UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: stephen25000 on July 15, 2017, 06:14:13 PM

Title: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 15, 2017, 06:14:13 PM
Has hunt for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?

 Just months after police announced extra funding amid reports they were closing in on a suspect, we reveal they made just TWO flights to Portugal last year

Madeleine McCann detectives made just two flights to Portugal last year 

Earlier this year Scotland Yard chief said the investigation was far from over

Mark Rowley revealed new information and 'critical' leads were still coming in

Met Police confirmed in March that Home Office had approved extra funding


Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4699346/Has-hunt-Madeleine-McCann-ground-halt.html#ixzz4mvBQz5yD
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook


So, as I and others predicted, the investigation appears to be going nowhere and grinding to it's inevitable shelving.

I wonder if this ties in to last weeks admission that the McCann's attempt to go to the E.C.H.R. is over ?

95
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 06:34:28 PM
Has hunt for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?

 Just months after police announced extra funding amid reports they were closing in on a suspect, we reveal they made just TWO flights to Portugal last year

Madeleine McCann detectives made just two flights to Portugal last year 

Earlier this year Scotland Yard chief said the investigation was far from over

Mark Rowley revealed new information and 'critical' leads were still coming in

Met Police confirmed in March that Home Office had approved extra funding


Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4699346/Has-hunt-Madeleine-McCann-ground-halt.html#ixzz4mvBQz5yD
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook


So, as I and others predicted, the investigation appears to be going nowhere and grinding to it's inevitable shelving.

I wonder if this ties in to last weeks admission that the McCann's attempt to go to the E.C.H.R. is over ?
I think most of us felt it was unlikely that Grange would solve the case but hoped it would give us a better understanding of what happened to Maddie
They have...they believe she was abducted
The case may not be shelved as you think but simply left open
Are you sure SY claimed they were closing in on suspects....more likely just tabloid talk
I don't see this has anything to do with the ECHR
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 15, 2017, 07:01:27 PM
The story seems to have arisen as a result of an answer to a FOI request that DCI Wall has only made two recent trips to Portugal.

So what?

There are Portuguese feet on the ground if that should be required ... and the wonders of modern technology have enabled instant worldwide conferencing and visual communication with other parties.

Madeleine sells papers whether there is anything constructive to say or anything to speculate about.  I'm content to wait and see.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 15, 2017, 07:05:13 PM
In the end, this case will be shelved once more, and at some point, someone is going to have to justify the expenditure.

IMV, the cliche of having one more lead to pursue is looking increasingly ridiculous.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 15, 2017, 08:51:00 PM
In the end, this case will be shelved once more, and at some point, someone is going to have to justify the expenditure.

IMV, the cliche of having one more lead to pursue is looking increasingly ridiculous.

Expenditure has been justified throughout the investigation.  I would have expected that initially the impetus concerned the reinstatement of a prematurely concluded search for a missing little girl and the longevity of the case is as a result of following active avenues for investigation which requires no justification.

If Madeleine is not found as a result of the present investigation her case will remain open.  I find nothing at all ridiculous about any aspect of the search for a person missing for a decade apart from the fact that initially no-one was looking for her.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 15, 2017, 09:25:56 PM
Expenditure has been justified throughout the investigation.  I would have expected that initially the impetus concerned the reinstatement of a prematurely concluded search for a missing little girl and the longevity of the case is as a result of following active avenues for investigation which requires no justification.

If Madeleine is not found as a result of the present investigation her case will remain open.  I find nothing at all ridiculous about any aspect of the search for a person missing for a decade apart from the fact that initially no-one was looking for her.

That again is a matter of opinion.

Also, she was looked for by many people, including volunteers.

That she wasn't searched for, is another myth.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 15, 2017, 09:30:34 PM
That again is a matter of opinion.

Also, she was looked for by many people, including volunteers.

That she wasn't searched for, is another myth.
I think there are a lot of people in Luz, in the GNR, in the PJ, in the Maritime Police, in the bombeiros etc. who would take umbrage at the notion she wasn't searched for.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 15, 2017, 09:35:01 PM
I think there are a lot of people in Luz, in the GNR, in the PJ, in the Maritime Police, in the bombeiros etc. who would take umbrage at the notion she wasn't searched for.

Precisely SIL.

I would add it is insulting to the people including, local residents, holidaymakers, ex-pats, police officers , etc., who gave up their time, to search, and not just for a few hours either.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 15, 2017, 10:12:56 PM
That again is a matter of opinion.

Also, she was looked for by many people, including volunteers.

That she wasn't searched for, is another myth.

Apart from the heroic effort put in by her parents, what exactly was happening in Madeleine McCann's case between her case being archived in 2008 and Scotland Yard reopening it in 2013?

There was no active investigation into Madeleine's case or an active search for her being carried out, with the exception of that being paid for by Madeleine's Fund;  that is no myth - that is disgraceful fact.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 15, 2017, 10:22:05 PM
Apart from the heroic effort put in by her parents, what exactly was happening in Madeleine McCann's case between her case being archived in 2008 and Scotland Yard reopening it in 2013?

There was no active investigation into Madeleine's case or an active search for her being carried out, with the exception of that being paid for by Madeleine's Fund;  that is no myth - that is disgraceful fact.
I absolutely agree
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 15, 2017, 10:23:24 PM
Apart from the heroic effort put in by her parents, what exactly was happening in Madeleine McCann's case between her case being archived in 2008 and Scotland Yard reopening it in 2013?

There was no active investigation into Madeleine's case or an active search for her being carried out, with the exception of that being paid for by Madeleine's Fund;  that is no myth - that is disgraceful fact.
What happened was the case was archived due to a lack of ways to take it forward, notably the opportunity of a reconstruction blocked by the T7.

One of the best clips from the 10 year anniversary specials was Clarence Mitchell, when he was describing the use of PIs pre-archival as 'technically' illegal and 'one of the obstacles at the time', or words to that effect.

Your last sentence is an IYO and should be changed to such.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 15, 2017, 10:27:46 PM
Apart from the heroic effort put in by her parents, what exactly was happening in Madeleine McCann's case between her case being archived in 2008 and Scotland Yard reopening it in 2013?

There was no active investigation into Madeleine's case or an active search for her being carried out, with the exception of that being paid for by Madeleine's Fund;  that is no myth - that is disgraceful fact.

What heroic effort ?

That is propaganda.

The last known recorded  physical search for their daughter took place in the early morning of the 4 th May 2007.

Donated money was used to pay a succession of incompetents who achieved nothing.

Tax payers money in the UK and Portugal has been used to pay for investigations, with nothing  achieved.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 15, 2017, 11:31:49 PM
What heroic effort ?

That is propaganda.

The last known recorded  physical search for their daughter took place in the early morning of the 4 th May 2007.

Donated money was used to pay a succession of incompetents who achieved nothing.

Tax payers money in the UK and Portugal has been used to pay for investigations, with nothing  achieved.

 Pedro do Carmo: "Maddie's parents are not suspects. Period."

Journalist:Ten years on about the events at Praia da Luz, why do you think the case is still so much debated?

Pedro do Carmo, deputy director of the Judiciary Police: First, there was a deliberate and legitimate effort on the part of the child's parents to keep the topic on the agenda of the media.
http://expresso.sapo.pt/sociedade/2017-05-03-Pedro-do-Carmo-Os-pais-de-Maddie-nao-sao-suspeitos.-Ponto-1

You may deride in the basest terms the profound influence Madeleine McCann's parents had on the search for her but in a recent interview, the deputy director of the Judiciary Police is rather inclined to give credit where credit is due.

In the same interview he was also at pains to stress that as far as the PJ is concerned the present case is far from concluded.
"We are very demanding with our work. In this case, we are not satisfied and remain committed to resolve the case." Pedro do Carmo

Question to you: is it your opinion that taxpayers' money should not in general be used to pay for investigating crime or is it only in the particular case of the missing child, Madeleine McCann?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: sadie on July 16, 2017, 01:16:58 AM
What happened was the case was archived due to a lack of ways to take it forward, notably the opportunity of a reconstruction blocked by the T7.

One of the best clips from the 10 year anniversary specials was Clarence Mitchell, when he was describing the use of PIs pre-archival as 'technically' illegal and 'one of the obstacles at the time', or words to that effect.

Your last sentence is an IYO and should be changed to such.

Your first sentence is IYO, of course.

The reconstruction should have taken place immediately after Madeleine went missing IMO

But Amaral made all sorts of feeble excuses IMO to prevent that taking place
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 16, 2017, 01:33:08 AM
Your first sentence is IYO, of course.

The reconstruction should have taken place immediately after Madeleine went missing IMO

But Amaral made all sorts of feeble excuses IMO to prevent that taking place
The first sentence is according to the archiving report.

As to what it would have taken to do a reconstruction in Amaral's time .........

That would be the sealing off of the heart of Luz.

And the co-operation of the T7.   8((()*/
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: misty on July 16, 2017, 01:42:41 AM
The first sentence is according to the archiving report.

As to what it would have taken to do a reconstruction in Amaral's time .........

That would be the sealing off of the heart of Luz.

And the co-operation of the T7.   8((()*/

You wonder why they didn't co-operate?

Deleted Daily Express article

Sunday November 4,2007
By Matt Drake


FOUR friends of Kate and Gerry McCann expect to be named as prime suspects over the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine.

Dr Russell O’Brien and his partner Jane Tanner, Matthew Oldfield and Dr David Payne were last night forced to bring in their own lawyers after increasing fears that Portuguese police were preparing to implicate them in the case of the vanished four-year-old girl.

It has emerged that the four, all members of the “Tapas Nine” dining party, have been warned detectives are prepared to make them official suspects in the next few days.

The latest dramatic development follows the discovery by Portuguese investigators of contradictions in key statements made in the first few hours after Madeleine vanished.

DNA samples also appear to support the chilling theory that Kate and Gerry were involved in whatever happened to their daughter.

Yesterday an emotional Gerry said: “Today marks six months since Madeleine was taken from us. It is an incredibly long time for us but must be even longer for Madeleine.

“It is so painful for us simply being separated, but all the more distressing when we have to speculate about the situation in which Madeleine finds herself. We have no idea whether she is suffering but we have to hope and pray that she is being treated like a princess, as she deserves.”

If named, the McCanns’ friends Dr O’Brien, 36, Ms Tanner, 37, Dr Payne, 41, and Mr Oldfield, 37, will join them and expatriate Robert Murat as the only suspects in the investigation.

Portuguese police have received permission from a judge to travel to Britain to re-interview the four.

Last night a source close to them said: “They are aware this might happen and although they have yet to receive any official word there have been strong enough signs for them to take legal advice..................
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 16, 2017, 02:00:20 AM
You wonder why they didn't co-operate?

Deleted Daily Express article

Sunday November 4,2007
By Matt Drake


FOUR friends of Kate and Gerry McCann expect to be named as prime suspects over the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine.

Dr Russell O’Brien and his partner Jane Tanner, Matthew Oldfield and Dr David Payne were last night forced to bring in their own lawyers after increasing fears that Portuguese police were preparing to implicate them in the case of the vanished four-year-old girl.

It has emerged that the four, all members of the “Tapas Nine” dining party, have been warned detectives are prepared to make them official suspects in the next few days.

The latest dramatic development follows the discovery by Portuguese investigators of contradictions in key statements made in the first few hours after Madeleine vanished.

DNA samples also appear to support the chilling theory that Kate and Gerry were involved in whatever happened to their daughter.

Yesterday an emotional Gerry said: “Today marks six months since Madeleine was taken from us. It is an incredibly long time for us but must be even longer for Madeleine.

“It is so painful for us simply being separated, but all the more distressing when we have to speculate about the situation in which Madeleine finds herself. We have no idea whether she is suffering but we have to hope and pray that she is being treated like a princess, as she deserves.”

If named, the McCanns’ friends Dr O’Brien, 36, Ms Tanner, 37, Dr Payne, 41, and Mr Oldfield, 37, will join them and expatriate Robert Murat as the only suspects in the investigation.

Portuguese police have received permission from a judge to travel to Britain to re-interview the four.

Last night a source close to them said: “They are aware this might happen and although they have yet to receive any official word there have been strong enough signs for them to take legal advice..................
Right, so......

Amaral should have done a reconstruction is the premise.

Amaral got hoiked from the case when?

Report dated 4 Nov 2007.  Friends afraid of being made arguidos.

If this was a recipe, I couldn't cook it, because it is soooooooooooooo garbled.

For Amaral to do a recon, he had to be on the case, and the T9 had to be in Portugal.

Neither of those in Nov 2007.

I can't cook a meal without the ingredients.  Sorry.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: misty on July 16, 2017, 02:07:10 AM
Right, so......

Amaral should have done a reconstruction is the premise.

Amaral got hoiked from the case when?

Report dated 4 Nov 2007.  Friends afraid of being made arguidos.

If this was a recipe, I couldn't cook it, because it is soooooooooooooo garbled.

For Amaral to do a recon, he had to be on the case, and the T9 had to be in Portugal.

Neither of those in Nov 2007.

I can't cook a meal without the ingredients.  Sorry.

The PJ did a recon with the 3 of the Smiths in May 2007 after bringing them back to Portugal. No reason why they couldn't have taken a couple of hours to do the same thing with the Tapas group. It wasn't as if all the group went to & from the apartments during the crucial 90m period. After all, they removed holidaymakers from their apartments in August 2007 when the cadaver dogs were brought in.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 16, 2017, 03:32:55 AM
Right, so......

Amaral should have done a reconstruction is the premise.

Amaral got hoiked from the case when?

Report dated 4 Nov 2007.  Friends afraid of being made arguidos.

If this was a recipe, I couldn't cook it, because it is soooooooooooooo garbled.

For Amaral to do a recon, he had to be on the case, and the T9 had to be in Portugal.

Neither of those in Nov 2007.

I can't cook a meal without the ingredients.  Sorry.

You seem to be unaware that it was decided not to enact a reconstruction at a time when Amaral's influence on the investigation was very much in evidence?


