UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Robittybob1 on October 17, 2017, 07:36:54 PM

Title: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 17, 2017, 07:36:54 PM
Snippets of conversation about the sailing on Thursday:

"they did not take these children sailing it wouldn't be allowed and no parent would agree to it. For any outside of the building activities parental consent is needed and the Ocean Club would need expensive insurance policies to do it. No such documents exist."

"so you are saying someone lied about that activity. OK I'll look into it again."

"It must have been a major error on Goncalo's watch if he was told they went sailing when they didn't."

"Even if they went sailing parents would have joined them to make sure they were safe surely"

 "I don't know, they were very small boats with just 3 kids at a time."

"It would not be allowed to take small children out on the Atlantic with only nursery nurse and no qualified supervision, it is absolutely ludicrous. Not only that it would take them half an hour to get down there and half an hour back at least 15 minutes each way to get them ready so that's two hours so when did they do any alleged sailing."

"The whole story worried me too. So were the staff lying? that is the question."

 "Maybe they just went a few meters into the water."

 "On the forum we have a person who lives in Luz so I could ask them what Ocean Club does for sailing activities with the kids. He is a friend of John Hill who is still there."

 "Even if they just used blow up toy boats, there is still no time to do it in and why are they lying to make it into a major sailing expedition. This was a drop in centre where parents came to pick up at varying times some just dropping for an hour. There are no filled in forms produced for any outside of the creche activities.
Well ask would seem like a strange activity to do on such a short time
People also dropped off at varying times not just pick up."

As you can see from that there is a debate out there whether the sailing for the kids actually took place.  What does the forum think?
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: jassi on October 17, 2017, 08:42:21 PM
I've always thought taking children of that age 'sailing' a bit foolhardy, but I wasn't there so don't know what it involved.
Maybe it was nothing more than a small inflatable towed around within a shallow roped-off area of water.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on October 17, 2017, 08:53:57 PM
I've always thought taking children of that age 'sailing' a bit foolhardy, but I wasn't there so don't know what it involved.
Maybe it was nothing more than a small inflatable towed around within a shallow roped-off area of water.

and going sailing sounds just spiffing and jolly food fun...what , what Rodger! but, to be fair being planked in a rubber dingy and towed around in a pool can be fun for 3 year olds...
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 17, 2017, 09:31:46 PM
Danny Collins says they just built sand castles on the Thursday http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=8391.msg418508#msg418508
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: G-Unit on October 17, 2017, 10:22:16 PM

https://twitter.com/TiredmummyofTwo/status/607820385808187393/photo/1
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on October 17, 2017, 10:35:43 PM
https://twitter.com/TiredmummyofTwo/status/607820385808187393/photo/1

No pictures of actual ships then?  No pictures of water under said ships? awww Maybe the McCanns took pictures of the children having 'fun'...
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: sadie on October 18, 2017, 12:10:24 AM
Snippets of conversation about the sailing on Thursday:

"they did not take these children sailing it wouldn't be allowed and no parent would agree to it. For any outside of the building activities parental consent is needed and the Ocean Club would need expensive insurance policies to do it. No such documents exist."

"so you are saying someone lied about that activity. OK I'll look into it again."

"It must have been a major error on Goncalo's watch if he was told they went sailing when they didn't."

"Even if they went sailing parents would have joined them to make sure they were safe surely"

 "I don't know, they were very small boats with just 3 kids at a time."

"It would not be allowed to take small children out on the Atlantic with only nursery nurse and no qualified supervision, it is absolutely ludicrous. Not only that it would take them half an hour to get down there and half an hour back at least 15 minutes each way to get them ready so that's two hours so when did they do any alleged sailing."

"The whole story worried me too. So were the staff lying? that is the question."

 "Maybe they just went a few meters into the water."

 "On the forum we have a person who lives in Luz so I could ask them what Ocean Club does for sailing activities with the kids. He is a friend of John Hill who is still there."

