UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: John on September 28, 2017, 04:34:26 PM
-
Scotland Yard given another £154,000 to allow them to explore a further theory as to what became of Madeleine McCann. The detective work itself which is being referred to as being 'sensitive in nature' is being pursued in Portugal by Portuguese police.
There were fears that Operation Grange would be wound down this week but this further funding should see investigative work continue until next year. It is widely accepted however that should this latest theory prove to be yet another dead end, the enquiry will be shelved until such time as new and compelling evidence is found.
The Operation Grange team whch originally consisted of over 20 detectives was scaled down dramatically last year to a team of two officers overseen by a supervising officer. Their task is to collate information and coordinate with those overseas detectives still pursuing enquiries abroad.
70
-
Jerry Lawton has just tweeted that the funding is set to continue.
Jerry Lawton @JerryLawton 3m3 minutes ago
More
The police probe into the disappearance of Madeleine #McCann is to continue after the Home Office grants Scotland Yards extra funds
I'm delighted the Home Secretary has decided to extend funding for Madeleine's case. I was worried it might have been a case of spoiling the ship for a halfpenny worth of tar.
With reference to John's post regarding the sensitive nature of the work being carried out ... it seems to confirm that rapport has been established between the PJ and SY after reports of a shaky start at the reopening of the case in 2013.
That can only be beneficial should such a cooperation in a major case ever be required in the future.
-
I'm delighted the Home Secretary has decided to extend funding for Madeleine's case. I was worried it might have been a case of spoiling the ship for a halfpenny worth of tar.
With reference to John's post regarding the sensitive nature of the work being carried out ... it seems to confirm that rapport has been established between the PJ and SY after reports of a shaky start at the reopening of the case in 2013.
That can only be beneficial should such a cooperation in a major case ever be required in the future.
SY is in a no win situation, they are damned if they do and damned if they don't. As long as there are potential lines of enquiry to be pursued I wouldn't want to be the Home Secretary who pulls the plug.
-
It has become little more than a face saving exercise.
Damned either way.
It will be interesting reading the comments in the Mail or elsewhere.
-
Scotland Yard given another £154,000 to allow them to explore a further theory as to what became of Madeleine McCann. The detective work itself which is being referred to as being 'sensitive in nature' is being pursued in Portugal by Portuguese police.
There were fears that Operation Grange would be wound down this week but this further funding should see investigative work continue until next year. It is widely accepted however that should this latest theory prove to be yet another dead end, the enquiry will be shelved until such time as new and compelling evidence is found.
The Operation Grange team whch originally consisted of over 20 detectives was scaled down dramatically last year to a team of two officers overseen by a supervising officer. Their task is to collate information and coordinate with those overseas detectives still pursuing enquiries abroad.
I don't doubt what you say, but what is the source for the last paragraph ?
-
A Home Office spokesman said: "Following an application from the Metropolitan Police, the Home Office has confirmed funding for Operation Grange until the end of March 2018.
"As with all applications, the resources required are reviewed regularly and careful consideration is given before any funding is allocated.”
The spokesman revealed the total awarded to Operation Grange for the financial year 2017/2018 is £309,000.
The figure is made up of the new £154,000 for police operational costs, the previous £85,000 given in March, totalling £239,000.
An extra £70,000 has also come out of the budget for “recently agreed admin and employment” which does not pay for detectives.
The spokesman added: “The number of officers remains at the same level.”
Scotland Yard declined to comment on the Maddie inquiry new cash boost.
Detectives on the inquiry, headed by Detective Chief Inspector Nicola Wall, say there is “still important work to do and focused lines of investigation to be pursued.”
A Scotland Yard spokesman said: “The inquiry has not reached a conclusion and we’re continuing with focus and determination.
"There are no immediate plans to reduce officer numbers further at this time.”
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/madeleine-mccann-latest-updates-missing-investigation-portugal-funding-home-office-operation-grange-a7972461.html
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/4569974/madeleine-mccann-cops-given-154000-to-continue-search-for-missing-child-in-fresh-hope-for-parents-kate-and-gerry/
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2017/sep/28/madeleine-mccann-investigation-to-go-on-after-being-granted-extra-154000
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-41431516
-
Great we can carry on debating and researching in meantime.
-
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4930154/New-hope-Madeleine-McCann-parents-search-continues.html#reader-comments
-
I wonder if their lead involves an alleged abductor? (I thought I'd bring up your favourite topic.)
-
I wonder if their lead involves an alleged abductor?
I think the lead must be pretty compelling. The police working on Madeleine's case seem to think it is justified or else they wouldn't have made a case for it to the Home Office.
In turn the Home Secretary will have studied the application before approving it.
The fact that the Portuguese police are also using resources in time, money and personnel to continue work on this particular line of inquiry, shows that they too are on board
The really sad thing in my opinion is that very many of the naysayers would care nothing about expenditure were it being misdirected to where they think it should ... irrespective of the conclusions reached by two national police forces firmly following real evidence showing precisely how wrong the naysayers are and have been for over ten years.
-
I think the lead must be pretty compelling. The police working on Madeleine's case seem to think it is justified or else they wouldn't have made a case for it to the Home Office.
In turn the Home Secretary will have studied the application before approving it.
The fact that the Portuguese police are also using resources in time, money and personnel to continue work on this particular line of inquiry, shows that they too are on board
The really sad thing in my opinion is that very many of the naysayers would care nothing about expenditure were it being misdirected to where they think it should ... irrespective of the conclusions reached by two national police forces firmly following real evidence showing precisely how wrong the naysayers are and have been for over ten years.
I'm sure I wouldn't know who these naysayers are, but they are entitled to an opinion, and one that does not conform to the McCann gang of supporters standards is just as valid as anyone else's.
It interesting that the extra money amounts to just over 200k. It would be good to know just how much the McCanns have spent on legal fees from the fund because they did spend over 300k for media coverage- you know that bad media they hated so mucho.
The fund money could have covered these costs- that is what is so disgusting . Now it seems strange to me that the couple have pursued Amaral instead of pursuing leads of their missing 'abducted' child...
-
Scotland Yard given another £154,000 to allow them to explore a further theory as to what became of Madeleine McCann. The detective work itself which is being referred to as being 'sensitive in nature' is being pursued in Portugal by Portuguese police.
There were fears that Operation Grange would be wound down this week but this further funding should see investigative work continue until next year. It is widely accepted however that should this latest theory prove to be yet another dead end, the enquiry will be shelved until such time as new and compelling evidence is found.
The Operation Grange team whch originally consisted of over 20 detectives was scaled down dramatically last year to a team of two officers overseen by a supervising officer. Their task is to collate information and coordinate with those overseas detectives still pursuing enquiries abroad.
The first sentence suggest to me that its the PJ who are driving the investigation and OG need the funding to keep up.
-
The first sentence suggest to me that its the PJ who are driving the investigation and OG need the funding to keep up.
Yes indeed, I thought that also Barrier.
-
Yes indeed, I thought that also Barrier.
Yep,the answer is in Portugal.always has been imo.
-
The first sentence suggest to me that its the PJ who are driving the investigation and OG need the funding to keep up.
Madeleine's case falls under Portuguese jurisdiction ... they are the lead authority. I find it rather comforting that as such, they appear to be keeping their finger right on the pulse of exactly what is going down in the investigation.
-
Madeleine's case falls under Portuguese jurisdiction ... they are the lead authority. I find it rather comforting that as such, they appear to be keeping their finger right on the pulse of exactly what is going down in the investigation.
Yep,and not a word of abduction either.
-
Yep,the answer is in Portugal.always has been imo.
That would appear to be in accord with the thinking of Madeleine's mum who has believed exactly that for a number of years ...
‘We will never give up’: Madeleine McCann is ‘still in Portugal’, Mum Kate believes
http://metro.co.uk/2016/02/15/we-will-never-give-up-madeleine-mccann-is-still-in-portugal-mum-kate-believes-5682392/?ito=cbshare
Who knows? But if the Portuguese police are as active on it as is believed ... it may not be so far from the mark.
