UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: John on May 09, 2018, 12:34:34 PM

Title: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: John on May 09, 2018, 12:34:34 PM
Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?

Is this a coincidence too far or is someone taking the Mick?

24
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on May 09, 2018, 12:41:47 PM
Not only that, but he is a DOCTOR, lives in SALISBURY, which is close to PORTON DOWN, and the location of the NOVICHOK poisonings of the SKRIPALS. 

Something about this really stinks.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: jassi on May 09, 2018, 12:51:51 PM
Not only that, but he is a DOCTOR, lives in SALISBURY, which is close to PORTON DOWN, and the location of the NOVICHOK poisonings of the SKRIPALS. 

Something about this really stinks.

We only need to place Skripal senior in PDL that night and we've cracked it.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on May 09, 2018, 01:05:59 PM
Man carrying a tot, couldn't really be more apt could it? 
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Carana on May 09, 2018, 01:08:56 PM
Not only that, but he is a DOCTOR, lives in SALISBURY, which is close to PORTON DOWN, and the location of the NOVICHOK poisonings of the SKRIPALS. 

Something about this really stinks.

LOLL
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Carana on May 09, 2018, 01:17:45 PM
Seriously, as the only source as to the identity of this person appears to be the Sun, forgive me for wondering if this chap is indeed Tannerman.

It might be, or it could also be a hack who'd somehow got hold of info from not-tannerman /crèchedad who also happened to be walking in the area at the time with a little girl in his arms and put 2+2 together and came up with 7.

It might have been clearer if the PJ had got hold of the night crèche records for that night, at least it would have narrowed down who could have been wandering around at that time. Or, perhaps they did, but has anyone found the evening crèche records in the files?

Nanny baby-sitting arrangements might have also narrowed things down a bit as well. I haven't seen any records of those, either.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: misty on May 09, 2018, 01:24:17 PM
Seriously, as the only source as to the identity of this person appears to be the Sun, forgive me for wondering if this chap is indeed Tannerman.

It might be, or it could also be a hack who'd somehow got hold of info from not-tannerman /crèchedad who also happened to be walking in the area at the time with a little girl in his arms and put 2+2 together and came up with 7.

It might have been clearer if the PJ had got hold of the night crèche records for that night, at least it would have narrowed down who could have been wandering around at that time. Or, perhaps they did, but has anyone found the evening crèche records in the files?

Nanny baby-sitting arrangements might have also narrowed things down a bit as well. I haven't seen any records of those, either.

I believe there were very few 2 year old girls on the M/W guest who fitted the profile, A quick check of Facebook profiles with photos & the image from Salisbury Medical practice certainly showed me, a few years ago, that Totman was almost certainly Crecheman.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: John on May 09, 2018, 01:45:01 PM
It must be a weird coincidence unless someone doctored the tapas restaurant diners list?

So there you have it, the mysterious stranger sat down near to the tapas 9 and Tanner never recognised him.

(http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-uLXYmatNRGg/TYu6YM6SDRI/AAAAAAAAB6s/mBSwvM9DKro/s1600/01%2BTapas%2Btuesday.JPG)
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: jassi on May 09, 2018, 01:52:05 PM
Seriously, as the only source as to the identity of this person appears to be the Sun, forgive me for wondering if this chap is indeed Tannerman.

It might be, or it could also be a hack who'd somehow got hold of info from not-tannerman /crèchedad who also happened to be walking in the area at the time with a little girl in his arms and put 2+2 together and came up with 7.

It might have been clearer if the PJ had got hold of the night crèche records for that night, at least it would have narrowed down who could have been wandering around at that time. Or, perhaps they did, but has anyone found the evening crèche records in the files?

Nanny baby-sitting arrangements might have also narrowed things down a bit as well. I haven't seen any records of those, either.

Perhaps it's going to be like a remake of Sparticus.

I am Tannerman. No I am Tannerman    @)(++(*
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on May 09, 2018, 02:03:09 PM
It must be a weird coincidence unless someone doctored the tapas restaurant diners list?