 "Even if they just used blow up toy boats, there is still no time to do it in and why are they lying to make it into a major sailing expedition. This was a drop in centre where parents came to pick up at varying times some just dropping for an hour. There are no filled in forms produced for any outside of the creche activities.
Well ask would seem like a strange activity to do on such a short time
People also dropped off at varying times not just pick up."

As you can see from that there is a debate out there whether the sailing for the kids actually took place.  What does the forum think?

I dont know who suggested half an hour each way, but just spare a moment and measure distances on Google earth. 
From the Madeleines nursery group venue, by the main reception, to the beach was no more than 350 metres.  By  using some of the large number of small alleyways (very safe) the distance is probably no more than 300 metres.   Madeleine was the youngest so with all the other children older, my bet is that they set a cracking pace.

https://www.quora.com/How-much-time-does-it-take-to-walk-300-meters-for-a-normal-adult

About 3.5 minutes for a normal adult for 300 metres and I would suggest that excited children in a rope crocadile would do the same distance in less than twice that time.   When going somewhere exciting, even quite small children manage to keep up with adults, but for discussions sake I prefer to double the time.

So shall we say a very conservative 8 minutes each way?

......................

I feel sure that if they were going into water anything deeper than the shortests childs height, there would be one adult per child and additionally life jackets.  + probably a rescue boat at standby ... and despite what someone says, there would be insurance in place.  IMO

These kids were old enough to put their own cardigans and coats on, so why would it take so long to life jacket them up?   They could do most of it themselves.


I think the timings mentioned here are unreal, just as at one time the timings from Tapas restaurant to 5A used to be grossly entended, so are the timings on here imo


FGS How would a working Mum ever be able to get her little ones dressed and ready and taken somewhere before she got to work, if it took her these sort of times?


I really cannot understand why so many people in PdL are disbelieved.  In my experience most people are honest
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 18, 2017, 12:49:45 AM
It seems the PJ looked into Cat Bakers sailing episode and they seem to agree it happened.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CATRIONA-TREASA-B.htm  in their report they have the distance as only 100 meters.
"The route taken was as follows:

1. The parents left the children at "Baby Club", Mark Warner, situated next to the principal reception and which is open 24 hours;
2. then Catriona, with Madeleine and 4 or 5 more children, walked toward the beach. The distance is about 100 metres but not in a straight line;"
Was it really checked?
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: sadie on October 18, 2017, 01:03:26 AM
It seems the PJ looked into Cat Bakers sailing episode and they seem to agree it happened.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CATRIONA-TREASA-B.htm  in their report they have the distance as only 100 meters.
"The route taken was as follows:

1. The parents left the children at "Baby Club", Mark Warner, situated next to the principal reception and which is open 24 hours;
2. then Catriona, with Madeleine and 4 or 5 more children, walked toward the beach. The distance is about 100 metres but not in a straight line;"
Was it really checked?

I think she has that wrong, but please feel free to measure the distance on GE. [Use the stubby blue upright rule on the top band to measure with.  Set it to "path" and the distances to metres.  Measuring a bending path is a bit fiddly until you get used to it]

Had it been only a hundred metres, then it would have taken even less time.  Shall we be generous and say 4 minutes each way?


I think the OC nannies were truthful and the sailing, even if minor stuff, did happen
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: G-Unit on October 18, 2017, 08:16:09 AM
I dont know who suggested half an hour each way, but just spare a moment and measure distances on Google earth. 
From the Madeleines nursery group venue, by the main reception, to the beach was no more than 350 metres.  By  using some of the large number of small alleyways (very safe) the distance is probably no more than 300 metres.   Madeleine was the youngest so with all the other children older, my bet is that they set a cracking pace.

https://www.quora.com/How-much-time-does-it-take-to-walk-300-meters-for-a-normal-adult

About 3.5 minutes for a normal adult for 300 metres and I would suggest that excited children in a rope crocadile would do the same distance in less than twice that time.   When going somewhere exciting, even quite small children manage to keep up with adults, but for discussions sake I prefer to double the time.

So shall we say a very conservative 8 minutes each way?

......................

