keep their patio door locked at night even though there was no external access to the patio?  A child could get up and sleep walk out through the unlocked door and climb the rail.  Sleepwalking is a strange phenomenon that is quite unpredictable.  Would you always have enough foresight to prevent an accident from it?
http://listverse.com/2013/06/07/10-terrifying-tales-of-sleepwalking/
Quote
Sleepwalking is more common in children than in adults. About 17% of 4-8 year olds experience sleepwalking, compared to 4 to 10% of adults. Stuart Miller was 8 years old when he had an accident while sleepwalking. One night, in September of 1993, Stuart began sleepwalking. He lived in a flat on the fourth floor of council housing, and that night, he fell from his bedroom window. The courts decided that Reading Borough Council, the owner of that block, was responsible, as they had failed to install windows that were childproof. The fall dealt severe damage to Stuart’s spine, and has left him wheelchair bound for life. After 7 years in the courts, he was awarded £1.35m ($2m) in damages.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 19, 2016, 10:59:36 AM
This is taken from an article written by one of the OC guests and she doesn't mention these stickers.https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2007/dec/14/ukcrime.madeleinemccann

It seems to suggest the balcony was relatively low when the words: "I worried about the height of the balcony", are used.

There is a Eurocode for handrail and balustrade heights.
For external the minimum height is 1100 mm.
Are you suggesting the building does not comply with the Eurocode? If so why are you suggesting it?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2016, 11:14:40 AM
There is a Eurocode for handrail and balustrade heights.
For external the minimum height is 1100 mm.
Are you suggesting the building does not comply with the Eurocode? If so why are you suggesting it?
Can you see any measurements? I can't.  It was Bridget O'Donnell who said ""I worried about the height of the balcony".  So maybe you need to ask her if she is "suggesting the building does not comply with the Eurocode?"
PS: Putting a measuring tape up against my body and imagining what a 1100 mm balustrade would be like and   it didn't feel low to me.  So I wonder what height it really is.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 19, 2016, 12:19:49 PM
Here's the Payne's balcony, which would have been similar to O'Donnell's

(http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/OA3_8/03_volume_III_o_apenso_VIII_Page_563.jpg)
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2016, 12:48:17 PM
Here's the Payne's balcony, which would have been similar to O'Donnell's


1100 mm came up to the top of my hip bone. So that balcony looks lower than that, as it looks lower than the waist of "Fiona", but that is just from a visual analysis.  What would happen if it had been constructed at a lower than standard height?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2016, 01:42:01 PM
There is a Eurocode for handrail and balustrade heights.
For external the minimum height is 1100 mm.
Are you suggesting the building does not comply with the Eurocode? If so why are you suggesting it?
From the photo supplied and comparing my height to a measurement of 1100mm the balustrade is lower the Eurocode standard.  Whether the standard covers these existing buildings I don't know.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 19, 2016, 01:47:13 PM
Can you see any measurements? I can't.  It was Bridget O'Donnell who said ""I worried about the height of the balcony".  So maybe you need to ask her if she is "suggesting the building does not comply with the Eurocode?"
PS: Putting a measuring tape up against my body and imagining what a 1100 mm balustrade would be like and   it didn't feel low to me.  So I wonder what height it really is.

1100 mm as per the code. There is no valid reason reason to think otherwise. Unless you believe that internal components were used in error in which case it would be 950mm but you or Bridget would need a valid reason to think that.
I'll make it easy: The average human being is crap at estimating mass distance and time so
screw what Bridget O'Donnell thought about the balcony/balustrade height. For her opinion to count she would need to know how high it was as measured rather than viewed and guessed, added to a knowledge of Eurocodes allied to the construction industry. Had she that knowledge I am sure she would have said "the balustrades were below the height recommended by the the code" rather than the woolly remarks attributed to her.
The chain from start to finish on the building project will include but not be limited to:
Client;architect;structural engineering consultant;local planning officer;main contractor;balustrade subcontractor;building inspectors. I would imagine balustrades without the relevant code would have been noticed by most of those with remedial works carried out as a result.
Unless of course we are expected to believe there was a vast conspiracy theory around a p**s balling bit of hand rail ?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Angelo222 on August 19, 2016, 01:58:36 PM
The McCann's apartment was a ground floor apartment even though it sat high on the pool side (south).  What amazes me is that the design of the security wall/railing shown below is such that a young child could climb up on it very easily and topple over onto the steps below.

It gets worse.  If you look at the wall further along it appears to be only about a foot high with no railing atop it.

To me that looks like an accident just waiting to happen?

(http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/notwviewfrompatio.jpg)

(http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/.pond/zzstairsrear.jpg.w300h505.jpg)
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pathfinder73 on August 19, 2016, 02:35:21 PM
Railings were there on 3 May 2007.

(http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/000skynews8.jpg)
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2016, 02:39:23 PM
1100 mm as per the code. There is no valid reason reason to think otherwise. Unless you believe that internal components were used in error in which case it would be 950mm but you or Bridget would need a valid reason to think that.
...
Unless of course we are expected to believe there was a vast conspiracy theory around a p**s balling bit of hand rail ?
Once I'd worked out what you said in the ending bit I realised how right you are.  If we set out to prove the height of these balustrades and they are found to be substandard.  The building then having some minor defect in complying with the building code could mean that the company has a commercial reason to keep an accident resulting from these substandard balustrades quiet.
If say an accidental death occurred in another apartment and that cadaver somehow ended up in the McCann's apartment, we can have a source of cadaver odour without the requirement that Madeleine need die to be the suspected cause of the cadaver odour.

So immediately we could theoretically get a different picture of what could have happened that night.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 19, 2016, 02:44:20 PM
From the photo supplied and comparing my height too a measurement of 1100mm the balustrade is lower the Eurocode standard.  Whether the standard covers these existing buildings I don't know.

There is an old adage which covers distortion on photos. "Will that finger go up that nostril?"
Your point about codes and standards being?

 

Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2016, 02:57:10 PM
There is an old adage which covers distortion on photos. "Will that finger go up that nostril?"
Your point about codes and standards being?
I know as new standards have been introduced in NZ they are not applied to existing structure.  So were these buildings exempt from Euro-standards because of their vintage?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Angelo222 on August 19, 2016, 03:15:20 PM
Railings were there on 3 May 2007.

(http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/000skynews8.jpg)

Well spotted Pathfinder, I find that extremely significant.  Is there a record anywhere of them being taken away to be forensically examined?

That wall/railing combo looks to be no more than about 2' or 600mm high to me.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Brietta on August 19, 2016, 03:17:56 PM
The McCann's apartment was a ground floor apartment even though it sat high on the pool side (south).  What amazes me is that the design of the security wall/railing shown below is such that a young child could climb up on it very easily and topple over onto the steps below.

It gets worse.  If you look at the wall further along it appears to be only about a foot high with no railing atop it.

To me that looks like an accident just waiting to happen?

(http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/notwviewfrompatio.jpg)

(http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/.pond/zzstairsrear.jpg.w300h505.jpg)


The thing is though that there is no evidence that any child has suffered serious injury or death having toppled from a balcony at any time or anywhere in Luz.

There is evidence that a child disappeared from her bedroom within a holiday apartment as well as evidence of an intruder.

Perhaps issues such as appropriate lighting ... security of apartment keys ... security patrols along the lines of those instituted in the open resort after Madeleine's disappearance might have had an effect had they been in force. 
The height of the balcony or lack of it is in my opinion an irrelevance.

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2008/09/03/article-1052055-021A2CEB000004B0-912_468x286.jpg)
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 19, 2016, 05:26:34 PM
I know as new standards have been introduced in NZ they are not applied to existing structure.  So were these buildings exempt from Euro-standards because of their vintage?


So ?
They would have been built to what ever standard obtained at the time of construction. That is the norm with construction standards. Eurocodes kicked off life in 1980s. UK standards have been roughly the same since 1975. There is no credible reason to believe the standard obtaining at the time was not applied to this particular building so what is the beef ?.
It would not have been MW's responsibility to enforce the standard at the time of construction that is for sure. The owners of the properties would be responsible for ensuring that they complied all necessary and appropriate regulations when being let out to avoid potential litigation. MW's responsibility would be to ensure the owners had complied with the relevant regulations where MW were acting as the owners letting agents.



Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: stephen25000 on August 19, 2016, 05:43:52 PM

So ?
They would have been built to what ever standard obtained at the time of construction. That is the norm with construction standards. Eurocodes kicked off life in 1980s. UK standards have been roughly the same since 1975. There is no credible reason to believe the standard obtaining at the time was not applied to this particular building so what is the beef ?.
It would not have been MW's responsibility to enforce the standard at the time of construction that is for sure. The owners of the properties would be responsible for ensuring that they complied all necessary and appropriate regulations when being let out to avoid potential litigation. MW's responsibility would be to ensure the owners had complied with the relevant regulations where MW were acting as the owners letting agents.

...and b....r all to do with this case.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 19, 2016, 06:16:31 PM
Well spotted Pathfinder, I find that extremely significant.  Is there a record anywhere of them being taken away to be forensically examined?

That wall/railing combo looks to be no more than about 2' or 600mm high to me.

Look at the bottom of the stairs in the posted photo that is taken looking up.
Two things about it:
1. The rise on the stairs is constant but it don't look it in the pic do it ?. The rise at the top looks less than that at the bottom............... &%+((£
2. The rise will be between 150mm and 220mm (6" to 9" in Mickey Mouse money).
Regs say the top of the wall will be 900mm to 1000mm above the pitch line* of the stairway and parallel to it.
Play with dividers on the screen by all means for a sense check but it will only be a sense check.

All very interesting ..................  ?{)(**


Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 19, 2016, 08:31:25 PM

The thing is though that there is no evidence that any child has suffered serious injury or death having toppled from a balcony at any time or anywhere in Luz.

There is evidence that a child disappeared from her bedroom within a holiday apartment as well as evidence of an intruder.

Perhaps issues such as appropriate lighting ... security of apartment keys ... security patrols along the lines of those instituted in the open resort after Madeleine's disappearance might have had an effect had they been in force. 
The height of the balcony or lack of it is in my opinion an irrelevance.

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2008/09/03/article-1052055-021A2CEB000004B0-912_468x286.jpg)

Maybe theres no evidence that any child fell over the balcony because children were not left alone to enable them to do so
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 19, 2016, 08:36:19 PM
There is a Eurocode for handrail and balustrade heights.
For external the minimum height is 1100 mm.
Are you suggesting the building does not comply with the Eurocode? If so why are you suggesting it?
Bridget could just have meant the height of the balcony DROP not the exact specifications of the railings
Balconies however low or high are climbable and no normal parents leave ther kids around them unsupervised
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2016, 08:47:13 PM
Maybe theres no evidence that any child fell over the balcony because children were not left alone to enable them to do so
All the Tapas 9 left their kids alone.  So what are you talking about?  They were checked at regular intervals but there is plenty of time in between for untoward events to occur.  Others saw what the Tapas 9 were doing and may have copied it and suffered.  How can anyone know what other occupants of other apartments did to get a break once their children were down for the night?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2016, 08:52:16 PM
Bridget could just have meant the height of the balcony DROP not the exact specifications of the railings
Balconies however low or high are climbable and no normal parents leave their kids around them unsupervised
It should still be possible to go and produce a video and take physical measurements of Bridget's balcony and balustrade and see what exactly she was talking about.
We could even interview her and show her the video we've taken and ask her for her own impressions in her own words.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pegasus on August 19, 2016, 09:09:18 PM
That photo is not even from Block 5 IMO.
That photo is block 6 Misty.
I can prove an identical sticker on sliding door of 5A.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2016, 09:19:26 PM
That photo is block 6 Misty.
I can prove an identical sticker on sliding door of 5A.
What about on apartment G4O?  (The one where Jez was staying at in block 4.)
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: misty on August 19, 2016, 09:38:31 PM
That photo is block 6 Misty.
I can prove an identical sticker on sliding door of 5A.

I know you can. It was just an observation based on the obvious height of the window based on the view.

I actually thought BOD was commenting on the height of the balcony from the ground in her comment, not the height of the railings.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pegasus on August 19, 2016, 09:50:21 PM
"BEFORE STEPPING OUT" warning sticker on balcony door of 5A.
Processos Vol IV p970 foto 8
 
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pegasus on August 19, 2016, 09:59:53 PM
What about on apartment G4O?  (The one where Jez was staying at in block 4.)
3 apartments in block 4 were provided to the parents.
One was a penthouse  apartment, provided on 5th May.
There is a good chance it was G4-O.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 19, 2016, 10:15:32 PM
I know you can. It was just an observation based on the obvious height of the window based on the view.

I actually thought BOD was commenting on the height of the balcony from the ground in her comment, not the height of the railings.

