UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: John on August 26, 2017, 01:33:50 AM

Title: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: John on August 26, 2017, 01:33:50 AM
Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!

(http://media.lifestyle.one/jpg/80/0/0/800/478/0/0/0//aspectfit/North/0/0/0/0/0/c/news_real_life/58d8d28ce01e2f562d763352/madeleine-mccann-detective-dave-edgar-still-alive-portuguese-police3.jpg)

It seems that Dave Edgar has given another interview and to an Irish newspaper this time about his experiences as a private investigator in the Madeleine McCann case. The article is due to be published in Ireland on Sunday. 

From what I hear, the article is based on his 'Maddie could still be alive' belief so it will be interesting to see what evidence he provides to support it.

56
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 26, 2017, 06:05:32 AM
Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!

(http://media.lifestyle.one/jpg/80/0/0/800/478/0/0/0//aspectfit/North/0/0/0/0/0/c/news_real_life/58d8d28ce01e2f562d763352/madeleine-mccann-detective-dave-edgar-still-alive-portuguese-police3.jpg)

It seems that Dave Edgar has given another interview and to an Irish newspaper this time about his experiences as a private investigator in the Madeleine McCann case. The article is due to be published in Ireland on Sunday. 

From what I hear, the article is based on his 'Maddie could still be alive' belief so it will be interesting to see what evidence he provides to support it.

Not yet sure if it will appear online.

More to follow when available...

Such as the Beckham lookalike, which he and Mitchell held a conference on, and did absolutely diddly Squat to investigate.

As he 'worked for the Mccanns, anything he says has to be taken in context.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Erngath on August 26, 2017, 08:24:18 AM
Such as the Beckham lookalike, which he and Mitchell held a conference on, and did absolutely diddly Squat to investigate.

As he 'worked for the Mccanns, anything he says has to be taken in context.

Can you expand on " As he worked for the McCanns, anything he says has to be taken in context."
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: jassi on August 26, 2017, 09:25:31 AM
Can you expand on " As he worked for the McCanns, anything he says has to be taken in context."

Commonly known as 'don't believe a word that he (Edgar) says'
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 26, 2017, 11:02:29 AM
Oh no! not more secret lairs in lawless hinterlands.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 26, 2017, 11:11:08 AM
Oh no! not more secret lairs in lawless hinterlands.

Ah yes Alice, that lawless village 10 miles from PDL.

 *&*%£
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: jassi on August 26, 2017, 11:40:35 AM
If McCanns had believed on of that rubbish, they'd have organised a a snatch team to rescue her.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 26, 2017, 11:42:05 AM
If McCanns had believed on of that rubbish, they'd have organised a a snatch team to rescue her.

Exactly, it was a total load of rollox.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: misty on August 26, 2017, 11:59:31 AM
If McCanns had believed on of that rubbish, they'd have organised a a snatch team to rescue her.

There was apparently a plane ready & waiting to go to Morocco to fetch a child thought to be Madeleine......once bitten etc.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 26, 2017, 12:06:09 PM
There was apparently a plane ready & waiting to go to Morocco to fetch a child thought to be Madeleine......once bitten etc.

...and we know where that ended up as well.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: misty on August 26, 2017, 12:31:52 PM
...and we know where that ended up as well.

It would really be nice if you'd stop displaying such obvious satisfaction that Madeleine hasn't been located despite the best intentions of so many involved in helping.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 26, 2017, 01:02:02 PM
It would really be nice if you'd stop displaying such obvious satisfaction that Madeleine hasn't been located despite the best intentions of so many involved in helping.

Many people were involved at the start, though the key people stopped after the morning of the 4 th May 2007.

By the way, how can you find someone who can't be found ?

IMHO of course.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: faithlilly on August 26, 2017, 01:13:28 PM
I would imagine the article will simply be a rehash of this article from March this year.

https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/3185160/madeleine-mccann-investigator-claims-her-kidnappers-are-being-protected-as-he-speaks-for-first-time/
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Brietta on August 26, 2017, 01:16:31 PM
Many people were involved at the start, though the key people stopped after the morning of the 4 th May 2007.

By the way, how can you find someone who can't be found ?

IMHO of course.

Probably in much the same way you find the corpse that never was?
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Angelo222 on August 26, 2017, 01:28:34 PM
I would imagine the article will simply be a rehash of this article from March this year.

https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/3185160/madeleine-mccann-investigator-claims-her-kidnappers-are-being-protected-as-he-speaks-for-first-time/

A nice little earner for Edgar unless he has waived his fee off to a worthy cause? 

He appears to be paving the way ahead of a new private investigation which no doubt he wants to lead. 
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 26, 2017, 01:29:59 PM
Probably in much the same way you find the corpse that never was?

So yet again, not that I expect an answer, where would she be if still alive ?

There really aren't many possibilities.

The simple truth is SY ort the PJ have not determined how she disappeared or her fate.

However, with not one trace since she disappeared....................
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: G-Unit on August 26, 2017, 05:48:47 PM
Matthew James? Interestingly he seems to have some familiar ideas about bloodlines and elites;

http://mara-gamiel4.blogspot.co.uk/
https://mara-gamiel.blogspot.co.uk/
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: sadie on August 26, 2017, 10:03:27 PM
So yet again, not that I expect an answer, where would she be if still alive ?

There really aren't many possibilities.

The simple truth is SY ort the PJ have not determined how she disappeared or her fate.

However, with not one trace since she disappeared....................
Wrong !

Madeleine could be at any place on earth ... on land, or sailing the seven seas
That is why it is so difficult finding her
.... but I think that she was in Gozo, Malta in 2012.



BTW, your post is in your opinion, I take it?   Do keep to the rules stephen
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 26, 2017, 10:24:07 PM
Wrong !

Madeleine could be at any place on earth ... on land, or sailing the seven seas
That is why it is so difficult finding her
.... but I think that she was in Gozo, Malta in 2012.



BTW, your post is in your opinion, I take it?   Do keep to the rules stephen

Or on the Federation Starship Enterprise.

Pointers Sadie, pointers.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: misty on August 26, 2017, 10:29:46 PM
Or on the Federation Starship Enterprise.

Pointers Sadie, pointers.

You mean Pointy-ears, as per your profile pic.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: sadie on August 26, 2017, 11:09:45 PM
Or on the Federation Starship Enterprise.

