UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Robittybob1 on September 15, 2017, 09:36:43 AM
-
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MCCANNS-WANTED.htm
How many of those people that were on that list did not get interviewed, or how many do not have a file in the McCann PJ files?
Why would the McCanns have asked for these people to be interviewed?
"Faxed from Society of Attorneys 16 Oct 2007 to Ministerio Publico in Portimao.
GERALD PATRICK MCCANN and KATE MARIE HEALY, better identified in the documents referenced above, approach, very respectfully, to set forth and request, Sir, the following:
1 - Since the applicants stopped being considered witnesses, moving to suspects of the disappearance of Madeleine McCann, witnesses central to the discovery of truth were not questioned, or re-questioned.
2 - With the recent investigations, witness interviews and interrogations of the applicants, new questions were raised and doubts aroused, broadening, in this way, the object of the investigation, as well as matters of fact considered relevant to the investigations.
3 - Indeed, the Investigation departed from confining itself to the disappearance of the minor, proceeding to embrace other matters, allegedly connected with her.
4 - It is therefore essential to hear these witnesses who can explain facts now very relevant, such as the way the couple treated their children, their personality and routine and, even, the reactions manifested by them after the disappearance and the consequent psychological and emotional state.
5 - So, and because it is believed essential and indispensable for the establishment of the facts and consequent discovery of the truth, they come to request the hearing of the following groups of witnesses, all present and with direct knowledge of the facts:
Group 1 (persons with whom the couple dined every night during the holidays)
David Payne, with address at ...> (Leicester) (0,774,884 ####)
Fiona Payne to address in ...> (Leicester) (0,779,627 ####)
Diane Webster, with address at ...> (Renhold, Bedford) (0,123,477 ####)
Russell O'Brien, with address at ...> (Exeter) 0,771,325 ####)
Jane Tanner, with address at ...> (Exeter) (6,780,858 #####)
Rachael Oldfield, with address at ...> (London) (0,777,159 ####)
Matthew Oldfield, with address at ...> (London) (0,777,159 ####)
Group 2 (independent customers and employees of the Ocean Club who saw the behavior of Kate and Gerry on the day of the disappearance):
Dan Smith, with address at ...> (Ocean Club, c / o Mark Warner)
Steve Carpenter, with address at ...> (Ware, Herts) (0,781,577 ####)
Carolyn Carpenter, with address at ...> (Ware, Herts)
Jeremy Wilkins, with address at ...> (London)
Catriona Baker, with address at ...> (Surrey) (0,785,823 ####)
Group 3 (people who saw and/or spoke with Kate and Gerry at the time they noticed Madeleine's disappearance):
Patricia Cameron, with address at ...> (Dumbarton) (079,122 ####)
Paul Seddon, with address at ...> (Salford) (079,262 #####)
Michelle Thompson, with address at ...> (Liverpool) (0,151,280 ####)
Emma Kinghts, with address at ...> (Ocean Club, c / o Mark Warner) (3,519,614 ####)
Alan Pike, with address at ...> (Skipton) (0,781,212 ####)
Group 4 (people who knew the daily routine of Kate and Gerry and their relationship with their children before coming to Portugal):
Janet Kennedy, with address at ...> (Rothley, Leics) (0,118,230 ####)
Amanda Coxon, with address at ...> (Leicestershire) (0,794,042 ####)
Karen McCalman, with address at ...> (Leicesterhire) (0,116,269 ####)
Patricia Cameron, with address at ...> (Dumbarton) (0791 202 ####)
Sharon Lewin, with address at ...> (Leicester) (0,788,780 ####)
Hayley Plummer, with address at ...> (Syston) (0,778,987 ####)
Group 5 (persons closely involved in the routine of Kate and Gerry in Portugal after the disappearance of Madeleine and their emotional state)
Sandy Cameron, with address at ...> (Dumbarton) (0,793,399 ####)
Michael Wright, with address at ...> (Skipton) (0,777,556 ####)
Clarence Mitchell, with address at ...> (Bath) (0,779,628 ####)
Linda McQueen, with address at ...> (Merseyside) (0,780,956 ####)
Nicky Gill, with address at ...> (Liverpool) (079,004 ####)
Justine McGuiness, with address at ...> (Dorchester) (0,780,109 ####)
Group 6 (Professionals who can confirm that there was no abnormality in the way Kate and Gerry treated their children):
Dr. Phil Hussey, with address at ...> (Leics) (0,116,260 ####)
Dr Ian Schofield, with address at ...> (Mountsorrel) (0,116,230 ####)
6 - It is certain that some of these witnesses have already been heard, at least once, in the investigation.