So there you have it, the mysterious stranger sat down near to the tapas 9 and Tanner never recognised him.

(http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-uLXYmatNRGg/TYu6YM6SDRI/AAAAAAAAB6s/mBSwvM9DKro/s1600/01%2BTapas%2Btuesday.JPG)
An hour and a half earlier.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Angelo222 on May 09, 2018, 02:22:00 PM
An hour and a half earlier.

Despite the times I find it very hard to believe that they were not known to each other especially as they were doctors.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on May 09, 2018, 02:40:03 PM
Despite the times I find it very hard to believe that they were not known to each other especially as they were doctors.
Doctors don’t all know each other by dint of their profession as far as I’,m aware. Would you expect two teachers from different locales on holiday in the same resort to know each other?
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: jassi on May 09, 2018, 02:52:24 PM
Totman was on the tennis circuit so would be known to the Tapas group
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on May 09, 2018, 02:59:17 PM
Totman was on the tennis circuit so would be known to the Tapas group
So it’s a fact that Jane Tanner knew the identity of the man she saw now is it?
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: jassi on May 09, 2018, 03:12:42 PM
So it’s a fact that Jane Tanner knew the identity of the man she saw now is it?

Not what my posts says, that's just your twist.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on May 09, 2018, 03:18:21 PM
Not what my posts says, that's just your twist.
Jane Tanner saw a man who turns out to be Totman.  Totman was on the tennis circuit and so would be known by the Tapas group (according to you).  So if you’re not saying it’s a fact JT knew the id of the man she saw, what are you saying?
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: faithlilly on May 09, 2018, 03:18:53 PM
So it’s a fact that Jane Tanner knew the identity of the man she saw now is it?

If this Julian is the same Julian then Tanner would have seen him when she was watching while the men played tennis on the evening of 3rd of May.

From Gerry’.
‘
------ That they bathed the children, the deponent having left at 18H00 for a tennis game only for men, at which were: DAN, tennis instructor; JULIAN, with whom he had played tennis several times; and CURTIS, with whom he had also played.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: jassi on May 09, 2018, 03:19:51 PM
Jane Tanner saw a man who turns out to be Totman.  Totman was on the tennis circuit and so would be known by the Tapas group (according to you).  So if you’re not saying it’s a fact JT knew the id of the man she saw, what are you saying?

I'm saying he would be known to the group.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on May 09, 2018, 03:26:56 PM
I'm saying he would be known to the group.
Jane Tanner included, as she is a member of the group?
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: faithlilly on May 09, 2018, 03:31:33 PM
Jane Tanner included, as she is a member of the group?

If she had seen him at the tennis courts on the 3rd she’d certainly know him by sight.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Eleanor on May 09, 2018, 03:34:30 PM
This is getting ridiculous.  I don't know whether to laugh or cry.  He knew The McCanns?  They knew him?  Did he know Madeleine, does anyone think?
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: faithlilly on May 09, 2018, 03:35:42 PM
This is getting ridiculous.  I don't know whether to laugh or cry.  He knew The McCanns?  They knew him?  Did he know Madeleine, does anyone think?

If he is Julian the tennis player then he certainly knew Gerry. Gerry said as much.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Eleanor on May 09, 2018, 03:44:39 PM
If he is Julian the tennis player then he certainly knew Gerry. Gerry said as much.

Could you supply a Cite for what Gerry said?  Thanks in advance.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Brietta on May 09, 2018, 03:47:21 PM
If Jane Tanner knew Dr Totman she would have recognised him had she seen him passing relatively closely in front of her.

The fact that she did not, suggests to me that the man she did see was Tannerman whoever he may be, and not Dr Totman.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: John on May 09, 2018, 03:52:58 PM
If Jane Tanner knew Dr Totman she would have recognised him had she seen him passing relatively closely in front of her.

The fact that she did not, suggests to me that the man she did see was Tannerman whoever he may be, and not Dr Totman.

