How DNA caught a suspected killer also linked to Madeleine case.

[Mr Gray]

You have obviously missed the ‘might’ in my post. I have not stated Brech as a suspect. I have put my personal theory on the forum, hoping open-minded members will constructively contribute. And so what if I think the parents had nothing to do with Madeleine’s disappearance and that she might be alive? I guess your next reply will be ‘semantics’.

[Anthro]

Thank you, Davel. As far as I know, OP will not tell where and how the investigation is going. I did send information to them. Within this context, Miss Taken Identity’s reply “neither has OP’ seems non-sensical.

[Robittybob1]

Neither have OG.

When you can demonstrate that Brech was in the PDL in the days prior to 3rd May, then you might have a point.
A theory with nothing to support it is worthless - IMO

No it at least puts a possible name to "spottyman".

[Miss Taken Identity]

You have obviously missed the ‘might’ in my post. I have not stated Brech as a suspect. I have put my personal theory on the forum, hoping open-minded members will constructively contribute. And so what if I think the parents had nothing to do with Madeleine’s disappearance and that she might be alive? I guess your next reply will be ‘semantics’.

No you have not put your theory on the forum. You have stated that OG are looking for (suspect) a foreign paedophile- you have failed to produce evidence to back this claim up. You are reiterating your take on THEIR alledged theory!

You then name a person, who should be given the same treatment as the parents- innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Unless you feel anyone apart from the parents are fair game for accusations without substance?

So  you guessed wrong about my reply, you may have guessed wrong about your named suspect!  and maybe also the parents!

"
You can talk about them if that's what makes you happy..I don't really see the point"- sayeth some one who has posted over 60k messages about... err  um oh yah the parents!

Oh the Irony 

[jassi]

No it at least puts a possible name to "spottyman".

Without any demonstrated justification.

[Miss Taken Identity]

Thank you, Davel. As far as I know, OP will not tell where and how the investigation is going. I did send information to them. Within this context, Miss Taken Identity’s reply “neither has OP’ seems non-sensical.

Oh great another one for OG to suddenly find out about!

"OP will not tell where and how the investigation is going."   So why are you claiming to know they are looking for foreign paedophiles?  sheesh!

who are OP?  and  what are you talking about>"Miss Taken Identity’s reply “neither has OP’ seems non-sensical"
'

It may be IF is had said it 

[Miss Taken Identity]

No it at least puts a possible name to "spottyman".

what if it is the wrong name? and has anyone come forward to say they saw this named spottyman with MBM after her claimed disappearance?

[Anthro]

Have you not read the papers re. Madeleine during late June 2019?

[Robittybob1]

Without any demonstrated justification.

There was more likeness there than between Gerry and the Smithman e-fits.

[jassi]

There was more likeness there than between Gerry and the Smithman e-fits.

Gerry was identified as possibly being Smithman by a witness.
Is Anthro a witness or just another armchair detective ?

[Anthro]

With respect, Jassi. How is this relevant and/or constructive. Do some members have a habit of ridiculing others?

[Robittybob1]

Gerry was identified as possibly being Smithman by a witness.
Is Anthro a witness or just another armchair detective ?

I think we all become possible witnesses once the e-fits are published. After the Crimewatch program they got hundreds of phone calls with possible information.  They asked for people to call them.

[jassi]

With respect, Jassi. How is this relevant and/or constructive. Do some members have a habit of ridiculing others?

I am ridiculing your 'theory', not you.
How you interpret it is entirely your affair.

[Robittybob1]

With respect, Jassi. How is this relevant and/or constructive. Do some members have a habit of ridiculing others?

You can tell us your background if you like.  I'm an armchair detective.  In fact I had a La-z-boy recliner in my office.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ffW0wHoeYjI

[Miss Taken Identity]

Have you not read the papers re. Madeleine during late June 2019?

What has the newpapers got to do with this conversation?

You made the statement, I asked for your source. you ignored it, now you are claiming you got it from newspapers? really.. and where did they get this story from if OG are not talking about it?

Again please quote the direct source which OG Staff member tells the newspaper.