-
Yep,and not a word of abduction either.
Yes, no 'stranger abduction' mentioned- interesting indeed.
-
Yep,and not a word of abduction either.
Actually ... there isn't a word about anything at all to do with the investigation ... apart from its sensitivity. So not really any great need to get hung up on the "A" word, is there?
-
Actually ... there isn't a word about anything at all to do with the investigation ... apart from its sensitivity. So not really any great need to get hung up on the "A" word, is there?
Nor a burglary gone wrong either,OG are at last catching up with the PJ imo.
-
That would appear to be in accord with the thinking of Madeleine's mum who has believed exactly that for a number of years ...
‘We will never give up’: Madeleine McCann is ‘still in Portugal’, Mum Kate believes
http://metro.co.uk/2016/02/15/we-will-never-give-up-madeleine-mccann-is-still-in-portugal-mum-kate-believes-5682392/?ito=cbshare
Who knows? But if the Portuguese police are as active on it as is believed ... it may not be so far from the mark.
Yes... Kate knew all along her daughter is in Portugal, Kate knew right away what happened to her daughter... Mmmm yes, so remind me again why the need for world wide publicity to search for a child who is in Portugal and of course she will still be alive, naturally.
-
Nor a burglary gone wrong either,OG are at last catching up with the PJ imo.
At risk of repeating myself ... there has been no information emanating from the investigation apart from the easily guessed fact that it is at a sensitive stage.
What point are you trying to make by continuing to pick up on what they have not said when aware that they have said nothing at all ... and have clearly explained (not that they had to) exactly why they've said nothing.
Do you have a valid point to make ?
-
Nor a burglary gone wrong either,OG are at last catching up with the PJ imo.
May we ask what is your opinion?
-
Don't know how much of a pulse Brunt has his finger on but a certain level of diplomacy is being used,could this be the admin funding being talked of.
"It is complicated work, it involves a certain level of diplomacy, and the search for the clues that would corroborate that theory may take some time to emerge."
He said the Scotland Yard team has been described as "minding the shop" while their Portuguese colleagues search for the illusive clues that would confirm the latest theory.
http://news.sky.com/story/madeleine-mccann-police-investigation-gets-more-funding-from-home-office-11057946
Still its better than the crack pot theories spouted last year when extra funding was given with stories having OG supposed to have been chasing European traffickers.
-
Don't know how much of a pulse Brunt has his finger on but a certain level of diplomacy is being used,could this be the admin funding being talked of.
http://news.sky.com/story/madeleine-mccann-police-investigation-gets-more-funding-from-home-office-11057946
Still its better than the crack pot theories spouted last year when extra funding was given with stories having OG supposed to have been chasing European traffickers.
""There's no time limit at the moment but the feeling is, if after a few months, this theory is not able to be stood up then the investigation will be wound up."
Well I just hope it is my theory they are investigating for it hasn't failed as yet in explaining what happened.
But a theory is only as good as the evidence that could be found to back it up.
-
May we ask what is your opinion?
On what Rob?
-
At risk of repeating myself ... there has been no information emanating from the investigation apart from the easily guessed fact that it is at a sensitive stage.
What point are you trying to make by continuing to pick up on what they have not said when aware that they have said nothing at all ... and have clearly explained (not that they had to) exactly why they've said nothing.
Do you have a valid point to make ?
The Sun believe it was a burglary gone wrong and The Sun believe that's what OG believe. Well according to todays masterpiece of investigative journalism. It took three of them to do it...... &%+((£
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/2238940/madeleine-mccann-disappearance-investigation-latest/
-
The Sun believe it was a burglary gone wrong and The Sun believe that's what OG believe. Well according to todays masterpiece of investigative journalism. It took three of them to do it...... &%+((£
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/2238940/madeleine-mccann-disappearance-investigation-latest/
Potential sightings of the British three-year old followed up by British cops total 8,685 across 101 countries and territories, a Freedom of Information request by The Sun showed in October last year.
Why did they need to do a foi request,October 2015 the met issued a statement telling us just that any way.
-
Don't know how much of a pulse Brunt has his finger on but a certain level of diplomacy is being used,could this be the admin funding being talked of.
http://news.sky.com/story/madeleine-mccann-police-investigation-gets-more-funding-from-home-office-11057946
Still its better than the crack pot theories spouted last year when extra funding was given with stories having OG supposed to have been chasing European traffickers.
"There is an ongoing theory about what happened to Madeleine McCann," he said. [Brunt]
at the heart of this has been an abduction. [Rowley]
Portuguese colleagues search for the illusive clues that would confirm the latest theory. [Brunt]
the legal requirements the Portuguese have is quite labour intensive in terms of dotting I’s and crossing T’s and working through that detail/ [Rowley]
It sounds to me like OG have a theory which won't quite stand up in Portugal. They are hoping that the PJ will be able to find evidence which confirms their theory. I do hope that the word illusive is a spelling mistake and was supposed to be elusive.
http://news.sky.com/story/madeleine-mccann-police-investigation-gets-more-funding-from-home-office-11057946
-
Portuguese colleagues search for the illusive clues that would confirm the latest theory. [Brunt]
the legal requirements the Portuguese have is quite labour intensive in terms of dotting I’s and crossing T’s and working through that detail/ [Rowley]
It sounds to me like OG have a theory which won't quite stand up in Portugal. They are hoping that the PJ will be able to find evidence which confirms their theory. I do hope that the word illusive is a spelling mistake and was supposed to be elusive.
One wonders,elusive one that can't be found,illusive one that was never there.
-
One wonders,elusive one that can't be found,illusive one that was never there.
Perhaps Sky know something that we don't @)(++(*
-
Perhaps Sky know something that we don't @)(++(*
exclusive?
-
Isn't it wonderful the difference a day makes? SY have admitted they are resigned to chasing theories in the search for Maddie. Have they lost their marbles completely I ask myself?? %#£%
-
Isn't it wonderful the difference a day makes? SY have admitted they are resigned to chasing theories in the search for Maddie. Have they lost their marbles completely I ask myself?? %#£%
Or tiddlywinks?
-
Isn't it wonderful the difference a day makes? SY have admitted they are resigned to chasing theories in the search for Maddie. Have they lost their marbles completely I ask myself?? %#£%
Do they have any left to lose ?
-
Isn't it wonderful the difference a day makes? SY have admitted they are resigned to chasing theories in the search for Maddie. Have they lost their marbles completely I ask myself?? %#£%
The police have chased strange things in the past;
An undercover police officer "chased himself round the streets" for 20 minutes after a CCTV operator mistook him for suspect.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/9066337/CCTV-police-officer-chased-himself-after-being-mistaken-for-burglar.html
-
The first sentence suggest to me that its the PJ who are driving the investigation and OG need the funding to keep up.
...or is it a case that SY are funding the Portuguese police to do what they cannot do?
-
'I think she's still alive': Mum of missing Claudia Lawrence tears up as she backs extra funding for Madeleine McCann investigation
Joan spoke on This Morning as she insisted that 'you can't put a price on a child's life'
BY ROSE HILL
13:37, 29 SEP 2017
Mum of missing Claudia Lawrence became emotional on This Morning today as she backed extra funding in the search to find Madeleine McCann.
Scotland Yard have recently announced that they would be injecting an additional £154,000 to keep the search for Maddie going.
Her disappearance has become one of the most high-profile and costly police investigations in history. Over £11million has been spent since she went missing from her bed in May 3 2007 during a holiday in Praia da Luz in the Algarve.
But Joan, whose daughter Claudia went missing in 2009, backed the amount of money spent on the case.
When host Eamonn Holmes brought up the criticism that the McCanns faced over the money spent on the investigation in comparison on the amount spent on her daughter's, Joan insisted that the circumstances were "very different".
She was also asked whether she thought that her daughter was still alive.
Joan said: "Yes, I do."
"Because you have to?" Eamonn questioned.
She said: "I have hope and a very strong faith and I say a little prayer every morning to get me through the day and I don't feel any instinct that she isn't alive - and the same with Madeleine. But I have hope."