7 - But, at that time, the direction of the investigation was apparently different, [that being] the reason why some of these witnesses were not heard on the matters mentioned above, currently considered relevant to the prosecution of the investigation and who already were, furthermore, the object of actual proceedings, namely the questioning and the interrogations of the applicants.
We submit that, their testimony [being] essential to the discovery of the truth, and given that the witnesses designated above actually live in the United Kingdom, where they will be found, (except Dan Smith and Emma Knights who will be found in Portugal), it is requested further, under Arts. 229 and following of CPP, 145 and following of Law 14-4/99 of 31 August (Law of International Legal Assistance in Criminal Matters) and 3 and following of the European Convention on Mutual Legal Support in Criminal Matters, that a Rogatory Letter be expedited for them to be heard in the United Kingdom.
They ask that the request be granted
The Advocates
CARLOS PINTO DE ABREU
ROGERIO ALVES"
-
I fail to see the objective of this thread Robbie. Once the focus of the investigation moved from stranger abduction to possible parental involvement, the onus then moved to the parents to establish what occurred on the night that Maddie disappeared. To provide corroboration it was essential that these witnesses be spoken to. I see no mystery in that?
-
How does it work in Portugal? Did the McCanns get to see all the statements once they became arguidos or not? If not did they just choose a list of people that could have been important for some reason. I was hoping to try and understand why the people on this list were included on the list. OK it might be speculative but upon completing this we may have an insight as to what was going on. I have no idea whether it will work or not.
They can only name names of people they had met or talked to subsequently.
-
Group 1 are the Tapas 7 - we know why they were reinterviewed.
Group 2 (independent customers and employees of the Ocean Club who saw the behavior of Kate and Gerry on the day of the disappearance):
Dan Smith, with address at ...> (Ocean Club, c / o Mark Warner)
Steve Carpenter, with address at ...> (Ware, Herts) (0,781,577 ####)
Carolyn Carpenter, with address at ...> (Ware, Herts)
Jeremy Wilkins, with address at ...> (London)
Catriona Baker, with address at ...> (Surrey) (0,785,823 ####)
Does Dan Smith have a file? TBH I've never heard of his name before.
-
Dan Smith is that the same as Peter Daniel Smith?
"1615 to 1624 Witness Testimony of Peter Daniel Smith taken 2007/05/26 with map of sighting
6-Processos, Volume VI, pgs. 1615 to1624
06_VOLUME_VIa_Page_1615
06_VOLUME_VIa_Page_1616
06_VOLUME_VIa_Page_1617
06_VOLUME_VIa_Page_1618
06_VOLUME_VIa_Page_1619
06_VOLUME_VIa_Page_1620
06_VOLUME_VIa_Page_1621
06_VOLUME_VIa_Page_1622
06_VOLUME_VIa_Page_1623
06_VOLUME_VIa_Page_1624
Date of Diligence: 2007.05.26 15H30
Location: DIC Portimao
Name: PETER DANIEL SMITH"
Otherwise it draws a complete blank.
-
Steve Carpenter is obviously Stephen Carpenter. http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/STEPHEN-CARPENTER.htm
Date of interview 2008.05.17 Is there evidence this was a follow-up or not?
"Duration of Interview: 39 minutes
DCF: Do you agree with me reading out your statement'
SC: Yes, I agree, yes.
DCF: Or would you prefer to read out the statement yourself'
SC: No, thats fine, you can read it.
DCF: I thought it would make more sense that way:
SC: Ah ha."
So I would say there is an earlier statement which is no longer in the file.
-
Carolyn Carpenter no statement I know of.
"Carolyn Carpenter
Rogatory interview not included in DVD:
2. Page 18 Interview Carolyn Elizabeth CARPENTER, she was interviewed on 21st April 2008, the interview was recorded on DVD, please see enclosed 1 copy of the transcript, 1 copy of the DVD, 1 copy of her statement and a copy of the
Detective's statement evidencing the interview.
Carolyn Carpenter page 18"
So there is evidence of a statement being taken but it is not included. - Suspicious?
-
Carolyn Carpenter no statement I know of.
"Carolyn Carpenter
Rogatory interview not included in DVD:
2. Page 18 Interview Carolyn Elizabeth CARPENTER, she was interviewed on 21st April 2008, the interview was recorded on DVD, please see enclosed 1 copy of the transcript, 1 copy of the DVD, 1 copy of her statement and a copy of the
Detective's statement evidencing the interview.