Snip
In chapter five Amaral writes ...

"The reconstruction was never to take place. The reasons put forward to justify that decision - in spite of opinions to the contrary - are multiple.

There are lots of holiday-makers at this time and sealing off the perimeter would ruin their stay;

the airspace would have to be closed;

the hotel complex would be overrun with hordes of journalists;

people might think that the parents and their friends were suspects and, of course, the field mustn't be left open for that kind of deliberation.
For all that, a more discreet reconstruction, even partial, with only the couple present, might provide useful information. No a priori judgment is implied, quite the contrary."
Goncalo Amaral


http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=8368.msg416680#msg416680
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 16, 2017, 08:16:17 AM
You seem to be unaware that it was decided not to enact a reconstruction at a time when Amaral's influence on the investigation was very much in evidence?


Snip
In chapter five Amaral writes ...

"The reconstruction was never to take place. The reasons put forward to justify that decision - in spite of opinions to the contrary - are multiple.

There are lots of holiday-makers at this time and sealing off the perimeter would ruin their stay;

the airspace would have to be closed;

the hotel complex would be overrun with hordes of journalists;

people might think that the parents and their friends were suspects and, of course, the field mustn't be left open for that kind of deliberation.
For all that, a more discreet reconstruction, even partial, with only the couple present, might provide useful information. No a priori judgment is implied, quite the contrary."
Goncalo Amaral


http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=8368.msg416680#msg416680
Supporters need to stop flip-flopping about when a reconstruction should have been done and what the circumstances were like in Luz at said time.  You can't pick a bit here and pick a bit there and cobble it together as though it all joins up.

By the end of 4 May 2007, when it emerged that the time lines were a bit of a mess, the McCann-alerted press were swarming over Luz.

A recon, whether with 2 or 9 people, or more, required that a large chunk of Luz could be quarantined.

The road the McCanns abutted was not a quiet road.  It had become one of the more important routes in Luz.

The PJ had until the T7 departed to do a recon. Nov 07 came nowhere close.

I was watching Panorama Nov 07 last night, which has sections of the press melee hounding the McCanns on their drive back to Faro airport.

Rebelo requested a recon at a time when it could have been achieved quietly.  The T7 refused.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 08:22:52 AM
Pedro do Carmo: "Maddie's parents are not suspects. Period."

Journalist:Ten years on about the events at Praia da Luz, why do you think the case is still so much debated?

Pedro do Carmo, deputy director of the Judiciary Police: First, there was a deliberate and legitimate effort on the part of the child's parents to keep the topic on the agenda of the media.
http://expresso.sapo.pt/sociedade/2017-05-03-Pedro-do-Carmo-Os-pais-de-Maddie-nao-sao-suspeitos.-Ponto-1

You may deride in the basest terms the profound influence Madeleine McCann's parents had on the search for her but in a recent interview, the deputy director of the Judiciary Police is rather inclined to give credit where credit is due.

In the same interview he was also at pains to stress that as far as the PJ is concerned the present case is far from concluded.
"We are very demanding with our work. In this case, we are not satisfied and remain committed to resolve the case." Pedro do Carmo

Question to you: is it your opinion that taxpayers' money should not in general be used to pay for investigating crime or is it only in the particular case of the missing child, Madeleine McCann?

I have answered that question numerous times.

A great deal of money has already been spent, with nothing to show for it. Ditto in Portugal.

Now you tell me, when will enough be enough as regards this case, and knowing full well police budgets and public finances , according to the government are stretched to the limit. Also, police services are being reduced even further.

So the question is, why are you and others, prepared for this expenditure to continue  without limits as regards time  ?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 08:25:20 AM
Pedro do Carmo: "Maddie's parents are not suspects. Period."

Journalist:Ten years on about the events at Praia da Luz, why do you think the case is still so much debated?

Pedro do Carmo, deputy director of the Judiciary Police: First, there was a deliberate and legitimate effort on the part of the child's parents to keep the topic on the agenda of the media.
http://expresso.sapo.pt/sociedade/2017-05-03-Pedro-do-Carmo-Os-pais-de-Maddie-nao-sao-suspeitos.-Ponto-1

You may deride in the basest terms the profound influence Madeleine McCann's parents had on the search for her but in a recent interview, the deputy director of the Judiciary Police is rather inclined to give credit where credit is due.

In the same interview he was also at pains to stress that as far as the PJ is concerned the present case is far from concluded.
"We are very demanding with our work. In this case, we are not satisfied and remain committed to resolve the case." Pedro do Carmo

Question to you: is it your opinion that taxpayers' money should not in general be used to pay for investigating crime or is it only in the particular case of the missing child, Madeleine McCann?

The same Pedro also admitted he didn't know what happened to Madeleine.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Benice on July 16, 2017, 09:18:45 AM
I have answered that question numerous times.

A great deal of money has already been spent, with nothing to show for it. Ditto in Portugal.

Now you tell me, when will enough be enough as regards this case, and knowing full well police budgets and public finances , according to the government are stretched to the limit. Also, police services are being reduced even further.

So the question is, why are you and others, prepared for this expenditure to continue  without limits as regards time  ?

The expenditure is 'peanuts' in the scheme of things.  It costs taxpayers £150 million a year just to remove chewing gum from our streets.

As long as SY know there are leads still to  be followed - then of course they should carry on imo.

If it was announced that a lot more taxpayers' money was going to be spent on searching for Ben Needham, I would be delighted. 

Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 09:21:49 AM
The expenditure is 'peanuts' in the scheme of things.  It costs taxpayers £150 million a year just to remove chewing gum from our streets.

As long as SY know there are leads still to  be followed - then of course they should carry on imo.

If it was announced that a lot more taxpayers' money was going to be spent on searching for Ben Needham, I would be delighted.

I was waiting for the chewing gum to rise again.

Meanwhile police services are being cut back.

Are you happy with that ?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: carlymichelle on July 16, 2017, 02:45:36 PM
 @)(++(* the media must be  reading our  forum


https://au.news.yahoo.com/a/36394471/investigation-into-madeleine-mccanns-disappearance-halted-despite-fresh-critical-leads-and-85-000-boost/#page1

 8(>((
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 02:49:37 PM
@)(++(* the media must be  reading our  forum


https://au.news.yahoo.com/a/36394471/investigation-into-madeleine-mccanns-disappearance-halted-despite-fresh-critical-leads-and-85-000-boost/#page1

 8(>((

No
The story comes from an earlier story from the daily mail which started this thread
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 16, 2017, 04:01:10 PM
I was waiting for the chewing gum to rise again.

Meanwhile police services are being cut back.

Are you happy with that ?

I seem to recall quite a few satisfied comments when detectives working on Madeleine's case were amongst the first to be severely cut back.
The fact that they asked for more funding to enable them to continue to work on active leads also caused not a little consternation in some quarters.

Doesn't it seriously worry you that every single penny - including the money raised for Madeleine's Fund - is actively railed against and grudged;  particularly when the ire is directed at an active police investigation with a missing girl at the centre of it?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: sadie on July 16, 2017, 05:45:15 PM
I seem to recall quite a few satisfied comments when detectives working on Madeleine's case were amongst the first to be severely cut back.
The fact that they asked for more funding to enable them to continue to work on active leads also caused not a little consternation in some quarters.

Doesn't it seriously worry you that every single penny - including the money raised for Madeleine's Fund - is actively railed against and grudged;  particularly when the ire is directed at an active police investigation with a missing girl at the centre of it?
It is very odd, Brietta, especially as these people have it in for only The Mccanns?

The same people dont seem to mind the fact that large amounts of money are being spent on searching  for other missing children.

In fact it is so odd that ir could be called bizarre and unfathomable.   Perhaps for some reason they are jealous of the Mccanns?   Otherwise the only other reasons that i can think of is that they are Amarals mates or gain some benefit from Madeleine not being found.

Can anyone else offer any reasons for the hatred that is so frequently aimed at The Mccanns?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 16, 2017, 06:34:42 PM
It is very odd, Brietta, especially as these people have it in for only The Mccanns?

The same people dont seem to mind the fact that large amounts of money are being spent on searching  for other missing children.

In fact it is so odd that ir could be called bizarre and unfathomable.   Perhaps for some reason they are jealous of the Mccanns?   Otherwise the only other reasons that i can think of is that they are Amarals mates or gain some benefit from Madeleine not being found.

Can anyone else offer any reasons for the hatred that is so frequently aimed at The Mccanns?

It is my opinion that initially many people were manipulated by false media reports at the time; what the motivation for the inexcusable ten year campaign of vilification may be totally escapes me;  I find it beyond reason.

If the present investigation into Madeleine's disappearance comes to a conclusion without resolution I will be very sad for Madeleine and I will be very sad for the family who nurtured her for the first four years of her life.

But we are not at the square one of 2007.

The current investigation has cleared a forest of dead wood by following investigative opportunities which had been neglected until Madeleine's case was reopened in 2013.

It is now just a waiting game.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 09:30:05 PM
It is my opinion that initially many people were manipulated by false media reports at the time; what the motivation for the inexcusable ten year campaign of vilification may be totally escapes me;  I find it beyond reason.

If the present investigation into Madeleine's disappearance comes to a conclusion without resolution I will be very sad for Madeleine and I will be very sad for the family who nurtured her for the first four years of her life.

But we are not at the square one of 2007.

The current investigation has cleared a forest of dead wood by following investigative opportunities which had been neglected until Madeleine's case was reopened in 2013.

It is now just a waiting game.


...and it has gone nowhere.

They do not know how Madeleine disappeared, let alone her ultimate fate.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 10:09:54 PM

...and it has gone nowhere.

They do not know how Madeleine disappeared, let alone her ultimate fate.
According to SY Maddie was abducted
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 16, 2017, 10:13:52 PM
According to SY Maddie was abducted

It's an opinion, and they have got nowhere.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 16, 2017, 10:19:45 PM
It's an opinion, and they have got nowhere.

It's the experts opinion
The experts who have access to all the evidence
Unlike us
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 16, 2017, 11:16:03 PM
It's the experts opinion
The experts who have access to all the evidence
Unlike us

We look forward to reading about early arrests and charges then.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 17, 2017, 12:59:25 AM
We look forward to reading about early arrests and charges then.
So do I and I have a feeling it is any day soon.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: John on July 17, 2017, 01:22:17 AM
@)(++(* the media must be  reading our  forum


https://au.news.yahoo.com/a/36394471/investigation-into-madeleine-mccanns-disappearance-halted-despite-fresh-critical-leads-and-85-000-boost/#page1

 8(>((

Yes, we have previously been approached by the Australian media for an interview.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: John on July 17, 2017, 01:24:02 AM
According to SY Maddie was abducted

And probably from the road outside too. 

SY have achieved very little progress in this case.  Redwood thought that he was onto something when he dug up the mound in Praia da Luz but that too was a dead end.  The PJ are not following any new leads despite recent comments so the case is effectively already mothballed.  All that is left is Mss Wall's Final Report and the justification for spending £11 million.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 17, 2017, 01:58:30 AM
And probably from the road outside too. 

SY have achieved very little progress in this case.  Redwood thought that he was onto something when he dug up the mound in Praia da Luz but that too was a dead end.  The PJ are not following any new leads despite recent comments so the case is effectively already mothballed.  All that is left is Mss Wall's Final Report and the justification for spending £11 million.

The justification is that when a little girl vanished without trace an inadequate police investigation occurred which  resulted in premature closure of her case while there were investigative opportunities in existence which were missed and therefore ignored.
Years later a review of her case highlighted procedures which had been missed and steps were taken to rectify that situation.
Madeleine McCann or any other missing British national abroad, surely merited that much consideration given the gaps evident in her case initially?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 17, 2017, 02:56:28 AM
The justification is that when a little girl vanished without trace an inadequate police investigation occurred which  resulted in premature closure of her case while there were investigative opportunities in existence which were missed and therefore ignored.
Years later a review of her case highlighted procedures which had been missed and steps were taken to rectify that situation.
Madeleine McCann or any other missing British national abroad, surely merited that much consideration given the gaps evident in her case initially?
Kindly provide some examples to support this barrage of criticism.

Let me see ....

Reconstruction blocked.  Not done by OG to date.

Re-interviewed lots of people interviewed at the time.

Dug up 3 areas in/around Luz, to find that 41 'anomalies' were not anomalous.  Learned how hard it is to dig a grave in the Algarve.

Added 2 known plus two unknown men as arguidos.  Of the two unknown men, one was 16 at the time.  The other is clearly not fit-for-crime-purpose.

Published 2 e-fits not around at the time, and which are positively toxic.

Sterling work.  Around 11 or 12 million sterling.

So are you going to state clearly and unequivocally what Paulo Rebelo's team allegedly missed?

Or are you merely broadcasting your opinion that the first investigation does not meet your fancy?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:39:50 AM
Kindly provide some examples to support this barrage of criticism.

Let me see ....

Reconstruction blocked.  Not done by OG to date.

Re-interviewed lots of people interviewed at the time.

Dug up 3 areas in/around Luz, to find that 41 'anomalies' were not anomalous.  Learned how hard it is to dig a grave in the Algarve.

Added 2 known plus two unknown men as arguidos.  Of the two unknown men, one was 16 at the time.  The other is clearly not fit-for-crime-purpose.

Published 2 e-fits not around at the time, and which are positively toxic.

Sterling work.  Around 11 or 12 million sterling.

So are you going to state clearly and unequivocally what Paulo Rebelo's team allegedly missed?
I
Or are you merely broadcasting your opinion that the first investigation does not meet your fancy?

The very fact that SY are there is indicative that a proper job wasn't done first time round
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 17, 2017, 07:43:01 AM
The very fact that SY are there is indicative that a proper job wasn't done first time round
What can I say?  *&*%£
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:50:01 AM
What can I say?  *&*%£

Obviously nothing
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: G-Unit on July 17, 2017, 08:12:31 AM
The very fact that SY are there is indicative that a proper job wasn't done first time round

SY are involved because David Cameron wanted them to be. Whether he believed the McCann's smear campaign against the PJ which began on 3rd/4th May 2007 I don't know. If he did it was probably another of his errors of judgement imo.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 08:12:37 AM
Obviously nothing

It is indicative that they have found nothing, as I expected and predicted.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: barrier on July 17, 2017, 08:32:07 AM
All that is left is Mss Wall's Final Report and the justification for spending £11 million.