Pointers Sadie, pointers.

Sorry, cant give any public pointers, but I do have ideas other than PT, in the big wide world, where to look for Madeleine ... and even places that nobody seems too have thought of within PT

If that is your theory, DR Spock, why dont you take off on Starship Enterprise and zoom around the world looking for the wee mite, now a young lady


Nigh night
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 27, 2017, 02:45:17 AM
Sorry, cant give any public pointers, but I do have ideas other than PT, in the big wide world, where to look for Madeleine ... and even places that nobody seems too have thought of within PT

If that is your theory, DR Spock, why dont you take off on Starship Enterprise and zoom around the world looking for the wee mite, now a young lady


Nigh night

It was Mr. Spock Sadie, and just like your theories, just a wee bit of fiction.

IMHO.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: G-Unit on August 27, 2017, 09:08:23 AM
Wrong !

Madeleine could be at any place on earth ... on land, or sailing the seven seas
That is why it is so difficult finding her
.... but I think that she was in Gozo, Malta in 2012.



BTW, your post is in your opinion, I take it?   Do keep to the rules stephen

Matt James says she was in Malta in June 2007;

It has been proposed by 'higher forces' that those who hold Madeleine McCann are more often than not on 'the seven seas' and flit from sacred shore to sacred shore to elude detection. The indications are that Malta, Rhodes & even Cyprus may have been where their 'lavish' ocean vessel may have been moored.
https://mara-gamiel.blogspot.co.uk/2007/06/ancient-citadel.html

Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: slartibartfast on August 27, 2017, 10:09:54 AM
Matt James says she was in Malta in June 2007;

It has been proposed by 'higher forces' that those who hold Madeleine McCann are more often than not on 'the seven seas' and flit from sacred shore to sacred shore to elude detection. The indications are that Malta, Rhodes & even Cyprus may have been where their 'lavish' ocean vessel may have been moored.
https://mara-gamiel.blogspot.co.uk/2007/06/ancient-citadel.html

A touch of the Reductio ad absurdum there.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 27, 2017, 10:17:23 AM
A touch of the Reductio ad absurdum there.

You're being too polite Slarti.

It had the touch of another Dan Brown offering from la-la land.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: John on August 27, 2017, 11:23:22 AM
Today's Sunday Life

In this week's Sunday Life we have an eight page special on the disappearance of Madeleine McCann, ten years after she vanished. A former RUC detective who spent years searching for her tells us what he thinks happened and what his investigations uncovered. Don't miss The Maddie Files in this week's Sunday Life.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 27, 2017, 11:23:40 AM
Is the article from Edgar online yet ?
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: John on August 27, 2017, 11:26:00 AM
Is the article from Edgar online yet ?

No.

It's against my principles to buy a newspaper but I know the local newsagent so he might donate one.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 27, 2017, 11:30:17 AM
No.

It's against my principles to buy a newspaper but I know the local newsagent so he might donate one.

Thank you.

It should prove an 'interesting' read John.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: sadie on August 27, 2017, 11:46:32 AM
Matt James says she was in Malta in June 2007;

It has been proposed by 'higher forces' that those who hold Madeleine McCann are more often than not on 'the seven seas' and flit from sacred shore to sacred shore to elude detection. The indications are that Malta, Rhodes & even Cyprus may have been where their 'lavish' ocean vessel may have been moored.
https://mara-gamiel.blogspot.co.uk/2007/06/ancient-citadel.html

Thank you for finding that Gunit.  Very interesting reading.  It confirms my thoughts on the subject.  Lavish ocean vessel, so Elites?   
The Phoenician islands of Malta Rhodes and Cyprus!  ... and the Knights Hospitalier = The Knights of St John = ? the Templars before they vanished in the early 14th Century. 

So, St John again and Phoenicians/ Cananites again, the original pirates?   The pirates who knew every port and every cave along the coasts of Europe and well beyond?

Were they historically the first to set up trafficking, I wonder ?  Canaanite = Cannabis  and McCann / Kenn***edy?   Is Madeleine pure blood Canaanite?

I am sure The Mccanns aren't pirates but are they pure blood descended?   Should SY be searching for someone/ people in that bloodline group?

***  Note:  in early times spelling was very hit and miss.   Kenn has the same sort of sound to Cann, so is likely derived from the same source = Canaanites



Somewhere in his massive website, Matt James states that Madeleine was spotted in Malta/Gozo 28 times.

Madeleine spotted 28 times on the Phoenician island of Malta, with its labyrinth of prehistoric tunnels linking all parts of the islands, all totally out of sight, and reputedly at one time reaching to the Vatican.  Matt James knows about all these sightings.   Has these sightings been hidden from us ?  If so, why?   

Also the quite large number of sightings of Madeleine in the Porto/ Guimaraes area.  IIRC there were about 5 or 6 of these in the first days/weeks after Madeleine vanished.  Why didn't we hear about these?  Yet I have pointers that she was there immediately after what SY call the abduction  8(>((


Enough info, but remember that I have seen photos a little girl dancing at the massive headquarters of Knights of St John at the little town of Xewkija on Gozo, and partially because my investigations took me to that exact spot to look and also because of a likeness to Kate and other things mentioned elsewhere on forum, I think it was almost cetrtainly Madeleine Mccann.  Alive in 2012?  I think so.

Also a British barrister came home from a visit to Malta and reputedly broke down as he told the British police that he thought that he had met Madeleine in Malta, introduced by a friend.  This was discussed on this forum about three years ago.  The discussion may or may not still be there, but members will remember it.   

I bet the barrister felt awful dropping his friend in it, but I guess he felt compelled to report it .  Brave man.

That's all for now 8()-000(


ETA.  Based upon facts and those photos, I think that Dave Edgar could very well be right about Madeleine being alive today.  I think she was in 2012 and when a little girl has won the hearts of the people looking after her, they are unlikely to have killed her,.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on August 27, 2017, 11:58:47 AM
A nice little earner for Edgar unless he has waived his fee off to a worthy cause? 

He appears to be paving the way ahead of a new private investigation which no doubt he wants to lead.

And lead he shall.... All right up a garden path.. This could be the big push to get more money for SY for the  end of September.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Brietta on August 28, 2017, 03:02:41 PM
David Edgar had a long and distinguished police career.

Before joining Cheshire constabulary as a constable, where he worked his way through the ranks, he had worked his way through the ranks in the Royal Ulster Constabulary.