I feel sure that if they were going into water anything deeper than the shortests childs height, there would be one adult per child and additionally life jackets.  + probably a rescue boat at standby ... and despite what someone says, there would be insurance in place.  IMO

These kids were old enough to put their own cardigans and coats on, so why would it take so long to life jacket them up?   They could do most of it themselves.


I think the timings mentioned here are unreal, just as at one time the timings from Tapas restaurant to 5A used to be grossly entended, so are the timings on here imo


FGS How would a working Mum ever be able to get her little ones dressed and ready and taken somewhere before she got to work, if it took her these sort of times?


I really cannot understand why so many people in PdL are disbelieved.  In my experience most people are honest

Who says "Madeleine was the youngest? "
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: sadie on October 18, 2017, 09:24:51 AM
Who says "Madeleine was the youngest? "
Who was younger then?

I well remember a discussion on forum about Madeleine being too young for her groups normal age range, with someone saying that she would be OK because of her abilities (intellect and sociability?  Dunno now, anyone remember?)



Who was youmger Gunit?
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: jassi on October 18, 2017, 09:30:13 AM
Wasn't she in the same group as one of Tanner's children, who was a few months  younger than Madeleine?
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: G-Unit on October 18, 2017, 10:02:37 AM
Who was younger then?

I well remember a discussion on forum about Madeleine being too young for her groups normal age range, with someone saying that she would be OK because of her abilities (intellect and sociability?  Dunno now, anyone remember?)



Who was youmger Gunit?

Perhaps it's a false memory Sadie. Most of the Mini's were 3 years of age. Not knowing their birth dates I've no idea who was the youngest. 
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: jassi on October 18, 2017, 10:05:53 AM
Perhaps it's a false memory Sadie. Most of the Mini's were 3 years of age. Not knowing their birth dates I've no idea who was the youngest.

Madeleine was almost 4, so not likely to be the youngest then.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: G-Unit on October 18, 2017, 10:41:12 AM
The biggest problem with the sailing in my opinion is the statement of the nanny who shared the care of the Minis.

She is not sure whether during the morning Madeleine's group had outdoor activities.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/EMMA_WILDING.htm

On the morning of 3rd at 10 am, Catriona took 6 children out of the Mini Club to the beach. Her colleague seems not to have noticed, even though she must have been preparing to take her group to the tennis courts for Mini tennis at 10.30 am. She does manage to remember that Gerry dropped Madeleine off that morning and collected her at lunchtime though. (he didn't)

She also says;

on Wednesday May 2, her group and Madeleine's group went to the beach

According to Catriona's programme of activities the Lobsters didn't go to the beach on Wednesday, however.

Lyndsay Johnson says;

on a date which she cannot be precise about but which was some time last week, Madeleine McCann participated in a boat trip, organised by the company's crêche. Several children participated in this outing to the sea, accompanied by the employees mentioned above and an expert in water activities, whose name she is not aware of.

The employees mentioned are;

 the "MiniClub" category is supervised by her colleague Amy T. who, in her turn, coordinates a group of leaders composed of Catriona B. and Emma W.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LYNSAY-JAYNE.htm



Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Robittybob1 on October 18, 2017, 11:07:44 AM
The biggest problem with the sailing in my opinion is the statement of the nanny who shared the care of the Minis.

She is not sure whether during the morning Madeleine's group had outdoor activities.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/EMMA_WILDING.htm

On the morning of 3rd at 10 am, Catriona took 6 children out of the Mini Club to the beach. Her colleague seems not to have noticed, even though she must have been preparing to take her group to the tennis courts for Mini tennis at 10.30 am. She does manage to remember that Gerry dropped Madeleine off that morning and collected her at lunchtime though. (he didn't)

She also says;

on Wednesday May 2, her group and Madeleine's group went to the beach

According to Catriona's programme of activities the Lobsters didn't go to the beach on Wednesday, however.

Lyndsay Johnson says;

on a date which she cannot be precise about but which was some time last week, Madeleine McCann participated in a boat trip, organised by the company's crêche. Several children participated in this outing to the sea, accompanied by the employees mentioned above and an expert in water activities, whose name she is not aware of.