With the way that Rowley expressed the thoughts back in April,it'll make little or no sense.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 08:34:47 AM
It is indicative that they have found nothing, as I expected and predicted.

Most of us realised SY would not completely solve the case
It was just too long after the event
What we hoped is that they would shed some light on what actually happened to a Maddie
They have come to the conclusion Maddie was abducted and the parents not involved
Which is what some of us have been saying for years
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: barrier on July 17, 2017, 08:35:51 AM
Most of us realised SY would not completely solve the case
It was just too long after the event
What we hoped is that they would shed some light on what actually happened to a Maddie
They have come to the conclusion Maddie was abducted and the parents not involved
Which is what some of us have been saying for years

What report is that written in then?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 08:37:19 AM
What report is that written in then?

Both Redwood and the current investigators have confirmed this
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 08:40:28 AM
Most of us realised SY would not completely solve the case
It was just too long after the event
What we hoped is that they would shed some light on what actually happened to a Maddie
They have come to the conclusion Maddie was abducted and the parents not involved
Which is what some of us have been saying for years

They do not know who was involved, if anyone was.

They claim abduction as a belief.

No evidence of a third party in the apartment, that night.

They did not investigate the Mccanns, and relied on the shelving report, which they 'misunderstood', and they weren't the first ones to do that. yet the meaning of the shelving report was crystal clear to others.

If you think that will change, you are mistaken beyond measure.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 08:42:12 AM
Both Redwood and the current investigators have confirmed this

They said they believe. nothing more.

In the real world, we know the cause of Madeleine's disappearance has not been ascertained.

Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 08:42:47 AM
They do not know who was involved, if anyone was.

They claim abduction as a belief.

No evidence of a third party in the apartment, that night.

They did not investigate the Mccanns, and relied on the shelving report, which they 'misunderstood', and they weren't the first ones to do that. yet the meaning of the shelving report was crystal clear to others.

If you think that will change, you are mistaken beyond measure.

Do you have a cite for not investigating the parents and not understanding the archiving report
Otherwise it's just your opinion and im sure you are mistaken
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 08:44:04 AM
They said they believe. nothing more.

In the real world, we know the cause of Madeleine's disappearance has not been ascertained.

They believe based on the evidence and they are the experts with access to evidence we may not know about
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 08:47:32 AM
Do you have a cite for not investigating the parents and not understanding the archiving report
Otherwise it's just your opinion and im sure you are mistaken

This has been done before.

''And let it not be said, also, that the appellants were cleared by the archival dispatch of the crime-process.''

Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: barrier on July 17, 2017, 08:48:25 AM
Both Redwood and the current investigators have confirmed this

Hmm,yet neither one can confirm that the poor girl is alive or dead,yet if believed the 4 amigos were asked if they had killed Madeleine.If and its a big if they know she was abducted,then its not to much of a leap to say they would know,what point of egress was used,what time, what mode of transport if any was used to spirit her away,where she's likely to be now,unless she is in the one last broom cupboard not searched in SY,thats maybe the reason the latest rubbish is saying they don't need to be in Portugal to find Madeleine.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 08:49:52 AM
They believe based on the evidence and they are the experts with access to evidence we may not know about

Precisely, what expertise do they have in missing peoples cases ?

....and meanwhile, no matter any denials, no forensic or other evidence, shows a third party in the apartment.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 09:03:19 AM
This has been done before.

''And let it not be said, also, that the appellants were cleared by the archival dispatch of the crime-process.''

Cleared of what
They haven't been cleared because they have never been charged
Simple
Not suspects in the present investigation
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 09:10:59 AM
Cleared of what
They haven't been cleared because they have never been charged
Simple
Not suspects in the present investigation

Do you not understand the shelving report ?

ON which the Supreme Court Judgement refers to, as did OG.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 17, 2017, 09:17:00 AM

We are going to be nice today.  And I am going to make sure that we are.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 09:22:46 AM
We are going to be nice today.  And I am going to make sure that we are.

Fair enough Eleanor. 8((()*/
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: G-Unit on July 17, 2017, 09:28:54 AM
Cleared of what
They haven't been cleared because they have never been charged
Simple
Not suspects in the present investigation

Their lawyer said, in court, that they had been cleared. Perhaps she reads the UK newspapers?

Kate and Gerry McCann have been officially cleared of any involvement in the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/2440157/Madeleine-McCann-Kate-and-Gerry-McCann-officially-cleared-of-arguido-status.html

Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 17, 2017, 09:29:46 AM
Fair enough Eleanor. 8((()*/

Thank you, Stephen.  Your assistance on this is always welcome.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 09:44:38 AM
We are going to be nice today.  And I am going to make sure that we are.

I'm always nice
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 09:59:24 AM
Their lawyer said, in court, that they had been cleared. Perhaps she reads the UK newspapers?

Kate and Gerry McCann have been officially cleared of any involvement in the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/2440157/Madeleine-McCann-Kate-and-Gerry-McCann-officially-cleared-of-arguido-status.html
Headline says cleared of arguido status
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 17, 2017, 10:03:07 AM
I'm always nice

Good.  Keep it up.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 10:03:36 AM
Headline says cleared of arguido status

Subject to a 20 year period, in which if new evidence emerges, it could be re-enacted.

Then again, I expect this case will be shelved, with no resolution.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: G-Unit on July 17, 2017, 10:06:42 AM
Headline says cleared of arguido status

The headline is truthful. The bit below, which I quoted, is not. That's why I quoted it.  8**8:/:
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 10:43:32 AM
The headline is truthful. The bit below, which I quoted, is not. That's why I quoted it.  8**8:/:

I think it shows how careful you have to be with newspaper articles...and this is the telegraph
It looks like they were told they had been cleared of the arguido status then got carried away
Chinese whispers
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: G-Unit on July 17, 2017, 10:47:42 AM
According to Ms Kandohla the search hasn't ground to a halt. An unnamed but exclusive source at the Met told her so. Is it usual for official denials to be made by anonymous 'spokespeople'?

Scotland Yard today took an unusual step of denying “a speculative non story” that the Maddie inquiry was grinding to a halt.......Speaking exclusively to The Sun Online, the SY spokesman said defiantly: “We should not have to explain or justify how many times we are going to Portugal. Whatever we do, and we are doing our very best, someone always wants to criticise the actions of the police regarding Madeleine McCann......The investigation continues with focus and determination. It is not winding down, it is not grinding to a halt. It is on going.
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/4029785/maddie-mccann-cops-insist-search-hasnt-ground-to-a-halt-but-admit-they-only-have-11-weeks-left-to-find-her-before-their-money-runs-out/
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: John on July 17, 2017, 10:49:23 AM
The very fact that SY are there is indicative that a proper job wasn't done first time round

First off, SY aren't there.  They never had a permanent presence there.  I've never heard of any police force undertaking a proper investigation by proxy at a distance of 1,500 miles.  It's pathetic really!
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: John on July 17, 2017, 10:51:09 AM
Most of us realised SY would not completely solve the case
It was just too long after the event
What we hoped is that they would shed some light on what actually happened to a Maddie
They have come to the conclusion Maddie was abducted and the parents not involved
Which is what some of us have been saying for years

I wonder if that was their true agenda from the start?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 10:54:28 AM
First off, SY aren't there.  They never had a permanent presence there.  I've never heard of any police force undertaking a proper investigation by proxy at a distance of 1,500 miles.  It's pathetic really!
It's a very unusual case John
SY get a lot of criticism on here and on other forums
Totally unfair imo
They have obviously found information that the pj didn't properly investigate
That's why they are there
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: John on July 17, 2017, 10:55:58 AM
Their lawyer said, in court, that they had been cleared. Perhaps she reads the UK newspapers?

Kate and Gerry McCann have been officially cleared of any involvement in the disappearance of their daughter Madeleine
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/2440157/Madeleine-McCann-Kate-and-Gerry-McCann-officially-cleared-of-arguido-status.html

Unsurprising really given the lengths lawyers will go for their princely fee.  If I were the McCanns I would be looking for a refund given that their lawyers lost the case and could well cost them substantial damages too.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 10:58:47 AM
It's a very unusual case John
SY get a lot of criticism on here and on other forums
Totally unfair imo
They have obviously found information that the pj didn't properly investigate
That's why they are there

Yet they are no further than the original investigation.


' 11 weeks to find Madeleine: Police have just under three months before £85,000 funding runs out

The Metropolitan Police's £85,000 funding for search runs out in September

Officers are still determined to find her and defended lack of visits to Portugal

Parents Kate and Gerry McCann have not given up and will 'overcome despair'


Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4702576/11-weeks-Madeleine-police-funding-runs-out.html#ixzz4n570yxtt
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook


I thought the McCann's financial resources were limited, and that is a result of their failed legal actions.

So when will they start searching.....................
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: John on July 17, 2017, 11:01:12 AM
It's a very unusual case John
SY get a lot of criticism on here and on other forums
Totally unfair imo
They have obviously found information that the pj didn't properly investigate
That's why they are there

Maybe if the prime suspects had stayed a little longer, been a little more obliging and were a little teeny weeny bit more cooperative then the original investigators may have been able to rule them out properly instead of this farce which has endured for ten years culminating in the Portuguese Supreme Court going to the trouble to state that they were never cleared.  What a mess!!

When your child disappears on holiday you cooperate fully with the investigating officers whether you love them or hate them...that is a simple logic understood by most people.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 11:10:06 AM
Maybe if the prime suspects had stayed a little longer, been a little more obliging and were a little teeny weeny bit more cooperative then the original investigators may have been able to rule them out properly instead of this farce which has endured for ten years culminating in the Portuguese Supreme Court going to the trouble to state that they were never cleared.  What a mess!!

When your child disappears on holiday you cooperate fully with the investigating officers whether you love them or hate them...that is a simple logic understood by most people.

Indeed.

The police were doing their job, and we know the abuse that Kate Mccann directed at them, from her book.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 11:11:40 AM
Indeed.

The police were doing their job, and we know the abuse that Kate Mccann directed at them, from her book.

Totally deserved imo
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 11:16:14 AM
Totally deserved imo

No, they were doing their job.

What it did reveal was Kate Mccann's true personality and her coarse use of English.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: carlymichelle on July 17, 2017, 11:17:05 AM
No, they were doing their job.

What it did reveal was Kate Mccann's true personality and her coarse use of English.

didnt she  abuse mrs fenn the same way?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 11:19:39 AM
No, they were doing their job.

What it did reveal was Kate Mccann's true personality and her coarse use of English.

Nothing wrong with Kate's personality or her use of English
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 17, 2017, 11:20:05 AM
'WE'RE FOCUSED AND DETERMINED' Maddie McCann cops insist search HASN’T ground to a halt… but admit they only have 11 weeks left to find her before their money runs out
Met Police say they are still confident of finding the missing girl 10 years after she went missing as a three-year-old in Praia da Luz, Portugal, with officers 'working on all leads'


Snip
Scotland Yard today took an unusual step of denying “a speculative non story” that the Maddie inquiry was grinding to a halt. A website claimed cops were struggling based purely on a Freedom of information request showing they had only make two flights to Portugal in the past year.

Flights reportedly cost £500 and £100 was spent on overnight expenses by senior investigating officer DCI Nicola Wall.

Speaking exclusively to The Sun Online, the SY spokesman said defiantly: “We should not have to explain or justify how many times we are going to Portugal. Whatever we do, and we are doing our very best, someone always wants to criticise the actions of the police regarding Madeleine McCann.

“If we make two trips people say that’s not enough. If we make more that’s seen as being too many so whatever we do we can’t win! But seriously if we need to be in Portugal, in particular Praia da Luz, for policing reasons we will be there immediately. But right now we are working here, in London, on material captured as a necessary and essential part of the inquiry.

“The investigation continues with focus and determination. It is not winding down, it is not grinding to a halt. It is on going.

“And as Assistant Commissioner Rowley said in April we want to solve it, we want a breakthrough.”

https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/4029785/maddie-mccann-cops-insist-search-hasnt-ground-to-a-halt-but-admit-they-only-have-11-weeks-left-to-find-her-before-their-money-runs-out/
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 17, 2017, 11:21:58 AM
I think everything you are saying is down to the incompetence of the original investigation
[1]They acted on their flawed understanding of the alerts and forensics ....they chose to ignore the advice from Harrison Grime and the FSS and thought they knew better
Amarals is stii doing this
Talking about proof of death in the apartment
[2]Absolute tosh

Point 2 is a fairly accurate summation of Point 1.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 11:24:04 AM
didnt she  abuse mrs fenn the same way?

Indeed she did Carly.

Mrs. Fenn merely offered her help.

At least Gerry Mccann had the good grace to apologize  for his wife's outburst.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 11:25:48 AM
'WE'RE FOCUSED AND DETERMINED' Maddie McCann cops insist search HASN’T ground to a halt… but admit they only have 11 weeks left to find her before their money runs out
Met Police say they are still confident of finding the missing girl 10 years after she went missing as a three-year-old in Praia da Luz, Portugal, with officers 'working on all leads'


Snip
Scotland Yard today took an unusual step of denying “a speculative non story” that the Maddie inquiry was grinding to a halt. A website claimed cops were struggling based purely on a Freedom of information request showing they had only make two flights to Portugal in the past year.

Flights reportedly cost £500 and £100 was spent on overnight expenses by senior investigating officer DCI Nicola Wall.

Speaking exclusively to The Sun Online, the SY spokesman said defiantly: “We should not have to explain or justify how many times we are going to Portugal. Whatever we do, and we are doing our very best, someone always wants to criticise the actions of the police regarding Madeleine McCann.