I find his service in the RUC in particular exemplifies the finer points in the character of this man of which not the least is his bravery; he served in a country at a time when just putting on that uniform to go out to do his job in the community he served, was enough to put a target on his back or an explosive under the driver's seat of his vehicle.

This is a brave and honourable police officer with a proven track record of involvement in many highly successful investigations.

Those who attempt to denigrate him are in my opinion probably not fit to lace his boots.  I would be angry about it did I not find it so droll.
Keyboard warriors criticising a real warrior ... because of his time associated with Madeleine's case.  Nothing unique about that considering only those above and beyond criticism include a putative abductor.

Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: faithlilly on August 28, 2017, 03:10:48 PM
David Edgar had a long and distinguished police career.

Before joining Cheshire constabulary as a constable, where he worked his way through the ranks, he had worked his way through the ranks in the Royal Ulster Constabulary.

I find his service in the RUC in particular exemplifies the finer points in the character of this man of which not the least is his bravery; he served in a country at a time when just putting on that uniform to go out to do his job in the community he served, was enough to put a target on his back or an explosive under the driver's seat of his vehicle.

This is a brave and honourable police officer with a proven track record of involvement in many highly successful investigations.

Those who attempt to denigrate him are in my opinion probably not fit to lace his boots.  I would be angry about it did I not find it so droll.
Keyboard warriors criticising a real warrior ... because of his time associated with Madeleine's case.  Nothing unique about that considering only those above and beyond criticism include a putative abductor.

 Henri Exton, another brave and honourable police officer with a proven track record of involvement in many highly successful investigations, receives exactly the same treatment from supporters simply because he was highly dubious  of the McCann's and their friend's story.

Seems no one in this sorry saga's hands are clean.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Brietta on August 28, 2017, 03:34:33 PM
Henri Exton, another brave and honourable police officer with a proven track record of involvement in many highly successful investigations, receives exactly the same treatment from supporters simply because he was highly dubious  of the McCann's and their friend's story.

Seems no one in this sorry saga's hands are clean.

I don't recall Alpha Investigations Group being involved in defrauding anyone.  Different story for Oakley International though who manged to pull the wool over the eyes of quite a few including perhaps Henri Exton, who may not have been paid for more than £100,000 for work he was owed for Madeleine's case.
http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/141881/Madeleine-McCann-detective-charged-with-1m-con

Did Mr Exon try to retrieve that sum from Madeleine's Fund in the full knowledge there would be no way of getting it from his employer particularly with the FBI being first in the queue.
Interesting though nonetheless and a sure vehicle for discontent I would have thought.

Which leads me back to your post ... you have omitted the cite for your claim regarding Henri Exton ... would you mind terribly if I asked you to post it up.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: jassi on August 28, 2017, 03:42:15 PM
Were Alpha Investigation that ex-SAS group? 
If so just the people to have routed out that lawless village we hear so much about
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Angelo222 on August 28, 2017, 04:08:17 PM
Were Alpha Investigation that ex-SAS group? 
If so just the people to have routed out that lawless village we hear so much about

No, that was Halligen and Exton of Oakley which was formed from Halligen's Red Defence organisation specifically to look for Maddie.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 28, 2017, 05:49:49 PM
David Edgar had a long and distinguished police career.

Before joining Cheshire constabulary as a constable, where he worked his way through the ranks, he had worked his way through the ranks in the Royal Ulster Constabulary.

I find his service in the RUC in particular exemplifies the finer points in the character of this man of which not the least is his bravery; he served in a country at a time when just putting on that uniform to go out to do his job in the community he served, was enough to put a target on his back or an explosive under the driver's seat of his vehicle.

This is a brave and honourable police officer with a proven track record of involvement in many highly successful investigations.

Those who attempt to denigrate him are in my opinion probably not fit to lace his boots.  I would be angry about it did I not find it so droll.
Keyboard warriors criticising a real warrior ... because of his time associated with Madeleine's case.  Nothing unique about that considering only those above and beyond criticism include a putative abductor.

So his police record is available ?

What of the other officers he worked on investigations with ?


Or are you saying Edgar solved all the crimes he investigates by himself.

If you say yes, then cites would be useful.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Brietta on August 28, 2017, 06:55:36 PM
So his police record is available ?

What of the other officers he worked on investigations with ?


Or are you saying Edgar solved all the crimes he investigates by himself.

If you say yes, then cites would be useful.

Please read my post with more care before going off on one.

I said "This is a brave and honourable police officer with a proven track record of involvement in many highly successful investigations."

As far as I know British police officers work to a command structure and with that command directing teams of officers ... why on earth would you suggest other than that?
He was no different from other officers going out every day risking injury or death in the line of duty and in my opinion respect is due for that; just as it is for officers with a similar history.

David Edgar worked his way up through the ranks of the RUC ... he did likewise when he joined the force in Cheshire I think that shows admiral grit and determination.

What I find abhorrent is that armchair detectives see fit to denigrate this experienced retired detective because of his involvement in Madeleine McCann's case.

Time for them to look in before looking out to disparage anyone at all who holds a glimmer of hope for Madeleine in particular those who know what they are talking about.

Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: slartibartfast on August 28, 2017, 07:07:13 PM
Please read my post with more care before going off on one.

I said "This is a brave and honourable police officer with a proven track record of involvement in many highly successful investigations."

As far as I know British police officers work to a command structure and with that command directing teams of officers ... why on earth would you suggest other than that?
He was no different from other officers going out every day risking injury or death in the line of duty and in my opinion respect is due for that; just as it is for officers with a similar history.

David Edgar worked his way up through the ranks of the RUC ... he did likewise when he joined the force in Cheshire I think that shows admiral grit and determination.

What I find abhorrent is that armchair detectives see fit to denigrate this experienced retired detective because of his involvement in Madeleine McCann's case.

Time for them to look in before looking out to disparage anyone at all who holds a glimmer of hope for Madeleine in particular those who know what they are talking about.

He finished as a DI, next step from Sergeant.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 28, 2017, 07:08:58 PM
Please read my post with more care before going off on one.

I said "This is a brave and honourable police officer with a proven track record of involvement in many highly successful investigations."

As far as I know British police officers work to a command structure and with that command directing teams of officers ... why on earth would you suggest other than that?
He was no different from other officers going out every day risking injury or death in the line of duty and in my opinion respect is due for that; just as it is for officers with a similar history.