Joan then began to tear up as her feelings got the better of her.
Claudia disappeared on March 18 2009 and was a chef working at the University of York. She was last seen near her home in Heworth, York after returning home from work.
The North Yorkshire Police have treated the disappearance as a suspected murder - though there is no evidence that Claudia is dead.
*To contact UK Police National Missing Persons Bureau , call 08450 005 481 or Missing People on 116 000 and Missing Kids UK on 116 000
http://www.mirror.co.uk/tv/tv-news/i-think-shes-still-alive-11259100
There are many good people around who see the point of keeping the search going for a missing person. None more so than someone who is living through the same trauma the McCanns are enduring; having similarly suffered the loss of a dearly loved child with no idea of what may have happened to her.
As far as Madeleine's case is concerned ... one wonders how the sums allowed are worked out.
Last March the sum of £85,000 was justified and was granted to keep the search for Madeleine going strong until the end of this month when it was subject to review.
After again being justified the continued search for Madeleine was granted the sum of £154,000 to cover the same time scale.
That is really a considerable addition which in my opinion must mean something positive is going on regarding the investigation.
I think the extra amount allocated must logically have been warranted by something additional being paid for which wasn't happening six months ago.
It could be a number of things so not really much point in speculation ... except to be confident that Madeleine's case isn't static but continues to progress.
-
...or is it a case that SY are funding the Portuguese police to do what they cannot do?
That thought had crossed my mind, John.
I don't know if SY would be able to sub-contract with taxpayers' money ... and I don't know if the Portuguese might not be insulted by the suggestion?
-
...or is it a case that SY are funding the Portuguese police to do what they cannot do?
Its possible,£85,000 of it must be the same as per the previous six months,OG officers are now effectively twiddling their thumbs according to some reports leaving £69,000 for operational, admin and employment cost's? that's never been put forward before.I would think the PJ would welcome any help to get the blasted monkey off their back.
-
'I think she's still alive': Mum of missing Claudia Lawrence tears up as she backs extra funding for Madeleine McCann investigation
Joan spoke on This Morning as she insisted that 'you can't put a price on a child's life'
BY ROSE HILL
13:37, 29 SEP 2017
Mum of missing Claudia Lawrence became emotional on This Morning today as she backed extra funding in the search to find Madeleine McCann.
Scotland Yard have recently announced that they would be injecting an additional £154,000 to keep the search for Maddie going.
Her disappearance has become one of the most high-profile and costly police investigations in history. Over £11million has been spent since she went missing from her bed in May 3 2007 during a holiday in Praia da Luz in the Algarve.
But Joan, whose daughter Claudia went missing in 2009, backed the amount of money spent on the case.
When host Eamonn Holmes brought up the criticism that the McCanns faced over the money spent on the investigation in comparison on the amount spent on her daughter's, Joan insisted that the circumstances were "very different".
She was also asked whether she thought that her daughter was still alive.
Joan said: "Yes, I do."
"Because you have to?" Eamonn questioned.
She said: "I have hope and a very strong faith and I say a little prayer every morning to get me through the day and I don't feel any instinct that she isn't alive - and the same with Madeleine. But I have hope."
Joan then began to tear up as her feelings got the better of her.
Claudia disappeared on March 18 2009 and was a chef working at the University of York. She was last seen near her home in Heworth, York after returning home from work.
The North Yorkshire Police have treated the disappearance as a suspected murder - though there is no evidence that Claudia is dead.
*To contact UK Police National Missing Persons Bureau , call 08450 005 481 or Missing People on 116 000 and Missing Kids UK on 116 000
http://www.mirror.co.uk/tv/tv-news/i-think-shes-still-alive-11259100
There are many good people around who see the point of keeping the search going for a missing person. None more so than someone who is living through the same trauma the McCanns are enduring; having similarly suffered the loss of a dearly loved child with no idea of what may have happened to her.
As far as Madeleine's case is concerned ... one wonders how the sums allowed are worked out.
Last March the sum of £85,000 was justified and was granted to keep the search for Madeleine going strong until the end of this month when it was subject to review.
After again being justified the continued search for Madeleine was granted the sum of £154,000 to cover the same time scale.
That is really a considerable addition which in my opinion must mean something positive is going on regarding the investigation.
I think the extra amount allocated must logically have been warranted by something additional being paid for which wasn't happening six months ago.
It could be a number of things so not really much point in speculation ... except to be confident that Madeleine's case isn't static but continues to progress.
Big difference is this. Was Claudia Laurence's mother ever a prime suspect? Did she ever refuse to cooperate with the police and go out of her way to demean and ridicule specific officers? Thought not!!
The McCann's (K and G) lost the right to any sympathy a long time ago, they made their bed and now they have to lie in it imo. Their thoughtlessness, stupidity and downright selfishness caused this mess.
-
Its possible,£85,000 of it must be the same as per the previous six months,OG officers are now effectively twiddling their thumbs according to some reports leaving £69,000 for operational, admin and employment cost's? that's never been put forward before.I would think the PJ would welcome any help to get the blasted monkey off their back.
Therein lies the problem. Portugal and Madeleine will be forever intrinsically linked unless this case is solved.
-
Big difference is this. Was Claudia Laurence's mother ever a prime suspect? Did she ever refuse to cooperate with the police and go out of her way to demean and ridicule specific officers? Thought not!!
The McCann's (K and G) lost the right to any sympathy a long time ago, they made their bed and now they have to lie in it imo. Their thoughtlessness, stupidity and downright selfishness caused this mess.
You may feel they have lost the right to your sympathy but not mine nor obviously Claudia's mother.
And I'm sure many people still feel sympathy for them.
-
Big difference is this. Was Claudia Laurence's mother ever a prime suspect? Did she ever refuse to cooperate with the police and go out of her way to demean and ridicule specific officers? Thought not!!
The McCann's (K and G) lost the right to any sympathy a long time ago, they made their bed and now they have to lie in it imo. Their thoughtlessness, stupidity and downright selfishness caused this mess.
Can I ask what the hell Kate not answering questions and their child arrangements have to do with the search for Madeleine and what is spent on it?
-
Claudia's mother has the intelligence to realise that Claudia's and Madeleine's cases are completely different.
I am sure if any new information on Claudia's disappearance arises, more money will be given to investigate.
-
Claudia's mother has the intelligence to realise that Claudia's and Madeleine's cases are completely different.
I am sure if any new information on Claudia's disappearance arises, more money will be given to investigate.
I don't think any money was given to the case. It was funded out of the normal police budget, probably because it was an event which took place in the UK.
-
'I think she's still alive': Mum of missing Claudia Lawrence tears up as she backs extra funding for Madeleine McCann investigation
Joan spoke on This Morning as she insisted that 'you can't put a price on a child's life'
BY ROSE HILL
13:37, 29 SEP 2017
Mum of missing Claudia Lawrence became emotional on This Morning today as she backed extra funding in the search to find Madeleine McCann.
Scotland Yard have recently announced that they would be injecting an additional £154,000 to keep the search for Maddie going.
Her disappearance has become one of the most high-profile and costly police investigations in history. Over £11million has been spent since she went missing from her bed in May 3 2007 during a holiday in Praia da Luz in the Algarve.
But Joan, whose daughter Claudia went missing in 2009, backed the amount of money spent on the case.
When host Eamonn Holmes brought up the criticism that the McCanns faced over the money spent on the investigation in comparison on the amount spent on her daughter's, Joan insisted that the circumstances were "very different".
She was also asked whether she thought that her daughter was still alive.
Joan said: "Yes, I do."
"Because you have to?" Eamonn questioned.
She said: "I have hope and a very strong faith and I say a little prayer every morning to get me through the day and I don't feel any instinct that she isn't alive - and the same with Madeleine. But I have hope."
Joan then began to tear up as her feelings got the better of her.
Claudia disappeared on March 18 2009 and was a chef working at the University of York. She was last seen near her home in Heworth, York after returning home from work.
The North Yorkshire Police have treated the disappearance as a suspected murder - though there is no evidence that Claudia is dead.