I have great sympathy with that suggestion Brietta and especially since he was going the wrong way.  The mystery deepens!
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Eleanor on May 09, 2018, 04:09:29 PM

It is quite obvious to me, IMO, that Totman and Tannerman are not the same person. IMO.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: John on May 09, 2018, 05:15:00 PM
It is quite obvious to me, IMO, that Totman and Tannerman are not the same person. IMO.

How anyone could lift a child out of an apartment and get clean away with so many tourists and locals wandering about is definitely a bit of a mystery.  The other element to this is why even risk it?
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: pathfinder73 on May 09, 2018, 05:31:47 PM
It is quite obvious to me, IMO, that Totman and Tannerman are not the same person. IMO.

What is obvious is that Totman/Crecheman clothes and child matched Jane's description so you come to the unbelievable conclusion that there was another man/child matching Jane's description at the same time?
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Brietta on May 09, 2018, 05:36:33 PM
How anyone could lift a child out of an apartment and get clean away with so many tourists and locals wandering about is definitely a bit of a mystery.  The other element to this is why even risk it?

Unless corroborated by other witness statements we know nothing about ... no-one saw Jes Wilkins and son on his perambulations around Luz.  No-one saw Mr and Mrs Moyes returning from the restaurant where they dined, crossing the car park and entering the building.  No-one mentions the woman Mrs Murat saw, indeed no-one mentions Mrs Murat.

Either people in Luz were singularly unobservant or it was really quiet with not too many people out and about at that time.  Madeleine was very tired that night ... maybe other holidaymakers' children were too and most were indoors and dining at home given that we are told it was quite a chilly night.

Why would anyone risk kidnapping a child under any circumstances anyway?  If Tannerman actually was the man who did, the risk paid off for him as when seen Jane assumed he was innocently carrying his own child home and the alarm wasn't raised till some time later.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Brietta on May 09, 2018, 05:48:45 PM
What is obvious is that Totman/Crecheman clothes and child matched Jane's description so you come to the unbelievable conclusion that there was another man/child matching Jane's description at the same time?
(http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P15/15_VOLUME-XVa_Page_3978.jpg)
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9475.msg460800#msg460800

The man seen by Gail Cooper may match ... but definitely on the 3rd of May two other men each carrying a child were observed.  Firstly by Mr McCluskey ... 'McCluskeyman'? and by Mr Smith ... Smithman.

By my count that makes four.  Who knows how many more called in following OG appeals.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: faithlilly on May 09, 2018, 06:02:07 PM
Could you supply a Cite for what Gerry said?  Thanks in advance.

I already have just a few posts ago but here it is again.

From Gerry’.
‘
------ That they bathed the children, the deponent having left at 18H00 for a tennis game only for men, at which were: DAN, tennis instructor; JULIAN, with whom he had played tennis several times; and CURTIS, with whom he had also played.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: faithlilly on May 09, 2018, 06:03:55 PM
(http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/P15/15_VOLUME-XVa_Page_3978.jpg)
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9475.msg460800#msg460800

The man seen by Gail Cooper may match ... but definitely on the 3rd of May two other men each carrying a child were observed.  Firstly by Mr McCluskey ... 'McCluskeyman'? and by Mr Smith ... Smithman.

By my count that makes four.  Who knows how many more called in following OG appeals.

There was absolutely nothing to link the man Gail Cooper saw and Madeleine’s disappearance, not one scintilla of evidence.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Eleanor on May 09, 2018, 06:05:54 PM
I already have just a few posts ago but here it is again.

From Gerry’.
‘
------ That they bathed the children, the deponent having left at 18H00 for a tennis game only for men, at which were: DAN, tennis instructor; JULIAN, with whom he had played tennis several times; and CURTIS, with whom he had also played.

Thank you.  But is there more than one Julian, I have to ask myself.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: faithlilly on May 09, 2018, 06:08:31 PM
Thank you.  But is there more than one Julian, I have to ask myself.