David Edgar worked his way up through the ranks of the RUC ... he did likewise when he joined the force in Cheshire I think that shows admiral grit and determination.

What I find abhorrent is that armchair detectives see fit to denigrate this experienced retired detective because of his involvement in Madeleine McCann's case.

Time for them to look in before looking out to disparage anyone at all who holds a glimmer of hope for Madeleine in particular those who know what they are talking about.

Read my post.

Let's have some cites for the cases he has solved himself.

As to Edgar, he has found absolutely NOTHING.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: sadie on August 28, 2017, 07:20:39 PM
Read my post.

Let's have some cites for the cases he has solved himself.

As to Edgar, he has found absolutely NOTHING.
Behave yourself stephen  You are putting words in Briettas mouth and bullying again.

Brietta very clearly said
Quote
with a proven track record of involvement in many highly successful investigations
.

She never said anything about his having solved cases on his own, but I bet he has.  Larger cases are usually a group effort led by a high ranking  officer and those are the ones which get publicity
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 28, 2017, 07:22:19 PM
I don't recall Alpha Investigations Group being involved in defrauding anyone.  Different story for Oakley International though who manged to pull the wool over the eyes of quite a few including perhaps Henri Exton, who may not have been paid for more than £100,000 for work he was owed for Madeleine's case.
http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/141881/Madeleine-McCann-detective-charged-with-1m-con

Did Mr Exon try to retrieve that sum from Madeleine's Fund in the full knowledge there would be no way of getting it from his employer particularly with the FBI being first in the queue.
Interesting though nonetheless and a sure vehicle for discontent I would have thought.

Which leads me back to your post ... you have omitted the cite for your claim regarding Henri Exton ... would you mind terribly if I asked you to post it up.

Nor I. Mind you they were only in existence for two years.
Incorporated on 10 June 2009.
Dissolved on 25 October 2011.
Then lest we forget a person whose name I disremember temporarily describing Oakley as "Really The Big Boys" involved in stuff they couldn't even talk about.
In my experience it pays to listen to the bells in yer 'ead. That one was a five by five DING frigging DONG.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 28, 2017, 07:26:52 PM
Behave yourself stephen  You are putting words in Briettas mouth and bullying again.

Brietta very clearly said .

She never said anything about his having solved cases on his own, but I bet he has.  Larger cases are usually a group effort led by a high ranking  officer and those are the ones which get publicity

So where is evidence of this proven track record ?
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: G-Unit on August 28, 2017, 07:41:45 PM
I don't recall Alpha Investigations Group being involved in defrauding anyone.  Different story for Oakley International though who manged to pull the wool over the eyes of quite a few including perhaps Henri Exton, who may not have been paid for more than £100,000 for work he was owed for Madeleine's case.
http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/141881/Madeleine-McCann-detective-charged-with-1m-con

Did Mr Exon try to retrieve that sum from Madeleine's Fund in the full knowledge there would be no way of getting it from his employer particularly with the FBI being first in the queue.
Interesting though nonetheless and a sure vehAicle for discontent I would have thought.

Which leads me back to your post ... you have omitted the cite for your claim regarding Henri Exton ... would you mind terribly if I asked you to post it up.

Who are this Alpha Investigations Group?

14 May 2009 Daily Mirror
Mr Edgar, who now runs the Alpha Investigations Group with business partner Arthur Cowley,

No he doesn't;

He said Mr Cowley’s company had no connection with the Madeleine investigation. ‘I am employed by the McCann family and I pick my staff,’ he added.

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1206842/Why-did-Madeleine-McCann-detectives-ask-questions.html#ixzz4r4nfLz4v
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook

Does an OBE trump a judge's commendation to a team of police officers?

31 December 1998
The Guardian
Excerpt:
ORDER OF THE BRITISH EMPIRE
OBE
(Awarded to)
Henri Herman Exton, QPM Grade 7, MoD
http://newsoutlines.blogspot.co.uk/2010/03/royal-victorian-medal.html
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: sadie on August 28, 2017, 07:43:09 PM
So where is evidence of this proven track record ?

Promotion to Inspector is pretty good especially as this was his second Police force.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: faithlilly on August 28, 2017, 10:46:20 PM
I don't recall Alpha Investigations Group being involved in defrauding anyone.  Different story for Oakley International though who manged to pull the wool over the eyes of quite a few including perhaps Henri Exton, who may not have been paid for more than £100,000 for work he was owed for Madeleine's case.
http://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/141881/Madeleine-McCann-detective-charged-with-1m-con

Did Mr Exon try to retrieve that sum from Madeleine's Fund in the full knowledge there would be no way of getting it from his employer particularly with the FBI being first in the queue.
Interesting though nonetheless and a sure vehicle for discontent I would have thought.

Which leads me back to your post ... you have omitted the cite for your claim regarding Henri Exton ... would you mind terribly if I asked you to post it up.

Oakley may have defrauded the fund. Exton was defrauded too. Further why do you think Exton ( sic) would have tried to retrieve money from the fund? Do you have any evidence on which to base your question?

Let's be clear, Exton defrauded non one and to suggest that his very critical report on the McCanns and their friends was shaped by being defrauded is not only ridiculous but I'm sure boardering on libel.

As to Exton, he is MI5’s former undercover operations chief. He was also awarded the Queen's Police Medal and is an OBE. So if we're playing your policeman is more successful than mine I think Exton knocks Edgar into a cocked hat.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Brietta on August 29, 2017, 12:13:29 AM
Oakley may have defrauded the fund. Exton was defrauded too. Further why do you think Exton ( sic) would have tried to retrieve money from the fund? Do you have any evidence on which to base your question?

Let's be clear, Exton defrauded non one and to suggest that his very critical report on the McCanns and their friends was shaped by being defrauded is not only ridiculous but I'm sure boardering on libel.

As to Exton, he is MI5’s former undercover operations chief. He was also awarded the Queen's Police Medal and is an OBE. So if we're playing your policeman is more successful than mine I think Exton knocks Edgar into a cocked hat.

The Sunday Times libelled the McCanns and were forced to pay substantial damages and issue an apology as a result.

Can you produce evidence in support of your allegation: Henri Exton's "very critical report on the McCanns and their friends"?