*To contact UK Police National Missing Persons Bureau , call 08450 005 481 or Missing People on 116 000 and Missing Kids UK on 116 000
http://www.mirror.co.uk/tv/tv-news/i-think-shes-still-alive-11259100
There are many good people around who see the point of keeping the search going for a missing person. None more so than someone who is living through the same trauma the McCanns are enduring; having similarly suffered the loss of a dearly loved child with no idea of what may have happened to her.
As far as Madeleine's case is concerned ... one wonders how the sums allowed are worked out.
Last March the sum of £85,000 was justified and was granted to keep the search for Madeleine going strong until the end of this month when it was subject to review.
After again being justified the continued search for Madeleine was granted the sum of £154,000 to cover the same time scale.
That is really a considerable addition which in my opinion must mean something positive is going on regarding the investigation.
I think the extra amount allocated must logically have been warranted by something additional being paid for which wasn't happening six months ago.
It could be a number of things so not really much point in speculation ... except to be confident that Madeleine's case isn't static but continues to progress.
Why do people think that stopping the funding would be 'putting a price on a child's life?' The child is either alive or dead and no amount of funding will change that.
-
Big difference is this. Was Claudia Laurence's mother ever a prime suspect? Did she ever refuse to cooperate with the police and go out of her way to demean and ridicule specific officers? Thought not!!
The McCann's (K and G) lost the right to any sympathy a long time ago, they made their bed and now they have to lie in it imo. Their thoughtlessness, stupidity and downright selfishness caused this mess.
I don't think Madeleine's parents are courting anything other than hope for her. There is no one better qualified to show them compassion and understanding than someone who has suffered the loss of a child possibly never to discover what happened to her than, Joan Lawrence.
She has suffered when the search for Claudia was scaled back ... but that hasn't caused her to voice criticism that
there is still money being allocated for Madeleine. Quite the contrary.
-
Why do people think that stopping the funding would be 'putting a price on a child's life?' The child is either alive or dead and no amount of funding will change that.
At what point in any investigation should this principle be applied?
-
At what point in any investigation should this principle be applied?
At the point where the benefit of continuing is outweighed by the benefit of stopping.
That decision should be made by those in charge.
-
At the point where the benefit of continuing is outweighed by the benefit of stopping.
That decision should be made by those in charge.
And in this case they are continuing.
-
I don't think Madeleine's parents are courting anything other than hope for her. There is no one better qualified to show them compassion and understanding than someone who has suffered the loss of a child possibly never to discover what happened to her than, Joan Lawrence.
She has suffered when the search for Claudia was scaled back ... but that hasn't caused her to voice criticism that
there is still money being allocated for Madeleine. Quite the contrary.
I don't think anyone can compare the loss of a grown woman to a young child.
-
I don't think anyone can compare the loss of a grown woman to a young child.
I think every disappearance is unique with unique consequences for the families involved.
Regarding Claudia and Madeleine the similarities are that both vanished leaving not a trace behind them and there it ends.
But I would guarantee that all the emotions felt by the parents of the woman are mirrored by those of the parents of the child.
They are members of an exclusive order which none of us would wish to join which gives them a deeper understanding and empathy for differing circumstances but the same conclusion ... Madeleine's parents have lost a child but so have Claudia's ... in my opinion the age of the disappeared makes no difference to the pain of that.
-
I think every disappearance is unique with unique consequences for the families involved.
Regarding Claudia and Madeleine the similarities are that both vanished leaving not a trace behind them and there it ends.
But I would guarantee that all the emotions felt by the parents of the woman are mirrored by those of the parents of the child.
They are members of an exclusive order which none of us would wish to join which gives them a deeper understanding and empathy for differing circumstances but the same conclusion ... Madeleine's parents have lost a child but so have Claudia's ... in my opinion the age of the disappeared makes no difference to the pain of that.
The fact that they are 'members of an exclusive order' means their opinions on funding are likely to be similarly biased. Parental desperation for answers, while understandable, doesn't amount to a reason to continue. Weighing up the chances of success is what counts.
-
And in this case they are continuing.
Which means that they expect to get something out of it.
I wonder what that might be ?
-
'I think she's still alive': Mum of missing Claudia Lawrence tears up as she backs extra funding for Madeleine McCann investigation
Joan spoke on This Morning as she insisted that 'you can't put a price on a child's life'
BY ROSE HILL
13:37, 29 SEP 2017
Mum of missing Claudia Lawrence became emotional on This Morning today as she backed extra funding in the search to find Madeleine McCann.
Scotland Yard have recently announced that they would be injecting an additional £154,000 to keep the search for Maddie going.
Her disappearance has become one of the most high-profile and costly police investigations in history. Over £11million has been spent since she went missing from her bed in May 3 2007 during a holiday in Praia da Luz in the Algarve.
But Joan, whose daughter Claudia went missing in 2009, backed the amount of money spent on the case.
When host Eamonn Holmes brought up the criticism that the McCanns faced over the money spent on the investigation in comparison on the amount spent on her daughter's, Joan insisted that the circumstances were "very different".
She was also asked whether she thought that her daughter was still alive.
Joan said: "Yes, I do."
"Because you have to?" Eamonn questioned.
She said: "I have hope and a very strong faith and I say a little prayer every morning to get me through the day and I don't feel any instinct that she isn't alive - and the same with Madeleine. But I have hope."
Joan then began to tear up as her feelings got the better of her.
Claudia disappeared on March 18 2009 and was a chef working at the University of York. She was last seen near her home in Heworth, York after returning home from work.
The North Yorkshire Police have treated the disappearance as a suspected murder - though there is no evidence that Claudia is dead.
*To contact UK Police National Missing Persons Bureau , call 08450 005 481 or Missing People on 116 000 and Missing Kids UK on 116 000
http://www.mirror.co.uk/tv/tv-news/i-think-shes-still-alive-11259100
There are many good people around who see the point of keeping the search going for a missing person. None more so than someone who is living through the same trauma the McCanns are enduring; having similarly suffered the loss of a dearly loved child with no idea of what may have happened to her.
As far as Madeleine's case is concerned ... one wonders how the sums allowed are worked out.
Last March the sum of £85,000 was justified and was granted to keep the search for Madeleine going strong until the end of this month when it was subject to review.
After again being justified the continued search for Madeleine was granted the sum of £154,000 to cover the same time scale.
That is really a considerable addition which in my opinion must mean something positive is going on regarding the investigation.
I think the extra amount allocated must logically have been warranted by something additional being paid for which wasn't happening six months ago.
It could be a number of things so not really much point in speculation ... except to be confident that Madeleine's case isn't static but continues to progress.
There are many good people around who think that the investigation is purely looking at evidenceless theories and that at this point, if she is alive, she will only be found if someone confesses or she escapes.
-
Which means that they expect to get something out of it.
I wonder what that might be ?
I think someone should answer the questions which have been raised this year. They're not going to go away and the remit did say;
The ‘investigative review’ will be conducted with transparency, openness and thoroughness.
So far we have seen obscurity, secrecy and lack of thoroughness in my opinion.
Was Operation Grange's remit to investigate only abduction, as Colin Sutton asserts?
How, exactly, did Operation Grange reach the conclusion that the parents and their friends were not involved?
How, exactly, did OG rule out woke and wandered?
-
There are many good people around who think that the investigation is purely looking at evidenceless theories and that at this point, if she is alive, she will only be found if someone confesses or she escapes.
IMO to eliminate all other possibilities is important and necessary work to prove the final case theory. It is complicated work but they know what the truth is. The police won't care if they look dumb because confusion is good 8(>((
Pedro do Carmo: If it depended on my heart, the case would already be solved. But it doesn’t depend on my heart. It depends, very much, on our minds.
“The whole secret lies in confusing the enemy, so that he cannot fathom our real intent.” Sun Tzu, The Art of War
-
We are getting a bit close to Speculation as Fact. Please be aware.
This is a Moderation Comment.
-
The fact that they are 'members of an exclusive order' means their opinions on funding are likely to be similarly biased. Parental desperation for answers, while understandable, doesn't amount to a reason to continue. Weighing up the chances of success is what counts.