“If we make two trips people say that’s not enough. If we make more that’s seen as being too many so whatever we do we can’t win! But seriously if we need to be in Portugal, in particular Praia da Luz, for policing reasons we will be there immediately. But right now we are working here, in London, on material captured as a necessary and essential part of the inquiry.

“The investigation continues with focus and determination. It is not winding down, it is not grinding to a halt. It is on going.

“And as Assistant Commissioner Rowley said in April we want to solve it, we want a breakthrough.”

https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/4029785/maddie-mccann-cops-insist-search-hasnt-ground-to-a-halt-but-admit-they-only-have-11-weeks-left-to-find-her-before-their-money-runs-out/

Just typed cliches.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 17, 2017, 11:59:04 AM
Just typed cliches.

"Scotland Yard today took an unusual step of denying “a speculative non story” that the Maddie inquiry was grinding to a halt."
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/4029785/maddie-mccann-cops-insist-search-hasnt-ground-to-a-halt-but-admit-they-only-have-11-weeks-left-to-find-her-before-their-money-runs-out/

Nothing cliched as far as I can see.  Although I do find it extraordinary that it was deemed necessary for the official spokesperson for the body involved in the search for a missing girl have had to issue a denial of yet another " speculative non story".

So we have one organisation whose main concern is selling newspapers and another organisation whose main concern is finding Madeleine McCann.
I would think very seriously were I you about my attitude to one initiative as opposed to the other.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 12:01:59 PM
"Scotland Yard today took an unusual step of denying “a speculative non story” that the Maddie inquiry was grinding to a halt."
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/4029785/maddie-mccann-cops-insist-search-hasnt-ground-to-a-halt-but-admit-they-only-have-11-weeks-left-to-find-her-before-their-money-runs-out/

Nothing cliched as far as I can see.  Although I do find it extraordinary that it was deemed necessary for the official spokesperson for the body involved in the search for a missing girl have had to issue a denial of yet another " speculative non story".

So we have one organisation whose main concern is selling newspapers and another organisation whose main concern is finding Madeleine McCann.
I would think very seriously were I you about my attitude to one initiative as opposed to the other.

I have said quite clearly, that I see no resolution of the case.

I just see the same cliches typed out again and again.

Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 17, 2017, 12:09:49 PM
I have said quite clearly, that I see no resolution of the case.

I just see the same cliches typed out again and again.
That seems highly likely.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Benice on July 17, 2017, 12:12:37 PM
Nothing wrong with Kate's personality or her use of English

I don't swear (only because it never occurs to me to)  but even I thought she was very restrained in the circumstances.  I'm not sure whether I could have stopped myself from saying it out loud so that they - especially Ricardo Paivo - could actually hear my opinion.

I don't suppose we shall ever know if the claim that it turned out to be a 'prophetic' comment was ever proved one way or the other.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: John on July 17, 2017, 12:15:15 PM
I think everything you are saying is down to the incompetence of the original investigation
They acted on their flawed understanding of the alerts and forensics ....they chose to ignore the advice from Harrison Grime and the FSS and thought they knew better
Amarals is stii doing this
Talking about proof of death in the apartment
Absolute tosh

The bottom line is that Amaral was there, none of us were.  As a police officer you tend to notice things in any investigation which aren't just quite right.  He has espoused several theories based on that knowledge and that is his right, the dog alerts and forensics are but a tiny piece of the puzzle.  Amaral could be right or then again he might be completely mistaken, only time will tell hopefully.

As SY have failed to find anyone or anything of real significance to the case we might be in for a very long wait.  I suspect only one person knows what happened to Madeleine McCann and he will probably take that secret to his grave.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 17, 2017, 12:15:35 PM
I have said quite clearly, that I see no resolution of the case.

I just see the same cliches typed out again and again.

Then thank God you chose science as a career and not policing because I don't think you would ever have been very good at the latter.

What exactly did you consider a cliche in the information the official police spokesperson was authorised to impart?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 17, 2017, 12:19:22 PM
The bottom line is that Amaral was there, none of us were.  As a police officer you tend to notice things in any investigation which aren't just quite right.  He has espoused several theories based on that knowledge and that is his right, the dog alerts and forensics are but a tiny piece of the puzzle.  Amaral could be right or then again he might be completely mistaken, only time will tell hopefully.

I prefer my police officers to be motivated by the available evidence.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: John on July 17, 2017, 12:25:27 PM
I prefer my police officers to be motivated by the available evidence.

I totally agree.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 12:32:04 PM
Then thank God you chose science as a career and not policing because I don't think you would ever have been very good at the latter.

What exactly did you consider a cliche in the information the official police spokesperson was authorised to impart?

Repetition of the same statements.

As to the first sentence, I would certainly place you in the bracket. You appear to show unwavering support of the mccanns, knowing full well, the crime if any, has not been determined, and no one has been charged.

You see in science, you need evidence to back up a theory........

I have said, there is b....r all in this case.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 17, 2017, 12:40:18 PM
Investigators denied claims the search had reached a stalemate following reports only two trips to Portugal have been made in the past year.

Detectives, who said they do not have to be in Portugal to conduct their investigation, added they are in possession of significant material gathered during previous trips.

"A lot of potentially significant images and material were captured on previous trips to Portugal and we are still working on all leads,"a Met Police spokesperson told The Sun.
http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/madeleine-mccann-discovery-funds-will-run-out-september-1630602


If by September the police are still claiming to be following leads in Madeleine McCann's case ... the home secretary is going to be presented with the choice to set the precedent of closing down an active investigation into the case of a missing child or allowing it to be taken to conclusion by awarding more funding.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: John on July 17, 2017, 01:34:07 PM
Investigators denied claims the search had reached a stalemate following reports only two trips to Portugal have been made in the past year.

Detectives, who said they do not have to be in Portugal to conduct their investigation, added they are in possession of significant material gathered during previous trips.

"A lot of potentially significant images and material were captured on previous trips to Portugal and we are still working on all leads,"a Met Police spokesperson told The Sun.
http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/madeleine-mccann-discovery-funds-will-run-out-september-1630602


If by September the police are still claiming to be following leads in Madeleine McCann's case ... the home secretary is going to be presented with the choice to set the precedent of closing down an active investigation into the case of a missing child or allowing it to be taken to conclusion by awarding more funding.

Throwing more money at an investigation which has a very narrow brief is a waste of time.  If Walls and SY were doing their job properly they would be investigating the Metodo 3 debacle and all who were involved in it.  At the end of the day this conspiracy to pervert the course of justice might be the only way that charges can be brought against anyone.

Madeleine might never be found but there are living identifiable persons who should be prosecuted for their unsavoury criminal conduct following the disappearance.  There is a mountain of evidence against these individuals and I for one want to see them prosecuted and prosecuted in Portugal.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 02:02:12 PM
Throwing more money at an investigation which has a very narrow brief is a waste of time.  If Walls and SY were doing their job properly they would be investigating the Metodo 3 debacle and all who were involved in it.  At the end of the day this conspiracy to pervert the course of justice might be the only way that charges can be brought against anyone.

Madeleine might never be found but there are living identifiable persons who should be prosecuted for their unsavoury criminal conduct following the disappearance.  There is a mountain of evidence against these individuals and I for one want to see them prosecuted and prosecuted in Portugal.

If there was an attempt to pervert the course if justice then that's the job of Portugal to investigate
What are they doing about it
I'm not sure there was any such attempt
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Angelo222 on July 17, 2017, 02:30:21 PM
If there was an attempt to pervert the course if justice then that's the job of Portugal to investigate
What are they doing about it
I'm not sure there was any such attempt

Reading between the lines I gather they don't want to rock the boat while the other investigation is live.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 02:39:44 PM
Reading between the lines I gather they don't want to rock the boat while the other investigation is live.

Reading between what lines
Is it just what you think maybe happening
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Angelo222 on July 17, 2017, 02:48:58 PM
Reading between what lines
Is it just what you think maybe happening

The same lines tell me that Amaral is also waiting on the sidelines to pounce.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 03:17:40 PM
The same lines tell me that Amaral is also waiting on the sidelines to pounce.

Sorry but I think it's all in your imagination
Amarals has already tried to sue Correia and amarals lost
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Angelo222 on July 17, 2017, 03:48:11 PM
Sorry but I think it's all in your imagination
Amarals has already tried to sue Correia and amarals lost

Suing Correia for defamation has nothing to do with his activities on behalf of Metodo.  The only reason Amaral failed in his attempt to sue Correia was because he was convicted at trial.

As for the subject of this thread the SY investigation is being wrapped up right now so any official search has long since ceased.  Time for the McCanns to do what they should have done ten years ago instead of scuttling back to Blighty and that is get off their feckin tosser backsides and go help Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum search.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 04:01:40 PM
Suing Correia for defamation has nothing to do with his activities on behalf of Metodo.  The only reason Amaral failed in his attempt to sue Correia was because he was convicted at trial.

As for the subject of this thread the SY investigation is being wrapped up right now so any official search has long since ceased.  Time for the McCanns to do what they should have done ten years ago instead of scuttling back to Blighty and that is get off their feck in tosser backsides and go search.
I think that is ridiculous but everyone to their own
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 17, 2017, 04:05:04 PM
It's a very unusual case John
SY get a lot of criticism on here and on other forums
Totally unfair imo
They have obviously found information that the pj didn't properly investigate
That's why they are there
What, pray tell, is this obviously found information?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 04:08:51 PM
What, pray tell, is this obviously found information?

Information in the files
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 17, 2017, 04:15:03 PM
Information in the files
Care to expand on this?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: jassi on July 17, 2017, 04:20:15 PM
None of this 'improperly investigated information' seems to have led anywhere, so perhaps it didn't need investigating in the first place.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 04:21:07 PM
Care to expand on this?

No need to
SY reviewed the files and found points that had not been followed through
Like the phone traffic j
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 04:22:48 PM
None of this 'improperly investigated information' seems to have led anywhere, so perhaps it didn't need investigating in the first place.

Yes I suppose that's why the pj didn't bother to investigate it
They probably do it a lot
Why bother
Probably won't lead anywhere
The fact is that sometimes it does and that's why it has to be followed up
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: jassi on July 17, 2017, 04:23:56 PM
No need to
SY reviewed the files and found points that had not been followed through
Like the phone traffic j

Has that led anywhere ?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: jassi on July 17, 2017, 04:31:41 PM
Yes I suppose that's why the pj didn't bother to investigate it
They probably do it a lot
Why bother
Probably won't lead anywhere
The fact is that sometimes it does and that's why it has to be followed up

Maybe they realised it was a non-starter from the begining.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: barrier on July 17, 2017, 04:40:48 PM
Has that led anywhere ?

Cul-de-sac?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 17, 2017, 04:44:45 PM
No need to
SY reviewed the files and found points that had not been followed through
Like the phone traffic j
£11 million to check out people in Luz making phone calls to people in Luz?

Did they check out Gerry making calls to Kate?  No?

So a bit of non-substantiated PJ-slagging then.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: jassi on July 17, 2017, 04:48:13 PM
Sounds like an £11 million  box ticking exercise to me.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 04:49:09 PM
£11 million to check out people in Luz making phone calls to people in Luz?

Did they check out Gerry making calls to Kate?  No?

So a bit of non-substantiated PJ-slagging then.

It seems, unfortunately, par for the course.

I dare say the PJ will  be blamed when the case is shelved again.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: jassi on July 17, 2017, 04:53:04 PM
It seems, unfortunately, par for the course.

I dare say the PJ will  be blamed when the case is shelved again.

As none of these leads have led anywhere,  the PJ not investigating them can't have harmed the 'search'  IMO
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 04:54:45 PM
As none of these leads have led anywhere,  the PJ not investigating them can't have harmed the 'search'  IMO

I agree, but we will still see the blame game.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: barrier on July 17, 2017, 05:33:11 PM
I agree, but we will still see the blame game.

The updated version in the Mail has this to say.

Quote
Scotland Yard is chasing a critical lead it believes could crack the case and it is understood they have returned to a theory that burglars were involved

But the Portuguese police, who have previously accused the British of acting like a 'colonial power' in their country, say there is no evidence to back this up. 
Carlos Anjos, the former head of the country's Policia Judiciaria officers' union, said the Metropolitan Police's theory that Madeleine was taken in a botched burglary is 'absurd'. 


Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4702576/11-weeks-Madeleine-police-funding-runs-out.html#ixzz4n6iXxUbk
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 05:54:34 PM
The updated version in the Mail has this to say.


Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4702576/11-weeks-Madeleine-police-funding-runs-out.html#ixzz4n6iXxUbk

The funding runs out then and a decision will be made as to further funding
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 17, 2017, 06:14:36 PM
That's not what I said
I said I know why it's cost so much as will anyone who has followed the case
I dare say there will be people in SY and the Home Office who know "exactly why it cost £11 million".

The idea that you do is unbelievable, in the literal sense.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 17, 2017, 06:17:10 PM
Cul-de-sac?

More like cul-de-canard, je pense  ?{)(**
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 06:39:34 PM
I dare say there will be people in SY and the Home Office who know "exactly why it cost £11 million".

The idea that you do is unbelievable, in the literal sense.

But I do
Don't you know why it has cost so much
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 17, 2017, 06:50:46 PM
But I do
Don't you know why it has cost so much
You have been invited to explain.

You have declined to explain.

What remains is your unsubstantiated, unbelievable claim.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 06:56:38 PM
You have been invited to explain.

You have declined to explain.

What remains is your unsubstantiated, unbelievable claim.

Was it 50,000 statements ...pieces of evidence
Each one professionally translated
Then assessed for value
An incredible job
Unheard of before
Totally unique
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: jassi on July 17, 2017, 07:04:11 PM
Pity it has delivered so little.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:08:29 PM
Was it 50,000 statements ...pieces of evidence
Each one professionally translated
Then assessed for value
An incredible job
Unheard of before
Totally unique


That is pure supposition.

Who translated the documents and where was it done ?

Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:08:47 PM
Pity it has delivered so little.