One of the libels admitted by the Sunday Times rather refutes there is any substance whatsoever in your claim which makes it not bordering on libel but is an actual libel if you cannot do so.

I await your cite with interest ... in the interim, here is mine.

Quote
As the newspaper now accepts, there is no question of the McCanns having
sought to suppress any evidence; indeed all of the material collated by the
private investigators had been provided to the relevant Portuguese and
Leicestershire police four years earlier. The private investigators' report
(including the e-fits) was also provided to the Metropolitan Police in 2011 shortly
after it commenced its review into Madeleine's disappearance.

http://www.carter-ruck.com/images/uploads/documents/McCann-Press_Release-03102014.PDF


By the way ... I stopped playing playground games along the lines of: "playing your policeman is more successful than mine" when I became an adult.  I recommend the experience to you.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: faithlilly on August 29, 2017, 10:35:23 AM
The Sunday Times libelled the McCanns and were forced to pay substantial damages and issue an apology as a result.

Can you produce evidence in support of your allegation: Henri Exton's "very critical report on the McCanns and their friends"?

One of the libels admitted by the Sunday Times rather refutes there is any substance whatsoever in your claim which makes it not bordering on libel but is an actual libel if you cannot do so.

I await your cite with interest ... in the interim, here is mine.

Quote
As the newspaper now accepts, there is no question of the McCanns having
sought to suppress any evidence; indeed all of the material collated by the
private investigators had been provided to the relevant Portuguese and
Leicestershire police four years earlier. The private investigators' report
(including the e-fits) was also provided to the Metropolitan Police in 2011 shortly
after it commenced its review into Madeleine's disappearance.

http://www.carter-ruck.com/images/uploads/documents/McCann-Press_Release-03102014.PDF


By the way ... I stopped playing playground games along the lines of: "playing your policeman is more successful than mine" when I became an adult.  I recommend the experience to you.

Not really sure why you have provided a cite. There is no argument that the Times paid damages to the McCanns for an article which later turned out to be partially untrue. Nowhere, however, within the text of the apology printed in the paper does it say that the reporter's description of the report was false. Below is the apology.

"In articles dated October 23 ("Madeleine clues hidden for 5 years" and "Investigators had E-Fits five years ago", News) we referred to efits which were included in a report prepared by private investigators for the McCanns and the Fund in 2008. We accept that the articles may have been understood to suggest that the McCanns had withheld information from the authorities. This was not the case. We now understand and accept that the efits had been provided to the Portuguese and Leicestershire police by October 2009. We also understand that a copy of the final report including the efits was passed to the Metropolitan police in August 2011, shortly after it commenced its review. We apologise for the distress caused."

As you will see the aology makes no mention of retracting the claim by a 'source close to the fund' that the report by Exton was ' “hypercritical of the people involved” and “would have been completely distracting” if it became public'. It also makes no mention of retracting the claim that Tanner's earlier sighting was dismissed as less credible after “serious inconsistencies” were found in her evidence or that there was questions about “anomalies” in the statements given by the McCanns and their friends.

I know it has been the supporter's habit to cherry pick the apology issued by the Times but the apology, as the above shows, was issued with regard to the allegations of hidden evidence and not the nature of Exton's report.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: G-Unit on August 29, 2017, 11:02:29 AM
Not really sure why you have provided a cite. There is no argument that the Times paid damages to the McCanns for an article which later turned out to be partially untrue. Nowhere, however, within the text of the apology printed in the paper does it say that the reporters description of the report was false. Below is the apology.

"In articles dated October 23 ("Madeleine clues hidden for 5 years" and "Investigators had E-Fits five years ago", News) we referred to efits which were included in a report prepared by private investigators for the McCanns and the Fund in 2008. We accept that the articles may have been understood to suggest that the McCanns had withheld information from the authorities. This was not the case. We now understand and accept that the efits had been provided to the Portuguese and Leicestershire police by October 2009. We also understand that a copy of the final report including the efits was passed to the Metropolitan police in August 2011, shortly after it commenced its review. We apologise for the distress caused."

As you will see the aology makes no mention of retracting the claim by a source close to the fund that the report by Exton was ' “hypercritical of the people involved” and “would have been completely distracting” if it became public'. It also makes no mention of retracting the claim that Tanner's earlier sighting was dismissed as less credible after “serious inconsistencies” were found in her evidence or that there was questions about “anomalies” in the statements given by the McCanns and their friends.

I know it has been the supporters habit to cherry pick the apology issued by the Times but the apology, as the above shows, was issued with regard to the allegations of hidden evidence and not the nature of Exton's report.

Exton confirmed last week that the fund had silenced his investigators for years after they handed over their controversial findings. He said: “A letter came from their lawyers binding us to the confidentiality of the report.”

He claimed the legal threat had prevented him from handing over the report to Scotland Yard’s fresh investigation, until detectives had obtained written permission from the fund.
https://jillhavern.forumotion.net/t8322-wow-a-must-read-madeleine-clues-hidden-for-five-years-sunday-times-full-article-now-on-page-1

It seems the e-fits were handed over to the PJ and LP in 2009, but there's no mention of the report being handed over until 2011. Was it handed over by Exton rather than by the McCanns? I can't think why SY would ask him for it if they already had it.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: faithlilly on August 29, 2017, 11:13:45 AM
Exton confirmed last week that the fund had silenced his investigators for years after they handed over their controversial findings. He said: “A letter came from their lawyers binding us to the confidentiality of the report.”

He claimed the legal threat had prevented him from handing over the report to Scotland Yard’s fresh investigation, until detectives had obtained written permission from the fund.
https://jillhavern.forumotion.net/t8322-wow-a-must-read-madeleine-clues-hidden-for-five-years-sunday-times-full-article-now-on-page-1

It seems the e-fits were handed over to the PJ and LP in 2009, but there's no mention of the report being handed over until 2011. Was it handed over by Exton rather than by the McCanns? I can't think why SY would ask him for it if they already had it.

So it would appear the report lay gathering dust for 3 years and even then it was not given over willingly.

I wonder how that played with OG ?
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Benice on August 29, 2017, 11:44:45 AM
Not really sure why you have provided a cite. There is no argument that the Times paid damages to the McCanns for an article which later turned out to be partially untrue. Nowhere, however, within the text of the apology printed in the paper does it say that the reporter's description of the report was false. Below is the apology.

