UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Brietta on September 28, 2017, 03:49:43 PM

Title: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Brietta on September 28, 2017, 03:49:43 PM
Cristovao continues to express opinions about Madeleine's case.

Ex-top cop breaks Madeleine McCann silence to say where he thinks she was taken
Paulo Pereira Cristovao says: “I think this case has lots of mistakes – from many persons, from many situations, from the police and maybe from the government"
BY ALAN SELBY
22:46, 22 APR 2017UPDATED11:42, 2 MAY 2017
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/ex-top-cop-breaks-madeleine-10278020


However much he dabbled in spreading disinformation during his tenure at Diario de Noticias ~ not even his fictional detectives pointed an accusing finger of involvement of Madeleine's parents.

Quote
Last year, as a columnist for Diario de Noticias, he became a prolific commentator on the Madeleine inquiry, writing a series of articles apparently derived in part from conversations with his former colleagues.
Quote
The book, much of it composed of a fictional dialogue between two fictional PJ officers, Francisco and Joao, recycles some of the cruellest smears against the McCanns, such as the claim that Gerry did not get sufficiently involved in the children's routines.

Such information, it claims, gave the police "an idea how the family functioned".

It also contains details that can have come only from inside the investigation: as a view of PJ thinking, it may well be as authentic an account as has yet been given.

If so, its conclusions are shocking, among them the view that Madeleine is dead and that if her parents did not kill her physically, they did so by their public campaign to find her.

"The publicity given to her face was her death warrant - that's if she really left that apartment still alive," he writes.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-560696/Madeleine-The-damning-case-police-Britains-investigative-reporter.html#ixzz4tz5vzuwj


Quote
Ten years ago, Mr Cristovao claimed the McCanns had been neglectful to leave their children alone as they dined nearby.

But he insists he does not believe Kate and Gerry, from Rothley, Leics, are behind her death.

He said: “The most important thing was starting an investigation on Madeleine – where is she? – instead of starting an investigation because the mother looks like this, or the father looks like that, or the mother won’t cry, or the father won’t cry.

“For me, that’s bulls**t, because everybody has their own way. ............ Everybody reacts differently.”
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/ex-top-cop-breaks-madeleine-10278020


So it may be ten years down the line since Madeleine's disappearance ... but here you have a man who apparently knows as much about Madeleine's case as the inspectors who worked it ... who is convinced enough of Madeleine's parents non involvement in any aspect of her disappearance to be directly quoted affirming his opinion of it.

49
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Montclair on September 28, 2017, 06:56:03 PM
He was very much involved with both the Joana and the Madeleine case so everything to do with it.  Mr Cristovao left the police to head up Portugal’s Association for Missing Children the year Maddie vanished. He later wrote a book about the case, "The Star of Madeleine".

http://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/520155/Madeleine-McCann-cop-trial-violent-robberies-Portugal-controversial-book

Paulo Pedro Cristóvão was not involved in anyway with the investigation into the disappearance of Maddie. All he did was write a book about it.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 28, 2017, 07:34:38 PM
Paulo Pedro Cristóvão was not involved in anyway with the investigation into the disappearance of Maddie. All he did was write a book about it.
Was it ever translated into English? Do you remember the title?

Found something myself "He gained widespread prominence after authoring a book, Estrela da Madeleine (Madeleine’s Star)
 in which he analyses the disappearance of Madeleine McCann from her holiday apartment almost eight years ago.
(http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/starOfMadeleine.JPG)
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Montclair on September 28, 2017, 07:41:03 PM
Was it ever translated into English? Do you remember the title?

I don't think that is was translated into English and IIRC the title is "A Estrela de Madeleine". I didn't read it.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: misty on September 28, 2017, 07:46:16 PM
Some translation of the book here, Rob.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic11923.html
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 28, 2017, 07:46:52 PM
I don't think that is was translated into English and IIRC the title is "Estrela de Maddie". I didn't read it.
Does that mean you read Portuguese?  Looking at the cover I thought the McCanns could have gone him for copyright infringement.  The cover looks so similar to Kate McCann's book.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 28, 2017, 08:16:35 PM
Some translation of the book here, Rob.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic11923.html
Quite mysterious "Due to legal issues, it cannot be me, the author, to tell you what the truth, the truth of the case, is; but I can assure you that you can find it here, among the lines of this book."  A real mystery hunt.

