TVI ordered to pay €20,000 to Robert Murat for calling him a "paedophile".

[jassi]

Davel I was replying to Erngath's reasons not you.  However I don't believe you when you say what you have above because it would appear to me that whatever Goncalo Amaral did he comes in from criticism from supporters of the McCanns and from my research has done for over a decade.

It's all because he dared to sully the name and reputation of the saintly couple.
Had he slunk away like a good little boy, we would have heard no more of him or his career.
IMO

[Erngath]

Yet I gather some of the PJ officers supported Goncalo Amaral in the Lisbon trial.

Also so the only reason that Goncalo Amaral is wrong in pretty much everything he did according to the supporters is because he wrote a book on the case. Is that really why he comes in for so much abuse here and mores so, elsewhere?

His book was imo written as a money earning exercise . His book is based on his flawed thinking and reasoning.
He accused Madeleine's parents of being involved in her disappearance.
There's absolutely nothing about the man which I admire.
I would say more but this is all off topic.

[Erngath]

No.. He's wrong because imo he mistunderdtood the evidence... There could be no complaint if his conclusion s were based on sound principles

Agreed .

[carlymichelle]

It's all because he dared to sully the name and reputation of the saintly couple.
Had he slunk away like a good little boy, we would have heard no more of him or his career.
IMO

when amaral won  the supporters were  beyond angry they were stunned  too all along they thought the mcanns  would  wipe the floor with amaral but he wiped the floor with them  davel has never forgiven amaral for beating  the saintly  couple he adores  imo

[Mr Gray]

Davel I was replying to Erngath's reasons not you.  However I don't believe you when you say what you have above because it would appear to me that whatever Goncalo Amaral did he comes in from criticism from supporters of the McCanns and from my research has done for over a decade.

IMO It's on record.. He misunderstood the evidence

[Erngath]

It's all because he dared to sully the name and reputation of the saintly couple.
Had he slunk away like a good little boy, we would have heard no more of him or his career.
IMO

Oh if only!

[jassi]

when amaral won  the supporters were  beyond angry they were stunned too all along they thought the mcanns  would  wipe the floor with amaral but he wiped the floor with them  davel has never forgiven amaral for beating  the saintly  couple he adores  imo

Has anything changed ?  They still seem desperately angry.

[carlymichelle]

Has anything changed ?  They still seem desperately angry.

not  really has it??

[Brietta]

I am sure they do Davel so why no criticism of Paulo Rebelo by name only Goncalo Amaral?

From my reading supporters posts on this forum so far you would think Goncalo Amaral was the only PJ officer involved in the case.

Who else wrote a book making the claims he did?

I wonder if he had included Murat in his 'theories' in like vein, if he would have been sued by him too?

[Vertigo Swirl]

I’m sure the fact that the dogs didn’t alert to anything connected to Murat helped to refocus the investigation.

It would be a pretty poor police investigation that ruled out a suspect on the basis that sniffer dogs did not alert in his home.

[Brietta]

Yet there was there was no mistrial or any one died because of this alleged misunderstanding, so what harm was done and why the continual complaints.

There was no trial.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Has anything changed ?  They still seem desperately angry.

Yup.  We named our cat Amaral just so that I could kick it when I get home every night, that’s how bloody furious I still am.

[Brietta]

Back on topic now, please ... "TVI ordered to pay €20,000 to Robert Murat for calling him a "paedophile"." Thank you

[barrier]

Delete please off topic.

[Robittybob1]

Didn't the PJ dig up parts of Casa Liliana back in May 2007 and used probes and ground penetrating radar in an attempt to find any trace of the missing child.

Misty will know.  I make a point of knowing as little as possible about RM.