I have thought this for a while.
-
There are many good people around who think that the investigation is purely looking at evidenceless theories and that at this point, if she is alive, she will only be found if someone confesses or she escapes.
In my opinion theories are fine; just as long as when they don't pan out because there is not a shred of supporting evidence someone doesn't take it into their head to write a book promoting not the actuality but their notion of it.
Which may indeed have misguided some good people into thinking that police work consists of picking a theory out of a lucky bag then sticking to it despite every indication to the contrary.
Real police work consists of following the evidence.
Which is precisely what the present investigators of the Policia Judiciaria and Scotland Yard have done and are continuing to do.
I doubt very much that Scotland Yard made the case for more funding to complete their investigation into Madeleine's disappearance on some nebulous notion ... they know exactly where the evidence has led them.
I doubt very much that without hard evidence the Home Secretary would have almost doubled their funding to enable the police to keep going with whatever it is they have got their teeth into.
There is no second guessing on that ... it is my experience there is little sentiment in politics ... she based her decision on evidence presented to her by the police.
In my opinion passively waiting either for 'confession' or a person who very probably is unaware of her circumstances to 'escape' them ~ is a step down the line from whatever investigative opportunity SY and the PJ are currently pursuing, which we are told is at a critical and sensitive stage.
In my opinion they are well past the 'theory' stage and have been for some time.
-
In my opinion theories are fine; just as long as when they don't pan out because there is not a shred of supporting evidence someone doesn't take it into their head to write a book promoting not the actuality but their notion of it.
Which may indeed have misguided some good people into thinking that police work consists of picking a theory out of a lucky bag then sticking to it despite every indication to the contrary.
Real police work consists of following the evidence.
Which is precisely what the present investigators of the Policia Judiciaria and Scotland Yard have done and are continuing to do.
I doubt very much that Scotland Yard made the case for more funding to complete their investigation into Madeleine's disappearance on some nebulous notion ... they know exactly where the evidence has led them.
I doubt very much that without hard evidence the Home Secretary would have almost doubled their funding to enable the police to keep going with whatever it is they have got their teeth into.
There is no second guessing on that ... it is my experience there is little sentiment in politics ... she based her decision on evidence presented to her by the police.
In my opinion passively waiting either for 'confession' or a person who very probably is unaware of her circumstances to 'escape' them ~ is a step down the line from whatever investigative opportunity SY and the PJ are currently pursuing, which we are told is at a critical and sensitive stage.
In my opinion they are well past the 'theory' stage and have been for some time.
You have no evidence of the current investigations following evidence.
-
You have no evidence of the current investigations following evidence.
... and here was me thinking that was what police do ... looking for evidence and when they have found some, taking it a step further in the chain to the next and to the next and .... etc, etc, etc, ... until it either dries up or points in a different direction or there is sufficient to lay charges and continue from there.
In my opinion no Home Secretary at a time of terrorist activity and all round budgetary constraints, is going to be impressed by a request for more money without justification.
The fact that Amber Rudd has not only acceded to police requests to grant money to keep Madeleine's investigation going but has agreed to an increase from £85,000 last year to £154,000 is in my opinion proof that she was shown some compelling reasons for doing so.
In my opinion that would be the evidence they are following.
I think it is only in a parallel universe that it could ever be thought that a police investigation could ever be conducted without following evidence.
-
... and here was me thinking that was what police do ... looking for evidence and when they have found some, taking it a step further in the chain to the next and to the next and .... etc, etc, etc, ... until it either dries up or points in a different direction or there is sufficient to lay charges and continue from there.
In my opinion no Home Secretary at a time of terrorist activity and all round budgetary constraints, is going to be impressed by a request for more money without justification.
The fact that Amber Rudd has not only acceded to police requests to grant money to keep Madeleine's investigation going but has agreed to an increase from £85,000 last year to £154,000 is in my opinion proof that she was shown some compelling reasons for doing so.
In my opinion that would be the evidence they are following.
I think it is only in a parallel universe that it could ever be thought that a police investigation could ever be conducted without following evidence.
So would you agree that the PJ were following evidence in their investigation of 2007/2008 ?
-
So would you agree that the PJ were following evidence in their investigation of 2007/2008 ?
Certainly from the latter part of 2007 until the archiving report was written.
However there is evidence to suggest that whatever the initial PJ investigation was following from the third of May until then ... it was entirely the wrong call.
-
Certainly from the latter part of 2007 until the archiving report was written.
However there is evidence to suggest that whatever the initial PJ investigation was following from the third of May until then ... it was entirely the wrong call.
Can I remind you Brietta that it was Rebelo who requested the reconstitution and for the tapas friends to be questioned again ? That certainly doesn't sound like an investigator who was convinced of the party's innocence and was following a different line of enquiry.
And further there was no evidence to suggest that the PJ
-
I get the feeling with several of the threads being promoted in the last few days that contrary to supporter being buoyed by the granting of extra funding they are rather nervous of what it suggests.
Bet they wish they knew what the PJ are getting up to !
-
I get the feeling with several of the threads being promoted in the last few days that contrary to supporter being buoyed by the granting of extra funding they are rather nervous of what it suggests.
Bet they wish they knew what the PJ are getting up to !
What does it suggest to you, Faithlilly, other than it's taking a lot of time & effort to unravel the mystery?
-
The answer lies in the conclusions reached by the Rebelo investigation ... that there was no evidence to lay charges against Murat (arguido) Kate (arguida) or Gerry McCann (arguido).
It was compounded when Madeleine's case was reopened by Scotland Yard and the Policia Judiciaria in 2013 and the conspiracy theories were disregarded in favour of proper police work which has recently resulted in the award of £154,000 to enable work to continue; hopefully towards successful conclusion.
-
I think every disappearance is unique with unique consequences for the families involved.
Regarding Claudia and Madeleine the similarities are that both vanished leaving not a trace behind them and there it ends.
But I would guarantee that all the emotions felt by the parents of the woman are mirrored by those of the parents of the child.
They are members of an exclusive order which none of us would wish to join which gives them a deeper understanding and empathy for differing circumstances but the same conclusion ... Madeleine's parents have lost a child but so have Claudia's ... in my opinion the age of the disappeared makes no difference to the pain of that.
I still insist you cannot compare the two. Granted both sets of parents lost a daughter but Claudia Lawrence was a grown woman who was independently making her way in life and was not dependent on her parents. Madeleine on the other hand was a three-year-old child totally dependent on her parents who had the responsibility of her safety and security to consider.
Joan Lawrence hit the nail on the head when she stated the cases are very different, they are and for the reasons previously given.
-
The fact that they are 'members of an exclusive order' means their opinions on funding are likely to be similarly biased. Parental desperation for answers, while understandable, doesn't amount to a reason to continue. Weighing up the chances of success is what counts.
I think it was rather crass of ITV and Eamonn Holmes to put Joan Lawrence in the hot seat in the way they did in relation to funding of the Madeleine case. If they wanted to make a story out of the additional £154,000 funding why didn't they get someone from team McCann to appear? Extremely poor judgement imo but then it is ITV.
-
I think it was rather crass of ITV and Eamonn Holmes to put Joan Lawrence in the hot seat in the way they did in relation to funding of the Madeleine case. If they wanted to make a story out of the additional £154,000 funding why didn't they get someone from team McCann to appear? Extremely poor judgement imo but then it is ITV.
There was a rumour that the McCanns had huge offers on the table for the 10th anniversary interviews, but they did just one. Strange really because they could have picked up money to pay their debts to the Portuguese courts had they accepted the offers, thereby saving the Fund to be spent on it's true purpose.
I got the impression during that one interview that one of them didn't really want to be there. I got the same impression with footage of the church service; express entry and a swift exit. No lingering and chatting that day. So my guess is that the McCanns are not interested in publicity at the moment.
I expect Mrs Lawrence accepted their invitation to keep her daughter's case in the public eye. Was that taking advantage of a vulnerable person? In a way, but it gave her a platform too. It was meaningless, of course, because no-one with a missing relative would want people to stop looking. The people who should be answering questions, of course, have no intention of doing so.