Me too;

I worried about the height of the balcony. Should we ask for one on the ground floor?
https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2007/dec/14/ukcrime.madeleinemccann
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2016, 10:36:56 PM
Me too;

I worried about the height of the balcony. Should we ask for one on the ground floor?
https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2007/dec/14/ukcrime.madeleinemccann
There is that possible interpretation but I think my one was better.
Quote
Excitedly, we were shown to our apartments. Ours was on the fourth floor, overlooking a family and toddler pool, opposite a restaurant and bar called the Tapas. I worried about the height of the balcony. Should we ask for one on the ground floor?
She already had described how high up she was, so it was the consideration of how high the protection railing was that was her next thought.  Either way (either interpretation) she was worried about it.  So we need to look to see why she was not convinced she was safe.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: misty on August 19, 2016, 10:48:41 PM
There is that possible interpretation but I think my one was better.She already had described how high up she was, so it was the consideration of how high the protection railing was that was her next thought.  Either way (either interpretation) she was worried about it.  So we need to look to see why she was not convinced she was safe.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3113068/Why-Britons-plunging-hotel-balconies-Three-deaths-12-falls-three-months-alcohol-lax-safety-rules-prove-lethal-combination.html

It's a Brit thing, Robittybob.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pegasus on August 19, 2016, 11:24:33 PM
(snip) ...a balcony drop an open door and your toddlers alone ...
... and a clearly visible warning sticker on the sliding door
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 19, 2016, 11:34:44 PM
... and a clearly visible warning sticker on the sliding door

Whch was ignored too but if youre an imbecile or careless ignorant parent wouldnt matter anyway
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2016, 11:42:00 PM
Whch was ignored too but if youre an imbecile or careless ignorant parent wouldnt matter anyway
Maybe they had taught their kids to read their own warning notices!
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 20, 2016, 01:15:09 AM

And it is OK for you to say "Whch was ignored too but if youre an imbecile or careless ignorant parent wouldnt matter anyway". 
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 20, 2016, 10:47:50 AM
Bridget could just have meant the height of the balcony DROP not the exact specifications of the railings
Balconies however low or high are climbable and no normal parents leave ther kids around them unsupervised

1. She probably did if you look at the full context.
2. Spot on.

It's fun to watch how far the ripples spread though in defence of the indefensible  ?{)(**
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 20, 2016, 02:31:48 PM
To me the real interpretation is on the writer of the article.  As long as she is still standing someone could ask her.

Why is it relevant what exactly she meant? Most parents would take one look at those balconies and make a mental note not to let their kids out there alone, whichever floor they were on. It's not rocket science, they were dangerous.
On the evening of 3rd while KM was showering it would have taken seconds for MM to be out there climbing on the patio furniture for a glimse of her Daddy or of her friends. Assuming KM had a shower, of course.

She took a bath, did her make-up and drank a glass of New Zealand wine with her husband.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN.htm

Kate had a shower which lasted around 5 minutes.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN_ARGUIDO.htm

Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 20, 2016, 02:44:25 PM
Why is it relevant what exactly she meant? Most parents would take one look at those balconies and make a mental note not to let their kids out there alone, whichever floor they were on. It's not rocket science, they were dangerous.
On the evening of 3rd while KM was showering it would have taken seconds for MM to be out there climbing on the patio furniture for a glimse of her Daddy or of her friends. Assuming KM had a shower, of course.

She took a bath, did her make-up and drank a glass of New Zealand wine with her husband.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN.htm

Kate had a shower which lasted around 5 minutes.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN_ARGUIDO.htm

neither statement is verbatim and each has been translated twice
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 20, 2016, 03:17:53 PM
Why is it relevant what exactly she meant? Most parents would take one look at those balconies and make a mental note not to let their kids out there alone, whichever floor they were on. It's not rocket science, they were dangerous.
On the evening of 3rd while KM was showering it would have taken seconds for MM to be out there climbing on the patio furniture for a glimse of her Daddy or of her friends. Assuming KM had a shower, of course.

She took a bath, did her make-up and drank a glass of New Zealand wine with her husband.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN.htm

Kate had a shower which lasted around 5 minutes.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/KATE-MCCANN_ARGUIDO.htm
Did you understand we are talking about Bridget O'Donnell's child in G4 O,  4 stories up, a fall from that height would cause quite different injuries than the minor bump Madeleine would have got from falling from a balcony outside G5 A.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pegasus on August 20, 2016, 03:42:35 PM
(snip) ... minor bump ... (snip) ... falling from a balcony outside G5A.
At 5A the vertical distance from top of railing to the ground, is equal to the entire height of the external steps plus the railing height.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: John on August 22, 2016, 04:53:07 PM
The fact that warning stickers were put on the patio doors alerting parents to the danger of allowing young children onto the balcony only serves to reinforce the view that the design of the balconies were not child friendly. 
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pegasus on August 22, 2016, 07:01:27 PM
The fact that warning stickers were put on the patio doors alerting parents to the danger of allowing young children onto the balcony only serves to reinforce the view that the design of the balconies were not child friendly.
To make the balcony safe for unsupervised small children you would have to make the railings extremely high - higher than plastic table height (see PJ photos) plus child height. Also you would need to fit a gate at the top of the stairs of the same height, and with a lock completely unopenable by children of any age. The railings and the stair-top gate would have to be about 2 metres high - like a cage.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pegasus on August 22, 2016, 07:13:02 PM
At 5A the vertical distance from top of railing to the ground, is equal to the entire height of the external steps plus the railing height.
... should be possible to calculate this
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on August 22, 2016, 07:29:01 PM
... should be possible to calculate this
Do we need to?

What I see from the photographs is like a piece of child's play equipment.

The top rail is at an enticing height for little children.  Then it's up with the feet onto the bottom brick level.  Then it's up with the feet onto the bottom rail. Then it's "ooh can I climb over and down the other side?"

It's a personal decision, but I wouldn't leave a young child out there unsupervised.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 22, 2016, 08:04:31 PM
The fact that warning stickers were put on the patio doors alerting parents to the danger of allowing young children onto the balcony only serves to reinforce the view that the design of the balconies were not child friendly.

More likely a CMA exercise to avoid litigation like the signs that say "don't dry your dog in a microwave oven" [unless one is a North Korean of course].
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pegasus on August 22, 2016, 08:43:51 PM
Do we need to?

What I see from the photographs is like a piece of child's play equipment.

The top rail is at an enticing height for little children.  Then it's up with the feet onto the bottom brick level.  Then it's up with the feet onto the bottom rail. Then it's "ooh can I climb over and down the other side?"

It's a personal decision, but I wouldn't leave a young child out there unsupervised.
At the railing alongside the steps, the drop beyond the railing was visible.. But at the railing outside the south bedroom, the drop beyond the railing was not visible, because of the plant completely obscuring the view through the railing.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 22, 2016, 09:59:05 PM
To make the balcony safe for unsupervised small children you would have to make the railings extremely high - higher than plastic table height (see PJ photos) plus child height. Also you would need to fit a gate at the top of the stairs of the same height, and with a lock completely unopenable by children of any age. The railings and the stair-top gate would have to be about 2 metres high - like a cage.

Yes, lets make holiday apartments like alcatraz with cieling high bars on all doors and windows in case unsupervised toddlers may fall to their death or serious injury if left unsupervised by absent parents. May as well convert all patio door locks too to something impossible for toddlers to open if they arent already.

My point being, should it have to be made again and again, is that toddlers cant protect themselves from dangers when left to their own devices. To accuse holiday companies of putting kids in danger here is to remove family responsibility, and thats where it lies, when it happens, unlike the incidents such as non checking of health and safety vis a vis gas, carbon monoxide, eg as it also lies when any child falls out of Any dwelling when unsupervised
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 23, 2016, 03:45:03 AM
Yes, lets make holiday apartments like alcatraz with cieling high bars on all doors and windows in case unsupervised toddlers may fall to their death or serious injury if left unsupervised by absent parents. May as well convert all patio door locks too to something impossible for toddlers to open if they arent already.

My point being, should it have to be made again and again, is that toddlers cant protect themselves from dangers when left to their own devices. To accuse holiday companies of putting kids in danger here is to remove family responsibility, and thats where it lies, when it happens, unlike the incidents such as non checking of health and safety vis a vis gas, carbon monoxide, eg as it also lies when any child falls out of Any dwelling when unsupervised
It is not that easy to take your kids on holiday with you.  Even if they used a listening service it is still possible for a child to open a door and climb the balcony rails. Every species has had this problem with its young.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 23, 2016, 10:06:14 AM
It is not that easy to take your kids on holiday with you.  Even if they used a listening service it is still possible for a child to open a door and climb the balcony rails. Every species has had this problem with its young.

I always found it easier to deal with children on holiday than at home for a variety of reasons.

1. I could give them more attention as I had less duties to perform.
2. I could offer them more fun activities so they didn't get bored and mischievous.
3. They were easier to control because of 2 above.[behave or we don't go swimming]
4. Without the constraints of work, school, etc. time wasn't so important allowing flexibilty of meal and bedtimes.

I didn't worry about childcare, that was my job and where I went my children went.

Mark Warner's family friendly holidays seem to cater to those who don't really want to spend a holiday with their children. Haven holidays, as an example, cater for families who want to holiday together, they have evening venues and entertainment aimed at the whole family.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on August 24, 2016, 08:22:10 PM
I always found it easier to deal with children on holiday than at home for a variety of reasons.

1. I could give them more attention as I had less duties to perform.
2. I could offer them more fun activities so they didn't get bored and mischievous.
3. They were easier to control because of 2 above.[behave or we don't go swimming]
4. Without the constraints of work, school, etc. time wasn't so important allowing flexibilty of meal and bedtimes.

I didn't worry about childcare, that was my job and where I went my children went.

Mark Warner's family friendly holidays seem to cater to those who don't really want to spend a holiday with their children. Haven holidays, as an example, cater for families who want to holiday together, they have evening venues and entertainment aimed at the whole family.

Exactly G.. our family were the same. Our children loved the outdoors,camping and wild camping in groups up north, great fun. 

Anyone, who has never had children would make that statement " Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?" Everything is a risk for toddlers- a child can die of drowning with as much as a  large glass of water! chocking on buttons and don't even ask about what kind of things gets shoved up noses! Toddlers require full time attention- they are pushing boundaries because they have a lot to learn to become an adult.  This is why I still can't believe those doctors left ther children alone, knowing they woke up or were sick... It really does beggar belief.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 24, 2016, 11:22:05 PM
Exactly G.. our family were the same. Our children loved the outdoors,camping and wild camping in groups up north, great fun. 

Anyone, who has never had children would make that statement " Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?" Everything is a risk for toddlers- a child can die of drowning with as much as a  large glass of water! chocking on buttons and don't even ask about what kind of things gets shoved up noses! Toddlers require full time attention- they are pushing boundaries because they have a lot to learn to become an adult.  This is why I still can't believe those doctors left ther children alone, knowing they woke up or were sick... It really does beggar belief.
Is a 3-4 year old still a "toddler"?  Not really.
Quote
toddler a young child who is just beginning to walk
 

So when a kid has a nightmare and goes sleepwalking should the balconies be constructed so that even a dreaming kid can climb over them?  I have had kids and kids that sleep walk.  OK they need not take responsibility for that but imagine if in the sale and purchase agreement it was pointed out to the seller that the balconies were not up to the current standards and hence they got the buildings cheaper, but before they got around to changing the design a child drops to her death.  Who is liable if the purchaser knew the building was dangerous? 
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Angelo222 on August 25, 2016, 02:20:08 PM
Is a 3-4 year old still a "toddler"?  Not really.   

So when a kid has a nightmare and goes sleepwalking should the balconies be constructed so that even a dreaming kid can climb over them?  I have had kids and kids that sleep walk.  OK they need not take responsibility for that but imagine if in the sale and purchase agreement it was pointed out to the seller that the balconies were not up to the current standards and hence they got the buildings cheaper, but before they got around to changing the design a child drops to her death.  Who is liable if the purchaser knew the building was dangerous?

If the owner and the operators knew that the accommodation was not child safe yet they let it to families with young children then they are liable regardless of warning stickers on windows.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: stephen25000 on August 25, 2016, 04:41:27 PM
If the owner and the operators knew that the accommodation was not child safe yet they let it to families with young children then they are liable regardless of warning stickers on windows.

Perhaps that should include warning stickers to parents, not to leave children in potentially dangerous situations.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: misty on August 25, 2016, 05:10:29 PM
If the owner and the operators knew that the accommodation was not child safe yet they let it to families with young children then they are liable regardless of warning stickers on windows.

I totally agree. Unless the sliding door is fitted with a child safety latch then a warning sticker is next to useless, especially on the upper floors. Young children don't cease wandering when their parents are sleeping.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: jassi on August 25, 2016, 05:48:14 PM
Child-proof locks not much use if you then go and leave the door open.

Can this type of door be locked with a key from the inside?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 25, 2016, 06:57:26 PM
If the owner and the operators knew that the accommodation was not child safe yet they let it to families with young children then they are liable regardless of warning stickers on windows.
That is surprising and if it was it would be a worry for their business then wouldn't it, for what would they need to do ?  What would the need to do to keep the mediterranean feel yet make the balconies child safe?  No wonder the Head of building services is hanging around.
I made a mistake in a previous post "So when a kid has a nightmare and goes sleepwalking should the balconies be constructed so that even a dreaming kid can climb over them?" Should have been:
"So when a kid has a nightmare and goes sleepwalking should the balconies be constructed so that even a dreaming kid can NOT climb over them?"
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 25, 2016, 07:12:15 PM
I wonder how high it is from the top of the railings to the bottom of those steps or to that garden?

After falling from the balcony Brad dropped 10ft onto a protruding tiled roof and died on the way to hospital in Cagliari, Sardinia's capital.
The resort, which is on a spectacular stretch of Sardinia overlooking bays and beaches, maintains that the balcony conformed with both British and Italian safety regulations.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/italy/6043646/Toddler-fell-to-death-through-gap-in-balcony-railings-claim-family.html

The wall below the railings could be seen as a step up.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/aug/18/balcony-brad-kremer-fall-sardinia

In the UK an external balustrade should be 1 meter from datum (where you stand)
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 25, 2016, 09:30:18 PM
I wonder how high it is from the top of the railings to the bottom of those steps or to that garden?

