“A Laughable Story”

[G-Unit]

 
I don't know is my answer John,  never been in that situation thank god.  What I do know is that Kate must have been in one hell of a state searching around that apartment and not finding her daughter,  she must have been out of her mind with worry.

You don't know what Kate McCann was thinking and feeling at all, you're assuming you do.

[Lace]

So thats logic thinking then isnt it to search the apartment.

It cant be both as you said kmc  wasnt thinking logically.

So she didn't find her... and still didn't close it... after she had looked out of it... and left her prints on it.

Kate  searched the apartment for Madeleine,  no doubt getting more and more frantic as she did so,  its no wonder when she didn't find her that she just tore out of there to get help.

[Lace]

You don't know what Kate McCann was thinking and feeling at all, you're assuming you do.

Yes I can imagine how she felt G-Unit can't you?

[kizzy]

Kate  searched the apartment for Madeleine,  no doubt getting more and more frantic as she did so,  its no wonder when she didn't find her that she just tore out of there to get help.

Kmc was searching round the apartment IIRC for near on 10 mins. Gmcc was wondering where she was.

So she didnt exactly tear out of there. I minute to me would be a life time.

She went to the window looked out no one IMO would think it not strange she did not close it.

There was gusts of wind blowing the curtains - the twins were in there cots practically underneath it.

IMO the window was never open in the first place for any of what she did to make sense.

[Mr Gray]

Kmc was searching round the apartment IIRC for near on 10 mins. Gmcc was wondering where she was.

So she didnt exactly tear out of there. I minute to me would be a life time.

She went to the window looked out no one IMO would think it not strange she did not close it.

There was gusts of wind blowing the curtains - the twins were in there cots practically underneath it.

IMO the window was never open in the first place for any of what she did to make sense.

do you actually think any of this is evidence...someone behaving odd as you out it is not evidence of any crime

[kizzy]

do you actually think any of this is evidence...someone behaving odd as you out it is not evidence of any crime

No, but IMO if that window wasnt open why did the mccs say it was.

[kizzy]

 
I don't know is my answer John,  never been in that situation thank god.  What I do know is that Kate must have been in one hell of a state searching around that apartment and not finding her daughter,  she must have been out of her mind with worry.

If the window was open that would tell you straight away Maddie had been taken like she said - at that point, you would either scream or run out not spend time searching the place.

But what if it was the patio door open that -  I believe is when you would search hoping Maddie had not gone out on her own.

If she had of been found wandering about hours later - it would have been adductor took her from her bed.

Not that she had woke and wondered and something terrible happened to her because no one was there.. all in my opinion same as yours L

[pathfinder73]

I didn't say she said that to the Police.

So it's irrelevant. Anybody can say anything after police files are released to cover their ass!

[Mr Gray]

No, but IMO if that window wasnt open why did the mccs say it was.

Because it was open

[Lace]

So it's irrelevant. Anybody can say anything after police files are released to cover their ass!

I wouldn't say she was covering her ass,  more defending herself against allegations that she staged an abduction.  Wouldn't you want to put the record straight.  Why didn't Amaral think to himself that maybe Kate had looked out of the window instead of jumping to the conclusion she must have opened it to stage an abduction?

[Lace]

If the window was open that would tell you straight away Maddie had been taken like she said - at that point, you would either scream or run out not spend time searching the place.

But what if it was the patio door open that -  I believe is when you would search hoping Maddie had not gone out on her own.

If she had of been found wandering about hours later - it would have been adductor took her from her bed.

Not that she had woke and wondered and something terrible happened to her because no one was there.. all in my opinion same as yours L

Well she must be guilty then as she didn't act the way you think she should have [in your opinion]

[The General]

Well she must be guilty then as she didn't act the way you think she should have [in your opinion]

Glad that's settled.

[Vertigo Swirl]

No, but IMO if that window wasnt open why did the mccs say it was.

It was open - Amy Tierney saw it open.

[kizzy]

Because it was open

Did you see it open - if not its only what you assume to fit your agenda.

[kizzy]

Well she must be guilty then as she didn't act the way you think she should have [in your opinion]

That's not by far the only thing though ...is it.