Carolyn Carpenter page 18"
So there is evidence of a statement being taken but it is not included. - Suspicious?
Yes, IMO very suspicious
Because also the statements of
Raj Balu ....................... http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RAJ_BALU.htm
Raj; "I did not ask to see my original statements in order to refresh my memory. I confirm that these statements are correct". . Where are the original statements?
and
Neil Berry ....................http://mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/NEIL_BERRY.htm re missing statement of 7th May 2007
Neil: "From 22.00 onwards all the events that took place were already described in my previous statement of 7th May 2007 and i cannot add any further information, other than that which was already added." Where is the previous statement?
These two men are the only people who can give a verification that they spoke with Gerry when he was searching.
Carolyn Carpenter heard Madeleines name called, or was it whispered? Was she near an abductor at that moment? Did The Carpenters path cross the abductors?
These three people could (possibly) support Gerry ... yet in isolation their statements have vanished. Why?
I find it very suspicious and wonder if there was something in them that crossed Amarals "theory"... so they were hidden. I bet SY will have interviewed these three and will know now what is missing.
I realise that I could be wrong, but how come the three pertinent statements all vanished?
Only my thoughts, but really rather suspicious.
-
Your post includes the McCann's reasons for including people at the top of each group they want interviewing, Rob.
I think they wanted the tennis coach, Dan Stuk (not Smith) to be interviewed - his location being given as Mark Warner.
-
Your post includes the McCann's reasons for including people at the top of each group they want interviewing, Rob.
I think they wanted the tennis coach, Dan Stuk (not Smith) to be interviewed - his location being given as Mark Warner.
Well if you think you got his name did the PJ click on too and interview Dan Stuk, another name I've never heard of.
Yes a statement is included http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/DAN-STUK.htm It gives a good report on Gerry and Kate.
-
Well if you think you got his name did the PJ click on too and interview Dan Stuk, another name I've never heard of.
Yes a statement is included http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/DAN-STUK.htm It gives a good report on Gerry and Kate.
Allegedly more than 700 persons were questioned so that is hardly surprising.
-
Allegedly more than 700 persons were questioned so that is hardly surprising.
The release of the files no hence those interviewed should really have put paid to the myth of the poor investigation.
-
The release of the files no hence those interviewed should really have put paid to the myth of the poor investigation.
There are always those who prefer the comfort zone of writing on cave walls...... 8(>((
-
Somehow the PJ missed interviewing some key people. They never got round to Donna Hill, and John Hill wasn't interviewed until 30th June 2007. Emma Knight's first interview was 30th April 2008.
There is a typed list called MW employees and Emma Knight is on that, but for some reason wasn't interviewed. Donna Hill isn't on it, and her husband was added in pen.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P4/04_VOLUME_IVa_Page_852.jpg
-
The release of the files no hence those interviewed should really have put paid to the myth of the poor investigation.
It is the pattern of what files have not been released that concern me deeply, to the point I think the PJ on this case need to be internally reviewed to see if there was any hint of corruption.
-
It is the pattern of what files have not been released that concern me deeply, to the point I think the PJ on this case need to be internally reviewed to see if there was any hint of corruption.
Why?, for not releasing all the files for your perusal ?
-
Why?, for not releasing all the files for your perusal ?
For not releasing the ones potentially supportive of Gerry.
-
For not releasing the ones potentially supportive of Gerry.
I'm sure the department of Justice had good reason for witholding the files that they did. Not convinced it was a PJ decision.
-
For not releasing the ones potentially supportive of Gerry.
...or damaging? We don't know what they say and can't draw conclusions.
-
...or damaging? We don't know what they say and can't draw conclusions.
I don't think the McCanns would be want the PJ to interview witnesses that were known to be hostile. Going by the names on this list these were the ones that would have seen Kate and Gerry the most.
-
I'm sure the department of Justice had good reason for witholding the files that they did. Not convinced it was a PJ decision.
Exactly therefore there needs to be a review to see if there was an element of deception going on behind the scenes.
-
Exactly therefore there needs to be a review to see if there was an element of deception going on behind the scenes.
Then you'd better write and tell them.
-
Then you'd better write and tell them.
We will don't worry about that.
-
I don't worry about these things. They don't impinge on my life.
-
It is the pattern of what files have not been released that concern me deeply, to the point I think the PJ on this case need to be internally reviewed to see if there was any hint of corruption.