After falling from the balcony Brad dropped 10ft onto a protruding tiled roof and died on the way to hospital in Cagliari, Sardinia's capital.
The resort, which is on a spectacular stretch of Sardinia overlooking bays and beaches, maintains that the balcony conformed with both British and Italian safety regulations.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/italy/6043646/Toddler-fell-to-death-through-gap-in-balcony-railings-claim-family.html

The wall below the railings could be seen as a step up.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/aug/18/balcony-brad-kremer-fall-sardinia

In the UK an external balustrade should be 1 meter from datum (where you stand)
That is very pertinent to the the MM case.  This type of accident could have happened anywhere in the complex but since G4 and G5  block look identical on the exterior in particular block G4.  Then if the parents of an injured kid seek medical assistance they could easily involve the English doctors to check whether the child is dead or alive.
it is possible OC to have responded in a similar way if it had been disclosed.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/italy/6043646/Toddler-fell-to-death-through-gap-in-balcony-railings-claim-family.html
Quote
The tour company, Sardatur Holidays, said the hotel complied with health and safety requirements but it had appointed an independent consultant to make further checks.
A spokesman said: "The balcony in question is protected by a wall and metal railing above and whilst it is unclear at the current time how the child fell the Carabinieri are currently treating the matter as a tragic accident.
"We would like to reassure all passengers both currently staying at the hotel and those due to travel
that the hotel complies with all appropriate building and local laws and that all heath and safety checks are up to date."
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 26, 2016, 12:01:34 AM
Child-proof locks not much use if you then go and leave the door open.

Can this type of door be locked with a key from the inside?

if you leave the doors open but assuming your kids will sleep through then youre taking a risk IMO and if your kids escape and are stolen from the street whose fault is it???
But the mccanns say they left the doors open for their kids benefit ie they wouldnt be woken up by them coming in the front
So they took the decision that its better to not wake them when checking but leave the  at risk of escaping, bizarre, as always




Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 26, 2016, 12:05:54 AM
if you leave the doors open but assuming your kids will sleep through then youre taking a risk IMO and if your kids escape and are stolen from the street whose fault is it???
So would someone tell the McCanns this prior to an untoward event occurring?  If you had been there would you have told Gerry he was being a fool?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: sadie on August 26, 2016, 12:07:46 AM
1100 mm as per the code. There is no valid reason reason to think otherwise. Unless you believe that internal components were used in error in which case it would be 950mm but you or Bridget would need a valid reason to think that.
I'll make it easy: The average human being is crap at estimating mass distance and time so
screw what Bridget O'Donnell thought about the balcony/balustrade height. For her opinion to count she would need to know how high it was as measured rather than viewed and guessed, added to a knowledge of Eurocodes allied to the construction industry. Had she that knowledge I am sure she would have said "the balustrades were below the height recommended by the the code" rather than the woolly remarks attributed to her.
The chain from start to finish on the building project will include but not be limited to:
Client;architect;structural engineering consultant;local planning officer;main contractor;balustrade subcontractor;building inspectors. I would imagine balustrades without the relevant code would have been noticed by most of those with remedial works carried out as a result.
Unless of course we are expected to believe there was a vast conspiracy theory around a p**s balling bit of hand rail ?

The thing that worries me more than the height, which seems pretty OK, is the gap between each vertical of the railings.  There are strict Laws about that too.  A child must not be able to get his head stuck in the gap, yet they must be narrow enough to keep the child in.

I think the photo supposedly from the Paynes apartment [Btw, I dont think that is Fiona] gives a false impression, because the camera is held high and it seems the person is standing well away from the railings.  It is difficult to comprehend  without a trained eye, but Alice and some others will understand the perspective causing this false impression

The height of 1.1 metres was specified so that an adult leaning over the balcony would not be top heavy and fall over accidentally.  I used to be tall but now i have shrunk, I am medium height and 1.1 metres (over 3'6") comes up well above my waist on to my chest.  It would take a man of almost 7' to accidentally topple over railings that height.

Without the aid of the mini wall underneath, no 3 - 4 year old girl would be able to scale the railings ... and I am very doubtful if she would be able to scale it even using that.


The danger imo, is the rather wide gaps between the railings .... but I am not there to measure them, so I cant be sure.


What we must bear in mind is the date that these apartments were built and the Laws at that time.  They might have been different then.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 26, 2016, 12:14:12 AM
The thing that worries me more than the height, which seems pretty OK, is the gap between each vertical of the railings.  There are strict Laws about that too.  A child must not be able to get his head stuck in the gap, yet they must be narrow enough to keep the child in.

I think the photo supposedly from the Paynes apartment [Btw, I dont think that is Fiona] gives a false impression, because the camera is held high and it seems the person is standing well away from the railings.  It is difficult to comprehend  without a trained eye, but Alice and some others will understand the perspective causing this false impression

The height of 1.1 metres was specified so that an adult leaning over the balcony would not be top heavy and fall over accidentally.  I used to be tall but now i have shrunk, I am medium height and 1.1 metres (over 3'6") comes up well above my waist on to my chest.  It would take a man of almost 7' to accidentally topple over railings that height.

Without the aid of the mini wall underneath, no 3 - 4 year old girl would be able to scale the railings ... and I am very doubtful if she would be able to scale it even using that.


The danger imo, is the rather wide gaps between the railings .... but I am not there to measure them, so I cant be sure.


What we must bear in mind is the date that these apartments were built and the Laws at that time.  They might have been different then.

Stop changing the subject sadie the kids shouldnt even had been given the chance to potentially a) get out and b) climb over or through anything that was dangerous...it wasnt OC at fault here if anything like this happened but the potential was there
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: sadie on August 26, 2016, 01:00:10 AM
Stop changing the subject sadie the kids shouldnt even had been given the chance to potentially a) get out and b) climb over or through anything that was dangerous...it wasnt OC at fault here if anything like this happened but the potential was there
You probably haven't noticed but I have been away for a time.  I am working my way thru the thread and responding to things as I reach them.  I am responding to Alice ... not to you.

The patio balcony was IN sight of the Tapas group. It was illuminated by the street lamp immediately opposite.  Had Madeleine been there, her first thought would have been to shout to her Mum and Dad , who were only about 50 metres away. 

Madeleine has a mighty voice as we have seen in home videos and parents can pick out the sound of THEIR childs voice against any other noises.

Nah, she didn't go over the rail, thru it, or down the steps.  Almost for certain she was carried out thru the front door.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 26, 2016, 01:30:24 AM
All speculation
You dont know what thise kids would have done
And there is no way the mccans looked at their flat all night, why would they?!!!!
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: misty on August 26, 2016, 01:58:44 AM
I wonder how high it is from the top of the railings to the bottom of those steps or to that garden?

After falling from the balcony Brad dropped 10ft onto a protruding tiled roof and died on the way to hospital in Cagliari, Sardinia's capital.
The resort, which is on a spectacular stretch of Sardinia overlooking bays and beaches, maintains that the balcony conformed with both British and Italian safety regulations.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/italy/6043646/Toddler-fell-to-death-through-gap-in-balcony-railings-claim-family.html

The wall below the railings could be seen as a step up.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/aug/18/balcony-brad-kremer-fall-sardinia

In the UK an external balustrade should be 1 meter from datum (where you stand)

There is no EU directive regarding heights of balconies & balustrades. It is up to each country to issue their own law.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Brietta on August 26, 2016, 02:27:06 AM

Balconies please.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 26, 2016, 02:32:50 AM
Balconies please.

Ok do you have any idea why the mccanns would take the risk  leaving their toddlers alone at night whilst they went out to dine? The risk being them going out on the balcony, ta

Would YOU do that?
would  YOU leave your other babies alone! After being convinced your first born was abducted!?!!
I bet you would NOT
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 26, 2016, 03:20:18 AM
Ok do you have any idea why the mccanns would take the risk  leaving their toddlers alone at night whilst they went out to dine? The risk being them going out on the balcony, ta

Would YOU do that?
would  YOU leave your other babies alone! After being convinced your first born was abducted!?!!
I bet you would NOT
Are you for real? I think bog

Brietta youneed to have a word with yourself see ya wouldnt wanna beya
The balcony of G5A was not high enough to cause sufficient injury to case death IMO.  If Madeleine had left the room on her own accord the door to the kids bedroom would have been more fully open.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2016, 07:57:33 AM
You are sounding a bit touchy about all this, Alice.  You are not one of the owners or senior people at OC are you?  Your name is not Crossland is it ?  8(0(*

The thing that worries me more than the height, which seems pretty OK, is the gap between each vertical of the railings.  There are strict Laws about that too.  A child must not be able to get his head stuck in the gap, yet they must be narrow enough to keep the child in.

I think the photo supposedly from the Paynes apartment [Btw, I dont think that is Fiona] gives a false impression, because the camera is held high and it seems the person is standing well away from the railings.  It is difficult to comprehend  without a trained eye, but Alice and some others will understand the perspective causing this false impression

The height of 1.1 metres was specified so that an adult leaning over the balcony would not be top heavy and fall over accidentally.  I used to be tall but now i have shrunk, I am medium height and 1.1 metres (over 3'6") comes up well above my waist on to my chest.  It would take a man of almost 7' to accidentally topple over railings that height.

Without the aid of the mini wall underneath, no 3 - 4 year old girl would be able to scale the railings ... and I am very doubtful if she would be able to scale it even using that.


The danger imo, is the rather wide gaps between the railings .... but I am not there to measure them, so I cant be sure.


What we must bear in mind is the date that these apartments were built and the Laws at that time.  They might have been different then.

Does this pic help? The wall below the railings reaches almost to the men's knees. I'm only 5'1" and my knees are  45cm from the ground [yes, I did measure my leg; how mad is that lol?]. So the height of the wall must be at least 45cm.

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2008/09/03/article-1052055-021A2CEB000004B0-912_468x286.jpg)

 

Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 26, 2016, 08:12:12 AM
Does this pic help? The wall below the railings reaches almost to the men's knees. I'm only 5'1" and my knees are  45cm from the ground [yes, I did measure my leg; how mad is that lol?]. So the height of the wall must be at least 45cm.

(http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2008/09/03/article-1052055-021A2CEB000004B0-912_468x286.jpg)

 
I think we should get SiL to take some 4 year old kids to the Ocean Club and see if they can scale those balustrades.  To me they look scaleable.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2016, 08:33:46 AM
You probably haven't noticed but I have been away for a time.  I am working my way thru the thread and responding to things as I reach them.  I am responding to Alice ... not to you.

The patio balcony was IN sight of the Tapas group. It was illuminated by the street lamp immediately opposite.  Had Madeleine been there, her first thought would have been to shout to her Mum and Dad , who were only about 50 metres away. 

Madeleine has a mighty voice as we have seen in home videos and parents can pick out the sound of THEIR childs voice against any other noises.

Nah, she didn't go over the rail, thru it, or down the steps.  Almost for certain she was carried out thru the front door.

In my previous post I suggested the wall below the raining as being 45cms high at least. The railings are at least 45cms too, making 90cms at least to the top of the railings. 

Madeleine was 90cm tall, according to her parents. This pic shows the state of the foliage around the apartment on 9th May. The question is what would Madeleine have been able to see from her perspective. I don't think a child would necessarily call out to anyone unless she could see them, you see;

(http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/1may7/GUARDIAN-15-5-7/GD3301579@A-Police-officer-stan-9167.jpg)

http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/1may7/GUARDIAN-15-05-07.htm

Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2016, 08:40:56 AM
I think we should get SiL to take some 4 year old kids to the Ocean Club and see if they can scale those balustrades.  To me they look scaleable.

There was also patio furniture. It only takes a moment to drag a chair near to the rail and climb up on it for a better view.  At least half the height of the child is then above the total barrier height.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2016, 09:27:43 AM
The balcony of G5A was not high enough to cause sufficient injury to case death IMO.  If Madeleine had left the room on her own accord the door to the kids bedroom would have been more fully open.

Look at the policeman and the balcony above him and give me an estimate of the height of the railings above ground level. Or, guess the height of the gate at the bottom of the steps and use that as a guide to calculate the height of the top of the railings to the ground.

Finally, imagine yourself as a parent standing on that balcony and looking over those railings to the steps below. It's pretty clear that a child going head first over those railings is going to have a hard landing. If they escape hitting their head on the wall beside the stairs they would be lucky. Would you let your children have unsupervised access to that balcony? I wouldn't.

(http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/1may7/GUARDIAN-15-5-7/GD3301579@A-Police-officer-stan-9167.jpg)
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 26, 2016, 09:39:52 AM
Look at the policeman and the balcony above him and give me an estimate of the height of the railings above ground level. Or, guess the height of the gate at the bottom of the steps and use that as a guide to calculate the height of the top of the railings to the ground.

Finally, imagine yourself as a parent standing on that balcony and looking over those railings to the steps below. It's pretty clear that a child going head first over those railings is going to have a hard landing. If they escape hitting their head on the wall beside the stairs they would be lucky. Would you let your children have unsupervised access to that balcony? I wouldn't.

(http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/1may7/GUARDIAN-15-5-7/GD3301579@A-Police-officer-stan-9167.jpg)
"Look at the policeman and the balcony above him" - well I think the balcony above the policeman is on the floor above the McCann's apartment.
When I look  at the photo the balustrade of the McCanns apartment is the one behind the grille.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2016, 10:33:15 AM
"Look at the policeman and the balcony above him" - well I think the balcony above the policeman is on the floor above the McCann's apartment.
When I look  at the photo the balustrade of the McCanns apartment is the one behind the grille.

Sorry, I thought it was obvious where it is. It is of course the one behind the grill at the top of the steps. Now imagine a child on the chair next to the railing. Quite a drop onto hard surfaces imo.

There are, therefore, two reasons why a girl might decide to leave her games and books and go out of those doors onto the balcony. The same two reasons are an incentive to climb on a chair for a better view.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2016, 12:12:40 PM
I think I shown that the balcony was no place to allow small children to access or use unsupervised. As you say, it was an accident waiting to happen. Whether an accident did happen and at what time is not the point of this thread.

The spots sampled in the lounge were never shown to be blood. The only clue that some may have been blood is that Keela alerted behind the couch, and she was a blood detection dog.

 






Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: John on August 26, 2016, 12:32:29 PM
"Look at the policeman and the balcony above him" - well I think the balcony above the policeman is on the floor above the McCann's apartment.
When I look  at the photo the balustrade of the McCanns apartment is the one behind the grille.

