More recent events related to Madeleine McCann's case

[Eleanor]

The abduction theory is not logical or plausible in my opinion and this case has nothing in common with the Lamplugh case.

You might like to pay attention to possible Libel as well.

Sometimes "In My Opinion" isn't good enough.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

Do I ?  What leads you to that conclusion.  Show us the evidence!

I'm basing it on your posts which, to me at least, read as if you do not accept there are any other possibilities.

[Vertigo Swirl]

The abduction theory is not logical or plausible in my opinion and this case has nothing in common with the Lamplugh case.

If the abduction theory is neither logical nor plausible then you must believe the two highly respected police forces investigating are complete idiots!  Abduction IS the only logical and plausible explanation, not only in my opinion but in that of David Canter, Operation Grange, the German police and numerous other professional and respected individuals and commentators.  It must be an incredible puzzle to you that this is the case, I wonder how you rationalise it without going down some curly-wurly [ censored word ]y wormhole?

[Vertigo Swirl]

I'm basing it on your posts which, to me at least, read as if you do not accept there are any other possibilities.

Just one post in which I have claimed the open window proves abduction, just one, go on, I know you’re frightfully busy but if you make claims like this you need to provide evidence,

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

You simply don't understand that stranger abduction can be both rare AND the only logical and plausible explanation.  Look at the Susie Lamplugh case for example'  Would you dismiss the possibility that she was abducted because it doesn't happen very often?

Abduction, however rare, is plausible and possible.

It isn't the "obvious" conclusion in the McCann case, in my opinion. Was Mark Harrison really just missing something so "obvious"?

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

Just one post in which I have claimed the open window proves abduction, just one, go on, I know you’re frightfully busy but if you make claims like this you need to provide evidence,

You haven't proved abduction in any of your posts. You have described the open window as evidence of abduction. It's also evidence of a burglar, or it being a hot day and someone opening a window etc etc etc. We agree that there is no proof of an abduction.

[Eleanor]

You haven't proved abduction in any of your posts. You have described the open window as evidence of abduction. It's also evidence of a burglar, or it being a hot day and someone opening a window etc etc etc. We agree that there is no proof of an abduction.

And no proof that The McCanns killed their daughter and disposed of her body.

[Billy Whizz Fan Club]

And no proof that The McCanns killed their daughter and disposed of her body.

Absolutely correct.

[Vertigo Swirl]

You haven't proved abduction in any of your posts. You have described the open window as evidence of abduction. It's also evidence of a burglar, or it being a hot day and someone opening a window etc etc etc. We agree that there is no proof of an abduction.

Right so let’s never hear the “no evidence of an abduction “ mantra again.

[Mr Gray]

The abduction theory is not logical or plausible in my opinion and this case has nothing in common with the Lamplugh case.

Why not...

What I think is that you are so convinced by what you believe is evidence that you cant accept you could be wrong

[Wonderfulspam]

Right so let’s never hear the “no evidence of an abduction “ mantra again.

What abduction?

[Vertigo Swirl]

What abduction?

the one that there is evidence of having taken place in Apartment 5a on 3rd May 2007 in PdL.

[Wonderfulspam]

the one that there is evidence of having taken place in Apartment 5a on 3rd May 2007 in PdL.

Nope, never seen any evidence of that I'm afraid.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Nope, never seen any evidence of that I'm afraid.

Take your blinkers off then.

[Wonderfulspam]

I've just had to close the front room window just in case someone walks past & reports an abduction.