A great pity but let's wait and see
Strange no one questions the costs of the jersey investigation which also found nothing
Where one man and his dog was paid 150000 and only found a coconut
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 17, 2017, 07:09:01 PM
Was it 50,000 statements ...pieces of evidence
Each one professionally translated
Then assessed for value
An incredible job
Unheard of before
Totally unique
Pull the other one.

Kate says a first task was to have all the statements professionally translated, at a cost of nearly £100,000.

Even if Kate was mean enough to withhold her translated version from OG, you are still £10.9 million short.

Unbelievable.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:16:49 PM
A great pity but let's wait and see
Strange no one questions the costs of the jersey investigation which also found nothing
Where one man and his dog was paid 150000 and only found a coconut

It was deemed to be probably coconut, but not 100%.

Let's not forget either secondary transfer.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: jassi on July 17, 2017, 07:18:14 PM
A great pity but let's wait and see
Strange no one questions the costs of the jersey investigation which also found nothing
Where one man and his dog was paid 150000 and only found a coconut

Perhaps that's because this is a thread about Madeleine McCann and you know how we're not to supposed  go off topic. 
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:21:35 PM
Perhaps that's because this is a thread about Madeleine McCann and you know how we're not to supposed  go off topic.

The thread has constantly discussed the cost...
How can you judge the cost without comparison to other investigations
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:23:48 PM
The thread has constantly discussed the cost...
How can you judge the cost without comparison to other investigations

You judge the cost on what it has achieved.

Which is ...............
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:24:54 PM
Pull the other one.

Kate says a first task was to have all the statements professionally translated, at a cost of nearly £100,000.

Even if Kate was mean enough to withhold her translated version from OG, you are still £10.9 million short.

Unbelievable.

Grange could not use Kate's translation for obvious reasons
This isn't my explanation it's from a senior policeman making a public statement on the issue
The sheer volume of evidence is what has caused the cost
Ignore the truth if you wish
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:25:37 PM
You judge the cost on what it has achieved.

Which is ...............

No you don't
That is a ridiculous statement

Someone who knows the cost of everything band the value of nothing
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:26:24 PM
Grange could not use Kate's translation for obvious reasons
This isn't my explanation it's from a senior policeman making a public statement on the issue
The sheer volume of evidence is what has caused the cost
Ignore the truth if you wish

Then cite what the senior police man said.

Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: slartibartfast on July 17, 2017, 07:26:57 PM
Grange could not use Kate's translation for obvious reasons
This isn't my explanation it's from a senior policeman making a public statement on the issue
The sheer volume of evidence is what has caused the cost
Ignore the truth if you wish

Please provide the cite.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:28:31 PM
Then cite what the senior police man said.

It was on a radio show...one of your London ones if I recall
He explained the enormous cost of translation and assessing the evidence when so much evidence is involved
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:29:36 PM
Please provide the cite.

Am I the only person who is aware of this
That's incredible
I'm on my phone at the moment
Will look later
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:30:07 PM
It was on a radio show...one of your London ones if I recall
He explained the enormous cost of translation and assessing the evidence when so much evidence is involved

You made the claim and can't provide a cite.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:32:53 PM
Am I the only person who is aware of this
That's incredible
I'm on my phone at the moment
Will look later

We will wait for that.

Translation costs are easily found.

It also depends whether  a person or persons provided their services free of charge.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:34:32 PM
You made the claim and can't provide a cite.

The claim is supported by logical reasoning
I can't provide a cite at the moment as I'm on my phone
It really is quite obvious the amount of evidence in the files would take a considerable amount of man hours to translate and process
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:35:46 PM
The claim is supported by logical reasoning
I can't provide a cite at the moment as I'm on my phone
It really is quite obvious the amount of evidence in the files would take a considerable amount of man hours to translate and process

... and if a person or persons did it voluntarily........................
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:36:08 PM
We will wait for that.

Translation costs are easily found.

It also depends whether  a person or persons provided their services free of charge.

Do you have any experience of legal translation costs
I do
In these circumstances no one provides their services for free
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:37:39 PM
... and if a person or persons did it voluntarily........................
The police would have to use a professional accredited service
They charge
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:38:35 PM
Do you have any experience of legal translation costs
I do
In these circumstances no one provides their services for free

Yes I do.

Well, we will await for you to justify your claims later.

Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:39:56 PM
The police would have to use a professional accredited service
They charge

Does OG have in the team anyone who speaks Portuguese ?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:40:46 PM
Yes I do.

Well, we will await for you to justify your claims later.

So how much did you pay for your translation
Cite
I know how much I paid for mine
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: barrier on July 17, 2017, 07:42:13 PM
Grange could not use Kate's translation for obvious reasons
This isn't my explanation it's from a senior policeman making a public statement on the issue
The sheer volume of evidence is what has caused the cost
Ignore the truth if you wish

Hogan Howe is whom you refer to,he never explained the cost,only explaining what do 30 ofiicers do all day when asked,lets not forget the landscaping,all them officers to be hostelled none of which is cheap.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:44:30 PM
Hogan Howe is whom you refer to,he never explained the cost,only explaining what do 30 ofiicers do all day when asked,lets not forget the landscaping,all them officers to be hostelled none of which is cheap.

It wasn't HH
It was a London radio show
It makes perfect sense
He said the cost was due to the sheer volume of evidence that had to be assessed
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:46:29 PM
So how much did you pay for your translation
Cite
I know how much I paid for mine


One of my staff did the translation davel, as part of her job.

Now, we await your cite.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: barrier on July 17, 2017, 07:47:51 PM
It wasn't HH
It was a London radio show
It makes perfect sense
He said the cost was due to the sheer volume of evidence that had to be assessed

It was HH on LBC.In this case youtube is your friend.No mention of cost's only the amount of police time.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:49:01 PM

One of my staff did the translation davel, as part of her job.

Now, we await your cite.

So she didn't do it free
She was paid for her time
Was she accredited by the court
I had 5 pages translated and it cost £800
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:49:47 PM
It was HH on LBC.In this case youtube is your friend.No mention of cost's only the amount of police time.

Was it
Thanks for your help
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:50:49 PM
So she didn't do it free
She was paid for her time
Was she accredited by the court
I had 5 pages translated and it cost £800

No need, she is German and fluent in four languages.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:52:33 PM
Was it
Thanks for your help

So davel, no mention of costs then.

By the way, on which program did you hear it   ?

I listen to LBC everyday.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:52:38 PM
No need, she is German and fluent in four languages.
As far as I know for court documents that would not be acceptable
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 17, 2017, 07:52:59 PM
Grange could not use Kate's translation for obvious reasons
This isn't my explanation it's from a senior policeman making a public statement on the issue
The sheer volume of evidence is what has caused the cost
Ignore the truth if you wish
I won't bother going forward on this one.

It became clear several posts back that you could not support your unbelievable assertion.  8((()*/
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:54:00 PM
So davel, no mention of costs then.

By the way, on which program did you hear it   ?

I listen to LBC everyday.
Then you must have heard it
He explained why the investigation had cost so much but did not give a breakdown
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 07:54:41 PM
I won't bother going forward on this one.

It became clear several posts back that you could not support your unbelievable assertion.  8((()*/
Hogan Howe on LBC
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 07:58:52 PM
Hogan Howe on LBC

Hogan Howe is not a program host davel.

He has been interviewed several times on there, so perhaps you can be more specific.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 08:00:25 PM
Hogan Howe is not a program host davel.

He has been interviewed several times on there, so perhaps you can be more specific.
You have just stated Hogan Howe did not have a clue
That is libellous
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: barrier on July 17, 2017, 08:04:52 PM
April 2016,transcript with thanks to Joanna Morais.

Quote
Unknown caller - Hi, hi, good morning, my question is regarding to Madeleine McCann...

Nick Ferrari (host) - Oh yes.

Unknown caller - ...what chances can we find this girl?

Nick Ferrari - This is I think another additional 95,000 pounds that has been earmarked by the Home Office, I think, for Scotland Yard Sir Bernard, and that would mean around six months the investigations can continue.

Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe - Yeah, Michael (the caller) as you know there's been a lot of investigation time spent on this is, it's a terrible case isn't it, it's a child who went missing and everybody wants to know if she is alive if she is, where is she, and if suddenly she is dead then we need to give some comfort to the family, so it needed us to carry out an investigation together with the Portuguese and other countries have been involved and there is a line of inquiry that remains to be concluded and it's expected in the coming months that will happen. The size of the teams came down radically, I think we're now down to two or three people in that team, at one stage was about 30 officers in it, ahm, essentially it's a Portuguese inquiry...

Nick Ferrari - What do thirty people do all day Commissioner?

Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe - Well, the first steps they had to do was to actually review and look at all the things the Portuguese had done, to see whether or not there was anything we could offer that, you know, might help with that investigation, had they missed anything, now we do that for ourselves and the Portuguese review. So we thought, well, we were asked by the Prime Minister before I arrived, to see whether or not there was anything we could do to help that investigation. Our review...

Nick Ferrari - It takes thirty officers?!



Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe - Well, err, yep, but just bear in mind what happened there, so you got thousands of pages, I went in to one of our police stations back in 2011 and there was a whole room full of documents that this inquiry had produced, you know, from the hundreds of witnesses statements, to all every card they checked out, from all, you know, these inquiries for those who don't get involved in them don't realize just what they generate, huge amounts of material, and of course, these all have to be translated.

Nick Ferrari - Yes.

Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe - This didn't start out in English.

Nick Ferrari - Sure.

Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe - They were translated into English.

Nick Ferrari - Have you moved forward in any way?

Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe - I, well, that's what I'm indicating, is that first of all we had to extinguish the possibilities that existed in terms of inquiry, I think some of those have been stopped and there is a line of inquiry I think is, well, everybody agrees, is worthwhile pursuing.

Nick Ferrari - How long will this go on? When will you finally be prepared to stand down operation, I think it's Operation Grange, isn't it?

Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe - Well, really at the moment it will be the conclusion of this line of inquiry, unless something else comes up.

Nick Ferrari - So, you'd spend more money, again? Another 95,000 pound?

Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe - Well, if somebody comes to me, if somebody comes forward and gives good evidence we'll follow it.

Nick Ferrari - Yes.

Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe - We always say that, ahm, you know, a missing child inquiry is never closed.

Nick Ferrari - Yes, but there are a hundred eighty-seven missing children in Britain, not all fortunately of the circumstances of Madeleine McCann. How come this one attracts so much attention and indeed funding?

Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe - Well, of course, you know, this was a decision of the government, that in this case they wanted to fund the Metropolitan Police to make this inquiry. If you remember, of course, this poor girl came from Leicestershire area, and was obviously aboard in Portugal at the time. So, we went, the Home Office, the government asked the Met to get involved and we have done our best as anybody humanly can, to try and find this girl, and that's surely the thing that drives us all. Newspapers have got involved, private investigators got involved..

Nick Ferrari - So, you don't see any standing down in the near future of Operation Grange?

Sir Bernard Hogan-Howe - Well, I thought it was clear(?), which is first of all, the line of inquiry that is being pursued, that obviously is important, it's important in the coming months that is resolved and I think it will be, if something new comes forward of course we'll investigate it, but that line of inquiry probably is, at the moment, is the conclusion of this inquiry.

Video from you tube.


https://youtu.be/n9vJm03dlI8
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 08:11:17 PM
You have just stated Hogan Howe did not have a clue
That is libellous


In what way ?

if he doesn't know the cost, which he clearly didn't.

I hope davel, you are not trying to disrupt this thread.

Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 17, 2017, 08:14:46 PM
April 2016,transcript with thanks to Joanna Morais.

Video from you tube.


https://youtu.be/n9vJm03dlI8
So basically, this alleged clarification re costs is what normal people generally call waffle.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 08:21:48 PM
So basically, this alleged clarification re costs is what normal people generally call waffle.
If you want to ignore reality it's up to you
As HH pointed out there was a massive amount of information to translate and analyse
That is a concise statement and no sensible person would describe that as waffle
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: barrier on July 17, 2017, 08:22:31 PM
So basically, this alleged clarification re costs is what normal people generally call waffle.

He wasn't asked about general cost's only the then £95,000 for the next six months,thread title ground to a halt? well we know the cost came down to £85,000 for the six months from this April.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 08:23:51 PM
He wasn't asked about general cost's only the then £95,000 for the next six months,thread title ground to a halt? well we know the cost came down to £85,000 for the six months from this April.

I think it's probably a different episode then
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 08:28:24 PM
I think it's probably a different episode then

Episode davel.

It was on a phone-in program.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: barrier on July 17, 2017, 08:30:12 PM
I think it's probably a different episode then

Nope a search doesn't bring up any thing regarding the justification of the overall cost of OG,that will only be explained I would think by the HO who are funding it.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 08:32:49 PM
Episode davel.

It was on a phone-in program.

I understand
Not an unreasonable word to use in the circumstances
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 17, 2017, 09:40:54 PM
If you want to ignore reality it's up to you
As HH pointed out there was a massive amount of information to translate and analyse
That is a concise statement and no sensible person would describe that as waffle
No sensible person would claim to know "exactly why it cost £11 million".  Then compound it by using BHH as the source of this 'expertise'.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 09:46:19 PM
No sensible person would claim to know "exactly why it cost £11 million".  Then compound it by using BHH as the source of this 'expertise'.
I know exactly why it cost so much
Because of the incredible amount of data to be translated and collated
It just makes so much sense and is true
Sour grapes on your behalf methinks

Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 17, 2017, 09:51:37 PM
I know exactly why it cost so much
Because of the incredible amount of data to be translated and collated
It just makes so much sense and is true
Sour grapes on your behalf methinks
So how did Kate do it for £100,000 and some midnight oil?

£10.9 million unaccounted for.  Whatever 'youthinks'.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 17, 2017, 10:05:11 PM
So how did Kate do it for £100,000 and some midnight oil?