The photo shows Mrs Fenn looking over her balcony, her apartment was immediately above 5a. It was Mrs Fenn who reported that she heard a child crying for over an hour in the apartment below on the Tuesday prior to Madeleine's disappearance.

(http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/1may7/GUARDIAN-15-5-7/GD3301579@A-Police-officer-stan-9167.jpg)
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2016, 12:47:02 PM
The photo shows Mrs Fenn looking over her balcony, her apartment was immediately above 5a. It was Mrs Fenn who reported that she heard a child crying for over an hour in the apartment below on the Tuesday prior to Madeleine's disappearance.

(http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/press/1may7/GUARDIAN-15-5-7/GD3301579@A-Police-officer-stan-9167.jpg)

This photo was taken around the 9th May. I've enlarged it but I can't see any railings on top of the wall outside the parent's bedroom.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Brietta on August 26, 2016, 01:03:38 PM
(http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/01_VOLUME_Ia_Page_21_small1.jpg)

Crime scene photo Foto 16 clearly shows the rails in situ, so no mystery there. 

The only mystery might be how we have managed to fill seven pages of comment discussing dangerous balcony railings when there is not one shred of evidence that Madeleine was either near them, climbed up them, was thrown from them or fell from the balcony they enclosed or even fell down the stairs (a) because the child gate had carelessly left open or (b) because the child gate had been closed necessitating her climbing it.

Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alfie on August 26, 2016, 01:21:31 PM
This is one of those "how many angels can fit onto the head of a pin" debates isn't it?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2016, 02:06:36 PM
(http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/01_VOLUME_Ia_Page_21_small1.jpg)

Crime scene photo Foto 16 clearly shows the rails in situ, so no mystery there. 

The only mystery might be how we have managed to fill seven pages of comment discussing dangerous balcony railings when there is not one shred of evidence that Madeleine was either near them, climbed up them, was thrown from them or fell from the balcony they enclosed or even fell down the stairs (a) because the child gate had carelessly left open or (b) because the child gate had been closed necessitating her climbing it.

We have spent far more pages discussing an abductor without a shred of evidence that there was one.

At least we know that Madeleinde could have accessed the balcony early evening without anyone supervising. She could also have accessed it between 8.30pm and 10pm with no-one supervising.

She had a lot more time to fall off that balcony than an abductor had to abduct her.

I wonder if the News of the World were on the right balcony? If so, where did those railings go and why?

Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Brietta on August 26, 2016, 02:53:28 PM
We have spent far more pages discussing an abductor without a shred of evidence that there was one.

At least we know that Madeleinde could have accessed the balcony early evening without anyone supervising. She could also have accessed it between 8.30pm and 10pm with no-one supervising.

She had a lot more time to fall off that balcony than an abductor had to abduct her.

I wonder if the News of the World were on the right balcony? If so, where did those railings go and why?

A fall from a height is not a good thing to happen to anyone under any circumstances ... however such falls are not necessarily fatal.

Toddler 'got back on his feet' after falling 35ft from a flat window
07:10, 26 AUG 2016
BY GLASGOW LIVE

Kyler Bell, 2, is being treated for a broken jaw, wrist and swelling to the brain after he fell from a second floor flat window in Rutherglen.

A two-year-old toddler who fell from 35 feet from a second-floor flat window '"stood back up on his feet" following the accident.

Kyler Bell landed on the pavement outside his mum's flat on Kirkwood Street in Rutherglen on Tuesday, 27 August and was taken to the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital shortly after the fall.

He is being treated for a broken wrist, jaw and swelling to the brain.

The tot is believed to have been helped up on to his feet by a taxi driver who was passing by and found Kyler crying with blood on his face.

A source told the Record: "A taxi driver ran over and helped him. He thought he lad must have fallen over as he came running out of the close.

"He didn't realise at first that the child came out of the window.

"The boy was crying and there was some blood on his face. The taxi driver helped him to his feet and he stood up for a few seconds before falling back down again.

"He had some injuries but he was crying and conscious so that has to be a good sign."

Emergency services were called to the scene on Tuesday afternoon at around 4.15pm. Police say inquiries are ongoing.
http://www.glasgowlive.co.uk/news/glasgow-news/toddler-got-back-feet-after-11802393



With best wishes to Tyler for a speedy recovery from his serious injuries ... the fact remains that speculation apart there is no evidence that Madeleine either exited the apartment of her own volition or that she fell to her death over the balcony.

Apparently the current Scotland Yard investigation has left the door open on the thought that Madeleine may very well still be alive ... I am sure that is a professional opinion based more on where the evidence and their enquiries have taken them rather than the guesswork characteristic of the Amaral epoch.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2016, 03:15:00 PM
A fall from a height is not a good thing to happen to anyone under any circumstances ... however such falls are not necessarily fatal.

Toddler 'got back on his feet' after falling 35ft from a flat window
07:10, 26 AUG 2016
BY GLASGOW LIVE

Kyler Bell, 2, is being treated for a broken jaw, wrist and swelling to the brain after he fell from a second floor flat window in Rutherglen.

A two-year-old toddler who fell from 35 feet from a second-floor flat window '"stood back up on his feet" following the accident.

Kyler Bell landed on the pavement outside his mum's flat on Kirkwood Street in Rutherglen on Tuesday, 27 August and was taken to the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital shortly after the fall.

He is being treated for a broken wrist, jaw and swelling to the brain.

The tot is believed to have been helped up on to his feet by a taxi driver who was passing by and found Kyler crying with blood on his face.

A source told the Record: "A taxi driver ran over and helped him. He thought he lad must have fallen over as he came running out of the close.

"He didn't realise at first that the child came out of the window.

"The boy was crying and there was some blood on his face. The taxi driver helped him to his feet and he stood up for a few seconds before falling back down again.

"He had some injuries but he was crying and conscious so that has to be a good sign."

Emergency services were called to the scene on Tuesday afternoon at around 4.15pm. Police say inquiries are ongoing.
http://www.glasgowlive.co.uk/news/glasgow-news/toddler-got-back-feet-after-11802393



With best wishes to Tyler for a speedy recovery from his serious injuries ... the fact remains that speculation apart there is no evidence that Madeleine either exited the apartment of her own volition or that she fell to her death over the balcony.

Apparently the current Scotland Yard investigation has left the door open on the thought that Madeleine may very well still be alive ... I am sure that is a professional opinion based more on where the evidence and their enquiries have taken them rather than the guesswork characteristic of the Amaral epoch.

A fall may kill and it may not. Like most accidents, luck plays a part in the outcome.

There is no evidence that an abductor removed Madeleine from the apartment either.

SY have also left the door open on the thought that Madeleine may well be dead.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: John on August 26, 2016, 03:25:37 PM
Nah, she didn't go over the rail, thru it, or down the steps.  Almost for certain she was carried out thru the front door.

Just seconds after Gerry had been in his apartment Jane Tanner saw a man carrying a child in his arms striding away from the general direction of said apartment.

Significant?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: slartibartfast on August 26, 2016, 04:41:07 PM
Just seconds after Gerry had been in his apartment Jane Tanner saw a man carrying a child in his arms striding away from the general direction of said apartment.

Significant?

...when you put it like that....
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2016, 05:04:25 PM
...when you put it like that....

Oh, can I play?  Jeremy Watkins, who was clearly heading up that way, was engaged in conversation by Gerry and delayed.........
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Angelo222 on August 26, 2016, 05:08:34 PM
Oh, can I play?  Jeremy Watkins, who was clearly heading up that way, was engaged in conversation by Gerry and delayed.........

But then Miss Clippetyclop appears, walks past both of them and but for a few seconds could well have bumped into the child carrying stranger.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Brietta on August 26, 2016, 05:11:16 PM
Just seconds after Gerry had been in his apartment Jane Tanner saw a man carrying a child in his arms striding away from the general direction of said apartment.

Significant?

Three quarters of an hour later it was discovered a child was missing feet from where Jane Tanner witnessed the man  crossing the road carrying a child. In the absence of conclusive evidence that the child was not Madeleine ... I would say the sighting was hugely significant.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Brietta on August 26, 2016, 05:14:42 PM
But then Miss Clippetyclop appears, walks past both of them and but for a few seconds could well have bumped into the child carrying stranger.

Had Jeremy Wilkins not stopped to speak to Gerry it is highly probable he would have passed the man with the child and been able to ascertain his direction of travel.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Angelo222 on August 26, 2016, 05:18:11 PM
Had Jeremy Wilkins not stopped to speak to Gerry it is highly probable he would have passed the man with the child and been able to ascertain his direction of travel.

Absolutely but Tanner beat him to it!,
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Brietta on August 26, 2016, 05:47:54 PM
Absolutely but Tanner beat him to it!,

Mr and Mrs Moyes were also out and about round about that time ... if they had been just five minutes later returning home they might perhaps have witnessed something relevant.

"We went out for a meal about seven o’clock down in the town. We walked back about nine o’clock, round past, erm, the church, round past the supermarket, back to the apartment. Went out on the balcony about quarter past nine."
Susan Moyes
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 26, 2016, 09:06:50 PM
Just seconds after Gerry had been in his apartment Jane Tanner saw a man carrying a child in his arms striding away from the general direction of said apartment.

Significant?
Purely coincidental. Not related in any way at that stage.   
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: sadie on August 27, 2016, 12:19:50 AM
Purely coincidental. Not related in any way at that stage.
I disagree Robitty.

I think this abduction was seriously planned and that the actual lifting of Madeleine was timed to take place at what normally would have been the safest time.  That 'safest' time was immediately after one of the half hourly checks had taken place.   

Achieved at that time, theoretically  meant that it was unlikely they would be interrupted in the abduction .... and also meant that there was almost half an hour before the next check.   

So a longer get-away period before the search started and the police were called..
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 27, 2016, 01:04:32 AM
I disagree Robitty.

I think this abduction was seriously planned and that the actual lifting of Madeleine was timed to take place at what normally would have been the safest time.  That 'safest' time was immediately after one of the half hourly checks had taken place.   

Achieved at that time, theoretically  meant that it was unlikely they would be interrupted in the abduction .... and also meant that there was almost half an hour before the next check.   

So a longer get-away period before the search started and the police were called..
So that becomes your theory now prove it.  It is easier to make up a theory than it is to find the proof.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pegasus on August 27, 2016, 01:13:06 AM
In the absence of conclusive evidence that the child was not Madeleine ... I would say the sighting was hugely significant.
Mr Redwood stated he has identified the child as the daughter of a different family.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 27, 2016, 01:15:42 AM
He did
And tanners description morphed by her or others to fit
First it was feet only
Then it was the colour of the top being pink
Incredible
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pegasus on August 27, 2016, 01:28:58 AM
In a different and later case further east in the Algarve, concerned onlookers phoned GNR because they saw a tourist staggering around on a high balcony carrying a child. What railing height would be needed to protect a child in that situation?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 27, 2016, 01:42:18 AM
Very high like basketballman high lol
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: misty on August 27, 2016, 01:43:56 AM
In a different and later case further east in the Algarve, concerned onlookers phoned GNR because they saw a tourist staggering around on a high balcony carrying a child. What railing height would be needed to protect a child in that situation?

Probably 2m.
Is the balcony height any more of a concern than the walkway walls/railings on the upper floors of Block 5 (where maybe there are no safety notices?)

Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 27, 2016, 01:49:53 AM
Probably 2m.
Is the balcony height any more of a concern than the walkway walls/railings on the upper floors of Block 5 (where maybe there are no safety notices?)
Any balcony with a sharp drop is a concern for two and three yr olds left alone' lets n forget the POINT misty other wise you might be classed as an apologst for everythng mccann

Just saying
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: misty on August 27, 2016, 02:06:41 AM
Any balcony with a sharp drop is a concern for two and three yr olds left alone' lets n forget the POINT misty other wise you might be classed as an apologst for everythng mccann

Just saying

Any place where a child can fall from a height is a safety concern, I'm not disputing that. The question was "are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?" and the answer is they are just as much of a risk as the walkways. IMO they are more of a hazard to adults than children.
Do you think the twins could get out of their travel cots?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 27, 2016, 02:15:31 AM
Any place where a child can fall from a height is a safety concern, I'm not disputing that. The question was "are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?" and the answer is they are just as much of a risk as the walkways. IMO they are more of a hazard to adults than children.
Do you think the twins could get out of their travel cots?
What did you mean by walkways?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: misty on August 27, 2016, 02:22:49 AM
What did you mean by walkways?

The open passageways in front of the upper apartments.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 27, 2016, 06:40:23 AM
Any place where a child can fall from a height is a safety concern, I'm not disputing that. The question was "are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?" and the answer is they are just as much of a risk as the walkways. IMO they are more of a hazard to adults than children.
Do you think the twins could get out of their travel cots?

Which is precisely why children need to be supervised. Adults are responsible for their own behaviour and safety, children rely on others to keep them safe.

I can't see the relevance of twins and cots to dangerous balconies?

Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 27, 2016, 07:14:09 AM
Which is precisely why children need to be supervised. Adults are responsible for their own behaviour and safety, children rely on others to keep them safe.

I can't see the relevance of twins and cots to dangerous balconies?
It is never going to be without errors, as the adults have to sleep sometime.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 27, 2016, 07:32:59 AM
It is never going to be without errors, as the adults have to sleep sometime.

When responsible parents are awake they supervise their children to keep them safe. If they have to leave their children they leave them with another responsible adult who is also expected to supervise the children and keep them safe.

At night responsible parents secure doors and windows so children are kept in and intruders are kept out.

If anything happens to one of these children the adults are not to blame, they have done all they can be expected to do.

Leaving children unsupervised with access to dangerous balconies or in an unsecured apartment isn't responsible behaviour by adults.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 27, 2016, 07:47:33 AM
The open passageways in front of the upper apartments.
I have yet to see a photo which shows the passageways as yet.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Angelo222 on August 27, 2016, 09:48:33 AM
I have yet to see a photo which shows the passageways as yet.

