Sunny's request for cites

[slartibartfast]

It is not a Myth.  It was offered as a suggestion.

It is a myth, it is regularly brought out and there is no form of evidence of it ever happening.

[Mr Gray]

It is a myth, it is regularly brought out and there is no form of evidence of it ever happening.

Then IMO you could refer  to the detection of cadaver odour as a myth

[Vertigo Swirl]

It is a myth, it is regularly brought out and there is no form of evidence of it ever happening.

Is it referred to as a fact or a theory?

[slartibartfast]

Then IMO you could refer  to the detection of cadaver odour as s myth

If you want to consider a dog trained to alert to cadaver odour alerting as a myth that is up to you.

[G-Unit]

It is not a Myth.  It was offered as a suggestion.

It's a bit fanciful, though because we don't know if the grandfather ever even lived in the apartment.

[Mr Gray]

If you want to consider a dog trained to alert to cadaver odour alerting as a myth that is up to you.

it's a myth that the alert confirms cadaver odour

[Sunny]

It is not a Myth.  It was offered as a suggestion.

I believe this was certainly not offered as a suggestion but as a fact

If Grandpas Pjays were on the bedside table next to the wall, they would from time to time, maybe always, be touching the wall.  Same with Grandpas ashes


Perhaps Grandpas ashes were moved around from time to time even spending the summer holidays in the garden, thus accounting for all the alerts in and around 5a?     Just an attempt to give a reason for the alerts IMO.

[Eleanor]

I believe this was certainly not offered as a suggestion but as a fact

If Grandpas Pjays were on the bedside table next to the wall, they would from time to time, maybe always, be touching the wall.  Same with Grandpas ashes


Perhaps Grandpas ashes were moved around from time to time even spending the summer holidays in the garden, thus accounting for all the alerts in and around 5a?     Just an attempt to give a reason for the alerts IMO.

Read Sadie's last several posts again.  It's not difficult.  You can pick up her posts by clicking on her name which goes to her profile.

[Sunny]

Read Sadie's last several posts again.  It's not difficult.  You can pick up her posts by clicking on her name which goes to her profile.

Thank you for explaining how to search others peoples posts, Eleanor.

Here is another one by sadie

But in any case the most likely source of that alert .... and let's make it clear, there was only one, was the ashes or the deceased pyjamas on the bedside table.  There to comfort the widow in a foreign country

That is still one very strong  suggestion.    So a hypothetical urn of ashes placed on a bedside table then becomes "the most likely source of the alert", quite amazing really considering there is no evidence of this urn of ashes.

All IMO.

[Brietta]

It's a bit fanciful, though because we don't know if the grandfather ever even lived in the apartment.

Certainly not at the same time as his remains might have been there.

[Brietta]

I believe this was certainly not offered as a suggestion but as a fact

If Grandpas Pjays were on the bedside table next to the wall, they would from time to time, maybe always, be touching the wall.  Same with Grandpas ashes


Perhaps Grandpas ashes were moved around from time to time even spending the summer holidays in the garden, thus accounting for all the alerts in and around 5a?     Just an attempt to give a reason for the alerts IMO.

Didn't you notice "If" ?

[Robittybob1]

Thank you for explaining how to search others peoples posts, Eleanor.

Here is another one by sadie

That is still one very strong  suggestion.    So a hypothetical urn of ashes placed on a bedside table then becomes "the most likely source of the alert", quite amazing really considering there is no evidence of this urn of ashes.

All IMO.

That just goes to show how problematic dog alerts can be.

[Sunny]

That just goes to show how problematic dog alerts can be.

In what way Rob.  IMO the most problematic thing appears to be that some supporters seem to be desperate to make up reasons for the alerts. 

Did you read my further post where said says that the ashes on the bedside table were the most likely reason for the alert in the bedroom.  How can some hypothetical ashes be a reason for an alert, let alone the most likely reason.

[Robittybob1]

In what way Rob.  IMO the most problematic thing appears to be that some supporters seem to be desperate to make up reasons for the alerts. 

Did you read my further post where said says that the ashes on the bedside table were the most likely reason for the alert in the bedroom.  How can some hypothetical ashes be a reason for an alert, let alone the most likely reason.

Did you see the post where Eddie barked near a tree, but someone claimed there had been ashes scattered there so that alert had to be discounted.  It could not be proved whether Eddie alerted to the ashes or not.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10278.msg496924#msg496924

[Mr Gray]

In what way Rob.  IMO the most problematic thing appears to be that some supporters seem to be desperate to make up reasons for the alerts. 

Did you read my further post where said says that the ashes on the bedside table were the most likely reason for the alert in the bedroom.  How can some hypothetical ashes be a reason for an alert, let alone the most likely reason.

What do you think was  the reason for the alert to cuddle cat