Of course that’s a possibility. Another one of those McCannland coincidences?
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: G-Unit on May 09, 2018, 06:42:24 PM
Thank you.  But is there more than one Julian, I have to ask myself.

I expect the guest sheets in the PJ files would show whether there was another guest whose name began with J.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Eleanor on May 09, 2018, 06:56:47 PM
I expect the guest sheets in the PJ files would show whether there was another guest whose name began with J.

If The PJ didn't find the original Julian they might have had some difficulty finding another.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on May 09, 2018, 07:04:25 PM
Thank you.  But is there more than one Julian, I have to ask myself.

Brian Jones had two sons named Julian.
Both named for Julian "Cannonball" Adderley.
Now work that into the conversation at a dinner party  8(0(*
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Eleanor on May 09, 2018, 07:06:34 PM
Brian Jones had two sons named Julian.
Both named for Julian "Cannonball" Adderley.
Now work that into the conversation at a dinner party  8(0(*

I've got one.  How's about that then.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Alice Purjorick on May 09, 2018, 07:18:39 PM
I've got one.  How's about that then.

Tops me! the best I can do is a nephew of same name.
One more and we have a five a side footy team.
I wonder if the Julian is prepared to come out of retirement and become an international crime fighter again like when he was 13 on Kirrin Island and all that....................OK zipping it now boss  ?{)(**
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Eleanor on May 09, 2018, 07:27:56 PM
Tops me! the best I can do is a nephew of same name.
One more and we have a five a side footy team.
I wonder if the Julian is prepared to come out of retirement and become an international crime fighter again like when he was 13 on Kirrin Island and all that....................OK zipping it now boss  ?{)(**

My Julian only plays Rugby.  Public School you know.  He wouldn't be seen dead with a football.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Robittybob1 on May 09, 2018, 07:33:17 PM
I prefer Julia.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: kizzy on May 10, 2018, 08:30:02 AM
I prefer Julia.

Julia, for a rugby player.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: G-Unit on May 10, 2018, 08:35:49 AM
If The PJ didn't find the original Julian they might have had some difficulty finding another.

Afaik the PJ weren't looking for a Julian. I thought you might fancy a little light research actually. 
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Robittybob1 on May 10, 2018, 09:00:38 AM
Afaik the PJ weren't looking for a Julian. I thought you might fancy a little light research actually.
Where would you start?
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: G-Unit on May 10, 2018, 09:10:01 AM
Where would you start?

Here; scroll down and there's all the guest names.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/TAPAS_BOOKING.htm
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Eleanor on May 10, 2018, 09:15:07 AM
Here; scroll down and there's all the guest names.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/TAPAS_BOOKING.htm

Why didn't The PJ do this?  I thought it was their day job, not mine.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on May 10, 2018, 03:07:16 PM
Here; scroll down and there's all the guest names.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/TAPAS_BOOKING.htm


Well done G!...

We wonder who would make it up and why...@ Johns Question
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: G-Unit on May 10, 2018, 05:23:36 PM
Why didn't The PJ do this?  I thought it was their day job, not mine.

I thought it was you who wondered if there were two Julians, not them?
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Eleanor on May 10, 2018, 05:38:33 PM
I thought it was you who wondered if there were two Julians, not them?

You pointed out JULIAN.  But you didn't say which one.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Carana on May 10, 2018, 05:49:51 PM
Why didn't The PJ do this?  I thought it was their day job, not mine.

I've asked this before: did the PJ ever check the evening crèche / night nanny records to see who could have been wandering around with a child in their arms that night?
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: misty on May 10, 2018, 07:55:13 PM
I've asked this before: did the PJ ever check the evening crèche / night nanny records to see who could have been wandering around with a child in their arms that night?