Well there's plenty to choose from on the www.  The balustrades at OC would not pass scrutiny these days as far as child safety is concerned.  Fixing a low railing on top of a low wall is a recipe for disaster. A balcony railing should be child proof in that it does not provide a means whereby a young child can climb up on it.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 27, 2016, 10:47:08 AM
Well there's plenty to choose from on the www.  The balustrades at OC would not pass scrutiny these days as far as child safety is concerned.  Fixing a low railing on top of a low wall is a recipe for disaster. A balcony railing should be child proof in that it does not provide a means whereby a young child can climb up on it.
I fully agree with you about this, but what concerns me is this fault is general so if there is someone affected from a fall from a balustrade is it more likely someone else other than Madeleine. (That is just from considering the probabilities e.g there could be 100 apartments with children in them so it is 99:1 that the person falling is someone other than Madeleine.
But because there are 7 doctors among the Tapas 9 there is a high chance that one of the doctors gets involved with the treatment/examination of an injured child.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: jassi on August 27, 2016, 12:22:21 PM
Well there's plenty to choose from on the www.  The balustrades at OC would not pass scrutiny these days as far as child safety is concerned.  Fixing a low railing on top of a low wall is a recipe for disaster. A balcony railing should be child proof in that it does not provide a means whereby a young child can climb up on it.

Ah, you mean electrified, or made with barb wire  8(0(*
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Brietta on August 27, 2016, 12:32:58 PM
I have yet to see a photo which shows the passageways as yet.

(http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-WU3hGdCVzw8/TyawaHsZMBI/AAAAAAAACVI/d2WS7xWuBTs/s400/Fenn_3.JPG)
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Brietta on August 27, 2016, 12:36:11 PM
It is never going to be without errors, as the adults have to sleep sometime.

Not at all.

No reason why they can't work to a shift pattern of two hours on two hours off ~ with the children being watched 24/7.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 27, 2016, 12:46:29 PM
Not at all.

No reason why they can't work to a shift pattern of two hours on two hours off ~ with the children being watched 24/7.
Are you being serious?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: John on August 27, 2016, 01:09:44 PM
Well there's plenty to choose from on the www.  The balustrades at OC would not pass scrutiny these days as far as child safety is concerned.  Fixing a low railing on top of a low wall is a recipe for disaster. A balcony railing should be child proof in that it does not provide a means whereby a young child can climb up on it.

I totally agree, balustrades should be fit for purpose.  Incorporating a low wall which would allow small children to climb up to balustrade level was irresponsible imo. Railings should be tall enough that small children cannot possibly climb up on them and horizontally spaced so that children cannot put their heads through. Anything less than four foot high is pretty useless.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: jassi on August 27, 2016, 01:14:06 PM
Vertical railings about 5 foot high seem about right.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 27, 2016, 01:30:03 PM
Any place where a child can fall from a height is a safety concern, I'm not disputing that. The question was "are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?" and the answer is they are just as much of a risk as the walkways. IMO they are more of a hazard to adults than children.
Do you think the twins could get out of their travel cots?

Outside in the real world under "working at height", height is not specified in units of measurement but as
"Work at height means work in any place where, if there were no precautions in place, a person could fall a distance liable to cause personal injury".
Which relies on a personal judgement of that distance and proper supervision; or put another way someone has to take responsibility and loses the "how was that my fault because.." backstop.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 28, 2016, 10:49:33 AM
It depends on how you look at it. Considering the balustrades were suspect, I wonder if they thought two year olds safe in the apartments.

On what basis do you make that statement ?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 28, 2016, 10:55:32 AM
On what basis do you make that statement ?
on the opinion of the forum as discussed in http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=7503.0
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 28, 2016, 11:07:12 AM
on the opinion of the forum as discussed in http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=7503.0

So was there an official complaint investigated by an appropriate authority which concluded the balustrades were unsafe on which "The Forum" based it's collective opinion ?

Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 28, 2016, 11:23:17 AM
So was there an official complaint investigated by an appropriate authority which concluded the balustrades were unsafe on which "The Forum" based it's collective opinion ?
There are plenty of intelligent people here on the forum who are more than able to see that the design of the balustrades were an accident waiting to happen.  There are several photos of the PJ examining the balustrades so I have no doubt there were documents raised on this issue.  May be not part of the file released, but still raised.
A whole section of balustrade has been removed for some reason.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 28, 2016, 11:36:01 AM
There are plenty of intelligent people here on the forum who are more than able to see that the design of the balustrades were an accident waiting to happen.  There are several photos of the PJ examining the balustrades so I have no doubt there were documents raised on this issue.  May be not part of the file released, but still raised.
A whole section of balustrade has been removed for some reason.
And there is evidence the OC were aware of the problem by virtue of the wording of the safety warning stickers that had been placed on the windows.  But they aren't much use to kids that cannot yet read.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 28, 2016, 11:56:08 AM
And there is evidence the OC were aware of the problem by virtue of the wording of the safety warning stickers that had been placed on the windows.  But they aren't much use to kids that cannot yet read.

My dog can't read 'no dogs allowed' signs either, but they aren't aimed at her.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 28, 2016, 12:02:26 PM
My dog can't read 'no dogs allowed' signs either, but they aren't aimed at her.
You are underestimating your dog's intelligence.  Don't let her fool you!
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 28, 2016, 12:50:28 PM
You are underestimating your dog's intelligence.  Don't let her fool you!

 @)(++(*

Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 28, 2016, 01:24:41 PM
There are plenty of intelligent people here on the forum who are more than able to see that the design of the balustrades were an accident waiting to happen. There are several photos of the PJ examining the balustrades so I have no doubt there were documents raised on this issue.  May be not part of the file released, but still raised.
A whole section of balustrade has been removed for some reason.

Please explain how the balustrade design is an "accident waiting to happen". What do see as the fundamental error in the design which renders it unsafe?. While you are at it please explain what you mean by "an accident waiting to happen". Then again while you are at it define "accident".
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 28, 2016, 01:33:24 PM
Please explain how the balustrade design is an "accident waiting to happen". What do see as the fundamental error in the design which renders it unsafe?. While you are at it please explain what you mean by "an accident waiting to happen". Then again while you are at it define "accident".
I'll do this tomorrow it is 12:30 AM here.    It is all covered in the thread. 
Accident as used in the first definition (Google)
Quote
an unfortunate incident that happens unexpectedly and unintentionally, typically resulting in damage or injury.
"he had an accident at the factory"
synonyms:   mishap, misfortune, misadventure, mischance, unfortunate incident, injury, disaster, tragedy, catastrophe, contretemps, calamity, blow, trouble, problem, difficulty; technicalcasualty
"he was involved in an accident at work"
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 28, 2016, 07:36:25 PM
Please explain how the balustrade design is an "accident waiting to happen". What do see as the fundamental error in the design which renders it unsafe?. While you are at it please explain what you mean by "an accident waiting to happen". Then again while you are at it define "accident".
Have you read the thread yet?  All of the questions have been answered IMO.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 28, 2016, 07:56:21 PM
Have you read the thread yet?  All of the questions have been answered IMO.

Nice telegraphed body swerve Bob and not totally unexpected.
So far all I am seeing is a bunch of guesses based on photographs where no one can agree how high, codes of practice, what warning signage should be erected, is that signage mandatory or advisory and does it comply with appropriate laws or regulations.

Based on all that unknown information the consensus it is "the considered opinion of the forum the balustrades are dangerous" and somehow an element of culpability rests with the OC.
Go tell it to The Marines  ?{)(**

What it tells me is that after all the bods involved have designed out as much of the risk as possible the residual risk has to be identified and managed. That may be simply a matter of warning people of the risk with simple signage and the residual risk being managed by those people warned. It is not about creating a totally risk free society and environment. Note my use of "risk" not "dangerous".

Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 28, 2016, 08:11:14 PM
Nice telegraphed body swerve Bob and not totally unexpected.
So far all I am seeing is a bunch of guesses based on photographs where no one can agree how high, codes of practice, what warning signage should be erected, is that signage mandatory or advisory and does it comply with appropriate laws or regulations.

Based on all that unknown information the consensus it is "the considered opinion of the forum the balustrades are dangerous" and somehow an element of culpability rests with the OC.
Go tell it to The Marines  ?{)(**

What it tells me is that after all the bods involved have designed out as much of the risk as possible the residual risk has to be identified and managed. That may be simply a matter of warning people of the risk with simple signage and the residual risk being managed by those people warned. It is not about creating a totally risk free society and environment. Note my use of "risk" not "dangerous".
What was worrying me was that you were not seeing the step produced in the design of the balustrade.  There was a concrete base part which a kid could step up onto then either lean over or swing a leg over and then no ledge on the other side. So it was a trap.  No amount of warning signs will stop accidents happening with a design fault like that.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pegasus on August 28, 2016, 09:10:42 PM
On the west section of railing it would be possible to not realise there is a drop on the other side.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: misty on August 28, 2016, 09:10:58 PM
Do you mean addition of minerals and trace elements in the form of ash?

Genetic engineering & Agenda 21.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 28, 2016, 09:13:19 PM
On the west section of railing it would be possible to not realise there is a drop on the other side.
Did you write this correctly?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pegasus on August 28, 2016, 09:53:54 PM
Did you write this correctly?
Yes there are two railings see photos they are both south-facing, one is located on west half of balcony, one on east half. You can work out east and west from the fact that the Atlantic is south from apartment.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 28, 2016, 11:42:15 PM
What was worrying me was that you were not seeing the step produced in the design of the balustrade.  There was a concrete base part which a kid could step up onto then either lean over or swing a leg over and then no ledge on the other side. So it was a trap.  No amount of warning signs will stop accidents happening with a design fault like that.

I rather think you are missing the point. The question there being by accident, by design or through lack of knowledge of the subject matter.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Brietta on August 28, 2016, 11:43:48 PM
Thanks Brietta, demonstrates the extensive foliage growth in through the railings.

I totally missed Eddie's trained response on the balcony ... was there one? 
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pegasus on August 28, 2016, 11:55:22 PM
I totally missed Eddie's trained response on the balcony ... was there one?
A faint one but it is important to notice it is immediately after sticking nose through the foliage-hidden railings.
IMO he is detecting scent rising up from the flowerbed several metres below (or from some part of the climbing plant above that flowerbed).
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 29, 2016, 12:17:40 AM
I rather think you are missing the point. The question there being by accident, by design or through lack of knowledge of the subject matter.
@ Alice Purjorick - What point did I miss?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Brietta on August 29, 2016, 01:30:45 AM
A faint one but it is important to notice it is immediately after sticking nose through the foliage-hidden railings.
IMO he is detecting scent rising up from the flowerbed several metres below (or from some part of the climbing plant above that flowerbed).

" ... there is some interest here but it will take some further examination to see what's going on"  Martin Grime

I don't see one vestige suggestive of let alone proof that Madeleine or anyone else fell over those railings.  Nor did I see anything approaching Eddie's trained response ~ particularly to a wafting miasma which I am sure would have pressed all his buttons and set him off.
Nor do I see anything to back up Mr Amaral's theory that there was a fall down the stairs.

It took a long time for there to be an acceptance of the fact that burglaries were common in the holiday complex.

It took longer for there to be an acceptance that home invasions in which little girls were assaulted had happened in the Algarve.

In the absence of confirmation of a spate of toddlers taking headers over balconies in Luz which was assiduously covered up like the burglaries and assaults appear to have been ... I would say that the balconies were no more likely to be a risk than balconies anywhere. 
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pegasus on August 29, 2016, 03:49:03 AM
" ... there is some interest here but it will take some further examination to see what's going on"  Martin Grime

I don't see one vestige suggestive of let alone proof that Madeleine or anyone else fell over those railings.  Nor did I see anything approaching Eddie's trained response ~ particularly to a wafting miasma which I am sure would have pressed all his buttons and set him off.
Nor do I see anything to back up Mr Amaral's theory that there was a fall down the stairs.

It took a long time for there to be an acceptance of the fact that burglaries were common in the holiday complex.

It took longer for there to be an acceptance that home invasions in which little girls were assaulted had happened in the Algarve.

In the absence of confirmation of a spate of toddlers taking headers over balconies in Luz which was assiduously covered up like the burglaries and assaults appear to have been ... I would say that the balconies were no more likely to be a risk than balconies anywhere.
Agreed risk of climbing and falling over those railings was no greater than at other apartments nearby. But still a risk.

Another risk was of falling down the steps. At the time of the Rebelo team examination of the balcony and steps this was not easy to fully test because IMO the stair top gate had been removed long before then.

Here are the Rebelo PJ team on 29 Oct 2007 and it's clear they are discussing the falling down steps scenario

http://i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00649/news-graphics-2007-_649456a.jpg

http://www.mccannfiles.com/imagelib/sitebuilder/misc/show_image.html?linkedwidth=actual&linkpath=http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/zzrebelo4d.jpg&target=tlx_pic40au
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 29, 2016, 04:06:05 AM
This cadaver dog search is months after the 3 May 2007 so whatever happened on the night has long gone in this exterior situation, so it is not surprising there is only a partial response from Eddie.  In my New Theory I might say "this is the spot someone tosses a bag with the cadaver in it over the balustrade to be recovered later."  I have not seen rails myself. but they are there in a daylight photo.
why would the gate at the top of the steps be removed?
Steps like that should have had a handrail.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: pegasus on August 29, 2016, 04:25:06 AM
why would the gate at the top of the steps be removed? (snip)
Easily confirmed by looking at press photos like Mail 10 Aug 2007, or dog video 1 Aug 2007, no gate at top.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 29, 2016, 07:05:02 AM
" ... there is some interest here but it will take some further examination to see what's going on"  Martin Grime

I don't see one vestige suggestive of let alone proof that Madeleine or anyone else fell over those railings.  Nor did I see anything approaching Eddie's trained response ~ particularly to a wafting miasma which I am sure would have pressed all his buttons and set him off.
Nor do I see anything to back up Mr Amaral's theory that there was a fall down the stairs.