It sounds like a thriller "This book represents the opportunity to say the things that have not been written yet, and, essentially, what nobody has thought yet, or did not have the courage to reveal. Hence the challenge that is proposed to you, that of finding what is real in between the absurd of true facts and of fiction." 
Shame it wasn't translated if that is the case.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 28, 2017, 08:45:20 PM
It is available but only in Portuguese.  I'll see if I can get the book translated in full.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: John on September 28, 2017, 08:57:06 PM
Some translation of the book here, Rob.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic11923.html

Thanks for that misty, clearly Cristovao, being a senior member of the local PJ who had worked many other cases with Goncalo Amaral, was involved to the extent that he knew what was going on although not tasked directly in the investigation.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 28, 2017, 09:36:56 PM
Thanks for that misty, clearly Cristovao, as a member of the local PJ, was involved to the extent that he knew what was going on although not tasked directly in the investigation.

I am enjoying it, getting a pj prospective...
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: misty on September 28, 2017, 09:45:41 PM
Thanks for that misty, clearly Cristovao, being a senior member of the local PJ who had worked many other cases with Goncalo Amaral, was involved to the extent that he knew what was going on although not tasked directly in the investigation.

He retired in 2006, John, so should not have had access to any part of the investigation.
https://www.wook.pt/autor/paulo-pereira-cristovao/43650

Paulo Pereira Cristóvão nasceu em Lisboa, em Julho de 1969.
Entrou para os quadros da Polícia Judiciária em 1990, onde se manteve até 2006, após exoneração de funções a seu pedido. Durante esses anos, investigou alguns dos mais complexos processos de tráfico de seres humanos, terrorismo, homicídio, raptos, sequestros e organizações criminosas, como máfias de Leste, na Direcção Central de Combate ao Banditismo. Em 2004 optou pela investigação do crime económico, concretamente no combate à corrupção.
Durante aqueles anos recebeu formação de entidades nacionais e estrangeiras, nas especialidades de Perfis e Tendências Criminais, Perícia Psicológica, Justiça Criminal, entre outras.
Após sair da Polícia Judiciária, abriu uma empresa de business intelligence


Paulo Pereira Cristóvão was born in Lisbon in July 1969.
He entered the cadres of the Judicial Police in 1990, where he remained until 2006, after exoneration of duties at his request. During these years, he investigated some of the most complex human trafficking, terrorism, murder, kidnapping, kidnapping and criminal organizations such as Eastern Mafia in the Central Directorate for Combating Banditry. In 2004 he chose to investigate economic crime, specifically in the fight against corruption.
During those years he was trained by national and foreign entities, in the specialties of Criminal Profiles and Trends, Psychological Expertise, Criminal Justice, among others.
After leaving the Judicial Police, he opened a business intelligence company

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

@ Rob
Uns Feios, Outros Porcos, Todos Maus
de Paulo Pereira Cristóvão

I'd be interested in reading the translation of this book.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: John on September 28, 2017, 10:28:58 PM
I am enjoying it, getting a pj prospective...

An interesting comment which I don't recall being discussed previously...

Quote from: Chapter 10
João Tavares replies:

- Let’s see: according to the neighbour upstairs, mother and daughter had been yelling at each other. It seems that the child was hyperactive

and later on...

Quote from: Chapyer 16
When questioned about the relationship that was visible between Madeleine and her parents, all the witnesses that were interrogated by the investigators were unanimous in saying that there was a lot of complicity between father and daughter. The neighbor that lives above apartment 5A stated that she heard Madeleine shouting, during those days that the family spent at the Ocean Club, for two sorts of reasons. Either because she was yelling at her mother while her mother yelled back, or because she was screaming out for her father. This portrait was interesting for the policemen, as it offered them an idea of what that family could be like.

Later in time, when they read the mother’s diary, they confirmed just that. Kate called her daughter ‘hysterical’ and hyperactive, consuming the mother’s strength to a limit, while she complained that Gerry didn’t help her much with the children, leaving her with the chore, the heavy chore, of taking care of those children on her own. She was probably not referring to the action of ‘raising’ them, but rather to daily care: food, clothing, baths, putting them to bed, teaching discipline. This also helps to understand the reason why Madeleine, and probably also the twins, preferred their father. He was associated to playing and to good things. The mother was associated to less pleasant issues of daily life.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: misty on September 28, 2017, 11:27:26 PM
An interesting comment which I don't recall being discussed previously...

and later on...

