UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2017, 10:23:58 AM

Title: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2017, 10:23:58 AM
In a YouTube documentary by Steve Gibson he raises the point that there is a visible impression on Madeleine's bed and once he pointed it out to me I can't seem to not see it from now on.  Is this a real impression that he outlines or not?
https://youtu.be/Ayr7Dzet-D8?t=2939 is the start of the relevant section. 
What does the forum think about this matter?
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: stephen25000 on August 19, 2017, 10:49:47 AM
The bed Rob looks barely disturbed, and in my opinion does not look slept in at all.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: G-Unit on August 19, 2017, 03:18:25 PM
Kate said Madeleine snuggled down. This is what 'snuggled down' looks like at 10:10

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=79WbUuCSyFs

Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: John on August 19, 2017, 03:54:42 PM
In a YouTube documentary by Steve Gibson he raises the point that there is a visible impression on Madeleine's bed and once he pointed it out to me I can't seem to not see it from now on.  Is this a real impression that he outlines or not?
https://youtu.be/Ayr7Dzet-D8?t=2939 is the start of the relevant section. 
What does the forum think about this matter?

By the time this photo had been taken any number of people could have sat on or moved the bed coverings so no inference can possibly be made from it.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: misty on August 19, 2017, 05:13:02 PM
By the time this photo had been taken any number of people could have sat on or moved the bed coverings so no inference can possibly be made from it.

All the more reason the bedding should have been bagged up & sent for analysis. The PJ don't even seem to have asked if the bed was made in the morning & the pillow pumped up.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: G-Unit on August 19, 2017, 07:03:31 PM
All the more reason the bedding should have been bagged up & sent for analysis. The PJ don't even seem to have asked if the bed was made in the morning & the pillow pumped up.

What kind of analysis?
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: Brietta on August 19, 2017, 08:08:04 PM
What kind of analysis?

Madeleine: How the police ruined the forensic evidence in her bedroom
By VANESSA ALLEN
Last updated at 01:22 16 November 2007

Poice searching for Madeleine McCann allowed potentially crucial clues from her bed to be destroyed, it emerged yesterday.
Detectives failed to send her bedding for analysis, even though an abductor could have left fibres, fingerprints or DNA on it.

By the time officers returned to the Ocean Club apartment more than 24 hours after Madeleine's disappearance, cleaners at the holiday complex had washed the sheets, blankets and pillowcase.

A source from the Portuguese police laboratory said: "Some important clue could have been found on those items besides hair, which was what was sent to the institute.
"They forgot that the items in the bedroom could hypothetically have had fibres belonging to a possible abductor or even a fingerprint."

The error is the latest in a series of blunders surrounding the collection of forensic evidence from Kate and Gerry McCann's apartment in Praia da Luz.

Police failed to seal off the apartment as a crime scene, meaning vital samples were contaminated with ash from officers' cigarettes.

Other evidence was trampled under foot by up to 50 people, who left shoe marks and fingerprints.

Officers also allowed the McCanns to move their possessions to another apartment.

Mr and Mrs McCann, both 39, from Leicestershire, have always insisted their daughter was abducted while they ate dinner with friends nearby.

They have been horrified by blunders in the investigation, which they fear could have destroyed their chances of learning what happened to Madeleine.

Their spokesman Clarence Mitchell declined to comment-on the police investigation, but said it was hoped it was being carried out "as professionally and as competently as possible".

Forensics expert Allan Scott said the bedding could have been a vital source of evidence.
"It is very difficult to be in contact with another surface and not leave a trace of yourself behind."

Further forensic sampling was carried out in the apartment in August, after sniffer dogs allegedly found the "scent of death" and microscopic traces of blood.

Scientists have continued to work on the samples in the hope they could still provide a breakthrough.

The revelations came as a lawyer began moves to bring a private prosecution against the McCanns for alleged child neglect.
Anthony Bennett faxed an application for a court summons against the couple to magistrates in Leicestershire.
He said his move was sparked by a 'lack of action' by the Leicestershire authorities.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-494203/Madeleine-How-police-ruined-forensic-evidence-bedroom.html#ixzz4qEIHLDqa


Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: stephen25000 on August 19, 2017, 08:28:11 PM
Madeleine: How the police ruined the forensic evidence in her bedroom
By VANESSA ALLEN
Last updated at 01:22 16 November 2007

Poice searching for Madeleine McCann allowed potentially crucial clues from her bed to be destroyed, it emerged yesterday.
Detectives failed to send her bedding for analysis, even though an abductor could have left fibres, fingerprints or DNA on it.