It took a long time for there to be an acceptance of the fact that burglaries were common in the holiday complex.

It took longer for there to be an acceptance that home invasions in which little girls were assaulted had happened in the Algarve.

In the absence of confirmation of a spate of toddlers taking headers over balconies in Luz which was assiduously covered up like the burglaries and assaults appear to have been ... I would say that the balconies were no more likely to be a risk than balconies anywhere.

It's strange how any scenario other than abduction is dismissed for lack of proof, even though there's no proof of abduction either.

Burglaries and child molestations elsewhere are not supporting evidence of an abduction, I'm afraid, no matter how much people try to link them. Nor are charity collectors, cigarette butts on a balcony or men hanging around Luz, arguing in the street or using their mobile phones.

The balconies were commented on by two witnesses and had a warning sticker on the access doors. Very few parents looking at them would allow small children on them unsupervised. Nor would they leave small children in a situation where they could get onto the balconies unobserved. That's probably why no child has been reported to have fallen off them; responsible parenting.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 29, 2016, 07:14:23 AM
.... That's probably why no child has been reported to have fallen off them; responsible parenting.
That's probably why no child has been reported to have fallen off them; responsible parenting and actively covering up any previous incident.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 29, 2016, 07:26:39 AM
Easily confirmed by looking at press photos like Mail 10 Aug 2007, or dog video 1 Aug 2007, no gate at top.
But why was it removed?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 29, 2016, 11:43:42 AM
That's probably why no child has been reported to have fallen off them; responsible parenting and actively covering up any previous incident.

An incident such as that isn't easily covered up. The suggestion has to be made immediately or an ambulance will be called. If the parents made the suggestion holiday company employees would have been horrified. If the holiday company made the suggestion the parents would have been horrified. Too risky for either side to make that suggestion imo.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 29, 2016, 09:33:52 PM
What was worrying me was that you were not seeing the step produced in the design of the balustrade. There was a concrete base part which a kid could step up onto then either lean over or swing a leg over and then no ledge on the other side. So it was a trap.  No amount of warning signs will stop accidents happening with a design fault like that.

1. Oh I rather believe I did see it thinking it was a neat structural and architectural detail to solve a problem.
2. How was it a trap?
Now tell us how you would have done it.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 29, 2016, 09:42:46 PM
1. Oh I rather believe I did see it thinking it was a neat structural and architectural detail to solve a problem.
2. How was it a trap?
Now tell us how you would have done it.
Because there is no ledge on the far side. You can't recover a footing (in some cases). 
I am not a builder but my friend had a modern apartment on the second floor, and the balcony had a safety barrier made from flat safety glass 1200 mm high.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 29, 2016, 11:26:29 PM
Because there is no ledge on the far side. You can't recover a footing (in some cases). 
I am not a builder but my friend had a modern apartment on the second floor, and the balcony had a safety barrier made from flat safety glass 1200 mm high.

You "are not a builder" is a cop out. You reckon you know enough to be critical of what was there so you should be able to come up with a solution that is based on something more substantial than "well my mate has one like this".
And you have yet to state why you think it is a trap.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 29, 2016, 11:36:36 PM
You "are not a builder" is a cop out. You reckon you know enough to be critical of what was there so you should be able to come up with a solution that is based on something more substantial than "well my mate has one like this".
And you have yet to state why you think it is a trap.
Why do I have to do any of that?  And I did say why it was a trap.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 30, 2016, 03:17:28 AM
" ... there is some interest here but it will take some further examination to see what's going on"  Martin Grime

I don't see one vestige suggestive of let alone proof that Madeleine or anyone else fell over those railings.  Nor did I see anything approaching Eddie's trained response ~ particularly to a wafting miasma which I am sure would have pressed all his buttons and set him off.
Nor do I see anything to back up Mr Amaral's theory that there was a fall down the stairs.

It took a long time for there to be an acceptance of the fact that burglaries were common in the holiday complex.

It took longer for there to be an acceptance that home invasions in which little girls were assaulted had happened in the Algarve.

In the absence of confirmation of a spate of toddlers taking headers over balconies in Luz which was assiduously covered up like the burglaries and assaults appear to have been ... I would say that the balconies were no more likely to be a risk than balconies anywhere.
that is right where ever the balconies are unsafe they are a hazard for young children.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 30, 2016, 07:16:26 AM
This looks like a reasonably safe balustrade.    In the top photo safe baustrade and the dangerous OC balustrades below.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 30, 2016, 11:35:23 AM
This looks like a reasonably safe balustrade.    In the top photo safe baustrade and the dangerous OC balustrades below.

Well Bob The Not A Builder there is a bit missing in both photos.
Also you fail to say "in your opinion".
You fail to say what design codes were used for the balustrades and why in your inexpert opinion they are incorrect.
You fail to make comment on the biggest risk wrt to the balcony at Appt 5A.
You fail to show any risk assessment.
You fail to show signage.
In fact you pretty much fail altogether
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: sadie on August 30, 2016, 11:43:46 AM
Well Bob The Not A Builder there is a bit missing in both photos.
Also you fail to say "in your opinion".
You fail to say what design codes were used for the balustrades and why in your inexpert opinion they are incorrect.
You fail to make comment on the biggest risk wrt to the balcony at Appt 5A.
You fail to show any risk assessment.
You fail to show signage.
In fact you pretty much fail altogether

You seem unduly protective and over sensitive re Ocean Club.  IMO of course.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 30, 2016, 11:47:26 AM
Well Bob The Not A Builder there is a bit missing in both photos.
Also you fail to say "in your opinion".
You fail to say what design codes were used for the balustrades and why in your inexpert opinion they are incorrect.
You fail to make comment on the biggest risk wrt to the balcony at Appt 5A.
You fail to show any risk assessment.
You fail to show signage.
In fact you pretty much fail
"Also you fail to say "in your opinion"."  - when I say "looks like" that is an opinion.
Design codes would be regional so pointless, but safety is universal.
"You fail to make comment on the biggest risk wrt to the balcony at Appt 5A."  Well that sounds like your own assessment so I leave that one to you.
"You fail to show any risk assessment.
You fail to show signage." Why would I want to do that?
"In fact you pretty much fail altogether."  I challenge you to stop being critical and come up with something of value.

I'm getting plenty of positive feed back that the likes of your comments seem futile.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 30, 2016, 11:51:42 AM
You seem unduly protective and over sensitive re Ocean Club.  IMO of course.
You'd wonder but she shows a flaw if that was the case for she says "You fail to make comment on the biggest risk wrt to the balcony at Appt 5A."  So is Robin Crosland saying there is an even bigger risk that we've missed so far?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: sadie on August 30, 2016, 12:02:14 PM
Kate at balcony.  Kate is tall but the rail is lower than waist height.  I would have thought that by modern standards the rail was too low for safety. 

http://gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/4g-1.jpg
(http://gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/4g-1.jpg)

Depending on the rail height, if the weight of the body above the rail  is greater than the weight of the body below the rail, then it would be very easy to topple over.  The head and shoulders of humans are very heavy.  Kate is tall but other guests must be taller..

Possibly OC was built before modern standards became the Law?.  Or the Law is different in  PT ?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 30, 2016, 12:11:45 PM
Kate at balcony.  Kate is tall but the rail is lower than waist height.  I would have thought that by modern standards the rail was too low for safety. 

http://gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/4g-1.jpg
(http://gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/4g-1.jpg)

Depending on the rail height, if the weight of the body above the rail  is greater than the weight of the body below the rail, then it would be very easy to topple over.  The head and shoulders of humans are very heavy.  Kate is tall but other guests must be taller..

Possibly OC was built before modern standards became the Law?.  Or the Law is different in  PT ?
That is an interesting photo Sadie.  Do you know where and when that one was taken?  What I notice is that there has been a mesh added to the balustrade to stop kids going through the vertical rails.  Is this the risk "Alice Purjorick" is speaking of?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: slartibartfast on August 30, 2016, 12:36:22 PM
Alice, I ask you again are you ....... ........ or an owner/ big shot at Ocean Club?

You seem unduly protective and over sensitive re Ocean Club.  IMO of course.

Sadie, please desist from attempting to out posters.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 30, 2016, 01:00:37 PM
Was it possible for kids to go through/between the vertical rails of the balustrades at OC?  I haven't seen what the actual spacing is.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: John on August 30, 2016, 01:14:00 PM
Kate at balcony.  Kate is tall but the rail is lower than waist height.  I would have thought that by modern standards the rail was too low for safety. 

http://gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/4g-1.jpg
(http://gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/4g-1.jpg)

Depending on the rail height, if the weight of the body above the rail  is greater than the weight of the body below the rail, then it would be very easy to topple over.  The head and shoulders of humans are very heavy.  Kate is tall but other guests must be taller..

Possibly OC was built before modern standards became the Law?.  Or the Law is different in  PT ?

A couple of things come to mind.  Firstly, 5a didn't have safety netting on the balustrades by the patio door so I assume that photo was taken elsewhere. Secondly, the McCanns were moved from 5a overnight for various reasons including an attempt to preserve a potential crime scene so a daylight shot of Kate peering over the balcony of 5a was unlikely.  Lastly, the photo appears to have been taken of an elevated position so I assume it was of the balcony on the floor above? 
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 30, 2016, 01:16:52 PM
What would the spacing be?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: John on August 30, 2016, 01:19:41 PM
What would the spacing be?

Don't know but they appear very wide.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 30, 2016, 02:19:03 PM
How interesting! This pic, I think, is of the Block 4 penthouse apartment balcony - no mesh on the railings.

(https://imagesus-ssl.homeaway.com/mda01/265a16af-305f-4d64-be48-58fc58370a0c.1.6)

https://www.homeaway.co.uk/p435924
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: sadie on August 30, 2016, 03:34:52 PM
You'd wonder but she shows a flaw if that was the case for she says "You fail to make comment on the biggest risk wrt to the balcony at Appt 5A."  So is Robin Crosland saying there is an even bigger risk that we've missed so far?
According to the internet blurb, Robin Crosland was/is a part owner of OC.  Also, he was the architect for OC.

The biggest risk I see is the gap between the verticals of the railings.  They look too wide, but measuring is better than not being absolutely sure.

The top rail also seems rather low, especially if a tallish drunk person was falling about a bit.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 30, 2016, 04:50:40 PM
It amuses me that people who clearly know three fifths of five eighths of Felicity Arkwright about building codes and health and safety requirements for buildings suddenly become so knowledgeable implying their belief has value and should be greeted like the second coming of the messiah.
"How big is the gap? I don't know how big should it be?" is testimony to knowing FA about the topic which in any event is likely to have no bearing on the disappearance of MM if you think about that balcony and environs for a few seconds.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 30, 2016, 07:10:29 PM
@Alice Purjorick - I have just clicked as to why the balustrades at OC are so dangerous.  I'll begin by looking up the building codes about this before presenting it.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 30, 2016, 07:31:15 PM
Get a straight rod and have one end touching the floor of the balcony and lean it toward the top rail.  What is the angle it makes (with the floor) when the rod touches the floor and the top rail at the same time?

This will turn out to be the biggest design fault for when a person needs the support of the top rail they are already toppling (leaning ) over.  A person above a certain height would not be able to recover from this position especially if they were side on or back toward the rail.
Modern design always have the inner face vertical or even slightly concave.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 30, 2016, 09:24:01 PM
A couple of things come to mind.  Firstly, 5a didn't have safety netting on the balustrades by the patio door so I assume that photo was taken elsewhere. Secondly, the McCanns were moved from 5a overnight for various reasons including an attempt to preserve a potential crime scene so a daylight shot of Kate peering over the balcony of 5a was unlikely.  Lastly, the photo appears to have been taken of an elevated position so I assume it was of the balcony on the floor above?


It was taken outside 4g the second mccann apartment
I wonder if they had it put it up or all apartments had it on whichever floor it is

(http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/4G.jpg)

http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/APARTMENT.htm



just over 3/4 of the way down the page
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on August 30, 2016, 10:39:40 PM

It was taken outside 4g the second mccann apartment
I wonder if they had it put it up or all apartments had it on whichever floor it is

http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/APARTMENT.htm

just over 3/4 of the way down the page

It doesn't seem to be a feature of all the apartments. Perhaps the owners of that one did it because they had little ones?



(https://imagesus-ssl.homeaway.com/mda01/77fd37b2-6c27-447e-b3d7-df7f42324351.1.6)

https://www.homeaway.co.uk/p757665?utm_medium=affiliates&utm_source=cj&CID=a_cj_8052471&utm_campaign=10780683_&utm_content=8052471
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 30, 2016, 11:48:46 PM
It doesn't seem to be a feature of all the apartments. Perhaps the owners of that one did it because they had little ones?



(https://imagesus-ssl.homeaway.com/mda01/77fd37b2-6c27-447e-b3d7-df7f42324351.1.6)

https://www.homeaway.co.uk/p757665?utm_medium=affiliates&utm_source=cj&CID=a_cj_8052471&utm_campaign=10780683_&utm_content=8052471


I suppose if anyone was really interested they could look at British Building Regulations Document K which covers all the relevant items under discussion. Also look at EN 6399 & BS6180. The trouble is you need sufficient legal and technical knowledge to know what it is all about and how it is all applied...... 8(0(*
Watch this space if you want some entertainment.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: misty on August 30, 2016, 11:54:01 PM

I suppose if anyone was really interested they could look at British Building Regulations Document K which covers all the relevant items under discussion. Also look at EN 6399 & BS6180. The trouble is you need sufficient legal and technical knowledge to know what it is all about and how it is all applied...... 8(0(*
Watch this space if you want some entertainment.