The investigation was reviewed in 2012.
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/portugal-police-review-madeleine-mccann-case-7546882.html
-
We will don't worry about that.
Who are the 'we' Rob ?
-
The investigation was reviewed in 2012.
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/portugal-police-review-madeleine-mccann-case-7546882.html
Any review would have its objectives. I am asking for a review with the objective of looking for evidence of corruption in the PJ team working on the McCann case. This is a topic often talked about but quickly put aside as they don't want to upset the Portuguese.
-
Any review would have its objectives. I am asking for a review with the objective of looking for evidence of corruption in the PJ team working on the McCann case. This is a topic often talked about but quickly put aside as they don't want to upset the Portuguese.
Who is 'they' ? Who often talks about corruption ?
-
Who are the 'we' Rob ?
I am assembling a team at the moment, obviously there is myself and I hope to include "Laura" as the interpreter. I don't have all the names as yet but that is the plan.
-
I am assembling a team at the moment, obviously there is myself and I hope to include "Laura" as the interpreter. I don't have all the names as yet but that is the plan.
How much are you going to raise SY,£12,£13,£14 million?
-
Who is 'they' ? Who often talks about corruption ?
There are many interviews recorded and I recall them saying things like a review should happen after the case is solved, not now while it is still in progress. Are you not aware of these conversations? I'll see if I can get a transcript or footage to show you.
-
I am assembling a team at the moment, obviously there is myself and I hope to include "Laura" as the interpreter. I don't have all the names as yet but that is the plan.
Do you expect SY to take you seriously?
-
There are many interviews recorded and I recall them saying things like a review should happen after the case is solved, not now while it is still in progress. Are you not aware of these conversations? I'll see if I can get a transcript or footage to show you.
Are these credible persons or just air-heads like of lot of commentators?
-
Are these credible persons or just air-heads like of lot of commentators?
Gerry McCann and SY officials etc.
-
Any review would have its objectives. I am asking for a review with the objective of looking for evidence of corruption in the PJ team working on the McCann case. This is a topic often talked about but quickly put aside as they don't want to upset the Portuguese.
I think you might be letting your imagination run away with you Rob. Anyone can see the evidence the PJ collected and why they followed the path they did.
-
Do you expect SY to take you seriously?
I'm going to deal with the Portuguese directly from now on.
-
I think you might be letting your imagination run away with you Rob. Anyone can see the evidence the PJ collected and why they followed the path they did.
You and I look at the same problem in slightly different ways. Every now and then our views align but obviously not on this one.
-
How much are you going to raise SY,£12,£13,£14 million?
Are you willing to back the fighting fund?
-
Are you willing to back the fighting fund?
A fool and his money are soon parted, I don't recognise either when looking in the mirror.
-
A fool and his money are soon parted, I don't recognise either when looking in the mirror.
This is not the place for insults.
-
This is not the place for insults.
Care to show where I insulted any one?
-
Care to show where I insulted any one?
I was reminding myself not to insult you my dear friend.
-
Well done, Rob, for taking the initiative 8((()*/
The potential injustices of Carolyn Carpenters, Neil Berrys and Raj Balus statements vanishing has bugged me for a long time .. and I have mentioned them several times on this forum ... but no-one seemed to realise just how important it was to Gerry that they vanished.
I always wondered about corruption; if they were with-held because they crossed Amarals theory, but I couldn't be sure ... so with no forum interest, I let it drop
I congratulate you on pressing forward with them. The situation needs looking at. 8@??)(
-
Well done, Rob, for taking the initiative 8((()*/
The potential injustices of Carolyn Carpenters, Neil Berrys and Raj Balus statements vanishing has bugged me for a long time .. and I have mentioned them several times on this forum ... but no-one seemed to realise just how important it was to Gerry that they vanished.
I always wondered about corruption; if they were with-held because they crossed Amarals theory, but I couldn't be sure ... so with no forum interest, I let it drop
I congratulate you on pressing forward with them. The situation needs looking at. 8@??)(
I have glanced at this previously. The missing statements were taken by LP. They were passed on to the Home Office. The Home Office passed them to the PGDL in Lisbon. I assume they passed them to the PJ.
As far as I can see LP definitely sent both Carpenter statements to the Home Office but only one of them is in the files. AFAIK it's not possible to prove that the PJ received everything, so suggesting that they withheld statements is conjecture.