The records aren't in the files -  so that's a yes from me.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Robittybob1 on May 10, 2018, 09:49:59 PM
I've asked this before: did the PJ ever check the evening crèche / night nanny records to see who could have been wandering around with a child in their arms that night?
Somehow they knew the number of kids at the night creche, so I assume someone did have the records.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: G-Unit on May 11, 2018, 07:08:19 AM
Somehow they knew the number of kids at the night creche, so I assume someone did have the records.

I would be very surprised if the night creche records were kept for four years until OG came along. I think it's more likely that they examined the questionnaires received by LP and found the information there.

It seems that it wasn't just the PJ who never thought of the possibility that Jane had seen a holidaymaker, the UK policemen helping them didn't appear to think of of it either. 
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Brietta on May 11, 2018, 12:23:29 PM
I would be very surprised if the night creche records were kept for four years until OG came along. I think it's more likely that they examined the questionnaires received by LP and found the information there.

It seems that it wasn't just the PJ who never thought of the possibility that Jane had seen a holidaymaker, the UK policemen helping them didn't appear to think of of it either.

It was a Portuguese investigation in which the Portuguese investigators had their feathers ruffled by their British counterparts 'trying to help'.

I don't really see how the Brits could be expected to 'interfere' in that in an atmosphere of such distrust and paranoia that the instruction was given to 'shadow' a senior British officer!

Under normal circumstances I would have disagreed that vital paperwork had been destroyed ... but if possible forensic opportunities could be sent to the laundry and others not bagged ... you may very well be correct.

I wonder how it would have gone down if the Brits had insisted on following up the action on Tannerman and Dr Totman ... not well I'm thinking.


Snip
:: The intervention of multiple UK police forces and agencies created "frustration" and "resentment" among Portuguese police.

:: The decision by the Association of Chief Police Officers to put Leicestershire Police in charge of the operation was a mistake because the force was ill-equipped to deal with such a big investigation.

:: Challenges to the Portuguese police's approach to the investigation led to warnings that Britain should not try to act as a "colonial power".

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"It was unhelpful…I've no doubt relationships from the outset with the Portuguese were impacted by it and I think that had a long-term negative effect on the investigation."

Mr Gamble - who refuses to release the detail of his findings - said the initial Portuguese police response to Madeleine's disappearance was "haphazard" and that potentially crucial information had not been followed up.

https://news.sky.com/story/madeleine-secret-report-on-police-probe-10391226



Snip
He says the British police, the Diplomatic Service, the MI5 and even the NHS were blocking his path to the 'material truth'.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
We needed quick answers to the questions' - particularly from the English police whose tardiness he was already critcising.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Amaral was suspicious of the motives of the British police officers who arrived in Luz on

May 7. He ordered a 'shadow' on the senior British officer in Luz. 'I want to know what they are doing,' he told his subordinate. 'You will escort them day and night.'
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
As the British police urged caution, Amaral became ever more convinced of his theories. He rationalised that the UK police were reluctant to get drawn into a prosecution on foreign soil.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
The point is that the British force was still pursuing the possibility of a kidnap.

Tension between the two police forces had been growing for some time and in that month when the McCanns were declared suspects, it erupted.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
https://www.standard.co.uk/news/a-copper-without-shame-maddies-top-detective-blames-everyone-but-himself-6836324.html


Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: G-Unit on May 11, 2018, 06:42:23 PM
It was a Portuguese investigation in which the Portuguese investigators had their feathers ruffled by their British counterparts 'trying to help'.

I don't really see how the Brits could be expected to 'interfere' in that in an atmosphere of such distrust and paranoia that the instruction was given to 'shadow' a senior British officer!

Under normal circumstances I would have disagreed that vital paperwork had been destroyed ... but if possible forensic opportunities could be sent to the laundry and others not bagged ... you may very well be correct.

I wonder how it would have gone down if the Brits had insisted on following up the action on Tannerman and Dr Totman ... not well I'm thinking.


Snip
:: The intervention of multiple UK police forces and agencies created "frustration" and "resentment" among Portuguese police.

:: The decision by the Association of Chief Police Officers to put Leicestershire Police in charge of the operation was a mistake because the force was ill-equipped to deal with such a big investigation.