-
I still insist you cannot compare the two. Granted both sets of parents lost a daughter but Claudia Lawrence was a grown woman who was independently making her way in life and was not dependent on her parents. Madeleine on the other hand was a three-year-old child totally dependent on her parents who had the responsibility of her safety and security to consider.
Joan Lawrence hit the nail on the head when she stated the cases are very different, they are and for the reasons previously given.
Joan Lawrence does not begrudge a penny of the money being spent on the search for Madeleine McCann precisely because she knows exactly the pain of losing a much loved daughter without any evidence being left behind to indicate precisely what may have happened to her.
The adult and the child disappeared very likely because of a situation against their will and over which they had no control. Joan was unable to hide the pain of that eight years after Claudia's disappearance.
Those left behind just not knowing are tortured by "what ifs?" none more so than Kate and Gerry McCann who have had their terror and hysteria at the event lampooned for public entertainment.
A bit like the Roman Circus.
As far as Claudia's case is concerned ... the police regretfully have gone as far with it as they can.
As far as Madeleine's case is concerned ... the police have said they have further to go.
Which is why Joan approves the extra resources being allocated to Madeleine's case.
-
From the OFM.
'"Kate and Gerry are extremely thankful to the Metropolitan Police for requesting extra funding.
They are very encouraged there remains work to be done that requires them seeking an extra budget. They are hoping naturally, it will be granted.
They are grateful to all those officers who are still working on the case and are actively looking for Madeleine.
They appreciate everything the police have done and are doing to get a resolution after all this time.
~ Clarence Mitchell, McCann Family Spokesperson'
Very odd that on their own Facebook page it's Clarence Mitchell, a person we were told had been given his marching orders months ago, who is issuing a thank you on BEHALF of the McCanns. Why, on their own page, couldn't they thank SY themselves ?
-
From the OFM.
'"Kate and Gerry are extremely thankful to the Metropolitan Police for requesting extra funding.
They are very encouraged there remains work to be done that requires them seeking an extra budget. They are hoping naturally, it will be granted.
They are grateful to all those officers who are still working on the case and are actively looking for Madeleine.
They appreciate everything the police have done and are doing to get a resolution after all this time.
~ Clarence Mitchell, McCann Family Spokesperson'
Very odd that on their own Facebook page it's Clarence Mitchell, a person we were told had been given his marching orders months ago, who is issuing a thank you on BEHALF of the McCanns. Why, on their own page, couldn't they thank SY themselves ?
They can give the impression of being more important than they are by having an official spokesperson.
-
They can give the impression of being more important than they are by having an official spokesperson.
Or distancing ? When the proverbial hits the fan they can deny they ever praised the extra work being done. Most odd! If I was to take a punt I'd say the McCanns weren't the least bit happy with this extra funding.
Strange also that the message was posted after the funding had been granted. Were the McCanns told about the extra funding before the public? IMO it would be strange if they weren't.
-
Too much Opinion as Fact. Stop now or I will be Deleting.
-
Posted elsewhere.
Interesting reporting from Sunday Times this morning:
A £12m investigation of the disappearance of Madeleine McCann has been granted an extra £154,000 because detectives are hunting a “person of significance”.
A source close to Operation Grange — Scotland Yard’s six-year search for Madeleine — has said finding the person is one of the “critical lines of inquiry” that police hope may help to solve the mystery. Madeleine, who was then three, disappeared in May 2007 while on holiday with her family in Portugal.
Last week the Home Office announced the funding that will keep four detectives on the investigation until the end of March next year. The source said: “It is as much to rule the person out of the inquiry as anything else.”The Portuguese investigation of Madeleine’s disappearance was criticised by the British authorities as being not fit for purpose. Scotland Yard began an investigative review into the disappearance in 2011.
However, The Sunday Times understands that Met detectives have been relying on Portuguese transcripts of key interviews with British witnesses, rather than conducting their own.
Operation Grange has conducted no formal witness interviews with Gerry or Kate McCann or the seven friends they dined with on the night Madeleine disappeared.
Colin Sutton, a former Met detective chief inspector, said: “I would conduct fresh interviews with all the key British witnesses. We’re talking about interviews given by the McCanns and friends through an interpreter, written down in Portuguese and then translated back into English so officers from Grange can read them. The room for error would be enormous.”
The Met said the Operation Grange team would not comment while the investigation was ongoing.
@DavidCollinsST
My highlight in red.
The sun's take on it.
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/4586988/madeleine-mccann-new-development-investigation-portugal/
-
So would you agree that the PJ were following evidence in their investigation of 2007/2008 ?
worth remembering the PJ didn't believe the 'abduction from window story' because there WAS NO EVIDENCE of that- so that kinda makes it more interesting. 8)--))
-
I think it was rather crass of ITV and Eamonn Holmes to put Joan Lawrence in the hot seat in the way they did in relation to funding of the Madeleine case. If they wanted to make a story out of the additional £154,000 funding why didn't they get someone from team McCann to appear? Extremely poor judgement imo but then it is ITV.
I concur with this sentiment it is crass because she was put on the spot, and perhaps like many other people are too afraid to diss the McCanns story or them.
-
Strange that OG would accept, unchallenged, transcript of PJ investigation from what is considered a flawed investigation.
-
Strange that OG would accept, unchallenged, transcript of PJ investigation from what is considered a flawed investigation.
Indeed, but what did Rowley say with this regard?
I am perplexed that it has cost 12 mill to just go over witness statement from the UK residents, without even touching the Tapas statements or re interviewing them. The very fact that the case is 'very sensitive' makes me wonder who this/these people are and what their involvement was/is.
I agree with this G,
"There was a rumour that the McCanns had huge offers on the table for the 10th anniversary interviews, but they did just one. Strange really because they could have picked up money to pay their debts to the Portuguese courts had they accepted the offers, thereby saving the Fund to be spent on it's true purpose.
I got the impression during that one interview that one of them didn't really want to be there. I got the same impression with footage of the church service; express entry and a swift exit. No lingering and chatting that day. So my guess is that the McCanns are not interested in publicity at the moment."
-
The Mails take on it.
The Portuguese investigation of Madeleine's disappearance was criticised by the British authorities as being not fit for purpose. Scotland Yard began an investigative review into the disappearance in 2011, on the orders of then-Prime Minister David Cameron.
However, The Sunday Times understands Met detectives have been relying on Portuguese transcripts of key interviews with British witnesses, rather than conducting their own.
Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4938194/Madeleine-McCann-police-hunting-person-significance.html#ixzz4uGBNTKpZ
-
IMO it appears they are still looking for Smithman.
-
IMO it appears they are still looking for Smithman.
That was my very first thought Slarti.
-
IMO it appears they are still looking for Smithman.
The apparent sensitivity of it all suggests to me that the Smithman is not a 'nobody'
-
IMO it appears they are still looking for Smithman.
It fits the description and wording DCI Andy used.......... &%+((£
-
This extract from the Times interested me.
'However, The Sunday Times understands that Met detectives have been relying on Portuguese transcripts of key interviews with British witnesses, rather than conducting their own.
Operation Grange has conducted no formal witness interviews with Gerry or Kate McCann or the seven friends they dined with on the night Madeleine disappeared.'
The wording is interesting and, IMO, deliberately vague. ' The Times understands', how, from who ? Not a source from within the investigation obviously or we would have been told that. So who ? Who would benefit from the public being informed that OG not only didn't bother to get their own translations done but didn't even conduct any interviews with the main protagonists?
Who would it benefit to undermine the investigation in that way ? Someone who knows they are being investigated ? You could argue that it would certainly be helpful if you are in the frame to suggest that the police investigation investigating you hadn't even carried out the most fundamental of steps and, even more shockingly, used the translations of an already discredited investigation too.
Are the defence foundations being laid for a very public calling to account ?
-
This extract from the Times interested me.
