UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: John on August 27, 2017, 02:08:38 PM
-
Madeleine McCann - Missing But Never Forgotten
(https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/e/e9/Sunday_Life_Logo.gif)
By Tony Allen
Published Sun 27 August 2017
26
[attachment deleted by admin]
-
Yep. Same old rubbish, reheated.
Have to wonder, why now?
-
Edgar mentions that 13 mil + is not enough for a case this complex? seriously complex how? child goes missing. can't be found. no DNA or evidence to show involvement of any stranger involved with this situation.
Nothing complex about that at all. No doubt after the tax payers invest 65 million in Edgar ( I know where she is and its too complex to explain) to find her we can all go to bed with smiles on our faces...
Or we can just pat him on the head and sigh and there, there..
-
If Dave Edgar was so convinced that Madeleine had been secreted in some abductors lair not that far from Luz, why then boast to have spent three years scouring the world for her? These claims are nonsensical.
-
If Dave Edgar was so convinced that Madeleine had been secreted in some abductors lair not that far from Luz, why then boast to have spent three years scouring the world for her? These claims are nonsensical.
That is the nub of it, and it could be expressed in several colourful metaphors.
-
The Sunday Life and Edgar missed the most likely scenario and that is that she went out looking for her father and was run over. The driver of the car not knowing where she had come from probably decided to take her for medical attention but on discovering she was dead thought better of it and hid her remains. All imho
-
The Sunday Life and Edgar missed the most likely scenario and that is that she went out looking for her father and was run over. The driver of the car not knowing where she had come from probably decided to take her for medical attention but on discovering she was dead thought better of it and hid her remains. All imho
Dave Edgar would be delighted to head a new private enquiry, I bet he would, will he do it for free? And if he's so confident the girl is where he claims she is why hasn't the area around Luz been 'scoured' by him already, after all he's had numerous years to do it?
Or is it as I suspect, another case of blowing ones own trumpet? Maybe he or Sunday Life will reveal how much he was paid for that story since I don't see any waiver?
-
Edgar mentions that 13 mil + is not enough for a case this complex? seriously complex how? child goes missing. can't be found. no DNA or evidence to show involvement of any stranger involved with this situation.
Nothing complex about that at all. No doubt after the tax payers invest 65 million in Edgar ( I know where she is and its too complex to explain) to find her we can all go to bed with smiles on our faces...
Or we can just pat him on the head and sigh and there, there..
Would that be true if it were an established child trafficking ring?
-
No, we've probably got to the point where is she turns up, great, otherwise we are not going to let the fate of a person we don't know effect us over much.
Hmmmm ... bit of a conundrum there don't you think? Taking into consideration the amount of time you spend doing just that.
Cite
... we are not going to let the fate of a person we don't know effect us over much Slartibartfast
The difference between internet pundits like you and me and Dave Edgar is ... he really does know what he is talking about.
-
Hmmmm ... bit of a conundrum there don't you think? Taking into consideration the amount of time you spend doing just that.
Cite
... we are not going to let the fate of a person we don't know effect us over much Slartibartfast
The difference between internet pundits like you and me and Dave Edgar is ... he really does know what he is talking about.
So what does Edgar actually know ?
Having read through his various articles and newspaper articles on him, not a lot IMHO.
His success in helping solve the case, a big fat 0%
-
Hmmmm ... bit of a conundrum there don't you think? Taking into consideration the amount of time you spend doing just that.
Cite
... we are not going to let the fate of a person we don't know effect us over much Slartibartfast
The difference between internet pundits like you and me and Dave Edgar is ... he really does know what he is talking about.
He didn't know what he was talking about when he make a fool of himself holding a press conference with Mitchell. He was appealing for information about a woman without doing any basic inquiries first.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1206842/Why-did-Madeleine-McCann-detectives-ask-questions.html
-
He didn't know what he was talking about when he make a fool of himself holding a press conference with Mitchell. He was appealing for information about a woman without doing any basic inquiries first.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1206842/Why-did-Madeleine-McCann-detectives-ask-questions.html
Indeed. That has become infamous IMO, in terms of rank stupidity.
-
He didn't know what he was talking about when he make a fool of himself holding a press conference with Mitchell. He was appealing for information about a woman without doing any basic inquiries first.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1206842/Why-did-Madeleine-McCann-detectives-ask-questions.html
Or when claiming in Lisbon he had read only part of the files.
'GP – Did you have access to the criminal process?
