A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[barrier]

But the likelihood of an abduction has been confirmed by the professional sleuths

Only the blinkered SY sleuths.

[Mr Gray]

Only the blinkered SY sleuths.

i dont think they are blinkered at all....I think its the sceptics who are blinkered.

[pathfinder73]

Baptista closed at 8pm. How long would it have taken JM to make that short drive up Rua FdG Martins & what car was she driving?

Have you asked Jenny Murat that question? Ask the witness because I wasn't with her. She may have talked to somebody. You don't know what actually happened until you ask the witness.

I left about 8:15 to 8:30 pm. https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JEREMY-WILKINS.htm

Do you believe that within 15 minutes there are two women in purple with long black hair at the same location?  What are the chances? All this should have been cleared long ago!

[Eleanor]

Have you asked Jenny Murat that question? Ask the witness because I wasn't with her. She may have talked to somebody. You don't know what actually happened until you ask the witness.

I left about 8:15 to 8:30 pm. https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JEREMY-WILKINS.htm

Do you believe that within 15 minutes there are two women in purple with long black hair at the same location?  What are the chances? All this should have been cleared long ago!

Oh Dear.  Do you think that Goncalo Amaral didn't do this?

[pathfinder73]

Oh Dear.  Do you think that Goncalo Amaral didn't do this?

Jane Tanner seen dressed in purple was first reported by Jez Wilkins on 8 April 2008 so how would Amaral know about it when he was working on the case in 2007?

The woman in purple just like Tannerman should have been cleared long ago!

[G-Unit]

Oh Dear.  Do you think that Goncalo Amaral didn't do this?

Did you expect the PJ to read the UK newspapers and track down and question everyone who gave them stories? Jenny Murat mentioned nothing in her statement to the PJ about this woman in purple.

[Eleanor]

Did you expect the PJ to read the UK newspapers and track down and question everyone who gave them stories? Jenny Murat mentioned nothing in her statement to the PJ about this woman in purple.

I expected Goncalo to do a very much better job than he actually did.  In fact it was abysmal.  I can't help wondering why.

[Mr Gray]

I expected Goncalo to do a very much better job than he actually did.  In fact it was abysmal.  I can't help wondering why.

i think it could have something to do with the amount of alcohol he drank at lunch and after work...no one can function at a reasonable level with that sort of behaviour

[Brietta]

The Very same can be said of any one that was going about their daily business and trying to retro fit them into something suspicious like an alleged abduction by amateur sleuths. St Mary Mead is where it belongs.

Do the "amateurs" to whom you refer include the Judicial Police who reopened Madeleine's investigation to make the attempt to find out who kidnapped her?


Judiciária confirma reabertura do caso Maddie
Judiciary confirms reopening of Maddie case

A Policia Judiciaria voltou a abrir a investigação ao caso Maddie, a menina Inglesa desaparecida em 2007 de um aldeamento na praia da Luz, no Algarve.
The Judicial Police once again opened the investigation into the case of Maddie, the English girl who disappeared in 2007 from a village on Praia da Luz, in the Algarve.

Depois de questionado este orgão de investigação criminal responde em comunicado que "esta investigação tem sido desenvolvida em articulação com autoridades internacionais, obedecendo às regras de cooperação judiciária e policial, que as circunstâncias da situação justificam".
After being questioned, this criminal investigation body replies in a statement that "this investigation has been carried out in conjunction with international authorities, obeying the rules of judicial and police cooperation, which the circumstances of the situation justify".

Para já a Policia Judiciaria não presta mais esclarecimentos.
For the time being the Judiciary Police does not provide further clarification.


O esclarecimento da Judiciária surge depois de, nesta sexta-feira, o jornal "Correio da Manhã" ter dado conta de que esta policia segue novas pistas de rapto e que os inspectores procuram um suspeito de ter levado a criança.
The clarification of the Judiciary comes after this Friday, the newspaper "Correio da Manhã" reported that this police is following new kidnapping tracks and that the inspectors are looking for a suspect of having taken the child.
https://rr.sapo.pt/2019/05/03/pais/judiciaria-confirma-reabertura-do-caso-maddie/noticia/150075/

[Brietta]

Only the blinkered SY sleuths.

You are wrong.  Are the Juddicial Police 'blinkered' too?  Or how else do you think Euclides Monteiro came into the equation?

[Brietta]

I expected Goncalo to do a very much better job than he actually did.  In fact it was abysmal.  I can't help wondering why.

In my opinion merely reading the statements taken from the Ocean Club employees really shows up just how poor the investigation actually was ... they contain very little useful detail which could be used to collate everyone's whereabouts.

Investigation seems to have been concentrated on the timeline drawn up by the McCann friends to the exclusion of everyone else making what should have been a model for everyone in the vicinity into an impediment and a hook to hang suspicion on.

[barrier]

You are wrong.  Are the Juddicial Police 'blinkered' too?  Or how else do you think Euclides Monteiro came into the equation?

Q:Do you accept the girl was abducted;

Do Carmo:we dont know what happened and have to be prepared for different scenario's.


Meanwhile in the real world another 209 die in the uk because of the virus,puts into perspective.

[Mr Gray]

Q:Do you accept the girl was abducted;

Do Carmo:we dont know what happened and have to be prepared for different scenario's.


Meanwhile in the real world another 209 die in the uk because of the virus,puts into perspective.

Do Carmo also said the parents are not suspects and there's no evidence against them....I think most of us realise the mccann controversy is of no real importance now..

[Brietta]

Q:Do you accept the girl was abducted;

Do Carmo:we dont know what happened and have to be prepared for different scenario's.


Meanwhile in the real world another 209 die in the uk because of the virus,puts into perspective.

In the real world life goes on and when the present pandemic has run its course we will expect the rule of law and order to remain in place ... what sort of 'real world' scenario will you be content to live in if evidence and therefore JUSTICE is ignored in a missing child case.

[The General]

In the real world life goes on and when the present pandemic has run its course we will expect the rule of law and order to remain in place ... what sort of 'real world' scenario will you be content to live in if evidence and therefore JUSTICE is ignored in a missing child case.

One that gives equal consideration to all available evidence.