£10.9 million unaccounted for.  Whatever 'youthinks'.
Kate did the translation only
SY had the expense of analysis and correlating all the information

SY had files that had not been released

Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 17, 2017, 10:22:35 PM
Kate did the translation only
SY had the expense of analysis and correlating all the information

SY had files that had not been released

Surely you mean collating  the data ?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: G-Unit on July 17, 2017, 10:37:25 PM
So how did Kate do it for £100,000 and some midnight oil?

£10.9 million unaccounted for.  Whatever 'youthinks'.

Agency costs;

In 2011 £ 100,000 on G4S staff
In 2012 £   60,000
In 2013 £   55,000
In 2014 £   58,000
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/scotland-yard-used-ex-police-7112764

2014;
57 flights to Portugal £16,000

The bulk of the costs is said to come from salaries, overtime and property expenses.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/11838484/Met-Police-hunt-for-Madeleiene-McCann-costs-11-million.html

Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 17, 2017, 11:09:00 PM
Agency costs;

In 2011 £ 100,000 on G4S staff
In 2012 £   60,000
In 2013 £   55,000
In 2014 £   58,000
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/scotland-yard-used-ex-police-7112764

2014;
57 flights to Portugal £16,000

The bulk of the costs is said to come from salaries, overtime and property expenses.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/11838484/Met-Police-hunt-for-Madeleiene-McCann-costs-11-million.html
To be honest, I have never been interested in a detailed breakdown as to where the dosh went.  The only figure that would get my genuine interest is how much was spent on the 'sun tans in Luz' trip in June 2014.  The bill must have been eye-watering to investigate and rule out those 41 anomalies.

I was simply pointing out to a fellow forum member that to claim a detailed understanding of where the money has gone is tosh.

I find it reassuring from the FOI request that DCI Nicola Wall can apparently 'sneak' in and out of Portugal without the DCI Andy Redwood media fanfare.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 17, 2017, 11:38:33 PM
To be honest, I have never been interested in a detailed breakdown as to where the dosh went.  The only figure that would get my genuine interest is how much was spent on the 'sun tans in Luz' trip in June 2014.  The bill must have been eye-watering to investigate and rule out those 41 anomalies.

I was simply pointing out to a fellow forum member that to claim a detailed understanding of where the money has gone is tosh.

I find it reassuring from the FOI request that DCI Nicola Wall can apparently 'sneak' in and out of Portugal without the DCI Andy Redwood media fanfare.

Pretty much I would say although in general terms all you need know about costs is they come in through your front door on two legs and if you want to cut costs start by heaving out bodies...... 8(>((
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 18, 2017, 07:42:43 AM

Are we wandering a bit Off Topic here?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 18, 2017, 07:46:46 AM
Are we wandering a bit Off Topic here?
Only vastly.  So much less than normal.   8((()*/
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 18, 2017, 07:48:28 AM
Only vastly.  So much less than normal.   8((()*/

That's what I thought.

Perhaps we could try to stick to The Topic.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 18, 2017, 08:04:49 AM
To be honest, I have never been interested in a detailed breakdown as to where the dosh went.  The only figure that would get my genuine interest is how much was spent on the 'sun tans in Luz' trip in June 2014.  The bill must have been eye-watering to investigate and rule out those 41 anomalies.

I was simply pointing out to a fellow forum member that to claim a detailed understanding of where the money has gone is tosh.

I find it reassuring from the FOI request that DCI Nicola Wall can apparently 'sneak' in and out of Portugal without the DCI Andy Redwood media fanfare.

It is a fact
Not tosh
That the reason this investigation had cost so much is the incredibly large amount of information that has had to be translated and processed
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 18, 2017, 08:06:06 AM
It is a fact
Not tosh
That the reason this investigation had cost so much is the incredibly large amount of information that has had to be translated and processed

Then prove it.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 18, 2017, 08:08:00 AM
Then prove it.

It is obvious Stephen
You just need to think about it
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 18, 2017, 08:11:19 AM
It is obvious Stephen
You just need to think about it

You've made the statement.

Time to back it up.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 18, 2017, 08:31:08 AM
You've made the statement.

Time to back it up.

40,000 documents to translate and assess..
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 18, 2017, 08:33:41 AM
40,000 documents to translate and assess..

Salaries for 30 Officers for quite some time.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 18, 2017, 08:37:20 AM
40,000 documents to translate and assess..

I thought it was 50,000 last night.

SIL gave you an example last night of costing.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 18, 2017, 08:38:36 AM
I thought it was 50,000 last night.

SIL gave you an example last night of costing.

is sil an expert on costings...i dont see any breakdown of costs from sil...you must be mistaken
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 18, 2017, 08:43:07 AM
is sil an expert on costings...i dont see any breakdown of costs from sil...you must be mistaken

You are diverting.

You ask for cites from others, now do the courtesy of doing so yourself.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 18, 2017, 08:44:10 AM
I agree with Eleanor.

This is going off topic and is leading to arguments.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 18, 2017, 08:45:14 AM
Has it crossed anyone's mind that Operation Grange won't be half inching the money?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 18, 2017, 08:48:33 AM
I agree with Eleanor.

This is going off topic and is leading to arguments.

Thank you, Stephen.  This is what generally happens when Threads go Off Topic.

However, there is some quite interesting stuff that John may wish to divert elsewhere.

Meanwhile, Back On Topic.  Merci Beaucoup.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: jassi on July 18, 2017, 08:51:43 AM
Just for clarification, does the £12 mil include the review period or  is it just for the post-review investigation ?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 18, 2017, 09:06:06 AM
Thank you, Stephen.  This is what generally happens when Threads go Off Topic.

However, there is some quite interesting stuff that John may wish to divert elsewhere.

Meanwhile, Back On Topic.  Merci Beaucoup.

Indeed Eleanor.

Perhaps someone can start a thread to discuss  the spending of resources by OG, but the only trouble is, there is no official breakdown of costs.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 18, 2017, 12:05:46 PM
Indeed Eleanor.

Perhaps someone can start a thread to discuss  the spending of resources by OG, but the only trouble is, there is no official breakdown of costs.
That should be fun.
We could start with a high level breakdown into say:
1 Salaries plus Overhead.
2 Travel and accommodation.
3 Bought Outs [in this case I can only see translation costs being a significant sum].
4 Contingency [Things we haven't thought of but say ten percent of what we have thought of in value].
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 18, 2017, 03:18:34 PM
The news is that the search for Madeleine McCann has not ground to a halt.

In April of this year the Home Office granted Operation Grange another £85,000 to keep the investigation going; think about it folks ~ were I considering adding an extension to the house, if I was very careful I could probably manage it for that ~ in London would it even pay for an architect's drawing?

The additional funding was not only welcome but had been justified by the investigation who were following active case leads.

Apart from the fact that £85,000 is hardly likely to bring the country to it's knees it is a very modest amount in terms of a budget to keep an active police investigation going.
Particularly if the police are investigation what they believe is important information in the search for a missing child.

No wonder Nicola Wall is using technology to cut down on air fares and accommodation costs ... but in my opinion the fact that she has visited twice this year indicates that very important business regarding Madeleine's case was on her agenda and that of her counterpart in Portugal; requiring eyeball to eyeball discussion.

Can anyone offer an explanation that now there is assurance that the inquiry into Madeleine's case still has avenues for progression to be made that yet again, the cost appears to be an issue?

The question put to Kate about which such angst has been raised could, in the circumstances, well be rephrased ...
Question:
Are you aware that you are jeopardising the investigation, which seeks to discover what happened to Madeleine McCann?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 18, 2017, 07:22:35 PM
That should be fun.
We could start with a high level breakdown into say:
1 Salaries plus Overhead.
2 Travel and accommodation.
3 Bought Outs [in this case I can only see translation costs being a significant sum].
4 Contingency [Things we haven't thought of but say ten percent of what we have thought of in value].

What a very good idea.  That should keep us going for a minute or ten.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: sadie on July 19, 2017, 12:35:18 AM
Has it crossed anyone's mind that Operation Grange won't be half inching the money?
No brown paper envelopes there, I supect!
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: sadie on July 19, 2017, 12:41:58 AM
Then prove it.
No need, it is obvious
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 19, 2017, 01:27:40 AM
No brown paper envelopes there, I supect! *&*%£

Of course not, Sadie.  Operation Grange would have to be entirely mad to be stealing money from the investigation, or even to be diverting it.

And as for a couple of jollies to The Algarve.  Please don't be ridiculous.  The suggestion is stupid, and only serves to prove how very silly the sceptics are.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Angelo222 on July 19, 2017, 10:30:03 AM
To be honest, I have never been interested in a detailed breakdown as to where the dosh went.  The only figure that would get my genuine interest is how much was spent on the 'sun tans in Luz' trip in June 2014.  The bill must have been eye-watering to investigate and rule out those 41 anomalies.

I was simply pointing out to a fellow forum member that to claim a detailed understanding of where the money has gone is tosh.

I find it reassuring from the FOI request that DCI Nicola Wall can apparently 'sneak' in and out of Portugal without the DCI Andy Redwood media fanfare.

I too have wondered at that, not a single leak from PJ HQ that SY were in town.  Could it be that DCI Walls went there secretly and only the most senior officers at police HQ were aware of it?  I fail to see how a cosy chat over a coffee could ever achieve anything except a bon accord in international relations.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: G-Unit on July 19, 2017, 10:50:19 AM
I too have wondered at that, not a single leak from PJ HQ that SY were in town.  Could it be that DCI Walls went there secretly and only the most senior officers at police HQ were aware of it?  I fail to see how a cosy chat over a coffee could ever achieve anything except a bon accord in international relations.

Perhaps she was summoned? The case is a Portuguese case after all.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 19, 2017, 10:59:38 AM
Now we have this...................

' Met Police asks retired detectives to return amid staffing crisis

Hundreds of retired detectives are being asked whether they would come back to work, as Scotland Yard faces a staffing crisis. '

http://news.sky.com/story/met-police-asks-retired-detectives-to-return-amid-staffing-crisis-10953026

It has however, being going on for years in the UK.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1238876/One-police-officers-return-work-picking-lucrative-golden-handshakes.html
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Angelo222 on July 19, 2017, 11:30:10 AM
Has anyone ever asked how much is the UK taxpayer paying Portugal to continue the Maddie enquiry?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 19, 2017, 11:42:05 AM
Has anyone ever asked how much is the UK taxpayer paying Portugal to continue the Maddie enquiry?

What makes you think the UK is paying Portugal
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 19, 2017, 06:29:18 PM
What makes you think the UK is paying Portugal
The question can still be asked.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 28, 2017, 08:46:48 PM
Time is running out though... the clock is ticking and there doesn't seem to be the same' rent a sympathy mob' tweeting and tooting about the parents of Maddie. Speaking of who, they are no where near finding her as they have not been 'looking' for her, just reading over old notes and statements in an attempt to tell somebody something, whether that something is  important or not is anyones guess.

But for my money I am looking for  'we just don't know what happened'. or This is what happened- providing evidence. I don't want to hear what they believe happened either. make- believe does not make great evidence. And one theory is no more plausble or believable in another one.

One thing is certain little Maddie has been let down by the parents, the Tapas, the PJ, the SY, The journos, the media and the lawyers working for the parents. ALL are guilty of her continued demise/suffering.

All made money from her situation and in my opinion that is dispicable and deplorable.

Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: misty on July 28, 2017, 08:51:22 PM
Time is running out though... the clock is ticking and there doesn't seem to be the same' rent a sympathy mob' tweeting and tooting about the parents of Maddie. Speaking of who, they are no where near finding her as they have not been 'looking' for her, just reading over old notes and statements in an attempt to tell somebody something, whether that something is  important or not is anyones guess.

But for my money I am looking for  'we just don't know what happened'. or This is what happened- providing evidence. I don't want to hear what they believe happened either. make- believe does not make great evidence. And one theory is no more plausble or believable in another one.

One thing is certain little Maddie has been let down by the parents, the Tapas, the PJ, the SY, The journos, the media and the lawyers working for the parents. ALL are guilty of her continued demise/suffering.

All made money from her situation and in my opinion that is dispicable and deplorable.

Would you rather all those you consider to have let Madeleine down had done nothing at all?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 28, 2017, 08:52:36 PM
Would you rather all those you consider to have let Madeleine down had done nothing at all?

So, let's have a complete list.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: misty on July 28, 2017, 08:58:31 PM
So, let's have a complete list.

Miss Taken has provided a list.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 28, 2017, 08:58:59 PM
Would you rather all those you consider to have let Madeleine down had done nothing at all?

 The behaviour of those I have mentioned should have done nothing because what they did achieve was the same as doing nothing = nothing,
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on July 28, 2017, 09:01:17 PM
Miss Taken has provided a list.

So you agree on the list ?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: misty on July 28, 2017, 09:11:07 PM
Are you being serious? This site is a protect the parents site just in case you missed that misty. The behaviour of those I have mentioned should have done nothing because what they did achieve was the same as doing nothing = nothing, only difference they ALL made money.

If they had all done nothing this forum topic would not exist & Madeleine would have been banished to the same obscurity as other missing children previously were.
Spare a thought for the deceased Charlie Gard's parents & those who have made money a-plenty from their fight for a cause - did they achieve nothing?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: misty on July 28, 2017, 09:13:39 PM
So you agree on the list ?

There are a few more I would like to add but I am not of a mind to provoke outrage.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 28, 2017, 09:29:23 PM
If they had all done nothing this forum topic would not exist & Madeleine would have been banished to the same obscurity as other missing children previously were.
Spare a thought for the deceased Charlie Gard's parents & those who have made money a-plenty from their fight for a cause - did they achieve nothing?

The judge was pretty caustic about those on social media who have an opinion on everything without the benefit of being in posession of the full facts. I'll go with the judge.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: misty on July 28, 2017, 09:32:21 PM

 ... the question of who speaks for those who have no voice has been raised, once again.
There are those who believe Amaral spoke for Madeleine when he decreed that her parents had covered up her death & he felt it was his role to bring them to justice. Why would you deny the parents the same right to be Madeleine's voice to counter Amaral's claims? Why would you deny them the right to legally counter anyone who has pre-determined & promoted Madeleine's fate without a shred of evidence?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 28, 2017, 09:35:07 PM
The judge was pretty caustic about those on social media who have an opinion on everything without the benefit of being in posession of the full facts. I'll go with the judge.