Is Cristovao implying that there is another statement from Mrs Fenn which is missing from the files? If so, why did Mrs Fenn feel the need to repeat the Tuesday crying incident in her August statement?
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: John on September 28, 2017, 11:31:04 PM
Is Cristovao implying that there is another statement from Mrs Fenn which is missing from the files? If so, why did Mrs Fenn feel the need to repeat the Tuesday crying incident in her August statement?

As I have stated repeatedly, detectives are privileged to much more information that ever appears in any statements and we must remember that always.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on September 28, 2017, 11:34:02 PM
It really is an eye opener this book.

This is quite pertinent:

Post subject: Re: A Estrela de Madeleine

PostPosted: Wed Feb 23, 2011 9:43 pm 

 

Offline

Joined: Fri Aug 21, 2009 12:50 pm
Posts: 11064   

Chapter 27 – Finally...


It was in this police, social, political, journalistic and psychological context that the main characters of this play lived, throughout many months. Because, after all, this is a show. It had everything that a grand production needs: leading actors, supporting actors, doubles, “lights, camera, action”, laughter, tears, lies, police cunning, police ingenuity, the good and the bad, the innocent girl, power games, manipulation, “blood, sweat and tears”, hatred and love, ostentation, good people and bad people, solidarity that was denied to those who needed it, and when they needed it most.

As if this were not enough, this mega-production also included prime ministers, directors, prosecutors, English millionaires, ambassadors, bottomless funds, loaned airplanes, a pope who receives but not too much, a cardinal who is a fierce defendant of Opus Dei, secret services, sightings from Jupiter, express CSIs, lots and lots of DNA, private investigators who are constantly a step away from cracking the case, crazy associations of conspiracies… a world of actions and characters that set this show in motion, a show that took place in a small, unknown village, Aldeia da Luz, which ended up projecting itself all over the planet.

Were we prepared for all of this? Obviously not. Which does not mean that after making the necessary adaptations, we did not rise to the situation, which we did. We took a while to adjust to the novelty. It’s normal, in a human being. What is not normal is that those who have the truth right in front of them, refuse to see her, simply because it is not convenient.

In the beginning, we said we could be integrated but not submitted. Look at Spain, the country right next to us. If this case had taken place there, it would not have had an external approach like it did in Portugal, simply because Spain is duly integrated within Europe, but still places its national identity and pride before everything else. Unfortunately, in Portugal this is not always the main perspective.

Throughout more than 60 years of history, the Portuguese Policia Judiciaria was always proud of its good work. It was an institution that had its very peculiar culture, one of transmission of knowledge among colleagues. The greatest asset of that police force was the mixture of people that formed its investigative personnel.

People from humble origins and others from wealthy families. Some who had only basic instruction and others with a degree. For all of them, to become an “Agent with the Policia Judiciaria” was a motive of pride and worthy of everyone’s respect.

This mixture of backgrounds, all of them necessary with a PJ Brigade, often helped to solve cases through a combination of experiences and perceptions, which had been obtained from real life. And this mixture created a feeling of solidarity and of familiarity. It was a second family for many agents, and not rarely, it was their only family.

Criminal investigation today is not exempt from mistakes, because it has to be done by men and women, not by error-free computers. Facts and possibilities are analyzed under the light of knowledge that was produced by others before, and adapted to each case in particular. It is not always done the best way, but other professions also make mistakes, so why would anyone believe that criminal investigators are free from error? This is precisely why everyone is considered innocent until proved guilty.

The serious criminal investigator, when he makes a mistake or when he makes a conclusive judgment, does not do it inadvertently, but rather because indices point him into that way. He is a collector of evidence, which, directly or indirectly, will allow the law to produce an accusation against someone for the practice of a crime. And even because those who have the mission of accusing others, may also err, because they are also men and women, there are other stages that follow, of a superior hierarchy in terms of decision, that are under the responsibility of other men and women, whose mission it is to judge the accuracy of the steps that had been taken before. Of course, the system does not always function in such a clear manner, due to the fact that we are dealing with human beings, and power and control so often rule above the truth. This investigation has largely overstepped the mere search for truth about what happened to the little girl. It has become a power game in which different forces have disputed everything among them, except for the desire to discover the truth.