.http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FRANCES_KENNAH.htm
-
I have glanced at this previously. The missing statements were taken by LP. They were passed on to the Home Office. The Home Office passed them to the PGDL in Lisbon. I assume they passed them to the PJ.
As far as I can see LP definitely sent both Carpenter statements to the Home Office but only one of them is in the files. AFAIK it's not possible to prove that the PJ received everything, so suggesting that they withheld statements is conjecture.
.http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FRANCES_KENNAH.htm
It is conjecture alright but it needs looking into to sort it out. I'm really only asking the questions that an enquiry could handle.
-
Group 1 are the Tapas 7 - we know why they were reinterviewed.
Group 2 (independent customers and employees of the Ocean Club who saw the behavior of Kate and Gerry on the day of the disappearance):
Dan Smith, with address at ...> (Ocean Club, c / o Mark Warner)
Steve Carpenter, with address at ...> (Ware, Herts) (0,781,577 ####)
Carolyn Carpenter, with address at ...> (Ware, Herts)
Jeremy Wilkins, with address at ...> (London)
Catriona Baker, with address at ...> (Surrey) (0,785,823 ####)
Does Dan Smith have a file? TBH I've never heard of his name before.
A name very similar to dan Smith appears in this document and it says a statement was gained.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FRANCES_KENNAH.htm
"11. Page 45 (PJ Ref VI) Interview (Duncan Raymond) Raymond Duncan SMITH - He was interviewed on 30th April 2008 and a statement obtained, please see enclosed copy."
He seems to very his name so Duncan could easily be remembered as Dan.
So we will never get to know what Dan Smith testified.
-
While looking through that list of interviews the name Jeremy Wilkins came up and he was on the list requested by the McCanns too.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FRANCES_KENNAH.htm
"23. Page 50 (PJ Ref X) Interview Jeremy Michael WILKINS - He declined to be interviewed on DVD but did agree to a written statement. He was interviewed on 7th April 2008 and a statement obtained, please see enclosed copy."
OK Kate refused to answer questions and Wilkins declined to be interviewed on DVD. How many others declined? Search for the word declined: No others declined. Is that significant?
To point it mildly this statement was Rollox.
-
Group 1 are the Tapas 7 - we know why they were reinterviewed.
Group 2 (independent customers and employees of the Ocean Club who saw the behavior of Kate and Gerry on the day of the disappearance):
Dan Smith, with address at ...> (Ocean Club, c / o Mark Warner)
Steve Carpenter, with address at ...> (Ware, Herts) (0,781,577 ####)
Carolyn Carpenter, with address at ...> (Ware, Herts)
Jeremy Wilkins, with address at ...> (London)
Catriona Baker, with address at ...> (Surrey) (0,785,823 ####)
Next on that list is Catriona Baker.
"34. Page 19 - Interview Catriona BAKER who worked as a child minder/creche worker at the Mark Warner resort - She was interviewed on 14th April 2008 and a statement obtained, please see enclosed copy." http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FRANCES_KENNAH.htm
In the file it is dated "CATRIONA BAKER 18-04-08 ROGATORY"
In this statement it states "I was interviewed on DVD, by DC GIERC of the Leicestershire Police between 10h09 and 10h54 on Monday, 14th of April of 2008 in the Leicestershire police headquarters. I can affirm that my statement on DVD is truthful and in accord with my understanding.
Between 11h57 and 12h12 of the same day I was again interviewed on DVD by DC GIERC. During this interview I was permitted to refresh my memory after reading my translated original statement made to the Portuguese police. There are two facts that I would like to clarify: "dining out service" which is mentioned is available for the adults, being that the children would be left under the care of a childcare worker during dinner. My original deposition also mentioned that Madeleine offered more attention to the boys in the club. I do not remember having made such an affirmation given that Madeleine passed the majority of time playing with Jane Tanner's daughter. I confirm that the deposition in this second DVD is truthful and in accord with my knowledge and that it will be registered.
Between 13h35 and 13h45 of the same day I was once again interviewed by DC GIERC. One more time I confirm that my statement is true and in accord with my understanding.
This statement is truthful and in accord with my understanding."
But looking at the opening paragraph "
cr5_3
cr5_4
cr5_5
cr5_6
LEICESTERSHIRE POLICE SQUAD
WITNESS TESTIMONY OF CATRIONA SISILE BAKER
Occupation: Childcare worker
This statement, consisting of four pages, each signed by me, is true to the best of my knowledge and belief and I make it knowing that, if it is tendered in evidence, I shall be liable to prosecution if I have wilfully states in it anything I know to be false or do not believe to be true.