:: Challenges to the Portuguese police's approach to the investigation led to warnings that Britain should not try to act as a "colonial power".

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"It was unhelpful…I've no doubt relationships from the outset with the Portuguese were impacted by it and I think that had a long-term negative effect on the investigation."

Mr Gamble - who refuses to release the detail of his findings - said the initial Portuguese police response to Madeleine's disappearance was "haphazard" and that potentially crucial information had not been followed up.

https://news.sky.com/story/madeleine-secret-report-on-police-probe-10391226



Snip
He says the British police, the Diplomatic Service, the MI5 and even the NHS were blocking his path to the 'material truth'.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
We needed quick answers to the questions' - particularly from the English police whose tardiness he was already critcising.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Amaral was suspicious of the motives of the British police officers who arrived in Luz on

May 7. He ordered a 'shadow' on the senior British officer in Luz. 'I want to know what they are doing,' he told his subordinate. 'You will escort them day and night.'
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
As the British police urged caution, Amaral became ever more convinced of his theories. He rationalised that the UK police were reluctant to get drawn into a prosecution on foreign soil.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
The point is that the British force was still pursuing the possibility of a kidnap.

Tension between the two police forces had been growing for some time and in that month when the McCanns were declared suspects, it erupted.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
https://www.standard.co.uk/news/a-copper-without-shame-maddies-top-detective-blames-everyone-but-himself-6836324.html

Yes, unfortunately the Brits managed to give the impression that they were interfering rather than helping.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: kmc on April 01, 2019, 01:32:15 AM
I know this is an old subject - so currently off topic....but I googled Julian Totman and saw an image of him in the Salisbury Journal.  It struck me that he looks about the same height as my husband, who is 6.3ft (192cm).   I would think that of everything Jane Tanner noticed the difference between the stature of a man of (170cm) 5.7ft  and someone over 6ft should have been pretty major - a 5.6ft to 5.7ft man is pretty small.  Anyhow, not sure if it is overthinking things. but I still have a gut feeling that Tannerman was the actual abductor.  There was, to me, something fishy about Redwood's excitement at removing "Tannerman" - always felt off.  Anyhow, I don't know how you could work out if I am right about Totman's height but I see most chair "seats" are 45cm off the ground....so if someone can work it out - perhaps they could re-evaluate if the police "Totman" photo is the same man - to me the guy in the set up photo feels smaller than the real Dr Julian Totman.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Robittybob1 on April 01, 2019, 04:11:20 AM
Totman has continued to being quite open about things so I'd rule him out as an abductor.  As you say he is too tall compared to Jane's sighting.  So NOT likely to be Totman.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: kmc on April 01, 2019, 12:10:53 PM
I am certainly not suggesting Totman/Crecheman was the abductor.   Never thought he was - but "Tannerman" may well still be.   All I am pointing out is that both the Tanner and Smith Family sitings recorded a height of 170cm AND 170-175cm - which is between 5.7 and 5.8ish, i.e. a pretty short man. Yet, if you take a look at the image of Totman with colleagues - he is pretty much head and shoulders above anyone in the room.  In fact, his height is is most striking characteristic about him.  As a result, I think it was odd for Redwood to be so confident that he was the man Tanner saw.....and more peculiar if SY used a shorter man to mock up the "image" of Totman.  Perhaps that was why there was such a song and dance about the child's clothing.  (Which also seemed odd as I don't know a lot of families who would hang onto pretty cheap/worn looking PJs from May 2007 until Oct 2015.  I get holding on to good quality pieces for the possibility of another child... but those PJs don't look like clothing most mothers would hang onto for that length of time).  The whole thing just seems pretty weird - particularly because if you remove Tannerman completely, then police basically have absolutely nothing to work with - which is why they are probably having such a tough time right now.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: misty on April 01, 2019, 12:24:35 PM
I am certainly not suggesting Totman/Crecheman was the abductor.   Never thought he was - but "Tannerman" may well still be.   All I am pointing out is that both the Tanner and Smith Family sitings recorded a height of 170cm AND 170-175cm - which is between 5.7 and 5.8ish, i.e. a pretty short man. Yet, if you take a look at the image of Totman with colleagues - he is pretty much head and shoulders above anyone in the room.  In fact, his height is is most striking characteristic about him.  As a result, I think it was odd for Redwood to be so confident that he was the man Tanner saw.....and more peculiar if SY used a shorter man to mock up the "image" of Totman.  Perhaps that was why there was such a song and dance about the child's clothing.  (Which also seemed odd as I don't know a lot of families who would hang onto pretty cheap/worn looking PJs from May 2007 until Oct 2015.  I get holding on to good quality pieces for the possibility of another child... but those PJs don't look like clothing most mothers would hang onto for that length of time).  The whole thing just seems pretty weird - particularly because if you remove Tannerman completely, then police basically have absolutely nothing to work with - which is why they are probably having such a tough time right now.