Finally, everything was done and the conclusion is that the investigators will have a hard time to reach their initial goals, but it will still be a dignified conclusion to the work and dedication that were placed into this case. Madeleine Beth McCann would thank them, for everything that they gave up for her, and for the search. For her truth. If someday, someone would like to thank them, they will reply:

“You’re welcome. That is what we are here for!”
 
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 29, 2017, 12:48:15 AM
Is this the whole book translated? 

A Estrela de Madeleine

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic11923.html?sid=8c96e889c80219d5f2bf298df4e5407d
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic11923-10.html
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic11923-20.html

Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Brietta on September 29, 2017, 12:56:10 AM
Is this the whole book translated? 

A Estrela de Madeleine

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic11923.html?sid=8c96e889c80219d5f2bf298df4e5407d
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic11923-10.html
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic11923-20.html

I believe it only consists of 150 pages ... so could be ... I've never read it from start to finish.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Montclair on September 29, 2017, 10:16:36 AM
Thanks for that misty, clearly Cristovao, being a senior member of the local PJ who had worked many other cases with Goncalo Amaral, was involved to the extent that he knew what was going on although not tasked directly in the investigation.

He did not work many other cases with Gonçalo Amaral! PPC was stationed in Lisbon and GA in the Algarve.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Montclair on September 29, 2017, 10:18:58 AM
Does that mean you read Portuguese?  Looking at the cover I thought the McCanns could have gone him for copyright infringement.  The cover looks so similar to Kate McCann's book.

I read Portuguese. I believe that PPC wrote his book long before Kate McCann wrote hers.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Lace on September 29, 2017, 10:49:39 AM
Is this the whole book translated? 

A Estrela de Madeleine

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic11923.html?sid=8c96e889c80219d5f2bf298df4e5407d
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic11923-10.html
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/topic11923-20.html

I just skimmed through a few chapters and already I have picked up on a glaring error,   he says the spare bed was not in use and would have showed up a footprint,   Kate McCann had slept in that bed the night before and it was unmade,   so that is totally wrong to start with.

I don't have time for someone who wasn't there and has decided to write a book on what he thinks happened.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: stephen25000 on September 29, 2017, 11:00:17 AM
I just skimmed through a few chapters and already I have picked up on a glaring error,   he says the spare bed was not in use and would have showed up a footprint,   Kate McCann had slept in that bed the night before and it was unmade,   so that is totally wrong to start with.

I don't have time for someone who wasn't there and has decided to write a book on what he thinks happened.

You weren't there, so how do you know what happened Lace ?
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Erngath on September 29, 2017, 11:05:27 AM
You weren't there, so how do you know what happened Lace ?


Lace didn't write a book pretending to know what happened.
He did!
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Lace on September 29, 2017, 11:17:30 AM
You weren't there, so how do you know what happened Lace ?

I wasn't there,  and I haven't written a book pretending to know what evidence there was.

I can see from the photographs taken of the bedroom in 5a that the bed was unmade,   Kate McCann said in her statement that she had slept in that bed the night before.   I believe the Police officers observed the bed too.

So it looks as though this person hasn't even bothered to look at the police photographs.

I take with a pinch of salt a book written by someone who hasn't even bothered to read the facts.


Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Lace on September 29, 2017, 11:21:04 AM
As I have stated repeatedly, detectives are privileged to much more information that ever appears in any statements and we must remember that always.

Oh come off it John,   do you not think Amaral would grabbed this information with both hands and made a meal of it in his book?    'Look evil Kate she moaned about her child,  she was desperate for help'. 

Mrs. Fenn denied saying that she heard screaming from 5a,  she said she didn't even know they were there,   so who do you believe?
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: stephen25000 on September 29, 2017, 11:33:39 AM
I wasn't there,  and I haven't written a book pretending to know what evidence there was.

I can see from the photographs taken of the bedroom in 5a that the bed was unmade,   Kate McCann said in her statement that she had slept in that bed the night before.   I believe the Police officers observed the bed too.

So it looks as though this person hasn't even bothered to look at the police photographs.

I take with a pinch of salt a book written by someone who hasn't even bothered to read the facts.

Actually, Madeleine's bed looks unused.