DE answers that he read parts of the files in the translation that the McCanns asked to be done.'
-
Or when claiming in Lisbon he had read only part of the files.
'GP – Did you have access to the criminal process?
DE answers that he read parts of the files in the translation that the McCanns asked to be done.'
He was not hired to review the first investigation he was hired to search for Madeleine. He investigated what he was told to investigate imo.
-
He was not hired to review the first investigation he was hired to search for Madeleine. He investigated what he was told to investigate imo.
Therefore his work was, and his opinion is, worthless.
Some of Edgar's finest work.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/7364631/McCanns-detective-searching-for-girl-in-a-wig-seen-with-two-gipsies.html
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1206842/Why-did-Madeleine-McCann-detectives-ask-questions.html
And lest we forget the classic ' Madeleine's abductor may be a woman'.
-
Therefore his work was, and his opinion is, worthless.
Some of Edgar's finest work.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/7364631/McCanns-detective-searching-for-girl-in-a-wig-seen-with-two-gipsies.html
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1206842/Why-did-Madeleine-McCann-detectives-ask-questions.html
And lest we forget the classic ' Madeleine's abductor may be a woman'.
Isn't that what happened to Elizabeth Smart - hidden in plain sight?
http://www.thedailybeast.com/amanda-berry-jaycee-dugard-and-more-kidnap-victims-found-alive-photos
"Mitchell and his wife, Wanda Barzee, held Smart captive for nine months as they wandered through California and Utah. Mitchell claimed to be a fundamentalist street preacher who had been told to take “seven sisters” as wives—and he repeatedly sexually assaulted Smart as he held her captive, telling her she was his wife. They hid in broad daylight by disguising Smart in veils and wigs."
-
Isn't that what happened to Elizabeth Smart - hidden in plain sight?
http://www.thedailybeast.com/amanda-berry-jaycee-dugard-and-more-kidnap-victims-found-alive-photos
"Mitchell and his wife, Wanda Barzee, held Smart captive for nine months as they wandered through California and Utah. Mitchell claimed to be a fundamentalist street preacher who had been told to take “seven sisters” as wives—and he repeatedly sexually assaulted Smart as he held her captive, telling her she was his wife. They hid in broad daylight by disguising Smart in veils and wigs."
Those cases did not attract a hundredth of the worldwide publicity afforded to the McCann case. Realistically how easy do you think it would be to hide a child who has been described as 'the most famous missing person in the world' in plain site ?
-
Those cases did not attract a hundredth of the worldwide publicity afforded to the McCann case. Realistically how easy do you think it would be to hide a child who has been described as 'the most famous missing person in the world' in plain site ?
You have probably missed this story posted by Brietta, Faith, showing that even in modern-day Portugal whole communities can exist without the outside world knowing. Those within that community have probably never heard of Madeleine McCann or seen her picture.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=8376.msg418571#msg418571
-
He was not hired to review the first investigation he was hired to search for Madeleine. He investigated what he was told to investigate imo.
In YOUR opinion, nothing more.
-
You have probably missed this story posted by Brietta, Faith, showing that even in modern-day Portugal whole communities can exist without the outside world knowing. Those within that community have probably never heard of Madeleine McCann or seen her picture.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=8376.msg418571#msg418571
u
I only see one community misty and I'm pretty sure Madeleine isn't being hidden there.
-
Therefore his work was, and his opinion is, worthless.
Some of Edgar's finest work.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopics/madeleinemccann/7364631/McCanns-detective-searching-for-girl-in-a-wig-seen-with-two-gipsies.html
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1206842/Why-did-Madeleine-McCann-detectives-ask-questions.html
And lest we forget the classic ' Madeleine's abductor may be a woman'.
And you are basing this on what ?
Just on Gunits opinion, see post above
-
In YOUR opinion, nothing more.
As he didn't read all the files it follows that he didn't review their contents which is why I said IN MY OPINION that he was hired to search for Madeleine. He confirms that was his function.
ID – After explaining the purpose of the trial, she asks what DE’s function was.
DE answers he tried to discover where Madeleine was.
GP – Did you have access to the criminal process?
DE answers that he read parts of the files in the translation that the McCanns asked to be done.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=2301.0
-
He was not hired to review the first investigation he was hired to search for Madeleine. He investigated what he was told to investigate imo.
Like most PI's on a substantial retainer, they do what they are told. Have readers forgotten the confidentiality clause inserted in their contracts which prevents them from speaking out after they are fired?