Date: 18 of April, 2008
Signature: "
I imagine it took a couple of days to type up and she came and signed it on the 18th yet the interview was on the 14th. No problems. I wonder if the correction she pointed out was made to her original statement?
Corrections " There are two facts that I would like to clarify: "dining out service" which is mentioned is available for the adults, being that the children would be left under the care of a childcare worker during dinner. My original deposition also mentioned that Madeleine offered more attention to the boys in the club. I do not remember having made such an affirmation given that Madeleine passed the majority of time playing with Jane Tanner's daughter." Were they note on her original statement CATRIONA BAKER STATEMENT 06-05-07?
The sixth of May statement does not mention "attention to the boys"
There seems to be an amendment re the dining out service. " * Dining Out Service 7.30pm-11.30pm
(children are watched in a room above the main Ocean Club 24 hour reception; there is no extra charge for this service but parents must take and fetch their own children)"
Amendments made but no dates on the amendments.
-
Now we will look at Group 3 and see if statement s were collected from them and if they ended up in the PJ files.
"Group 3 (people who saw and/or spoke with Kate and Gerry at the time they noticed Madeleine's disappearance):
Patricia Cameron, with address at ...> (Dumbarton) (079,122 ####)
Paul Seddon, with address at ...> (Salford) (079,262 #####)
Michelle Thompson, with address at ...> (Liverpool) (0,151,280 ####)
Emma Kinghts, with address at ...> (Ocean Club, c / o Mark Warner) (3,519,614 ####)
Alan Pike, with address at ...> (Skipton) (0,781,212 ####)
-
35. Page 20 - Interview Paul SEDDON - He was interviewed on 16th April 2008 and a statement obtained, please see enclosed copy. (http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FRANCES_KENNAH.htm)
statement taken OK
Witness statement of Paul Seddon (McCann Priest) 2008.04.16 in file http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/PAUL_SEDDEN.htm (incorrect spelling of his name)
Quite a moving testimony really. - Thanks Paul.
-
Next on list "Patricia Cameron, with address at ...> (Dumbarton) (079,122 ####) "
"36. Page 22 - Interview Patricia CAMERON - this is a duplicate request, please refer to Page 20 of this letter."
"3. Page 20 Interview of Patricia CAMERON, she was interviewed on 15th April 2008, and a statement obtained, please see enclosed copy." http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FRANCES_KENNAH.htm
What does the statement say? Basically OK.
-
Next is Michelle Thompson "Michelle Thompson, with address at ...> (Liverpool) (0,151,280 ####) "
"13. Page 20. Interview of Michelle THOMPSON - she was interviewed on 7th May 2008, and a statement obtained, please see enclosed copy."
is her statement in the released file? Yes http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/M_THOMPSON.htm
major points:
"On the morning of the 4th of May, 2007, Kate called our land line but we did not hear it as we were asleep and did not put the phone on the bed. She left a message and asked us to call her once we heard the message. Kate must have tried Jon?s mobile once as we stirred when it rang at about 03h20. Jon spoke briefly with Kate and then called her around 03h30. I knew that Kate and Gerry were on holidays in Portugal. Kate was very anguished and on the telephone and told me that she had checked on the children every half-hour. It was around 22h00, and when she went to check on the children she found that someone had entered the apartment and taken Madeleine from where she slept; that Madeleine had been abducted. The person must have entered, passed by the twins and taken her. "
Is there a statement from Jon Corner? Not in the file and not on list http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FRANCES_KENNAH.htm
I wonder why Jon Corner is left of the list even though Kate spoke to Jon first.
-
Next two "Emma Kinghts, with address at ...> (Ocean Club, c / o Mark Warner) (3,519,614 ####)
Alan Pike, with address at ...> (Skipton) (0,781,212 ####) "
We are all aware of Emma Knights statement.
What about Allan Pike?
Witness statement of Alan Robert Pike (crisis counsellor) 2008.05.07 http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/ALAN-PIKE.htm
"I got to know Gerald McCann and Kate Healy on Saturday, May 5, 2007. I would describe my relationship with them in totally clinical terms. I provided them counselling help with regards to their emotional state provoked by the fact that they were separated from their daughter Madeleine. I spoke with Gerry and Kate very early in the morning on the 5th of May, 2007. Our services were requested by the Mark Warner agency. I travelled specifically to speak to them in person, and with the family and agency functionaries."