The employees mentioned are;

 the "MiniClub" category is supervised by her colleague Amy T. who, in her turn, coordinates a group of leaders composed of Catriona B. and Emma W.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/LYNSAY-JAYNE.htm
That is hardly enough to say it didn't happen is it?
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: G-Unit on October 18, 2017, 11:32:11 AM
That is hardly enough to say it didn't happen is it?

I didn't say it didn't happen, just that the only nanny who said it did happen on the day and in the form she described it was Catriona.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Robittybob1 on March 19, 2019, 01:35:39 AM
What day and what time did the kids do their sailing activity?

Catriona Baker's rogatory statement has: "On Thursday the 3rd of May 2007, I remember Gerry having accompanied Madeleine to the club between 9h15 and 9h20 in the morning. I do not remember who came to pick her up for lunch but after she returned in the afternoon for a dive/swim. These activities were realized with the other children. On this day I remember that we sailed and I saw friends of the McCanns on the beach, David and Jane. Around 14h45 Madeleine returned to the Minis Club on top of the reception but I do not remember who accompanied her. This afternoon we went swimming."

That makes it sound as if it was an afternoon activity.  Where did the "dive/swim" take place?  Was that down at the beach?  http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CAT_BAKER.htm
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Robittybob1 on March 19, 2019, 01:40:38 AM
"During the week which Madeleine stayed in the club there were three events organized that included a trip to the beach. One of these events took place on Thursday in the morning, as referred to previously. Another of these events consisted of a trip to the beach with "hula hoops", shovels and buckets, etc, and the other trip to the beach was in order to eat ice cream. Together, the trips to the beach took place in the afternoon but I cannot state precisely which days. There should be a recording of this in the Mark Warner registers.

During these trips to the beach I never noticed anything untoward given that my attention was on the children in my charge."
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CAT_BAKER.htm

But now the sailing trip happens Thursday morning.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Robittybob1 on March 19, 2019, 01:45:53 AM
(http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/04%20-%20VOLUME%20IVa_Page_873_prosesso.jpg)

There was a "dive and find pool time organised for Thursday afternoon.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Robittybob1 on March 19, 2019, 01:53:16 AM
"- On the first two days the children played and did activities in the sand. On the Thursday they went sailing next to the beach.
- On that day they sailed in a small yellow "catamaran";
- Alice Standley accompanied the children on the route and on the boat. Three children sailed with her at one time;

- Chris Unswork transported the children in a red amphibious boat (life-saving boat) until the boat reached the open sea, and, a few minutes later, returned them to the beach to pick up three other children from the group;"

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CATRIONA-TREASA-B.htm

In both situations there was one supervisor looking after 3 kids.   So they would definitely be in trouble if a child fell overboard.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Robittybob1 on March 19, 2019, 01:59:09 AM
"- We were told by Catriona that the only days they went to the beach were Tuesday afternoon (1 May 2007) between 15:30 and 16:30, on Wednesday (the next day) at the same time and on Thursday between 10 and 11 o'clock (see attached table [of creche activities])."   http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CATRIONA-TREASA-B.htm

It must have been Thursday morning by that.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Robittybob1 on March 19, 2019, 03:48:05 AM
What day and what time did the kids do their sailing activity?

Catriona Baker's rogatory statement has: "On Thursday the 3rd of May 2007, I remember Gerry having accompanied Madeleine to the club between 9h15 and 9h20 in the morning. I do not remember who came to pick her up for lunch but after she returned in the afternoon for a dive/swim. These activities were realized with the other children. On this day I remember that we sailed and I saw friends of the McCanns on the beach, David and Jane. Around 14h45 Madeleine returned to the Minis Club on top of the reception but I do not remember who accompanied her. This afternoon we went swimming."