The definition of abduction/kidnapping is the taking or carrying away of one person by another, by force or fraud, without the consent of the person so taken or carried away, and without lawful excuse. If the abductor passed the child to another person, that person is an accomplice. IMO DCI Redwood was being absolutely truthful when he said that Tannerman was not the abductor - imo Tannerman was the accomplice. Having determined that this was the time & circumstances of the abduction, the clock could then be moved on to try to determine what happened next.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: G-Unit on April 01, 2019, 12:51:33 PM
The definition of abduction/kidnapping is the taking or carrying away of one person by another, by force or fraud, without the consent of the person so taken or carried away, and without lawful excuse. If the abductor passed the child to another person, that person is an accomplice. IMO DCI Redwood was being absolutely truthful when he said that Tannerman was not the abductor - imo Tannerman was the accomplice. Having determined that this was the time & circumstances of the abduction, the clock could then be moved on to try to determine what happened next.

Are you saying that Totman was the accomplice or that there were two men around wearing similar clothes and carrying similarly dressed children across their outstretched arms?
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: misty on April 01, 2019, 01:03:06 PM
Are you saying that Totman was the accomplice or that there were two men around wearing similar clothes and carrying similarly dressed children across their outstretched arms?

No. I believe that Dr Totman was walking back to Block 4 carrying his daughter. DCI Redwood only said their clothing which Dr Totman may have been wearing was uncannily similar to the description of Tannerman; he made no reference to the carrying method. I speculate that Dr Totman saw another individual near or in Block 5 car-park who wasn't carrying a child at the time.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Brietta on April 01, 2019, 01:24:57 PM
The definition of abduction/kidnapping is the taking or carrying away of one person by another, by force or fraud, without the consent of the person so taken or carried away, and without lawful excuse. If the abductor passed the child to another person, that person is an accomplice. IMO DCI Redwood was being absolutely truthful when he said that Tannerman was not the abductor - imo Tannerman was the accomplice. Having determined that this was the time & circumstances of the abduction, the clock could then be moved on to try to determine what happened next.
I think the man seen by Jane Tanner was the key and I think the rubbishing of Madeleine's parents and their friends as leaked to the Portuguese press, should have taken a back seat to the task of attempting to find him for elimination purposes.

The fact that it was not known as a result of police enquiry at the time, that Dr Totman was carrying his daughter from the creche to Block 4 appears slip shod to me.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: G-Unit on April 01, 2019, 03:10:31 PM
No. I believe that Dr Totman was walking back to Block 4 carrying his daughter. DCI Redwood only said their clothing which Dr Totman may have been wearing was uncannily similar to the description of Tannerman; he made no reference to the carrying method. I speculate that Dr Totman saw another individual near or in Block 5 car-park who wasn't carrying a child at the time.

