A Good, Bad or Average Theory What's The Difference?

[Eleanor]

Same corridor then...let's not split hairs.

And let's not tell me to self moderate.  I would never do that to you.

[Angelo222]

Snip
Until then I’d barely heard of Sr Amaral. In the five months he held this job I never met him. Gerry did only once, very briefly.  madeleine:  Kate McCann

If that is what a police coordinator is supposed to do it just something else he slacked off on then.

She wasn't aware he was there watching her as she refused to answer the police questions but he was.  She was the prime suspect, not Gerry. It was Goncalo's job to oversee that interview.

[Angelo222]

And let's not tell me to self moderate.  I would never do that to you.

You stated they had never met but they were in the same police station at the same time only feet away.  Davel seems to think Portimão cop shop is some sort of social club where detectives hobnob with suspects. The McCanns were there as official suspects, not as visitors expecting a handshake and a cup of tea.

[Holly Goodhead]

I didn't say it wasn't valid, I said it wasn't the same. My analogy referred to a certainty that another party wasn't aware of, so the 'actual' odds were different from their perspective (humans thought 1 million to one, aliens knew odds on - we gonna make it rain). But even a retard like me can concede that Mr and Mrs McCann, when doing their little mental risk assessment, could not have conceived 'abduction' as a possibility, despite their wanton neglect. So their calculated odds may be, say, 10,000-1. But your supposed abductor know different - he's thinking 5's max.
So, to reiterate, these odds - they're subjective. You think you know, but there's variables you know shirt about.
Poker? When they present it on the telly they can predict all odds of winning given the held cards  - the variables are known.

What evidence do you have that any abductor was male? 

And how can you talk about 'odds' when the motive is unknown? 

[Eleanor]

You stated they had never met but they were in the same police station at the same time only feet away.  Davel seems to think Portimão cop shop is some sort of social club where detectives hobnob with suspects. The McCanns were there as official suspects, not as visitors expecting a handshake and a cup of tea.

So you think it is acceptable to tell another Moderator On Forum to Self Moderate, despite not being entirely wrong?

You have so seriously disappointed me.

But I will be after you on the next occasion that you are even remotely careless.

[Vertigo Swirl]

You stated they had never met but they were in the same police station at the same time only feet away.  Davel seems to think Portimão cop shop is some sort of social club where detectives hobnob with suspects. The McCanns were there as official suspects, not as visitors expecting a handshake and a cup of tea.

Cite? 

[Mr Gray]

You stated they had never met but they were in the same police station at the same time only feet away.  Davel seems to think Portimão cop shop is some sort of social club where detectives hobnob with suspects. The McCanns were there as official suspects, not as visitors expecting a handshake and a cup of tea.

Angelo now resorts to a pathetic attempt at personal insults. 
If amaral is so hands on then he would have been present when cipriano was interrogated and beaten.... That isn't what happens in any coffee shop I've been too.

[Mr Gray]

This has been discussed at great length already. Amaral was in the police station when the McCanns were being questioned, he didn't need to meet them as in share a conversation or shake hands or anything as that would have been unprofessional. The McCanns were suspects and required to be treated as such.

So you now admit he never met them which makes your claim he saw fear in their eyes untrue.
As you have claimed you think Maddie left the apartment herself and then met her fate.... Why do you keep supporting amaral who got it all wrong it seems

[Vertigo Swirl]

So you now admit he never met them which makes your claim he saw fear in their eyes untrue.
As you have claimed you think Maddie left the apartment herself and then met her fate.... Why do you keep supporting amaral who got it all wrong it seems

Just to annoy McCann supporters I suspect.

[Mr Gray]

Just to annoy McCann supporters I suspect.

So angelo thinks he annoys posters... Certainly doesn't annoy me.  I'm not particularly bothered what anyone here thinks... It's the truth that matters

[barrier]

Just to annoy McCann supporters I suspect.

It works?

[barrier]

So angelo thinks he annoys posters... Certainly doesn't annoy me.  I'm not particularly bothered what anyone here thinks... It's the truth that matters

Yep,imo its not been fully told yet,25 yrs for a semblance of what may have happened to B Needham to come to light,can't see it any different for M McCann imo.

[Vertigo Swirl]

It works?

It generates more posts, inflammatory and argumentative posts usually do.  Without them this forum would have died years ago.
If the GNR officers were Tweedle Dum and Tweedle Dee then it follows Amaral was the Mad Hatter, certainly as far as his theory goes.

[barrier]

It generates more posts, inflammatory and argumentative posts usually do.  Without them this forum would have died years ago.
If the GNR officers were Tweedle Dum and Tweedle Dee then it follows Amaral was the Mad Hatter, certainly as far as his theory goes.

Agreed,I posted a couple of days ago about groundhog day,its every day in here,still it passes the time for a minute or two whilst waiting for the coffee to cool.

[Mr Gray]

Yep,imo its not been fully told yet,25 yrs for a semblance of what may have happened to B Needham to come to light,can't see it any different for M McCann imo.

Shouldn't have to wait that long according to super cop... Once M15 opens the files the truth will be told... How can anyone take him seriously

Perhaps angelo can tell us why MI5 would be involved in the McCann case