That makes it sound as if it was an afternoon activity.  Where did the "dive/swim" take place?  Was that down at the beach?  http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CAT_BAKER.htm
There is an observation of David and Jane down at the beach - I presume at the time they did the sailing.  Maybe we can cross reference that.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Robittybob1 on March 19, 2019, 03:58:39 AM
"interviews with authors Anthony Summers and Robbyn Swan, whose book “Looking for Madeleine” became a bestseller.
First published in 2014, it gives a detailed account of the events leading up to the disappearance, as well as what played out afterwards.
It reads: “After lunch, over at the Mini Club, nanny Cat Baker decided to take her chance out on the water.

“With Baker heading their ‘snake’, the line of children trooped down the beach for an outing on a boat.”

The book revealed how Madeleine “was fearful” and cried on Ms Baker's lap.

She then told Ms Baker: “I’m scared.”

The nanny added: “She soon got over it though.”"

Maybe Catriona Baker had forgotten when the sailing took place!  Was it before or after lunch?
https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1100675/madeleine-mccann-disappearance-nanny-prai-da-luz-portugal-scared-spt
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: The General on March 22, 2019, 08:32:34 AM
I wonder if there was some minor obfuscation re: sailing due to the activity not being carried out in full compliance with health and safety arrangements  - so an attempt to not be seen to be negligent to some degree.

Totally unrelated, but I wouldn't trust my 3 year old to a couple of nannies and a sailing instructor to go out 'sailing'; shallow water, roped off, life jacket, fully competent or not.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: G-Unit on March 22, 2019, 09:34:56 AM
"- On the first two days the children played and did activities in the sand. On the Thursday they went sailing next to the beach.
- On that day they sailed in a small yellow "catamaran";
- Alice Standley accompanied the children on the route and on the boat. Three children sailed with her at one time;

- Chris Unswork transported the children in a red amphibious boat (life-saving boat) until the boat reached the open sea, and, a few minutes later, returned them to the beach to pick up three other children from the group;"

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CATRIONA-TREASA-B.htm

In both situations there was one supervisor looking after 3 kids.   So they would definitely be in trouble if a child fell overboard.

So six children went to the sailing.Three supervisers were involved. Catriona must have been on the beach with three children when Chris Unsworth took the other three in the red boat. I assume they were then put into the yellow boat with Alice Stanley. In Cat's rog all the boats were yellow and Madeleine cried when the safety boat was launched.

We only used the launches to transport the children to the small yellow boats. When we returned to the other boat she was happy again.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/CAT_BAKER.htm

What other boat? The sail boat? If Cat was in there with Madeleine who was caring for the three children left on the beach? Like everything in this case the details are sketchy.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Eleanor on March 22, 2019, 09:48:50 AM

I think the real point is that Madeleine was on the boat on that day, and not dead several days before, as according to Bennet's, sorry Havern's Forum.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Brietta on March 22, 2019, 09:53:55 AM
I think the real point is that Madeleine was on the boat on that day, and not dead several days before, as according to Bennet's, sorry Havern's Forum.

I was wondering why Madeleine's sail had any relevance to her disappearance ... I had forgotten about that particular conspiracy theory.

It's a fairly 'new' one is it not ... dreamt up only when all else had failed?
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: G-Unit on March 22, 2019, 10:05:07 AM
I think the real point is that Madeleine was on the boat on that day, and not dead several days before, as according to Bennet's, sorry Havern's Forum.

Madeleine sailed that day according to Cat Baker, an altered Creche timetable, Jane Tanner and Fiona Payne. Anyone else? Oh yes, Neil Berry but his words, like Jayne Jensen's, aren't evidemce apparently.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 22, 2019, 10:10:32 AM
Madeleine sailed that day according to Cat Baker, an altered Creche timetable, Jane Tanner and Fiona Payne. Anyone else? Oh yes, Neil Berry but his words, like Jayne Jensen's, aren't evidemce apparently.
Did any of the creche staff make statements to the effect that Madeleine was mysteriously absent in the days leading up to her disappearance? If not I wonder why not...?   *%6^
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Robittybob1 on March 22, 2019, 10:16:08 AM
Madeleine sailed that day according to Cat Baker, an altered Creche timetable, Jane Tanner and Fiona Payne. Anyone else? Oh yes, Neil Berry but his words, like Jayne Jensen's, aren't evidence apparently.
I think there are many statements taken by the British liaison officers, that they didn't want released when the PJ archived their case.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: G-Unit on March 22, 2019, 10:19:23 AM
Did any of the creche staff make statements to the effect that Madeleine was mysteriously absent in the days leading up to her disappearance? If not I wonder why not...?   *%6^