By the time officers returned to the Ocean Club apartment more than 24 hours after Madeleine's disappearance, cleaners at the holiday complex had washed the sheets, blankets and pillowcase.

A source from the Portuguese police laboratory said: "Some important clue could have been found on those items besides hair, which was what was sent to the institute.
"They forgot that the items in the bedroom could hypothetically have had fibres belonging to a possible abductor or even a fingerprint."

The error is the latest in a series of blunders surrounding the collection of forensic evidence from Kate and Gerry McCann's apartment in Praia da Luz.

Police failed to seal off the apartment as a crime scene, meaning vital samples were contaminated with ash from officers' cigarettes.

Other evidence was trampled under foot by up to 50 people, who left shoe marks and fingerprints.

Officers also allowed the McCanns to move their possessions to another apartment.

Mr and Mrs McCann, both 39, from Leicestershire, have always insisted their daughter was abducted while they ate dinner with friends nearby.

They have been horrified by blunders in the investigation, which they fear could have destroyed their chances of learning what happened to Madeleine.

Their spokesman Clarence Mitchell declined to comment-on the police investigation, but said it was hoped it was being carried out "as professionally and as competently as possible".

Forensics expert Allan Scott said the bedding could have been a vital source of evidence.
"It is very difficult to be in contact with another surface and not leave a trace of yourself behind."

Further forensic sampling was carried out in the apartment in August, after sniffer dogs allegedly found the "scent of death" and microscopic traces of blood.

Scientists have continued to work on the samples in the hope they could still provide a breakthrough.

The revelations came as a lawyer began moves to bring a private prosecution against the McCanns for alleged child neglect.
Anthony Bennett faxed an application for a court summons against the couple to magistrates in Leicestershire.
He said his move was sparked by a 'lack of action' by the Leicestershire authorities.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-494203/Madeleine-How-police-ruined-forensic-evidence-bedroom.html#ixzz4qEIHLDqa

Three points.

An 'abductor' is an unproven possibility.

Secondly, what is Ms. Allen's expertise in this field ?

...and of course that was a 2007 article..

Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: John on August 19, 2017, 08:30:41 PM
If, and it is still a big if, Madeleine was abducted from her bed then there was every chance that the alleged abductor left DNA evidence behind on the bed covers or on the floor by the bed.  If the PJ failed to avail of those opportunities then they were indeed negligent.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: misty on August 19, 2017, 08:31:55 PM
Three points.

An 'abductor' is an unproven possibility.

Secondly, what is Ms. Allen's expertise in this field ?

...and of course that was a 2007 article..

You're not going to find forensic evidence if you don't look for it. The bedroom curtains should also have been taken away for trace analysis. I don't expect you to understand how necessary that was, as you are clearly of the same mindset as Amaral.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: stephen25000 on August 19, 2017, 08:44:20 PM
You're not going to find forensic evidence if you don't look for it. The bedroom curtains should also have been taken away for trace analysis. I don't expect you to understand how necessary that was, as you are clearly of the same mindset as Amaral.

Ah the insults fly again.

I do understand, and eminently far more than you appear to do.

The parents and associates contaminated the crime scene, whilst searching for an abducted child in the apartment.

I have said in the past, the forensic testing could have been more thorough, but then again, we are relying on press reports.

Neither of us was there.

The parents could also have submitted the articles for testing. After all they are supposed to be intelligent.

Likewise, the other children should have been tested for drugs/sedatives, and neither the PJ or the parents did anything about it.

The McCann's tests a few months later were irrelevant and certainly not independent.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: misty on August 19, 2017, 08:47:39 PM
Ah the insults fly again.

I do understand, and eminently far more than you appear to do.

The parents and associates contaminated the crime scene, whilst searching for an abducted child in the apartment.

I have said in the past, the forensic testing could have been more thorough, but then again, we are relying on press reports.

Neither of us was there.

The parents could also have submitted the articles for testing. After all they are supposed to be intelligent.

Likewise, the other children should have been tested for drugs/sedatives, and neither the PJ or the parents did anything about it.

The McCann's tests a few months later were irrelevant and certainly not independent.