If Totman was walking towards block 4 he wasn't the man described by Jane Tanner. If he wasn't the man described by Jane Tanner his and his child's clothes were irrelevant.There was also no need to photograph him with his armsin that 'carrying a child across them' position.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Brietta on April 01, 2019, 03:40:36 PM
If Totman was walking towards block 4 he wasn't the man described by Jane Tanner. If he wasn't the man described by Jane Tanner his and his child's clothes were irrelevant.There was also no need to photograph him with his armsin that 'carrying a child across them' position.
Precisely along the lines of the point I was making in my post, don't you know.

But taking it just one step further is that Dr Totman walked a considerable distance carrying his sleeping child and not a single person saw him do it.
Neither did the police trace him at the time to find out that he or anyone else was going about their lawful business at around the same time a witness had reported to them that she had seen a man perhaps going unlawfully about his.

What were the chances of the police apprehending an abductor if they were incapable of locating a man with nothing to hide and who had reported that he might have been the sighting ... something I doubt an abductor would do.


Snip
In October 2007 the McCanns put out a sketch of the Tannerman but Mr Totman had already told the Guarda Nacional Republicana in May that it was probably him but they kept looking for the suspect.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5698933/Madeleine-McCann-police-spent-four-years-trying-ID-man-GP-said-him.html


The questions also arise as to why it had to wait until October for an efit to be issued ... and why it was left to the parents of the missing child to take the initiative and not the police??
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: Brietta on April 01, 2019, 03:54:25 PM
No. I believe that Dr Totman was walking back to Block 4 carrying his daughter. DCI Redwood only said their clothing which Dr Totman may have been wearing was uncannily similar to the description of Tannerman; he made no reference to the carrying method. I speculate that Dr Totman saw another individual near or in Block 5 car-park who wasn't carrying a child at the time.

I think your post neatly explains the puzzlement that Dr Totman was walking in the wrong direction to be the man seen by Jane Tanner.
His importance to the investigation was not so much what he was doing but what he saw.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: barrier on April 01, 2019, 04:04:33 PM
I think your post neatly explains the puzzlement that Dr Totman was walking in the wrong direction to be the man seen by Jane Tanner.
His importance to the investigation was not so much what he was doing but what he saw.


Nothing,confirmed when Redwood moved the time on.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: kmc on April 01, 2019, 04:07:17 PM
Trying to post the image of Totman to show his height....but not sure it will work.  I guess my main point is that if I was sitting on a jury in any trial and was asked to convict someone based on an e-fit/description....forget that he was probably walking in another direction - such a height discrepancy would present a major issue for me - so I don't understand why it wasn't for Redwood.
Title: Re: Tannerman, Crècheman, Innocentman and now TOTman. Could you make it up?
Post by: G-Unit on April 01, 2019, 06:51:59 PM
Precisely along the lines of the point I was making in my post, don't you know.

But taking it just one step further is that Dr Totman walked a considerable distance carrying his sleeping child and not a single person saw him do it.
Neither did the police trace him at the time to find out that he or anyone else was going about their lawful business at around the same time a witness had reported to them that she had seen a man perhaps going unlawfully about his.

What were the chances of the police apprehending an abductor if they were incapable of locating a man with nothing to hide and who had reported that he might have been the sighting ... something I doubt an abductor would do.


Snip
In October 2007 the McCanns put out a sketch of the Tannerman but Mr Totman had already told the Guarda Nacional Republicana in May that it was probably him but they kept looking for the suspect.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5698933/Madeleine-McCann-police-spent-four-years-trying-ID-man-GP-said-him.html


The questions also arise as to why it had to wait until October for an efit to be issued ... and why it was left to the parents of the missing child to take the initiative and not the police??

So you think that Redwood didn't rule Tannerman out? Why all the effort expended to convince viewers of Crimewatch that he'd found the man seen by Jane Tanner?

Quite a few people have claimed to have spoken to the Portuguese police, but there's no evidence that they did, nor is there any evidence that the questionnaires collected by LP were sent to Portugal. If they had been there would have been no need for their officers to consult them in order to inform members of the PJ what they said.