Now why would the innocent parents of a missing little girl need such a clause? What was there to hide?
-
Like most PI's on a substantial retainer, they do what they are told. Have readers forgotten the confidentiality clause inserted in their contracts which prevents them from speaking out after they are fired?
Now why would the innocent parents of a missing little girl need such a clause? What was there to hide?
So I would assume Edgar had to go to the fund directors and ask for their permission to talk to the newspaper.
-
So I would assume Edgar had to go to the fund directors and ask for their permission to talk to the newspaper.
I wouldn't have thought so since it is all old news anyway.
Just noticed the Belfast Telegraph, who publish the Sunday Life, have put Edgar's theory on their website now.
http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/sunday-life/madeleine-mccann-still-alive-and-could-be-minutes-from-where-she-disappeared-claims-exdetective-36076016.html
-
I wouldn't have thought so since it is all old news anyway.
Of course this is a rehash of an article published in March of this year, I think, but anyone who thinks that Edgar would talk to the media without the fund's direct permission is naive to say the least.
-
Of course this is a rehash of an article published in March of this year, I think, but anyone who thinks that Edgar would talk to the media without the fund's direct permission is naive to say the least.
I would say that anyone seeking to be employed by the Fund would be very careful in what they say to the media. For all we know it was someone acting for the Fund who encouraged Edgar to give the interview ahead of the Met funding decision.
-
u
I only see one community misty and I'm pretty sure Madeleine isn't being hidden there.
If she was living within the travelling community she could easily be hidden in plain sight.
-
He was not hired to review the first investigation he was hired to search for Madeleine. He investigated what he was told to investigate imo.
The McCanns may well have prioritised the areas of the case they wanted him to concentrate on first. That seems perfectly reasonable to me.
IMO
-
Like most PI's on a substantial retainer, they do what they are told. Have readers forgotten the confidentiality clause inserted in their contracts which prevents them from speaking out after they are fired?
Now why would the innocent parents of a missing little girl need such a clause? What was there to hide?
It's my understanding that these clauses are commonplace and are put in place primarily to prevent employees of people in the public eye from selling their 'stories' to the newspapers both during their employment and especially after it ceases - for huge amounts of money.
A necessary safeguard IMO.
-
If she was living within the travelling community she could easily be hidden in plain sight.
Is that your best hope - that she's living the life of a raggle taggle gypsy ?
-
The McCanns may well have prioritised the areas of the case they wanted him to concentrate on first. That seems perfectly reasonable to me.
IMO
It is perfectly reasonable. My point was that if he hasn't read the files I wouldn't describe him as knowing what he's talking about.
-
Is that your best hope - that she's living the life of a raggle taggle gypsy ?
No, don't be silly. My best hope is that she is alive, healthy, happy(ish) & being well-educated like so many other children who are trafficked for adoption.
-
If she was living within the travelling community she could easily be hidden in plain sight.
If she was living with a travelling community how does that reconcile with Edgar's "nicked by a sex trafficking gang".
-
If she was living with a travelling community how does that reconcile with Edgar's "nicked by a sex trafficking gang".
It was another example of hiding in plain sight as a poster was not happy with the Elizabeth Smart answer. Have you any idea how many children are trafficked out of India to the USA, the same with Guatemala & various other countries?
http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2009/03/meet-parents-dark-side-overseas-adoption/
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2000/jun/13/internationalcrime
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/7522678.stm
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2049647/BBC-documentary-exposes-50-year-scandal-baby-trafficking-Catholic-church-Spain.html
Many of those children are out there, living in communities which have no idea who they really are. If Madeleine has been abducted for trafficking at least the her parents & authorities are providing the chance she could be recovered.
-
It was another example of hiding in plain sight as a poster was not happy with the Elizabeth Smart answer. Have you any idea how many children are trafficked out of India to the USA, the same with Guatemala & various other countries?
http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2009/03/meet-parents-dark-side-overseas-adoption/
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2000/jun/13/internationalcrime
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/americas/7522678.stm
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2049647/BBC-documentary-exposes-50-year-scandal-baby-trafficking-Catholic-church-Spain.html
Many of those children are out there, living in communities which have no idea who they really are. If Madeleine has been abducted for trafficking at least the her parents & authorities are providing the chance she could be recovered.
It is generally from poor countries to rich ones.