Who, exactly, was directing the investigation - the victims or the police?
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2017, 08:50:53 PM
If, and it is still a big if, Madeleine was abducted from her bed then there was every chance that the alleged abductor left DNA evidence behind on the bed covers or on the floor by the bed.  If the PJ failed to avail of those opportunities then they were indeed negligent.
What I found amazing to discover was that no one ever secured the crime scene in that the patio door was never secured.  Another thing that is amazing is that the bed clothes from Madeleine's bed were allowed to be laundered.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: G-Unit on August 19, 2017, 08:52:19 PM
Madeleine: How the police ruined the forensic evidence in her bedroom
By VANESSA ALLEN
Last updated at 01:22 16 November 2007

Poice searching for Madeleine McCann allowed potentially crucial clues from her bed to be destroyed, it emerged yesterday.
Detectives failed to send her bedding for analysis, even though an abductor could have left fibres, fingerprints or DNA on it.

By the time officers returned to the Ocean Club apartment more than 24 hours after Madeleine's disappearance, cleaners at the holiday complex had washed the sheets, blankets and pillowcase.

A source from the Portuguese police laboratory said: "Some important clue could have been found on those items besides hair, which was what was sent to the institute.
"They forgot that the items in the bedroom could hypothetically have had fibres belonging to a possible abductor or even a fingerprint."

The error is the latest in a series of blunders surrounding the collection of forensic evidence from Kate and Gerry McCann's apartment in Praia da Luz.

Police failed to seal off the apartment as a crime scene, meaning vital samples were contaminated with ash from officers' cigarettes.

Other evidence was trampled under foot by up to 50 people, who left shoe marks and fingerprints.

Officers also allowed the McCanns to move their possessions to another apartment.

Mr and Mrs McCann, both 39, from Leicestershire, have always insisted their daughter was abducted while they ate dinner with friends nearby.

They have been horrified by blunders in the investigation, which they fear could have destroyed their chances of learning what happened to Madeleine.

Their spokesman Clarence Mitchell declined to comment-on the police investigation, but said it was hoped it was being carried out "as professionally and as competently as possible".

Forensics expert Allan Scott said the bedding could have been a vital source of evidence.
"It is very difficult to be in contact with another surface and not leave a trace of yourself behind."

Further forensic sampling was carried out in the apartment in August, after sniffer dogs allegedly found the "scent of death" and microscopic traces of blood.

Scientists have continued to work on the samples in the hope they could still provide a breakthrough.

The revelations came as a lawyer began moves to bring a private prosecution against the McCanns for alleged child neglect.
Anthony Bennett faxed an application for a court summons against the couple to magistrates in Leicestershire.
He said his move was sparked by a 'lack of action' by the Leicestershire authorities.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-494203/Madeleine-How-police-ruined-forensic-evidence-bedroom.html#ixzz4qEIHLDqa

Inaccuracies;

"By the time officers returned to the Ocean Club apartment more than 24 hours after Madeleine's disappearance, cleaners at the holiday complex had washed the sheets, blankets and pillowcase".

The forensic team from the Police Science Laboratory arrived at 15.30 on 4th May. The photographs they took clearly show the bedding in place on the bed.

"Police failed to seal off the apartment as a crime scene, meaning vital samples were contaminated with ash from officers' cigarettes"

The apartment was locked by the PJ team at around 4am on the 4th and the GNR guarded it thereafter.

"Officers also allowed the McCanns to move their possessions to another apartment."

They were allowed to take some items before the apartment was secured and the remainder were collected by the McCanns and Emma Knight on the morning of Sunday 6th.

A search was also made for possible biological traces and fibres on the single bed from where the minor disappeared, using a variable-wave light source appropriate for the task, the result obtained having been negative.

The area of the pillow of the bed from the minor disappeared was inspected with the intention to detect the presence of some smell [aroma] characteristic of volatile substances typical of chloroform or ether, this search proving negative
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/5A_FORENSIC_4_5_7.htm
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: stephen25000 on August 19, 2017, 08:53:31 PM
Who, exactly, was directing the investigation - the victims or the police?

Who is responsible for this case ?

Tell me also, why the parents didn't submit the clothes, plus of course the toy for testing ?

After all , part of most medical courses would include analytical chemistry, as would 'A' Level courses in Chemistry, which presumably both did. They would be aware of the need for testing materials forensically.

