Author Topic: Madeleine McCann's parents lose libel case with the European Court of Human Rights  (Read 45565 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Mr Gray

That may or not be the case, what cannot be doubted is that the first trial listed the alerts as fact's , upheld by the ECHR.

It is the case... Fact. So how and why were these lies accepted by the court as fact's... That's the question that has not been answered

Offline Vertigo Swirl

IMO an ethical, honourable lawyer knowing that there was zero chance of winning at the ECHR would have turned down the opportunity to represent a client in such an appeal, on the basis that it was unwinnable.  But I don't  think that's what happened here.  I think the McCanns' lawyers clearly were of the opinion that the McCanns had a case and that  ECHR had been broken otherwise they would have not been able to put forward any sort of cohesive appeal.  And if they held that opinion, it is perfectly reasonable for others to see where they were coming from, even if that opinion was legally refuted at the ECHR. 
"You can't reason with the unreasonable".

Offline The General

It is the case... Fact. So how and why were these lies accepted by the court as fact's... That's the question that has not been answered
Coming up in the next hour here on Fox.......Which is it today? The judges were wrong, or the lawyers failed? Or both? It was just the judges 3 days ago.
Which excuse will be added tomorrow? Find out later in the show.
Here's Tom with sports.......
Subject Matter Expert - Hobos.

Offline Wonderfulspam

In my opinion, the only reason they brought the civil action against Amaral was to clear their own consciences.

No, the McCanns have been quite clear that the only reason they brought the action was due to the damage to the search. Further more they are now satisfied that an active investigation into the abduction is since under way. So there's no reason for them to appeal against this decision. But let's see what happens in 3 months time. Hopefully Madeleine's abductor will be found before then though.
Christian Brueckner Fan Club

Offline The General

I didn't know who the lawyers were 3 days ago... Only found out in the published judgement.
I'm astonished at the choice.
You wouldnt ask your GP to give you a heart transplant.
This is the same lawyer who lost the case in Portugal
Hey, wait a goddamm minute. This has all the hallmarks of Metodo 3's appointment! Was this......was this another cunning ploy? Appoint incompetence to give the appearance of diligence? Kevin Halligan?
You've ceretainly given us food for thought.....
Subject Matter Expert - Hobos.

Offline jassi

Coming up in the next hour here on Fox.......Which is it today? The judges were wrong, or the lawyers failed? Or both? It was just the judges 3 days ago.
Which excuse will be added tomorrow? Find out later in the show.
Here's Tom with sports.......

A million excuse can be put forward and probably will be.

None of them will alter reality. McCann lost.
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Offline Wonderfulspam

Coming up in the next hour here on Fox.......Which is it today? The judges were wrong, or the lawyers failed? Or both? It was just the judges 3 days ago.
Which excuse will be added tomorrow? Find out later in the show.
Here's Tom with sports.......

Davel should have represented them pro-Bono.
He could have taken The Edge along aswell to provide musical entertainment during recess.
Christian Brueckner Fan Club

Offline kizzy

I didn't know who the lawyers were 3 days ago... Only found out in the published judgement.
I'm astonished at the choice.
You wouldnt ask your GP to give you a heart transplant.
This is the same lawyer who lost the case in Portugal

Well, it seems the mccs were satisfied with their choice of lawyers they're not appealing.

The case was frivolous, to say the least....imo they relied on sympathy.

Judging by your posts it's because your integrity and credibility are in tatters and all you're doing is making it worse.

Isn't it easier just to admit you got it wrong, and not take it too personally?

You can argue till the cows come home it won't change anything ...the mccs lost.




Offline barrier

A million excuse can be put forward and probably will be.

None of them will alter reality. McCann lost.

Yep, ever since 2017 its been they'll win, no the won't, the why's and wherefores can be discussed ad infinitum the fat lady has sung, time to move on .
More important things in the press, two tv presenters jumped the queue to see a coffin, Harry is upset Meagain wasn't allowed up to Balmoral, echr loss is history.
This is my own private domicile and I shall not be harassed, biatch:Jesse Pinkman Character.

Offline Wonderfulspam

Yep, ever since 2017 its been they'll win, no the won't, the why's and wherefores can be discussed ad infinitum the fat lady has sung, time to move on .
More important things in the press, two tv presenters jumped the queue to see a coffin, Harry is upset Meagain wasn't allowed up to Balmoral, echr loss is history.

& in the Mail this week it said that Brueckner will be charged for his crimes against Madeleine later this year.
Christian Brueckner Fan Club

Offline Eleanor

I can understand why you don't want to discuss it any more. Instead of Amaral and the Portuguese courts being criticised, they were exonerated. The Portuguese courts dealt with the case correctly, and the alleged human rights violations were unfounded. Obviously some people have no interest in discussing what Amaral and the Portuguese courts got right.

I can understand why you didn't want to consider my suggestion.  Nothing new there.

Offline Mr Gray

So based on sceptics opinion on the ruling..
I can say CB is 100% guilty of MM's murder because HCW said so... I don't need to see his evidence... Doesnt matter if its total BS... The fact he's said it makes it a, fact

Lol

Offline barrier

So based on sceptics opinion on the ruling..
I can say CB is 100% guilty of MM's murder because HCW said so... I don't need to see his evidence... Doesnt matter if its total BS... The fact he's said it makes it a, fact

Lol

The fact is he said it, thats not in dispute .The legend is writ, you'll understand in the end.
This is my own private domicile and I shall not be harassed, biatch:Jesse Pinkman Character.

Offline barrier

& in the Mail this week it said that Brueckner will be charged for his crimes against Madeleine later this year.

In the mean time the emergency budget has gone down like a lead balloon.
This is my own private domicile and I shall not be harassed, biatch:Jesse Pinkman Character.

Offline Wonderfulspam

So based on sceptics opinion on the ruling..
I can say CB is 100% guilty of MM's murder because HCW said so... I don't need to see his evidence... Doesnt matter if its total BS... The fact he's said it makes it a, fact

Lol

You've already been doing that for over two years now.
Christian Brueckner Fan Club