The boxes ticked by prime suspect Brueckner

[G-Unit]

With respect - my post was about Eleanor, not you per se.
I used your post as a convenient vehicle for comment to keep the discussion together with a subliminal nod to topic of keeping boxes stacked together with Eleanor's comment in the lead.  No ulterior motive from me and I know nothing of why Eleanor chose to mention your name in her post.

Thank you for the clarification.  I was struggling to see a connection.

[The General]

Its so significant that sceptics think that's a possibility... An absolute joke imo

Stop goading.
It is significant, otherwise law enforcement, investigators and emergency services wouldn't use them.

[The General]

I salute Eleanor who is one of the most even handed and fair moderators one could ever have wished for even during the most difficult times (and some of those a rational person would find difficult to believe, it took us a long time to work it out, and unfortunately confidentiality dictates my discretion so I can't share) - but as she has always said - the forum is not a democracy and at the end of the day John takes the final decisions, backed up by his mod team.  Of whom Eleanor and I were his staunchest support for the ethos behind what he tried and did achieve with this forum at a time when it was a very difficult thing to do.

That is water under the bridge now because the times have most certainly changed now and there is only a rump which doesn't recognise that.  But Eleanor has stuck with it through thick and thin and I wish her many happy years of posting.
@ Eleanor
Your middle name is integrity and you have given great service to this forum as a moderator: RESPECT and thanks for that.

Off topic. Let's get back on track please.

[Mr Gray]

Stop goading.
It is significant, otherwise law enforcement, investigators and emergency services wouldn't use them.

see my previous posts...the alerts were in no way significant..no more than an experiment

[The General]

see my previous posts...the alerts were in no way significant..no more than an experiment

If they contemporaneously alerted in CB's Winnebago they'd be significant, yes or no.

[Mr Gray]

If they contemporaneously alerted in CB's Winnebago they'd be significant, yes or no.

not unless physical evidence was found

[G-Unit]

If they contemporaneously alerted in CB's Winnebago they'd be significant, yes or no.

Or to Murat's surroundings or belongings.

[barrier]

If they contemporaneously alerted in CB's Winnebago they'd be significant, yes or no.

Also his compound, well old factory wasn't it, the  secret lair in a building.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Or to Murat's surroundings or belongings.

So, if the dogs alerted to CB's personal effects would you take that as evidence of his involvement in Madeleine's murder?  Of course you wouldn't. 

[The General]

not unless physical evidence was found

So they do have merit, certainly more than an experiment (your term, not mine).

[The General]

Also his compound, well old factory wasn't it, the  secret lair in a building.

The subterranean death dungeon.
I'll bet they had the 'experimental' doggies crawling all over that gaff*




*yes, Mr / Mrs Paraglider, I'm assuming again. Mad, isn't it?

[Mr Gray]

So they do have merit, certainly more than an experiment (your term, not mine).

No.. Its the physical evidence found that has merit. It was Harrison and Grime who were in the early stages of using the alerts as intelligence.. Harrison seemed to do an about turn after the searches.. An experiment I think is a fair description

[Mr Gray]

The subterranean death dungeon.
I'll bet they had the 'experimental' doggies crawling all over that gaff*




*yes, Mr / Mrs Paraglider, I'm assuming again. Mad, isn't it?

They were looking for evidence.. That isnt experimental.. Its what the dogs are trained for

[The General]

They were looking for evidence.. That isnt experimental.. Its what the dogs are trained for

So the dogs can find evidence where humans can't?

[Mr Gray]

So the dogs can find evidence where humans can't?

The dogs show where to look for evidence. The difference berween a cadaver dog and any other scent dog is that other scent dogs are trained on... And only on... Their target scent
Cadaver dogs in the UK are not. In fact no one knows exactly what they react to.
Grime has clarified his position now... The only.reliable cadaver dog is one trained solely on human remains.