Goncalo Amaral.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Given the circumstances, they would find their daughter dead and just randomly in tht counry put her in a bin? Just insanity.

The troll believes the McCanns murdered their daughter before they went to dinner and then left her body in an unlocked apartment, apparently happy for friends of theirs to check on the kids during the evening (even though one of them had been strangled or bludgeoned to death) and then decided that the best time to dispose of the body was mid-way through dinner and to do so by carrying it uncovered through the holiday village to a bin some distance away, knowing that they could bump into other holiday makers at any time.  And then, knowing that he had been seen by numerous people, the father stood before the world’s media (which he apparently invited to cover the disappearance in the first place)  making a bold appeal for information leading to her return.  As you say, just insanity.   

[Eleanor]

The troll believes the McCanns murdered their daughter before they went to dinner and then left her body in an unlocked apartment, apparently happy for friends of theirs to check on the kids during the evening (even though one of them had been strangled or bludgeoned to death) and then decided that the best time to dispose of the body was mid-way through dinner and to do so by carrying it uncovered through the holiday village to a bin some distance away, knowing that they could bump into other holiday makers at any time.  And then, knowing that he had been seen by numerous people, the father stood before the world’s media (which he apparently invited to cover the disappearance in the first place)  making a bold appeal for information leading to her return.  As you say, just insanity.

There is a very serious lack of logic going on here and right from the start.  The McCanns had neither the time or the means to dispose of their daughter's body.  But it's a bit of a waste of time pointing this out.

[Vertigo Swirl]

The troll believes the McCanns murdered their daughter before they went to dinner and then left her body in an unlocked apartment, apparently happy for friends of theirs to check on the kids during the evening (even though one of them had been strangled or bludgeoned to death) and then decided that the best time to dispose of the body was mid-way through dinner and to do so by carrying it uncovered through the holiday village to a bin some distance away, knowing that they could bump into other holiday makers at any time.  And then, knowing that he had been seen by numerous people, the father stood before the world’s media (which he apparently invited to cover the disappearance in the first place)  making a bold appeal for information leading to her return.  As you say, just insanity.

And not only all this, but they managed to act in a way entirely consistent with parents who were experiencing the sudden unexpected disappearance of a child (according to the FLOs) AND they got away with it!!!!  Despite the enormous risks they took which resulted in one of them being supposedly seen in the act of hiding a body!!!  Truly insane. 

[Wonderfulspam]

The troll believes the McCanns murdered their daughter before they went to dinner and then left her body in an unlocked apartment, apparently happy for friends of theirs to check on the kids during the evening (even though one of them had been strangled or bludgeoned to death) and then decided that the best time to dispose of the body was mid-way through dinner and to do so by carrying it uncovered through the holiday village to a bin some distance away, knowing that they could bump into other holiday makers at any time.  And then, knowing that he had been seen by numerous people, the father stood before the world’s media (which he apparently invited to cover the disappearance in the first place)  making a bold appeal for information leading to her return.  As you say, just insanity.

Nope, you have that wrong I'm I'm afraid.

[Wonderfulspam]

And not only all this, but they managed to act in a way entirely consistent with parents who were experiencing the sudden unexpected disappearance of a child (according to the FLOs) AND they got away with it!!!!  Despite the enormous risks they took which resulted in one of them being supposedly seen in the act of hiding a body!!!  Truly insane.

Not impossible.

[Wonderfulspam]

There is a very serious lack of logic going on here and right from the start. The McCanns had neither the time or the means to dispose of their daughter's body.  But it's a bit of a waste of time pointing this out.

Depends on exactly how accurate the timeline is, no way to be certain is there, & I've just described an entirely viable method, but never mind.

Of course, if you know of any credible evidence Maddie was abducted, other than, because the McCanns said so, that would debunk my theory entirely.

Do you know of any of that, care to share it?

[Vertigo Swirl]

There is a very serious lack of logic going on here and right from the start.  The McCanns had neither the time or the means to dispose of their daughter's body. But it's a bit of a waste of time pointing this out.

Even barmy old Blonk realises the truth of this statement which is why he has had to invent another (equally implausible) scenario.

[Wonderfulspam]

Even barmy old Blonk realises the truth of this statement which is why he has had to invent another (equally implausible) scenario.

Well, let's see/hear the abduction evidence & we can put this bin theory to bed once & for all.

[barrier]

Well, let's see/hear the abduction evidence & we can put this bin theory to bed once & for all.

The bin theory can't be put to bed, what if CB used one, after all Wolters says he killed the girl.

[Wonderfulspam]

The bin theory can't be put to bed, what if CB used one, after all Wolters says he killed the girl.

Well Brueckner whom I believe was Smithman, was headed somewhere, & Maddie was never seen again.

So yes, maybe he took her to the dark deserted beach, or an apartment somewhere nearby, did what he wanted to do, then disposed of her in the manner I've described.

No way to rule it out entirely really is there, I mean, it's possible isn't, Kate herself thought so.

[Rossb]

Not impossible.

You would have to be a socipath or psychopath to act normal like that, neither of them appear to be. No one had any concerns about the eay they acted until the reporting of maddy and the only witness to criticise was that of yvonne martin. The morning after asking kate randomly if gerry was the real father lmao. Thats certainly a question i would intervene with as a member of the public

[Wonderfulspam]

You would have to be a socipath or psychopath to act normal like that, neither of them appear to be. No one had any concerns about the eay they acted until the reporting of maddy and the only witness to criticise was that of yvonne martin. The morning after asking kate randomly if gerry was the real father lmao. Thats certainly a question i would intervene with as a member of the public

Not necessarily.

Maybe they put on a convincing enough act & those around them fell for it.

No way to be sure really is there.

That is, until the three police forces release the concrete abduction evidence, & they don't appear to be doing that anytime soon, & haven't in the last 15 years either.

But maybe tomorrow.

[Vertigo Swirl]

The bin theory can't be put to bed, what if CB used one, after all Wolters says he killed the girl.

CB would not have put her in a bin in the centre of a town he used to hang out in unless he really has rocks in his head.

[Rossb]

Not necessarily.


Just does not convince me, they were too sociable for everyone. Muat have at least one person in those days mention something strange or wrong but none.
Maybe they put on a convincing enough act & those around them fell for it.

No way to be sure really is there.

That is, until the three police forces release the concrete abduction evidence, & they don't appear to be doing that anytime soon, & haven't in the last 15 years either.

But maybe tomorrow.

[Wonderfulspam]

Just does not convince me, they were too sociable for everyone. Muat have at least one person in those days mention something strange or wrong but none.

Well good for you.

Me personally, I'm not convinced Maddie was abducted.

Do you know of any evidence that she actually was, other than, because the McCanns said so & SY said so, & Wolters said so, & Brueckner said so?

Any abduction evidence other than that spring to mind?