When Madeleine is Found.

[Eleanor]

Glad to oblige. 

I think the thread title is over optimistic, shouldn't it say if?

So why are you bothering to comment?  But not well mannered enough to address your comment to me personally.  How very rude..

[Vertigo Swirl]

lol. "I really liked you, despite the fact that we didn't agree.  And now I am disappointed.  The loss is only mine."

Thank god it was you who caused the disappointment - I have always been the hat  ted  one- giggles.

It would be a nice ending to a story if Maddie was found alive and well and looking forward to getting back to her loving family. However, I don't see that happening.  If she wrote a book, throwing her anger at her parents, well deserved of course, how would supporters feel- I wonder.  We just don't have a thread to discuss Madeleine on this forum, just her parents.

It is as if Madeleine is a by product of Kate n Gerry's feelings.

I would be happy even if Madeleine sued her parents and married Amaral.  She would still be alive and it would be proven that years spent accusing the parents of disposing her body were years wasted by all the sceptics I’ve ever debated with. 

[Miss Taken Identity]

Oh Dear.  How very awful you are.  But we don't have much of a choice on this Forum.

Is there ANY chance you can stick to the rules!   calling me awful is name calling and John said... as well its all shite anyway.

Barry and General get watched and moderated for nothing other than they are not McCann luvvies/supporters.


Poor Maddie- what would she think if she could read this forum Thread...

[Vertigo Swirl]

Is there ANY chance you can stick to the rules!   calling me awful is name calling and John said... as well its all shite anyway.

Barry and General get watched and moderated for nothing other than they are not McCann luvvies/supporters.


Poor Maddie- what would she think if she could read this forum Thread...

Barry?

[Brietta]

lol. "I really liked you, despite the fact that we didn't agree.  And now I am disappointed.  The loss is only mine."

Thank god it was you who caused the disappointment - I have always been the hat  ted  one- giggles.

It would be a nice ending to a story if Maddie was found alive and well and looking forward to getting back to her loving family. However, I don't see that happening.  If she wrote a book, throwing her anger at her parents, well deserved of course, how would supporters feel- I wonder.  We just don't have a thread to discuss Madeleine on this forum, just her parents.

It is as if Madeleine is a by product of Kate n Gerry's feelings.

This thread is all about Madeleine.

In my opinion your post reveals that you are the one who has the fixation on her parents. 
I can think of absolutely no-one whose first thought on hearing that Madeleine had been found alive and well would suggest that the outcome you appear to be salivating over would ever occur.

I think it is far more likely that in the event of Madeleine finding her identity she will be be appalled that there were people who spent so many years of her life promoting the notion that she was dead and who have the impudence to imagine that she shares their bigotry to the extent it would even cross her mind to act as you suggest.

[Eleanor]

Barry?

Miss Taken is just back to wind up everyone.  As ever, not frightfully good at it. 

Oh for one single Sceptic who could offer anything beyond spite, and something horrible that happened in their own lives.

[sadie]

This thread is all about Madeleine.

In my opinion your post reveals that you are the one who has the fixation on her parents. 
I can think of absolutely no-one whose first thought on hearing that Madeleine had been found alive and well would suggest that the outcome you appear to be salivating over would ever occur.

I think it is far more likely that in the event of Madeleine finding her identity she will be be appalled that there were people who spent so many years of her life promoting the notion that she was dead and who have the impudence to imagine that she shares their bigotry to the extent it would even cross her mind to act as you suggest.

Post of the week

 

[G-Unit]

This thread is all about Madeleine.

In my opinion your post reveals that you are the one who has the fixation on her parents. 
I can think of absolutely no-one whose first thought on hearing that Madeleine had been found alive and well would suggest that the outcome you appear to be salivating over would ever occur.

I think it is far more likely that in the event of Madeleine finding her identity she will be be appalled that there were people who spent so many years of her life promoting the notion that she was dead and who have the impudence to imagine that she shares their bigotry to the extent it would even cross her mind to act as you suggest.

This thread is entitled 'When Madeleine is found'. The assumption being that she will be found. That is surely an assumption too far? No-one knows what happened on 3rd May 2007 and therefore in my opinion no-one should be promoting any conclusions about her fate.

[Erngath]

This thread is entitled 'When Madeleine is found'. The assumption being that she will be found. That is surely an assumption too far? No-one knows what happened on 3rd May 2007 and therefore in my opinion no-one should be promoting any conclusions about her fate.

Does that apply to WS , whose tag line promotes his assumption and conclusion.

Do you think Amaral promoted his conclusions about Madeleine's fate?

[kizzy]

Yes it is..why else are they going to the ECHR

To find Maddie surely - don't say it's going to be about them

[Mr Gray]

To find Maddie surely - don't say it's going to be about them

Thats a bit silly...they won't find Maddie at the ECHR...it's to show amaral is wrong....which imo has clearly affected the search

[G-Unit]

Does that apply to WS , whose tag line promotes his assumption and conclusion.

Do you think Amaral promoted his conclusions about Madeleine's fate?

All the more reason to stick to the facts. The title of the thread suggests it's a fact that Madeleine will be found and that the only uncertainty is when that will happen. It isn't a fact that she will be found alive.

[kizzy]

Thats a bit silly...they won't find Maddie at the ECHR...it's to show amaral is wrong....which imo has clearly affected the search

Still, first priority then going after GA - now that is what's silly.

sillier still - how on earth are they going to prove GA wrong.

[Mr Gray]

Still, first priority then going after GA - now that is what's silly.

sillier still - how on earth are they going to prove GA wrong.

If someone libels you it's normal to take them to court...they don't have to prove amaral wrong. From what I've seen the ECHR will look at what evidence supports amarals claims to see if what he has said is reasonable...

[Erngath]

All the more reason to stick to the facts. The title of the thread suggests it's a fact that Madeleine will be found and that the only uncertainty is when that will happen. It isn't a fact that she will be found alive.

I believe poster's here realise that it isn't a fact that she will be found alive.
Do you accept that Amarall had no right to promote his assumptions and conclusions as fact?