"In articles dated October 23 ("Madeleine clues hidden for 5 years" and "Investigators had E-Fits five years ago", News) we referred to efits which were included in a report prepared by private investigators for the McCanns and the Fund in 2008. We accept that the articles may have been understood to suggest that the McCanns had withheld information from the authorities. This was not the case. We now understand and accept that the efits had been provided to the Portuguese and Leicestershire police by October 2009. We also understand that a copy of the final report including the efits was passed to the Metropolitan police in August 2011, shortly after it commenced its review. We apologise for the distress caused."

As you will see the aology makes no mention of retracting the claim by a 'source close to the fund' that the report by Exton was ' “hypercritical of the people involved” and “would have been completely distracting” if it became public'. It also makes no mention of retracting the claim that Tanner's earlier sighting was dismissed as less credible after “serious inconsistencies” were found in her evidence or that there was questions about “anomalies” in the statements given by the McCanns and their friends.

I know it has been the supporter's habit to cherry pick the apology issued by the Times but the apology, as the above shows, was issued with regard to the allegations of hidden evidence and not the nature of Exton's report.

Firstly, I am always very sceptical about anything claimed by 'a source' close to anyone or anything.

However, you seem to be assuming that it is the McCanns and their friends who were 'hypercriticised'.  You could be right, but unless we know for definite who ''the people involved'' are - it could refer to a number of people  - from the PJ to the UK police and all the other 'agencies'  in between who got involved.   IIRC there was criticism (with hindsight)  that the input of so many people turned out  to be less than helpful to the case in some people's opinion.

On the subject of cherry picking:  this was the same Times article where is was also announced that Martin Smith had changed his mind and no longer believed it was Gerry that he saw.    IIRC sceptics were not so keen to accept that the Times had got that right as they were to believe that the report had been withheld by the McCanns for 'sinister' reasons.   
AIMHO

Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: G-Unit on August 29, 2017, 12:11:44 PM
So it would appear the report lay gathering dust for 3 years and even then it was not given over willingly.

I wonder how that played with OG ?

Why did OG then sit on the information themselves until the Crimewatch programme in October 2013? The review stage ended before that;

the review became a full investigation in July 2012.
http://news.met.police.uk/news/update-on-the-investigation-into-the-disappearance-of-madeleine-mccann-135459
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: jassi on August 29, 2017, 12:13:20 PM
Perhaps " Top Cop " Redwood didn't appreciate the significance for a year or two.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: faithlilly on August 29, 2017, 12:27:41 PM
Firstly, I am always very sceptical about anything claimed by 'a source' close to anyone or anything.

However, you seem to be assuming that it is the McCanns and their friends who were 'hypercriticised'.  You could be right, but unless we know for definite who ''the people involved'' are - it could refer to a number of people  - from the PJ to the UK police and all the other 'agencies'  in between who got involved.   IIRC there was criticism (with hindsight)  that the input of so many people turned out  to be less than helpful to the case in some people's opinion.

On the subject of cherry picking:  this was the same Times article where is was also announced that Martin Smith had changed his mind and no longer believed it was Gerry that he saw.    IIRC sceptics were not so keen to accept that the Times had got that right as they were to believe that the report had been withheld by the McCanns for 'sinister' reasons.   
AIMHO

And the 'anomalies' ?
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: G-Unit on August 29, 2017, 12:31:50 PM
Firstly, I am always very sceptical about anything claimed by 'a source' close to anyone or anything.

However, you seem to be assuming that it is the McCanns and their friends who were 'hypercriticised'.  You could be right, but unless we know for definite who ''the people involved'' are - it could refer to a number of people  - from the PJ to the UK police and all the other 'agencies'  in between who got involved.   IIRC there was criticism (with hindsight)  that the input of so many people turned out  to be less than helpful to the case in some people's opinion.

On the subject of cherry picking:  this was the same Times article where is was also announced that Martin Smith had changed his mind and no longer believed it was Gerry that he saw.    IIRC sceptics were not so keen to accept that the Times had got that right as they were to believe that the report had been withheld by the McCanns for 'sinister' reasons.   
AIMHO

This is how the Times described the report, which they claim to have read;

Their report, seen by The Sunday Times, focused on a sighting by an Irish family of a man carrying a child at about 10pm on May 3, 2007, when Madeleine went missing.

An earlier sighting by one of the McCanns’ friends was dismissed as less credible after “serious inconsistencies” were found in her evidence. The report also raised questions about “anomalies” in the statements given by the McCanns and their friends.

As well as questioning parts of the McCanns’ evidence, it contained sensitive information about Madeleine’s sleeping patterns and raised the highly sensitive possibility that she could have died in an accident after leaving the apartment herself from one of two unsecured doors.
https://jillhavern.forumotion.net/t8322-wow-a-must-read-madeleine-clues-hidden-for-five-years-sunday-times-full-article-now-on-page-1

They have no direct quote from Martin Smith.


Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Brietta on August 29, 2017, 12:38:53 PM
Not really sure why you have provided a cite. There is no argument that the Times paid damages to the McCanns for an article which later turned out to be partially untrue. Nowhere, however, within the text of the apology printed in the paper does it say that the reporter's description of the report was false. Below is the apology.

"In articles dated October 23 ("Madeleine clues hidden for 5 years" and "Investigators had E-Fits five years ago", News) we referred to efits which were included in a report prepared by private investigators for the McCanns and the Fund in 2008. We accept that the articles may have been understood to suggest that the McCanns had withheld information from the authorities. This was not the case. We now understand and accept that the efits had been provided to the Portuguese and Leicestershire police by October 2009. We also understand that a copy of the final report including the efits was passed to the Metropolitan police in August 2011, shortly after it commenced its review. We apologise for the distress caused."

As you will see the aology makes no mention of retracting the claim by a 'source close to the fund' that the report by Exton was ' “hypercritical of the people involved” and “would have been completely distracting” if it became public'. It also makes no mention of retracting the claim that Tanner's earlier sighting was dismissed as less credible after “serious inconsistencies” were found in her evidence or that there was questions about “anomalies” in the statements given by the McCanns and their friends.

I know it has been the supporter's habit to cherry pick the apology issued by the Times but the apology, as the above shows, was issued with regard to the allegations of hidden evidence and not the nature of Exton's report.