-
Group 4 (people who knew the daily routine of Kate and Gerry and their relationship with their children before coming to Portugal):
Janet Kennedy, with address at ...> (Rothley, Leics) (0,118,230 ####)
Amanda Coxon, with address at ...> (Leicestershire) (0,794,042 ####)
Karen McCalman, with address at ...> (Leicesterhire) (0,116,269 ####)
Patricia Cameron, with address at ...> (Dumbarton) (0791 202 ####)
Sharon Lewin, with address at ...> (Leicester) (0,788,780 ####)
Hayley Plummer, with address at ...> (Syston) (0,778,987 ####)
-
Janet Kennedy -
"25. Page 53 (PJ Ref XII) Identify babysitters to the McCann's children - These were identified as being Janet KENNEDY and Sharon LEWIN both of who have been interviewed and are subject to separate entries on this report." Quote: Frances Kennah
Statement available.
Point made "Gerry is a typical male and is very organised, but I feel it is Kate who dominates. Gerry adores Kate. At times, Gerry appears to be totally absorbed in his work showing some difficulty concentrating outside of this realm. Kate brings him back to reality. At times, he can appear rude or curt. I would say that they have a fresh relationship, and they are very much in love with one another and admire each other immensely. Gerry is very paternal, not only with his children but this is a natural trait that has nothing to do with his experience as a doctor. "
Clarification added "Instead of using the term 'is the one who dominates' with regard to the relationship between Kate and Gerry, I would like to state that they respect each other's decisions and all decisions are taken together. It was Kate's own proposal to stay at home and look after the children instead of returning to work as a doctor." Amendment not made to statement.
-
Amanda Coxon
"27. Page 54 (PJ Ref XIII) Identify housemaid(s) to the McCann family - Amanda COXON is employed to look after the children and assist with household tasks. COXON is being interviewed and her statement will be subject to a separate entry."
"15. Page 21. Interview of Amanda COXON - she was interviewed on 2nd May 2008, and a statement obtained, please see enclosed copy." Kennah.
Statement http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/AMANDA-COXON.htm
Point: all positive.
"With relation to the question about haemorrhages, I was never present at any episode when Madeleine bled, other than a normal nose bleed when she inserted her finger into her nose and bled.
Nothing different from any other child having a nose bleed."
-
Karen McCalman.
"6. Page 21 Interview of Karen McCALMAN, she was interviewed on 16th May 2008, and a statement obtained, please see enclosed copy." Kennah.
Karen McCalman's statement is not with the file.
-
Patricia Cameron, with address at ...> (Dumbarton) (0791 202 ####) already covered.
Sharon Lewin, with address at ...> (Leicester) (0,788,780 ####)
Hayley Plummer, with address at ...> (Syston) (0,778,987 ####)
Sharon Lewin and Hayley Plummer:
"26. Page 53 (PJ Ref XII) Identify nursery staff to the McCann family - They were identified as Sharon LEWIN and Hayley PLUMMER, both have been interviewed and statements obtained. (See separate entries on this report)" Kennah.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/SHARON_LEWIN.htm "At the nursery medication could only be administered by the senior members of staff and with the agreement of the children's parents. The only medication that I recall Madeleine taking was Calpol to lower her temperature."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/HAYLEY_PLUMBER.htm "Gerry and Kate never appeared to have any type of problem in their relation with Madeleine. We would have regular meetings with the parents in the nursery and Kate and Gerry did not express any worry about Madeleine or her behaviour and they never appeared to be tired or frustrated in relation to their daughter."
-
Group 5 might be a bit more interesting.
"Group 5 (persons closely involved in the routine of Kate and Gerry in Portugal after the disappearance of Madeleine and their emotional state)
Sandy Cameron, with address at ...> (Dumbarton) (0,793,399 ####)
Michael Wright, with address at ...> (Skipton) (0,777,556 ####)
Clarence Mitchell, with address at ...> (Bath) (0,779,628 ####)
Linda McQueen, with address at ...> (Merseyside) (0,780,956 ####)
Nicky Gill, with address at ...> (Liverpool) (079,004 ####)
Justine McGuiness, with address at ...> (Dorchester) (0,780,109 ####) "
Sandy Cameron http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/A-J-CAMERON.htm
Point: "On one occasion, I believe it was on July of 2007, I took Patricia to the supermarket. We carried bags in the boot (trunk) of the Renault Scenic; bought various items including fresh fish, shrimp and beef. When we unloaded the shopping bags, we noticed that blood has run out of the bottom of the plastic bag. After this shopping trip and still in the month of July 2007, I began to notice a strange odour in the car. I did not give it much importance and assumed it was likely due to the leakage from the rubbish bags or from the blood which had escaped from the shopping bags. As a result, we removed the carpet from the boot (trunk) in order to clean it. I tossed (beat) the boot carpet to remove any particles and cleaned it with a wet cloth and left it to air out. "
Michael Wright "3. Page 44 ( PJ Ref V) Interview Michael WRIGHT (cousin of Kate McCann). He was interviewed on 16th April 2008 and a statement obtained, please see enclosed copy." No statement from cousin but another Michael Wright unrelated.