As to be taken with a pinch of salt, that is how I regard the Mccann book.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: slartibartfast on September 29, 2017, 12:01:38 PM
Oh come off it John,   do you not think Amaral would grabbed this information with both hands and made a meal of it in his book?    'Look evil Kate she moaned about her child,  she was desperate for help'. 

Mrs. Fenn denied saying that she heard screaming from 5a,  she said she didn't even know they were there,   so who do you believe?

Cite please for Mrs Fenn.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Montclair on September 29, 2017, 12:40:28 PM
From what I remember about the book when it came out, PPC stated that it was fiction using the disappearance of Maddie as a basis for the story.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 29, 2017, 12:46:00 PM
From what I remember about the book when it came out, PPC stated that it was fiction using the disappearance of Maddie as a basis for the story.
But in amongst that fiction are facts so he says.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Angelo222 on September 29, 2017, 12:52:10 PM
He did not work many other cases with Gonçalo Amaral! PPC was stationed in Lisbon and GA in the Algarve.

From what I have seen they worked potential child abduction cases together.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Lace on September 29, 2017, 01:04:53 PM
Actually, Madeleine's bed looks unused.

As to be taken with a pinch of salt, that is how I regard the Mccann book.

He's not talking about Madeleine's bed,  he's talking about the spare bed.   Saying if someone came in through the window they would have left a foot print.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 29, 2017, 01:28:41 PM
He's not talking about Madeleine's bed,  he's talking about the spare bed.   Saying if someone came in through the window they would have left a foot print.
More like an indent rather than a footprint IMO.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Lace on September 29, 2017, 01:41:10 PM
More like an indent rather than a footprint IMO.

Rob,   this is what is said in chapter one of the book  - 
The furniture is impeccably aligned against the walls, as if someone had tried to make as much room as possible, in the center of the living room. In the bedroom, the bed where the child was sleeping is on the opposite side of the window. Under the window, there is another bed that had not been in use. Whomever entered through the window, would have left foot marks on the bed, which in that position resembled a trap. But that had not happened.



See he says 'there is another bed THAT HAD NOT BEEN IN USE,  whomever entered through the window, would have left  foot marks on the bed.

The bed under the window had been in use,   Kate slept in it the night before.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Lace on September 29, 2017, 01:45:18 PM
Cite please for Mrs Fenn.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KFHbkbBh5BM
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: stephen25000 on September 29, 2017, 01:51:09 PM
He's not talking about Madeleine's bed,  he's talking about the spare bed.   Saying if someone came in through the window they would have left a foot print.

I was talking about Madeleine's bed.

That was an anomaly from the start for me.

It did not look slept in.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Brietta on September 29, 2017, 03:01:44 PM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KFHbkbBh5BM

Think we may be sliding off topic a wee bit ... but I found this of interest ...

Tot's screams 'a myth' Sunday Mirror

THE SEARCH FOR MADELEINE DAY 143

By Grant Hodgson
23/09/2007

A key witness in the Madeleine McCann case yesterday DENIED telling cops that she heard the family screaming and arguing.

Pamela Fenn, 81, who lives above the Praia da Luz apartment Madeleine vanished from, supposedly said she heard the four-year-old "scream for four hours" the night before. The reports fuelled police theories that mum Kate sedated Madeleine. But widow Mrs Fenn, interviewed by police two days after Madeleine disappeared, said: "I never heard her screaming or Kate and Gerry arguing.

"I didn't realise anything was wrong until I heard all sorts of commotion outside."
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/Nigel/id331.htm


Quite frankly I think anything at all emanating from Portugal sources and amateur translators particularly those from hairdressers' salons ... is so suspect as to be next to worthless.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Lace on September 29, 2017, 03:27:56 PM
I was talking about Madeleine's bed.

That was an anomaly from the start for me.

It did not look slept in.

Ah so you don't believe Amaral's theory about Madeleine waking groggy from sleep [in her bed] and falling from the sofa?

You believe they disposed of her body early on in the evening,   taking her somewhere no one could find her,  not the sea it was too shallow, not thrown over a cliff,  body would have hit the rocks,  not buried,  ground too hard.  Where Stephen?   In the bag in the wardrobe that they didn't take with them when they went to the Paynes apartment?   Or earlier in the week and they took a cardboard cut out to the crèche?   Don't forget they managed to retrieve her body weeks later,   to take her somewhere in the car,  or was it to put her in someone's coffin?
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Montclair on September 29, 2017, 03:35:29 PM
From what I have seen they worked potential child abduction cases together.

