New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance.

[barrier]

Boy when them egss turn out to be dummy's and don't hatch will there be some backtracking.

[Mr Gray]

Boy when them egss turn out to be dummy's and don't hatch will there be some backtracking.

HCW says he has concrete/strong/material evidence Maddie is dead.
I think it's highly probable that will prove abduction.

The only backtracking will come from those who have suggested abduction is impossible..

[Brietta]

Boy when them egss turn out to be dummy's and don't hatch will there be some backtracking.

I doubt that very much indeed but you can keep on hoping.  Shouldn't be long to wait now to find out what is happening.

Not that I think it will matter what happens either way for some whose closure of mind is equalled in my opinion only by terrorists or in the bible belt of America.

[Mr Gray]

I doubt that very much indeed but you can keep on hoping.  Shouldn't be long to wait now to find out what is happening.

Not that I think it will matter what happens either way for some whose closure of mind is equalled in my opinion only by terrorists or in the bible belt of America.

I think the very least he will have is proof of abduction and that is going to upset a lot of people

[faithlilly]

Mrs  Murat saw a woman in a plum top standing outside the family's apartment en route to Baptista supermarket.   About 19h50 she went to the "Batista" supermarket to buy bread.  She would have travelled down Rua Dr Francisco G.M. where the tapas group all walked to and from their apartments to the Tapas restaurant

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JENNIFER-MURAT.htm


 Mrs Murat also described seeing a woman standing outside the (McCann) family's apartment on the night Madeleine went missing.

"I noticed her there and she kind of looked as if she was trying to hide from me. I do remember she was wearing a plum-coloured top," she said.

https://www.glasgowtimes.co.uk/news/15261405.algarve-resident-tells-of-car-sighting-near-madeleine-mccann-apartment/


In his statement Jez describes a woman wearing purple standing outside the apartments to the 'group'.  His words are, as taken from your quote,   " She was stopped on the street in front of one of the group's apartments when I passed her down towards the exit to my apartment".   This was on Rua Aghostina de Silva.

Jez knew which the McCann apartment was, so the woman in purple wasn't standing outside their apartment and she was not on Mrs Murats route to Baptista supermarket.


In the meantime from Jane Tanners May4th statement

At about 19.00 they all went back to their own apartments with the children. The witness bathed her children, read them a story and put them to bed. E**e who was unwell and having trouble sleeping, stayed with her father, who had arrived in the meantime. The witness went for dinner at the Tapas restaurant at about 20.30.

Timewise it could physically have been Jane, but so many differences it seems very unlikely.
-  Wearing purple v Maroon top ?
-  Slim, long black haired woman v Janes regular figure, not one most would describe as slim and brown hair, not black
-  Rua Aghostina v Rua Francisco
-  7.50pm v 8.15 pm

It all very tenuous.
What I truly resent is pathfinder virtually accusing Jane of being the woman in purple, when he doesn't know.  Stop it pathfinder; you go too far.   A bit of honour would go down well.

No apology from me.  Pathfinder owes Jane an apology though

A coincidence too far for me but of course you are free to believe exactly what you like.

[pathfinder73]

If that is the case, why would she be hanging around/loitering?

Tanner sent a text as phone records prove before entering the tapas and she left the apartment before Russell as it was his turn to look after unwell Evie.

[pathfinder73]

Mrs  Murat saw a woman in a plum top standing outside the family's apartment en route to Baptista supermarket.   About 19h50 she went to the "Batista" supermarket to buy bread.  She would have travelled down Rua Dr Francisco G.M. where the tapas group all walked to and from their apartments to the Tapas restaurant

https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/JENNIFER-MURAT.htm


 Mrs Murat also described seeing a woman standing outside the (McCann) family's apartment on the night Madeleine went missing.

"I noticed her there and she kind of looked as if she was trying to hide from me. I do remember she was wearing a plum-coloured top," she said.

https://www.glasgowtimes.co.uk/news/15261405.algarve-resident-tells-of-car-sighting-near-madeleine-mccann-apartment/


In his statement Jez describes a woman wearing purple standing outside the apartments to the 'group'.  His words are, as taken from your quote,   " She was stopped on the street in front of one of the group's apartments when I passed her down towards the exit to my apartment".   This was on Rua Aghostina de Silva.

Jez knew which the McCann apartment was, so the woman in purple wasn't standing outside their apartment and she was not on Mrs Murats route to Baptista supermarket.


In the meantime from Jane Tanners May4th statement

At about 19.00 they all went back to their own apartments with the children. The witness bathed her children, read them a story and put them to bed. E**e who was unwell and having trouble sleeping, stayed with her father, who had arrived in the meantime. The witness went for dinner at the Tapas restaurant at about 20.30.

Timewise it could physically have been Jane, but so many differences it seems very unlikely.
-  Wearing purple v Maroon top ?
-  Slim, long black haired woman v Janes regular figure, not one most would describe as slim and brown hair, not black
-  Rua Aghostina v Rua Francisco
-  7.50pm v 8.15 pm

It all very tenuous.
What I truly resent is pathfinder virtually accusing Jane of being the woman in purple, when he doesn't know.  Stop it pathfinder; you go too far.   A bit of honour would go down well.

No apology from me.  Pathfinder owes Jane an apology though

Murat saw Tanner like Jez did in purple at that location and you will NEVER be able to prove I'm wrong. Tanner left the apartment before Russell because it was his turn to look after unwell Evie. Read the statements and do some real work not fantasy.

[Eleanor]

Murat saw Tanner like Jez did in purple at that location and you will NEVER be able to prove I'm wrong. Tanner left the apartment before Russell because it was his turn to look after unwell Evie. Read the statements and do some real work not fantasy.

Not even relevant.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Not even relevant.

especially not on a thread about CB.

[pathfinder73]

Not even relevant.

What isn't relevant? FACT is Jane Tanner said she left the apartment on her OWN. Russell left later.

Jez Wilkins saw Jane Tanner on her OWN dressed in PURPLE. The same location as Jenny Murat. Elementary!

[Vertigo Swirl]

What isn't relevant? FACT is Jane Tanner said she left the apartment on her OWN. Russell left later.

Jez Wilkins saw Jane Tanner on her OWN dressed in PURPLE. The same location as Jenny Murat. Elementary!

What has this got to do with New German suspect in Madeleine McCann mystery disappearance?  Do you think he and Jane Tanner were working together?

[pathfinder73]

The German wasn't seen unless you have a witness who saw him there?

[Mr Gray]

The German wasn't seen unless you have a witness who saw him there?

can the german prove hes innocent

[pathfinder73]

can the german prove hes innocent

Yes if he has an alibi to prove he was elsewhere.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Yes if he has an alibi to prove he was elsewhere.

Gerry had several alibis to prove he was elsewhere at the time of the Smith sighting but you don’t accept them so why should anyone accept any alibi put forward by CB?