Clarence Mitchell "41. Page 22 - Interview Clarence MITCHELL - He was interviewed on 28th April 2008 and a statement obtained, please see enclosed copy."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CLARENCE_EDEN_MITCHELL.htm
Point: "With regard to Kate and Gerry's behaviour; Their behaviour has been entirely of constant anguish, typical of parents who have lost their daughter in tragic circumstances. Everything that they said or did leads me to believe that they are completely innocent of involvement in the disappearance of Madeleine."
Linda McQueen "16. Page 22. Interview of Linda Ruth McQUEEN - she was interviewed on 7th May 2008, and a statement obtained, please see enclosed copy."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/L-R-MCQUEEN.htm
Point: "I have known Kate since 6 months of age and my mother and hers are still today great friends."
Nicky Gill "17. Page 22. Interview of Nicky GUI (Nicky Toni GILL) - she was interviewed on 7th May 2008, and a statement obtained, please see enclosed copy."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/NICKY_GILL.htm
Point: "On the following night at about midnight, Kate contacted me by phone, she was devastated and appeared lost. She said that judging from the action of the local police, one would think that she "had lost a dog". Her situation was one of desperation."
Justine McGuiness "18. Page 22. Interview of Justine McGUINNESS - she was interviewed on 12th May 2008, and a statement obtained, please see enclosed copy."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JUSTINE_MCGUINESS.htm
Point: "Because of my knowledge of the routine and the amount of members from press that surrounded them, I think it unlikely that they could have hidden or transported Madeleine in the vehicle."
-
A name very similar to dan Smith appears in this document and it says a statement was gained.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/FRANCES_KENNAH.htm
"11. Page 45 (PJ Ref VI) Interview (Duncan Raymond) Raymond Duncan SMITH - He was interviewed on 30th April 2008 and a statement obtained, please see enclosed copy."
He seems to very his name so Duncan could easily be remembered as Dan.
So we will never get to know what Dan Smith testified.
Raymond Duncan Smith was one of the people who hired the Renault before the McCanns did.
49 to 50-Witness statement of Duncan Raymond Smith (former Renault Scenic lessee) 2008.04.30
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/C_ROGATORIA_5.htm
-
Raymond Duncan Smith was one of the people who hired the Renault before the McCanns did.
49 to 50-Witness statement of Duncan Raymond Smith (former Renault Scenic lessee) 2008.04.30
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/C_ROGATORIA_5.htm
Were there 3 people in that category? There are certainly three that have caused a bit of confusion:
Duncan Raymond Smith
John Brown http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JOHN_BROWN.htm
Michael Wright http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MICHAEL_WRIGHT_1_MAY_08.htm
for on one document it says Michael Wright was a cousin of Kate , but Michael says he doesn't know them. I suppose that is possible, you don't have to know your cousins but why would the McCanns want a statement from someone they don't know.
-
Were there 3 people in that category? There are certainly three that have caused a bit of confusion:
Duncan Raymond Smith
John Brown http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JOHN_BROWN.htm
Michael Wright http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MICHAEL_WRIGHT_1_MAY_08.htm
for on one document it says Michael Wright was a cousin of Kate , but Michael says he doesn't know them. I suppose that is possible, you don't have to know your cousins but why would the McCanns want a statement from someone they don't know.
I believe there are 2 Michael Wrights Rob - Michael George Wright and Michael Terence Wright - Kate's relative
CARTAS ROGATORIAS (FILE 5)
MICHAEL WRIGHT 16th April 2008
66 to 69?Witness statement of
Michael Terence Wright 2008.04.16
My wife is Kate's cousin and I have known Kate since she was 8 years old. She used to spend holidays on Isle of Man where I lived. My wife's and Kate's families are quite close. I have known Gerry since 1997 when he was going out with Kate before they married.