Nanny Ms Penningtons comments re "They've taken her"

[DeNada]

When Kate apparently ran back to the tapas shouting 'They've taken her' did everyone there know she was talking about Maddie?

To my knowledge there were two female children in the apartment - why did no-one ask who or which one?

[debunker]

When Kate apparently ran back to the tapas shouting 'They've taken her' did everyone there know she was talking about Maddie?

To my knowledge there were two female children in the apartment - why did no-one ask who or which one?
[/quote

Cite please for everyone knowing before being told.

[Eleanor]

When Kate apparently ran back to the tapas shouting 'They've taken her' did everyone there know she was talking about Maddie?

To my knowledge there were two female children in the apartment - why did no-one ask who or which one?
[/quote

Cite please for everyone knowing before being told.

Debunker.  Will you please get The Quote thing right.  You have to scroll down to beyond the "Quote" thingy.

@ DeNada..  No one is actually sure what Kate said.  And would it make a difference anyway?

[Eleanor]

See.  Failure to scroll down when Quoting has b....red up the quote thingy.

[DeNada]

do you dispute the quote 'they've taken her'?

[DeNada]

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-483715/Kate-McCann-DID-scream-Theyve-taken-claims-new-nanny-witness.html

now do you want to use the rest of Ms Pennington evidence for your claims or shall we dismiss the lot?

[gilet]

Yes Denada the article has answered your own question.

"When we were coming out we saw Kate and she was screaming: 'They've taken her. They've taken her!'

Asked if it was the only thing she said, Miss Pennington answered: "It might not have been the first thing she said. But she definitely said it. She also repeated Madeleine's name and said: 'She's gone, she's gone'.

Nice, isn't it when you get the answer to a question so quickly? I wish all questions could be answered as easily.

[John]

We know from witness statements from people who actually were at the table that Kates' first words were,  "She's gone Gerry, Madeleine's gone".

Does that answer your question DeNada?

[debunker]

When Kate apparently ran back to the tapas shouting 'They've taken her' did everyone there know she was talking about Maddie?

To my knowledge there were two female children in the apartment - why did no-one ask who or which one?
[/quote

Cite please for everyone knowing before being told.

Debunker.  Will you please get The Quote thing right.  You have to scroll down to beyond the "Quote" thingy.

@ DeNada..  No one is actually sure what Kate said.  And would it make a difference anyway?

I am posting on an android tablet that does not do scroll. I have decluttered my study, realising that I rarely use many old books with so much available on the internet. I have every book I have ever bought- about 30000, covering two basic degrees, two advanced degrees as well as books used in preparing courses. A book specialist is going to visit next week to make an offer. Consequently all computers in the study are currently disconnected and all I have is a tablet as the boys are on holiday and playing minecraft all day and my wife takes her laptop to work and facebooks in the evening. I have to choose between a tablet, a kindle and an android archos.