It is quite simple ... as a direct result of the newspaper article to which you refer ... and the shameful conduct of the newspaper in refusal to interact with the McCanns ... they were forced to seek the redress of the law.

The Sunday Times admitted libel.

Quote
The Sunday Times' allegations were completely false. As the newspaper
now accepts, there is no question of the McCanns having sought to
suppress any evidence
; indeed all of the material collated by the private
investigators had been provided
to the relevant Portuguese and
Leicestershire police four years earlier. The private investigators' report
(including the e-fits) was also provided to the Metropolitan Police in 2011
shortly after the Met commenced its review into Madeleine's
disappearance.  Carter Ruck Solicitors
https://www.carter-ruck.com/images/uploads/documents/McCann-Press_Release-03102014.PDF

Therefore you are asserting that the information in the article which was proved to be wrong and therefore libel ... which the libel court agreed was libel ... which the offender agreed was libel ... is still fine to be bandied about as fact.

One simply cannot challenge that sort of mentality.

Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: faithlilly on August 29, 2017, 12:57:08 PM
It is quite simple ... as a direct result of the newspaper article to which you refer ... and the shameful conduct of the newspaper in refusal to interact with the McCanns ... they were forced to seek the redress of the law.

The Sunday Times admitted libel.

Quote
The Sunday Times' allegations were completely false. As the newspaper
now accepts, there is no question of the McCanns having sought to
suppress any evidence
; indeed all of the material collated by the private
investigators had been provided
to the relevant Portuguese and
Leicestershire police four years earlier. The private investigators' report
(including the e-fits) was also provided to the Metropolitan Police in 2011
shortly after the Met commenced its review into Madeleine's
disappearance.  Carter Ruck Solicitors
https://www.carter-ruck.com/images/uploads/documents/McCann-Press_Release-03102014.PDF

Therefore you are asserting that the information in the article which was proved to be wrong and therefore libel ... which the libel court agreed was libel ... which the offender agreed was libel ... is still fine to be bandied about as fact.

One simply cannot challenge that sort of mentality.

I have already posted the apology issued by the Times, detailing what the apology was for. At no time did they apologise for anything they claimed was contained in Exton's report.

Of course if you are claiming otherwise I am sure you will be able to supply a cite.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Benice on August 29, 2017, 01:04:39 PM
And the 'anomalies' ?

I would expect there to be anomalies even if only 2 people were involved  - let alone 9.     Memories are notoriously fallible and different people have vastly different perceptions of time, distance etc. and also different levels of the power of recall.      It would have been highly suspicious if there had been no anomalies or inconsistencies as that would strongly suggest collusion IMO.

There are some major anomalies in many of the statements made by witnesses outside of the group - especially with regard to times.   No-one has claimed that this is proof that some of them must be lying.

IMO
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Benice on August 29, 2017, 01:19:53 PM
This is how the Times described the report, which they claim to have read;

Their report, seen by The Sunday Times, focused on a sighting by an Irish family of a man carrying a child at about 10pm on May 3, 2007, when Madeleine went missing.

An earlier sighting by one of the McCanns’ friends was dismissed as less credible after “serious inconsistencies” were found in her evidence. The report also raised questions about “anomalies” in the statements given by the McCanns and their friends.

As well as questioning parts of the McCanns’ evidence, it contained sensitive information about Madeleine’s sleeping patterns and raised the highly sensitive possibility that she could have died in an accident after leaving the apartment herself from one of two unsecured doors.
https://jillhavern.forumotion.net/t8322-wow-a-must-read-madeleine-clues-hidden-for-five-years-sunday-times-full-article-now-on-page-1

They have no direct quote from Martin Smith.

They also received no complaint or demand for a retraction from Martin Smith - otherwise we would have seen it in the form of an apology etc. 

Martin Smith was quick to threaten legal action against newspapers who misrepresented him.   This 'claim'' made by the Times could not have been more momentous if it tried as it was a complete turnaround from his previous stance.

I do not believe for a second that Martin Smith would have allowed such a massive lie to be printed about him - if it was indeed a complete fabrication.  The fact that no apology or retraction was ever forthcoming says it all AFAIAC.

IMHO


Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: slartibartfast on August 29, 2017, 01:24:45 PM
It is quite simple ... as a direct result of the newspaper article to which you refer ... and the shameful conduct of the newspaper in refusal to interact with the McCanns ... they were forced to seek the redress of the law.

The Sunday Times admitted libel.

Quote
The Sunday Times' allegations were completely false. As the newspaper
now accepts, there is no question of the McCanns having sought to
suppress any evidence
; indeed all of the material collated by the private
investigators had been provided
to the relevant Portuguese and
Leicestershire police four years earlier. The private investigators' report
(including the e-fits) was also provided to the Metropolitan Police in 2011
shortly after the Met commenced its review into Madeleine's
disappearance.  Carter Ruck Solicitors
https://www.carter-ruck.com/images/uploads/documents/McCann-Press_Release-03102014.PDF

Therefore you are asserting that the information in the article which was proved to be wrong and therefore libel ... which the libel court agreed was libel ... which the offender agreed was libel ... is still fine to be bandied about as fact.

One simply cannot challenge that sort of mentality.

I would expect the paper to publish the least apology possible the the lawyers couldn't dispute and the libel lawyers to publish what they would have liked the paper to say.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Brietta on August 29, 2017, 01:28:27 PM
Exton confirmed last week that the fund had silenced his investigators for years after they handed over their controversial findings. He said: “A letter came from their lawyers binding us to the confidentiality of the report.”

He claimed the legal threat had prevented him from handing over the report to Scotland Yard’s fresh investigation, until detectives had obtained written permission from the fund.
https://jillhavern.forumotion.net/t8322-wow-a-must-read-madeleine-clues-hidden-for-five-years-sunday-times-full-article-now-on-page-1

It seems the e-fits were handed over to the PJ and LP in 2009, but there's no mention of the report being handed over until 2011. Was it handed over by Exton rather than by the McCanns? I can't think why SY would ask him for it if they already had it.

Note the year ... 2011.

Let me see ... what was it that happened in 2011?

Thinks  &%+((£ ? ? ?  Madeleine's case had been abandoned in 2008.  In 2007 her mum and dad were forced to continue directing the Madeleine Fund money to finance their own continuing search for her.

As a result of there being no official police search private investigators such as Dave Edgar were employed to carry out that task.  They ensured continuity of the search for a missing child and they collected information.