Can you give the examples because the only case that I know of where they worked together was the disappearance of Joana Cipriano?

Also, PPC's book came out in March 2008, even before the archiving of the case and before Kate's book.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: stephen25000 on September 29, 2017, 03:38:00 PM
Ah so you don't believe Amaral's theory about Madeleine waking groggy from sleep [in her bed] and falling from the sofa?

You believe they disposed of her body early on in the evening,   taking her somewhere no one could find her,  not the sea it was too shallow, not thrown over a cliff,  body would have hit the rocks,  not buried,  ground too hard.  Where Stephen?   In the bag in the wardrobe that they didn't take with them when they went to the Paynes apartment?   Or earlier in the week and they took a cardboard cut out to the crèche?   Don't forget they managed to retrieve her body weeks later,   to take her somewhere in the car,  or was it to put her in someone's coffin?

You obviously have no idea what happened.

We merely speculate.

Amaral was on the scene, which as far as I know is true for all posters on here.

By the way, it is best to avoid goading Lace.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: barrier on September 29, 2017, 03:40:16 PM
Ah so you don't believe Amaral's theory about Madeleine waking groggy from sleep [in her bed] and falling from the sofa?

You believe they disposed of her body early on in the evening,   taking her somewhere no one could find her,  not the sea it was too shallow, not thrown over a cliff,  body would have hit the rocks,  not buried,  ground too hard.  Where Stephen?   In the bag in the wardrobe that they didn't take with them when they went to the Paynes apartment?   Or earlier in the week and they took a cardboard cut out to the crèche?   Don't forget they managed to retrieve her body weeks later,   to take her somewhere in the car,  or was it to put her in someone's coffin?

Yet for all the publicity surrounding Operation Grange they have yet to come up with any thing that officially debunks any theory.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Lace on September 29, 2017, 04:47:33 PM
Yet for all the publicity surrounding Operation Grange they have yet to come up with any thing that officially debunks any theory.

OG have stated the McCann's are not innocent,  that debunked the death by accident theory.

Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Lace on September 29, 2017, 04:48:39 PM
You obviously have no idea what happened.

We merely speculate.

Amaral was on the scene, which as far as I know is true for all posters on here.

By the way, it is best to avoid goading Lace.

Ah in other words I don't know.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: John on September 29, 2017, 04:51:10 PM
I just skimmed through a few chapters and already I have picked up on a glaring error,   he says the spare bed was not in use and would have showed up a footprint,   Kate McCann had slept in that bed the night before and it was unmade,   so that is totally wrong to start with.

I don't have time for someone who wasn't there and has decided to write a book on what he thinks happened.

But was it unmade or disturbed by someone?

(http://i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00785/madeleine-bedroom2_785841c.jpg)
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: stephen25000 on September 29, 2017, 04:53:14 PM
OG have stated the McCann's are not innocent,  that debunked the death by accident theory.

Perhaps you should read that again.

Besides they don't know what happened. They are still scratching their proverbials.

IMHO of course.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Lace on September 29, 2017, 04:56:27 PM
But was it unmade or disturbed by someone?

(http://i.telegraph.co.uk/multimedia/archive/00785/madeleine-bedroom2_785841c.jpg)

It was unmade,  Kate had slept in it.    Do you think no one would have mentioned the fact that the made was made and then found in that state?
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: John on September 29, 2017, 04:59:13 PM
Think we may be sliding off topic a wee bit ... but I found this of interest ...

Tot's screams 'a myth' Sunday Mirror

THE SEARCH FOR MADELEINE DAY 143

By Grant Hodgson
23/09/2007

A key witness in the Madeleine McCann case yesterday DENIED telling cops that she heard the family screaming and arguing.

Pamela Fenn, 81, who lives above the Praia da Luz apartment Madeleine vanished from, supposedly said she heard the four-year-old "scream for four hours" the night before. The reports fuelled police theories that mum Kate sedated Madeleine. But widow Mrs Fenn, interviewed by police two days after Madeleine disappeared, said: "I never heard her screaming or Kate and Gerry arguing.

"I didn't realise anything was wrong until I heard all sorts of commotion outside."
http://www.gerrymccannsblogs.co.uk/Nigel/id331.htm


Quite frankly I think anything at all emanating from Portugal sources and amateur translators particularly those from hairdressers' salons ... is so suspect as to be next to worthless.