Did that apply in Portugal in the 90's, Alice? Just askin'.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 30, 2016, 11:59:14 PM
It doesn't seem to be a feature of all the apartments. Perhaps the owners of that one did it because they had little ones?



(https://imagesus-ssl.homeaway.com/mda01/77fd37b2-6c27-447e-b3d7-df7f42324351.1.6)

https://www.homeaway.co.uk/p757665?utm_medium=affiliates&utm_source=cj&CID=a_cj_8052471&utm_campaign=10780683_&utm_content=8052471
Yes i was wondering if it was someone else or the mccanns, if it was a resort thing theyd be all over i would have thought
Anyway, to get back to the thread question, railings are only dangerous if very young kids are allowed to get their head stuck or fall through them

Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Angelo222 on August 31, 2016, 12:26:37 AM
Something has just occurred to me.  Some of the apartments at OC are privately owned but some also come under the auspices of the resort rental arrangements.  It does appear that when allocated an apartment and regardless of whether you had young children with you, it was pot luck as to whether said apartment had safety netting fitted or not.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: sadie on August 31, 2016, 12:38:27 AM
It amuses me that people who clearly know three fifths of five eighths of Felicity Arkwright about building codes and health and safety requirements for buildings suddenly become so knowledgeable implying their belief has value and should be greeted like the second coming of the messiah.
"How big is the gap? I don't know how big should it be?" is testimony to knowing FA about the topic which in any event is likely to have no bearing on the disappearance of MM if you think about that balcony and environs for a few seconds.
I happen to have had a home that needed railings to fence it in ... no drop .... and we came across the regulations then... and it was all about trapping a childs head.  We built these railings years ago and all i know is that to to conform to the regulations, to my eye the uprights looked unpleasantly close together.   The contractors worried about spacing them correctly, but they certainly looked closer together than the railings at 5A
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 31, 2016, 12:39:00 AM
Something has just occurred to me.  Some of the apartments at OC are privately owned but some also come under the auspices of the resort rental arrangements.  It does appear that when allocated an apartment and regardless of whether you had young children with you, it was pot luck as to whether said apartment had safety netting fitted or not.

We dont have photos of all the apartments there to see, but in the end, the answer to the thread is still, dont let your toddlers crawl near danger

Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: sadie on August 31, 2016, 12:48:48 AM
But is she was stuck in the railing I don't think you would die from that unless she was left for a few days in the hot sun.  She would be hurt but not dead.
Could a girl of nearly 4 fall through the bars?  That too seems unlikely.  But we'll do some measurements and check this. 
Climbing over is my choice for there is a step that a kid can climb onto first and then lean over and fall.
Ergonomically I think that it would be difficult for Madeleine to climb over if she used the lower wall.  With her feet on that wall, it would not be easy I think.  Better to stand just a fraction away, than have her weight not over her feet at the start.  With feet on the wall her bottom and body weight would be over the patio and in a difficult position, I am thinkling for pushing up.  In the absence of a strong push up, she would need very strong arms and I am doubtful that a child of Madeleines age would have that strength.

I dont think I explained myself very well there.  Perhaps someone else could explain it better? 8**8:/:
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 31, 2016, 03:08:14 AM
It amuses me that people who clearly know three fifths of five eighths of Felicity Arkwright about building codes and health and safety requirements for buildings suddenly become so knowledgeable implying their belief has value and should be greeted like the second coming of the messiah.
"How big is the gap? I don't know how big should it be?" is testimony to knowing FA about the topic which in any event is likely to have no bearing on the disappearance of MM if you think about that balcony and environs for a few seconds.
I have always said it was an indirect effect on the disappearance of MM.  Someone else falls in one of the many other apartments but the injured child is brought to the "doctors" for assessment. So it is indirect but the root cause is still the balustrades.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 31, 2016, 09:57:50 AM
I have always said it was an indirect effect on the disappearance of MM.  Someone else falls in one of the many other apartments but the injured child is brought to the "doctors" for assessment. So it is indirect but the root cause is still the balustrades.

How so?
Have you performed an RCA . Now that really would be worth looking at.. ?{)(**
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on August 31, 2016, 11:54:54 PM
I think this issue of the missing railing deserves its own thread.  Granted, in the dog video posted by Brietta earlier the extent of the overgrown bushes made it impossible to see the railing in the dark but that is not the case in the unedited photo below taken in glorious sunshine.  In the later photo the top of the dwarf wall can clearly be seen (far right), the plant growth is not excessive, a white railing would be easily seen were it actually there in situ.

Now you see it... (photo taken May 2007)

(http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/000skynews8.jpg)

Now you don't!  (photo taken 2008)




(http://www.mccannfiles.com/sitebuildercontent/sitebuilderpictures/notwviewfrompatio.jpg)

I agree with this, especially if you look at the distance between the top of the wall and the horizontal railing, it wll have shown in the second photo imo

Not sure why it deserves its own thread, what significance can it have?

Perhaps the railing was damaged by the time the second photo was taken, ( all manner of people were in and out that apartment for that first year, and some illegally entering it) and replaced after, indeed it was replaced by 2012 at the latest when that tv show was aired

If it was removed by police for forensics i cant see why it wouldnt be mentioned in the files

Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: misty on September 01, 2016, 12:19:30 AM
I agree with this, especially if you look at the distance between the top of the wall and the horizontal railing, it wll have shown in the second photo imo

Not sure why it deserves its own thread, what significance can it have?

Perhaps the railing was damaged by the time the second photo was taken, ( all manner of people were in and out that apartment for that first year, and some illegally entering it) and replaced after, indeed it was replaced by 2012 at the latest when that tv show was aired

If it was removed by police for forensics i cant see why it wouldnt be mentioned in the files

Do you really think someone would remove the railing & fail to leave warning tape across the gap? Now THAT would be an accident waiting to happen.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on September 01, 2016, 12:30:24 AM
Do you really think someone would remove the railing & fail to leave warning tape across the gap? Now THAT would be an accident waiting to happen.

Depends misty.
If the apartment wasnt being rented out no need I guess.
Even if it was, would a police do not cross line tape really be needed over and above telling compus mentus renters it was taken away for repairs or a new one was being installed soon?
Not really sure why we are discussing this


Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 01, 2016, 12:32:14 AM
Do you really think someone would remove the railing & fail to leave warning tape across the gap? Now THAT would be an accident waiting to happen.
no the bushes would stop you falling.  No different than many garden fences around the majority of residences in NZ.  If you climb a fence you can expect to fall but its your own problem, don't blame anyone else.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 01, 2016, 12:36:53 AM
Depends misty.
If the apartment wasnt being rented out no need I guess.
Even if it was, would a police do not cross line tape really be needed over and above telling compus mentus renters it was taken away for repairs or a new one was being installed soon?
Not really sure why we are discussing this
It depends on why it was removed?  Was it removed looking for evidence of someone going over there?  I didn't see the railing in the videos when the cadaver dogs were doing their searches in 2007 so they must have been removed quite early IMO.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 02, 2016, 12:49:26 AM
We dont have photos of all the apartments there to see, but in the end, the answer to the thread is still, dont let your toddlers crawl near danger
The building standards put the onus on the owner to build the veranda so that the risk is minimised.  This principle is missing when part of the balustrade is climbable and the bar spacing is wide enough for a kid's head to past between bars.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: sadie on September 02, 2016, 01:59:45 PM
It depends on why it was removed?  Was it removed looking for evidence of someone going over there?  I didn't see the railing in the videos when the cadaver dogs were doing their searches in 2007 so they must have been removed quite early IMO.
Is that the video taken in the darkness?  Cos I cant pick anything out in it; it is all so vague it could be anywhere, imo
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 04, 2016, 02:51:18 AM
Is that the video taken in the darkness?  Cos I cant pick anything out in it; it is all so vague it could be anywhere, imo
Was that because the daytime temperatures were too hot for the dogs?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Admin on September 04, 2016, 11:15:39 AM
Was that because the daytime temperatures were too hot for the dogs?

I would say so plus less distractions at night.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 04, 2016, 11:43:51 AM
I would say so plus less distractions at night.
I did actually read that "the daytime temperatures were too hot for the dogs".  I am amazed at the amount of work those dogs were expected to do in those few days.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Brietta on September 04, 2016, 12:52:39 PM
I would say so plus less distractions at night.

Martin Grime was heard to say that they would need to come back in daylight ... was that ever done?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 04, 2016, 05:17:42 PM
Martin Grime was heard to say that they would need to come back in daylight ... was that ever done?
there are those photos of the detectives looking at the balustrades so you would have to say "yes".  Maybe not immediately, but really there isn't much to see.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on September 05, 2016, 02:54:06 AM
Exactly nothing to see
No rails removed
New investigating officer 6 months later not inspecting rails, but possibly scenario of child falling to their death which no onehas disproved
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 05, 2016, 03:11:46 AM
Exactly nothing to see
No rails removed
New investigating officer 6 months later not inspecting rails, but possibly scenario of child falling to their death which no one has disproved
Are you introducing a new theory here Mercury?  One in which Madeleine climbed the fence and then died on the other side of the railing from falling?  OK, that is possible and then what?  Who found her and disposed of her body or did someone take her for medical treatment? How would you make that work, for if she was deceased long enough to get the cadaver odour in the garden there'd be no reason to take her to the Doc Luz Medical Center - rules out Smithman.
It is possible to fall down there and be unfound during the initial searches but taken away just prior to the GNR arriving.  Risky business carrying a body when everyone is out looking for her.  Interesting variation though and I can't discount it completely.  Only drawback would be there no reason to have cadaver odour near the wardrobe.
Or would you have someone taking her inside first and then removing her later?

Not a silly scenario.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on September 05, 2016, 03:27:41 AM
I dont do whole theories start to finish to include all the known and unknown evidence
I donthave a theory
(I only make observations and suggest possiblities)
I leave that to those with mental stamina
No onehas stepped up to the mark to date,not even the so called finest police force in the world
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 05, 2016, 04:12:39 AM
I dont do whole theories start to finish to include all the known and unknown evidence
I donthave a theory
(I only make observations and suggest possiblities)
I leave that to those with mental stamina
No onehas stepped up to the mark to date,not even the so called finest police force in the world
Do you have any other theories involving the balconies for  I see a problem with this one as the tracker dogs AFAIK didn't track into the garden.  Look to be honest I'm a bit unsure of where the trackers dogs tracked in the first night.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: misty on September 05, 2016, 05:25:38 PM
Death theory involving the stairs?  That's a new one on me.  Cite, please.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1564725/Madeleine-McCann-died-after-fall-down-steps.html
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on September 05, 2016, 07:03:18 PM
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1564725/Madeleine-McCann-died-after-fall-down-steps.html
Many thanks for that.

Let me see if I pick the bones out of this.

The leak was by a senior detective to 24 Horas in Portugal, then picked up and rehashed by the Telegraph.

It alleges that Madeleine fell down stairs at her holiday home (which could only be those between the baby gate and the garden gate.)  It alleges that Madeleine hit her head on a ceramic flagstone (which must have been at the bottom of the concrete stairs) and died.  It alleges that the parents, fearful of a potential charge of manslaughter, disposed of the body, perhaps with the help of others in the Tapas group.  It alleges that this theory arose after a British report stated the dogs had detected the smell of death on the steps.

The date of the Telegraph report is 30 Sep 2007, therefore if this actually was a leak by the PJ, it seems to have been just days before Amaral was removed from the case.

Does it stand up to any scrutiny?  It does not appear to.  There is no mention of dog alerts on the stairs in the files.  There is no evidence of CSI activity on the stairs.

Perhaps the source was recounting the 'fell behind the sofa' theory, but wanted to be less than 100% accurate.

I wondered why I had never heard of it.  It's not in Amaral's book.  It's not in the Files.  That explains why I was unaware of it.

 
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 05, 2016, 07:29:34 PM
Many thanks for that.

Let me see if I pick the bones out of this.

The leak was by a senior detective to 24 Horas in Portugal, then picked up and rehashed by the Telegraph.

It alleges that Madeleine fell down stairs at her holiday home (which could only be those between the baby gate and the garden gate.)  It alleges that Madeleine hit her head on a ceramic flagstone (which must have been at the bottom of the concrete stairs) and died.  It alleges that the parents, fearful of a potential charge of manslaughter, disposed of the body, perhaps with the help of others in the Tapas group.  It alleges that this theory arose after a British report stated the dogs had detected the smell of death on the steps.

The date of the Telegraph report is 30 Sep 2007, therefore if this actually was a leak by the PJ, it seems to have been just days before Amaral was removed from the case.

Does it stand up to any scrutiny?  It does not appear to.  There is no mention of dog alerts on the stairs in the files.  There is no evidence of CSI activity on the stairs.

Perhaps the source was recounting the 'fell behind the sofa' theory, but wanted to be less than 100% accurate.

I wondered why I had never heard of it.  It's not in Amaral's book.  It's not in the Files.  That explains why I was unaware of it.
The article has some unusual features:
1. Death caused by falling in the area of the balcony (dog alerts on balcony could be extended to the steps). "The new theory emerged after a report from Britain said specialist sniffer dogs had detected the "smell of death" on the steps, it was claimed."  I.e. close to the area under discussion.
2. Some sort of involvement of the OC staff.  "It emerged as a source close to the McCanns said police were investigating claims that a disgruntled ex-employee from the Ocean Club, where the family was staying, may have been involved in Madeleine's abduction."
3.  The story appears fake but the "Police have discovered the woman identified does exist and that the tip-off came from an email address registered in the Iberian peninsula."  That is still a fairly large area. You would think it  would be possible to identify it a bit closer to a city rather than a vast area of land.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 02, 2016, 12:01:12 PM
Found this photo showing how easy the balustrade was to climb over.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alfie on October 02, 2016, 12:40:09 PM
Found this photo showing how easy the balustrade was to climb over.
Is that a smallish 4 year old child?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: slartibartfast on October 02, 2016, 02:11:44 PM
Is that a smallish 4 year old child?

