A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[The General]

Just suppose for this argument's sake,Holly's theory had some standing,what would you in the short term expect of OG?

It's a valid point. At this stage, after so many years and so much money spent, if it found that all parties were somehow incompetent, then a massive cover up would need to be instigated to ensure all arses were suitably covered, then a scapegoat identified - these thing take time.
There's no way SY would trot out that Holly went and solved the thing from an armchair while they, with all of the collective, multi-country resources, failed so palpably.

[Mr Gray]

It's a valid point. At this stage, after so many years and so much money spent, if it found that all parties were somehow incompetent, then a massive cover up would need to be instigated to ensure all arses were suitably covered, then a scapegoat identified - these thing take time.
There's no way SY would trot out that Holly went and solved the thing from an armchair while they, with all of the collective, multi-country resources, failed so palpably.

what absolute tosh....more [ censored word ]...so when hollys theory is ignored its because SY want a cover up.

From what I can see holly thinks maddie is still alive...abducted but a kind couple...other guests and bought up as their own daughter,.She has also given the name. Would teh mccanns also ignore the fact that maddie is still alive and its known who she is with...utter tosh

if hollys theory is true why havent SY made an effort to recover her in the past 2 and a half months

[Brietta]

I'm pretty sure I've heard police officers, not just in this case but others too, refer to hypothesising and theories about what happened and who was involved.

Usually based on in depth knowledge of all the known facts, evidence and intelligence.  Is there anyone on the forum who fits that bill?

[The General]

what absolute tosh....more [ censored word ]...so when hollys theory is ignored its because SY want a cover up.

From what I can see holly thinks maddie is still alive...abducted but a kind couple...other guests and bought up as their own daughter,.She has also given the name. Would teh mccanns also ignore the fact that maddie is still alive and its known who she is with...utter tosh

if hollys theory is true why havent SY made an effort to recover her in the past 2 and a half months

Jesus Davros. A bit over the top innit?
I weep for the future of polite discourse.

[The General]

Usually based on in depth knowledge of all the known facts, evidence and intelligence.  Is there anyone on the forum who fits that bill?

No.

[Mr Gray]

Jesus Davros. A bit over the top innit?
I weep for the future of polite discourse.

Sorry... I didn't think you would be offended by the word tosh... There's me thinking you were one of the lads

[Lace]

Just for this argument's sake,Holly's theory had some standing,what would you in the short term expect of OG?

I know your question was directed at davel,  but what I would expect them to do,  if it is plausible, say nothing to Holly but to investigate and then if it turns out she is right,  arrest solve the case,  report to the public and give thanks to Holly in their reports on tv and other media.

[Holly Goodhead]

Usually based on in depth knowledge of all the known facts, evidence and intelligence.  Is there anyone on the forum who fits that bill?

In this particular case, due to Portuguese law, we have much of the material.  It is possible for someone such as myself ie no professional involvement to seize on pieces and connect them to form a different picture if you will. 

Police investigations often call high profile cases wrong whether it be actual miscarriages of justice, or the likes of Sutcliffe going on to commit more crimes having been interviewed and eliminated or poor Colin Stagg. 

[Myster]

I know your question was directed at davel,  but what I would expect them to do,  if it is plausible, say nothing to Holly but to investigate and then if it turns out she is right,  arrest solve the case,  report to the public and give thanks to Holly in their reports on tv and other media.

Just imagine the accolades bestowed upon our senior investigator - a thorough going over by Andrew Marr, invitation to lunch with Her Maj and subsequent Damehood, free TV makeovers, Nike running shoe sponsorship, lifetime Man U. managerial appointment (once Ole gets the boot), resident slot on "Loose Women", the list is endless...

[Mr Gray]

In this particular case, due to Portuguese law, we have much of the material.  It is possible for someone such as myself ie no professional involvement to seize on pieces and connect them to form a different picture if you will. 

Police investigations often call high profile cases wrong whether it be actual miscarriages of justice, or the likes of Sutcliffe going on to commit more crimes having been interviewed and eliminated or poor Colin Stagg.

As I've said over and over... We can all come up with a solution but you claim to have found the solution... That's, what I find more than a little riduculous

[Mr Gray]

Just imagine the accolades bestowed upon our senior investigator - a thorough going over by Andrew Marr, invitation to lunch with Her Maj and subsequent Damehood, free TV makeovers, Nike running shoe sponsorship, lifetime Man U. managerial appointment (once Ole gets the boot), resident slot on "Loose Women", the list is endless...

Yes.... Sounds ridiculous doesn't it

[barrier]

I know your question was directed at davel,  but what I would expect them to do,  if it is plausible, say nothing to Holly but to investigate and then if it turns out she is right,  arrest solve the case,  report to the public and give thanks to Holly in their reports on tv and other media.

I doubt they would publicly thank a named  individual but thank the public as a whole.

[Myster]

Yes.... Sounds ridiculous doesn't it

I wish Holly had solved it... I really do, but can't see arrests being made anytime soon.

[Holly Goodhead]

I wish Holly had solved it... I really do, but can't see arrests being made anytime soon.

You don't know what it is yet 

[Holly Goodhead]

I doubt they would publicly thank a named  individual but thank the public as a whole.

Yes they might just say a member of the public was able to provide some useful info.