I suppose there is a subtle but distinct difference between screaming and crying.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: John on September 29, 2017, 05:00:44 PM
It was unmade,  Kate had slept in it.    Do you think no one would have mentioned the fact that the made was made and then found in that state?

We have no earthly means of knowing how and when the bedclothes got into that state.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Lace on September 29, 2017, 05:15:59 PM
We have no earthly means of knowing how and when the bedclothes got into that state.

Apart from Kate saying she slept in it,  why would she lie?

After all to say she hadn't slept in it but found it like that would be beneficial for the abduction scenario wouldn't it?

The fact is the person writing that book,  didn't know the evidence of the case by saying it was an unused bed.   So if he got that simple fact wrong,  then he most certainly got a lot more wrong in his book.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: barrier on September 29, 2017, 05:28:51 PM
OG have stated the McCann's are not innocent,  that debunked the death by accident theory.

Pardon?
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: John on September 29, 2017, 05:35:53 PM
Another to add to the list Lace.

I found three references to "the spare tire" [sic] in Cristovao's book but the Renault Grand Scenic carries its spare wheel under the car where one is fitted.  There is no spare tyre boot well in the Grand Scenic, only the shorter Scenic has this feature.  The small compartment in the boot is where the tools and puncture repair canister are stored.

From the book...Ch 10 and CH 13

"Second,  when  they  detected  the  odour  of  death  on  the  key  of  the  car  that  they  used,  which  was rented  more  than  twenty  days  after  the  little  girl  went  missing.  In  the  same  car  where  they  found traces  of  blood  and  hair  under  the  spare  tire."

"But  then,  chief,  what  about  the  residues  that  the  dogs  detected  inside  the  Renaul  Scenic?  Francisco  questions.-  Well,  that  really  messed  the  whole  picture  up,  because  finding  that  type  of  residues  in  the  area that  is  located  just  beneath  the  spare  tire  is  a  complicated  matter;  come  to  think  of  it,  it’s  not  really that  complicated…  or  at  least  not  to  me  –  the  chief  replies,  smiling.-  Sure  –  Francisco  continues  –  one  thing  is  to  transport  clothing  that  might  have  carried  traces from  the  child.  They  did  move  house  twice,  after  all,  didn’t  they?  Another  entirely  different  matter is  the  location  of  the  dog’s  findings.  Precisely  the  spot  where  one  would  hide  things  inside  a  car, right?  In  the  cavity  for  the  spare  tire,  more  precisely  beneath  the  tire.  What  a  strange  thing,  chief."
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Angelo222 on September 29, 2017, 05:48:54 PM
Can you give the examples because the only case that I know of where they worked together was the disappearance of Joana Cipriano?

Also, PPC's book came out in March 2008, even before the archiving of the case and before Kate's book.

My mistake Montclair, I should have said Kate's diaries and not the book.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: John on September 29, 2017, 06:02:56 PM
Please note that there are two threads relating to Paulo Pereira Cristovao.  Please ensure you post to the correct topic.  TY
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Robittybob1 on September 29, 2017, 07:55:58 PM
My mistake Montclair, I should have said Kate's diaries and not the book.
How does one get to read her diary?
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: John on September 29, 2017, 10:06:38 PM
How does one get to read her diary?

The police have access to just about everything Rob.

By the way, if anyone wants a pdf copy of Paulo's semi fictional book just pm me.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: slartibartfast on September 30, 2017, 09:10:04 AM
Apart from Kate saying she slept in it,  why would she lie?

After all to say she hadn't slept in it but found it like that would be beneficial for the abduction scenario wouldn't it?

The fact is the person writing that book,  didn't know the evidence of the case by saying it was an unused bed.   So if he got that simple fact wrong,  then he most certainly got a lot more wrong in his book.

Generally speaking, the police do not take suspect’s statements as gospel.
Title: Re: Former PJ inspector Paulo Pereira Cristovao and his book 'Madeleine's Star.'
Post by: Angelo222 on September 30, 2017, 05:28:19 PM
Generally speaking, the police do not take suspect’s statements as gospel.

A statement is merely a summary which allows the prosecutor's to make a decision about progressing a case.  The police have so much more information at their disposal.