These aren't.

Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alfie on October 02, 2016, 05:11:41 PM
These aren't.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=sDaRLZF9HqY (https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=sDaRLZF9HqY)
@)(++(* are these clips from Apartment 5a?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 02, 2016, 06:56:30 PM
Is that a smallish 4 year old child?
No of course not.  I'm just showing the forum that it is well known how unsafe the design and construction the balustrades were compared to the standard building codes.  Even a 4 year old could climb this one, see how much the clearance is between the top of the rail and the crutch.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: misty on October 02, 2016, 09:22:51 PM
These aren't.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=sDaRLZF9HqY (https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=sDaRLZF9HqY)

That video actually demonstrates just how possible it would have been for Madeleine to have opened the window herself & climbed out.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: slartibartfast on October 02, 2016, 09:35:19 PM
That video actually demonstrates just how possible it would have been for Madeleine to have opened the window herself & climbed out.

Kids of that age are very resourceful.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 02, 2016, 09:36:26 PM
That video actually demonstrates just how possible it would have been for Madeleine to have opened the window herself & climbed out.
Pulling up the shutters might have been beyond her.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: misty on October 02, 2016, 09:42:58 PM
Kids of that age are very resourceful.

The one in the video who not only pulled down the side of the cot but pushed it back up again....and not even 2 years old by the look of it.
I remember my daughter at about the same age used to go head-first over the child safety gate - an absolute nightmare.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: slartibartfast on October 02, 2016, 09:43:58 PM
The one in the video who not only pulled down the side of the cot but pushed it back up again....and not even 2 years old by the look of it.
I remember my daughter at about the same age used to go head-first over the child safety gate - an absolute nightmare.

Yes, my daughter climbed over a sofa at the same age...
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on October 03, 2016, 10:51:01 AM
No of course not.  I'm just showing the forum that it is well known how unsafe the design and construction the balustrades were compared to the standard building codes. Even a 4 year old could climb this one, see how much the clearance is between the top of the rail and the crutch.

Did we get a copy of the building codes and an engineering drawing of the balustrades then?
I must have missed that.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 03, 2016, 10:57:07 AM
Did we get a copy of the building codes and an engineering drawing of the balustrades then?
I must have missed that.
You don't need it the design faults are so self evident.  Any balustrade that allows a person to climb over it would be outside of the modern building codes.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 03, 2016, 07:31:40 PM
When I get to PDL maybe I could make enquiries as to whether the building met the requirements at the time of construction. 
A month or so back I looked at current codes and there needs to be a 1100 mm vertical non climbable element of the balustrade.
It clearly doesn't meet the current code for new construction. 
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 04, 2016, 01:05:35 AM
So you have measured the height or had someone do it for you?
A link to code you mention would be good.
We remain in the realms of "in your opinion"
If you get a tape measure and measure the point on your own body that is 1100 mm from the floor you will find it is a lot more than mid thigh.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: mercury on October 04, 2016, 01:22:00 AM
If you get a tape measure and measure the point on your own body that is 1100 mm from the floor you will find it is a lot more than mid thigh.

apartments are not built to protect children, thats not the designers jobs!
you want a child friendly and totally safe dwelling, hire legoland might be good
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 04, 2016, 01:58:08 AM
apartments are not built to protect children, thats not the designers jobs!
you want a child friendly and totally safe dwelling, hire legoland might be good
Good buildings must protect the occupants.  There are building codes and OC apartments are suspect.  Whether they were built prior to the modern standards that is possible.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on October 04, 2016, 10:43:50 AM
If you get a tape measure and measure the point on your own body that is 1100 mm from the floor you will find it is a lot more than mid thigh.

You appear to be missing one very important point and it does not relate to how tall anybody is.
It relates to elevations of features. See if you can spot it. Unless you have measurements you are guessing.
Imagine you are at H & S hearing.
"Well Sir I believe the balustrades were without the code because on this photo taken from below you can see the man of unspecified height has the railings only half way up his thigh and if we measure the height half way up your thigh Sir we can see that is .............".
The response from Sir would likely start "Really Mr R. are you seriously suggesting................".
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on October 04, 2016, 10:48:16 AM
Good buildings must protect the occupants.  There are building codes and OC apartments are suspect.  Whether they were built prior to the modern standards that is possible.

Presumably you have taken professional advice on this issue and can share from whom the advice came and the full findings?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 04, 2016, 06:09:58 PM
Presumably you have taken professional advice on this issue and can share from whom the advice came and the full findings?
Mrs Google! Many building codes required the similar outcome of 1100 mm non climbable element to the balustrade.  This needs to be thrashed out. 
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 04, 2016, 06:14:14 PM
Presumably you have taken professional advice on this issue and can share from whom the advice came and the full findings?
Do you know anything relevant to the issue?
Did the balustrades meet the requirements?
Which code is this covered by?

So far I have the photo of the officer climbing what looks like a balustrade at OC and the whole structure is very climbable.  Once he stands on the concrete base the non-climbable section comes up to just above his knees.
It seems it could be very easily scaled by small children.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 04, 2016, 06:28:33 PM
You appear to be missing one very important point and it does not relate to how tall anybody is.
It relates to elevations of features. See if you can spot it. Unless you have measurements you are guessing.
Imagine you are at H & S hearing.
"Well Sir I believe the balustrades were without the code because on this photo taken from below you can see the man of unspecified height has the railings only half way up his thigh and if we measure the height half way up your thigh Sir we can see that is .............".
The response from Sir would likely start "Really Mr R. are you seriously suggesting................".
I do get the feeling this issue will be argued in court.  At that stage certainly full measurements will be provided.  Up to now I have not seen anything that I could get an accurate (estimation) scale from.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 04, 2016, 07:38:57 PM
Was the intention of taking this photo just to show how easily climbed the balustrades were?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on October 04, 2016, 09:44:53 PM
Do you know anything relevant to the issue?
Did the balustrades meet the requirements?
Which code is this covered by?

So far I have the photo of the officer climbing what looks like a balustrade at OC and the whole structure is very climbable.  Once he stands on the concrete base the non-climbable section comes up to just above his knees.
It seems it could be very easily scaled by small children.

Dunno mate you said they didn't so prove they didn't.
You are still missing a pertinent point.
Hint: Ordnance datum.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: sadie on October 04, 2016, 10:14:04 PM
1. Well ring a ding ding we have so too. There ain't no flies on you now are there?.
2. Say what you like sadie it will affect neither my health nor my finances.
3. Is Robin George Crosland a structural engineer or building inspector?

Robin Crosland was the architect who designed O.C. according to Blackwatch of the Sargeants Blog ... so he probably could have been either with a little additional training.

Were you the structual engineer for O.C. ?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 04, 2016, 10:26:41 PM
Dunno mate you said they didn't so prove they didn't.
You are still missing a pertinent point.
Hint: Ordnance datum.
When we get there we will do some measurements OK of ordnance datums etc. Also to see whether kids could get their head stuck in the spaces and cause accidental asphyxiation.
Both unclimbable height and spacing are important  safety considerations.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on October 04, 2016, 11:18:46 PM
When we get there we will do some measurements OK of ordnance datums etc. Also to see whether kids could get their head stuck in the spaces and cause accidental asphyxiation.
Both unclimbable height and spacing are important  safety considerations.

I know  ?{)(**
The UK regs allow for a spacing of verticals that will not allow a 100mm diameter sphere to pass.
You are still mising he point about those in OC.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on October 04, 2016, 11:21:16 PM
Robin Crosland was the architect who designed O.C. according to Blackwatch of the Sargeants Blog ... so he probably could have been either with a little additional training.

Were you the structual engineer for O.C. ?

I was not a structural engineer on any project in Portugal.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 05, 2016, 01:27:10 AM
I know  ?{)(**
The UK regs allow for a spacing of verticals that will not allow a 100 mm diameter sphere to pass.
You are still mising he point about those in OC.
That is a pretty small head.  It really surprised me that they would insist on the verticals being so close.
I know you'll be saying "the building went up in the 70's when the rules were different".  That might be the case, but how do the regulations apply when the apartments are leased to tourists?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: slartibartfast on October 05, 2016, 07:44:24 AM
That is a pretty small head.  It really surprised me that they would insist on the verticals being so close.
I know you'll be saying "the building went up in the 70's when the rules were different".  That might be the case, but how do the regulations apply when the apartments are leased to tourists?

I think you are way up a blind alley. A huge amount of holiday accommodation has low balcony walls so the OC is nothing special.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alfie on October 05, 2016, 09:02:43 AM
I think you are way up a blind alley. A huge amount of holiday accommodation has low balcony walls so the OC is nothing special.
It's amazing there are any kids left in the world really when you consider how low balcony walls are generally.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: slartibartfast on October 05, 2016, 09:15:53 AM
It's amazing there are any kids left in the world really when you consider how low balcony walls are generally.

True, most parents are very careful.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alfie on October 05, 2016, 09:18:42 AM
True, most parents are very careful.
That being the case why do hundreds of thousands of children get injured in accidents every year?

ETA: millions actually.  So where are these "most parents" who are so very careful?

More than two million children under the age of 15 experience accidents in and around the home every year, for which they are taken to accident and emergency units. Many more are treated by GPs and by parents and carers. On average 62 children under the age of five died as a result of an accident and over 76.000 under  the age of 14  are admitted for treatment of which over 40% are under 5 years of age.

Those most at risk from a home accident are the 0-4 years age group. Falls account for the majority of non-fatal accidents while the highest numbers of deaths are due to fire. Most of these accidents are preventable through increased awareness, improvements in the home environment and greater product safety.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on October 05, 2016, 09:55:28 AM
That being the case why do hundreds of thousands of children get injured in accidents every year?

ETA: millions actually.  So where are these "most parents" who are so very careful?

More than two million children under the age of 15 experience accidents in and around the home every year, for which they are taken to accident and emergency units. Many more are treated by GPs and by parents and carers. On average 62 children under the age of five died as a result of an accident and over 76.000 under  the age of 14  are admitted for treatment of which over 40% are under 5 years of age.

Those most at risk from a home accident are the 0-4 years age group. Falls account for the majority of non-fatal accidents while the highest numbers of deaths are due to fire. Most of these accidents are preventable through increased awareness, improvements in the home environment and greater product safety.

Well, that's amazing. Yet, according to you, none of the children fell from quite dangerous looking balconies in European holiday destinations. Of course those figures would be included in other country's figures, so we don't know what they are, do we?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alfie on October 05, 2016, 10:36:09 AM
Well, that's amazing. Yet, according to you, none of the children fell from quite dangerous looking balconies in European holiday destinations. Of course those figures would be included in other country's figures, so we don't know what they are, do we?
If I have stated that no children have ever fallen from balconies in European holiday destinations it should be very easy for you to provide the cite of me saying so - over to you, or withdraw your claim. 
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 05, 2016, 10:55:36 AM
It's amazing there are any kids left in the world really when you consider how low balcony walls are generally.
Kids are intelligent.  Most cases they would consider what would happen if they ventured over the edge.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alfie on October 05, 2016, 11:12:54 AM
If I have stated that no children have ever fallen from balconies in European holiday destinations it should be very easy for you to provide the cite of me saying so - over to you, or withdraw your claim.
G-Unit, I'm waiting for the cite to back up your statement "Yet, according to you, none of the children fell from quite dangerous looking balconies in European holiday destinations" - let's be having it.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: G-Unit on October 05, 2016, 11:19:18 AM
G-Unit, I'm waiting for the cite to back up your statement "Yet, according to you, none of the children fell from quite dangerous looking balconies in European holiday destinations" - let's be having it.

Ok, you didn't say it. But in my opinion you have inferred it.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alfie on October 05, 2016, 11:22:15 AM
Ok, you didn't say it. But in my opinion you have inferred it.
Rubbish.  Of course children can fall over balconies.  Eric Clapton's son fell out of a high rise block window and died.  However there is precisely ZERO evidence that Madeleine McCann met her fate this way, so why are people speculating that she did?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: jassi on October 05, 2016, 11:30:48 AM
Rubbish.  Of course children can fall over balconies.  Eric Clapton's son fell out of a high rise block window and died.  However there is precisely ZERO evidence that Madeleine McCann met her fate this way, so why are people speculating that she did?

I have absolutely no idea, for if she had had such an accident, it would be no reason for concealment of as body.

An accident of that nature would be more likely to lead to a compensation claim against the holiday company.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 05, 2016, 11:47:12 AM
Rubbish.  Of course children can fall over balconies.  Eric Clapton's son fell out of a high rise block window and died.  However there is precisely ZERO evidence that Madeleine McCann met her fate this way, so why are people speculating that she did?

There is a sighting 9:15 PM of someone carrying a child past the McCann's apartment soon after Gerry has checked on Madeleine.  Is this someone carrying an unconscious child, is it a father carrying a child back from creche or is it an abductor taking MM away from the apartment?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on October 05, 2016, 11:47:47 AM
That is a pretty small head.  It really surprised me that they would insist on the verticals being so close.
I know you'll be saying "the building went up in the 70's when the rules were different".  That might be the case, but how do the regulations apply when the apartments are leased to tourists?

So be it.
I will not.
I thought you said you read the regs?
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 05, 2016, 11:52:41 AM
So be it.
I will not.
I thought you said you read the regs?
The NZ regs didn't cover that bit.  I couldn't find the Portuguese regulations.
Title: Re: Are the balconies at OC a risk to toddlers?
Post by: John on October 06, 2016, 01:23:20 PM
These aren't.


Absolutely brilliant Slarti.  Just shows what the little blighters can get up to!