In 2011 ... Scotland Yard sanctioned by the government instituted an official review of Madeleine McCann's case.

Can you see any connection between Madeleine's case being reviewed officially and all the information in the possession of those who had been conducting the only investigation into her disappearance since her case was archived in 2008 being passed to the official review team?

Most people can make the connection ... I won't hold my breath though for others.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: faithlilly on August 29, 2017, 01:29:04 PM
I would expect there to be anomalies even if only 2 people were involved  - let alone 9.     Memories are notoriously fallible and different people have vastly different perceptions of time, distance etc. and also different levels of the power of recall.      It would have been highly suspicious if there had been no anomalies or inconsistencies as that would strongly suggest collusion IMO.

There are some major anomalies in many of the statements made by witnesses outside of the group - especially with regard to times.   No-one has claimed that this is proof that some of them must be lying.

IMO
 

Of course Exton, being a highly decorated police officer, would know that and yet he still found the 'anomalies' disturbing enough to include them in his report.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Brietta on August 29, 2017, 01:36:11 PM

Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!

Back on topic please
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Alice Purjorick on August 29, 2017, 05:53:03 PM
Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!

Back on topic please

Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!


Correct she could be.
End of thread
Tara a bit
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on August 29, 2017, 06:24:28 PM

Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!


Correct she could be.
End of thread
Tara a bit


Aye so what are the chances...  she is either dead or alive . Him and the family and supporters have no evidence of either scenario, but the agenda is she is alive and well and happy... 8)--))
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: sadie on August 29, 2017, 08:42:42 PM

Aye so what are the chances...  she is either dead or alive . Him and the family and supporters have no evidence of either scenario, but the agenda is she is alive and well and happy... 8)--))
Seems that you are unhappy that Madeleine may well be alive !

How odd
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 29, 2017, 08:45:38 PM
Seems that you are unhappy that Madeleine may well be alive !

How odd

Where ?
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: sadie on August 29, 2017, 09:12:32 PM
Where ?
Try NSY or Porto PJ, stephen

They might just tell you being as you are such an ardent supporter of everything they do  8(0(*
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 29, 2017, 09:15:38 PM
Try NSY or Porto PJ, stephen

They might just tell you being as you are such an ardent supporter of everything they do  8(0(*

They haven't found how Madeleine disappeared Sadie.

If you can prove otherwise, please provide citations.

Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: sadie on August 29, 2017, 09:45:02 PM
They haven't found how Madeleine disappeared Sadie.

If you can prove otherwise, please provide citations.

In YOUR opinion ... and none of us are in a position to KNOW with any certainty

Please dont forget the rules, 'In your opinion'
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 29, 2017, 09:48:05 PM
In YOUR opinion ... and none of us are in a position to KNOW with any certainty

Please dont forget the rules, 'In your opinion'

So all your pointers and theories are effectively of no consequence whatsoever.

If they had solved the crime, if there was one, then they would not be pursuing  the 'one last lead' we have heard of for over 2 years now.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: faithlilly on August 29, 2017, 10:02:17 PM
http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/sunday-life/madeleine-mccann-still-alive-and-could-be-minutes-from-where-she-disappeared-claims-exdetective-36076016.html

Snip...“There’s one reason I’m sure Madeleine is alive — a body hasn’t been found,” he said.

“In my experience as a detective, when strangers kill children, or if strangers kill anyone for that matter, they do one thing very quickly and almost automatically — they dump the body of their victim so they’re not caught with it. That’s just the way it works.

“So, without a body, somebody must have taken Maddie away and be keeping her alive.”

Dave’s theory is drawn from the 30 years of experience he accrued in the RUC and Cheshire Police."

Has Edgar never heard of Keith Bennett, Genett Tate and Ben Needham?

Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: stephen25000 on August 29, 2017, 10:06:52 PM
http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/sunday-life/madeleine-mccann-still-alive-and-could-be-minutes-from-where-she-disappeared-claims-exdetective-36076016.html

Snip...“There’s one reason I’m sure Madeleine is alive — a body hasn’t been found,” he said.

“In my experience as a detective, when strangers kill children, or if strangers kill anyone for that matter, they do one thing very quickly and almost automatically — they dump the body of their victim so they’re not caught with it. That’s just the way it works.

“So, without a body, somebody must have taken Maddie away and be keeping her alive.”

Dave’s theory is drawn from the 30 years of experience he accrued in the RUC and Cheshire Police."

Has Edgar never heard of Keith Bennett, Genett Tate and Ben Needham?

If he is up to the task, he should have known, or he is deliberately ignoring it.

IMHO , of course.


Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: G-Unit on August 29, 2017, 10:18:00 PM
Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!

Back on topic please

One of his theories is that a lone paedophile has kept her imprisoned in a cellar or dungeon. What a terrible idea to suggest to her parents and to publicise in the media. It's enough to give her family nightmares in my opinion.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: faithlilly on August 29, 2017, 10:18:17 PM
If he is up to the task, he should have known, or he is deliberately ignoring it.

IMHO , of course.

Of course Stephen. We know for absolute certain that Keith Bennett was murdered yet the killers didn't dump his body but very carefully buried it on Saddleworth Moor. So carefully that over 50 years later, and after several exhaustive searches, it has never been found.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: faithlilly on August 29, 2017, 10:19:55 PM
One of his theories is that a lone paedophile has kept her imprisoned in a cellar or dungeon. What a terrible idea to suggest to her parents and to publicise in the media. It's enough to give her family nightmares in my opinion.

And yet he more than likely would have had to have sought permission from the fund to talk about the case to the newspaper in the first place.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Brietta on August 30, 2017, 12:50:00 AM
And yet he more than likely would have had to have sought permission from the fund to talk about the case to the newspaper in the first place.

Why would you think that?
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: faithlilly on August 30, 2017, 11:00:15 AM
Why would you think that?

If Oakley signed a confidentiality clause it is only common sense to suppose Edgar did too.
Title: Re: Former RUC officer Dave Edgar says Madeleine McCann could still be alive!
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on August 30, 2017, 07:40:07 PM
If Oakley signed a confidentiality clause it is only common sense to suppose Edgar did too.

Having said that Edgar was not aware of full facts, just breadcrumbs, few by the parents.

It is worth noting that the RUC have many, many unsolved murders in their case books. Not a pleasant job for the officers and not for the families either.