 8(0(*
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: jassi on August 19, 2017, 08:58:13 PM
I thought police had sealed off the apartment by the early hours of the morning.
How then could cleaners gain access and why, given that McCanns were supposed to be there until Saturday morning.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: stephen25000 on August 19, 2017, 09:02:56 PM
''By the time officers returned to the Ocean Club apartment more than 24 hours after Madeleine's disappearance, cleaners at the holiday complex had washed the sheets, blankets and pillowcase.''

Can we have a cite for this from the PJ files ? 8**8:/:
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: G-Unit on August 19, 2017, 09:05:23 PM
What I found amazing to discover was that no one ever secured the crime scene in that the patio door was never secured.  Another thing that is amazing is that the bed clothes from Madeleine's bed were allowed to be laundered.

Try reading the official files instead of believing the rubbish printed in the Daily Mail.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2017, 09:10:21 PM
''By the time officers returned to the Ocean Club apartment more than 24 hours after Madeleine's disappearance, cleaners at the holiday complex had washed the sheets, blankets and pillowcase.''

Can we have a cite for this from the PJ files ? 8**8:/:
No one is going to admit to that but wasn't that common knowledge.  The McCanns had taken their stuff and the OC had to prepare the room for the next lot of tenants. 
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: John on August 19, 2017, 09:14:17 PM
What I found amazing to discover was that no one ever secured the crime scene in that the patio door was never secured.  Another thing that is amazing is that the bed clothes from Madeleine's bed were allowed to be laundered.

It is clear from the statements of the first police responders (Tweedledee and Tweedledum according to Dr Healey) that they disbelieved the parents claim that the child had been lifted from her bed and abducted.  I think this is why restrictions were not immediately applied to everything in and around apartment 5a.  And that is why a local search was commenced immediately rather than road spotchecks.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: stephen25000 on August 19, 2017, 09:14:23 PM
No one is going to admit to that but wasn't that common knowledge.  The McCanns had taken their stuff and the OC had to prepare the room for the next lot of tenants.

The case files Rob, the files.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2017, 09:22:17 PM
Inaccuracies;

"By the time officers returned to the Ocean Club apartment more than 24 hours after Madeleine's disappearance, cleaners at the holiday complex had washed the sheets, blankets and pillowcase".

The forensic team from the Police Science Laboratory arrived at 15.30 on 4th May. The photographs they took clearly show the bedding in place on the bed.

"Police failed to seal off the apartment as a crime scene, meaning vital samples were contaminated with ash from officers' cigarettes"

The apartment was locked by the PJ team at around 4am on the 4th and the GNR guarded it thereafter.

"Officers also allowed the McCanns to move their possessions to another apartment."

They were allowed to take some items before the apartment was secured and the remainder were collected by the McCanns and Emma Knight on the morning of Sunday 6th.

A search was also made for possible biological traces and fibres on the single bed from where the minor disappeared, using a variable-wave light source appropriate for the task, the result obtained having been negative.

The area of the pillow of the bed from the minor disappeared was inspected with the intention to detect the presence of some smell [aroma] characteristic of volatile substances typical of chloroform or ether, this search proving negative
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/5A_FORENSIC_4_5_7.htm
Mark William Thomas reported that the apartment was left insecure.  His interview has been recorded in this video clip "Astonishing new theory of Madeleine McCann revealed on This morning" https://youtu.be/10Jztzz8Qs0

The case files Rob, the files.
Just think about it Stephen, who is controlling what is kept in the files and later what is released?  They are not going to release files that show gross incompetence.

But the report from Jose Roque (GNR) is your first bit of evidence of an abduction that you've been wanting to see for years.  He says "During the search he did not find anything strange apart from the bedclothes on Madeleine's bed, which were too tidy, it appeared that she had been picked up from or had left the bed with great care. There was a mark on the sheet that appeared to be made by a child's body." http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JOSE_ROQUE.htm
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: jassi on August 19, 2017, 09:24:55 PM
And that's your evidence of abduction ?   @)(++(*  @)(++(*   @)(++(*
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 19, 2017, 09:28:00 PM
If, and it is still a big if, Madeleine was abducted from her bed then there was every chance that the alleged abductor left DNA evidence behind on the bed covers or on the floor by the bed.  If the PJ failed to avail of those opportunities then they were indeed negligent.

It would have been a major drop off by the PJ but it's a big leap from that to presuming any DNA & finger prints which potentially could have been recovered were already on record.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 19, 2017, 09:34:39 PM
And that's your evidence of abduction ?   