Cat's colleague didn't notice six of the kids plus Cat disappearing for an hour on Thursday morning.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Robittybob1 on March 22, 2019, 10:21:49 AM
Cat's colleague didn't notice six of the kids plus Cat disappearing for an hour on Thursday morning.
I'm thinking it was actually held in the afternoon.  Catriona sees some of the Tapas 7 on the beach and I know they were there in the afternoon.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 22, 2019, 10:22:02 AM
Cat's colleague didn't notice six of the kids plus Cat disappearing for an hour on Thursday morning.
Does that address my point?  If so, how?
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Brietta on March 22, 2019, 10:23:58 AM
Madeleine sailed that day according to Cat Baker, an altered Creche timetable, Jane Tanner and Fiona Payne. Anyone else? Oh yes, Neil Berry but his words, like Jayne Jensen's, aren't evidemce apparently.
(http://static.independent.co.uk/s3fs-public/thumbnails/image/2019/03/15/12/2-madeleine-mccann.jpg)
How do you rate Neil Berry's photograph which he took of his daughter and he says Madeleine then? if you have decided his statement isn't evidence.
If the little girl is indeed Madeleine ... I think it blows at least one conspiracy theory ... out of the water.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: The General on March 22, 2019, 10:37:35 AM
(http://static.independent.co.uk/s3fs-public/thumbnails/image/2019/03/15/12/2-madeleine-mccann.jpg)
How do you rate Neil Berry's photograph which he took of his daughter and he says Madeleine then? if you have decided his statement isn't evidence.
If the little girl is indeed Madeleine ... I think it blows at least one conspiracy theory ... out of the water.
All that photo does is add to the intrigue, as it's blurry and the subject matter has their back to the camera. Typical of this whole case in fact.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: G-Unit on March 22, 2019, 11:04:34 AM
(http://static.independent.co.uk/s3fs-public/thumbnails/image/2019/03/15/12/2-madeleine-mccann.jpg)
How do you rate Neil Berry's photograph which he took of his daughter and he says Madeleine then? if you have decided his statement isn't evidence.
If the little girl is indeed Madeleine ... I think it blows at least one conspiracy theory ... out of the water.

It isn't me who said his statement isn't evidence, it's those who refused to beleive Madeleine launched herself into the sea.

In my opinion that photo was taken on Sunday morning judging by the anoubt of children and the actibity. At 10 am on Sunday it was Parachite Grass Time. The adult doesn't seem to be Cat and Berry's daughter seems very tall in comparison to that adult. 
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Brietta on March 22, 2019, 03:33:47 PM
All that photo does is add to the intrigue, as it's blurry and the subject matter has their back to the camera. Typical of this whole case in fact.
Actually no.  The subject of the photograph is the little girl facing the camera.  Netflix has merely introduced us to a photograph taken on someone's holiday in Luz which we haven't seen before.  There may be many more of such unseen by us ... but seen by the police in response to the appeal sent out for holiday photographs with unknown individuals in the background.
I think there is an assumption that people like us 'know it all' when in fact people like us know very little and what we do 'know' is quite often entirely wide of the mark.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Brietta on March 22, 2019, 03:38:05 PM
It isn't me who said his statement isn't evidence, it's those who refused to beleive Madeleine launched herself into the sea.

In my opinion that photo was taken on Sunday morning judging by the anoubt of children and the actibity. At 10 am on Sunday it was Parachite Grass Time. The adult doesn't seem to be Cat and Berry's daughter seems very tall in comparison to that adult.
You keep on reiterating it.
Repetition is how factoids become established.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: G-Unit on March 22, 2019, 03:58:39 PM
You keep on reiterating it.
Repetition is how factoids become established.

