The boxes ticked by prime suspect Brueckner

[Vertigo Swirl]

Bolded bit, then you can except Wolters maybe talking complete bull.

I have no doubt he hasn't told us everything.  You can interpret that as "complete bull" if you want - your prerogative.

[Mr Gray]

The open window claim isn't evidence as it is uncorroborated. In fact when Matt did his outside check the window wasn't open so take from that what you may.

Uncorroborated evidence is accepted in court as evidence... A rape case is a good example
Martin Smith id of Gerry is uncorroborated by any other in the group.. So are you saying his statement is not evidence..
Kates witness statement is evidence that could be presented to a jury

[sadie]

The point is that sceptics are totally mistaken.. Who would have guessed... In saying 15 million has been spent looking for MM.
It hasn't... 15 mill has been spent looking for the abductor and murderer of MM.. And it looks like its paid off.
Or should we just let child murderers get away with it. Thank god SY and the Germans have stuck with it when the pathetic PJ failed

13 million, Davel.

See how "The Generals" misinforation has caught on.  He said £15 million and it was wrong.


£13 million.  NOT £15 million

[Vertigo Swirl]

So evidence is only evidence if there is corroboration, is that what you’re saying?  Using your rules what evidence is there that the McCanns disposed of their daughter’s body?

Seeing as how you have chosen not to reply to this question I can only deduce that there is none.  Odd that you therefore lean towards this theory over all others, no?

[G-Unit]

Seeing as how you have chosen not to reply to this question I can only deduce that there is none.  Odd that you therefore lean towards this theory over all others, no?

We were dicusssing uncorroborated evidence. Where's the uncorroboborated evidence of this; I've not seen any in the files.

[sadie]

Me personally, no. I have the utmost respect for any man or woman who volunteers for her Majesty's Service, even you. But since displaying the badge offends you, or makes you think you can use it against me, I'll remove it. It was meant in honour and if I had any respect for you on a personal level, I'd tell you my story. Maybe another time.

Hey, Ms Para, you don't honestly think The General is a real General, do you?

[Vertigo Swirl]

We were dicusssing uncorroborated evidence. Where's the uncorroboborated evidence of this; I've not seen any in the files.

I don’t know what you mean.  This is the question I have asked and which you have left unanswered.

“So evidence is only evidence if there is corroboration, is that what you’re saying?  Using your rules what evidence is there that the McCanns disposed of their daughter’s body?”

[John]

Uncorroborated evidence is accepted in court as evidence... A rape case is a good example
Martin Smith id of Gerry is uncorroborated by any other in the group.. So are you saying his statement is not evidence..
Kates witness statement is evidence that could be presented to a jury

Martin Smith's evidence of seeing an as yet unidentified man carrying a child the night Madeleine disappeared was corroborated by the entire family. That is the important fact.

Uncorroborated evidence has little evidential value in court because it could well be made up or pure fiction intended to mislead.

[Vertigo Swirl]

Martin Smith's evidence of seeing an as yet unidentified man carrying a child the night Madeleine disappeared was corroborated by the entire family. That is the important fact.

Uncorroborated evidence has little evidential value in court because it could well be made up or pure fiction intended to mislead.

As could “corroborated “ evidence.

[Mr Gray]

Martin Smith's evidence of seeing an as yet unidentified man carrying a child the night Madeleine disappeared was corroborated by the entire family. That is the important fact.

Uncorroborated evidence has little evidential value in court because it could well be made up or pure fiction intended to mislead.

Martin Smith saw a man.. That's corroborated

He said 60 to 80% Gerry mccann... Not corroborated

I do agree with you his claim has little value

I disagree re uncorroborated evidence in general. Its admissible in court and the jury decides its value

[G-Unit]

I don’t know what you mean.  This is the question I have asked and which you have left unanswered.

“So evidence is only evidence if there is corroboration, is that what you’re saying?  Using your rules what evidence is there that the McCanns disposed of their daughter’s body?”

There is no such evidence.

[Vertigo Swirl]

There is no such evidence.

If there is no evidence that the McCanns disposed of their child’s body then why on earth do you believe that they did?  And please don’t insult my intelligence by pretending that you don’t.  You have made it clear that you think Amaral solved the case in 2007. How did he do that if there is no evidence that the McCanns committed any crime?

[G-Unit]

If there is no evidence that the McCanns disposed of their child’s body then why on earth do you believe that they did?  And please don’t insult my intelligence by pretending that you don’t.  You have made it clear that you think Amaral solved the case in 2007. How did he do that if there is no evidence that the McCanns committed any crime?

I don't know what happened to Madeleine McCann. How you interpret my posts is not how I do so, which makes it impossible to answer your questions.

[Vertigo Swirl]

I don't know what happened to Madeleine McCann. How you interpret my posts is not how I do so, which makes it impossible to answer your questions.

How very convenient for you.  Do you think Amaral solved the case in 2007 - yes or no? 

[G-Unit]

How very convenient for you.  Do you think Amaral solved the case in 2007 - yes or no?

Theories have been advanced by many people over the years, but the case still isn't solved.