Yes Jassi it isn't much to go on but the GNR thought it so.   A serious crime was a possibility so the place should have been kept secure but the cleaning staff or the OC/MW staff laundered sheets etc. 
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 19, 2017, 09:43:00 PM
Mark William Thomas reported that the apartment was left insecure.  His interview has been recorded in this video clip "Astonishing new theory of Madeleine McCann revealed on This morning" https://youtu.be/10Jztzz8Qs0
Just think about it Stephen, who is controlling what is kept in the files and later what is released?  They are not going to release files that show gross incompetence.

But the report from Jose Roque (GNR) is your first bit of evidence of an abduction that you've been wanting to see for years.  He says "During the search he did not find anything strange apart from the bedclothes on Madeleine's bed, which were too tidy, it appeared that she had been picked up from or had left the bed with great care. There was a mark on the sheet that appeared to be made by a child's body." http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JOSE_ROQUE.htm

The Public Prosecutor controls it.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: G-Unit on August 19, 2017, 09:45:10 PM
Mark William Thomas reported that the apartment was left insecure.  His interview has been recorded in this video clip "Astonishing new theory of Madeleine McCann revealed on This morning" https://youtu.be/10Jztzz8Qs0
Just think about it Stephen, who is controlling what is kept in the files and later what is released?  They are not going to release files that show gross incompetence.

But the report from Jose Roque (GNR) is your first bit of evidence of an abduction that you've been wanting to see for years.  He says "During the search he did not find anything strange apart from the bedclothes on Madeleine's bed, which were too tidy, it appeared that she had been picked up from or had left the bed with great care. There was a mark on the sheet that appeared to be made by a child's body." http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JOSE_ROQUE.htm

When did Mark Williams-Thomas arrive in Luz?

Speculation about bedclothes by a GNR officer six months after the event is not evidence, my friend.

Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 20, 2017, 07:32:04 PM
When did Mark Williams-Thomas arrive in Luz?

Speculation about bedclothes by a GNR officer six months after the event is not evidence, my friend.
You'd need to find out why the statement from Roque was taken so much later even though he was first on the scene.
Mark Williams-Thomas says a couple of days.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: G-Unit on August 20, 2017, 07:48:51 PM
You'd need to find out why the statement from Roque was taken so much later even though he was first on the scene.
Mark Williams-Thomas says a couple of days.

So Williams-Thomas was repeating what he'd heard when he said 5A wasn't secured by the police.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 20, 2017, 08:38:13 PM
So Williams-Thomas was repeating what he'd heard when he said 5A wasn't secured by the police.
All I know is what I hear him say in the video clip.  It sounds like he was personally aware that the apartment was not secured when he checked it.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: John on August 21, 2017, 03:02:07 PM
You'd need to find out why the statement from Roque was taken so much later even though he was first on the scene.
Mark Williams-Thomas says a couple of days.

One tends to find that initial observations by those first on the scene are correct. Things start to blur from that point as self preservation and vested interest take over.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 21, 2017, 04:47:09 PM
You'd need to find out why the statement from Roque was taken so much later even though he was first on the scene.
Mark Williams-Thomas says a couple of days.

The situation would not arise in UK because of the PNB system. Someone seems to be making a gross assumption the Portuguese do not use a similar system.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 21, 2017, 08:35:53 PM
The situation would not arise in UK because of the PNB system. Someone seems to be making a gross assumption the Portuguese do not use a similar system.
I'm not from the UK or Portugal so I would have no idea what the PNB system is.  What does PNB stand for to begin with please?
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: misty on August 21, 2017, 08:37:59 PM
I'm not from the UK or Portugal so I would have no idea what the PNB system is.  What does PNB stand for to begin with please?

Police Note Book.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 21, 2017, 10:33:16 PM
Police Note Book.
The old fashioned note book?
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 21, 2017, 10:41:54 PM
The old fashioned note book?

Yup. The contents of which are accepted as evidence in court.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Police_notebook
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 23, 2017, 11:11:15 PM
There is a lot of love out there amongst people interested in the case.
Title: Re: Is the impression of a child lying on the bed visible?
Post by: sadie on August 23, 2017, 11:27:09 PM
There is a lot of love out there amongst people interested in the case.

Good to hear that. 8((()*/    Thanks Rob.