The wording is interesting and, IMO, deliberately vague. ' The Times understands', how, from who ? Not a source from within the investigation obviously or we would have been told that. So who ? Who would benefit from the public being informed that OG not only didn't bother to get their own translations done but didn't even conduct any interviews with the main protagonists?
I think they refer to interviews rather than translations imo.
Thirty plus officers were one time having to transalate them according to Hogan Howe some time ago.
Not forgetting what Rowley had to say.
MR: Two points to that, firstly the involvement of the parents, that was dealt with at the time by the
original investigation by the Portuguese.
-
I doubt the Met has got 30 officers who would be fluent in Portuguese. Documents would need to be professional translated before detectives could begin to understand them. This probably accounted for a sizable portion of the budget in early days.
-
I think they refer to interviews rather than translations imo.
Thirty plus officers were one time having to transalate them according to Hogan Howe some time ago.
Not forgetting what Rowley had to say.
As I said barrier, the wording is very vague, purposely IMO.
If Hogan Howe said that it makes you wonder why we are now hearing the opposite?
-
If Hogan Howe said that it makes you wonder why we are now hearing the opposite?
From the Times.
'However, The Sunday Times understands that Met detectives have been relying on Portuguese transcripts of key interviews with British witnesses, rather than conducting their own.
Depends on how one reads it,to me it says that rather than conduct interviews with some key british witnesses they are happy with the PJ transcripts,which flies in the face of some who insist the original investigation was flawed,all opinion.
-
From the Times.
Depends on how one reads it,to me it says that rather than conduct interviews with some key british witnesses they are happy with the PJ transcripts,which flies in the face of some who insist the original investigation was flawed,all opinion.
Opinion maybe, but an opinion many would share . IMO 8(0(*
-
I think the most pertinent verbatim quote from today's Sunday Times is:
Quote:The Met said the Operation Grange team would not comment while the investigation was ongoing. End quote
-
I think the most pertinent verbatim quote from today's Sunday Times is:
Quote:The Met said the Operation Grange team would not comment while the investigation was ongoing. End quote
Exactly Brietta which makes you wonder where the information came from. Certainly not OG or the PJ as it paints neither of them in a good light. So where ?
-
This extract from the Times interested me.
'However, The Sunday Times understands that Met detectives have been relying on Portuguese transcripts of key interviews with British witnesses, rather than conducting their own.
Operation Grange has conducted no formal witness interviews with Gerry or Kate McCann or the seven friends they dined with on the night Madeleine disappeared.'
The wording is interesting and, IMO, deliberately vague. ' The Times understands', how, from who ? Not a source from within the investigation obviously or we would have been told that. So who ? Who would benefit from the public being informed that OG not only didn't bother to get their own translations done but didn't even conduct any interviews with the main protagonists?
Who would it benefit to undermine the investigation in that way ? Someone who knows they are being investigated ? You could argue that it would certainly be helpful if you are in the frame to suggest that the police investigation investigating you hadn't even carried out the most fundamental of steps and, even more shockingly, used the translations of an already discredited investigation too.
Are the defence foundations being laid for a very public calling to account ?
Yes, I can see how it appears. It is worth remembering what MR said... The McCann's were dealt with by the PJ and it is well documented that the PJ believed an 'abduction was staged' They also believed Maddie to be dead.
Therefore, as they (OG) started of with a review of the case due to the incompetent,bad handling by the PJ (allegations made solely by the family and their supporters) and the remit was about an abduction. Then it turned into an investigation, the PJ reopened their file due to new information and well.. From that we lose Tannerman and Gain Smithman.
This is important becuase if you read these threads closely the die hard 'supporters still believe in Tannerman and fight their case- unconvincingly I admit, and are trying to diss Smithman, again unconvincingly.
All very interesting.
-
Yes, I can see how it appears. It is worth remembering what MR said... The McCann's were dealt with by the PJ and it is well documented that the PJ believed an 'abduction was staged' They also believed Maddie to be dead.
Therefore, as they (OG) started of with a review of the case due to the incompetent,bad handling by the PJ (allegations made solely by the family and their supporters) and the remit was about an abduction. Then it turned into an investigation, the PJ reopened their file due to new information and well.. From that we lose Tannerman and Gain Smithman.
This is important becuase if you read these threads closely the die hard 'supporters still believe in Tannerman and fight their case- unconvincingly I admit, and are trying to diss Smithman, again unconvincingly.
All very interesting.
Add this to the resurrection over preceding days of threads concerning every PJ officer who has ever committed an offence and we seem to have a pattern emerging.
As that presently-maligned seventies purveyor of dodgy art used to say 'can you tell what it is yet ? '
-
Exactly Brietta which makes you wonder where the information came from. Certainly not OG or the PJ as it paints neither of them in a good light. So where ?
Et cui bono fuerit?
-
Et cui bono fuerit?
Indeed Alice !
-
Et cui bono fuerit?
&%+((£
And it must be most annoying that SY are playing along side the PJ... Perhaps they have a taste for sardine samichees nom,nom.nom 8(0(*
-
Indeed Alice !
Yeah I just thought I'd nick someone elses thunder but use the full quote 8(>((
-
I get the feeling with several of the threads being promoted in the last few days that contrary to supporter being buoyed by the granting of extra funding they are rather nervous of what it suggests.
Bet they wish they knew what the PJ are getting up to !
You must be joking!
I am 100% sure all of us on our side are absolutely delighted. Another chance to finish off the job of finding Madeleine, or at the very least finding the person / people who are behind it all.
You see we differ from some on your side: we all want Madeleine found .... unlike some, it seems, on your side
Now i am NOT getting involved in argument, and may not come in again for a time. I am not well enough
But our side has no fears, just hope. We want Madeleine found.
-
Yes, I can see how it appears. It is worth remembering what MR said... The McCann's were dealt with by the PJ and it is well documented that the PJ believed an 'abduction was staged' They also believed Maddie to be dead.
Therefore, as they (OG) started of with a review of the case due to the incompetent,bad handling by the PJ (allegations made solely by the family and their supporters) and the remit was about an abduction. Then it turned into an investigation, the PJ reopened their file due to new information and well.. From that we lose Tannerman and Gain Smithman.
This is important becuase if you read these threads closely the die hard 'supporters still believe in Tannerman and fight their case- unconvincingly I admit, and are trying to diss Smithman, again unconvincingly.
All very interesting.
I am neither dissing Tannerman nor am I dissing Smithman. I prefer to be open minded.
I think they could well be one and the same ... and I can see scenarios where the time lapse can be accounted for.
But despite everything fitting together like a jigsaw, i know that I could be incorrect.
-
Catching up...
"However, The Sunday Times understands that Met detectives have been relying on Portuguese transcripts of key interviews with British witnesses, rather than conducting their own."
A big vague, isn't it?
It could be conflating several things: the original PJ statements from 2007 and the Portuguese-speaking witnesses interviewed via UK rog requests a couple of years ago by the PJ on behalf of the British (OG). Yes, they would have been in Portuguese as that's the way it works (unless anyone needed an interpreter, which doesn't ring any bells).
"Operation Grange has conducted no formal witness interviews with Gerry or Kate McCann or the seven friends they dined with on the night Madeleine disappeared."
Formal interviews are normally under caution, aren't they? That doesn't mean that they didn't conduct informal ones or simply ask any of them to supply further information if they needed to clarify something.
-
Meanwhile..................
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/4588686/madeleine-mccann-parents-kate-gerry-tapas-seven-never-quizzed-british-police/
THE PARENTS of Madeleine McCann and their “Tapas Seven” holiday pals have never been quizzed as witnesses by Scotland Yard into her disappearance.
The £12million six and a half year police probe into Maddie’s feared kidnap, which is hunting “a person of significance”, has not once asked Kate and Gerry, their friends and other key witnesses, for their account on the night the youngster vanished.
Madeleine McCann went missing at the Ocean club apartment hotel in Praia de Luz , PortugalAFP
Madeleine McCann went missing at the Ocean club apartment hotel in Praia de Luz , Portugal
Her parents Kate and Gerry McCann have vowed to search for their missing daughter for the rest of their livesAFP
Her parents Kate and Gerry McCann have vowed to search for their missing daughter for the rest of their lives
The Met detectives have been relying on Portuguese transcripts of key interviews with British witnesses, and have never conducted their own, The Times has learned.