-
Those cases did not attract a hundredth of the worldwide publicity afforded to the McCann case. Realistically how easy do you think it would be to hide a child who has been described as 'the most famous missing person in the world' in plain site ?
I suspect, not as difficult as all that in other countries. That is after the initial period when her face was in all the papers. And long enough would have to be given for Madeleine to normalise her new situation in life.
Also, drugs can be given to make people forget their past
-
I suspect, not as difficult as all that in other countries. That is after the initial period when her face was in all the papers. And long enough would have to be given for Madeleine to normalise her new situation in life.
Also, drugs can be given to make people forget their past
Cite on the drugs.
-
If she was living with a travelling community how does that reconcile with Edgar's "nicked by a sex trafficking gang".
The deal fell through.
-
u
I only see one community misty and I'm pretty sure Madeleine isn't being hidden there.
Yep, we are all aware of only one community, but PT is quite a large country with many remote mountainous regions where there are few people around.
And we learn things as we go along
At one time we were only aware of Madeleine going missing,, then we found out about a string of kids missing
At one time we were only aware of Leonor cipriano being tortured, now we know of Virgolino Borges and Michael Cook (and maybe Jacintha Rees)
At one time we were aware of only one PJ Inspector having a criminal record. Now we know of at least four
With the nature of the hinterland of PT I think it quite possible that there are villages that few know of, where Madeleine COULD be hidden.
However, i doubt that Madeleine is hidden in PT.
-
It is generally from poor countries to rich ones.
I believe that Portugal is the 3rd poorest country financially in Europe & around 25% of the population live in some form of poverty. Do you think that excludes them from child trafficking, given their prominence in the drug-trafficking route?
-
I believe that Portugal is the 3rd poorest country financially in Europe & around 25% of the population live in some form of poverty. Do you think that excludes them from child trafficking, given their prominence in the drug-trafficking route?
So you equate Portugal with India and Guatemala? I suppose it fits the narrative.
-
So you equate Portugal with India and Guatemala? I suppose it fits the narrative.
Read my post again. India is one of the 10 richest countries globally.
-
Read my post again. India is one of the 10 richest countries globally.
42 vs 123
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita)
-
42 vs 123
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita)
That is per capita, not total wealth of country.
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/economy/indicators/india-among-10-rich-countries-but-average-indian-quite-poor-report/articleshow/52520769.cms
-
That is per capita, not total wealth of country.
http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/economy/indicators/india-among-10-rich-countries-but-average-indian-quite-poor-report/articleshow/52520769.cms
...and?
It's about individual wealth not entire countries.
-
...and?
It's about individual wealth not entire countries.
This was Alice's post. to which I duly responded.....
"It is generally from poor countries to rich ones".
No mention of individual wealth.
-
I would say that anyone seeking to be employed by the Fund would be very careful in what they say to the media. For all we know it was someone acting for the Fund who encouraged Edgar to give the interview ahead of the Met funding decision.
Indeed.
-
This was Alice's post. to which I duly responded.....
"It is generally from poor countries to rich ones".
No mention of individual wealth.
It was my post and there are many definitions of rich and poor countries. I mean in terms of individuals hence per capita.
-
This was Alice's post. to which I duly responded.....
"It is generally from poor countries to rich ones".
No mention of individual wealth.
I don't remember posting that.
I must be going Seminole.
-
I don't remember posting that.
I must be going Seminole.
Not you; it was my mistake looking back at the post. Sorry.
-
Topic please!
-
Topic please!
How would you define the topic John?
-
How would you define the topic John?
Isn't one of the most frequently asked questions by those who feel the need to question a variation of a theme of ...
"Why Madeleine McCann?"
"What about all the other missing children?"
Those who are missing are never forgotten by those who know and love them but if there is press interest it very soon fades ... making it a fair question: "Why Madeleine?"
For example, I think there is plenty in the opening post worthy of some good analytical discussion to inform of what steps can be taken for any missing child in the early stages of a disappearance and if sadly those have failed to keep the child alive in the public eye.
-
I don't remember posting that.
I must be going Seminole.
God forbid.
-
Missing but not forgotten? nice. I am sure many people want Maddie to be found alive, what I am not sure about is how will they cope if she comes forward with a nightmare of a story about what was happening to her. Yes, it would upset the parents oops we can't have a thread that doesn't mention the parents pain, or the supporters to feel it on their behalf.
'Missing not forgotten' yes, nice, fluffy and lovely image. Let's bow our heads and remember how it happened...oh god better not that would be trolling...