I agree!  Social Media-mob rule -crying eyes about everything is begining to get on ...
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: misty on July 28, 2017, 09:40:40 PM
The judge was pretty caustic about those on social media who have an opinion on everything without the benefit of being in posession of the full facts. I'll go with the judge.

If the judge & hospital felt they had ultimate power in Charlie's destiny they should have turned off the life support months ago instead of entertaining prolonged legal challenges - or at least let the parents take Charlie to the USA where his fate would no longer be their problem. Their procrastination led to the social media issues & ultimately, an undignified final few hours in Charlie's life.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 28, 2017, 10:04:16 PM
If the judge & hospital felt they had ultimate power in Charlie's destiny they should have turned off the life support months ago instead of entertaining prolonged legal challenges - or at least let the parents take Charlie to the USA where his fate would no longer be their problem. Their procrastination led to the social media issues & ultimately, an undignified final few hours in Charlie's life.

So you blame the Judge and GOSH ?
Maybe the Judge and GOSH were obliged to follow a defined protocol ?
The whole thing became an undignified circus with Septic* Pro Life organisations "bussing in" from 3000+ miles away. Social media issues were created by those on social media. Those people are responsible for their
own actions and no amount of claptrap can abnegate their personal responsibilities in that respect.

*Rhyming slang Septic Tank = yank.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 28, 2017, 10:09:09 PM
The search for Madeleine please.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: G-Unit on July 28, 2017, 11:07:00 PM
If the judge & hospital felt they had ultimate power in Charlie's destiny they should have turned off the life support months ago instead of entertaining prolonged legal challenges - or at least let the parents take Charlie to the USA where his fate would no longer be their problem. Their procrastination led to the social media issues & ultimately, an undignified final few hours in Charlie's life.

I think words like 'power' and 'procrastination' are unwarranted. Most of the time GOSH manages to work with relatives without any need for legal intervention. In this case they were unable to do so. There are links to the various court judgements here, as well as other info;

http://www.gosh.nhs.uk/frequently-asked-questions-about-charlie-gard-court-case

Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on July 28, 2017, 11:27:50 PM


Please take note the topic refers to the search for Madeleine McCann, all future off topic posts will be deleted. Thank you.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 30, 2017, 04:52:56 AM

Supposing that Operation Grange know who stole Madeleine, who she was passed on to and the direction in which she was taken, how would they manage to retrieve her?
First they would have to find her exact location.

In this day and age it is not possible to just snatch back an abducted child, especially if OG have no DNA proof.  This could be hard to come by as no supposed parent is legally obliged to provide DNA, and would almost certainly move on if they thought that they had been discovered.  So they would have to be watched unobtrusively.

This is a theory of mine.  And I am more than happy to have it debunked, if this is possible.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: G-Unit on July 30, 2017, 06:34:18 AM
Supposing that Operation Grange know who stole Madeleine, who she was passed on to and the direction in which she was taken, how would they manage to retrieve her?
First they would have to find her exact location.

In this day and age it is not possible to just snatch back an abducted child, especially if OG have no DNA proof.  This could be hard to come by as no supposed parent is legally obliged to provide DNA, and would almost certainly move on if they thought that they had been discovered.  So they would have to be watched unobtrusively.

This is a theory of mine.  And I am more than happy to have it debunked, if this is possible.

Most countries have undercover policemen. Getting DNA from a girl of 14 should be possible. With a match the countries authorities could swoop.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 30, 2017, 08:39:33 AM
Most countries have undercover policemen. Getting DNA from a girl of 14 should be possible. With a match the countries authorities could swoop.

Good point, G-Unit, I have thought around this a bit, but mainly I have been thinking of reasons for why a country with no extradition would be reluctant to cooperate.

It wouldn't be that easy to obtain DNA without alerting someone or involving a third party which could result in the child being moved.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: slartibartfast on July 30, 2017, 09:11:19 AM
Good point, G-Unit, I have thought around this a bit, but mainly I have been thinking of reasons for why a country with no extradition would be reluctant to cooperate.

It wouldn't be that easy to obtain DNA without alerting someone or involving a third party which could result in the child being moved.

Which country do you think she is in...

There are 33 countries with which Britain does not have an extradition agreement: Afghanistan, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Bahrain, Belarus, Bhutan, Cameroon, China, Dominican Republic, Egypt, Ethiopia, Georgia, Iran, Japan, Kazakhstan, Kuwait, Kyrgyzstan, Madagascar, Mongolia, Namibia, Oman, Pakistan, Qatar, Russia, Saudi Arabia, South Korea, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, UAE, Ukraine, Uzbekistan, Venezuela and Yemen.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: jassi on July 30, 2017, 09:13:16 AM
Seems to me that until she is discovered in one of these countries, there is little point in giving  any thought about extradition.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 30, 2017, 09:20:44 AM
Which country do you think she is in...

There are 33 countries with which Britain does not have an extradition agreement: Afghanistan, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Bahrain, Belarus, Bhutan, Cameroon, China, Dominican Republic, Egypt, Ethiopia, Georgia, Iran, Japan, Kazakhstan, Kuwait, Kyrgyzstan, Madagascar, Mongolia, Namibia, Oman, Pakistan, Qatar, Russia, Saudi Arabia, South Korea, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, UAE, Ukraine, Uzbekistan, Venezuela and Yemen.

Thanks, Slarty.  I don't think Madeleine is any particular country as such, but probably somewhere in South America would be most likely
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 30, 2017, 09:30:17 AM
Seems to me that until she is discovered in one of these countries, there is little point in giving  any thought about extradition.

Extradition might not be an option.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: G-Unit on July 30, 2017, 10:37:29 AM
Good point, G-Unit, I have thought around this a bit, but mainly I have been thinking of reasons for why a country with no extradition would be reluctant to cooperate.

It wouldn't be that easy to obtain DNA without alerting someone or involving a third party which could result in the child being moved.

Firstly a decision would have to be made as to who would request extradition of those holding her; Portugal or the UK. Madeleine has committed no crime so she would not be extradited. Her return would be requested and the country in question would make the decision.

I believe the Belgian police tested a drinks bottle/glass/straw after a sighting, so getting a similar sample could be fairly easy. Once a DNA match is obtained the local police could arrest all concerned.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 30, 2017, 10:52:49 AM
Firstly a decision would have to be made as to who would request extradition of those holding her; Portugal or the UK. Madeleine has committed no crime so she would not be extradited. Her return would be requested and the country in question would make the decision.

I believe the Belgian police tested a drinks bottle/glass/straw after a sighting, so getting a similar sample could be fairly easy. Once a DNA match is obtained the local police could arrest all concerned.

Some countries in South America simply do not extradite, even people who are not Nationals of that country.

I am supposing that it would have to be The UK in this case as Madeleine is a Ward of Court, but I don't know how that would work, or how anyone could actually prove it was Madeleine.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: G-Unit on July 30, 2017, 11:54:54 AM
Some countries in South America simply do not extradite, even people who are not Nationals of that country.

I am supposing that it would have to be The UK in this case as Madeleine is a Ward of Court, but I don't know how that would work, or how anyone could actually prove it was Madeleine.

Assuming her identity could be proved the UK would request her return, but any criminal activity took place in Portugal.That's not to say that those with her committed a crime in Portugal though.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 30, 2017, 12:01:49 PM
Assuming her identity could be proved the UK would request her return, but any criminal activity took place in Portugal.That's not to say that those with her committed a crime in Portugal though.

Exactly.  But proving it could be difficult.  They can't just say that they obtained DNA secretly.

Also not to say that those with her committed a crime in Portugal, or even knew who she was at the time.

It could be a minefield.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: G-Unit on July 30, 2017, 01:48:12 PM
Exactly.  But proving it could be difficult.  They can't just say that they obtained DNA secretly.

Also not to say that those with her committed a crime in Portugal, or even knew who she was at the time.

It could be a minefield.

If OG had enough to strongly suspect they had found her the local authorities would be the ones to get a DNA sample by whatever means they thought best.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 30, 2017, 01:56:00 PM
If OG had enough to strongly suspect they had found her the local authorities would be the ones to get a DNA sample by whatever means they thought best.

At which point whoever they might be would take off with Madeleine.  Back to square one.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Angelo222 on July 30, 2017, 04:17:51 PM
Some countries in South America simply do not extradite, even people who are not Nationals of that country.

I am supposing that it would have to be The UK in this case as Madeleine is a Ward of Court, but I don't know how that would work, or how anyone could actually prove it was Madeleine.

If by some slim chance Maddie was found outside of Portugal she would be returned to the UK.  Those involved or found with her would be the subject of extradition proceedings by the Portuguese.  For me this entire scenario is just wishful thinking though, I never expect she will ever be found let alone alive.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: jassi on July 30, 2017, 04:46:08 PM
If alive, she will be 14.  Another couple of years and she'll be able to please herself what she does.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 30, 2017, 04:54:42 PM
If by some slim chance Maddie was found outside of Portugal she would be returned to the UK.  Those involved or found with her would be the subject of extradition proceedings by the Portuguese.  For me this entire scenario is just wishful thinking though, I never expect she will ever be found let alone alive.

Some South American countries have no extradition, not even for foreigners.  And since Madeleine is currently still a minor, I wonder how Britain or Portugal would be able to deal with this, presuming of course that they could prove it was Madeleine.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: jassi on July 30, 2017, 05:05:09 PM
A tricky problem. Neither Britain, nor Portugal would be in a position to insist on anything.

To identify Madeleine would require fresh testing of her against Kate's & Gerry's DNA, probably by a laboratory in that country, under strict chain of custody conditions.
This assumes that the 'girl's' DNA sample was forthcoming.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 30, 2017, 05:20:53 PM
A tricky problem. Neither Britain, nor Portugal would be in a position to insist on anything.

To identify Madeleine would require fresh testing of her against Kate's & Gerry's DNA, probably by a laboratory in that country, under strict chain of custody conditions.
This assumes that the 'girl's' DNA sample was forthcoming.

Thanks for understanding what I have been trying to point out.

Any suggestions on how to get around this, anyone?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: G-Unit on July 30, 2017, 05:34:24 PM
Thanks for understanding what I have been trying to point out.

Any suggestions on how to get around this, anyone?

In the extremely unlikely event that it happened I'm sure the authorities would be up to dealing with it.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 30, 2017, 05:41:40 PM
In the extremely unlikely event that it happened I'm sure the authorities would be up to dealing with it.

Which authorities?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: G-Unit on July 30, 2017, 06:04:29 PM
Which authorities?

All the ones involved.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 30, 2017, 06:14:47 PM

Enough, I think.  Thank you to those who participated.  I mainly wanted my Theory on record as it is a possibility.  And would explain why Operation Grange are taking so long, and saying nothing.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: jassi on July 30, 2017, 06:38:02 PM
Enough, I think.  Thank you to those who participated.  I mainly wanted my Theory on record as it is a possibility.  And would explain why Operation Grange are taking so long, and saying nothing.

But probably doesn't - IMO
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on July 30, 2017, 06:40:27 PM
But probably doesn't - IMO

Never mind, eh.  It was worth a passing thought.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: slartibartfast on July 30, 2017, 09:18:05 PM
Some South American countries have no extradition, not even for foreigners.  And since Madeleine is currently still a minor, I wonder how Britain or Portugal would be able to deal with this, presuming of course that they could prove it was Madeleine.

Venezuela
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: G-Unit on July 30, 2017, 10:08:57 PM
Venezuela


Which countries do not have extradition treaties with the UK?

There are 33 countries with which Britain does not have an extradition agreement: Afghanistan, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Bahrain, Belarus, Bhutan, Cameroon, China, Dominican Republic, Egypt, Ethiopia, Georgia, Iran, Japan, Kazakhstan, Kuwait, Kyrgyzstan, Madagascar, Mongolia, Namibia, Oman, Pakistan, Qatar, Russia, Saudi .
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: misty on July 30, 2017, 10:56:02 PM

Which countries do not have extradition treaties with the UK?

There are 33 countries with which Britain does not have an extradition agreement: Afghanistan, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Bahrain, Belarus, Bhutan, Cameroon, China, Dominican Republic, Egypt, Ethiopia, Georgia, Iran, Japan, Kazakhstan, Kuwait, Kyrgyzstan, Madagascar, Mongolia, Namibia, Oman, Pakistan, Qatar, Russia, Saudi .

You would only need an extradition treaty with a country if you required the return of a person for trial or sentence. It is the Hague Convention which is the multilateral treaty for the speedy recovery of an abducted child. There are far more countries which are not signatories to the HC. https://www.hcch.net/en/states/other-connected-states
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: bros on July 31, 2017, 02:54:33 PM
Regarding extradion my 5cents.


1. If a country is a member of UN there is good change that all of the listed countries above are they have in their national legislation adopted law for children rights.  It is almost certain that she will reunite with bilogical parents if they have not given the right.

2. Second aspect is that no matter where is she now if she is discovered she is not legal resident in that country(forged papers, birth cerfti. etc)   since she is not adult she will be again reunited with the parents or the country who has legal jurisdiction over the child. The one who issued birt.cert. passport. etc.


Operation grange might have to solve the things for extradion but not for Maddie but for the offenders and they have yes to provide upfront evidence to the host countries before they ask for arrest, extradition detention(prison) and extradition  at end.  Yes this requires time.

At the end extradition is  term used for person who has been convicted of a crime in a judical process or they are under judicial investigation and are persons of interest.
 
 


Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 31, 2017, 07:35:59 PM
Regarding extradion my 5cents.


1. If a country is a member of UN there is good change that all of the listed countries above are they have in their national legislation adopted law for children rights.  It is almost certain that she will reunite with bilogical parents if they have not given the right.

