What Time Roughly Was The Bedroom Telephone Put In The Kitchen?

[Holly Goodhead]

VS, I wonder if the response might be along the lines of there being no evidence of Jeremy's psychopathy?

What evidence do you have APRIL? 

[Robittybob1]

Don’t you think it would be a bit strange that in a crime where only two people could have done it, it would be the psychopath who was innocent?

What I think is strange is putting it down to only two people who could have done it.

[Holly Goodhead]

What I think is strange is putting it down to only two people who could have done it.

Maybe that's because you're new to the case eh Robittybob1 

[Robittybob1]

Maybe that's because you're new to the case eh Robittybob1 

There is another person I'd like to look at as well who will remain anonymous at present.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Not when the other potential perp had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia and was brought up by an adoptive  mother who had been diagnosed with psychosis and severe depression.

Are Schizophrenics more murderous than psychopaths as a rule?

[mrswah]

Are Schizophrenics more murderous than psychopaths as a rule?

No, but I think it would depend on the individual case.

[Robittybob1]

Are Schizophrenics more murderous than psychopaths as a rule?

A Schizophrenic has a defense to murder as they are often found insane at the time of the killing.    I'd like to know the answer to that question too.

As a guess Schizophrenics would be more dangerous IMO.

[mrswah]

A Schizophrenic has a defense to murder as they are often found insane at the time of the killing.    I'd like to know the answer to that question too.

As a guess Schizophrenics would be more dangerous IMO.

Peter Sutcliffe was said to have schizophrenia----and he was certainly dangerous.

[mrswah]

Please identify the psychiatrist.

Wilkes mentions this in his book, but even he doesn't identify the psychiatrist.

[mrswah]

But it wasn’t a MAJOR accident: no lives were lost: no-one was even injured. So of course it wouldn’t have had a traumatic effect on you. It sounds like you may have been on autopilot when driving, hence why you didn’t notice things the police asked you. You may have been listening to the radio, or thinking about something...lots of minor RTA’s occur unexpectedly...

You can’t compare a prang in a car with having all your family shot dead!

Actually, I was injured, and taken to hospital. I remember being unable to move my hands---although I had no injuries to my hands, so I was either in shock or traumatised (not sure of the difference).

I suspect JB was too, when he made his first statements. He could well have been traumatised even if he committed the murders, IMO.

[APRIL]

What evidence do you have APRIL?

He was categorized as being such pretrial.

[Caroline]

Please identify the psychiatrist.

I don't need to and you and GU can delude yourselves that he doesn't exist - but you know he does really 

[Miss Taken Identity]

A Schizophrenic has a defense to murder as they are often found insane at the time of the killing.    I'd like to know the answer to that question too.

As a guess Schizophrenics would be more dangerous IMO.

This is the big question. let us look at how the diagnosis thingy works.

Patient tells doctor events and 'feeling's before -during-after events. The doctor who has read well on the subject from other people  give a diagnosis BASED on the 'feelings' which was relayed to him/her.

It is NOT a science in a factual respect, it is based on trust and theory.
1. to trust the patient isn't 'playing a card' to get the correct diagnosis to fit an agenda (Well known tactic in criminal trials)
2.The theory is based on guess work from the information he/she(psychiatrist) has to hand.

So any psychiatrist cannot possibly KNOW for sure Sheila was a danger to her family and self- if they were, she would have been sectioned for sure.

JB was not presented for a psychiatric assessment before the killings, his mental state  would have been based on his behavior after, taking into account a grieving process. witnesses would build a picture before the killings to add to the information already gained.

Maybe he wasn't a psychopath - just a greedy,cruel cold bloodied b@stard who murdered people to get what he wanted.

[Holly Goodhead]

I don't need to and you and GU can delude yourselves that he doesn't exist - but you know he does really 

If you have any evidence of such why not share it with the forum? 

[Holly Goodhead]

Certainly not to those who continually make excuses. He was categorised as such pre- trial.

Evidence please.