If there's something you disagree with feel free to say so. Until then I don't know what 'it' is.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 22, 2019, 05:47:59 PM
Asking this again - Did any of the creche staff make statements to the effect that Madeleine was mysteriously absent in the days leading up to her disappearance? If not I wonder why not...?   *%6^
. 
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: G-Unit on March 22, 2019, 07:30:18 PM
Asking this again - Did any of the creche staff make statements to the effect that Madeleine was mysteriously absent in the days leading up to her disappearance? If not I wonder why not...?   *%6^
.

What's that got to do wth sailing?
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 22, 2019, 07:48:58 PM
What's that got to do wth sailing?
I would have thought that was fairly obvious.  If any of the kids club staff claimed Madeleine was not in attendance Monday - Thursday  then that would be evidence that would support the “dead before the 3rd” theory, which you seem to think is a credible theory.  Did sny of them make that claim, if not why not?
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: G-Unit on March 22, 2019, 08:03:05 PM
I would have thought that was fairly obvious.  If any of the kids club staff claimed Madeleine was not in attendance Monday - Thursday  then that would be evidence that would support the “dead before the 3rd” theory, which you seem to think is a credible theory.  Did sny of them make that claim, if not why not?

I do not subscribe to that theory or any other. 
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 22, 2019, 08:09:55 PM
I do not subscribe to that theory or any other.
But you refuse to rule it out, right?
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: G-Unit on March 22, 2019, 08:59:41 PM
But you refuse to rule it out, right?

I have decided to rule out responding to your interrogations.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: John on March 22, 2019, 09:05:14 PM
A reminder to all posters to keep responses constructive and above all, amicable. TY
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 22, 2019, 09:09:20 PM
I have decided to rule out responding to your interrogations.
I understand.   8(>((
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 22, 2019, 09:12:17 PM
Who feels confident in ruling out the “dead beofore 3rd May” theory?  I do, anyone else?  Or should it remain a distinct possibility?
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Eleanor on March 22, 2019, 09:24:04 PM
Who feels confident in ruling out the “dead beofore 3rd May” theory?  I do, anyone else?  Or should it remain a distinct possibility?

Absolute nonsense.  Of course Madeleine wasn't dead before May the 3rd, or even if she is dead at all.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 22, 2019, 09:37:32 PM
Absolute nonsense.  Of course Madeleine wasn't dead before May the 3rd, or even if she is dead at all.
The thing is, despite all the evidence to the contrary, some apparently intelligent people refuse to rule it out, bizarre though it may seem.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Eleanor on March 22, 2019, 09:45:58 PM
The thing is, despite all the evidence to the contrary, some apparently intelligent people refuse to rule it out, bizarre though it may seem.

I don't understand that at all, so I try not to worry about it.
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Lace on March 23, 2019, 06:27:34 PM
The thing is, despite all the evidence to the contrary, some apparently intelligent people refuse to rule it out, bizarre though it may seem.


Very bizarre indeed.

The McCann's were behaving absolutely normally up until Kate made her alert.    Now how on earth can two people change from normal to absolute uncontrollable  grief in about half an hour?    Surely no time to find a body and dispose of it.   IMO
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: faithlilly on March 23, 2019, 06:39:04 PM

Very bizarre indeed.

The McCann's were behaving absolutely normally up until Kate made her alert.    Now how on earth can two people change from normal to absolute uncontrollable  grief in about half an hour?    Surely no time to find a body and dispose of it.   IMO

The parents displayed an unemotional facade in the days after the abduction. Why do you assume they couldn’t employ the same facade before the alert ?

How can we believe that the parents could so pragmatic that they could hold their emotions in check so they did not give the abductor some kind of kick but not when their very freedom depended on it ?
Title: Re: Did the kids really do sailing on Thursday?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 23, 2019, 06:44:35 PM
The parents displayed an unemotional facade in the days after the abduction. Why do you assume they couldn’t employ the same facade before the alert ?
Oh right so everyone who saw and heard them screaming and crying and in a state of virtual collapse after the alert made it up did they?