2. Second aspect is that no matter where is she now if she is discovered she is not legal resident in that country(forged papers, birth cerfti. etc)   since she is not adult she will be again reunited with the parents or the country who has legal jurisdiction over the child. The one who issued birt.cert. passport. etc.


Operation grange might have to solve the things for extradion but not for Maddie but for the offenders and they have yes to provide upfront evidence to the host countries before they ask for arrest, extradition detention(prison) and extradition  at end.  Yes this requires time.

At the end extradition is  term used for person who has been convicted of a crime in a judical process or they are under judicial investigation and are persons of interest.

Presumably she remains a ward of the Court of Chancery or has that been rescinded?
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on July 31, 2017, 07:42:10 PM
Regarding extradion my 5cents.


1. If a country is a member of UN there is good change that all of the listed countries above are they have in their national legislation adopted law for children rights.  It is almost certain that she will reunite with bilogical parents if they have not given the right.

2. Second aspect is that no matter where is she now if she is discovered she is not legal resident in that country(forged papers, birth cerfti. etc)   since she is not adult she will be again reunited with the parents or the country who has legal jurisdiction over the child. The one who issued birt.cert. passport. etc.


Operation grange might have to solve the things for extradion but not for Maddie but for the offenders and they have yes to provide upfront evidence to the host countries before they ask for arrest, extradition detention(prison) and extradition  at end. Yes this requires time.

At the end extradition is  term used for person who has been convicted of a crime in a judical process or they are under judicial investigation and are persons of interest.

Always given that OG turn up a crime that falls within The Met's authority and the perp has legged it to foreign parts. It's difficult to see how The Met have any authority over a crime committed in Portugal unless it is the murder or manslaughter of a UK citizen in Portugal then it's for up for grabs by either State.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: bros on July 31, 2017, 11:09:15 PM
An assumption is the mother of all mess ups.

How do we know that the crime occurred only in Portugal? Pre planning and organizing for i.e UK and executing in Portugal would certainly be punishable by law and would involve UK jurisdiction. There is legal reason why Homicide & Serious Crime Command of the Met took the case we don’t know all the details yet but how all this things have been organized shows some dots.

Met have mentioned multiple times of international police cooperation and this can only happen if there are legal ground  to put them through Interpol or Europol they work on judicial documents primarily not hunch.

Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 01, 2017, 11:34:34 AM
An assumption is the mother of all mess ups.

How do we know that the crime occurred only in Portugal? Pre planning and organizing for i.e UK and executing in Portugal would certainly be punishable by law and would involve UK jurisdiction. There is legal reason why Homicide & Serious Crime Command of the Met took the case we don’t know all the details yet but how all this things have been organized shows some dots.

Met have mentioned multiple times of international police cooperation and this can only happen if there are legal ground  to put them through Interpol or Europol they work on judicial documents primarily not hunch.

Are you able to show that Europol and Interpol have been involved? MLA requires the involvement of neither one.
On the face of it your gross assumption is no better than my less gross assumption unless ya'll are a conspiracy theorist. Deal me out of that one.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on August 01, 2017, 11:37:43 AM
An assumption is the mother of all mess ups.

How do we know that the crime occurred only in Portugal? Pre planning and organizing for i.e UK and executing in Portugal would certainly be punishable by law and would involve UK jurisdiction. There is legal reason why Homicide & Serious Crime Command of the Met took the case we don’t know all the details yet but how all this things have been organized shows some dots.

Met have mentioned multiple times of international police cooperation and this can only happen if there are legal ground  to put them through Interpol or Europol they work on judicial documents primarily not hunch.

You assume there was a crime.

You assume there was an abduction.

Assumptions are no more than speculation.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on August 01, 2017, 03:16:04 PM
You assume there was a crime.

You assume there was an abduction.

Assumptions are no more than speculation.

Spoil Sport.   8)><(
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: stephen25000 on August 01, 2017, 04:17:57 PM
Spoil Sport.   8)><(

Such is life Eleanor. 8(>((
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: bros on August 01, 2017, 05:25:05 PM
Are you able to show that Europol and Interpol have been involved? MLA requires the involvement of neither one.
On the face of it your gross assumption is no better than my less gross assumption unless ya'll are a conspiracy theorist. Deal me out of that one.

Dear Alice it is not so easy for one country police to pick up a phone and call another country police and request cooperation, maybe they can to play soccer or have a coke but not for legal matters. This is the main reason why Interpol and Europol have been made. They are not here either to make direct cooperation for police but to carry out judicial duties of booth countries and not directly but through Ministry of Justice or Department of Justice depending on the setup of the institution in one country.
The only case when those two institutions are bypassed is when two counties Ministry of Justice send letters to request setting  grounds for cooperation such the case in  with UK and Portugal . 

Spoiler; Try to find out what a police statement in Paraguay was  few years back when there was roomer that Maddie might be located in South America and will be easy to understand.
There is international machine activated against “someone” they have capability to dig them out as rain worms including there own eggs.   I will bet it is network they are against not individuals.

You assume there was a crime.

You assume there was an abduction.

Assumptions are no more than speculation.





You assume there was a crime.
1.I dont assume a crime Portugal Judicial authorities does. There is child missing from 5a and there is criminal proceeding open in Portugal with all elements .They don’t open criminal proceeding  for a child which walk away but they do open for  a  Crime committed after review of evidance, you cant open one without evidance.
Before you apply Criminal code you have to apply Criminal Procedure law. Until judicial police and the leading prosecutor office (sometimes investigative judge) close it is as such.

2. You assume Abduction
-I think the above answer is valid.

3. Assumption is no more than speculation.
I agree that’s why I elaborated above. I hope you will review you signature regarding the McCain’s and   two persons making money on a missing and listen to your advice once a again.

I agree with you that someone is making money but the investigation is here to show who.  Who is continuing to provide logistic on the actors involved on what happened May 3 2007.  Logistic is also punishable as obstruction of justice at least there are many more grounds they can be charged also.
This is a school case for needed international law enforcement cooperation to crack down on issue.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 01, 2017, 05:49:44 PM
Dear Alice it is not so easy for one country police to pick up a phone and call another country police and request cooperation, maybe they can to play soccer or have a coke but not for legal matters. This is the main reason why Interpol and Europol have been made. They are not here either to make direct cooperation for police but to carry out judicial duties of booth countries and not directly but through Ministry of Justice or Department of Justice depending on the setup of the institution in one country.
The only case when those two institutions are bypassed is when two counties Ministry of Justice send letters to request setting  grounds for cooperation such the case in  with UK and Portugal . 

Spoiler; Try to find out what a police statement in Paraguay was  few years back when there was roomer that Maddie might be located in South America and will be easy to understand.
There is international machine activated against “someone” they have capability to dig them out as rain worms including there own eggs.   I will bet it is network they are against not individuals.
 

You assume there was a crime.
1.I dont assume a crime Portugal Judicial authorities does. There is child missing from 5a and there is criminal proceeding open in Portugal with all elements .They don’t open criminal proceeding  for a child which walk away but they do open for  a  Crime committed after review of evidance, you cant open one without evidance.
Before you apply Criminal code you have to apply Criminal Procedure law. Until judicial police and the leading prosecutor office (sometimes investigative judge) close it is as such.

2. You assume Abduction
-I think the above answer is valid.

3. Assumption is no more than speculation.
I agree that’s why I elaborated above. I hope you will review you signature regarding the McCain’s and   two persons making money on a missing and listen to your advice once a again.

I agree with you that someone is making money but the investigation is here to show who.  Who is continuing to provide logistic on the actors involved on what happened May 3 2007.  Logistic is also punishable as obstruction of justice at least there are many more grounds they can be charged also.
This is a school case for needed international law enforcement cooperation to crack down on issue.

Dear Bros,
When the CPS publish comprehensive data and information with respect to such circumstances do you:
1 Believe I have not read it?
2 I would I take your word in preference to that of the CPS ?


Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on August 01, 2017, 08:04:42 PM

Logistics is never punishable.  It is simply logistics.  Which is why The MacCanns will never be found culpable.  Logistics
say that it was not possible for them to have disposed of the body of their daughter.

And anyone who thinks otherwise has a very sorry soul.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: G-Unit on August 02, 2017, 07:18:16 AM
Logistics is never punishable.  It is simply logistics.  Which is why The MacCanns will never be found culpable.  Logistics
say that it was not possible for them to have disposed of the body of their daughter.

And anyone who thinks otherwise has a very sorry soul.

Where there's a will there's a way.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Benice on August 02, 2017, 10:54:22 AM
Where there's a will there's a way.

Even with the best will in the world - you will still never get a quart to fit into a pint pot IMO.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on August 02, 2017, 01:11:46 PM
The aliens who are rebuilding the village destroyed by fire
AUGUST 01, 2017
(http://static.globalnoticias.pt/dn/image.aspx?brand=DN&type=generate&name=original&id=8676681&w=579&h=371&t=20170801215700)

Inside the municipality of Figueiró dos Vinhos, where the terrible fire of mid-June also arrived, there is a village repopulated by several foreign families. German, Dutch, Swiss, Swedish and Czech live in communion with nature, amidst the hills and valleys now black and covered in gray. Half of the thirty inhabitants of Vale Salgueiro are children - who never went to school. It was only after the fire that destroyed cars, houses, and caravans that the size of the community became known

Law more at www.noticiasmagazine.pt

http://www.dn.pt/noticias-magazine/interior/a-comunidade-de-estrangeiros-que-esta-a-reconstruir-uma-aldeia-destruida-pelo-fogo-8676681.html?utm_source=dn.pt&utm_medium=recomendadas&utm_campaign=afterArticle&_ga=2.159432957.1743070115.1501458851-565797815.1490875576

There are those who deride the notion that Madeleine McCann could be alive and well and hidden in plain sight.
I think the existence of this community proves that such a thing is perfectly possible and well within the bounds of feasibility.
(http://www.noticiasmagazine.pt/files/2017/07/28534425_BINARY_GI14072017LN000068-960x566_c.jpg)
After the fire, Social Security wanted to know how many people there are in the village and how they live. For a long time they did not have to fill in the forms.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 02, 2017, 10:07:03 PM
The aliens who are rebuilding the village destroyed by fire
AUGUST 01, 2017
(http://static.globalnoticias.pt/dn/image.aspx?brand=DN&type=generate&name=original&id=8676681&w=579&h=371&t=20170801215700)

Inside the municipality of Figueiró dos Vinhos, where the terrible fire of mid-June also arrived, there is a village repopulated by several foreign families. German, Dutch, Swiss, Swedish and Czech live in communion with nature, amidst the hills and valleys now black and covered in gray. Half of the thirty inhabitants of Vale Salgueiro are children - who never went to school. It was only after the fire that destroyed cars, houses, and caravans that the size of the community became known

Law more at www.noticiasmagazine.pt

http://www.dn.pt/noticias-magazine/interior/a-comunidade-de-estrangeiros-que-esta-a-reconstruir-uma-aldeia-destruida-pelo-fogo-8676681.html?utm_source=dn.pt&utm_medium=recomendadas&utm_campaign=afterArticle&_ga=2.159432957.1743070115.1501458851-565797815.1490875576

There are those who deride the notion that Madeleine McCann could be alive and well and hidden in plain sight.
I think the existence of this community proves that such a thing is perfectly possible and well within the bounds of feasibility.

(http://www.noticiasmagazine.pt/files/2017/07/28534425_BINARY_GI14072017LN000068-960x566_c.jpg)
After the fire, Social Security wanted to know how many people there are in the village and how they live. For a long time they did not have to fill in the forms.

Taking the meaning of feasible as "capable of being done or effected" one would not argue it is feasible.
What will be interesting, should it have occurred, is the mechanism by which it was effected.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on August 03, 2017, 01:01:47 AM
Taking the meaning of feasible as "capable of being done or effected" one would not argue it is feasible.
What will be interesting, should it have occurred, is the mechanism by which it was effected.

The community of foreigners which kept itself to itself managed to coexist along side the indigenous population causing neither upset nor comment.

They raised and educated their children without interference from or apparently close scrutiny of officialdom.  I don't know if their community just evolved along those lines or if they designed it to be so ... but keeping a low profile enabled them to very much do their own thing.
So whether the mechanism was accident or design in this instance, it occurred.

Who would have thought that only a national disaster such as the forest fires have been would have led to the revelation that no-one knew who they all are or how many?
Another such unlikely scenario might be at the root of the continuing search for Madeleine.  We are told they are still investigating ... in my opinion that means the search for Madeleine continues.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 03, 2017, 11:58:13 AM
The community of foreigners which kept itself to itself managed to coexist along side the indigenous population causing neither upset nor comment.

They raised and educated their children without interference from or apparently close scrutiny of officialdom.  I don't know if their community just evolved along those lines or if they designed it to be so ... but keeping a low profile enabled them to very much do their own thing.
So whether the mechanism was accident or design in this instance, it occurred.

Who would have thought that only a national disaster such as the forest fires have been would have led to the revelation that no-one knew who they all are or how many?
Another such unlikely scenario might be at the root of the continuing search for Madeleine.  We are told they are still investigating ... in my opinion that means the search for Madeleine continues.

Sooner or later it will need to be subjected to the test of Kipling's "Six Honest Serving Men" or Dean Gano's "Caused by" then what ?


Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: barrier on August 04, 2017, 08:41:30 AM
Seen reference to this elsewhere, as recently as Dec 2015 in a response to a FOI No: 2015120000612  request the MPS describe OG as an investigative review of the investigation(s) into the circumstances of the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Eleanor on August 23, 2017, 02:08:01 PM

The search for Madeleine hasn't ground to a halt.  It's just a bunch of very nasty people trying to make it so.  It isn't working.
Title: Re: Has the search for Madeleine McCann ground to a halt?
Post by: Brietta on August 23, 2017, 02:51:47 PM
The search for Madeleine hasn't ground to a halt.  It's just a bunch of very nasty people trying to make it so.  It isn't working.

The mystery is why they feel so motivated to do things like that?
Although I think even they have to concede they have failed if their objective was to impede anyone ever looking for Madeleine.