If Brueckner is Never Charged.

[Mr Gray]

If anyone attempted to access unused wells there would be signs of earth disturbance by way of footprints and tyre tracks. 

It's easy to explore wells with cameras:

https://youtu.be/qChpu0zCyTo

your post is present tense....I dont see there would be any signs of earth disturbance after 13 years

[Mr Gray]

Nothing to do with the MM case per se.  Please identify another case where 13 years after the crime was committed the police are appealling for info on two vehicles and telephone numbers the suspect had access to where the  whereabouts of the vehicles are known?

Although the prosecutor's office - described elsewhere as "cavalary of the law" -  has upheld the law by not naming the 'suspect' its clear the amount of information released would enable the media to pick up the baton. 

The MET's appeal is far more circumspect.  I can see huge repercussions for the prosecutor's office.  No wonder Portugal has chosen not to get involved with this madcap idea which in all probability breaks international law.

By all accounts CB is an unpleasant individual and a menace to children but he needs to be dealt with according to the law not the lynch mob.

I thought the Mc's argument with Amaral/The Lie is that it harms the search for MM if others are led to believe she's dead?  So how does it help when the prosecutor's office is making the same assertion without the evidence?

I would say the prosecutors office have strong evidence maddie is dead...thats what theyve said. The mcCanns have been left to the lynch mob for the past 13 years led by the PJ

[Vertigo Swirl]

Likewise.  My belief certainly gives me more comfort than believing MM met her end at the hands of a depraved individual 

Carry on believing it then, not that it changes reality in any way.

[Mr Gray]

In which case it begs the question why the MET is singing from a different hymn sheet:

While this male is a suspect we retain an open mind as to his involvement and this remains a missing person inquiry.

I don't believe the prosecutor's office (PO) has any evidence whatsoever that MM is dead or that CB was involved in her disappearance.

If the po has been carrying on like the "cavalry of the law" this high profile case could be its undoing!

SY in my opinion are being diplomatic...and the evidence the Germans have has not been shared, probably because the Grmans do not trust the professionalism of the PJ...they have said as much

[Vertigo Swirl]

SY in my opinion are being diplomatic...and the evidence the Germans have has not been shared, probably because the Grmans do not trust the professionalism of the PJ...they have said as much

Yes, as soon as the PJ find out what this evidence is, it will be flashed across the world’s media via the Rent-A-Gob Amaral.

[Mr Gray]

Likewise.  My belief certainly gives me more comfort than believing MM met her end at the hands of a depraved individual 

as ive posted before it would be wonderful if maddie was alive and well...but I am going with the evidence which means she is almost certainly dead

[Mr Gray]

Yes, as soon as the PJ find out what this evidence is, it will be flashed across the world’s media via the Rent-A-Gob Amaral.

precisely

[Holly Goodhead]

as ive posted before it would be wonderful if maddie was alive and well...but I am going with the evidence which means she is almost certainly dead

What evidence? 

[Mr Gray]

What evidence?

first piece of evidence is its been so long since the disappearnce...the overwhelming likelihood is maddie is dead...do you not agree

[Vertigo Swirl]

What evidence?

The evidence that the German police say they have concrete evidence.  Let’s play your favourite game.  Name another police force that have claimed to have concrete evidence of a crime when in reality they had absolutely nothing at all.  Apart from the PJ of course ;-)

[barrier]

The evidence that the German police say they have concrete evidence.  Let’s play your favourite game.  Name another police force that have claimed to have concrete evidence of a crime when in reality they had absolutely nothing at all.  Apart from the PJ of course ;-)

I beleive Sadie claims she has evidence in the form of a video which show's Madeleine alive in 2012,also she claims she passed it on to OG, ,OG still class it has a missing persons case,how does that fit in with the claims of the Germans.

[kizzy]

A totally ridiculous post...imo   ...I can guarantee the Germans are not so stupid to beleieve the dogs are evidence of maddies death

How can you guarantee it ... I think not D.

It can't be they are so professional the way they are going about things when it's so slapped dash imo.

What if they are reading it the same way as GA as You are forever saying he misread the evidence.

But it seems in Germany that what isn't accepted in Portugal ...it is in Germany. 15 out of 19 markers.

Isn't it 20 markers or 10 pairs are required in the UK before a match can be confirmed although as few as 15 are accepted in many other countries

[Anthro]

I would say the prosecutors office have strong evidence maddie is dead...thats what theyve said. The mcCanns have been left to the lynch mob for the past 13 years led by the PJ

I agree, Davel. The prosecutor’s reply that they have no body or any parts of the body gave me the impression that he chose his words very carefully. To me, this statement may well be a ‘clue’ as to what they have as evidence.

[Mr Gray]

How can you guarantee it ... I think not D.

It can't be they are so professional the way they are going about things when it's so slapped dash imo.

What if they are reading it the same way as GA as You are forever saying he misread the evidence.

But it seems in Germany that what isn't accepted in Portugal ...it is in Germany. 15 out of 19 markers.

Isn't it 20 markers or 10 pairs are required in the UK before a match can be confirmed although as few as 15 are accepted in many other countries

you are making the same simple mistake as amaral.

if it was 15 markers from a regular DNA sample ...not LCN DNA then that would be different. Then we have the fact that its from 3 to 5 poeple and maddies family used the car. You are showing...like amaral....a complete misunderstanding re the DNA and the dog alerts.

I dont see the Germans as being slap dash.....another ridiculous comment imo

[Holly Goodhead]

The evidence that the German police say they have concrete evidence.  Let’s play your favourite game.  Name another police force that have claimed to have concrete evidence of a crime when in reality they had absolutely nothing at all.  Apart from the PJ of course ;-)

It isn't coming from the German police/BKA.  Its from the public prosecutor's office.

Eberhard Siegesmund, deputy director general of the judicial system division, federal ministry of justice has described the public prosecutor's office as follows:

Even though it deserves to be called – actually by dint of statute, and this is something I will be coming back to later
– the “most objective authority in the world”, the public prosecution office is, however, not infrequently said, as the
“cavalry of the law”, to demonstrate a certain “dashing spirit” and is thus thought to be blind in its enthusiasm for
prosecution. Public prosecutors, although said to investigate swiftly and in a straightforward manner, are said to do so,
however, one-sidedly to the accused’s disadvantage, without any sure instinct and without the requisite critical distance.