Neither Gerry and Kate McCann nor their seven friends they dined with on the night Maddie vanished have been formerly interviewed.
Former Met detective chief inspector Collin Sutton, said: “I would conduct fresh interviews with all the key British witnesses. We’re talking about interviews given by the McCanns and friends through an interpreter, written down in Portuguese and then translated back into English so officers from Grange can read them. The room for error would be enormous.”
A source close to Scotland Yard's search Operation Grange said the new individual is now a "critical line of inquiry" in the investigation.
The source told the newspaper: "It is as much to rule out the person out of the inquiry as anything else."
-
It's difficult to work out where the media stand. It was known months ago that the T9 hadn't been formally interviewed by Operation Grange, so why mention it now? It looks like the Sunday Times took the plunge and the other newspapers copied their story.
They don't go into why it's significant either. Colin Sutton's opinion is interesting as he's a former Met detective, but the really significant fact is that the Portuguese Supreme Court pointed out that the first investigation was not able to rule the McCanns out of involvement, while A C Rowley suggested it had.
-
You must be joking!
I am 100% sure all of us on our side are absolutely delighted. Another chance to finish off the job of finding Madeleine, or at the very least finding the person / people who are behind it all.
You see we differ from some on your side: we all want Madeleine found .... unlike some, it seems, on your side
Now i am NOT getting involved in argument, and may not come in again for a time. I am not well enough
But our side has no fears, just hope. We want Madeleine found.
Hope you feel better soon Sadie.
-
It's difficult to work out where the media stand. It was known months ago that the T9 hadn't been formally interviewed by Operation Grange, so why mention it now? It looks like the Sunday Times took the plunge and the other newspapers copied their story.
They don't go into why it's significant either. Colin Sutton's opinion is interesting as he's a former Met detective, but the really significant fact is that the Portuguese Supreme Court pointed out that the first investigation was not able to rule the McCanns out of involvement, while A C Rowley suggested it had.
Sutton seems to suggest that there is room for error in translations,with £11+ million being spent I would like to think the translator's employed by the MET would be above that.
-
The media still regard this case as a cash cow imo - which is why we periodically get re-hashes of old news. One newspaper does it - and the others follow.
Profit rules their decisions to repeatedly print the same news imo
The McCanns paid to have the files in their possession professionally translated. Surely if they had noticed any major anomalies they would have brought them to SY's attention?
However, we don't know how many of the files were not released to the McCanns - but certainly not all of the 40 odd thousand documents SY had in their possession would have been seen by them IMO.
-
Meanwhile..................
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/4588686/madeleine-mccann-parents-kate-gerry-tapas-seven-never-quizzed-british-police/
(Snip)
THE PARENTS of Madeleine McCann and their “Tapas Seven” holiday pals have never been quizzed as witnesses by Scotland Yard into her disappearance.
Even more vague...
The concept of "formal interviews" somehow got lost, possibly in the rush to meet the copy deadline.
Hard to tell which version is accurate, but the latter may give some the impression that there had been no contact, whereas the lack of a formal interview doesn't preclude informal interviews or contact.
-
The media still regard this case as a cash cow imo - which is why we periodically get re-hashes of old news. One newspaper does it - and the others follow.
Profit rules their decisions to repeatedly print the same news imo
The McCanns paid to have the files in their possession professionally translated. Surely if they had noticed any major anomalies they would have brought them to SY's attention?
However, we don't know how many of the files were not released to the McCanns - but certainly not all of the 40 odd thousand documents SY had in their possession would have been seen by them IMO.
I think it would have been a physically impossible task to read through and collate that amount of information: in my opinion definitely a job for HOLMES.
Any way ... note to everyone ... we are once again sliding off topic.
Future comment concerning the increased award of £154,000 to Operation Grange to enable their search for Madeleine to continue ONLY. Thankyou
-
Sutton seems to suggest that there is room for error in translations,with £11+ million being spent I would like to think the translator's employed by the MET would be above that.
Hard to tell how much Sutton actually knows about the case... Nor is it clear how any questions asked of him as a pundit were phrased.
-
Even more vague...
The concept of "formal interviews" somehow got lost, possibly in the rush to meet the copy deadline.
Hard to tell which version is accurate, but the latter may give some the impression that there had been no contact, whereas the lack of a formal interview doesn't preclude informal interviews or contact.
On that Carana, we may find out in due course.
As you know, Redwood promised the investigation would have started at Square one, and that would have included, interviewing formerly, the Mccanns and their companions.
-
I think it would have been a physically impossible task to read through and collate that amount of information: in my opinion definitely a job for HOLMES.
Any way ... note to everyone ... we are once again sliding off topic.
Future comment concerning the increased award of £154,000 to Operation Grange to enable their search for Madeleine to continue ONLY. Thankyou
Hint taken, Brietta. ;)
-
It's difficult to work out where the media stand. It was known months ago that the T9 hadn't been formally interviewed by Operation Grange, so why mention it now? It looks like the Sunday Times took the plunge and the other newspapers copied their story.
They don't go into why it's significant either. Colin Sutton's opinion is interesting as he's a former Met detective, but the really significant fact is that the Portuguese Supreme Court pointed out that the first investigation was not able to rule the McCanns out of involvement, while A C Rowley suggested it had.
We are not party to what OG may KNOW.
But evidence that suggest The Mccanns were not there at the pertinent time, maybe ?
IMO
Last Edit: October 02, 2017, 11:52:24 PM by Slartibartfast »
ETA:
Why has the meaning of this post been altered? Slarti, yet again you have changed my words and there was no reason for interfering.
-
We are not party to what OG may KNOW.
But evidence that suggest The Mccanns were not there at the pertinent time, maybe ?
IMO
On that latest Panorama documentary they let slip a very important piece of information - the exact time of the alleged abduction 9:50 PM. You work out they discovered that?
https://youtu.be/s93f4FHRfBk?t=2386 OK it was Heriberto Janosch who proposed the time.
-
We are not party to what OG may KNOW.
But evidence that suggest The Mccanns were not there at the pertinent time, maybe ?
IMO
In fact they may have ABSOLUTE evidence that were not there at the pertinent time, or of SOMEONE ELSE that was there (an abductor?) and one of these may be the reason that they do not suspect The Mccanns.
WE are not party to all the KNOWN facts and neither shouild we be. IMO
-
On that latest Panorama documentary they let slip a very important piece of information - the exact time of the alleged abduction 9:50 PM. You work out they discovered that?
https://youtu.be/s93f4FHRfBk?t=2386 OK it was Heriberto Janosch who proposed the time.
These potential burglars only need to wake the child. The woken child can then wander. But that makes Madeleine wandering around the time that Russell is returning to the Tapas. I wonder how he didn't see anything?
-
We are not party to what OG may KNOW.
But evidence that suggest The Mccanns were not there at the pertinent time, maybe ?
IMO
No need to speculate, Sadie, it's not down to mysterious new evidence; Rowley told us how they did it;
"the involvement of the parents, that was dealt with at the time by the original investigation by the Portuguese."
Old evidence, not new. Evidence we have all seen too. From an investigation which couldn't even identify the crime, let alone what time it happened.
-
On the 11th anniversary of her disappearance, Madeleine McCann cops 'get yet
another £154,000 to continue investigation into missing girl for another six months'
The Met Police probe has been handed another £154,000 by the Home Office, according to the Daily Telegraph.
Details of the latest funds emerged in a parliamentary written answer from Baroness Williams of Trafford, a Home Office minister.
The answer stated: "An application from the Metropolitan Police Service (MPS) for further Special Grant funding for Operation Grange for 01 April – 30 September 2018 has been received.
"This is for an amount similar to the £154,000 granted for the period of 01 October 2017 – 31 March 2018.
"The MPS has been briefed that its latest application will be granted."
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/madeleine-mccann-cops-get-another-12471819